Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 6 of 2018
Date of Decision: 06.10.2023
Smti. Pharmon Dohling
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sahay, GA
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA (For R 1 & 2)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv. (For R 3)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
By way of this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has sought to highlight the alleged deplorable state
of the Public Health System in the State of Meghalaya and in particular,
the failure of the system in providing timely and adequate medical
assistance to her daughter who was brought to Nongpoh Civil Hospital
for emergency treatment following complications which occurred after
the delivery of her child on 30.01.2016 but due to the negligence of the
medical officer and nursing staff, she died on the same day itself as a
consequence of placenta retention.
2.
The prayer made in this petition is reproduced as under:
a) For a writ of mandamus or any other writ, order or direction
in the nature of mandamus directing the Respondents to
provide a compensation of Rs. 500000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs
Only) or any amount as your Lordship may deem fit and
proper to the mother of the deceased for the failure of the
state public health system to protect the life of her daughter
and the subsequent trauma caused to the petitioner and her
family.
b) For an order to respondents to issue directions for the
constitution of a committee of doctors including a
paediatrician and a dietician for charting out the nutrition
dietary plan for the grandchildren of the petitioner for the
next three years and to issue directions for the provision of
the nutritional requirements of the grandchildren of the
family through the next three years.
c) For an order to ensure free and compulsory education for
all the children of Melina Dohling.
d) For an order to ensure that every health centre has the
complete Home Delivery Kit as per the IPHS guidelines.
e) For an order to the immediate appointment of a permanent
Anaesthetic at the Nongpoh District Hospital.
f) For an order to carry out a Disciplinary action against the
doctor on-duty in the emergency / maternity ward during the
time of the maternal death.”
3.
Heard Mr. N. Syngkon, learned counsel for the petitioner who
has submitted that the history of this case is that the deceased daughter of
the petitioner aged about 30 years old was married and had four children
out of the said wedlock, the eldest boy being 7 years, the second, a girl,
is 5 years and third who is also a boy is 3 years old. The youngest who
was given birth on 30.01.2016 as a result of a delivery at home, survived,
but the mother developed complications soon after giving birth
apparently due to placenta retention, was immediately taken to Nongpoh
Civil Hospital in an auto-rickshaw. However, on arrival, she was made
to wait for about 20-25 minutes and by the time she was attended to by
the medical officers and nursing staff, she could not be saved and soon
after she passed away on the same day itself, that is, on 30.01.2016.
4.
The main grievance of the petitioner is that there was abject
negligence on the part of the medical staff at the said hospital inasmuch
as when the patient was brought in with heavy bleeding (hemorrhage)
and low blood pressure, she should have been given immediate attention
even to the extent of being administered injection of ergometrine and
oxytocin or oxytocin alone which would have helped the womb to
contract and push out the placenta and membrane.
5.
However, the said procedure which could even be carried out by
the ASHA worker was not followed as the hospital was not equipped
with adequate supply and storage of the required drug to administer the
injection. Even otherwise, the absence of a regular Anesthetist at the
hospital to administer anesthetics to the daughter of the petitioner at the
crucial period has also resulted in her death, submits the learned counsel.
6.
The learned counsel went on to submit that there are myriad
government schemes which guaranteed minimum entitlement of
maternal healthcare to the deceased daughter of the petitioner but the
respondents have violated their obligation to implementation of these
programmes.
7.
The learned counsel has listed some of such programmes like
the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM), 2005, Janani Suraksha
Yojana (JSY), 2005, Janani Shishu Suraksha Karyakram (JSSK), 2011,
The National Food Security Act, 2013, Indian Public Health Standards
(IPHS) and also the relevant provisions of the Constitution of India
including Article 21 and 47.
8.
The learned counsel has emphasized on the fact that in India,
the Maternal Mortality Ratio is about 174 per 1,00,000 live births. About
800 women still die today of preventable causes related to pregnancy and
childbirth. In Meghalaya, the maternal and infant mortality rates are
higher than the rest of the country with reports of non-functional Public
Health Centres (PHCs) and Community Health Centres (CHCs) due to
non-availability of doctors and basic health infrastructure.
9.
However, even while referring to the various programmes and
statutes including what is provided under the Constitution, the main
thrust of the submission of the learned counsel is that this Court may
cause an enquiry to be conducted into the cause of death of the deceased
daughter of the petitioner to find out the lapse in the system and the
negligent act on the part of the medical staff on duty on that particular
day, that is, 30.01.2016.
10.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned GA, appearing on behalf of the
respondents have resisted the submission and contention made by the
petitioner through her counsel by raising, at the first instance, the issue
of maintainability of this petition on the ground that the case of the
petitioner is one of grievance over inadequate or poor or lack of medical
assistance or medical services and in particular, in the area of maternal
health services which has resulted in the death of the daughter of the
petitioner. This being a case of alleged medical negligence, a writ
petition will not be maintainable in this respect.
11.
The learned GA has further emphasized on this aspect of the
matter by submitting that by their very nature, allegations of medical
negligence can suitably be dealt with by experts having working
knowledge of the subject matter, for instance, committees like the Ethics
Committee of the Medical Council, the Consumer Forum and also a
Civil Court can be best suited for this purpose and exercise.
12.
In support of this contention, the learned GA has referred to the
following authorities:
i.
Kamla Devi v. Union of India, 2015 SCC Online Del
7109;
ii.
Neelu Sarin v. Union of India, 1991 Supp (1) SCC 300;
iii.
Rashmi Dixit v. Medical Council of India, 2016 SCC
Online Del 5980;
iv.
State of Punjab v. Shiv Ram, (2005) 7 SCC 1;
v.
Lalita Devi v. State of Rajasthan, 2015 SCC Online Raj
11565.
13.
According to the learned GA, another area where a writ petition
is not maintainable is in cases involving disputed questions of facts.
From the pleadings of the parties what could be seen is that there are
many areas of disputed facts brought about in these proceedings which
could not have been adequately answered by way of an affidavit-inopposition, evidence both ocular and material required to be produced
can only be done so before the appropriate forum but could not be done
so in a writ proceeding.
14.
In view of the above, the petitioner having other efficacious
alternative remedy to seek legal redress for her alleged grievance, she is
therefore, at liberty to approach the appropriate forums even to the extent
of filing a suit before the Civil Court or to file a complaint before the
concerned Medical Council.
15.
The authorities cited in this regard are:
i.
Arun Kumar Manglik v. Chirayu Health & Medicare (P)
Ltd., (2019) 7 SCC 401;
ii.
16.
Kismat v. State of U.P., 2014 SCC Online All 15990.
On the factual aspect of the matter, the learned GA has
submitted that the deceased daughter of the petitioner, an inhabitant of
Mawdiangum Village had come for an Antenatal Care checkup at
Nongpoh National Sub-Centre on five occasions that is, (i) 25.09.2015,
(ii) 23.10.2015, (iii) 20.11.2015, (iv) 18.12.2015 and (v) 15.01.2016.
During such visits, she was given iron and calcium and tetanus toxoid
injection as well as she was counselled by PHN & ANM concerned who
had requested her to come to Nongpoh Civil Hospital whenever she is
due for delivery. However, she had delivered the baby at her own home
on 30.01.2016 between 10 a.m. to 11 a.m. She was brought to Nongpoh
Civil Hospital at 1:50 p.m. on the same day only after complications of
retained placenta arose.
17.
Again, it is submitted that when the deceased daughter of the
petitioner was brought to Nongpoh Civil Hospital on 30.01.2016 at 1:50
p.m. her relatives and an ASHA worker of Mawdiangum accompanied
her where she straight away was taken to the labour room followed by
the attending doctor, Dr. W. Nongpiur who immediately examined and
assessed her condition and found that her pulse is not palpable, blood
pressure is zero, no breathing, heart sounds inaudible and she was
unconscious. The doctor resorted to the process of cardio-pulmonary
resuscitation but unfortunately the patient could not be revived and she
was declared dead at 1:55 p.m. Her case was classed as „brought dead‟.
This fact was reinforced by the report filed by one Mr. Lawrence
Nongrum, PHN Nongpoh National Sub-Centre on 08.02.2016 who has
filed the format indicating this information as follows:
Sl. No. 9 – Place of Death – on the way to Civil Hospital
Nongpoh.
18.
The respondent No. 3/Union of India has also filed its counter
affidavit which in essence has reflected the role of the Union of India as
far as the Health Sector is concerned. However, it is made clear at the
outset that „Public Health‟ is a State subject being placed at Entry 6 of
List II of Schedule Seven of the Constitution of India and as such, it is
the duty of the State Government to lead the process of health sector
reforms and to protect the common individual citizen from health
hazards. The various schemes as pointed out by the petitioner have also
been highlighted by this respondent with relevant statistical information.
However, since no relief is sought for by the petitioner from this
respondent, it is submitted that the name of this respondent may be
deleted from this proceeding.
19.
This Court having considered the submission and contention of
the parties would deemed it proper for the issue of maintainability to be
discussed and decided first.
20.
The facts as stated above are not in dispute as far as the death of
the deceased daughter of the petitioner is concerned, whose death has
occurred soon after she gave birth to her fourth child and the manner
whereby she has developed complications soon after, prompting those
assisting her to immediately take her to Nongpoh Civil Hospital for the
required medical treatment. What follows thereafter has been detailed by
the respective parties hereinabove.
21.
Before proceeding further, it would do well to understand the
concept of „Medical Negligence‟ and what would amount to the same
under the given circumstances. It goes without saying that this would
apply only in the realm of the medical profession including institutions
such as hospitals with the main actors being the medical practitioners
and staff thereof. Of course, incidents of medical negligence may not be
confined only to medical institutions and the like but would be attributed
wherever medical attention is found inadequate or not present at all or
being administered irresponsibly.
22.
To better understand how this concept is being handled in a
judicial forum, a number of authorities is found present in a catena of
cases where judicial pronouncements by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as
well as various High Courts of our country have more or less crystallized
the subject matter. To name a few, in the case of Jacob Mathew v. State
of Punjab & Anr., (2005) 6 SCC 1 the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dealing
with the case of medical negligence has elaborately discussed the
subject. Reference to relevant portions of the said judgment would be
beneficial for this Court to come to a correct finding on the basis of the
issues raised herein.
23.
At para 31 it was observed as follows:
“31. The subject of negligence in the context of the medical
profession necessarily calls for treatment with a difference.
Several relevant considerations in this regard are found
mentioned by Alan Merry and Alexander McCall Smith in their
work Errors, Medicine and the Law (Cambridge University
Press, 2001). There is a marked tendency to look for a human
actor to blame for an untoward event, a tendency which is
closely linked with the desire to punish. Things have gone
wrong and, therefore, somebody must be found to answer for it.
To draw a distinction between the blameworthy and the
blameless, the notion of mens rea has to be elaborately
understood. An empirical study would reveal that the
background to a mishap is frequently far more complex than
may generally be assumed. It can be demonstrated that actual
blame for the outcome has to be attributed with great caution.
For a medical accident or failure, the responsibility may lie
with the medical practitioner and equally it may not. The
inadequacies of the system, the specific circumstances of the
case, the nature of human psychology itself and sheer chance
may have combined to produce a result in which the doctor's
contribution is either relatively or completely blameless.
Human body and its working is nothing less than a highly
complex machine. Coupled with the complexities of medical
science, the scope for misimpressions, misgivings and
misplaced allegations against the operator i.e. the doctor,
cannot be ruled out. One may have notions of best or ideal
practice which are different from the reality of how medical
practice is carried on or how the doctor functions in real life.
The factors of pressing need and limited resources cannot be
ruled out from consideration. Dealing with a case of medical
negligence needs a deeper understanding of the practical side
of medicine.”
24.
At para 48(1) one of the conclusions reached at by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court is that:
“48.We sum up our conclusions as under:
(1) Negligence is the breach of a duty caused by the
omission to do something which a reasonable man guided
by those considerations which ordinarily regulate the
conduct of human affairs would do, or doing something
which a prudent and reasonable man would not do. The
definition of negligence as given in Law of Torts, Ratanlal
& Dhirajlal (edited by Justice G.P. Singh), referred to
hereinabove, holds good. Negligence becomes actionable on
account of injury resulting from the act or omission
amounting to negligence attributable to the person sued.
The essential components of negligence are three: “duty”,
“breach” and “resulting damage”.”
25.
In the case of Martin F. D’Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq, (2009) 3 SCC
1, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has laid down the standard of proof of
medical negligence by reiterating the general principle involved, inter
alia with reference to the case of Jacob Mathew(supra). At paras 31 and
32 of the same wherein it was observed as follows:
“31. As already stated above, the broad general principles of
medical negligence have been laid down in the Supreme Court
judgment in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab: (2005) 6 SCC 1.
However, these principles can be indicated briefly here:
The basic principle relating to medical negligence is
known as the Bolam Rule. This was laid down in the
judgment of McNair, J. in Bolam v. Friern Hospital:
(1957) 1 WLR 582 as follows: (WLR p. 586)
"…where you get a situation which involves the use of
some special skill or competence, then the test as to
whether there has been negligence or not is not the
test of the man on the top of a Clapham omnibus,
because he has not got this special skill. The test is
the standard of the ordinary skilled man exercising
and professing to have that special skill. A man need
not possess the highest expert skill; It is wellestablished law that it is sufficient if he exercises the
ordinary skill of an ordinary competent man
exercising that particular art." (emphasis supplied)
Bolam: (1957) 1 WLR 582 test has been approved by the
Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew case: (2005) 6 SCC 1.
32. In Halsbury's Laws of England [Ed.: 4th Edn., Vol. 30, para
35], the degree of skill and care required by a medical
practitioner is stated as follows:
"35. Degree of skill and care required.– The practitioner
must bring to his task a reasonable degree of skill and
knowledge, and must exercise a reasonable degree of care.
Neither the very highest nor a very low degree of care and
competence, judged in the light of the particular
circumstances of each case, is what the law requires, and a
person is not liable in negligence because someone else of
greater skill and knowledge would have prescribed different
treatment or operated in a different way; nor is he guilty of
negligence if he has acted in accordance with a practice
accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical men
skilled in that particular art, even though a body of adverse
opinion also existed among medical men.
Deviation from normal practice is not necessarily evidence of
negligence. To establish liability on that basis it must be shown
(1) that there is a usual and normal practice; (2) that the
defendant has not adopted it; and (3) that the course in fact
adopted is one no professional man of ordinary skill would have
taken had he been acting with ordinary care.
(emphasis supplied)”
26.
The authorities cited by the learned GA on behalf of the State
respondents as far as the subject matter of medical negligence is
concerned are more or less in tune with whatever has been referred to
hereinabove. As such, it may not be required to deal with such
authorities individually.
27.
From whatever is found from the pleadings of the parties, it is
the assertion of the petitioner that because her deceased daughter when
she was brought to Nongpoh Civil Hospital in a very critical condition,
she was not attended to for about 20-25 minutes which aggravated the
situation and eventually led to her death and as such, gross medical
negligence can be attributed not only to the attending doctor but to the
other medical staff and the failure of the system as a whole, for which
adequate compensation and reliefs as prayed for is justified.
28.
On the other hand, it is the consistent denial of the hospital
authorities that the allegations of the petitioner are unfounded inasmuch
as though the patient was brought to Nongpoh Civil Hospital on
30.01.2016, her condition was such that instantly she was rushed into the
labour room where the attending doctor tried to revive the patient but
unfortunately, it was found that she was already dead when she was
brought to the hospital.
29.
It would be relevant to refer to para 29 of the Martin F. D‟Souza
case which reads as follows:
“29. Before dealing with these principles two things have to be
kept in mind: (1) Judges are not experts in medical science,
rather they are laymen. This itself often makes it somewhat
difficult for them to decide cases relating to medical negligence.
Moreover, Judges have usually to rely on testimonies of other
doctors which may not necessarily in all cases be objective,
since like in all professions and services, doctors too sometimes
have a tendency to support their own colleagues who are
charged with medical negligence. The testimony may also be
difficult to understand, particularly in complicated medical
matters, for a layman in medical matters like a Judge; and (2) A
balance has to be struck in such cases. While doctors who cause
death or agony due to medical negligence should certainly be
penalised, it must also be remembered that like all professionals
doctors too can make errors of judgment but if they are
punished for this no doctor can practise his vocation with
equanimity. Indiscriminate proceedings and decisions against
doctors are counterproductive and serve society no good. They
inhibit the free exercise of judgment by a professional in a
particular situation.”
30.
Obviously, in this case there is an element of disputed facts
which requires determination but could not have been carried out by a
writ court inasmuch as for the truth to be revealed, evidence has to be led
and liability imposed, if so required, which could only be done so before
an appropriate forum, as far as medical negligence is concerned,
judicially or otherwise.
31.
In this regard, in the case of Balkaran Das Gupta v. Union of
India Thru. Secy. Ministry of Railway, New Delhi & Ors., 2022 SCC
Online ALL 909, the Hon‟ble High Court of Allahabad dealing with the
issue of exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 in the area of
award of damages/compensation at paras 7 and 9 has observed as
follows:
“7.The first and foremost question, which falls for
determination of this Court in these proceedings, is as to
whether for the prayers made in the writ petition this Court
ought to exercise its jurisdiction, which necessarily is
discretionary, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. In
this regard, we find that there are two legal impediments before
the petitioner which are to be sailed across by him if this
petition is to succeed. The first such impediment is that any
claim for damages/compensation for any damage caused to the
property in question will necessarily require the Court to
investigate various disputed facts, which, in our opinion, will
not be permissible for the simple reason that such determination
requires detailed examination of evidence which can better be
made in a civil suit, which may be tried before a court of
competent civil jurisdiction.
9. No doubt, this Court exercises very wide powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India in the matter of issuing
writs, however, there are well recognized limitations which the
Court has to be conscious of while it is called upon to exercise
its writ jurisdiction. One of the such limitations, which is rather
self imposed limitation/restriction which needs to be observed
by this Court while exercising its discretionary powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is that it should not
enter into an issue which for its determination requires the
parties to adduce evidence. The disputed question of facts, thus,
are not permissible to be delved into by this Court while
exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India for the reason that the writ petitions are generally
decided on the basis of uncontroverted facts to be deduced from
the affidavits which the parties to a dispute are called upon to
file. It is well settled that relief under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is not available for deciding disputes for
which a remedy under general civil law is available to a party
approaching the Court.”
32.
As to the proper implementation of the various schemes in this
regard as pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, this Court
hopes and trust that the State Government would ensure that there is no
lapse on the part of those responsible to carry out such programmes for
the general welfare of all concerned.
33.
In view of the observations made hereinabove, under the
peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, this Court need not go
further but to come to the conclusion that firstly, an application for
issuance of an appropriate writ under Article 226 of the Constitution may
not be proper since there are disputed issues of facts which could only
have been resolved by the petitioner proceeding before an appropriate
forum.
34.
Accordingly, this petition is found to be devoid of merits, the
same is hereby dismissed.
35.
Before parting, without prejudice to the observations made
hereinabove, this Court would opine that the petitioner is at liberty to
pursue the matter before an appropriate forum, if so advised, for which
the time spent before this Court would stand condoned.
36.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
06.10.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review