The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. In the light of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion that the findings recorded by the Trial Court on the counter claim and the decree passed thereon are in strict conformity with law. The rent receipts relied upon by the defendant are devoid of any probative value, having been brought into existence only after the rejection of the plaint and its affirmation by this Court. Once these documents are excluded from consideration, there remains no material whatsoever to establish that the defendant was inducted as a tenant by his mother, plaintiff No.1, in respect of the suit schedule ‘A’ property.
21. Accordingly, this Court finds no infirmity in the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. Point Nos.(i) to (iii) are answered in the Negative. - 17 NC: 2026:KHC:6338 RFA No. 2829 of 2025 HC-KAR
22. Point No.(iv):- In view of the findings recorded on point Nos.(i) to (iii), this Court proceeds to pass the following; (i) The appeal is dismissed. (ii) Pending applications, if any, are also dismissed. SD/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM) List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 3RD DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2829 OF 2025 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
1.
PETER SANTOSH FRANCIS
SON OF LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT NO.28
11TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS,
4TH C BLOCK, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU-560 034.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. VISHRUTH .C, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by CHAITHRA A
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
MRS. SALOME FRANCIS
W/O LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 95 YEARS
2.
MR. J.A.M. SELVAM
S/O LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS
3.
MRS. MARY JOSEPHINE SUMITHRA
D/O LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
R1 AND R3 ARE RESIDING IN
MUNICIPAL NO.5
R2 RESIDING IN MUNICIPAL NO.2/3
SITUATED AT 'L', NO. 7TH STREET
ASHOK NAGAR, BENGALURU-560 025.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
4.
MRS. MARY SABITHA
D/O LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
RESIDING AT 10, L NO. 7TH STREET
ASHOK NAGAR, BENGALURU-560 025.
5.
MRS. MARY SUGANTHI
D/O. LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
RESIDING AT IN MUNICIPAL NO.17
SITUATED AT PUSHPAVENI LAYOUT
MARUTHI NAGAR, KAIKONDRANAHALLI
SARJAPUR ROAD, BENGALURU-560 035.
6.
MARIA THOMAS SAMPATHRAJ
S/O. LATE R. FRANCIS
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
RESIDING IN A PORTION OF NO.28
11TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS, 4TH 'C' BLOCK
KORMANGALA, BENGALURU-560 034.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SURESH S. LOKRE, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. SHRAVAN S. LOKRE, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R3)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/S. 96 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 15.11.2025, PASSED IN OS
NO. 25898/2022 ON THE FILE OF THE XXVIII ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, MAYOHALL, BENGALURU,
DISMISSING THE SUIT FOR PARTITION.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR DICTATING JUDGMENT,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
-3NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
The
captioned
Regular
First
Appeal
is
by
the
defendant directed against the judgment and decree dated
15.11.2025 passed on the file of the XXVIII Additional City
Civil
and
Sessions
Judge,
Bengaluru
in
O.S.No.25898/2022, wherein the counter claim filed by
defendant
No.1
was
allowed
thereby
directing
the
appellant herein to hand over the vacant possession of the
suit schedule ‘A’ property.
2. For the sake of brevity, the parties are referred to
the counter claim.
3. Facts leading to the case are as under;
The
defendant
O.S.No.25898/2022
had
instituted
a
seeking
partition
and
suit
in
separate
possession of the suit schedule properties and for a
declaration that the Settlement Deed dated 21.02.2000
executed by defendant No.1 in favour of defendant No.2
-4NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
and
the
Gift
Deed
dated
03.09.2001
executed
by
defendant No.1–mother in favour of defendant No.6 are
null and void and not binding on his alleged share. He also
sought the consequential relief of permanent injunction
restraining
schedule
defendant
properties.
No.1
The
from
alienating
the
suit
present
plaintiff,
who
was
arrayed as defendant No.1 in the said partition suit,
entered appearance, contested the claim, and filed a
counter claim seeking recovery of possession of Schedule
‘A’ property. Simultaneously, defendant No.1 also filed an
application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC seeking
rejection of the plaint.
4.
The Trial Court, by a considered order, allowed
the application filed by defendant No.1 and rejected the
plaint in O.S.No.25898/2022. However, the counter claim
filed
by
the
present
plaintiff
seeking
recovery
of
possession was retained for adjudication. In response to
the counter claim, the original plaintiff in the suit (arrayed
as defendant
in
the
counter
claim)
filed
a
written
-5NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
statement and, for the first time, set up a plea of tenancy
under his mother and produced certain rent receipts in
support
thereof.
documentary
Upon appreciation of
evidence,
the
Trial
the oral
Court
and
recorded
a
categorical finding that the rent receipts were concocted,
rejected the plea of tenancy, allowed the counter claim,
and
directed
the
defendant
to
hand
over
vacant
possession of the Schedule ‘A’ property.
5. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed on
the counter claim, the defendant has preferred the present
appeal.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant–
defendant, reiterating the grounds urged in the appeal
memorandum,
vehemently
contended
that
the
rent
receipts produced on record clearly establish a jural
relationship of landlord and tenant between the appellant
and his mother. It is further contended that the decree
directing immediate delivery of vacant possession is
-6NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
disproportionate and contrary to principles of equity and
natural justice. Learned counsel also submitted that the
plaintiff in the counter claim is a 95-year-old lady who has
undergone cardiac stent surgery and is under the influence
and control of plaintiff No.2–sister, an Architect by
profession, and that the counter claim is not a voluntary
act of the mother but is instituted at the behest of plaintiff
No.2. It is further argued that the appellant is presently
unemployed since March 2024 and that the Trial Court,
without considering the hardship likely to be caused, has
mechanically ordered eviction, warranting interference by
this Court.
7. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiff–mother, placing reliance on the material on
record, contended that the appellant is a qualified MBA
graduate who was employed as a Human Resources
professional
with
Kyndryl
properties
including
a
Solutions,
three-bedroom
owns
flat,
residential
and
has
sufficient means to secure alternative accommodation. It
-7NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
is further contended that the appellant is unlawfully
squatting over the suit schedule property by taking undue
advantage of the advanced age of plaintiff No.1 and that
the Trial Court, on proper appreciation of evidence, has
rightly granted the relief sought in the counter claim.
8.
Though the parties were advised to explore the
possibility of an amicable settlement, the appellant sought
as much as 25 months’ time to vacate the premises. In
view of the same, this Court proceeded to hear the matter.
Learned counsel on both sides have been heard at length.
This Court has independently examined the pleadings,
carefully scrutinised the oral and documentary evidence on
record, and assessed the reasoning adopted by the Trial
Court.
9.
In the light of the rival contentions urged, the
following points arise for consideration:
(i) Whether the Trial Court was justified
in holding that the pleadings in the plaint
-8NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
filed by the appellant in O.S.No.25898/2022
bind him and that the subsequent plea of
tenancy raised in the written statement to
the counter claim is an afterthought?
(ii) Whether the Trial Court committed
an error in rejecting the plea of tenancy by
holding that the rent receipts produced are
concocted?
(iii) Whether the decree passed on the
counter claim directing delivery of vacant
possession calls for interference by this
Court?
(iv) What order?
Findings on point Nos.(i) to (iii):-
The relationship between the parties is not in
dispute. Plaintiff No.1 is the mother of the defendant in the
counter claim, while plaintiff No.2 is the sibling of the
defendant. The defendant in the counter claim had, in the
first instance, approached the Civil Court by instituting
O.S.No.25898/2022 seeking the relief of partition and
-9NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
separate
possession. In the
said partition suit,
the
defendant, who figured as the plaintiff therein, made
specific and unequivocal pleadings with regard to the
nature
and
character
of
the
suit
properties.
He
categorically asserted that the suit schedule ‘A’ property
stood exclusively allotted to defendant No.1, namely his
mother, whereas the suit schedule ‘B’ property was
pleaded to be ancestral in nature, having been acquired by
defendant No.1 from her late father.
11. These pleadings were not casual or incidental
assertions but formed the very foundation of the claim for
partition and declaration sought in the earlier suit. The
averments clearly reflect the stand taken by the defendant
at the threshold, admitting exclusive ownership of plaintiff
No.1 in respect of Schedule ‘A’ property, while asserting
joint family rights only in respect of Schedule ‘B’ property.
The said pleadings assume significance, inasmuch as they
emanate
from
the
defendant
himself,
are
made
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
consciously, and were relied upon by him to seek
substantive reliefs from the Court.
12.
In the above factual and legal backdrop, this
Court deems it appropriate and necessary to extract
paragraph
Nos.10
to
of
the
plaint
in
O.S.No.25898/2022, as the said averments have a direct
bearing on the adjudication of the issues arising in the
present appeal. Accordingly, paragraph Nos.10 to 16 of
the plaint are extracted hereunder for ready reference:
"10. The plaintiff humbly submits that during
the lifetime of his father, the suit schedule 'A'
property was allotted to the First Defendant, who is
the Plaintiff mother. The Suit Schedule 'B' Property
is an Ancestral Property acquired by the First
Defendant from her father Late J.A.Bernard.
The
Suit Schedule 'C' Property was jointly purchased by
my Late Father and the First Defendant and all the
Original Documents in respect of the Suit Schedule
Properties are with the First and Second Defendants.
11. The plaintiff humbly submits that the Suit
Schedule 'A' Property was not acquired only by the
First Defendant but with the active physical and
financial contribution of my father's earning and the
above property was acquired.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
12. The plaintiff humbly submits that the Suit
Schedule 'B' Property as stated supra is an Ancestral
Property and Suit Schedule 'C' Property was jointly
purchased
by
my
Late
father
and
the
First
Defendant.
13. The plaintiff humbly submits that in view
of the above submission, the Suit Schedule 'A', 'B' &
'C' Properties are undivided Joint Family Properties
which are in possession and enjoyment of the
Plaintiff and the Defendants.
14.
The plaintiff humbly submits that due to
the hard work, financial contribution and other
miscellaneous expenses incurred in the upkeep of the
property the Plaintiff has been contributing and it is
very much evident that the First and the Second
Defendant are mere spectators and enjoying at the
expense of the labour of the plaintiff.
15. The plaintiff humbly submits that the First
Defendant took voluntary retirement in the year
1989 and as stated supra, the Plaintiff father died in
1999.
The entire concept of maintaining the Suit
Schedule Properties was vested with the Plaintiff's
father and after his death, the plaintiff and the Sixth
Defendant have been jointly contributing and taking
care of the Suit Schedule Properties. It is in this
context the Suit Schedule Property are undivided
Joint Family Properties and the plaintiff has a definite
share over the same.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
16. The plaintiff humbly submits that after the
retirement of the First Defendant, she has been
residing in the residence of the Second Defendant
and the First Defendant is under the control of the
Second Defendant."
(emphasis supplied)
13. Upon a
comprehensive examination of the
pleadings in O.S.No.25898/2022, this Court finds that the
relationship
between
the
parties
is
admitted
and
undisputed. The defendant in the present counter claim
had instituted the said suit seeking partition and separate
possession, wherein his mother was arrayed as defendant
No.1 and his siblings as defendant Nos.2 to 6. The gist of
the plaint in the partition suit was a clear assertion of coownership and joint family rights. The defendant, as
plaintiff therein, pleaded that the suit schedule properties
were either ancestral in nature or were acquired or jointly
acquired and that defendant No.1 had been misled into
executing the Settlement Deed and Gift Deeds impugned
therein.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
14.
Significantly, on a close and careful reading of
the entire plaint, this Court finds that nowhere has the
defendant, who was the plaintiff in the partition suit,
pleaded that he was in possession of the suit schedule ‘A’
property as a tenant under his mother, nor has he averred
that his possession was traceable to any lease or tenancy
arrangement. On the contrary, the entire foundation of the
plaint rests on assertions of ownership, joint possession,
and
entitlement
to
partition.
These
pleadings
unequivocally disclose the nature of possession claimed by
the defendant and constitute clear admissions as to his
status and rights over the property.
15.
It is well settled that pleadings are binding on
the parties and a litigant cannot be permitted to approbate
and
reprobate
by
taking
mutually
destructive
and
inconsistent stands. Having asserted ownership and joint
possession in the plaint, the defendant is estopped from
subsequently contending that his possession is that of a
tenant.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
16. The plea of tenancy has been introduced for the
first time only
after the rejection of the plaint in
O.S.No.25898/2022, which has attained finality. This plea
has been set up solely as a defence to the counter claim
filed by the mother seeking recovery of possession. The
timing, manner, and circumstances under which this plea
is raised unmistakably indicate that it is a belated and
contrived plea, intended only to obstruct and defeat the
lawful claim of the mother to recover possession of her
property.
17.
The extracted pleadings in the partition suit
must be examined in the context of Sections 17, 18, 21,
and 22 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The averments
made by the defendant in the partition suit, while he was
the plaintiff therein, constitute clear and categorical
admissions regarding the nature of the property and the
character
of
his
possession.
Such
admissions
substantive in nature and bind the maker thereof.
are
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nagindas
Ramdas v. Dalpatram Ichharam @ Brijram and
Others1 has unequivocally held that admissions made in
pleadings are admissible under Section 58 of the Evidence
Act, stand on a higher footing than evidentiary admissions,
and are fully binding on the parties unless withdrawn or
amended in accordance with law. In the present case, the
defendant neither sought nor obtained any amendment of
the pleadings in the partition suit. Consequently, those
admissions continue to bind him, and he cannot be
permitted to resile therefrom by setting up a diametrically
opposite plea in the counter claim proceedings.
19.
In the absence of any plea of tenancy at the
inception and in view of the clear and unambiguous
assertions of ownership and joint possession in the earlier
pleadings, the defendant is legally precluded from raising
a contradictory plea of tenancy for the first time in the
written statement filed to the counter claim. Such a plea is
(1974)1 SCC 242
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
not only inconsistent but strikes at the root of judicial
discipline and fairness in pleadings.
20.
In the light of the foregoing discussion, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the findings
recorded by the Trial Court on the counter claim and the
decree passed thereon are in strict conformity with law.
The rent receipts relied upon by the defendant are devoid
of any probative value, having been brought into existence
only after the rejection of the plaint and its affirmation by
this Court. Once these documents are excluded from
consideration, there remains no material whatsoever to
establish that the defendant was inducted as a tenant by
his mother, plaintiff No.1, in respect of the suit schedule
‘A’ property.
21. Accordingly, this Court finds no infirmity in the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. Point
Nos.(i) to (iii) are answered in the Negative.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:6338
RFA No. 2829 of 2025
HC-KAR
22. Point No.(iv):- In view of the findings recorded
on point Nos.(i) to (iii),
this Court proceeds to pass the
following;
ORDER
(i)
The appeal is dismissed.
(ii)
Pending
applications,
if
any,
are
also
dismissed.
SD/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
NBM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review