Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:100
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 29th August, 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
:
Petitioners
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and (27) Others
versus
Respondents :
State of Sikkim and Others
Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Ranjit Prasad and Ms. Neha
Kumari Gupta, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Shakil Raj Karki, Government Advocate for Respondent Nos.1
and 2.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India for the
Respondent Nos. 3 and 4.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The
Petitioners
are
members
of
“Project
affected
families”, their lands having been acquired for the development of
the Rangit Stage IV, Hydro Electric Power Project, pursuant to an
Agreement,
dated
09-12-2005,
executed
between
the
State-
Respondent No.1 with Respondent No.3, through Respondent No.2.
The Petitioners are presently employed under the Respondent No.4
Company. In the Writ Petition, they seek the following reliefs;
(a) a writ of Mandamus and/or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction for quashing the Article 4.16 of
the Said Agreement.
(b) a writ of mandamus and/or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction thereby directing the Respondent
No.4 to regularise the services of the Petitioners in view
of the regularisation orders issued by the Respondent
No.3 to the Petitioners.
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(c)
a writ of Mandamus and/or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction thereby directing the Respondent
No.4 to fix pay scale for the Petitioner Nos.1, 2 and 18
as at par with 3rd grade and the Petitioner Nos.3 to 17
and 19 to 29 as at par with 4th grade and all
entitlements to be provided to the Petitioners at par with
other regular project affected employees of the
Respondent No.4.
(d) a writ of Mandamus and/or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction thereby direct the Respondents
to rehabilitate the Petitioners as per the Article 3.6 of
the said Agreement.
(e) pass any other appropriate order/orders as this
Hon‟ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
2.
A brief summation of the facts of the Petitioners case is
that, the Respondent No.3 was selected by Respondent No.1, to
develop the Rangit Stage IV Hydro Electric Power Project in
West/South Sikkim and a consequent Agreement dated 09-12-2005
entered into between Respondent No.1 and Respondent No.3, for
the Project, on a build, own, operate and transfer basis (BOOT),
through
the
Sikkim
Power
Development
Corporation
(SPDC).
Pursuant thereto, lands were acquired from the Petitioners for the
above purpose and they were offered appointments in the office of
Respondent No.3, in various posts on ad hoc basis, in terms of
Clause 4.16 of the Agreement which provides as follows;
4.16
Displaced Families
The Company shall provide employment to one
member of each of the displaced families or
adversely affected as a result of the acquisition
of land for the Projects covered in the
Rehabilitation Plan referred to in Clause 3.6 and
4.4 above in the process of the construction of
the Project and such employment shall cease
immediately on completion of construction of the
project.
(i)
On completion of the period of probation of six months
and fulfillment of
the
terms and
conditions of the
ad hoc
appointments, the services of the Petitioners were regularised by the
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Respondent No.3 in 2008 and 2009, vide various orders (Annexures
R-3 to R-30 collectively). In the meanwhile, in the year 2015 the
Respondent No.3 became insolvent and the financial creditor
approached the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Hyderabad
Branch.
The NCLT ordered the commencement of Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against the Respondent No.3,
vide order dated 09-04-2019. The Petitioners made claims against
the Respondent No.3 through Legal Notice dated 13-11-2019, to
Amit Jain, Resolution Professional. The Resolution Professional
addressed the claims of the Petitioners upon which their pending
salaries and Employees Provident Fund (EPF) were credited to their
accounts. The NCLT then permitted Respondent No.4 to take over
the Project of Respondent No.3. The Petitioners continued working
in their respective posts in the Project under Respondent No.4 and
received monthly salaries from the Respondent No.4 in terms of the
regularisation orders issued by the Respondent No.3. The Petitioners
vide
legal
notice,
dated
22-12-2021,
communicated
to
the
Respondent No.4 that, their services be regularised in terms of
Clause 3.6 of the Agreement. Legal notice was also issued to the
Respondent Nos.1 and 2, who directed the Petitioners to get their
claims addressed by the Respondent No.4. The Respondent No.4
declined to regularise the services of the Petitioners in view of
Clause 4.16 of the Agreement dated 09-12-2005.
The Petitioners
claim that the services of Project affected persons, working in the
Teesta Stage V Hydro Electric Project under Respondent No.4 are
permanent, hence they seek parity with such employees.
3.
As per Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 failed to comply with Clause 3.6 of the
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Agreement which provided for rehabilitation and resettlement plan
for the Project affected persons, in coordination with Respondent
No.1, which unfortunately has not been drawn up till date. The
Petitioners are rendered not only landless now but also homeless, as
the lands acquired by the Respondent No.3 from the Petitioners was
their only source of livelihood.
Permanent jobs in the Project had
been promised and provided to the Petitioners by Respondent No.3.
The Project having been taken over by Respondent No.4, it becomes
their responsibility to ensure continuity of the permanent services of
the Petitioners. Emphasising on the permanent employment afforded
of the employees in the Teesta Stage V Hydro Electric Project of
Respondent No.4, Learned Senior Counsel urged that the Petitioners
be treated on parity with the said employees, as employees of both
Projects are Project affected families under Respondent No.4. That,
not only does Clause 4.16 of the Agreement suffer from inherent
defects rendering it unsustainable but the Petitioners have also been
working below the prevalent minimum wage, under Respondent
No.4. The prayers in the Writ Petition thus be granted. To support
his contentions, reliance was placed on Modified Voluntary Retirement
Scheme of 2002 of Azam Jahi Mill Workers Association
Textile Corporation Limited and Others
vs. National
and Union of India and Others
vs. Munshi Ram2.
4.
Learned Government Advocate while contesting the
claims of the Petitioners, submitted that Clauses 3.6, 4.4 and 4.16
contained in the Agreement, dated 09-12-2005, casts a duty upon
Respondent No.4 to take steps for rehabilitation and resettlement of
the Project affected families and the responsibility does not vest on
(2022) 17 SCC 797
2022 SCC OnLine SC 1493
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Respondents No.1 and 2. Clause 3.6 of the Agreement clearly
provides that, the Company shall wherever required and subject to
the approval of any competent authority, prepare a rehabilitation
and resettlement plan in coordination with the Government for local
residents, who may be adversely affected or displaced, due to
construction of the Project at the site as on the effective date. The
provision requires all expenses to be borne by the Company, for
costs of preparation and implementation of the rehabilitation and
resettlement plan.
The rehabilitation and resettlement plan were
duly implemented under State supervision.
The relief against the
State Government is sought for only in prayer (d) of the Writ
Petition, viz., to rehabilitate the Petitioners as per Clause 3.6 of the
Agreement, which having been complied with, the State-Respondent
is not liable to take further steps.
That, the instant Petition is an
afterthought and hit by delay and laches as apparent from the
pleadings as the Petitioners were provided employment way back in
the year 2008 and the Petition has rather belatedly been filed in
2022. Hence, the Petition deserves to be dismissed.
5.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India (DSGI) for the
Respondents No.3 and 4 resisting the stance of the Petitioners
contended that, this Court has no jurisdiction to consider the instant
matter which was settled by the NCLT, vide its Order dated 24-122020, on which count succour was obtained from Ghanashyam Mishra
and Sons Private Limited through the Authorised Signatory vs. Edelweiss
Asset Reconstruction Company Limited through the Director and Others .
That, the employees of Respondent No.3 have been taken over by
Respondent No.4, the Agreement was of 2005, the payment made in
(2021) 9 SCC 657
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
2019 while the Writ Petition has been lodged in 2022, there is no
explanation for the delay of seventeen years, which is thereby not
maintainable as it suffers from delay and laches.
Reliance was
placed on Mrinmoy Maity vs. Chhanda Koley and Others4 and Chennai
Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board and Others
vs. T. T.
Murali Babu .
(i)
It was further contended that, the NCLT approved the
Resolution Plan submitted by Respondent No.4.
The Agreement
dated 09-12-2005 executed between the State Government and the
Respondent No.3 is a part of the NCLT Order, pursuant to which
Respondent
No.4
acquired
Respondent
No.3
Company.
The
Petitioners having participated in the Resolution Proceedings did not
seek quashing of Clause 4.16 of the said Agreement and are
therefore estopped from seeking the same now.
(ii)
It was urged that there has been a misrepresentation
and concealment of facts as the Petitioners have stated that they
are employees of Respondent No.4 when, in fact, they were
contractual employees of Respondent No.3.
Respondent No.3 and
Respondent No.4 are two separate legal entities. On account of such
misrepresentation, they are not entitled to the reliefs.
(iii)
It was next contended that the Petitioners being
contractual employees cannot claim regularisation as a matter of
right. Contrary to their claims of not having been rehabilitated, in
compliance of Clause 3.6 of the Agreement, dated 09-12-2005, the
Petitioners have been rehabilitated and are being paid wages as per
entitlements applicable in the State of Sikkim. In this context, the
Petitioners had complained before the Labour Department alleging
2024 SCC OnLine SC 551
(2014) 4 SCC 108
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
deprivation of minimum wages by Respondent No.4, which was
dismissed by the Department, on letter dated 25-11-2021 indicating
payment of minimum wages being submitted by Respondent No.4.
The land of the Petitioners was acquired following due procedure in
terms of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and the Petitioners were
well compensated for their lands, that aside, the Act (supra) makes
no provision for rehabilitation and resettlement.
(iv)
In a contradictory argument it was submitted in the
written arguments of Learned DSGI that, Respondent No.4 was not
a party to the Agreement dated 09-12-2005 and therefore did it
assume any obligations thereunder. The Petitioners‟ contractual
engagement was exclusively with Respondent No.3, which ceased to
exist, hence no relief can be sought against Respondent No.4.
To
buttress her arguments, Learned DSGI sought strength from the
Judgment of this Court in Sonam Thendup Bhutia and Another vs. State
of Sikkim and Another .
(v)
It was urged that there has been no violation of the
fundamental rights of the Petitioners, hence the Writ Petition
deserves no consideration, for which reliance was placed on Yogesh
Mahajan vs. Professor R. C. Deka, Director, All India Institute of Medical
Sciences
and Ganesh Digamber Jambhrunkar and Others vs. State of
Maharashtra and Others .
6.
Learned Counsel for the parties were heard at length,
the pleadings perused, as also the citations relied on by Learned
Counsel for the parties.
2022 SCC OnLine Sikk 113
(2018) 3 SCC 218
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1417
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
7.
The questions that fall for determination are; (i) whether
this Court has jurisdiction to consider the matter; and (ii) whether
there has been delay and laches in the Petitioners approaching the
Court.
8.
Before
venturing
into
a
discussion
on
the
above
questions, it is essential to point out that the arguments submitted
by Learned DSGI to the effect that Respondent No.4 was not a party
to the Agreement dated 09-12-2005 and therefore did not assume
the obligations of Respondent No.3 are erroneous and misleading as
Learned DSGI herself has in an earlier argument conceded that the
Agreement
dated
09-12-2005,
executed
between
the
State
Government and the Respondent No.3 is a part of the NCLT Order
upon which, Respondent No.4 acquired Respondent No.3 and the
Petitioners had participated in the Resolution Proceedings where no
issues were raised regarding Clause 4.16 of the Agreement.
The
argument that Petitioners have stated that they are employees of
Respondent
No.4
when
they
are
contractual
employees
of
Respondent No.3 cannot be countenanced, in view of the Order of
the NCLT dated 24-12-2020, whereby the employees of Respondent
No.3 were taken over by Respondent No.4.
These points need
detain us no further.
9.
While addressing the argument on the jurisdiction of this
Court, it is no more res integra that the existence of the statutory
remedy does not affect the jurisdiction of the High Court to issue a
writ.
Nevertheless, Writ Jurisdiction being discretionary by policy,
the Writ Courts generally insist that the parties adhere to alternative
statutory remedies, as this reinforces the rule of law. However, in
exceptional cases, Writ Jurisdiction can still be exercised to access
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
the Court for justice and relief.
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
In this context, in Tamil Nadu
Cements Corporation Limited vs. Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation
Council and Another , the Supreme Court held as follows;
“57. Following
the
judgments
in Whirlpool
Corpn. v. Registrar, Trade Marks [(1998) 8 SCC 1] and
Harbanslal Sahnia [(2003) 2 SCC 107], this Court in Radha
Krishan Industries v. State of H.P. [(2021) 6 SCC 771] laid
down the following principles : (Radha Krishan
Industries case [(2021) 6 SCC 771], SCC p. 795, para 27)
“27. The principles of law which emerge
are that:
27.1. The power under Article 226 of the
Constitution to issue writs can be exercised not
only for the enforcement of fundamental rights,
but for any other purpose as well.
27.2. The High Court has the discretion
not to entertain a writ petition. One of the
restrictions placed on the power of the High
Court is where an effective alternate remedy is
available to the aggrieved person.
27.3. Exceptions to the rule of alternate
remedy arise where : (a) the writ petition has
been filed for the enforcement of a fundamental
right protected by Part III of the Constitution;
(b) there has been a violation of the principles of
natural justice; (c) the order or proceedings are
wholly without jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a
legislation is challenged.
27.4. An alternate remedy by itself does
not divest the High Court of its powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate
case though ordinarily, a writ petition should not
be entertained when an efficacious alternate
remedy is provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute,
which itself prescribes the remedy or procedure
for enforcing the right or liability, resort must be
had to that particular statutory remedy before
invoking the discretionary remedy under Article
226 of the Constitution. This rule of exhaustion
of statutory remedies is a rule of policy,
convenience and discretion.
27.6. In cases where there are disputed
questions of fact, the High Court may decide to
decline jurisdiction in a writ petition. However, if
the High Court is objectively of the view that the
nature of the controversy requires the exercise
of its writ jurisdiction, such a view would not
readily be interfered with.”.”
(2025) 4 SCC 1
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The law on the exercise of Writ Jurisdiction and its invocation
is therefore soundly determined and needs no reiteration.
10.
At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to the
Judgment of Ghanashyam Mishra (supra) relied on by Learned DSGI.
In the said matter, the Supreme Court was considering the following
questions;
“…………………………………………………
2.1. (i) As to whether any creditor including the
Central Government, State Government or any local
authority is bound by the resolution plan once it is
approved by an adjudicating authority under subsection (1) of Section 31 of the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as “the
I&B Code”)?
2.2. (ii) As to whether the amendment to
Section 31 by Section 7 of Act 26 of 2019 is
clarificatory/declaratory or substantive in nature?
2.3. (iii) As to whether after approval of
resolution plan by the adjudicating authority a creditor
including the Central Government, State Government
or any local authority is entitled to initiate any
proceedings for recovery of any of the dues from the
corporate debtor, which are not a part of the resolution
plan approved by the adjudicating authority?
…………………………………………………”
(i)
The Supreme Court inter alia elucidated therein as
follows;
“65. Bare reading of Section 31 of the I&B Code
would also make it abundantly clear that once the
resolution plan is approved by the adjudicating
authority, after it is satisfied, that the resolution plan
as approved by CoC meets the requirements as
referred to in sub-section (2) of Section 30, it shall be
binding on the corporate debtor and its employees,
members,
creditors,
guarantors
and
other
stakeholders. Such a provision is necessitated since
one of the dominant purposes of the I&B Code is
revival of the corporate debtor and to make it a
running concern.
67. Perusal of Section 29 of the I&B Code read
with Regulation 36 of the Regulations would reveal that
it requires RP to prepare an information memorandum
containing various details of the corporate debtor so
that the resolution applicant submitting a plan is aware
of the assets and liabilities of the corporate debtor,
including the details about the creditors and the
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
amounts claimed by them. It is also required to contain
the details of guarantees that have been given in
relation to the debts of the corporate debtor by other
persons. The details with regard to all material
litigation and an ongoing investigation or proceeding
initiated by the Government and statutory authorities
are also required to be contained in the information
memorandum. So also the details regarding the
number of workers and employees and liabilities of the
corporate debtor towards them are required to be
contained in the information memorandum.
68. All these details are required to be contained
in the information memorandum so that the resolution
applicant is aware as to what are the liabilities that he
may have to face and provide for a plan, which apart
from satisfying a part of such liabilities would also
ensure, that the corporate debtor is revived and made
a running establishment. The legislative intent of
making the resolution plan binding on all the
stakeholders after it gets the seal of approval from the
adjudicating authority upon its satisfaction, that the
resolution plan approved by CoC meets the
requirement as referred to in sub-section (2) of Section
30 is that after the approval of the resolution plan, no
surprise claims should be flung on the successful
resolution applicant. The dominant purpose is that he
should start with fresh slate on the basis of the
resolution plan approved.”
(ii)
It was further held that;
“102.1. That once a resolution plan is duly
approved by the adjudicating authority under subsection (1) of Section 31, the claims as provided in the
resolution plan shall stand frozen and will be binding
on the corporate debtor and its employees, members,
creditors, including the Central Government, any State
Government or any local authority, guarantors and
other stakeholders. On the date of approval of
resolution plan by the adjudicating authority, all such
claims, which are not a part of resolution plan, shall
stand extinguished and no person will be entitled to
initiate or continue any proceedings in respect to a
claim, which is not part of the resolution plan.
102.2. The 2019 Amendment to Section 31 of
the I&B Code is clarificatory and declaratory in nature
and therefore will be effective from the date on which
the I&B Code has come into effect.
102.3. Consequently all the dues including the
statutory dues owed to the Central Government, any
State Government or any local authority, if not part of
the resolution plan, shall stand extinguished and no
proceedings in respect of such dues for the period prior
to the date on which the adjudicating authority grants
its approval under Section 31 could be continued.”
[emphasis supplied]
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The Supreme Court has held in no uncertain term that once a
plea is approved by the adjudicating authority, the claims provided
therein stand frozen and are binding on the stakeholders therein.
(iii)
In Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Limited vs.
Satish Kumar Gupta and Others
the Supreme Court observed as
follows;
“107. For the same reason, the impugned
NCLAT judgment [Standard Chartered Bank v. Satish Kumar
Gupta, 2019 SCC OnLine NCLAT 388] in holding that claims
that may exist apart from those decided on merits by
the resolution professional and by the Adjudicating
Authority/Appellate Tribunal can now be decided by an
appropriate forum in terms of Section 60(6) of the
Code, also militates against the rationale of Section 31
of the Code. A successful resolution applicant cannot
suddenly be faced with “undecided” claims after the
resolution plan submitted by him has been accepted
as this would amount to a hydra head popping up
which would throw into uncertainty amounts payable
by a prospective resolution applicant who would
successfully take over the business of the corporate
debtor. All claims must be submitted to and decided
by the resolution professional so that a prospective
resolution applicant knows exactly what has to be
paid in order that it may then take over and run the
business of the corporate debtor. This the successful
resolution applicant does on a fresh slate, as has been
pointed out by us hereinabove. For these reasons,
NCLAT judgment must also be set aside on this count.”
[emphasis supplied]
11.
On the bedrock of these settled positions of law, it would
be apposite to notice that the Petitioners have averred that they
have put forth their demands before the Resolution Professional and
subsequently their demands with regard to the salary and EPF were
met. The Order of the NCLT dated 24-12-2020 inter alia reads as
follows;
“1.
(2020) 8 SCC 531
The present application bearing IA No. 171/2020
is filed by Resolution Professional seeking
following reliefs:
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
(i)
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
і.
Ассеpt and approve the Resolution Plan
dated 04.12.2019, as amended and
restated
vide
the
final
negotiated
resolution plan submitted on 20.01.2020,
each issued by NHPC and submitted in
respect of the CIR Process of the
Corporate Debtor.
ii.
Declare that the resolution plan, upon its
approval shall be binding on the Corporate
Debtor and its employees, members,
creditors,
guarantors
and
other
stakeholders (including but not limited to
Government Undertakings) involved in the
resolution plan;
iii.
Approve and grant such reliefs as sought
by the Resolution Applicant under the
Resolution Plan, as set out under para 19
and clause 15 of the Annexure G of the
Resolution Plan;
iv.
Approve
the
appointment
of
the
Monitoring Agency as stipulated in the
Resolution Plan from the Effective Date
until the Completion Date and direct that
the CoC and the Resolution Professional
may continue with their roles and
responsibilities, and have protections, as
set out in the Code including approving
the matters as are being approved, during
the period prior to the Effective Date;
v.
Direct that the powers of the Board of
Directors of the Corporate Debtor shall
remain suspended until the Completion
Date / Transfer Date.”
In tandem with the said Paragraph, Annexure „G‟ of the
NCLT Order is also to be considered.
As per Clause 7.2(b) of
Annexure „G‟, it was ordered as follows;
“7.2 Liquidation value to Employee’s/workmen’s dues
(a)
……………………………………………
(b)
The Services of existing employees who are
on
contract
employment
or
fulltime
employment would be suitably extended
considering their qualification, competency
and suitability and as per the requirement
of the Corporate Debtor and Resolution
Applicant over the construction period on
existing terms and conditions. ”
[emphasis supplied]
(ii)
The application, [being IA No.171 of 2020 (supra)] was
in the knowledge of the Petitioners.
Clause 7.2(b) (supra) was
brought to the notice of the Assistant Labour Commissioner,
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Department of Labour, vide letter dated 25-11-2022 by the Group
General Manager of Rangit IV Hydro Electric Project (JPCL),
Annexure R4.
Looking into this Clause, it is apparent that the
Petitioners who were evidently the employees of Respondent No.3,
became the employees of Respondent No.4, as Respondent No.4
was to continue it as a going concern. Indubitably, the Petitioners
were a part of the Resolution Process, having submitted their
demands to the Resolution Professional. They are evidently aware
of the outcome of the decision of the NCLT as can be seen from the
fact of the settlement of their salaries and EPF. The above Clause
extracted is not only succinct but explains lucidly about the service
conditions of the Petitioners. Despite the NCLT having dealt with the
service conditions of the Petitioners and spelt out that the services
of existing employees, who are on contract employment or full time
employment would be suitably extended, depending upon the
factors enumerated therein, the Petitioners did not at any point in
time deem it essential to raise the issue before the NCLT if they
were aggrieved by such an observation, nor was Clause 4.16 of the
Agreement agitated before the Adjudicating Authority as unjust.
They did not claim permanent employment in the Respondent No.4
Company in the face of the orders of the NCLT.
(iii)
As per Office Order of the Respondent No.3 dated 29-
06-2021
(Annexure
R3
collectively),
it
has
been
elucidated
unequivocally therein inter alia as follows;
“………………………………………………………………………………………
(i)
The services of the Four (04) employees as
employed/engaged
by
the
erstwhile
management of JPCL and posted at Project Site
Office as per the names enclosed at Annexure-I
of this order is hereby continued for a period of
One (01) year w.e.f. 01.04.2021 on the existing
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
salary, terms and conditions of Fixed Term Basis
(FTB) extendable from time to time as per
requirement.
(iv)
(ii)
The services of the Twenty Nine (29) Nos of PAF
persons
as
engaged
by
the
erstwhile
management of JPCL and posted at Project Site
Office as per the names enclosed at Annexure-II
of this order is hereby continued for a period of
One (01) year w.e.f. 01.04.2021 on the existing
terms and conditions on Fixed Term Basis (FTB)
extendable from time to time as per requirement
till the duration of construction of the project.
(iii)
While extending the services of the above
employees/PAFs, the provisions of minimum
wages as notified by the state and as applicable
to the employees/PAFs shall be complied with.
……………………………………………………………………”
This Office Order is indicative of the fact that the
employment of the Petitioners was in terms as agreed with
Respondent No.3. The Agreement with Respondent No.3 at Clause
4.16 which has already been extracted hereinabove, and provides
that the company shall provide employment to one member of each
of the displaced or adversely affected families as a result of the
acquisition of land for the Projects covered in the rehabilitation plan,
referred to in Clause 3.6 and Clause 4.4, in the process of the
construction of the Project.
therein
that
such
It has been categorically specified
employment
shall
cease
“completion of construction of the project”.
immediately
on
Relevantly, it may be
mentioned that at Clause 3.3 of the Agreement, it has been clarified
that the Government in association with the SPDC shall acquire at
the request and the expense of the Company and in accordance with
the provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894, under the State
Government and other applicable laws, such private lands within the
State
of
Sikkim
as
may
be
required
by
the
Company
for
construction, operation and maintenance of the Project (acquired
land) and transfer such acquired land in favour of the Company for
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
implementing the Project. It is pertinent to mention here that the
pleadings of neither the Petitioners nor the Respondents indicate
whether compensation was paid to the Petitioners in terms of Land
Acquisition Act, 1894.
Be that as it may, as it is not the bone of
contention between the parties no further discussions need ensue
thereon. Clause 3.6 of the Agreement provides as follows;
“3.6 Rehabilitation and Resettlement Plan
The Company shall wherever required and subject to
the approval of any competent authority, prepare a
rehabilitation and re-settlement plan in coordination
with the Government for local residents that might be
adversely affected or displaced due to construction of
the Project at the Site as on the Effective Date. The
cost of preparation and implementation of the above
plan shall be borne by the Company and implemented
under the supervision of the Government.”
Clause 4.4 of the Agreement provides for Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Plan and reads as follows;
“4.4 Rehabilitation and Resettlement Plan
The Company shall prepare rehabilitation and
resettlement plan in coordination with the Government
and implementation thereof will be done under the
supervision of the Government at the cost of the
Company pursuant to Clause 3.6. The amount so
incurred shall form part of the Project cost.”
(v)
From a bare reading of the above Clauses, there is no
specification that permanent employment is to be granted to the
Petitioners.
In terms of Clause 4.16 (supra), the members of the
displaced families have been granted employment which is to be till
completion or construction of the Project. The Agreement is of 2005,
the Petitioners did not raise any objection to the terms and
conditions therein as already pointed out. The argument advanced
by Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners that there has been no
compliance of Clause 3.6 of the Agreement cannot be countenanced
for the reasons enumerated hereinabove.
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
(vi)
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The argument that permanent jobs in the Project had
been promised and provided to the Petitioners by Respondent No.3
appears to be an erroneous submission on behalf of the Petitioners.
The Order issued to the Petitioner No.1 (by way of example), dated
19-03-2009 (in Annexure P3 collectively), by Respondent No.3,
specifies therein that “………… The services are being regularised as
per the Agreement made on 09.12.2005, with Govt. of Sikkim.
…………”. The terms of the Agreement, more especially Clause 4.16
has already been laid out hereinabove for clarity which makes no
mention of permanent employment to the Petitioners.
(vii)
Also the Petitioners have not been able to show any
statutory or other rights to have their contracts extended beyond
the period of the completion of the projects. It is now settled law
that no contract employee has right to have his or her contract
renewed from time to time.
This has been reiterated by the
Supreme Court in Yogesh Mahajan (supra) as follows;
“6. It is settled law that no contract employee
has a right to have his or her contract renewed from
time to time. That being so, we are in agreement with
the Central Administrative Tribunal and the High Court
that the petitioner was unable to show any statutory or
other right to have his contract extended beyond 30-62010. At best, the petitioner could claim that the
authorities concerned should consider extending his
contract. We find that in fact due consideration was
given to this and in spite of a favourable
recommendation having been made, the All India
Institute of Medical Sciences did not find it appropriate
or necessary to continue with his services on a
contractual basis. We do not find any arbitrariness in
the view taken by the authorities concerned and
therefore reject this contention of the petitioner.”
(viii)
Thus, in light of the factual situation and the legal
position propounded in the foregoing decisions, I find that no reason
arises for this Court to delve into matters settled by the NCLT,
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
where the final orders have been accepted without demur by the
Petitioners.
12.
While addressing the second question, it is apparent
from the timelines that the Petitioners have slept over their rights.
In Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (supra), the
Supreme Court held as follows;
“16. Thus, the doctrine of delay and laches
should not be lightly brushed aside. A writ court is
required to weigh the explanation offered and the
acceptability of the same. The court should bear in
mind that it is exercising an extraordinary and
equitable jurisdiction. As a constitutional court it has a
duty to protect the rights of the citizens but
simultaneously it is to keep itself alive to the primary
principle that when an aggrieved person, without
adequate reason, approaches the court at his own
leisure or pleasure, the court would be under legal
obligation to scrutinise whether the lis at a belated
stage should be entertained or not. Be it noted, delay
comes in the way of equity. In certain circumstances
delay and laches may not be fatal but in most
circumstances inordinate delay would only invite
disaster for the litigant who knocks at the doors of the
court. Delay reflects inactivity and inaction on the part
of a litigant — a litigant who has forgotten the basic
norms, namely, “procrastination is the greatest thief of
time” and second, law does not permit one to sleep
and rise like a phoenix. Delay does bring in hazard and
causes injury to the lis.”
(i)
It appears from the facts placed before this Court that
there has been an inordinate delay in approaching the Court. The
following can be culled out from the Writ Petition;
a)
On 09-12-2005, an Agreement was entered into between
Respondent No.1 with Respondent No.3 through Respondent
No.2.
b)
In 2008, vide various Office Orders (Annexure P3 collectively),
employment was given to the Petitioners by Respondent No.3.
c)
The NCLT issued its Order dated 24-12-2020.
2025:SHC:100
WP(C) No.33 of 2022
Pema Chhoda Sherpa and Others
d)
Vide
Office
Order
dated
vs. State of Sikkim and Others
29-06-2021
(Annexure
R3
collectively), the Respondent No.3 became a wholly owned
subsidiary company of Respondent w.e.f. 31-03-2021.
e)
Although the insolvency of Respondent No.3 pertained to the
year 2015 and the NCLT commenced the CIRP against
Respondent No.3 in April, 2019, but the Agreement between
Respondents No. 1 and 2 with Respondent No.3 was of the
year 2005 and Clause 4.16 is categorical in its intent and
purport, but remained unassailed from 2005.
f)
The Writ Petition came to be filed on 04-07-2022 enumerating
the grievances and reliefs sought.
(ii)
The
settled
position
of
law
is,
vigilantibus
non
dormientibus aequitas subvenit lex, in other words equity aids the
vigilant and not those who sleep over their rights. „Laches‟ derived
from the French language, meaning ”remissness and slackness‟,
involves unreasonable delay. Acquiescence would mean a tacit or
passive acceptance [See Union of India and Others vs. N. Murugesan and
Others : (2022) 2 SCC 25].
The conduct of the Petitioners points to
delay, laches and acquiescence. The timelines extracted above are
reflective of the belated steps taken by Petitioners in filing the
Petition.
The above discussions lends a quietus to the second
question settled for determination.
13.
The Writ Petition lacking merit, deserves to be and is
accordingly dismissed.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
29-08-2025
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review