Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 24
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 401 of 2019
Date of Decision: 29.09.2022
Shri. Pawan Rai & Anr.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC (For R 1)
Mr. S.P. Mahanta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv. (For R 2 & 3).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner No. 1 who is working as a Mazdoor and the
petitioner No. 2 who is working as Mali, in the Office of the respondents
No. 2 and 3, are before this Court with a prayer, amongst others, for setting
aside and quashing the impugned Employment Notice dated 01.10.2018,
as far as it relates to the filling up of one post of Fitter (Water Supply) and
also for being considered for promotion to the vacancies in the said post.
2.
The basis of the claim of the petitioners for promotion to the post
of Fitter (Water Supply) is founded on their contention that the same is a
promotional post and as such, the Employment Notice dated 01.10.2018,
calling for direct recruitment to the said post is without jurisdiction and
against the stated policy of the respondents.
3.
The petitioners it appears from the records had approached this
Court on an earlier occasion, against the same impugned Employment
Notice vide WP(C) No. 93 of 2019, and on an affidavit being filed by the
respondents, placing reliance on Rule 5(B) (3) and Rule 5(B) (5) of the
Cantonment Fund Servants Rules, 1937, had then filed another writ
petition being WP(C) No. 383 of 2019, for quashing the aforesaid Rules.
These two writ petitions were then subsequently withdrawn by the
petitioners with liberty to file afresh. Accordingly, the present writ petition
has been filed challenging the validity of the decisions of the Cantonment
Board, Shillong.
4.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties.
5.
Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioners has
strenuously argued the case of the petitioners on the premise, that the post
that has been advertised is not a direct recruitment post, by referring to the
affidavit filed by the respondents filed in WP(C) No. 93 of 2019, where
he submits, the respondents have admitted that on earlier occasions, the
said post of Fitter was filled up by way of promotion. It is further
submitted that except for the Cantonment Board in Shillong, the other
Cantonment Boards have promotional avenues for lower grade employees
such as Mali, Mazdoor, etc., and also that the post of Fitter is not a direct
recruitment post. He submits that the decision of the Cantonment Board
to change the promotional post of Fitter into a direct recruitment post is
arbitrary and illegal, especially in the absence of any valid notification
under the relevant Rules of the Cantonment Board.
6.
The learned counsel then submits that the petitioners have also
been deprived of any promotion in their careers, which goes against the
grain of entitlements of an employee in his service career. In support of
this contention, learned counsel has cited the following decisions:
i)
A. Satyanarayana and Others vs. S. Purushotam
and Others reported in (2008) 5 SCC 416.
ii)
Food Corporation of India and Ors. vs.
Parashotam Das Bansal & Ors. reported in (2008)
5 SCC 100.
iii)
Dr. Ms O.Z. Hussain vs. UOI reported in 1990
(Supp) SCC 688.
iv)
CSIR & Another vs. K.G.S. Bhatt & Another
reported in (1989) SCC 635.
v)
K.K. Roy vs. State of Tripura reported in (2004) 9
SCC 65.
7.
Mr. S.P. Mahanta, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. D.
Dkhar, learned counsel for the respondents in reply, has referred to the
affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of the respondents No. 2 and 3, and
submits that the post of Fitter (Water Supply) has been declared as a direct
recruitment post under the provision of Rule 5(B) (5) of the Cantonment
Fund Servants Rules, 1937. He submits that, the claim of the writ
petitioners that the said post is a promotional post, is without any basis
whatsoever, and a mere perusal of the Memorandum of Settlement,
entered into between the Cantonment Boards and the workmen on
13.05.1969, will make it clear that it nowhere says, provides or means that
the post of Fitter is to be filled by indirect recruitment, nor does it say it
has to be filled up by promotion. He asserts that the submissions of the
writ petitioners to the contrary on this aspect is misleading, as in fact, the
said Memorandum of Settlement dated 13.05.1969 was entered into, for
fixation of the schedule of pay scale and for revision of pay and
allowances of the Cantonment employees, and the term ‘direct’ and
‘indirect’ was with regard to the equation of the post with the post of State
Government employees.
8.
The learned Senior counsel then submits that the only source of
power for prescribing the qualifications and for classification of posts is
under Rule 5(B) (3) and Rule 5(B) (5) of the Cantonment Fund Servants
Rules, 1937. In this context, the learned Senior counsel has referred to the
‘Statement of Posts under the Cantonment Board within Eastern
Command’ in respect of which, the GOC-in-Chief is to prescribe
minimum qualifications under Rule 5(B) (3) of the Cantonment Fund
Servants Rules, 1937, which is annexed at Annexure – 4 to the affidavitin-opposition. He draws the attention of this Court to the said Statement
of Posts, wherein at Serial No. 3, the post of Fitter (Water Supply) is
shown as a direct recruitment post, with the minimum qualifications
prescribed of Primary School Standard Pass and Recruitment Trade Test
Pass as Fitter (Water Supply). He submits that the recruitment to the post,
is as per the roster maintained, and the employment notice issued
specifically calling for applications only from Scheduled Tribe candidates
was as per this roster. The learned Senior counsel has also referred to the
Reservation Roster Register which is annexed to the writ petition itself, to
substantiate this point.
9.
With regard to the contention of the petitioners that they have in
the entire service career not been afforded any promotion, the learned
Senior counsel submits that the petitioners have however, been given the
benefit of ACP and MACP, and to substantiate this point has referred to a
Paybill for payment of ACP arrears dated 30.04.2018, wherein the
petitioners have drawn the arrears as due, and appended their signatures
therein. He concludes by submitting that the petitioners have no case as
there has been no irregularity in the entire process, and even if the posts
could be filled up by way of promotion, he submits, the petitioners were
not eligible for lack of qualifications. He therefore prays that the writ
petition be dismissed.
10.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC for the respondent No. 1, has not
forwarded any submissions, in view of the fact that the main answering
respondent is the Cantonment Board.
11.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, and on perusing
the materials on record, the only issue that is to be considered is whether
the said post of Fitter (Water Supply) is a promotional post for which the
petitioners could have been considered against. The petitioners have tried
to make out a case that, the post is promotional, by relying upon the
Memorandum of Settlement that had been arrived at on 13.05.1969, for
the equation of post between the employees of the Cantonment Board and
the State Government. It is seen that under the heading/caption ‘whether
equated directly or indirectly’, the post of Fitter (Water Supply) at Serial
No. 16, is shown indirectly equated to Fitter II Class PWD. A plain
reading, shows that this does not denote the manner of recruitment but
only that there has been an indirect equation of similar posts. As such, the
submissions of the petitioners on this point is rejected. On another aspect,
it is seen that under the Cantonment Fund Servants Rules, 1937, with
regard to classification of post under Cantonment Board, Rule 5-B (5)(ii)
has provided as follows:
“Classification of Posts Under Cantonment Boards
Under Rule 5-B (5) of Cantonment Fund Servants Rules, 1937
(a) The following principles shall be adopted for classification of
posts in different cantonments : (i) ………………..
(ii) For technical and skilled posts, the higher post will be
declared as a promotion post subject to the condition that
wherever there is an indirect equation with corresponding
State Govt. post under Memorandum of Settlement, the
General Officer-Commanding-in-Chief, the Command will
lay down the minimum qualification under rule 5-B (3) of the
Cantonment Fund Servants Rules, 1937. In the absence of
prescribed educational/professional qualifications, posts will
be filled by direct recruitment.”
12.
As can be seen from above, this rule vests the power on the
General Officer Commanding in Chief, to prescribe the minimum
qualifications under Rule 5-B (3), whenever there is an indirect equation
with the corresponding State Government post under the Memorandum of
Settlement and that in the absence of prescribed educational/professional
qualifications, the post was to be filled up by direct recruitment. The
respondents therefore by adhering to and implementing this rule, had in
the Statement of Post under the Cantonment Board within Eastern
Command, accordingly stipulated the qualification apart from indicating
that the post was to be filled up by direct recruitment.
13.
In this view of the matter, the subsequent action of the
respondents in issuing the impugned Employment Notice prescribing the
qualifications and reserving the post for a Scheduled Tribe candidate as
per roster cannot be faulted with. In the totality of the circumstances
therefore, no case has been made out by the petitioners calling for any
interference by this Court. As far as, the claim for promotion of the
petitioners, this question need not be gone into, inasmuch as, the same
falls under a different subject matter altogether apart from the fact that,
there is no possibility in law or otherwise, of the petitioners being
considered against the post of Fitter (Water Supply) by way of promotion.
14.
In view of the foregoing reasons, therefore, there being no merit
in the instant writ petition, the same is accordingly dismissed, however,
leaving the parties to bear their own costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
29.09.2022
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review