Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018, 2100 OF 2018, 2577 OF
2018, 2639 OF 2018 AND 664 OF 2019
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018
Between:
Battula Srinu @ Mataye Kottu Srinu,
R/o. Nagarjuna Colony,
Sattenapally, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.1
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh.
...Respondent/complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2100 OF 2018
Between:
Tadikonda Srinivasa Rao @ Ganduluri Srinivasa Rao,
S/o Koteswara Rao,
occ.Coolie, R/o.Gundluru Village,
Sattenapalli Mandal, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.2
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2639 OF 2018
Between:
Pasupuleti Srinivas @ Mykel Jonson @ Mykel Srinu,
S/o Kotaiah,
R/o. Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli,
Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.3
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
...Respondent/Complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.664 OF 2019
Between:
Bontha Rama Krishna,
S/o. Koteswara Rao,
R/o. Venkatapaiah Colony,
Sattenapalli Town, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.6
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2577 OF 2018
Between:
Shaik Rafi,
Kanakanapalli Village,
Yannadevi, Sattenpalli.
...Appellant/Accused No.4
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
Date of Judgment Pronounced
:
07-10-2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
1.
2.
3.
Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the judgment?
Whether the copy of judgment may
be marked to Law Reporters/Journals?
Whether Their Lordships wish to see the
fair copy of the judgment?
Yes/No
Yes/No
Yes/No
___________________
K.SURESH REDDY, J.
__________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
* THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
+ CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018, 2100 OF 2018, 2577 OF 2018,
2639 OF 2018 AND 664 OF 2019
% Dated: 07.10.2026
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018
Between:
Battula Srinu @ Mataye Kottu Srinu,
R/o. Nagarjuna Colony,
Sattenapally, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.1
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh.
...Respondent/complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2100 OF 2018
Between:
Tadikonda Srinivasa Rao @ Ganduluri Srinivasa Rao,
S/o Koteswara Rao,
occ.Coolie, R/o.Gundluru Village,
Sattenapalli Mandal, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.2
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2639 OF 2018
Between:
Pasupuleti Srinivas @ Mykel Jonson @ Mykel Srinu,
S/o Kotaiah,
R/o. Vaddavalli, Sattenapalli,
Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.3
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
...Respondent/Complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.664 OF 2019
Between:
Bontha Rama Krishna,
S/o. Koteswara Rao,
R/o. Venkatapaiah Colony,
Sattenapalli Town, Guntur District.
...Appellant/Accused No.6
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2577 OF 2018
Between:
Shaik Rafi,
Kanakanapalli village,
Yannadevi, Sattenpalli.
...Appellant/Accused No.4
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep. by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Andhra Pradesh
....Respondent/Complainant
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
!Counsel for the appellants :
Smt. A. Swarupa Reddy,
Dr. Challa Srinivasa Reddy,
Sri B.V. Ram Naresh Kumar,
Sri K.V. Durga Divakar and
Sri S. Dilip Jaya Ram
^Counsel for the respondent:
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor
<GIST:
>HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred:
1. (2014) 10 SCC 14,
2. (2020) 7 SCC 1
3. 2023 INSC 988
4. 2026 INSC 217
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
Date of reserved for orders : 16.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 07.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 10.10.2026
APHC010375032018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
WEDNESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 1685/2018
Between:
...APPELLANT
Battula Srinu @ Mataye Kottu Srinu,
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. A SWARUPA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. K R J RAO
2. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
APHC010395112018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
WEDNESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2100/2018
Between:
...APPELLANT
Tadikonda Srinivasa Rao @ G.Srinivasa Rao
AND
...RESPONDENT
State Of Ap
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. Dr CHALLA SRINIVASA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. THOTA RAMAKOTESWARA RAO
2. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
APHC010700852018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3596]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2577/2018
Between:
...APPELLANT
Shaik Rafi
AND
...RESPONDENT
The State Of Andhra Pradesh
Counsel for the Apellant:
1. B V RAM NARESH KUMAR
2. LEGAL AID
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
APHC010726302018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3596]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2639/2018
Between:
...APPELLANT
Pasupuleti Srinivas @ Mykel Jonson @ Mykel Srinu
AND
...RESPONDENT
The State Of Andhra Pradesh
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. K V DURGA DIVAKARR
2. LEGAL AID
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
APHC010252272019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3596]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 664/2019
Between:
...APELLANT
Bontha Rama Krishna
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. S DILIP JAYA RAM
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. K R J RAO
2. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
Whether the Judgment is :
Speaking Yes / Reasoned Yes
Reportable Yes
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND
AND TWENTY SIX
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018, 2100 OF 2018, 2577 OF 2018,
2639 OF 2018 AND 664 OF 2019
COMMONJUDGMENT
(Per Hon‟ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Aggrieved by the conviction and sentence recorded in the judgment
dated 09.2.2018 in S.C.No. 330 of 2012 on the file of the Court of learned
Special Judge for Trial of Cases under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989-cum-IV Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Guntur, appellant-accused No. 1 filed Criminal Appeal
No.1685 of 2018, appellant/accused No.2 filed Criminal Appeal No.2100 of
2018, appellant/accused No.3 filed Criminal Appeal No.2639 of 2018,
appellant-accused No.4 filed Criminal Appeal No.2577 of 2018 and
appellant/accused No.6 filed Criminal Appeal No.664 of 2019.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
2.
Since all these Criminal Appeals arise out of the same Sessions
Case, they are heard together and are being disposed of by this common
judgment
3.
Initially, charge sheet was filed against Accused Nos.1 to 6. Even
before framing of charges, Accused No.5 died on 22.12.2011. Hence case
against him stood abated. Consequently, Accused Nos.1 to 4 and Accused
No.6 were tried by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under the following
two (2) charges.
i)
First charge was under Section 120B IPC
ii)
Second charge was under Section 302 r/w 34 IPC
4.
Substance of the charge is that, on 14.10.2010, at about
7:15 p.m., A1 to A4 and A6, having conspired with each other and in
furtherance of their common intention, attacked one Khambala Koteswara
Rao (hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’) at Balaji Sweet Home,
belonging to P.W.8, and hacked him with hunting sickles and knives, causing
his instantaneous death, thereby committed offences punishable under
Sections 120-B(1) and 302 read with Section 34 of IPC.
5.
After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions Judge
convicted the appellants/accused under Sections 120 B (1) and 302 IPC and
sentenced them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for ‘Life’ and also to pay a
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
fine of Rs.1000/- each, in default to undergo Simple Imprisonment for six (6)
months.
6.
Case of the prosecution, briefly, is as follows:-
All the accused and the material prosecution witnesses are residents of
Sattenapalli. P.W.1 is younger brother and P.W.3 is son of the deceased
respectively. The deceased was also resident of Sattenapalli. The deceased,
along with A.1 and A.2, was engaged in real estate business. In the course of
their business transactions, disputes arose between the deceased and A.1,
A.2, owing to which the latter bore grudge against the deceased. A.4 used to
assist the deceased. It is alleged that at about 4.00 p.m. on 14.10.2010, all the
accused conspired to do away with the life of the deceased. Subsequently, at
about 7.30 p.m. on the same day, the deceased, accompanied by A.4, went to
Balaji Sweet Shop to have badam milk.
(ii) At that juncture, A.1 to A.3 entered into sweet shop and attacked the
deceased with hunting sickles and knives indiscriminately. As a result of
attack, the deceased fell down near the counter and died in the shop. P.W.4
and P.Ws.9 to 11, who were working as salesmen in the said sweet shop,
became panic and came out of the shop. After the attack, A.1 and A.2 left the
scene on a motorcycle (M.O.14). Thereafter, A.4 took the motorcycle
belonging to the deceased and fled from the scene along with A.3 on the said
motorcycle (M.O.13). Having witnessed the incident, P.W.7 telephoned P.W.1
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
and informed him about the incident. Immediately, P.W.1 rushed to Balaji
Sweet Shop and found the deceased lying in a pool of blood. Upon viewing
the CCTV footage of the incident, P.W.1 approached the police and lodged a
report.
(iii) In the meanwhile, on receipt of information, P.W.15, the then
Inspector of Police, Sattenapalli Town Police Station visited Balaji Sweet Shop
and found the deceased lying in a pool of blood. He deployed police personnel
to safeguard the scene of offence and returned to police station. At about 9.00
p.m. on the same day, P.W.1 went to the police station and lodged a report,
which was marked as Ex.P.1. On receipt of Ex.P.1, P.W.15 registered a case
in Crime No.126 of 2010 for the offence punishable under Section 302 r/w 34
IPC. He issued copies of First Information Report to all the concerned. First
Information Report was marked as Ex.P.10. Thereafter, P.W.15 visited Balaji
Sweet Shop at about 9.45 p.m., secured the presence of P.W.13 and another,
and prepared an observation report-Ex.P4. He also prepared a rough sketchEx.P.11 at the scene of offence. He got the scene photographed and
videographed through P.W.12, and the photographs and CD were marked as
Ex.P.3. Subsequently, at about 11.00 p.m., he shifted the dead body to
Community Health Centre, Sattenapalli.
(iv) P.W.15 seized M.Os.7, 8, 10 and 11 at the scene of offence. At
about 11.30 p.m. on the same day, he recorded statement of P.W.2,
technician who was associated with the CCTV footage in the shop. He
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
instructed P.W.2 to transfer the visuals stored in the DVR into a DVD. He also
seized M.Os.1 to 3, namely, the DVR, adapter and BPL television, from the
sweet shop. P.W.2 transferred the visuals from the DVR into DVD (MO4)
under a cover of a panchanama.
(v) At about 8.00 a.m. on 15.10.2010, P.W.15 visited Community Health
Centre, Sattenapalli, along with P.W.13 and another. He recorded statements
of P.Ws.1, 3, 8 and others. He then held inquest over the dead body in the
presence of P.W.13 and another. Inquest report was marked as Ex.P.5.
Thereafter, he sent the dead body for post-mortem examination.
(vi) P.W.14, Civil Assistant Surgeon, Area Hospital, Sattenapalli,
conducted autopsy over the dead body. He found as many as 25 injuries on
the dead body. He opined the cause of death was due to haemorrhage and
hypovolaemic shock resulting from injuries to the neck vessels and lung. He
issued Post-mortem Certificate- Ex.P.9.
(vii) Thereafter, P.W.15 recorded statements of salesmen, P.W.4 and
P.Ws.9 to 11. After postmortem examination, P.W.15 collected clothes of the
deceased, marked as MOs.16 to 19. On 16.10.2010, P.W.15 recorded
statement of P.W.5. On 02.11.2010, at about 12.45 p.m., P.W.15
apprehended A.1 to A.4 while they were alighting from a lorry proceeding on
Piduguralla- Sattenapalli Road, in the presence of mediators. During
interrogation, the accused confessed about their involvement in the
commission of offence and stated that they had set fire to their clothes.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
Pursuant to the confessional statements made by the accused, P.W.15 seized
M.O.12, two knives, from the fields of A.1 under a cover of a panchanama.
P.W.15 also seized two motorbikes, marked as M.Os.13 and 14, from the
scooter stand situated at RTC Bus Stand, Vinukonda, pursuant to the
confessional statements made by the accused.
(viii) On 03.11.2011, at about 1.00 a.m., P.W.15 arrested A.5 and A.6.
All the accused were remanded to judicial custody. He forwarded the material
objects to Forensic Science Laboratory, Hyderabad, under a letter of advice.
RFSL reports were marked as Exs.P.13 and P.14. After collecting all the
documents and after completion of investigation, P.W.15 filed charge sheet.
7.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined P.Ws.1 to 15,
marked Exs.P1 to P14 and exhibited M.Os.1 to 19. On behalf of the defence,
no witness was examined except marking Exs.D1 to D4-portions of
statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C.
8.
When
the
accused
were
examined
under
Section
313 Cr.P.C., they denied the incriminating evidence appearing against them.
9.
Accepting the evidence of prosecution witnesses, particularly,
P.Ws.1, 2, 4 and P.Ws.8 to 11 coupled with Ex.P13, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge convicted all the appellants/accused as aforesaid.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
10.
Heard Smt. A. Swarupa Reddy, Dr. Challa Srinivasa Reddy,
Sri B.V. Ram Naresh Kumar, Sri K.V. Durga Divakar and Sri S. Dilip Jaya
Ram, learned counsel appearing for the appellants and Sri Marri Venkata
Ramana,
learned
Additional
Public
Prosecutor
appearing
for
the
State/respondent.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellants strenuously contend that the
name of Accused No.2 alone was mentioned in the earliest report, Ex.P1,
though P.W.1 was admittedly acquainted with Accused Nos.1, 3 and 4, and
that the omission to mention their names in the earliest report casts a serious
doubt on the subsequent version of the prosecution. They further contend that
the testimony of P.W.4 and P.Ws.9 to 11, who were working as salesmen in
Balaji Sweet shop who were strangers to the accused, cannot safely be relied
on in the absence of test identification parade.
12.
Learned counsel further contend that no reliance can be placed
on the testimony of P.W.5 with regard to the conspiracy, particularly in view of
the delay in recording his statement. They also contend that the prosecution
failed to establish motive for the accused to kill the deceased.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
13.
Learned counsel for the appellants further contend that the CCTV
footage marked as M.O.4, being secondary electronic evidence, is
inadmissible in the absence of certification complying with the requirements of
Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
14.
judgments
Learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance on the
of
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Anvar
P.V.
Vs. P.K.Basheer 1 and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar Vs. Kailash Kushanrao
Gorantyal2.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellants further contend that the
prosecution failed to examine the customers who were present in the sweet
shop at the time of incident. As such, the learned counsel appearing for the
appellants request this Court to allow all the appeals by setting aside the
conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
16.
On the other hand, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
opposed the appeals, contending that the prosecution has established the
motive through the evidence of P.W.1, coupled with Ex.P1. He further
contends that the prosecution could able to establish, through the evidence of
P.W.5, the motive for the accused to commit murder of the deceased. He
(2014) 10 SCC 14,
(2020) 7 SCC 1
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
further contends that P.W.4 and P.Ws.9 to 11 are independent witnesses,
having no interest either in the prosecution or in the accused, and that their
evidence clearly establish the attack on the deceased by A1 to A4. He also
contends that the weapons and motorcycles were recovered at the instance of
the accused and that the evidence of P.W.13, mediator, lends support to the
prosecution case with regard to such recoveries. According to the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, the identity of the accused is not in dispute.
17.
With regard to CCTV footage, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor contends that the original DVR was produced before the Court and
that both the DVR and the DVD were sent to Forensic Science Laboratory for
examination. Report of Forensic Science Laboratory (Ex.P13) is relied on in
support of the prosecution case. As such, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor requests this Court to dismiss all the appeals by confirming the
conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
18.
We have considered the rival submissions carefully and
scrutinized the entire evidence on record.
19.
P.W.1 is none other than younger brother of the deceased. He
has stated in his evidence that at about 8.00 p.m. on 14.10.2010, P.W.7
telephoned him and informed about the incident. He immediately rushed to
Balaji Sweet shop, where he found the deceased lying in a pool of blood.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
20.
P.W.1 further stated that he requested P.W.8, owner of the shop,
to show him the CCTV footage. After viewing the footage, P.W.1 went to the
police station at about 9.00 p.m. and presented Ex.P1 report. He has also
stated about the real estate business carried on by the deceased along with
Accused Nos.1 and 2 and the disputes between them in the course of such
business. Though P.W.1 was cross-examined at length, nothing adverse has
been elicited so as to discredit his testimony with regard to the events
narrated by him. At the same time, the omission of the names of Accused
Nos.1, 3 and 4 in the earliest report, Ex.P1, assumes significance and has to
be considered in the context of the entire evidence on record, particularly the
evidence relating to the identification and participation of the accused.
21.
We shall next consider the evidence of eyewitnesses, namely,
P.W.4 and P.Ws.9 to 11. Admittedly, these witnesses were working as
salesmen in Balaji Sweet shop. P.W.8, owner of the shop, also confirmed that
they were employed therein.
22.
According to these witnesses, the incident took place at about
7.30 p.m. on 14.10.2010. They deposed that Accused Nos.1 to 3 entered into
the shop and attacked the deceased with hunting sickles and knives
indiscriminately. They further stated that the deceased had come to the shop
along with Accused No.4, who was working as his assistant, and that Accused
No.4 was waiting outside when the attack took place.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
23.
P.W.5 also spoke about the accused leaving the scene on two
motorcycles, M.Os.13 and 14. According to their testimony, Accused Nos.1
and 2 left on one motorcycle, while Accused Nos.3 and 4 left on the
motorcycle belonging to the deceased. The fact that P.W.4 and P.Ws.9 to 11
were employees of the shop lends assurance to their presence at the scene of
offence. Their evidence, however, has to be assessed with reference to their
opportunity to observe the incident, the consistency of their testimony on
material particulars, the circumstances in which they identified the accused
and the other evidence available on record. Though these witnesses were
subjected to lengthy cross-examination, no material contradiction or infirmity
has been brought on record. Hence, there is no reason to discard their
testimony. Their evidence, therefore, has to be considered in conjunction with
the electronic evidence and the other circumstances relied on by the
prosecution.
24.
The objection with regard to CCTV footage marked as M.O.4
requires consideration. The appellants contend that M.O.4 is a copy of the
CCTV recording transferred from the original DVR and that, in the absence of
a certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act, the said electronic
record cannot be relied upon.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
25.
In support of the said contention, learned counsel placed reliance
on Anvar P.V. Vs. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473, and Arjun Panditrao
Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1.
26.
On the other hand, learned Additional Public Prosecutor contends
that the original DVR, marked as M.O.1, was produced before the Court and
that the original recording equipment as well as the DVD were sent to the
Forensic Science Laboratory for examination.
27. We have considered the rival submissions on this aspect. The
prosecution case, as emerging from the evidence of P.W.2, the technician,
and P.W.8, the owner of Balaji Sweet Shop, is that the CCTV footage was
transferred from the DVR to a DVD. P.Ws.2 and 8 deposed that the
Investigating Officer seized the DVR, marked as M.O.1 along with
adopter, MO2 and T.V., MO3, from Balaji Sweet Shop belonging to P.W.8.
P.W.15, the Investigating Officer, also deposed with regard to the seizure of
the DVR and other relevant articles and their subsequent forwarding to the
Forensic Science Laboratory for examination.
28. In Ex.P13, the expert has recorded the following:
“The sealed cardboard box contained the following marked by me as:
Item No.1: One 4 CH DVR CC Camera Recording Equipment, model: TA462S, bearing Serial No.003D5402, affixed with punch chit written
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
on it as Item No.6, contained one SATA Hard Disk of make:
Seagate, model: ST3500418AS, Capacity: 500GB, bearing S/N.
9VMFHNAL.
Item No.2: One DVD-R of make: National, capacity: 4.7 GB, written on it as
“Copy from CC camera Balaji Sweet Shop” etc., along with punch
chit.
EXAMINATIONS CONDUCTED
1) Physical Examination.
2) Examination regarding working condition.
3) The hard disk of Item No.1 is forensically imaged (cloned) onto an empty hard
disk of APFSL. This cloned hard disk is used for examination by using a computer
having TV Tuner Card.
REPORT
Based on the above examinations, I found that:
1) Item Nos.1 and 2 are in working condition.
2) I captured the video recording channel wise separately (4 channels) from the
coned hard disk of item no.1 pertaining to the date and time stamp as per
LOA i.e. on 14.10.2010 from 7.05 p.m. to 8.05 p.m. These four video clips
with „mpg‟ file format are recorded in a DVD-R marked as “Annexure-I,
COM/115/2010”
29. A perusal of Ex.P13 clearly discloses that the captured video recordings
were extracted separately, channel-wise, from all the four channels of the
cloned hard disk of Item No.1, pertaining to the date and time stamp
mentioned in the LOA, i.e., 14.10.2010 between 7.05 p.m. and 8.00 p.m. The
four video clips, in ‘mpg’ file format, were thereafter recorded on a DVD-R, as
stated in FSL report. Thus, the CCTV footage contained in the original DVR
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
(M.O.1) was copied onto the DVD-(CD) (M.O.4). Significantly, both the original
DVR (M.O.1) and the DVD-(CD) (M.O.4) were produced before the Court by
P.W.15, the Investigating Officer.
30. In the circumstances, M.O.1, being the original electronic record
containing the CCTV footage, having been produced before the Court, the
requirement of a certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872, does not arise in respect of the original electronic record. Further,
P.Ws. 2 and 8 deposed in their evidence stating that the investigating officerP.W.15 seized original DVR (M.O.1) from their shop. They further stated that
P.W.15 copied the visuals into M.O.4 (DVD) with the help of P.W.2. The
objection raised in this regard, therefore, cannot be sustained. The
prosecution, accordingly, relies on the said electronic evidence to substantiate
its case with regard to the occurrence in question.
31.
The legal position with regard to the admissibility of electronic
evidence is no longer res integra. In Anvar P.V. Vs. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10
SCC 473, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the special procedure
prescribed under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act is attracted when an
electronic record is sought to be produced in the form of computer output. The
said principle was subsequently considered and authoritatively clarified by the
three-Judge Bench in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao
Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1.
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
32.
The distinction recognised in the aforesaid decisions is between
the original electronic record or the original device containing such record, on
the one hand, and a computer output or copy derived therefrom, on the other.
Where the original electronic record itself is produced before the Court, the
requirement of a certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act
does not arise merely because the record is electronic in nature. The
certificate requirement is attracted where reliance is placed upon a computer
output or other secondary electronic evidence.
33.
Aforesaid principle was subsequently considered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Karnataka Vs. T. Naseer @ Nasir @
Thandiantavida Naseer,3. In that case also, the original electronic devices
were before the Trial Court as primary evidence. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
noticed that, in such circumstances, there was no requirement of a certificate
under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act in respect of the original
electronic devices. The Court further noticed that the certificate obtained by
the prosecution had been furnished by way of abundant caution.
34.
In the present case, the prosecution relies on the original DVR,
marked as M.O.1, as well as DVD, marked as M.O.4, containing the copied
2023 INSC 988
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
footage. The learned Additional Sessions Judge is stated to have played the
footage in open Court in the presence of the accused and their counsel.
35.
In the case on hand, the DVR containing the CCTV recording was
seized during the course of investigation, produced before the Trial Court and
marked as M.O.1. Thus, the prosecution is not relying merely upon a copy of
the CCTV footage generated from the DVR. The original electronic device in
which the relevant CCTV recording was stored was itself brought on record as
M.O.1.
36.
therefore,
The electronic record contained in the said original device is,
required
to
be
treated
as
primary
electronic
evidence.
Consequently, Certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act is not
required in the circumstances of the case.
37.
It is true that the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in its recent decision in
Pooranmal v. State of Rajasthan4, reiterated that a certificate under Section
65-B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act is mandatory where electronic evidence is
sought to be introduced by way of secondary evidence. The said principle,
however, operates in the field of secondary electronic evidence and does not
obliterate the distinction drawn in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar between the
original electronic record and a computer output derived therefrom.
2026 INSC 217
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
38.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case,
since M.O.1-DVR itself, containing the original CCTV recording, was produced
before the Trial Court and marked in evidence, the absence of a certificate
under Section 65-B(4) of the Indian Evidence Act does not render the original
electronic record contained in M.O.1 inadmissible. As already pointed out,
P.Ws.2 and 8 have stated that P.W.15 seized M.Os.1 to 3 from their shop.
The objection raised by the appellants on the said ground is, accordingly,
liable to be rejected.
39.
We shall now consider the evidence relating to the criminal
conspiracy. The prosecution mainly relies on the testimony of P.W.5 in this
regard. P.W.5 stated that, at about 3.00 p.m. on 14.10.2010, he witnessed the
accused discussing about the elimination of the deceased. However, despite
witnessing the said conversation, he did not disclose the matter to anyone at
that time.
40.
It is also significant that P.W.5 was stated to be a close friend of
the deceased. Nevertheless, according to P.W.15, the Investigating Officer,
the statement of P.W.5 was recorded for the first time on 16.10.2010, two
days after the conversation. Failure of P.W.5 to disclose the conspiracy at the
earliest opportunity, coupled with the delay in recording his statement,
assumes significance while assessing the reliability of his testimony. Having
regard to these circumstances, his evidence requires cautious scrutiny and, in
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
the absence of adequate assurance from the surrounding circumstances,
cannot safely be treated as sufficient to establish the conspiracy.
41.
On an overall consideration of the material available on record,
we are not inclined to place any reliance on the belated testimony of P.W.5, to
sustain the charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC.
42.
The prosecution has also relied on the alleged recovery of
weapons and motorcycles pursuant to the confessional statements made by
the accused. P.W.15 deposed with regard to the seizure of the hunting sickle
marked as M.O.9, the knives marked as M.O.12 and the motorcycles marked
as M.Os.13 and 14. P.W.13, the mediator, was examined in support of the
recoveries. As the evidence of P.W.15 coupled with the evidence of P.W.13
clinchingly establish the recovery of M.Os.9 and 12 to 14 at the instance of
accused.
43. As such, the evidence of P.W.14, Civil Assistant Surgeon, coupled
with the testimony of the eyewitnesses-P.Ws.4 and 9 to 11 and the contents of
the inquest report, clearly establishes that the death of the deceased was
homicidal. The ocular testimony, the admissible electronic evidence, the
medical evidence and the circumstances surrounding the recoveries, when
considered cumulatively, establish the participation of Accused Nos.1 to 4 in
the commission of offence. The omissions and other infirmities pointed out by
the learned counsel for the appellants, when considered in the light of the
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
evidence as a whole, are not of such magnitude as to create a reasonable
doubt regarding their participation. The prosecution has, therefore, succeeded
in establishing the guilt of Accused Nos.1 to 4 under Section 302 IPC by
cogent, reliable and legally admissible evidence beyond reasonable doubt.
44. However, the evidence relied on by the prosecution to establish the
charge under Section 120-B(1) IPC stands on a different footing. Though the
evidence on record is sufficient to establish the participation of Accused Nos.1
to 4 in the commission of offence under Section 302 IPC, the same does not
establish, beyond reasonable doubt, the existence of any prior agreement or
meeting of minds amongst them so as to constitute the offence of criminal
conspiracy. The testimony of P.W.5, for the reasons discussed hereinabove,
does not inspire confidence to establish such agreement. The prosecution
has, therefore, failed to establish the charge under Section 120-B(1) IPC
against Accused Nos.1 to 4 beyond reasonable doubt.
45. Insofar as Accused No.6 is concerned, the prosecution is relying on
the evidence of P.W.5. As already pointed out that though P.W.5 witnessed
the conspiracy at about 3.00 p.m. on 14.10.2010, he did not disclose the
same with anyone. For the above reasons and having regard to the belated
recording of statement of P.W.5 and the absence of sufficient corroborative
circumstances, we are not inclined to place any reliance on the testimony of
P.W.5 to sustain the conviction under Section 120-B(1) IPC. Further, there is
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
no other cogent, reliable and legally admissible evidence connecting Accused
No.6 either with the alleged conspiracy or with the commission of the
homicidal death of the deceased. The prosecution has, therefore, failed to
establish the guilt of Accused No.6 under Sections 302 and 120-B(1) IPC
beyond reasonable doubt.
46.
In the result, Criminal Appeal No.664 of 2019 is allowed, setting
aside the conviction and sentence recorded against appellant/A6 under
Sections 120 B (1) and 302 IPC by the learned Special Judge for Trial of
Cases under Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of
Atrocities) Act, 1989-cum-IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, in
Sessions Case No.330 of 2012 dated 09.2.2018. Consequently, appellant/A6
is acquitted. Fine amount, if any, paid by appellant/Accused No.6 shall be
refunded to him. Appellant/Accused No.6 is directed to be set at liberty
forthwith, if he is not required in connection with any other case or crime.
47.
Insofar as Accused Nos.1 to 4 are concerned, Criminal Appeal
Nos.1685 of 2018, 2100 of 2018, 2639 of 2018 and 2577 of 2018 are partly
allowed. Conviction recorded against the appellants/Accused Nos.1 to 4 under
Section 120-B (1) IPC by the learned Special Judge for Trial of Cases under
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act,
1989-cum-IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, in Sessions Case
No.330 of 2012, dated 09.02.2018, is hereby set aside and they are acquitted
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
of the said charge. However, the conviction and sentence recorded against
the appellants/Accused Nos.1 to 4 under Section 302 IPC is hereby
confirmed. Needless to state, the period already undergone by the
appellants/Accused Nos.1 to 4 shall be given set-off under Section 428
Cr.P.C.
Consequently, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand
closed.
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
__________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
Date: 07.10.2026
Note:
LR copy to be marked
B/o GR
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
And
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018, 2100 OF 2018, 2577 OF 2018,
2639 OF 2018 AND 664 OF 2019
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Date: 07.10.2026
GR
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
KSR, J & JS, J
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.1685 OF 2018,
2100 OF 2018, 2639 OF 2018,
664 of 2019 and 2577 OF 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review