Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 23.06.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 24.07.2026
Date of uploading
: 29.07.2026
APHC010808672018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3578]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE 24th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.2860 OF 2018 & 618 OF 2019
Crl.A.No.2860 of 2018:
Pasupuleti Prabhakar @ Prabhu @ Yesu
...APELLANT
Vs.
The State of A P
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SOWJANYA LAKKKULA (for A1)
2. MR.KODURU BUJJI BABU (for A2)
Counsel for the Respodent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
...RESPODENT
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
Criminal Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018 & 618 of 2019
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals are preferred by Accused Nos.1 and 2,
respectively, under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C., questioning the judgment
of conviction and sentences, dated 07.09.2018, passed by the learned
Principal Sessions Judge, Guntur, in Sessions Case No.482 of 2014.
2.
Since both these appeals arise out of the very same judgment,
they are heard together and decided by this common judgment.
3.
Charges against which the appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2
were tried were under Sections 120-B, 201 and 302 of IPC.
The
substance of charges is that, A.1 being paramour of A.2, both of them
decided to eliminate son of A.2 viz., Vullangula Sekhar, who was of
unsound mind, (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”) as they felt
that the deceased was intruding into their privacy, in continuation of
their sexual lust, in furtherance of which, on 21.05.2013, while
deceased was at their residence at Bongaralabeedu, Guntur, A.1 killed
the deceased with wire by throttling and further, in furtherance of their
conspiracy, in order to screen the evidence, A.2 took away the dead
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
body of the deceased in an auto and thrown away the same at eastern
canal bund in between Jakeer Hussain Nagar and Halfpeta towards
Basivireddypalem, thereby A.1 and A.2 have committed offences
punishable under Sections 120-B, 302 and 201 r/w.34 of IPC.
4.
After trial, learned Principal Sessions Judge, Guntur, found A.1
and A.2 to be guilty for the offences under Sections 120-B and 201
r/w.34 IPC. Further, A.1 was found guilty for the offence punishable
under Section 302 IPC. Therefore, both A.1 and A.2 were convicted
and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life and payment of fine of
Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for three months
each, in respect of the offence under Section 120-B IPC. Further, A.1
and A.2 were also convicted and sentenced to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for a period of five years and also payment of fine of
Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for three months
in respect of the offence punishable under Section 201 IPC. Further,
A.1 was also convicted and sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life
and payment of fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer simple
imprisonment for three months, in respect of the offence punishable
under Section 302 IPC.
The substantive sentences imposed against
the accused for the aforesaid offences were directed to run
concurrently.
5.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
Case of the prosecution, briefly, is as follows:
(a) A.2 was married to one Vullangula Venkateswara Rao of
Injanampadu Village, about 28 years back. They were blessed with
son and daughter. The deceased is the son of A.2 through said
Venkateswara Rao. Deceased was of unsound mind. After the death
of said Venkateswara Rao, A.2 started residing at Guntur where she
got close acquaintance with A.1. A.1, being paramour of A.2, started
living together and in that process, they have taken on rent a room in
second floor of the house at 1st lane, Bongaralabeedu, Donka Road,
Guntur, from its owner-PW.1 representing that they were husband and
wife. Initially, A.1 and A.2 started living there and after few days, A.2
brought in her deceased son to live together. A.1 used to scold and
beat the deceased often, as he became an obstacle for their
cohabitation. In furtherance of their conspiracy, A.1 and A.2 designed
to eliminate him.
(b) In that regard, on 21.05.2013, both A.1 and A.2 plotted to
eliminate the deceased. At about 9.00 A.M., A.2 left the house and
while A.1 and deceased remained at home. Thereafter, A.2 returned
home between 1.00 P.M. and 2.00 P.M. and after some time, she got
down screaming that her son was killed by A.1. PW.1-house owner,
on hearing the screaming, came out and enquired about the same.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
The dead body of deceased was brought down by A.2 with the help of
a person residing in the same building as tenant. PW.1 noticed froth
coming out of mouth of deceased. Even, PW.3, who was residing
adjacent to the house of accused, having heard the cries from the
house of PW.1, rushed there and found that A.2 was with the body of
the deceased. A.2, thereafter, hired auto belonging to PW.8 and took
the dead body of the deceased to Tenali, where mother and brothers
of A.2 were residing.
(c) On reaching the residence of PWs.6 and 7, mother and
brother of A.2, A.2 informed them that her son was killed by A.1.
PWs.6 and 7 refused shelter to A.2 and her deceased son as sister-inlaw of A.2 (wife of PW.7) was in advance stage of pregnancy, rather
A.2 was advised to take away the dead body of the deceased to her
husband’s house. Then, PW.8, auto-driver, asked A.2 to get down
from auto along with the dead body of deceased, on which A.2, once
again, hired him to take them to Guntur back.
On the way, after
crossing Kolakaluru, A.2 asked PW.8 to stop auto, on the pretext of
attending to nature call.
When auto was stopped, she got down,
pulled down the dead body and left it at Canal bund, informing him that
since nobody is agreeing to handle the dead body, she was
constrained to leave it there and both of them left the place.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
(d) On 22.05.2013, PW.4 Village Revenue Assistant of Halfpeta
village, having come to know of a dead body lying at canal bund
between Halfpeta and Jakir Hussain Nagar, visited the said place and
found dead body of a male, aged about 18 and 19 years. He observed
the dead body and noticed an injury around the neck of the boy and
small injuries on the body bitten by ants.
wrapped in a blanket.
The dead body was
PW.4 informed the same to PW.5-Village
Revenue Officer, Halfpeta. Immediately, PW.5 reached canal bund,
where dead body was lying. He also noticed that body was bundled in
a black colour blanket and green colour lungi. Further, he noticed a
black colour bruise around the neck of the dead body and froth was
coming from the mouth and blood was trickling out from the right ear.
He immediately submitted a report with the Taluq Police Station,
Tenali. Ex.P2 is the said report.
(e) PW.13, the then Sub-Inspector of Police, Tenali Rural Police
Station, on receipt of Ex.P2 report, registered a case in Crime No.77 of
2013 for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201 IPC and
issued express F.I.R. and the same was sent to the Judicial Magistrate
with copies to all concerned. Ex.P8 is the FIR.
(f) PW.14, Inspector of Police, upon receipt of FIR, took up
further investigation. He examined PW.5 and recorded his statement
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
and then proceeded along with PW.5 to the scene of offence. He
prepared scene of observation report under Ex.P3 in the presence of
PW.5 and others. As the dead body was unidentified, he got the same
photographed and Ex.P10 are the photographs with C.D. and he also
got prepared Ex.P.9 rough sketch of the scene of offence.
Immediately, he sent the dead body of the deceased to Government
Hospital, Tenali to preserve the same in the mortuary room until its
identity is established. He requisitioned services of dogs squad and
clues team.
He found no incriminating material at the scene of
offence.
(g) PW.14 further secured presence of PW.4 and two others,
who have seen the dead body of deceased at first instance and got
recorded their statements. In order to establish the identify of dead
body, pamphlets containing the photograph of deceased person were
printed and published and got faxed radio message to all neighbouring
police stations, besides, he also sent search parties to neighbouring
police stations for identification of dead body.
(h) On 23.05.2013, while PW.14 was in office, at about 10.00
A.M., PW.6, PW.7, PW.9, PW.10 and two others appeared before him
and identified the person as that of Vullangula Sekhar, none other than
PW.10’s brother’s son.
Then, they proceeded to Government
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
Hospital, Tenali, along with above said persons and after having
identified the dead body, in the presence of mediators, inquest came
to be conducted over the dead body. The inquest panchayatdars –
PWs.5, 6, 7, 9 and 10, opined that murder has taken place at the
rented premises, where accused and deceased boy were residing.
Ex.P4 is the inquest report and that the death was due to throttling.
The statements of PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10 came to be recorded.
Thereafter, dead body was sent for post-mortem examination.
(i) On 23.05.2013 at 4.10 P.M., PW.12 Civil Assistant Surgeon,
District Hospital, Tenali, conducted autopsy over the dead body of the
deceased and issued Ex.P.7 post mortem report, opining that the
cause of death was on account of asphyxia due to pressure over neck
and the approximate age of injuries being 2 to 3 days prior to the post
mortem examination.
(j) On 24.05.2013, PW.14 proceeded to the house of accused.
He secured presence of PWs.1, 2, 3 and others and got their
statements recorded. PW.1 is the owner, who rented out the room,
where A.1, A.2 and deceased were residing. PWs.2 and 3 are the
neighbours.
(k) During further investigation, on 27.05.2013, presence of
auto-rickshaw driver-PW.8 was secured and his statement came to be
recorded.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
Since the scene of offence was found to be in Guntur,
PW.14 has transferred C.D. file to the jurisdictional Arundalpet Police
Station, Guntur, for further investigation.
(l) On 01.07.2013, PW.15, Inspector of Police, Arundalpet Police
Station, Guntur, took up further investigation and he re-registered the
case and issued Ex.P11 FIR. He also visited the scene of offence
along with PW.11 and another and got prepared Ex.P5 scene of
offence observation report. He secured black colour fan-MO.1 and got
prepared rough sketch and also photographed the scene of offence.
Photographs were marked as Ex.P12. He examined PW.1, owner of
the house, and neighbours-PWs.2 and 3, however, he did not record
their statements as they reiterated what they already stated before
PW.14.
(m) On 03.07.2013, he visited crime scene where dead body
was found and examined PW.5 and two others.
Further, on
09.07.2013, PW.15 examined PWs.6, 7, 9, 10 and another, but, did
not record their statements as they reiterated their earlier versions
given before PW.14. He also examined PW.8 in similar way. On
19.11.2013, accused came to be apprehended while they were at
railway station, Arundalpet, in the presence of PW.11.
On their
confession, PW.15 seized electric wire from the bag carried by them.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
MO.2 is the electric wire. He got prepared mediatornama under Ex.P6.
Accused were produced before the concerned Magistrate and they
were remanded to judicial custody. After completion of investigation,
PW.15 filed charge-sheet against the accused for the aforesaid
offences.
6.
In support of its case, prosecution examined PWs.1 to 15 and
marked Exs.P1 to P12 and exhibited Mos.1 and 2.
On behalf of
accused, A.2 got examined herself as DW.1 and Ex.C1 was marked
by Court.
7.
On closure of prosecution evidence, the accused were
examined under
Section
Cr.P.C.,
and
they
denied the
incriminating evidence appearing against them.
8.
The learned Principal Sessions Judge, on appreciation of
evidence brought on record and also considering the statement made
by A.2 on oath before the Court, ultimately, found both the accused
guilty for the offences under Sections 120-B and 201 IPC and further,
A.1 was found guilty for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC
and accordingly, convicted and sentenced them as mentioned supra,
vide impugned judgment, dated 07.09.2018. Aggrieved by the said
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
judgment, the present Criminal Appeals have been preferred by
appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2.
9.
Heard Mr.Sayed Sardar Saheb Akil, learned counsel appearing
for Ms.Sowjanya Lakkakula, learned counsel for the appellant-A1;
Mr.Koduru Bujji Babu, learned counsel for the appellant-A2, and
Mr.Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public Prosecutor,
representing the respondent/State.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant-A1 contends that there is no
legal evidence to connect the occurrence of incident to the accused
and that in the absence of any eyewitnesses to the occurrence of
incident, the incriminating material relied on by the prosecution does
not prove its case beyond reasonable doubt to convict the accused. It
is further contended that absolutely there is no motive for accused to
kill the deceased and the circumstances narrated by the prosecution
do not complete the chain of events pointing the guilt solely
attributable to the accused. He further contended that none of the
witnesses have spoken of the presence or involvement of accused
No.1 for the alleged murder.
It is also contended that absolutely,
there is no evidence with regard to the theory of conspiracy, neither
first FIR nor the second FIR, referred to the charge under Section
120-B IPC and it is only developed at later stage of investigation with
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
reference to the statements of material witnesses, evidence of whom,
therefore, is completely untrustworthy and unreliable.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant-A.2, while reiterating the
contentions raised on behalf of appellant-accused No.1, contends that
absolutely, there is no legally acceptable evidence on record and that
the prosecution failed to prove the guilt of accused beyond reasonable
doubt. He also contends that Ex.C.1 and the statement made by A.2
on oath before the Court cannot be solely relied on to confirm her guilt
and the findings so rendered by the learned Principal Sessions Judge
are clearly perverse. It is further contended that there is no iota of
evidence to suggest conspiracy between A.1 and A.2 and even as per
the case of prosecution, as the murder was committed by A.1 alone,
the conviction and sentence against A.2 for the offence under Section
120-B IPC is unsustainable.
12.
Per contra, Mr.Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor, while supporting the impugned judgment of the learned
Principal Sessions Judge, contends that the prosecution has
successfully established the circumstances, which clearly complete the
chain of events pointing out the guilt towards the appellants/accused
Nos.1 and 2 insofar as their conspiracy to eliminate the deceased and
further, as the dead body came to be first found within the house of
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
accused, which got clearly established through the evidence of PWs.1
and 3, in view of Section 106 of the Evidence Act, it is for the accused
to explain as to how the deceased was murdered as it was a case of
homicidal death. Since, there was no explanation from either of the
accused in that regard, the trial Court has rightly found them to be
guilty for the offences under Section 120-B for conspiracy and under
Section 302 IPC for murder by A.1. He further contended that the
conduct of both accused and as well as manner in which the dead
body came to be thrown in canal, by A.2 in particular, as spoken by the
other material witnesses, clearly established that they intended to
screen the evidence for which the learned Principal Sessions Judge
has rightly convicted them for the offence under Section 201 IPC. In
that view of the matter, he sought dismissal of both the appeals by
confirming the impugned judgment of the learned Principal Sessions
Judge.
13.
We have carefully gone through the entire evidence of
prosecution witnesses and the material available on record.
14.
The case of prosecution is that the death of deceased is on
account of homicide. As per the evidence on record, PW.1 owner of
the house, where A.1 and A.2 were residing on rent, and even PW.3,
neighbour of PW.1, have stated that at about 2.00 P.M. on 21.05.2013,
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
A.2 came down weeping and stated that her son was killed by her
husband A.1, and later, the dead body was brought down from her
room. The post-mortem examination report-Ex.P7 and the evidence of
PW.12 Civil Assistant Surgeon, District Hospital, Tenali, who
conducted autopsy over the dead body, opined that the death was on
account of asphyxia due to pressure over neck and that the age of
injuries were 2 to 3 days prior to the post-mortem examination.
Further, post-mortem examination report also reveals that there were
external injuries in the nature of: (a) ligature mark around the neck
below hyoid bone 25 cm x ½ cm; (b) contusion of 3 cm x 3 cm below
injury No.1; (c) oozing of blood at left ear; (d) abrasion of 1 cm x 1 cm
on abdomen and (e) face and upper part of chest, both shoulders
congested. The above evidence of PW.12 clearly establishes that it is
a case of homicidal death.
15.
As rightly contended by the learned counsel for the appellants,
this is a case of circumstantial evidence as there are no direct
eyewitnesses to the incident.
16.
The Hon’ble Apex Court time and again has reiterated the
principles to be applied in testing a case based on circumstantial
evidence. In Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra1,
(1984) 4 SCC 116
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
the Hon’ble Apex Court has laid down five golden principles dealing
with proof of a case based on circumstantial evidence. It is apt to refer
to the relevant portion of aforesaid judgment, which reads as under:
“153. A close analysis of this decision would show that
the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against
an accused can be said to be fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt
is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the
circumstances concerned “must or should” and not “may be”
established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal
distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be
proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao
Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793 : 1973
SCC (Cri) 1033 : 1973 Crl LJ 1783] where the observations
were made: [SCC para 19, p. 807: SCC (Cri) p. 1047]
“Certainly, it is a primary principle that the
accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a
court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’
and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from
sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say,
they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis
except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to
leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent
with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all
human probability the act must have been done by the
accused.”
Keeping in view the aforesaid five golden principles, we shall now
examine the evidence on record.
17.
As
per
the
evidence
of
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
prosecution
witnesses,
the
circumstances to complete the chain of events, are, that: (a) both
accused Nos.1 and 2 were residing along with deceased at the rented
premises at Bongaralabeedu, Guntur, which was let out by PW.1owner of the house; (b) The dead body of deceased was brought down
by A.2 from the second floor of the building, where accused were
living, and taken away the same in the auto belonging to PW.8 to
Tenali, where mother and brothers of A.2 were living and as they
(PWs.6 and 7) refused to shelter, A.2 and the dead body of deceased,
therefore, while returning back from Tenali to Guntur, the body of
deceased was thrown away at canal bund between Jakeer Hussain
Nagar and Halfpeta towards Basivireddypalem. Thereafter, A.2 and
as well as A.1 absconded till they came to be apprehended on
19.11.2013; and (c) seizure of MO.2 electric wire under ExP6
mediatornama from the accused at the time of their apprehension,
which was used for strangulating the deceased.
18.
PW.6 mother of A.2 stated that she had four sons and a
daughter. A.2 initially got married to one Venkateswara Rao about 25
years back, with whom she was blessed with son (deceased) and
daughter.
Said Venkateswara Rao passed away later.
A.2, the
deceased, was mentally unsound, he was in her care for some time.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
A.2 developed intimacy with A.1 and A.2 has taken back her son to
stay along with A.1 and both of them started living together at Guntur.
19.
Even, PW.7, brother of A.2, also stated that after death of A.2’s
husband-Venkateswara Rao, she started living with A.1 at Guntur and
further that, the mentally retorted son, who was under care of his
mother, was taken back by A.2 to live along with A.1 at Guntur.
20.
PW.9 and PW.10, who are younger and elder brothers of late
Venkateswara Rao (first husband of A.2), also stated that after demise
of their brother, A.2 started living with her paramour i.e. A.1 along with
her mentally retorted son at Bongaralabeedu, Guntur. Therefore, the
evidence of PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10, who are none other than mother,
brother and brother-in-law of A.2, clearly corroborated that A.2 was
living with her paramour-A.1, and mentally retorted son (deceased) at
Bongaralabeedu, Guntur.
21.
PW.1, owner of the house, stated that a single room in second
floor of the building was rented to A.1 and A.2, who represented to be
husband and wife and working in cell phone company.
The said
building was situated at 1st line, Bongaralabeedu, Guntur.
PW.2,
though initially also spoke of accused residing at the said building,
later, she turned hostile. PW.3, neighbour, also deposed that accused
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
were residing on rent in the building belonging to PW.1. During the
cross-examination of PW.1, except for making a suggestion that A.1
and A.2 never stayed in the house belonging to PW.1 on rent, nothing
has been elicited by both A.1 and A.2. It has been consistent stand of
PW.1, PW.3 coupled with the evidence of PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10 that the
accused along with deceased were residing in the building belonging
to PW.1. Therefore, the first circumstance is clearly established.
22.
PW.1 stated that on 21.05.2013 at about 2.00 P.M., A.2
returned back to her home and after some time, she climbed down
from building and stated that her son was killed by A.1-her husband,
and with the help of other tenant, A.2 brought down the dead body.
PW.1 stated that she noticed the froth coming out from the mouth of
the deceased.
Thereafter, A.2 stated to have taken away the
deceased in an auto stating that she was taking the boy to the
hospital. Thereafter, after one week, PW.1 saw news reports that the
boy was killed and his body was thrown at canal bund by A.2.
PW.3,
neighbour of PW.1, also corroborated the aforesaid version of PW.1.
She stated that on hearing cries of A.2, she rushed there and saw A.2
taking body of the boy in an auto rickshaw.
23.
Further, PW.8-auto driver stated that while he was returning
after dropping passengers at Sarada Colony, one male and one
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
female person stopped him at 1st Line, Bongaralabeedu, hired his auto
along with a dead body. He was hired to take them to Tenali via
Narakoduru. He identified the said male and female persons, who
stopped and hired auto, were A.1 and A.2. Therefore, the evidence of
PWs.1, 3 and 8, clearly corroborates and establishes that the dead
body of deceased was brought down from the rented residence of the
accused, shifted from there in his auto to Tenali.
The second
circumstance of finding that dead body was in the residence of
accused, therefore, is clearly established.
24.
PWs.6 and 7 have stated that A.2 along with dead body of
deceased came to their residence by auto and that A.2 had informed
that the boy was killed by her paramour-A.1, however, as wife of PW.7
was in advance stage of pregnancy, they refused to let in A.2 along
with dead body, rather, they advised her to take away the dead body
to her husband’s house and that A.2 left. Further, PW.8 stated that
when he asked A.2 to de-board the auto along with dead body, he was
once again hired to return back to Guntur and on the way, at the
instance of A.2 to attend nature call, he stopped the auto and at that
juncture, A.2 has dragged the dead body from the auto and thrown
away at the canal bund and thereafter, fled away from there.
Therefore, the above evidence clearly establishes that A.2 had taken
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
the dead body first to her mother's place and when they denied entry,
she has abandoned the dead body midway, and therefore, threw the
same. This behaviour of A.2 is quite unnatural for the reason, the first
and foremost thing a mother is expected to do once boy is found to be
dead, naturally, the incident ought to have been reported to the
jurisdictional police by launching a report or to take the boy to nearby
hospital to save the life, particularly, when she claimed to be illiterate.
Neither of the possible courses and reasonably expected courses
were adopted; besides, A.2 threw away the dead body at canal bund,
absconded for almost six months till she, along with other accused,
came to be apprehended.
25.
As per evidence of PW.15, the accused came to be
apprehended on 19.11.2013 and on their confession, MO.2 came to
be seized under Ex.P6 mediatornama. MO.2 is the electric wire, with
which the deceased was throttled to death. Seizure or recovery of
MO.2 from the accused clearly confirms their participation in the
commission of murder of deceased.
26.
As per the case of prosecution, the motive for murder is that the
deceased, mentally unsound boy, was coming in the way of conjugal
life of A.1 and A.2, who were living together. PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10 have
clearly stated that after death of the husband of A.2, she started living
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
with A.1 along with her son, who was mentally unsound. As can be
seen from their evidence, that the accused and deceased were living
under same roof and they were last seen together and also dead body
of deceased was brought down from the residence by A.2, as
witnessed by PWs.1 and 3, before the body is shifted in auto
belonging to PW.8, coupled with the behaviour of accused post the
incident that they chose not to report the incident to police, assumes
much significance to come to conclusion that there was a clear motive
which always precedes the intention of committing a particular act, in
the present case, murdering the deceased.
27.
Since the body of deceased was found in the residence of
accused and that the same was shifted from there later, that the
prosecution has clearly established the said factum by way of
evidence of PWs.1, 3 and 8, and further that the death is on account of
homicide, in terms of Section 106 of the Evidence Act, it is for the
accused to explain the reasons for the death or otherwise. There is no
denial of the fact that the accused and deceased were living together
in the rented house where the dead body was shifted from. Added to
this, the conduct of accused, in particular A.2, who took away the dead
body of her son and later thrown away at canal bund, without either
taking to the hospital or reporting to the police, clearly indicates both
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
accused were in addendum and hatched conspiracy to do away with
the deceased. The accused were absconding after the incident and
dead body came to be identified by PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10 only after
issuing publication which is yet another incriminating circumstance.
Even during inquest, PWs.6, 7, 9 and 10 stated that both accused as
well as deceased were living together and A.2 when came with dead
body to Tenali informed that A.1 killed the deceased, hence, it
completes chain of events and all circumstances unerringly and
decisively point guilt towards accused. The overall evidence adduced
by prosecution clearly points all fingers towards accused and the
strong
circumstantial
evidence
indicates
conspiracy
is
clearly
discernible.
28.
Yet another aspect which needs to be noted is the letter, which
was got addressed by A.2, which has been marked as Ex.C.1. In the
said letter, A.2 has stated that her son was got killed by A.1 and that
she did not commit any crime except that the dead body was taken to
her mother’s house, as they did not allow her to let in, she had to leave
the body at canal bund and for which, she was willing to undergo any
punishment. Learned trial Court, later examined her on oath, and in
the process, she has clearly admitted the contents of Ex.C.1.
However, during the examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C., she had
denied the contents of Ex.C.1.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
Though much reliance cannot be
placed on either Ex.C.1 or the statement recorded on oath before the
learned Magistrate, rightly, learned trial Court has treated aforesaid
circumstance
as
one
corroborating
circumstance
indicating
involvement and compatibility of both accused in commission of
murder of deceased.
29.
On analysis of evidence of prosecution witnesses, the
circumstances lead to irresistible conclusion that the prosecution has
clearly established the chain of events to conclusively pointing out
guilt towards the accused alone and none else. We, therefore, do not
find any reason to interfere with the conviction and sentences
recorded against the appellants/A.1 and A.2 by the learned Principal
Sessions Judge. Hence, there are no merits in these Appeals and the
same are liable to be dismissed.
30.
Accordingly, both the Criminal Appeals are dismissed, by
confirming the conviction and sentences imposed against the
appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2, by the learned Principal Sessions
Judge, Guntur, in Sessions Case No.482 of 2014, dated 07.09.2018.
31.
As the appellant/accused No.1 was enlarged on bail by this
Court, by order, dated 22.04.2024, passed in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl. Appeal Nos.2860 of 2018
& 618 of 2019
Crl.A.No.2860 of 2018; and appellant/accused No.2 was enlarged by
this Court, by order, dated 29.07.2025, passed in I.A.No.1 of 2025 in
Crl.A.No.618 of 2019, they are directed to surrender forthwith before
the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Guntur, to serve the remaining
sentence of imprisonment, otherwise the learned Principal Sessions
Judge is directed to secure the presence of the appellants/accused
Nos.1 and 2, by issuing Non-bailable Warrants and commit them to
prison to serve the remaining sentence of imprisonment. It is made
clear that the period of detention already undergone by the
appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2 shall be given set-off under Section
428 Cr.P.C.
As a sequel thereto, the miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending
in this Criminal Appeal shall stand closed.
___________________
K. SURESH REDDY, J.
_______________________
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J.
Date:24th July, 2026.
cs
Whether the order is :
Speaking Yes / Reasoned Yes
Reportable /No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review