Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 25
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WPC No. 245 of 2020 with
WPC No. 280 of 2020
WPC No. 286 of 2020
WPC No. 287 of 2020
WPC No. 288 of 2020
WPC No. 289 of 2020
Date of Order: 10.06.2022
__________________________________________________________
Solaiman Sarkar
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Hipperson Arengh
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Javed Sarkar
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Bluestar Ch. Sangma
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Edmund D. Sangma
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Parwithson Sangma
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.Chanda, Adv.
Mr. S.Thapa, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. B.Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, GA.
Mr. H.Abraham, GA.
i)
ii)
:
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This batch of writ petitions being identical and similar are being
disposed of by this common judgment and order.
2.
The writ petitioner’s prayer in these petitions is for directions to be
issued to the respondents to finalize the process for their regularization
which had been recommended vide letter dated 29-11-2018 issued by the
respondent No. 4 and for recall of an impugned advertisement dated 1705-2017 and impugned notice dated 22-07-2020.
3.
The petitioners were appointed as Para Medical Staff/Surveillance
Worker, Grade-IV under the respondent No. 4, the District and Medical
Health Officer, I/c NVBDCP (Vector Borne Disease Office), West Garo
Hills, Tura on the following dates:
(i)
Solaiman Sarkar [WP(C). No. 245/2020] on 16-05-2012.
(ii)
Hipperson Arengh [WP(C). No. 280/2020] on 13-06-2012.
(iii)
Javed Sarkar [WP(C). No. 286/2020] on 24-04-2013.
(iv)
Bluestar Ch. Sangma [WP(C). No. 287/2020 on October, 2014.
(v)
Edmund D. Sangma [WP(C). No. 288/2020] on 05-12-2012.
(vi)
Parwithson Sangma [WP(C). No. 289/2020] on 30-10-2014.
4.
It is submitted by Mr. S.Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioners
that since their appointment, the writ petitioners have been serving without
a break and the respondent No.4 on a request for supply of names for
consideration for confirmation and regularization sent by the respondent
No. 3, had forwarded the names of the petitioners along with hundred other
names for consideration for regularization. The learned counsel also
submits that for the said post occupied by the petitioners on adhoc basis,
an advertisement had earlier been floated on 17-05-2017 to which he
contends has not culminated as yet in any selection and the petitioners are
continuing to serve against the said posts. However, the further grievance
that has been put forward is that a notice dated 22-07-2020 has been issued
by the respondent No. 5, the Member Secretary, District Selection
Committee, West Garo Hills, Tura calling upon the candidates who had
applied for the post of Surveillance Worker to collect their call letters for
the written test which was to be held on 08-08-2020.
5.
It is contended by the learned counsel that as the petitioners have
been recommended for regularization by the respondent No.4, the selection
process should be cancelled and the petitioners considered for
regularization of their services against the said vacant posts that had been
advertised.
6.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG assisted by Mr. A. H.
Kharwanlang, learned GA in reply, submits that no right has accrued to the
petitioners to claim for regularization without undergoing a regular
selection process. In this context, the learned AAG had drawn the attention
of this Court to the appointment orders which he submits has categorically
stated that the temporary appointment is terminable at the expiry of the
period mentioned therein, and that regular appointment is to be made only
through the recommendations of the appropriate recruiting authority. He
further submits that the said recommendation of the respondent No.4 is of
no consequence, as the same has been made at his own level, without taking
into consideration the nature of temporary appointment that had been given
to the petitioners, and the procedure for regular selection to those posts.
7.
In support of his case, the learned AAG has placed reliance on the
case of State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1 wherein he submits
it has been held that it is ordinarily not proper for Constitutional Courts to
direct absorption in permanent employment of those who have been
engaged without following the due process of selection as envisaged by the
constitutional scheme. He has also placed reliance on the case of M.P.State
Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Nanuram Yadav (2007) 8 SCC 264 to highlight the
principles to be adopted in the matter of public appointment. Lastly, he
submits that the petitioners have failed to apply for the said posts in terms
of the impugned advertisement dated 17-05-2017 and as such, have no
legitimate right or expectation to be accommodated against the said
sanctioned posts.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, it is noted that the
petitioners stake their claim to be considered for regularization only on the
basis of the said recommendation made by the respondent No. 4. In this
context, it would be relevant to examine the terms of their appointment as
set out in their letter of appointment. All the appointment letters are
identical in content and for the sake of convenience one such letter is
reproduced herein below:
“GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT MEDICAL & HEALTH OFFICER:
WEST GARO HILLS:TURA:ORDER OF THE DISTRICT
MEDICAL & HEALTH OFFICER:WEST GARO HILLS:TURA:
APPOINTMENT ORDER
Dated Tura, the
th May/2012
No.NVBDCP/WGH/I/ESSTT/APPTT./SW/2012/________/
Subject to discharge without notice and without assigning any reasons
thereof and subject to satisfactory performance, Shri Solaiman
Sarker, S/o Lt. Jahangir Sarker, Village Shidakandi, P.O. New
Bhaitbari, West Garo Hills is hereby most temporarily appointed as
Surveillance Worker for a period of 3 (three) months from the date of
joining for duty in the office Establishment of the District Malaria
Officer (NVBDCP), West Garo Hills, Tura in the Scale of Pay of Rs.
7100-180-8360-EB-230-10430-310-13840/p.m.
plus
other
Allowances as admissible under the Government Rules against the
existing vacant post vice Shri Sengseng A. Sangma, (Rtd. Surveillance
Worker) took voluntary retirement and posted in Tikrikilla PHC with
immediate effect. This appointment is made purely on temporary basis
and is terminable at the expiry of this appointment unless or otherwise
it is extended depending on his performance. He is to note that regular
appointment is made only through the recommendations of the
Appropriate Recruiting Authority and this temporary appointment
does not entitle him in any way for claim of such appointment.
He is hereby directed to report for duty to the Medical & Health
Officer, I/C Tikrikilla PHC within 10(ten) days from the date of issue
of this order failing which it will be treated as forfeited.
Sd/5
(Dr. C.J.M Sangma)
District Medical & Health Officer,
West Garo Hills, Tura.
Memo. No.NVBDCP/WGH/I/ESSTT/APPTT./SW/2012/2055-62 Dt.
16-5-12.
Copy for favour of information and necessary action to : 1. The Director of Health Services (M.I), Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. The Dy. Director of Health Services (M), Meghalaya, Shillong.
3. The District Malaria Officer (NVBDCP), West Garo Hills,
Tura.
4. The Sr. Medical & Health Officer, I/C Darengre PHC. This
arrangement reduces the number of Surveillance Workers
under Darengre PHC by one which is unavoidable.
5. The Medical & Health Officer, I/C Tikrikilla PHC with a
request to forward the joining report of the incumbent to the
District Malaria Officer, Tura. This arrangement was done on
the basis of her request for posting of one additional
Surveillance Worker/MPW in Tikrikilla PHC due to shortage
of Health Workers against a big area vide Let. No.
TPHC/WGH/12-13/14-15 dtd. 20-4-2012. She is to allot the
areas to the Surveillance Worker accordingly.
6. The Accounts Branch, District Malaria Office, Tura.
7. Shri. Solaiman Sarker, S/o Lt. Jahangir Sarker, Village
Shidakandi, P.O. New Bhaitbari, West Garo Hills.
8. The Order file.
Sd/(Dr. C.J.M Sangma)
District Medical & Health Officer,
West Garo Hills, Tura.”
9.
A bare perusal of the appointment letter reflects that the same is for
a certain period and it has been made amply clear therein, that regular
appointment is to be made only through the recommendations of an
Appropriate Recruiting Authority, and that the temporary appointment as
given, does not entitle the appointee in any way for claim of regularization.
In this case, the Appropriate Recruiting Authority, is the District Selection
Committee, which is the authority that had floated the advertisement dated
17-05-2017. In sum and substance therefore, the terms of appointment
being crystal clear, there is no room for any other interpretation otherwise.
10.
The said recommendations of the respondent No. 4, on which heavy
reliance has been placed upon by the petitioner, in view of the terms of
appointment and also the prescribed mode of selection, which is to be
conducted by the District Selection Committee, appears to have been made
without any basis and in total disregard of the mandated regular selection
process and as such, the same cannot be taken to cloak the petitioners with
any vested right. The decisions placed by the learned AAG also being on a
settled point of law does not permit any consideration to be accorded to
such cases.
11.
In view of the facts and circumstances as discussed above, the
petitioners cannot be said to have any legitimate expectation or claim over
the said posts of Surveillance Worker which is to be filled up by a regular
selection process. As such, these petitions being devoid of any merit are
accordingly dismissed.
12.
Parties to bear their own costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
10.06.2022
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review