Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
CRR 4350 OF 2022
PARTHA SARATHI TRIPATHY
-VSSTATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Debdatta Saha,
Mr. Subhamay Dewanji
Mr. Saikat Biswas
For the Opposite Party No.2
: Mr. Pramod Kumar Drolia
Ms. Sanjukta Gupta
Argument concluded on
: 29.07.2026
Judgment Pronounced on
: 29.07.2026
UDAY KUMAR, J.: –
INTRODUCTION
1.
A supplementary affidavit has been filed today by the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner in compliance with the earlier directions of
this Court dated June 8th, 2026, to remove doubts and discrepancies
regarding the identity of the petitioner, Partha Sarathi Tripathi, whose
name appears in the licence under FSS Act number 10012022000264
as Partha Tripathi, being the person in charge of operations as
CRR 4350 OF 2022
evidenced by the document annexed at page 56 of the revisional
application. In this regard, the deponent, Partha Sarathi Tripathi, has
affirmed on affidavit dated July 7th, 2026, that Partha Tripathi and
Partha Sarathi Tripathi are one and the same identical person, and that
both names refer to the sole individual operating the enterprise.
Accepting the statements made on affidavit as sufficient to dispel any
clouds or ambiguity concerning his identity, I take up this matter for
pronouncement of judgment.
2.
By this application under Section 401 read with Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the petitioner has invoked the
inherent jurisdiction of this Court seeking quashing of the proceedings
relating to C.R. Case No. 384 of 2021 under Section 59 of the Food
Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as the "FSS
Act"), currently pending before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Hooghly at Chinsurah. The challenge is primarily directed against the
order dated December 15, 2021, whereby the learned Magistrate took
cognizance of the alleged offense punishable under Section 59 of the
said Act and directed issuance of process against the petitioner in his
capacity as the Manager of the manufacturing concern.
II. FOUNDATIONAL FACTS
3.
The chronological sequence of facts culminating in the filing of the
instant revisional application lies within a narrow compass. On March
11, 2021, at approximately 11:00 A.M., Opposite Party No. 2,
discharging functions as the Food Safety Officer, Eastern Railway,
CRR 4350 OF 2022
conducted an inspection of a retail food stall styled as "La-Fasta,"
situated between Platforms 3 and 4 of the Bandel Railway Station,
Hooghly. During the course of such inspection, the said officer
purchased eight statutory Tetra Packs, measuring two hundred
millilitres each, of Britannia Winkin Cow Thick Lassi (bearing Lot No.
351044FA5, Date of Packaging: 13.02.2021), manufactured by M/s.
Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Private Limited. The purchase was executed
upon a valid cash consideration of one hundred and sixty rupees
against a formal money receipt.
4.
In strict adherence to statutory sampling protocols, one part of the
seized sample was dispatched on March 12, 2021, to the West Bengal
Public Health Laboratory (Food & Water Department) for chemical and
microbiological analysis. While the department maintains that the
actual analysis of the sample was completed within the stipulated
timeline, the final analysis report was formally generated, signed, and
communicated only on May 20, 2021. This administrative delay in
issuing the report was officially attributed by the Food Analyst to severe
operational constraints, heavy backlogs, and staff limitations arising
from the COVID-19 pandemic. The said report ultimately declared the
food product to be "unsafe food" under Section 3(1)(zz) of the FSS Act,
citing alleged microbiological contamination, specifically the presence of
Escherichia coli (E. coli) and elevated coliform counts.
5.
Following the receipt of the report and obtaining administrative
sanction, Opposite Party No. 2 instituted a formal petition of complaint
giving rise to C.R. Case No. 384 of 2021 before the Learned Chief
CRR 4350 OF 2022
Judicial Magistrate, Hooghly at Chinsurah. The complaint arraigned the
stall handler, stall owner, marketer, and the present petitioner in his
individual capacity as Manager of the manufacturing unit as accused
persons. Conspicuously and crucially, the corporate manufacturing
entity itself, M/s. Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Private Limited, was
omitted from the array of accused.
6.
Upon
receiving
the
said
complaint,
the
learned
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate passed the impugned order dated December 15, 2021,
taking cognizance of the alleged offense punishable under Section 59 of
the FSS Act, directing the issuance of process against the petitioner.
Aggrieved by the initiation and continuation of the criminal proceeding,
the petitioner has invoked the inherent jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 401 read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973.
III. QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION
7.
The canvas of the controversy at the threshold of this revisional
application crystallizes into the following three pivotal legal questions:
First: Whether a criminal prosecution under Section 59 read
with Section 66 of the FSS Act can be legally maintained against
a corporate manager or officer in his individual capacity when
the principal corporate offender, the manufacturing entity itself,
has not been arraigned as an accused?
CRR 4350 OF 2022
Second: Whether an unexplained, inordinate delay of fifty-nine
days in delivering
the Food Analyst's report, in patent
contravention of the mandatory fourteen-day timeline under
Section 46(3) of the FSS Act, destroys the evidentiary reliability
of the analysis report of a short-shelf-life perishable dairy
product, thereby fatally infringing the statutory defence rights
guaranteed to the accused under Section 46(4) of the Act?
Third: Whether the complaint and investigation suffered from
an incurable breakdown of the statutory chain due to noncompliance with the jurisdictional authorization mandated
under Section 37 and the structured procedural workflow under
Section 42 of the FSS Act?
IV. SUBMISSIONS FOR THE PETITIONER
8.
Mr. Debdatta Saha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
forcefully contends that the prosecution launched against the petitioner
is an egregious abuse of the process of Court and legally nonmaintainable. He submits that under Section 66 of the FSS Act,
vicarious liability cannot be fastened upon a corporate officer unless the
company itself is arraigned as a principal offender. The omission to
implead M/s. Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Private Limited strikes at the
root of the jurisdiction, rendering the prosecution void ab initio, as
settled by the Apex Court in Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels and
Tours Private Limited [(2012) 5 SCC 661] and Sharad Kumar Sanghi v.
CRR 4350 OF 2022
Sangita Rane [(2015) 12 SCC 781], alongside the Madras High Court
decision in A.T. Kannan v. State (2021 SCC OnLine Mad 14094).
9.
Amplifying
his
submissions,
Mr.
Saha
further
submits
that
notwithstanding the department's administrative explanation regarding
pandemic-related backlogs, an inordinate delay of fifty-nine days in
issuing the Food Analyst's report severely prejudices the accused. In
respect of a short-shelf-life perishable dairy product like lassi, holding
the sample for nearly two months impairs its integrity and frustrates
the statutory right of the petitioner under Section 46(4) to seek reanalysis through a Referral Laboratory, as articulated in Municipal
Corporation of Delhi v. Ghisa Ram (AIR 1967 SC 970) and G.
Irudhayanathan v. B. Ramakrishnan (2020 SCC OnLine Mad 12748).
10. Finally, he assails the foundational competence and jurisdictional
authorization of the Food Safety Officer under Section 37 and the
mechanical invocation of procedure under Section 42 of the Act (Sailen
Ganguly v. State of West Bengal & Anr., 2016 SCC OnLine Cal 153).
Therefore, he prays for quashing of the impugned order against the
petitioner.
V. SUBMISSIONS FOR THE OPPOSITE PARTY NO. 2
11. Conversely, Mr. Pramod Kumar Drolia, learned counsel appearing for
Opposite Party No. 2, supports the impugned order by submitting that
the petitioner was directly in charge of and responsible for the
operational affairs of the manufacturing unit, thus fulfilling the
requirements of Section 66(2) of the FSS Act.
CRR 4350 OF 2022
12. He argues that arraigning the Manager in his official designation
satisfies initial procedural requirements and that any plea regarding
lack of direct oversight or transit-temperature variations are disputed
questions of fact to be tested during trial rather than evaluated at the
threshold under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C.
13. Addressing the delay in issuing the food analysis report, Mr. Drolia
relies upon the official communication dated April 7, 2021, wherein the
Food Analyst specifically explained that heavy backlogs and operational
constraints caused by the COVID-19 pandemic delayed the issuance of
the report, although the scientific evaluation of the sample itself was
duly handled. He contends that the detection of pathogenic organisms
renders the food unsafe, and therefore, the revisional application is
devoid of merit and ought to be dismissed.
VI. DISCUSSIONS AND LEGAL ANALYSIS
14. I have given anxious and circumspect consideration to the rival
submissions
advanced
by
the
parties,
examined
the
statutory
architecture of the FSS Act, and perused the materials on record.
15. The first question
strikes at the structural foundation of the
prosecution. The law governing corporate criminal liability under
modern welfare and regulatory statutes is well settled. Section 66(1) of
the FSS Act codifies the statutory doctrine of vicarious liability in
corporate crimes, stipulating that where an offense under the Act has
been committed by a company, every person who at the time the offense
was committed was in charge of, and was responsible to, the company
CRR 4350 OF 2022
for the conduct of its business, as well as the company, shall be deemed
to be guilty of the offense and shall be liable to be proceeded against
and punished accordingly.
16. The
explicit
phraseology
of
Section
66(1)
establishes
that
the
commission of an offense by the company is the foundational sine qua
non for attracting vicarious liability against its officers or employees.
Vicarious criminal liability is a legal fiction created by statute; it cannot
exist in a vacuum or operate independently. Unless the primary
offender, the corporate body, is formally arraigned as an accused and
its penal liability is brought into the lis, no derivative or vicarious
criminal liability can be fastened upon its individual directors,
managers, or employees.
17. This legal position is no longer res integra. A three-Judge Bench of the
Supreme Court in Aneeta Hada (supra), while interpreting analogous
provisions under Section 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881,
authoritatively held as follows:
"59. In view of our aforesaid analysis, we arrive at the irresistible
conclusion that for maintaining the prosecution under Section 141
of the Act, arraigning of a company as an accused is imperative.
The other categories of offenders can only be brought in the
dragnet on the touchstone of vicarious liability as the same has
been stipulated in the provision itself."
18. The aforesaid legal principle was reaffirmed with equal vigor in Sharad
Kumar Sanghi (supra), wherein the Apex Court underscored that where
the company has not been made a party to the criminal complaint, an
order taking cognizance against an individual officer alone is legally
CRR 4350 OF 2022
unsustainable. Applying these binding principles to the FSS Act, the
Madras High Court in A.T. Kannan (supra) has correctly held that a
prosecution under Section 66 of the FSS Act cannot be sustained
against a manager or officer in the absence of the manufacturing
company as an accused.
19. The contention of the prosecution that citing the petitioner as "The
Manager, M/s. Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Pvt. Ltd." satisfies the
mandate of Section 66 of the FSS Act is fundamentally flawed.
Arraigning an officer by their official designation does not equate in law
to impleading the corporate entity itself as a distinct juristic person. A
bare scrutiny of the cause title of C.R. Case No. 384 of 2021 reveals the
total omission of M/s. Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Private Limited from
the array of accused. Citing the petitioner merely as Manager in his
individual capacity does not cure this jurisdictional infirmity. This
omission constitutes a fatal, incurable jurisdictional defect that strikes
at the root of the prosecution.
20. Turning to the second question, Section 46(3) of the FSS Act mandates
that the Food Analyst shall, within a period of fourteen days from the
date of receipt of any sample for analysis, deliver to the Designated
Officer a report of the result of such analysis.
21. The prosecution has earnestly relied upon the written communication
dated April 7, 2021, wherein the Food Analyst explained that the
sample was processed within the functional window, but the formal
release of the report was delayed due to heavy backlogs and staffing
constraints
precipitated
by
the
COVID-19
pandemic.
While
CRR 4350 OF 2022
administrative exigencies and pandemic hardships are understandable,
I find that they must be weighed against the stringent statutory
timelines designed to protect the rights of the accused, particularly in
handling short-shelf-life perishable commodities.
22. The legislative intent behind imposing a strict fourteen-day timeline is
self-evident. Food products, particularly fermented dairy products like
lassi, are perishable commodities subject to rapid natural biological
degradation and microbial evolution. In the instant case, the sample
was received by the laboratory on March 12, 2021, but the test report
was generated only on May 20, 2021, representing an unexcused,
inordinate delay of fifty-nine days.
23. As propounded by the Apex Court in Ghisa Ram (supra), where a
perishable food sample undergoes natural decomposition or where
unexplained procedural gaps occur, the evidentiary value of the
analysis report is severely tested. Although the department has offered
an explanation that the analysis was conducted within time and that
the delay was confined to the administrative dispatch of the report due
to pandemic constraints, the fifty-nine-day hiatus between sample
receipt (March 12, 2021) and report generation (May 20, 2021) creates a
substantial grey area regarding sample integrity.
24. I am of the view that whether the sample remained free from
environmental or natural microbial self-generation during this extended
interim period, notwithstanding the reported presence of Escherichia
coli (E. coli) and coliform counts, raises serious triable concerns
CRR 4350 OF 2022
regarding prejudice to the accused's statutory right of re-analysis under
Section 46(4) of the FSS Act (G. Irudhayanathan, supra).
25. Finally, the statutory scheme under Sections 37 and 42 of the FSS Act
establishes an integrated, time-bound workflow governing inspection,
reporting, evaluation, and sanction. Section 37 deals with the
appointment of Food Safety Officers and vests them with specific,
territorially defined powers. Sub-section (2) of Section 37 read with
relevant rules mandates that a Food Safety Officer must be duly notified
for a specific local area by the Commissioner of Food Safety before
exercising statutory powers of entry, inspection, and seizure.
26. Section 42 prescribes a structured sequence requiring the receipt of the
analysis report, followed by an independent application of mind by the
Designated Officer, leading to a recommendation or sanction by the
competent authority, and culminating in the filing of a complaint. An
examination of the record discloses that this statutory chain was
broken at multiple junctures. The fifty-nine-day delay in analysis
fractured
the
workflow
under
Section
42(1),
and
the
record
demonstrates a mechanical transmission of files rather than a
reasoned, independent application of mind. Compliance with the
procedural mechanics of Section 42 is a mandatory prerequisite for
taking valid cognizance.
27. Where
the
foundational
steps,
from
initial
analysis
to
formal
authorization and sanction, are marked by procedural lapses and noncompliance with Sections 37 and 42 of the FSS Act, the entire edifice of
the prosecution collapses (Sailen Ganguly, supra). The failure to adhere
CRR 4350 OF 2022
to the mandatory procedural workflow vitiates the prosecution and
renders the order taking cognizance legally unsupportable.
28. In the present case, the record reflects a significant jurisdictional gap
regarding the formal authorization of the Food Safety Officer, Eastern
Railway, to exercise statutory powers over a retail stall located within
the railway station premises without seamless integration into the
statutory scheme envisaged for the local administrative jurisdiction of
Hooghly district.
29. In view of the exhaustive legal analysis and the binding precedents cited
herein, this Court arrives at the irresistible conclusion that the
prosecution initiated against the petitioner suffers from incurable
jurisdictional illegality, serious procedural non-compliance, and fatal
prejudice caused by statutory delay. Permitting such a proceeding to
continue against the petitioner amounts to a flagrant abuse of the
process of Court.
VII OPERATIVE PART & DIRECTIONS
30. Accordingly, the revisional application being CRR 4350 of 2022
succeeds and is allowed.
31. The criminal proceeding in C.R. Case No. 384 of 2021 pending before
the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Hooghly at Chinsurah, together
with the impugned order dated December 15, 2021 taking cognizance of
the offense against the petitioner, Sri Partha Sarathi Tripathy, is hereby
quashed and set aside.
CRR 4350 OF 2022
32. It is made clear that this order shall not preclude or affect the
continuation of proceedings, if any, against the remaining co-accused
persons in accordance with law.
33. All connected applications stand disposed of.
34. Interim orders stand vacated.
35. There shall be no order as to costs.
36. The Trial Court Record (TCR), if any, shall be sent down to the Trial
Court at once.
37. Case diary, if any, be returned forthwith.
38. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review