Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1/9
2026:CGHC:22404-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA(MAT) No. 399 of 2025
Parasram Ogre S/o Shri Digreelal Ogre Aged About 32 Years OccupationAgriculturist, R/o Village Pitaipali, Tahsil And P.S. Basna, District :
Mahasamund, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant (s)
versus
Chhitabai Ogre W/o Shri Parasram Ogre Aged About 30 Years OccupationHousewife, R/o Village Pilwapali, P.S. Basna, District Mahasamund,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
For Respondent
:Mr. Sudhir Kumar Sahu, Advocate
:Mr. Sumit Shrivastava, Advocate
D.B.: Hon'ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu &
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Judgment on Board
12/05/2026
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J.
1.
This appeal is preferred by the appellant/father under Section
19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as “ the Act
Digitally
signed by
PRAVEEN
KUMAR
SINHA
Date:
2026.05.18
16:11:54
+0530
of 1984”) against the order dated 29.08.2025 passed by the learned
2/9
Judge,
Family
Court,
Mahasamund,
Link
Court,
Saraipali,
in
Miscellaneous Civil Case No. 02 of 2023, whereby application filed by
the appellant/father under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act,
1890 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act of 1890”) seeking custody of
the minor daughter was dismissed.
2.
Assailing correctness and legality of the impugned order, learned
counsel for the appellant/father submits that the learned Family Court
failed to consider the paramount welfare and interest of the minor child,
Neelam Ogre. It is contended that the appellant, being the natural
guardian, is entitled to the custody of the minor daughter and is in a
better position to provide proper education and a secure future for her.
The learned Family Court failed to appreciate that it was the
respondent/wife who voluntarily left the matrimonial home and
deserted the appellant. According to the appellant, the testimony of the
witnesses examined on behalf of the respondent/wife suffers from
material contradictions and, therefore, ought not to have been relied
upon by the Family Court.
Therefore, impugned order passed by
Family Court cannot be sustained in law and deserves to be set aside.
3.
In alternate, learned counsel for the appellant submits that if this
Court is not inclined to grant custody of the minor daughter to the
appellant, appropriate visitation rights may be granted to enable him to
meet his daughter regularly.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/wife submits that
the appellant used to suspect the character of the respondent/wife and
repeatedly taunted the minor child, Neelam Ogre, by alleging that she
was not his biological daughter. It is further submitted that the
3/9
respondent/wife was subjected to physical and mental cruelty, including
harassment in connection with dowry demands. According to the
respondent, she was forcibly driven out of the matrimonial home by the
appellant. A social meeting was convened on 12.11.2019 at the
instance of the respondent; however, despite the same, appellant did
not make any effort to bring back the respondent-wife and the child. It
is further submitted that the respondent is properly taking care of the
child and paying due attention to her education and upbringing.
Learned counsel also submits that the appellant has contracted a
second marriage and is residing with another woman as husband and
wife. In such circumstances, entrusting the custody of the minor
daughter to the appellant would not be conducive to her welfare and
future. It is therefore contended that the order passed by the learned
Family Court is just, proper, and calls for no interference.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
entire record of the case.
6.
In the present case, marriage between the appellant/husband
and the respondent/wife solemnized on 02.07.2014 and the birth of a
girl child out of the wedlock are undisputed.
7.
The principles governing custody of a minor child are well
settled. While deciding the issue of custody, the paramount
consideration is always the welfare and best interest of the child and
not the legal rights of the parents.
8.
In case of Nil Ratan Kundu & Anr. Vs. Abhijit Kundu reported
in 2008 (9) SCC 413, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that while deciding
the delicate and complex issue of custody of a minor, the Court must
4/9
keep in mind not only the statutory provisions and rights flowing
therefrom, but also the human aspect involved in such matters. The
Court observed that custody disputes cannot be decided merely on
technical interpretations of law, as they involve emotional and social
dimensions requiring a humane approach. It was further held that,
while exercising parens patriae jurisdiction, the Court must give due
importance to the child’s comfort, health, education, intellectual
development, and moral and ethical upbringing. The preference of a
child, if of sufficient maturity and understanding, must also be
considered, though the final decision must rest upon what is ultimately
conducive to the welfare of the child.
9.
Recently, in Smriti Madan Kansagra Vs. Perry Kansagra
reported in (2021) 12 SCC 289, Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated that
the “best interest of the child” is the determinative factor in custody
matters. The Court observed that factors such as the age and
nationality of the child, the child’s ability to form an intelligent
preference, the environment and living conditions available for the
child’s holistic development, and the financial resources of the parents
are all relevant considerations, though financial capability alone cannot
be the sole determining factor. Paragraphs 15.1 to 15.5 of the
judgment read as follows:
“15.1. It is a well-settled principle of law that the
courts while exercising parens patriae jurisdiction
would be guided by the sole and paramount
consideration of what would best subserve the
interest and welfare of the child, to which all other
considerations must yield. The welfare and benefit of
the
minor
child
would
remain
the
dominant
5/9
consideration throughout. The courts must not allow
the determination to be clouded by the inter se
disputes between the parties and the allegations and
counter-allegations made against each other with
respect to their matrimonial life. In Rosy Jacob v.
Jacob A. Chakramakkal this Court held that: (SCC p.
855, para 15)
“15…..The children are not mere chattels:
nor are they mere playthings for their parents.
Absolute right of parents over the destinies and
the lives of their children has, in the modern
changed social conditions, yielded to the
considerations of their welfare as human beings
to that they may grow up in a normal balanced
manner to be useful members of the society...”
(emphasis supplied)
15.2. A three-Judge Bench of this Court in V. Ravi
Chandran (2) v. Union of India opined: (SCC p. 194,
para 27)
"27.... It was also held that whenever a
question arises before a court pertaining to the
custody of a minor child, the matter is to be
decided not on considerations of the legal rights
of the parties, but on the sole and predominant
criterion of what would serve the best interest of
the minor.”
(emphasis supplied)
15.3. Section 13 of the Hindu Minority and
Guardianship Act, 1956 provides that the welfare of
the minor must be of paramount consideration while
deciding custody disputes. Section 13 provides as
under:
"13. Welfare of minor to be paramount
consideration.-(1) In the appointment or
declaration of any person as guardian of a
Hindu minor by a court, the welfare of the minor
shall be the paramount consideration.
(2) No person shall be entitled to the
guardianship by virtue of the provisions of this
6/9
Act or of any law relating to guardianship in
marriage among Hindus, if the court is of
opinion that his or her guardianship will not be
for the welfare of the minor."
15.4. This Court in Gaurav Nagpal v. Sumedha
Nagpal held that the term "welfare" used in Section
13 must be construed in a manner to give it the
widest interpretation. The moral and ethical welfare
of the child must weigh with the court, as much as
the physical well-being. This was reiterated in Vivek
Singh v. Romani Singh , wherein it was opined that
the
"welfare"
of
the
child
comprehends
an
environment which would be most conducive for the
optimal growth and development of the personality of
the child.
15.5. To decide the issue of the best interest of the
child, the Court would take into consideration various
factors, such as the age of the child; nationality of the
child; whether the child is of an intelligible age and
capable of making an intelligent preference; the
environment and living conditions available for the
holistic growth and development of the child; financial
resources of either of the parents which would also
be a relevant criterion, although not the sole
determinative factor; and future prospects of the
child.”
10.
In the present case, the appellant/applicant, Parasram Ogre, was
examined as A.W.-1. In paragraph 12 of his cross-examination, he
admitted that a meeting was scheduled to be held on 12.11.2016,
though the same could not materialize. He further admitted that
thereafter the respondent/wife went to her parental home and that he
7/9
made no effort to bring her back. He also admitted that no further
meeting was convened thereafter by either side.
11.
The respondent/wife, in her examination-in-chief, stated that
though the behaviour of the appellant was cordial for a short period
after marriage and they initially led a happy marital life, she was
subsequently subjected to mental and physical harassment on account
of dowry demands after the birth of their daughter. She further deposed
that the appellant doubted her character and physically assaulted her
by alleging that the daughter was not his child. She also stated that a
social meeting was convened on 12.11.2016 before the elders of the
community, after which the appellant abandoned her and never came
to take her back. She further stated that the appellant has contracted a
second marriage. Nothing substantial could be elicited in her crossexamination to discredit her testimony.
12.
It is also pertinent to note that an interaction was held with the
minor child, Neelam Ogre, by the learned Family Court in the absence
of both parties. During such interaction, the minor disclosed that her
father had remarried. She further stated that she had been residing
with her mother since birth and expressed her desire to continue living
with her mother.
13.
Merely because the respondent/mother is unemployed and
dependent upon maintenance paid by the appellant cannot, by itself,
be a ground to deprive her of the custody of the minor child. No
amount of financial affluence can substitute the love, affection, care,
and emotional support which a mother can provide to a growing girl
child. Similarly, the economic condition of the maternal family cannot
8/9
be treated as a decisive factor for denying custody to the mother. If the
mother lacks independent financial means, the father may be directed
to provide maintenance, but such circumstance cannot be used as a
basis to deprive the mother of custody. It is equally important to bear in
mind the biological and emotional needs of a growing girl child,
particularly during the sensitive stage of puberty between the ages of
10 and 15 years. At such a stage, the child requires the special care,
guidance, and emotional support of the mother. Certain biological and
psychological changes undergone by a girl child during adolescence
are best attended to by the mother.
14.
In the present case, having regard to the evidence available on
record, particularly the statement made by the minor child before the
Family Court expressing her willingness to reside with her mother, and
considering
the
child’s
comfort,
health,
education,
intellectual
development, emotional well-being, and moral upbringing, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the welfare and best interest of the child
would
be
best
served
if
her
custody
remains
with
the
respondent/mother. Accordingly, we are of the opinion that finding
recorded by the learned Family Court granting custody of the minor
child to the respondent/mother does not warrant any interference and
the same is hereby affirmed.
15.
So far as the alternative prayer of the appellant seeking visitation
rights is concerned, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Yashita Sahu v
State of Rajasthan reported in (2020) 3 SCC 67 observed that in
custody disputes, it is invariably the child who becomes the real victim.
The Court further held that despite acrimonious disputes between
9/9
spouses, a child is entitled to the love, affection, care, and protection of
both parents, which constitutes a basic human right of the child. It was
further observed that even where custody is granted to one parent, the
other parent should ordinarily be granted adequate visitation rights so
that the child does not lose emotional and psychological contact with
either parent. Denial of such contact should occur only in exceptional
circumstances.
16.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the present case,
this Court deems it appropriate to grant visitation rights to the
appellant/father. Accordingly, it is directed that the respondent/mother
shall permit the minor child to meet and visit the appellant/father on
every Sunday between 12:00 noon and 4:00 p.m., or at such mutually
convenient time as may be agreed between the parties, at suitable
place within the village respondent is residing because in evidence,
respondent had submitted Ration Card of appellant mentioning his
name as husband of Kalavati and name of two children.
17.
The appeal is accordingly allowed in part.
18.
Let a decree be drawn accordingly.
Sd/- Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Praveen
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review