Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$%
$ &
#
'(
$
'
)
! "#$
%
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
&
&
! "#$
$
!
'
&&
! "#$
%
&
$
"(
-2-
&
$!
)
$*+ $#$
&&
" "
&
"*" $
&
"$+ $
&
&
$
&
!$
&
"* $#$
&
"!* $
&
$#$
"*#
&
&
)
&
,
-
,
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582:
<><:/?
9:<?0.<
1:4;228/5>0
<></503
4 $*+ $#$
2C<:>/
47/;2
2;3/450 "!* $
"*# 46
$#$ E
<58
3.2
$#$
$! 46
022?/5>
123/3/452: <;;9028
:/A2
"* $#$
.<:<3/=<
@9<0.
4 "!
/5
:2>/032:28
B=
3<3/45 64: 3.2 46625;2 195/0.<B72 9582:
"*" $
.<:<3/=<
"$+ $
=<=<
<5./3<
1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72
&
$
<5./3<
2;3/45
$
$#$
/F/7 98>2
" $ : C
2;3/45
64: 0.4:3 D
25/4:
/F/7 98>2
2C<:>/
.2 <B:/8>28 6<;30 46 3.2 ;<02 <:2 3.<3
32582: C<0 <11:4F28 B= 3.2
4F2:5A253 46
<
<:5<3<?< 64:
-3-
<77<B<8
/63
::/><3/45
:4G2;3 <58 3.2
43/6/;<3/45 C<0
/00928 64: /5F/3/5> 3.2 <117/;<530 64: 3.2 32582: 1:4G2;3
4C2F2:
<632: 3.2 64:A<3/45 46 52C
32582: 1:4G2;3 C<0 0341128
4F2:5A253
3.2
92 34 3.2 03411<>2 46 0<A2
<58 <704 82A<58/5> 64: 6/H<3/45 46 1:/;2 64: 344: 8<7 I
0"
###
12: @9/53<7 <58 <704 82A<58/5> 34 1:4F/82
;:41 ;4A1250<3/45 <A4953 <58 43.2: 82A<580 < >:491 46
6<:A2:0 /5;798/5> 3.2 123/3/452: 1<:3/;/1<328 /5 < 1:43203
<58
09BA/3328
3.:49>.
<A
<
<.0/78<:
:21:20253<3/45
3.2
2C<:>/ 45 "+ "$ $#$
4F2:5A253
<3 <B493 "",
3 /0 03<328 3.<3 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 C2:2
1:43203/5> 52<:
./><:<.<77/
3.2
A4F2A253
3.2
:400
F2./;720
" #
B= B74;?/5>
;;4:8/5>
3.2
;4A17</5<53 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 8/8 543 4B3</5 <5=
12:A/00/45 6:4A 3.2 ;45;2:528 <93.4:/3= 34 ;4589;3
1:43203
:201458253
09;.
3.2
47/;2
9B 5012;34:
3.2
47/;2 /564:A28 3.2 0<A2 34 :201458253
47/;2
<58 <704 <8F/028 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 34 8/0B9:02
6:4A 3.2 :4<8
201/32 3.2= ;453/5928 3.2/: 1:43203 <58
-4-
;<9028 8/039:B<5;2 34 3.2 19B7/; <58 A4F2A253 46 3.2
F2./;720
3.2
;;4:8/5>7=
123/3/452:
<58
3.2 ;4A17</53 C<0 748>28 <></503
43.2:0
"! "$ $#$
/5
:/A2
46625;20
.2
/5F203/><3/45
7</8
"* $#$
64:
3.2
<64:2A253/4528
:201458253
47/;2
<632:
;4A1723/5>
;.<:>2 0.223 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 64: 3.2
<64:2A253/4528 46625;20 B= <::<=/5> 3.2 123/3/452: <0
<;;9028
4 "!
.2 72<:528
3.2 <64:20</8 46625;20
<>/03:<32 344? ;4>5/J<5;2 64:
>>:/2F28 B= 3.2 0<A2
3.2
123/3/452: 1:262::28 3./0 123/3/45
2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: <58 3.2
72<:528
/>.
4"
3<32
49:3
4F2:5A253
72<82: 64: :201458253
.49>. 543/;2 /0 02:F28 34 :201458253
4$
.2 :2A</528 <B0253
1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02F2:<7 ;453253/450 72<:528
;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: ;45325828 3.<3 3.2 123/3/452:
B2/5>
<
72><7
1:<;3/3/452:
12:A/00/45 6:4A 3.2
<.0/78<:
0</8 1:43203 45 "+ "$ $#$
.<0
4B3</528
2C<:>/
52;200<:=
34 ;4589;3 3.2
.2:2<632:
09BA/3328 <
-5-
:21:20253<3/45 34 3.2
<.0/78<: 64: ;4589;3/5> 1:43203
C/3.493 8/039:B/5> 3.2 19B7/; 12<;2 4: 3.2 A4F2A253 46
3.2 F2./;720
201/32 3.2 0<A2 < 6<702 ;4A17</53 .<0 B225
748>28 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 45 < 147/3/;<7
:/F<7:=
2 <704 ;45325828 3.<3 3.2 123/3/452: .278 3.2
1:43203 <0 12: 3.2 &958<A253<7
/>.3 25F/0<>28 9582:
:3/;72 "* " < <58 "* " B 46 3.2
4503/393/45 46 58/<
5 ;<325< 46 G98>A2530 3.2
12H
45EB72
49:3 <58 3./0
49:3 .<F2 .278 3.<3 09;. :/>.3 ;<5543 B2 ;9:3</728 B= 3.2
47/;2 <58 3.2:2 /0 54 <B047932 1:4./B/3/45 6:4A .478/5>
19B7/; A223/5>0
1:4;200/450
82A4503:<3/450
23;
9;.
<;3/F/3/20 <:2 34 B2 :203:/;328 /5 7<:>2: 19B7/; /532:203
.25 3.2 123/3/452:0 .<F2 4B3</528 09;. 12:A/00/45 3.2
47/;2 ;<5543 6/72 < ;4A17</53 <></503 3.2A
;/:;9A03<5;2
3.2
1:4;228/5>0
/5/3/<328
5 09;.
<></503
123/3/452: /0 543./5> B93 <B902 46 1:4;200 46
3.2
49:3
;;4:8/5>7= .2 1:<=0 34 <774C 3.2 123/3/45
72<:528
72<82: <112<:/5> 64: :201458253
/>.
4"
49:3
4F2:5A253
3<32 4114028 3.2
-6-
123/3/45 B= ;453258/5> 3.<3
54C 3.2 /5F203/><3/45 /0
;4A172328 <58 ;.<:>2 0.223 .<0 B225 6/728 <58 3.2:2 <:2
A<32:/<70 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 3.2 123/3/452:
;;4:8/5>7= 1:<=0 34 8/0A/00 3.2 123/3/45
+
.<F2 >/F25 A= <5H/490 ;450/82:<3/45 B43. 45
3.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2
:2012;3/F2 1<:3/20 <58 12:9028 3.2 84;9A2530 A<82
<F</7<B72 45 :2;4:8
'
123/3/452:
<58
"+ "$ $#$
<58 09BA/3328 < :21:20253<3/45 64: 1:43203
<></503 3.2
;4978
B2
><3.2:28
6:4A
:2;4:80
3.2
43.2:0
<11:4<;.28
3.2
<.0/78<:
4F2:5A253
1:/;2 34 344: 8<7
:82: <58 <704 6/H<3/45 46 6</:
.2:2<632:
;4589;328 1:43203 <></503 3.2
3.2= G4/528 34>23.2: <58
4F2:5A253
8A/33287=
3.2 ;4A17</53 C<0 748>28 <632: 3C4 8<=0 6:4A 3.2 8<32 46
1:43203 2H;213 47/;2 ;4A17</53 54 43.2: ;4A17</530 .<F2
B225 :2;2/F28 B= 3.2
47/;2 <></503 3.2 1:43203 ;4589;328
B= 3.2 123/3/452: <58 43.2:0 64: ;:2<3/5> 19B7/; 8/039:B<5;2
4: 19B7/; 59/0<5;2
5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 3./0
49:3 /5
-7-
3.2 ;<02 46
/5
:/A/5<7
23/3/45
4 $#"'
$#$
8<328
#+ #" $#$+ @9<0.28 3.2 ;:/A/5<7 1:4;228/5>0 B= :262::/5>
3.2 G98>A253 46
45EB72
12H
49:3 /5
!
## $ %
<3 1<:<>:<1.
40 ! 34 +!
C./;. :2<80 <0
64774C0(
%
!
'
!
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
()
!
&
"#$"%$ %
)
*
)
(
+
,
!
"
-8-
&
%& ' .
/
1.
/
!'2 "#3"
/& 445 6 $"#3"% 7 & (8 "3 6 $"#3"% 9 /&2 579:
&
6 $!'2 4#"
9"%
9"
)
!
"#$"%$ %
'
'
'
;
<
1<
/
.
/&2 93# 6 !'2 "#37 /& ""33:
/
"#37 /
.
$9%
&
!
)
"#$"%$ %
$ %
&
6 $!'2
""="
"9%
"9 > !
)
'
!
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ % '
)
@
-
?
-9-
!
$ %
"#$"%$ %
'
;
'
/
&
/
'
&
A
(
< /
&
1A
( < /
&
/&& 77= 6 "#=9 /&& $& % 74B:
!
*
.
$"#=9% "
.
*
!
"#$"%$ %
$ %
79# C 754
99 C =B%
&
6 $/&&
/
)
/
)
=B
'
'
@
- 10 -
/
'
/
)
@
D
)
A
)
-
)
)
'
/
/
)
-
.
- 11 -
-
;
'
&
!
"# ' 2
'
'
'
'
$7B"7% E /&& " 6 $7B"7% 7
/&& $& % 47B 6 $7B"7% 7 /&& $& % 75" 6 $7B"7% "
/&& $(C/% 4"B:
&
*
##
6 $/&&
75E%
75E F
)
*
-
*
*
-
'
/
-
)
-
- 12 -
/
'
;
'$ F
!
)
1!
)
/
8C< $7B"3% "E /&& E7E 6 $7B"3% 5 /&&
$& % 3#E:
&
!
"#$"%
$ %
$ %
&
'
-
6 $/&&
E99@95
"7@"9 C "E%
"7
/
"#$"%$ %
&
!
!
!
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
!
)
;
- 13 -
;
@
@
;
;
'
G
'
G
@
)
'
&
"9
H
'
'
/
"E
' &
&
&
/
- 14 -
; !
-
-
;
'%
&
/
)
'
'
-
'' !
!
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
&
!
"#$7%
$3%
)
-
!
"#$7%
$9%
"# $7% H
$"%
)
@
$ %
/
@
'
/
/
- 15 -
$9% H
@
$ %
/
)
'
@
;
'( '
$ %
$ %
'
'"
'
&
;
!
&
'
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
7"
!
&
!
&
7"
- 16 -
'
'
-
/
@
@
'
&
'
'&
&
/
/
'
1/
/
'
$7B"3% = /&& 77" 6 $7B"3% 9 /&&
$& % ": 6 $/&&
9"4@"#
"93@9=%
.
"93
'
!
"#$"%$ %
)
!
&
7"
'
D
'
$ % (
'
I
/ )
1/ )
$ % (
!'2 "#37 /& 9BE:
- 17 -
'
9"9@"5
6 $!'2
9=%
J9= > F
/
/
'
)
'
F
$9%
"#
!
$3%
-
!
$"%
'
/
)
K
"9= A
)
!
"#$"%$ %
A
!
'
7"
- 18 -
'
H
!
*
!
!
/
*
1!
H
$"#=E% " /&& "":
/
G
-
-
-
/
&
D
)
' , &
&
1, &
&
"##" /
$"% /&& 3BB 6 "##" /&& $(C/% "7"9:
&
&
?
' / /
,
1/
,
5B5:
D &
/
D &
$"##7% " /&& EE4 6 " /&L&
&
6 $/&&
#3%
3"7
- 19 -
J#3
> '
!
7#$7%
!
9B$"%
!
D
K;
(
'
!
/
.
1!
$7B"=% 5 /&& 9#= 6
/
.
$7B"=% 7 /&& $& % 9=3:
6 $/&&
597@9E
E=@
37%
E=
JMK
A
!
7"
1L 6
JNK
$"##4% 4 /&& 7#3:
&
;
;
E4
'
/
/
/
/
$"#==% " /&& 3== 6 "#== /&&
$& % "5=:
'
&
.
- 20 -
!
/
,
G
!
"#3=
"#34
F
!
.
A
&
/
G (
A
&
/
"#=5 /&&
"3 6 !'2 "#=E 0 "39:
/
!
&
9 5
7E$"%
&
J
A
K
G
E
!
&
A
&
&
6 $2
/
/
/
$"#==% " /&& 3== 6 "#== /&& $& % "5=:
/&&
34"
"5%
J"5
> $"%
!
!
$7%
&
(
7E$"%
/
OK
E#
'
&
D
D
- 21 -
!
7E$"%
.
&
/
/
$"#==% " /&& 3== 6
"#== /&& $& % "5=: /&&
7B%
$2
/
J7B
;
!
7E$"%
D
D
-
'
!
7E$"%
;
D
)
;
) K !
6 $/&&
7"%
J7" > '
!
)
)
- 22 -
D
K
3B
/
/
/
$"#==% " /&& 3== 6"#==
/&& $& % "5=:
-
!
&
7E$"%
D
D
@
;
3"
.
@
'
@
@
!
7"
&
- 23 -
/
'
/
A
@
)
)
;
;
!
-
!
;
P)
Q
/
1P )
Q
/
$7B"3% #
/&& E5" 6 $7B"3% 9 /&& $& % 37":
'
'
&
!
-
"#
;
)
)
;
'
R
- 24 -
!
7"
&
(
;
'
'
'
JQ
)
H
K
'
- 25 -
-
'
-
-
;
(
!
"#$"%$ %
"#$"%$ %
&
H*
A
H*
!
)
)
*
!
1!
/
.
$7B"=% 5 /&& 9#= 6 $7B"=% 7 /&& $& % 9=3:
.
-
- 26 -
(
)
A
)
F
'
)
)
()
@
)
!
-
) I
)
?
?
,
.
)
?
)
- 27 -
)
-
)
($ .
H*
)
)
'
)
H*
H*
H*
'
H*
$
(%
%
!
)
'
)
G
H
,
;
- 28 -
'
A
L
!
;
;
'
)
)
;
/
'
)
G
)
!
,
/
(' A
&
H
,
,
- 29 -
)
&
$
%
)
D
H
&
,
((
""E9
$&
% H
7B"=
"#$"%$ %
!
!
&
"#$"%$ %
-
A
&
H
/
.
)
*
A
/
F
-
&
A
/
5=B 6 75#
; 1L 6 ,
"#"#
/
)
"#"# /&& G (
/ /& 37 6 39 ( L
/ 5= $"#"#%:
/
;
I
/
"55
&
&
-
- 30 -
-
; F
;
)
("
$ %
;
?
$ %
;
(
/
)
-
)
)
)
'
- 31 -
)
/
"55 & &
;
!
= <117=/5> 3.2 1:/5;/1720 46 3.2 <B4F2 G98>A2530
34 3.2 6<;30 <58 ;/:;9A03<5;20 46 3./0 ;<02 <8A/33287= 3.2:2 /0
54 09;. ;4A17</53 46 F/4725;2 4: 4B03:9;3/450 A<82 B= 3.2
123/3/452: 34 3.2 19B7/;
0/5;2 .2 <745> C/3. 43.2: 6<:A2:0
12<;26977= 1<:3/;/1<328 /5 3.2 1:43203 <></503 3.2
4F2:5A253
:82: <58 <704 6/H<3/45 46 6</: 1:/;2 34 344: 8<7! 3.<3 344
<632: 09BA/33/5> < :21:20253<3/45 34 3.2 ;45;2:528 <93.4:/3/20
<A 46 3.2 ;450/82:28 F/2C 3.<3 /6 253/:2 <772><3/450 /5 3.2 &
<58 43.2: 84;9A2530 3<?25 /534 ;450/82:<3/45 45 /30 6<;2 F<792
2F25 3.25 54 ;<02 .<0 B225 A<82 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: 64: 3.2
46625;20
;.<:>28
<></503
./A
./A
1:4;228/5>0
<></503
;;4:8/5>7=
1:4;228 34 1<00 3.2 64774C/5>(
<
.2 123/3/45 /0
B
.2
/0
25;2
<B902
;453/59<3/45
1:4;200
<></503
3.2
)
1:4;228/5>0
/5/3/<328
123/3/452: <;;9028
4 "!
/5
49:3
- 32 -
4 $*+ $#$
:/A2
:2>/032:28 B= 2F<:>/ 47/;2
46625;20
"!* $
195/0.<B72
"*" $
2;3/45 "*# 46
$#$
25/4:
3<3/45 64: 3.2
9582:
2;3/450
"$+ $
$
.<:<3/=<
=<=<
1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72
/F/7
"* $#$
98>2 <58
&
" $
<5./3<
/F/7
98>2
2F<:>/
.2:2B= @9<0.28
*(
$
/03
,
4,"
4,
: C
'
/0
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review