Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:16412
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 658 of 2025
Paras Pandey S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged About 62
SHOAIB
ANWAR
Digitally signed
by SHOAIB
ANWAR
Date: 2026.04.13
12:23:39 +0530
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Post Arjuni, Tahsil Kasdol,
District Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
--- Appellant
versus
1 - Nohar Prasad S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey ( Now Died )
Through Legal Representative Nil
1.1 - Manoj Kumar S/o Late Nohar Pandey Aged About 38 Years R/o
Village Rinwasarar, Post Arjuni, Tahsil Kasdol, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
1.2 - Mukesh S/o Late Nohar Pandey Aged About 36 Years R/o
Village Rinwasarar, Post Arjuni, Tahsil Kasdol, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
1.3 - Preeti Tiwari D/o Late Nohar Pandey Aged About 34 Years
(Wife Of Dinesh Tiwari), R/o Balgangadhar Tilak Ward, Janta Colony,
V.T.C. Raipur, Post Gudhiyari, Tahsil And District- Raipur, C.G.
1.4 - Ashwari Tiwari D/o Late Nohar Pandey Aged About 32 Years
(Wife Of Girja Shankar Tiwari),r/o Baba Ghasidas Ward No. 02,
Kharora, Post Kharora, Up Tahsil Kharora, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
1.5 - Smt. Shanti Bai Pandey W/o Late Nohar Pandey Aged About 60
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, Post Arjuni (B), Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
2 - Mordhwaj S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged About 55
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
3 - Ravi Prakash S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged About 53
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
4 - Dushyant Kumar S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged About
47 Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
5 - Smt. Gajendra Pandey W/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged
About 75 Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol,
District Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
6 - Smt. Surekha W/o Ajay Sharma Aged About 42 Years R/o
Kadambari Nagar, District Durg, C.G.
7 - Smt. Madhuri W/o Devesh Sharma Aged About 40 Years R/o
Village
Van
Colony
Gariyaband,
District
Gariyaband,
C.G.
8 - Smt. Shakuntala W/o Mukesh Tiwari Aged About 38 Years R/o
Jhanda Chowk, Raipur, District Raipur, C.G. , At Present R/o
Dongargarh, Bhandari Complex, Sispara, District Rajnandgaon, C.G.
9 - Smt. Minti Pandey W/o Shailendra Pandey Aged About 36 Years
R/o Ani Colony, House No. 1249/3, Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur, C.G.
10 - Teknarayan, S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey (Now Died)
Through Legal Representatives Nil
10.1 - Smt. Manorama W/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 67
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, Tahsil Kasdol, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
10.2 - Suman D/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 45 Years R/o
Village Rinwasarar, Tahsil Kasdol, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
(C.G.)
10.3 - Omprakash S/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 42
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, Tahsil Kasdol, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
10.4 - Hemprakash S/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 40
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, Tahsil Kasdol, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
10.5 - Smt. Sudha W/o Santosh Mishra Aged About 35 Years (D/o
Late Teknarayan Pandey), R/o Village Raikheda, Tahsil Tilda, District
Raipur, C.G.
11 - Smt. Neelam Pandey W/o Late Bhola Ram Pandey Aged About
68 Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.) At Present R/o Infront Of Risda Road,
Near Kali Mandir, Balodabazar, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
(C.G.)
12 - Sailendra Pandey S/o Late Bhola Ram Pandey Aged About 42
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.) At Present R/o Infront Of Risda Road,
Near Kali Mandir, Balodabazar, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
(C.G.)
13 - Hemant Pandey S/o Late Bhola Ram Pandey Aged About 36
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.) At Present R/o Infront Of Risda Road,
Near Kali Mandir, Balodabazar, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
(C.G.)
14 - Devesh Pandey S/o Late Bhola Ram Pandey Aged About 32
Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.) At Present R/o Infront Of Risda Road,
Near Kali Mandir, Balodabazar, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
(C.G.)
15 - Purendra Pandey S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged
About 60 Years R/o Village Rinwasarar, P.H. No. 2, Tahsil Kasdol,
District Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.) At Present R/o Infront Of
Risda Road, Near Kali Mandir, Balodabazar, District BalodabazarBhatapara (C.G.)
16 - Kamal Pandey S/o Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey Aged About
47 Years R/o Thakurdeva, Chowk Bazari, Rawabhatha, Ward No. 15,
Birgaon, Raipur, District Raipur, C.G.
17 - Smt. Maheshwari W/o Rishikesh Shukla Aged About 56 Years
R/o Mandir Chowk, Bramhanpara, Pithora, District- Mahasamund,
C.G.
18 - Smt. Nandini Choubey W/o Mukesh Choubey Aged About 54
Years R/o Village Maharajpur, Tahsil Kawardha, District- Kabirdham,
C.G.
19 - State Of Chhattisgarh The Collector Balodabazar, District
Balodabazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
SA No. 712 of 2025
Paras Pandey S/o Late Shri Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About 63
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No.02, Tahsil- Kasdol Distt- Baloda
Bazar-Bhatapara (C.G.)
--- Appellant
Versus
1 - Nohar Prasad ( Dead) Through His Lrs. (A). Manoj Kumar Nill
1.1 - Manoj Kumar S/o Late Nohar Prasad Pandey Aged About 39
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.O.- Arjuni, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
1.2 - Mukesh S/o Late Nohar Prasad Pandey Aged About 37 Years
R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.O.- Arjuni, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt. Baloda
Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
1.3 - Priti Tiwari D/o Late Nohar Prasad Pandey Aged About 35
Years (W/o Dinesh Tiwari), Address- Balgangadhar Tilak Ward, Janta
Colony, V T C, Raipur, P.O.- Gudiyari, Tahsil And Distt. Raipur, C.G.
1.4 - Ishwari Tiwari D/o Late Nohar Prasad Pandey Aged About 35
Years (W/o Girija Shankar Tiwari), Address- Baba Ghasidas Ward No.
02, Kharora, Distt.- Raipur, C.G.
1.5 - Smt. Shanti Bai Pandey W/o Late Nohar Prasad Pandey Aged
About 61 Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.O.- Arjuni, Tahsil- Kasdol,
Distt. Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
2 - Mordwaj S/o Late Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About 56 Years
R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt. Baloda
Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
3 - Ravi Prakash S/o Late Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About 54
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
4 - Dushyant Kumar S/o Late Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About
48 Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
5 - Smt. Gajendra Pandey W/o Late Guptnarayan Pandey Aged
About 71 Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol,
Distt. Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
6 - Smt. Surekha W/o Ajay Sharma Aged About 43 Years R/o
Kadambari Nagar, Distt. Durg, C.G.
7 - Smt. Madhuri W/o Devesh Sharma Aged About 41 Years R/o
Forest Colony, Gariyaband, Distt. Gariyaband, C.G.
8 - Smt. Shankuntala W/o Mukesh Tiwari Aged About 39 Years R/o
Jhanda Chowk, Raipur, C.G., Present Address- Dongargarh Bhandari
Complex, Sispara, Distt.- Rajnandgaon, C.G.
9 - Smt. Minti Pandey W/o Shailendra Pandey Aged About 37 Years
R/o N. E. Colony, House No. 1249/3, Bilaspur, Distt. Bilaspur, C.G.
495002
10 - Teknarayan (Died) Through Lrs Nil.
10.1 - Smt. Manorama W/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 68
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, Post- Arjuni (B), Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
10.2 - Om Prakash S/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 43
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, Post- Arjuni (B), Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
10.3 - Hemprakash S/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 41
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, Post- Arjuni (B), Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
10.4 - Suman D/o Late Teknarayan Pandey Aged About 46 Years R/o
Village- Riwasarar, Post- Arjuni (B), Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt. Baloda
Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
10.5 - Smt. Sudha W/o Santosh Kumar Mishra (D/o- Teknarayan
Pandey) Aged About 36 Years R/o Raikheda, Tahsil- Tilda, Dist.
Raipur, C.G.
11 - Smt. Neelam Pandey W/o Bholaram Pandey Aged About 69
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G., Present Address- In Front Of Kali
Mandir, Risda Road, Baloda Bazar, Tahsil- Baloda Bazaar, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
12 - Shailendra Pandey S/o Late Bholaram Pandey Aged About 42
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G., Present Address- In Front Of Kali
Mandir, Risda Road, Baloda Bazar, Tahsil- Baloda Bazaar, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
13 - Hemant Pandey S/o Late Bhoram Pandey Aged About 37 Years
R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt. Baloda
Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G., Present Address- In Front Of Kali Mandir,
Risda Road, Baloda Bazar, Tahsil- Baloda Bazaar, Distt. Baloda
Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
14 - Devesh Pandey S/o Bholaram Pandey Aged About 32 Years R/o
Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt. Baloda BazaarBhatapara, C.G., Present Address- In Front Of Kali Mandir, Risda
Road, Baloda Bazar, Tahsil- Baloda Bazaar, Distt. Baloda BazaarBhatapara, C.G.
15 - Purendra Pandey S/o Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About 61
Years R/o Village- Riwasarar, P.H. No. 02, Tahsil- Kasdol, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G., Present Address- In Front Of Kali
Mandir, Risda Road, Baloda Bazar, Tahsil- Baloda Bazaar, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
16 - Kamal Pandey S/o Sutichan Prasad Pandey Aged About 47
Years R/o Thakurdeva, Chowk Bajari, Ravabhata, Ward No. 15,
Birgoan, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, C.G.
17 - Smt. Maheshwari W/o Rishikesh Shukla Aged About 57 Years
R/o Mandir Chowk, Bhrahman Para, Pithaura, Distt. - Mahasamund,
C.G.
18 - Smt. Nandini Choubey W/o Mukesh Choubey Aged About 55
Years R/o Village- Maharajpur, Tahsil- Kawardha, Distt. Kabirdham,
C.G.
19 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector, Baloda Bazar, Distt.
Baloda Bazaar-Bhatapara, C.G.
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause title taken from CIS)
For Appellants
:
For Respondents Nos. 1 to:
4/Caveators in S.A. No.
658/2025
For Respondent/State
:
Shri
H.B.
Agrawal,
Senior
Advocate with Shri Vikaram
Pratap, Advocate
Shri Sunil Sahu, Advocate
Shri
Santosh
Advocate.
Soni,
Govt.
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, Judge
Judgment on Board
09.04.2026
1. Since both the appeals assail the common judgment and
decree and involve interconnected issues, they were heard
and being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. Challenge in these appeals is to the common judgment and
decree dated 29.10.2025 passed by the first District Judge
Balodabazar in Civil Appeal No. 30-A/2024 (Nohar Prasad
(dead) through LR’s Manoj Kumar & Others) and Civil Appeal
No. 22-A/2024 (Paras Pandey vs.
Nohar Prasad (dead)
through LR’s Manoj Kumar & Others) by which the Civil
Appeal preferred by the plaintiffs was partly allowed whereas
the civil Appeal preferred by Paras Pandey was dismissed. The
aforesaid civil Appeals were arising out of the judgment and
decree dated 04.05.2024 passed by the Civil Judge Senior
Division Kasdol District Baloda bazar in Civil Suit No.
17-A/2017 (Nohar Prasad Pandey & Others vs. Paras Pandey &
Others) by which the learned trial Court directed for partition
of the suit property bearing Khasra No. 5 area 9.834 hectare
in equal share of 1/12.
3.
(a)
Before proceeding with the case, it is noteworthy to
mention here that earlier the plaintiff Nohar Prasad Pandey
preferred Civil Suit No. 17-A/2017 (Nohar Prasad Pandey &
Others vs. Paras Pandey & Others) which was allowed by the
judgment and decree dated 16.08.2023, whereby the suit was
decreed declaring that the plaintiffs are entitled to 1/5th
share in the suit land situated at Village Rewasarar, P.H. No.
02, Tehsil Kasdol, District Balodabazar–Bhatapara (C.G.), as
described in Schedule ‘A’ appended to the plaint, comprising
five khasra numbers admeasuring 9.834 hectares.
(b)
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree dated
16.08.2023, the defendant No. 1 preferred civil appeal No. 14A/2023 (Paras Pandey vs. Nohar Prasad & Others), which was
decided by the learned First Additional District Judge
Balodabazar by judgment dated 26.02.2024 and remanded
back the matter holding that the judgment and decree dated
16.08.2023 passed by the Trial Court are hereby set aside, and
the matter is remitted to the Trial Court under Order 41 Rule
25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, for carrying out
further proceedings. The Trial Court was directed to afford an
opportunity to the plaintiffs to produce the genealogical tree
and to permit both the plaintiffs and the defendants to make
consequential amendments in their pleadings; to peruse its
order sheet in respect of witnesses already examined and
clearly specify the sequence of the plaintiffs’ witnesses; to
frame three additional issues; and thereafter to provide both
parties an opportunity to adduce evidence and produce
documents in support of their respective cases, and to decide
the matter in accordance with law within a period of two
months. The parties was directed to appear before the Trial
Court on 04.03.2024 for the aforesaid proceedings.
(c)
After remand of the matter, the learned trial Court
considered the issue and decided the same on 04.05.2024
holding
that
the plaintiffs have successfully proved their
case on the preponderance of probabilities. Accordingly, the
suit in respect of the suit land bearing Khasra No. 05,
admeasuring 9.834 hectares with land revenue of Rs. 53, is
decreed and the following preliminary decree is passed: (i) it
is declared that each of the plaintiffs is entitled to 1/12th
share in the suit property situated at Village Rewasarar, P.H.
No. 02, Tehsil Kasdol, District Balodabazar–Bhatapara (C.G.),
as described in Schedule “A” annexed to the plaint; (ii) the
plaintiffs are entitled to obtain possession of their respective
shares upon due partition of the suit property; and (iii) after
partition and delivery of possession, the plaintiffs shall be
entitled to a decree of permanent injunction restraining the
defendants, either directly or through any other person, from
interfering with the plaintiffs’ respective shares in the suit
land.
(d)
Against the said judgment two separate civil appeals
preferred by the plaintiff (Civil appeal No. 30-A/2024) and the
defendant No. 1 (Civil Appeal No. 22-A/2024), which were
decided by the common impugned judgment and decree
dated 29.10.2025, whereby the civil appeal preferred by the
plaintiff was allowed in part and the civil appeal preferred by
defendant no. 1 was dismissed. In respect of the defendant
No.1/appellant herein both the Courts have gave concurrent
finding. Thus, these two appeals by the defendant No. 1.
4. For the sake of convenience, the parties would be hereinafter
referred as per their status before the trial Court.
5. The Civil suit has been instituted by the plaintiffs against the
defendants
seeking
a
declaration
of
title,
permanent
injunction, partition, and possession in respect of the suit
property. The plaintiffs and defendant No. 1 are real brothers,
being the sons of Late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey. According to
the
plaintiffs,
the
suit
land
bearing
Khasra
No.
admeasuring about 9.835 hectares, situated at Village
Rewasarar, Tahsil Kasdol, District Baloda Bazar-Bhatapara, is
ancestral property which stood recorded in the name of their
father in the revenue records. It is pleaded that during the
lifetime of their father, other properties were already
partitioned amongst the legal heirs and each heir is in
possession of his respective share without any dispute.
However, the suit property continued to remain joint. It is
further the case of the plaintiffs that for the purpose of
purchasing a tractor through a bank loan for agricultural
development, the suit land was nominally transferred in the
name of defendant No. 1 pursuant to a family arrangement,
with a clear understanding that after repayment of the loan,
the land would be re-partitioned equally among all the
brothers. The plaintiffs assert that although the loan was
repaid, defendant No. 1 failed to honour the family
arrangement and, taking advantage of the revenue entries
standing in his name, refused to partition the property and
claimed exclusive ownership. Consequently, the plaintiffs
claim that each of them, along with defendant No. 1, is
entitled to a 1/5th share in the suit property and seek
appropriate reliefs.
6. The Defendant No. 1, filed his written statement, has denied
the
material
averments
of
the
plaintiffs
except
the
relationship between the parties. It is contended that there
had already been a partition effected by their father around
the year 1994, whereby different parcels of land were allotted
to each son, and the suit property fell exclusively to the share
of defendant No. 1. He denied the existence of any family
arrangement or nominal transfer for the purpose of
obtaining a bank loan and asserts that he alone had obtained
the loan for the tractor and had repaid the same. He further
claims to be in exclusive possession and cultivation of the suit
land since 1994 and raises objections that the suit is barred
by limitation and is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
7.
The Defendant No. 13, on the other hand, partly supports the
case of the plaintiffs by admitting that the suit property is
ancestral in nature and that the transfer in favour of
defendant No. 1 was made only for the purpose of securing a
loan under a family arrangement. It is further stated that due
to non-payment of the loan by defendant No. 1, the liability
was ultimately discharged through the sale of a house by
mutual consent of the family members, and it was agreed
that after repayment of the loan, the suit property would be
partitioned. However, defendant No. 1 failed to do so and
retained the property in his name. Nevertheless, defendant
No. 13 disputes the quantum of share claimed by the
plaintiffs and contends that each party is entitled to only
1/12th share in the suit property.
8.
After appreciating the evidence available on record and after
framing the issues, the learned trial Court by judgment and
decree dated 04.05.2024 partly allowed the suit of the plaintiff
holding that the suit property bearing Khasra No. 05
admeasuring 9.834 hectares is ancestral property originally
recorded in the name of late Sutikshan Prasad Pandey, and
that the plaintiffs and defendants are his Class-I legal heirs. It
was found that the defendant No.1 failed to establish any
prior partition or exclusive allotment of the suit land in his
favour, and mere mutation in revenue records does not
confer title. The Court further disbelieved the defendant’s
plea regarding payment of Rs. 5 lakhs in lieu of partition for
want of cogent evidence. Relying on Section 8 of the Hindu
Succession Act, 1956, the Court concluded that all heirs are
entitled to equal shares and declared that each plaintiff has a
1/12th share in the suit property with a right to seek partition
and possession. It was also held that the suit is not barred by
limitation, as the property remained joint and the plaintiffs’
possession was not conclusively ousted. The Court further
found that although other properties of the deceased had
been partitioned, the suit land remained joint. Accordingly,
the suit was decreed by passing a preliminary decree for
partition, granting the plaintiffs entitlement to separate
possession of their shares and a decree of permanent
injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with
the plaintiffs’ shares after partition.
9.
Against the said judgment and decree, two separate civil
appeals were preferred by the plaintiffs as well as Defendant
No. 1, which came to be decided by a common impugned
judgment and decree passed by the learned First Appellate
Court, whereby the appeal filed by the plaintiffs was partly
allowed, which has attained finality and the appeal preferred
by Defendant No. 1 was dismissed. Being aggrieved thereby,
both the present appeals have been preferred by Defendant
No. 1.
10. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the First
Appellate Court erred in rejecting the application under Order
41 Rule 27 CPC, as the documents relating to the 1998
partition were essential for proper adjudication and go to the
root of the case. The rejection has caused serious prejudice to
the appellant. It is further submitted that both the courts
have failed to consider that the suit property was already
partitioned and the appellant was in possession as per
revenue records. According to the learned counsel, the suit
filed in 2017 challenging the partition dated 15.04.1988 is
clearly barred by limitation and should have been dismissed
on this ground alone. Hence, the findings are perverse and
the suit ought to have been dismissed.
11. Learned counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 1 to 4
(caveators in S.A. No. 658/2025), along with the State counsel,
have supported the common impugned judgment passed by
the learned First Appellate Court.
12. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
material available on record.
13. The First Appellate Court, upon re-appreciation of the entire
evidence
on
record,
held
that
the
suit
property
is
ancestral/coparcenary property of late Sutikshan Prasad
Pandey and that both parties derived their rights therein by
birth. It affirmed that the suit was within limitation, as the
cause of action arose in December 2016 upon refusal of
partition by Defendant No. 01, and the suit filed in 2017 was
within the prescribed period. However, the Appellate Court
found that the Trial Court erred in applying Section 8 of the
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and in allotting 1/12th share to
each plaintiff by treating all heirs equally. It was held that
certain coparceners had already separated during the lifetime
of the deceased by taking their shares, and thus, they were
not entitled to claim further share in the remaining joint
property. The Court further disbelieved the defendant’s plea
of exclusive allotment in 1988 and payment of Rs. 5 lakhs in
lieu of partition due to lack of credible evidence, and held that
mere mutation in revenue records does not confer title.
Consequently, the Appellate Court concluded that the
remaining coparceners, including the plaintiffs, Defendant
No. 01, one brother, and two sisters, were entitled to equal
shares, thereby determining 1/8th share each in the suit
property. Accordingly, the appeal filed by the plaintiffs was
partly allowed, the judgment and decree of the Trial Court
dated 04.05.2024 were set aside, and a modified preliminary
decree for partition was passed declaring 1/8th share of each
plaintiff with entitlement to seek partition and possession,
along with permanent injunction against interference after
delivery of possession, while the appeal of Defendant No. 01
was dismissed.
14. While considering the application filed by Defendant No. 1
under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure the first
appellate Court has rightly held that the document sought to
be produced, i.e., the certified copy of the mutation register
of the year 1988, merely reflects mutation of the suit land in
the name of Defendant No. 1 pursuant to an alleged
partition, which fact is already borne out from Ex.P-11
(Mutation Entry No. 03 dated 15.04.1988) available on record.
The First Appellate Court further recorded that the said
document does not bring any new or material fact affecting
the merits of the case and was within the knowledge of
Defendant No. 1, which could have been produced at an
earlier stage. Accordingly, the application was rejected.
15. As far as the submission of learned counsel for the appellant/
defendant No.1 with regard to production of certain
documents in the appeal is concerned, such permission
cannot be granted as a matter of course, nor can additional
evidence be introduced at the whim or convenience of a
litigating party. In fact, the general principle is that the
appellate Court should not travel outside the record of the
trial Court and cannot take any evidence in an appeal under
Section 96 of the CPC. It is noteworthy to mention here that
once trial had concluded and the decree was under
challenged in an appeal, the appellants cannot be permitted
to fill the gaps in their case by seeking to adduce further
material to fortify the claim that was fundamentally flawed.
(See: Gobind Singh and Ors. v Union of India and Ors. (Civil
Appeal Nos.5168-5169 of 2011 decided on 9-3-2026)
16. The present Second Appeals, preferred by Defendant No. 1,
does not merit consideration and are liable to be dismissed.
The learned First Appellate Court, being the final court of
facts, has meticulously re-appreciated the entire oral and
documentary evidence on record and has recorded wellreasoned and cogent findings. It has rightly held that the suit
property is ancestral/coparcenary property of late Sutikshna
Prasad Pandey, and that the parties derive their rights therein
by birth. The finding of the First Appellate Court that the suit
was within limitation is also based on proper appreciation of
evidence, particularly the fact that the cause of action arose
only in December 2016 when Defendant No. 1 refused
partition, and the suit was instituted in 2017 within the
prescribed period.
17. The First Appellate Court has further rightly disbelieved the
plea of Defendant No. 1 regarding exclusive allotment of the
suit property in the year 1988 and the alleged payment of Rs.
5 lakhs in lieu of partition, as no cogent, reliable or
documentary evidence was produced to substantiate the
same. It is a settled principle of law that mere entries in
revenue records do not confer title, and the Appellate Court
has correctly applied this principle while rejecting the claim of
exclusive ownership of Defendant No. 1.
18. It is pertinent to mention here that the finding recorded by
both the Courts in respect of defendant No.1 is concurrent in
nature.
19. The scope of interference in a Second Appeal under Section
100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is extremely limited.
Interference is permissible only when the appeal involves a
substantial question of law. Concurrent findings of fact
recorded by both the Courts cannot be interfered with unless
such findings are shown to be perverse, based on no
evidence, or contrary to settled principles of law.
20. In the present case, both the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court have concurrently recorded findings, in
respect of the defendant No.1, on the basis of evidence
available on record, that the appellant failed to establish their
case by placing cogent and sufficient material. The appellant
has failed to demonstrate any perversity, illegality, or
misapplication of law in the findings so recorded.
21. The questions sought to be raised in the present Second
Appeal essentially relate to re-appreciation of evidence and
challenge to concurrent findings of fact. Such questions do
not give rise to any substantial question of law within the
meaning of Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
22. It is well established that when there is a concurrent finding
of fact, unless it is found to be perverse, the Court should not
ordinarily interfere with the said finding.
23. In the matter of State of Rajasthan and others Vs. Shiv Dayal
and another, reported in (2019) 8 SCC 637, reiterating the
settled proposition, it has been held that when any
concurrent finding of fact is assailed in second appeal, the
appellant is entitled to point out that it is bad in law because
it was recorded de hors the pleadings or based on misreading
of material documentary evidence or it was recorded against
any provision of law and lastly, the decision is one which no
Judge acting judicially could reasonably have reached.
24. Be that as it may, the argument advanced by learned counsel
for the appellant and the proposed question of law cannot be
regarded as satisfying the test of being ‘substantial question
of law’ within the meaning of Section 100 of CPC. These
questions, in my view, are essentially question of facts. The
appellants failed to raise any substantial question of law
which is required under Section 100 of the CPC in. In any
event, the Second Appeal did not involve any substantial
question of law as contemplated under Section 100 of the
CPC, no case is made out by the appellants herein. The
judgments impugned passed by the learned trial Court as
well as First Appellate Court are just and proper and there is
no illegality and infirmity at all.
25. Accordingly, both the appeals are liable to be and are hereby
dismissed at the admission stage.
SD/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Shoaib/Gowri
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review