The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Accordingly, the cancellation of the candidature of the petitioner being on account of the disability suffered by the petitioner which was detected during his medical re-examination, this Court is of the considered view that the communication dated 30.11.2018, would not mandate an interference from this Court.
13. Accordingly, the claim made by the petitioner in the present writ petition is held to be devoid of any merit and the same consequently stands dismissed. However, there would be no order as to costs. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010198592019
2026:GAU-AS:9729
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6063/2019
PANKAJ KOCH
S/O- KUHIRAM KOCH
R/O- VILL. NO. 4 GORMARA
P.O. AND P.S. CHARIDUAR
DIST.- SONITPUR
ASSAM
PIN- 784103.
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS.
REP. BY THE DEFENCE SECRETARY
GOVT. OF INDIA
SOUTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI.
2:THE DIRECTOR RECRUITMENT
ARMY RECRUITMENT OFFICE
SHILLONG ASSAM
RECRUITMENT OFFICE (HQ)
SHILLONG
MEGHALAYA
PIN- 900332
C/O 99 APO.
3:THE RESDIDENT MEDICAL OFFICER
155 BASE HOSPITAL
SHILLONG
Page No.# 2/7
MEGHALAYA
PIN- 793001.
4:THE ASSISTANT RTG OFFICER
RTG OFFICE (HQ) SHILLONG
MEGHALAYA 793001.
5:THE COMMANDANT
UNIT 33SOLMARA MILITARY STATION
TEZPUR- 784501.
-----------Advocate for : MR. I ALAM
Advocate for : ASSTT.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 16.07.2026
Heard Mr. I. Alam, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Ms.
B. Sarma, learned CGC, appearing for the respondents.
2.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has presented a challenge to an
order dated 30.11.2018, by which he was declared to be medically unfit for recruitment
against the post of Soldier [GD] for which he was selected in pursuance to a
recruitment process held for the same.
3.
The petitioner, herein, had appeared in a Army recruitment rally held in the
month of February, 2018, at Tezpur. On clearing the physical test, the petitioner was
vide admit card dated 21.02.2018, permitted to appear in the written examination. The
petitioner having cleared all the stages of the selection process, the name of the
petitioner came to be included in a select list published after the said recruitment
Page No.# 3/7
exercise. In view of his selection, the petitioner was issued with a communication dated
31.05.2018, provisionally selecting him for the post of Soldier [GD] and was allotted at
the ARTY Centre Hyderabad, for undergoing his training. In the said communication, it
was stipulated that the final selection of the petitioner would be subject to his
documents verification and being found to be medically and physically fit at the time of
dispatch to the said training centre. As there was a delay in carrying out of the requisite
documents verification and around 208 (two hundred eight) days having lapsed, the
petitioner was subjected to a further medical examination. On his such re-medical
examination by the Recruiting Medical Officer, the petitioner was found suffering from a
disability named “VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling of left testicle). Thereafter, the matter
was further reviewed by the Senior Recruiting Zone (North-East States), Shillong. The
petitioner was thereafter, also reviewed by a Graded Specialist Surgeon at Military
Hospital, Shillong. The Doctors examining the petitioner on his such re-medical
examination, having found the petitioner to be suffering from the said disability, he was
held to be unfit to be recruited as a Soldier in the Army and accordingly, vide a
communication 30.11.2018, the candidature of the petitioner was cancelled on the
ground that he was medically unfit.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present writ petition.
4.
Mr. I. Alam, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner, after reiterating the
facts, noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that the petitioner at the time of his medical
examination during the recruitment rally was not detected to be suffering from any
disability including the disability of “VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling of left testicle). He
submits that on account of a delay occasioning in the matter, the petitioner was
Page No.# 4/7
subjected to re-medical examination. On his such re-medical examination, the petitioner
was declared to be medically unfit on account of having “VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling
of left testicle). It is submitted that the said re-medical examination conducted on the
petitioner and the reports as obtained by the Respondent Authorities had been
conducted without the knowledge of the petitioner and the petitioner was not afforded
with an opportunity to make a claim for being examined by a Specialized Civil Doctor.
5.
Mr. I. Alam, further submits that the manner in which the petitioner was
subjected to a re-medical examination and the reports as obtained in the matter by the
Respondent Authorities leading to the cancellation of his candidature, the petitioner was
required to be afforded an opportunity to have himself medically examined before a
competent Doctor practicing in the Civil Hospital. Accordingly, he submits that this Court
would be pleased to direct the Respondent Authorities to have a review medical
examination of the petitioner and by incorporating in the panel of Doctors so
constituted a Specialist from a Civil Hospital.
6.
Per contra, Ms. B. Sarma, learned CGC, appearing for the respondents, has
submitted that a lapse of more than 208 (two hundred eight) days having occasioned
since the date of the medical examination of the petitioner during his recruitment rally,
the petitioner was mandated to be subjected to a further review medical examination in
terms of the directives operating in this connection. It is submitted that the petitioner
on being examined by the Recruiting Medical Officer, the petitioner was found to be
suffering from “VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling of left testicle). The petitioner
accordingly, was thereafter, forwarded to the Graded Specialist Surgery at Military
Hospital, Shillong, for a further examination by a Specialist Doctor. The petitioner on
Page No.# 5/7
being examined by the Specialist Doctor at the Graded Specialist Surgery at Military
Hospital, Shillong, it was affirmed that the petitioner suffered from “VERICOCOELE
LEFT” (swelling of left testicle) and accordingly, the petitioner was held to be unfit for
recruitment to the Force. She submits that the said aspect of the matter was duly
communicated to the petitioner vide a communication dated 30.11.2018.
7.
Ms. B. Sarma, learned CGC, submits that the disability detected in respect of
the petitioner would have the effect of hindering the completion by him of his training
programme and accordingly, the petitioner was found to be unfit for recruitment to the
Force. She submits that the opinion submitted by the Specialist Doctor of the
respondents, would require to be affirmed, inasmuch as, only persons fit in all respects
would be mandated to be recruited to the Force. Accordingly, she submits that the
rejection of the candidature of the petitioner would not mandate an interference from
this Court.
8.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials
brought on record.
9.
The petitioner initially, during the recruitment rally on medical examination, was
found to be medically fit. However, on completion of the recruitment process and the
petitioner having been placed in the merit list, the petitioner now being required to be
deputed for undergoing training, a letter in connection was issued to him on
31.05.2018. In the said letter, it was stipulated that he would be deputed for
undergoing the training subject to verification of his documents and he being found to
be physically fit at the time of his dispatch to the training centre. A period of 208 (two
Page No.# 6/7
hundred eight) days having lapsed since the petitioner was medically examined during
the recruitment rally and the date on which the petitioner had appeared before the
Respondent Authorities, in pursuance to the communication dated 31.05.2018, for
being dispatched to the training centre, the petitioner was subjected to a review
medical examination. The Recruiting Medical Officer, on examining the petitioner, found
that the petitioner was suffering from “VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling of left testicle).
Accordingly, the Recruitment Officer had referred the petitioner to Graded Specialist
Surgery at Military Hospital, Shillong. The petitioner was examined in the said Hospital
by a Specialist and it was affirmed that the petitioner was infact suffering from
“VERICOCOELE LEFT” (swelling of left testicle). Accordingly, the Specialist Doctor
examining the petitioner opined the petitioner to be unfit for recruitment to the Force.
10.
The said opinion having been received by the Respondent Authorities, the
Force authority issued a communication dated 30.11.2018, to the petitioner cancelling
his candidature on being found to be medically unfit on his medical re-examination.
While the petitioner has assailed the cancellation of his candidature effected vide the
communication dated 30.11.2018, which is based on the opinion rendered in the matter
by the Doctors examining him during his re-medical examination, the petitioner had not
brought on record any material to demonstrate that at the relevant point of time, he
was not suffering from any disability including the disability identified by the Doctors
examining him during his medical re-examination. In the appeal submitted by the
petitioner against the communication dated 30.11.2018, the petitioner had also not
highlighted the fact that the petitioner was not suffering from “VERICOCOELE LEFT”
(swelling of left testicle). The Respondent Authorities having found the petitioner to be
Page No.# 7/7
not fit for recruitment to the Force on account of suffering from “VERICOCOELE LEFT”
(swelling of left testicle), this Court would not sit on appeal over such opinion rendered
by a Specialist in the matter in absence of any material being brought on record by the
petitioner to dispute the said opinion rendered in his case by the Doctors examining
him during his medical re-examination.
11.
It is a settled position of law that it is only a person found fully fit, who would
be eligible to be recruited to the Army, and in the event, any candidate is found to be
medically unfit, it is not for this Court to sit on appeal and substitute its views, in place
of the opinion rendered in the matter by the Specialist of the Army, more so in absence
of any material brought on record by the petitioner to dispute such view taken by a
Specialist Doctor of the Army. It is also a settled position of law that the decision taken
in a re-medical examination of candidate by a competent authority of the Army should
be treated as final.
12.
Accordingly, the cancellation of the candidature of the petitioner being on
account of the disability suffered by the petitioner which was detected during his
medical re-examination, this Court is of the considered view that the communication
dated 30.11.2018, would not mandate an interference from this Court.
13.
Accordingly, the claim made by the petitioner in the present writ petition is
held to be devoid of any merit and the same consequently stands dismissed. However,
there would be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review