Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 458 OF 2020
1. Sri Pankaj Bhowmik,
Son of Sri Dinesh Bhowmik, resident of village & P.O. South
Krishnanagar, Joypur, P.S.Belonia, District-South Tripura,
Pin-799156.
2. Smt. Saswati Nandi Dey,
Daughter of Sri Ratan Chandra Nandi, wife of Sri Nitya Ranjan Dey,
Resident of village-Ramthakurpara, Belonia, P.S. Belonia,
District-South Tripura.
--- Appellants.
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary,
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura,
Having his office at Pandit Nehru Complex, Gorkhabasti, PO-Kujaban,
PS-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura.
2. The Director of Health Services, Directorate of Health Services,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gorkhabasti, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West
Tripura.
3. Sri Bishnu Debnath, son of Narayan Debnath, resident of villageKalachara, P.O. Bhuratali, P. S. Manu Bazar, Sabroom, District-South
Tripura, Pin-799143.
4. Sri Raju Danda, son of Amarendra Danda, resident of village-South
Sonaichari, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura, Pin-799155.
5. Sri Biswajit Sen, son of Manik Sen, resident of village-Debdaru,
P.O. Debdaru, District-South Tripura, Pin-799141.
6. Sri Sanjib Banik, son of Late Hrishikesh Banik, resident of villageRabindranagar, P.O. Kanchanpur, P.S. Kanchanpur, District-North
Tripura, Pin-799270.
7. Sri Chinmoy Debnath, son of Ratan Debnath, resident of villageMohanpur, P.O. Majlishpur, P.S. Ranirbazar, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799035.
8.Sri Bhaskar Purakayastha, son of Bhabatosh Purakayastha, resident of
village & P.O. Jogendranagar, Near Vidyasagar Girls School, P.S. East
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799010.
9.Sri Kajal Paul, son of Badal Paul, resident of village & P.O.
Lembucharra, P.S. Kamalpur, District-Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799287.
10.Sri Protim Kumar Sinha, son of Krishna Kumar Sinha, resident of
village-West Kanchanbari, P.O. & P.S. Kanchanbari,
District-Unokoti Tripura, Pin-799228.
---Respondents.
WA 460 OF 2020
1. Sri Rajib Roy, son of Sri Priyalal Roy, resident of village-Santirbazar,
P.O. & P.S. Santirbazar, District-South Tripura, Pin-799144.
2. Sri Khokan Das, son of Late Tarani Das, resident of village-Sapmara,
P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura.
--- Appellants.
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary,
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura,
Having his office at Pandit Nehru Complex, Gorkhabasti, PO-Kujaban,
PS-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura.
2. The Director of Health Services, Directorate of Health Services,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gorkhabasti, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West
Tripura.
3. Sri Milan Sukla Das, son of Sri Asit Mohan Sukla Das, resident of
village-East Bagafa, Santirbazar, District-South Tripura, Pin-799144.
4. Sri Sujit Das, son of Sri Subal Das, resident of village-East Bagafa,
Santirbazar, District-South Tripura, Pin-799144.
5. Sri Dhiman Das, son of Sri Dhirendra Chandra Das, resident of villageKalitilla, P.O. & P.S. Teliamura, District-Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205.
6. Sri Tanup Sukla Das, son of Sri Babul Sukladas, resident of village &
P.O. Maiganga, P.S. Teliamura, District-Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205.
7. Sri Bishnu Debnath, son of Narayan Debnath, resident of villageKalachara, P.O. Bhuratali, P.S. Manu Bazar, Sabroom, District-South
Tripura, Pin-799143.
8. Sri Raju Danda, son of Amarendra Danda, resident of village-South
Sonaichari, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura, Pin-799155.
9.Sri Biswajit Sen, son of Manik Sen, resident of village-Debdaru, P.O.
Debdaru, Disrtrict-South Tripura, Pin-799141.
10. Sri Sanjib Banik, son of Late Hrishikesh Banik, resident of villageRabindranagar, P.O. Kanchanpur,P.S. Kanchanpur, District-North Tripura,
Pin-799270.
11. Sri Chinmoy Denmath, son of Ratan Debnath, resident of villageMohanpur, P.O. Majlishpur, P.S. Ranirbazar, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799035.
12. Sri Bhaskar Purakayastha, son of Bhabatosh Purakayastha, resident
of village & P.O. Jogendranagar, Near Vidyasagar Girls School, P.S. East
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799010.
13. Sri Kajal Paul, son of Badal Paul, resident of village & P.O.
Lembucharra, P.S. Kamalpur, District-Dhalai Tripura, Pin-799287.
14.Sri Protim Kumar Sinha, son of Krishna Kumar Sinha, resident of
village-West Kanchanbari, P.O. & P.S. Kanchanbari, District-Unokoti
Tripura, Pin-799228.
---Respondents.
WP(C) 736 OF 2022
Dipankar Saha Roy, s/o Late Dipak Ranjan Saha Roy,
Village-Subhashnagar, East Pratapgarh, Jagatpalli Road, Near Manasabari,
Agartala, West Tripura, Age-31 years.
--- Petitioner.
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Principal
Secretary/Commissioner, Department of Secondary Education, Govt. of
Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Khejurbagan, P.S. New Capital
Complex, Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Secretary, Dept. of GA(AR), Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Khejurbagan, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3. The Director, Department of Secondary Education, Govt. of Tripura,
Siksha Sadan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001.
4. The Director, Department of Elementary Education, Govt. of Tripura,
Siksha Sadan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001.
5. The Member Secretary, Teacher’s Recruitment Board, Tripura, O/o
the Director of School Education, Govt. of Tripura.
---Respondents.
In both the Writ Appeals
For the Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
In the Writ Petition
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. P. Saha, Advocate.
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
: Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 23.09.2022
Date of delivery of
Judgment and order
: 19.12.2022
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment & Order
(Arindam Lodh, J)
The above two intra-court appeals along with the above writ
petition are combined together for disposal by this common judgment on
consent by learned counsels appearing on behalf of the parties to the lis
since identical questions are raised in both the appeals and the writ
petition.
2.
Admittedly, the respondent no.2, i.e. the Director of Health
Services, Government of Tripura issued a notification dated 30.10.2013
for holding walk-in-interview for filling up of various posts under the
Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura. Serial
No.5 of the notification is concerned with the vacancies for the post of
Pharmacist (Allopathy). There were 73 posts, out of which, 7 posts were
reserved for SC category candidates, 53 posts were reserved for ST
category candidates and 13 posts were reserved for UR category
candidates. That apart, the appellants of both the appeals (here-in-after
referred to as the “petitioners”) had challenged the Revised Employment
Policy, 2012 of the Government being arbitrary and illegal in the writ
petitions with a prayer to set aside the selection of private respondents. On
careful reading of the writ petitions, counter affidavits and the impugned
judgment and order dated 15.09.2020, it would reveal that the petitioners
primarily had raised twin constitutional issues, viz. (1) reservation in
excess of ceiling limit of 50% [60 out of 73 posts] and (2) constitutional
validity of Revised Employment Policy, 2012. Learned Single Judge had
dismissed the writ petitions on the ground of estoppel. Learned Single
Judge held that the petitioners knowing-fully well the number of posts,
notified for reserved category candidates, had participated in the selection
process and as such, being unsuccessful they could not challenge the
integrity of the selection process and the selection of the non-official
respondents. Reliance being placed on the following three decisions of the
apex court, which are as under:
(i)
Madanlal & Ors. Vrs. State of J & K & Ors.[ (1995) 3
SCC 486];
(ii)
(ii)Manish Kumar Shahi Vrs. State of Bihar [(2010) 12
SCC 576]; and
(iii)
(iii).Ramesh Chandra Shah & Ors. Vrs. Anil Joshi &
Ors. [(2013) 11 SCC 309]
3.
As regards the writ petition bearing No. WP(C) 736 of 2022,
the petitioner has prayed for quashing & cancelling the notification dated
15.07.2022, issued by the Teachers Recruitment Board, Tripura (for short,
TRBT) with a direction upon the respondents to issue fresh notification for
filling up 230 posts of Graduate Teachers (Class-IX-X) through “Selection
Test for Graduate Teacher (STGT)-2022”. The main grievance of the
petitioner is the recruitment process for filling up 230 numbers of posts of
Post Graduate Teachers (PGT). Particularly, out of 230 posts, 201 nos. of
posts have been kept reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
which apparently is in excess of 50%.
4.
In both the writ appeals, we heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned
senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners and Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. P.
Saha, learned counsel appearing for the State-respondents.
5.
In WP(C) No.736 of 2022, we also heard Mr. P. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner as well as Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl.
G.A. along with Mr. D.Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for the State
respondents.
6.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel questioned the distribution of
marks, which according to him, was not in tandem with the notified
employment policy of the Government. To deal with this issue, we find
that the petitioners failed to allege any malafide or bias against the
members of the selection committee. More so, the members of the
selection committee have not been impleaded in the writ petitions. In view
of this, according to us, this challenge as regards the distribution of marks
is bereft of merit and thus repelled.
7.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel had mainly focused his
challenge against the reservation of posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) on
available vacancies. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners strenuously
argued that under no circumstance Government cannot breach the thumb
rule of ceiling limit of 50% for reserved category candidates in a
recruitment year in view of repeated dictums given by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court on this issue. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel in support of
his submission, has placed reliance on the following case laws:
(i)
R.K. Sabharwal & Ors. Vrs. State of Punjab & Ors. [(1995)
2 SCC 745];
(ii)
Indra Sawhney & Ors. Vrs. Union of India & Ors. [ 1992
Supp(3) SCC 217];
(iii)
M. Nagaraj & Ors. Vrs. Union of India & Ors. [(2006) 8
SCC 212];
8.
(iv)
Tripurari Sharan & Anr. Vrs. Ranjit Kumar Yadav & Ors.
[(2018) 2 SCC 656];and
(v)
Dr. Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil Vrs. Chief Ministers & Ors.
[(2021) 8 SCC 1].
On the other hand, learned G.A. appearing on behalf of the
State-respondents contended that the State had undertaken the process of
selection at different points of time and also undertook the process of
filling up those vacancies in the posts of Pharmacist (Allo) at different
points of time, but, required number of reserved category candidates were
not available during those recruitment years. Taking into account the
submission of learned G.A., this court had sought for clarifications from
the State-respondents on the following questions:
I.
What was the first recruitment year for filling up the
posts of Pharmacists(Allo) and number of posts
advertised during the first recruitment process?
II.
After the first recruitment process, how many new posts
of
Pharmacists(Allo)
were created till the last
Advertisement which has been challenged in this writ
petition?
III. For how many recruitment years, 60 (sixty) posts of
Pharmacists (Allo) identified by the State-respondents,
in reserved categories, are being carried forward?
9.
By way of filing an additional affidavit, the State-respondents
had dealt with all the above questions. After first recruitment, many posts
of Pharmacist (Allopathy) were created under different notifications which
are annexed with the said additional affidavit. In reply to question no.III,
quoted here-in-above, the State-respondents have stated thus:
“In response to the above question it is humbly
stated that from the recruitment year 2011, 60 posts of
Pharmacist identified in reserved categories are being
carry forwarded.”
10.
Clarifying the above reply, learned G.A. iterated that required
number of candidates under reserved categories were not available in the
earlier recruitment years undertaken by the State-respondents at different
times till the recruitment year,2011 and ultimately from the recruitment
year 2011, 60 posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) were identified by way of
applying ‘carry forward’ rule to fill up the backlog vacancies in the
succeeding years of recruitment for the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy).
Learned G.A. further contended that to identify the above 60 nos. of posts,
the State-respondents strictly maintained 100 point roster as contemplated
under the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of
Vacancies in services and Posts) Act, 1991 [for short, the Act, 1991].
Learned G.A. strenuously argued that the State-respondents did not
commit any illegality in carrying forward the backlog vacancies for filling
up the vacant posts as contemplated under Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule
8 of The Tripura Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes Reservation
Rules,1992 as amended up to 3rd Amendment [here-in-after referred to as
the Rules, 1992”].
11.
In WP(C) No.736 of 2022, Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl.
G.A. appearing on behalf of the respondents in consonance with the
counter affidavit has submitted that as per ruling of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of R.K.Sabharwal (supra), some modification has been
made in the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation
Act,1991 vide notification dated 10.03.2005, and post based roster has
been introduced in place of vacancy based roster in the State of Tripura.
Accordingly, the respondents have rationalized 230 posts of Graduate
Teachers (as advised by the TRBT) in accordance with the prevailing law
and nothing has been done beyond the prescription of the Act,1991 and the
Rules thereof.
Re-iterating the same analogy, Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl.
G.A. appearing on behalf of the respondents in WP(C) 736 of 2022
submitted that 201 numbers of posts out of total 230 posts advertised for
recruitment of Graduate Teachers have been kept reserved for Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes candidates to fill up the backlog reserved
vacancies by applying the carry forward rule which could not be filled up
in the previous many years due to non availability of candidates.
12.
We have given our thoughtful considerations to the rival
submissions advanced by the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the
contesting parties. From the rival submissions one aspect is very clear that
numbers of recruitment processes were undertaken by the Staterespondents to fill up the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) for many
recruitment years after the initial, i.e. first recruitment, but, the reserved
vacant posts despite being carried forward could not be filled up due to
non-availability of candidates belonging to reserved category even after
the enactment of the Act, 1991 and the Rules,1992. Such unfilled
vacancies were treated as “backlog vacancies” and were carried forward in
subsequent recruitment years.
13.
The concept of reservation of appointment or posts in favour
of any backward class or citizens, which, in the opinion of the State has
not adequately represented in the services under the State is itself found in
our Constitution itself as enshrined in Clause (4) of Article 16 of the
Constitution of India. Clause (4) of Article 16 of the Constitution reads as
under:
“(4) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from making any
provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of
any backward class of citizens which, in the opinion of the State, is
not adequately represented in the services under the State.”
14.
In view of the above Clause (4) of Article 16 of the
Constitution of India and having found the inadequacy of representation of
backward classes in the services under the State of Tripura, the State
Legislature had enacted the Act, 1991. Thereafter, in exercise of the
powers conferred by Section 12 of the said Act, 1991, the Rules,1992 was
introduced. At its very inception, provision of reservation was made under
Rule 8 of Rules, 1992 in the matter of direct recruitment and departmental
promotion. Relevant extracts of Rule 8 may be reproduced here-in-below:
8.Direct
Recruitment through the Commission/Selection
Committee/ Selection Board/Departmental Promotion Committee
etc.
(1) While making a request to the Commission or to the Selection
Committee/Selection Board for recommending candidates for direct
recruitment the appointing authority shall also furnish information
about the reservation in favour of candidates belonging to the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. The information should
be based on the inspection report of 100 point Roster showing
position up to the year in which recruitment is proposed in respect of
the concerned post or service as may be furnished jointly by the
Director of Welfare for Scheduled Castes and the Director of Welfare
for Scheduled Tribes or their representatives……
(2) ***
***
***
(3) Interview of the candidates shall be arranged separately for
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and others.
(4) ***
***
***
(5) ***
***
***
(6) ***
***
***
(7) ***
***
***
8(a) (a) If it is found that the required number of Scheduled Castes
candidates or Scheduled Tribe candidates for filling up reserved
vacancies are not available the appointing authority may initiate a
proposal for filling up the reserved vacancies by exchange method,
i.e. for filling up the vacancies reserved for Scheduled Tribe
candidates, by available Scheduled Caste candidates or for filling up
the vacancies reserved for Scheduled Caste candidate, by available
Scheduled Tribe candidates, he shall send the proposal to the
Scheduled Castes Welfare Department and to Tribal Welfare
Department for their concurrence. When concurrence is received the
appointing authority will make appointment subject to the condition
that the vacancies will be carried forward.
(b) If candidate belonging to Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes is
not available by exchange method, then the vacancies may be filled
up by deputation/transfer according to concerned Recruitment Rules.
(c) If the required number of candidates are not available even
after further attempt within a recruitment year the reserved
vacancies shall be carried forward to the next recruitment year.”
15.
By the Constitution (Eighty-first Amendment) Act, 2000,
Clause (4-B) was inserted in the Article 16 of the Constitution of India.
The Clause (4-B) reads as under:
“(4-B) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from
considering any unfilled vacancies of a year which are reserved for
being filled up in that year in accordance with any provision for
reservation made under clause (4) or clause (4-A) as a separate class
of vacancies to be filled up in any succeeding year or years and such
class of vacancies shall not be considered together with the vacancies
of the year in which they are being filled up for determining the
ceiling of fifty percent reservation on total number of vacancies of
that year.”
16.
It is pertinent to mention the background in which Eighty-first
Amendment Act was brought in and Clause (4-B) was introduced in the
Constitution of India. In the case of Ram Chandra & Ors. Vrs. State of
U.P. and Ors., reported in 2019 SCC OnLine All 4648, the High Court of
Allahabad has observed thus:
“ 27. The issue with regard to extent of reservation as per clause
(4) of Article 16 of the Constitution of India was subject matter of
several cases in different High Courts as well as before the Supreme
Court of India. In the case of M.R. Balaji v. State of Mysore reported
in AIR 1963 SC 649, it was held that extension of reservation in
public service is a special provision and that should always be less
than 50% of total vacancies. While doing so, it was also made clear
that how much less than 50% would depend on relevant prevailing
circumstances of each cases. Prior to that, in General Manager,
Southern Railways v. Rangachari reported in AIR 1962 SC 36, it was
held that reservation under Article 16 (4) of the Constitution of India
cannot be used for creating monopolies or for unduly or
illegitimately disturbing the legitimate interests of other stakeholders.
A reasonable balance must be struck between the claims of Backward
Classes and claims of other employees as well as the requirement of
efficiency of administration.
28. …..Hon'ble Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney v. Union of
India reported in 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : AIR 1993 SC
477 examined various issues relating to reservation, application of
reservation to Other Backward Classes and the matters incidental
thereto. An important issue before the Court was that “can the extent
of reservation to posts in services under the State under Article 16 (4)
of the Constitution of India or, if permitted under Articles 16 (1) and
16 (4) together, exceed 50% of posts in a cadre or service under the
State or exceed 50% of appointment in a cadre or service in any
particular year and can such extent of reservation be determined
without determining the inadequacy of representation of each class in
different categories and grades of service under the State,” and on
adjudication, the Apex Court held that the rule of 50% ceiling in
grant of reservation laid down in M.R. Balaji v. State of
Mysore (supra) was an appointment rule and not a mere rule of
prudence. It was further held that 50% rule should be applied to each
year, otherwise it may happen that the open competition channel can
be choked for some years and, in the meanwhile, the
candidates/aspirants for unreserved vacancies may cross maximum
age limit and also lose the eligibility required to hold the posts.
***
***
***
30. Looking to the judgment given in the case of Indra
Sawhney v. Union of India (supra), it became impossible for the
Central Government as well as for various State Governments to
satisfy the carry forwarded vacancies of earlier years, if the entire
number of reserved vacancies was to go beyond 50% of the total
vacancies to be filled in that specific year. In result, the several carry
forwarded vacancies of earlier years which remained unfilled stood
lapsed.
31. The Government of India considered this aspect of the matter
on receiving several representations and decided to introduce the
constitutional amendment, i.e., 81st Amendment Act, 2000. By this
Amendment Act, clause (4-B) in Article 16 of the Constitution of
India was inserted. By clause (4-B), “carry forward/unfilled
vacancies of a year” are kept out and excluded from the overall
ceiling limit of 50% of reservation. A fine segregation of backlog
vacancies with the current vacancies is made to have special
recruitment to fill up the unfilled vacancies relating to Scheduled
Castes/Scheduled Tribes by holding special recruitment confining to
these categories. For ready reference, it would also be appropriate to
quote the statement of objects and reasons given to introduce
81st Amendment Act, 2000:—
“THE CONSTITUTION (EIGHTY-FIRST AMENDMENT) ACT,
2000, Assented on 9-6-2000 and came into force on 9-6-2000
Statement of Objects and Reasons, - Prior to 29-8-1997, the
vacancies reserved for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled
Tribes, which could not be filled up by direct recruitment on account
of non-availability of the candidates belonging to the Scheduled
Castes or the Scheduled Tribes, were treated as “Backlog
Vacancies”. These vacancies were treated as a distinct group and
were excluded from the ceiling of fifty per cent reservation. The
Supreme Court of India in its judgment in the Indra
Sawhney v. Union of India held that the number of vacancies to be
filled up on the basis of reservations in a year including carried
forward reservations should in no case exceed the limit of fifty per
cent. As total reservations in a year for the Scheduled Castes, the
Scheduled Tribes and the other Backward Classes combined together
had already reached forty-nine and a half per cent and the total
number of vacancies to be filled up in a year could not exceed fifty
per cent, it became difficult to fill the “Backlog Vacancies” and to
hold Special Recruitment Drives. Therefore, to implement the
judgment of the Supreme Court, an Official Memorandum dated 298-1997 was issued to provide that the fifty per cent limit shall apply
to current as well as “Backlog Vacancies” and for discontinuation of
the Special Recruitment Drive.
2. Due to the adverse effect of the aforesaid order dated 29-81997, various organisations including the Members of Parliament
represented to the central Government for protecting the interest of
the Scheduled castes and the Scheduled Tribes. The Government,
after considering various representations, reviewed the position and
has decided to make amendment in the constitution so that the
unfilled vacancies of a year, which are reserved for being filled up in
that year in accordance with any provision for reservation made
under Clause (4) or Clause (4A) of Article 16 of the Constitution,
shall be considered as a separate class of vacancies to be filled up in
any succeeding year or years and such class of vacancies shall not be
considered together with the vacancies of the year in which they are
being filled up for determining the ceiling of fifty percent, reservation
on total number of vacancies of that year. This amendment in the
Constitution would enable the State to restore the position as was
prevalent before 29-8-1997.
3. The Bill seeks to achieve the aforesaid object.”
32. Clause (4-B) of Article 16 of the Constitution of India, in view
of whatever stated above, is a device to lift the 50% cap on carry
over/backlog vacancies while maintaining ceiling limit of 50% on
current vacancies. So far as determination of current vacancies is
concerned that is on basis of taking into consideration the existing
and anticipating vacancies. However, the backlog/carry forwarded
vacancies which remained unfilled is a part of vacancies of earlier
years vacancies. This is a part of total vacancies determined but
remained unfilled due to non-availability of the candidates belonging
to Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes categories.”
17.
In the case of M. Nagaraj (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court while upholding the constitutional validity of Eighty-first
amendment inserting clause (4-B) in Article 16, clearly held that the
amended provision [4-B) is an enabling provision. In the cases in hand,
we are not concerned with Article 16 (4-A) which relates to reservation in
matters of promotion with consequential seniority, which was also held to
be an enabling provision.
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of R.K.Sabharwal
(supra) made it clear that in the event of non-availability of a reserved
candidate at the roster point, it would be open to the State Government to
carry forward the unfilled reserved vacancies in a just and fair manner.
Now, if we read this clarification together with Article 16(4-B) of the
Constitution, invariably it can be held that Article 16 (4-B) enabled the
State Government to legislate law and make provision as regards the
filling up of “backlog vacancies” in any succeeding year or years by way
of applying carry forward rule which are kept out and excluded from
overall ceiling limit of 50% of reservation.
19.
Under the second amendment Rules,2007 the State’s law-
makers only preferred to limit their exercise to the extent of the insertion
of the words “vacant posts” in clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8 of
Rules,1992, which reads as under:
“(c) If the required number of candidates are not available
even after further attempt within a recruitment year the reserved
[vacant posts] shall be carried forward to the next recruitment
year.”
20.
The language of this provision, according to us, is very clear
and unambiguous. The well-neigh principle is that Rule of “literal
construction” is the safe rule and should be followed unless the language
used is contradictory, ambiguous, or leads really to absurd results. Besides,
legislation is always to be understood first in accordance with its plain
meaning. A plain reading of sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of amended Rules,
2007 makes it clear that despite Clause (4-B) of Article 16 of the
Constitution of India, the State Government had consciously taken a
decision that the unfilled vacancies if not filled up within a recruitment
year, the reserved [vacant posts] shall be carried forward to the next
recruitment year. In other words, the law-makers wanted to limit carry
forward rule to fill up the reserved [vacant posts] i.e. backlog vacancies up
to
the
next
recruitment
year
only
and
not
in
any
further
subsequent/succeeding years. It is clarified that the expression “if the
required vacancies of candidates are not available even after further
attempt within a recruitment year” would mean and connote that the
authorities concerned can exercise the process of recruitment indicating
the unfilled backlog vacancies for a number of times within the same year
i.e. initial/first recruitment year.
21.
On careful reading of sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of the Rules,
1992 as amended in 2007, we are of the considered opinion that while
Article
(4-B)
had
given
wide
discretion
upon
the
State
Government/Legislature for enacting any law to decide the number of year
or years up to which unfilled vacancies will be carried forward, the State
Government under Clause (c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules,1992
legislated that in case the required number of candidates are not available
even after further attempt within a recruitment year, the reserved vacant
posts shall be carried forward to the next recruitment year.
22.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dr. Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil
(supra) it was held [per majority] while interpreting a newly inserted
provision which was enacted to bring it in alignment with existing pari
materia provisions, the Court should not be unmindful of the existing
constitutional provisions. When constitutional amendments introduce new
definition, judicial interpretation has leaned in favour of giving literal
meaning to the terms used which had led to change. The Supreme Court
on numerous occasions has given full literal effect to the terms of the
amendment brought in by the legislature, after understanding the rationale
for the change.
23.
By now, it is well-settled that when a power is given to do a
certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not all
[AIR 1936 PC 253(2)]. In the case of Ramchandra Keshab Adke Vrs.
Govind Joti Chavare, reported in AIR 1975 SC 915, the apex court held
that when a power is given to do certain thing in a certain way, the thing
must be done in that way or not at all and that other methods of
performance are necessarily forbidden. In the instant cases, the advertising
department, i.e. the Director of Health Services, Govt. of Tripura, the
respondent no.2 in both the appeals and the respondent no.5 in the writ
petition, have no power to carry forward backlog vacancies years after
years, which if allowed, will be in direct conflict with the provisions
encrypted in the Rules, 1992. Such unauthorized act of the Director of
Health Services, Government of Tripura in both the appeals and the
Member Secretary, Teacher’s Recruitment Board, Tripura, Office of the
School Education, Govt. of Tripura, in the writ petition, had given undue
advantage to the reserved category of candidates which offends the
equality clause in the matter of appointment as enshrined under Article 16
of the Constitution of India. The action of the official respondents invites
inequality amongst the equals. The official respondents ought to have
taken into account that relevant provision under Clause (c) of sub-rule (8)
of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 clearly provides carry forward rule to fill up
the backlog vacancies only limited up to the next recruitment year as
stated above in para 20 of this judgment. Thus, by way of by-passing the
mandatory provision of sub-rule(c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of SC & ST
Rules, 1992, the official respondents have committed a vital mistake in
overlooking statutory dictum as provided therein. The State-respondents
ought not have violated the statutory provisions. It is well settled that there
is no estoppel against law or statute. We have noticed, in the instant cases,
statutory violation ought to have subsisting since inception, i.e., since the
date of publication of the employment notification for filling up the
vacancies in the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) under the Directorate of
Health Services.
24.
In our considered view, since the official respondents acted
contrary to law and in contravention of the Rules,1992 (as amended in
2007), they had violated the statutory provisions, and in that case, the
respondents are prohibited to take the plea of estoppels to defend such
unlawful act. Clause(c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules,1992 is such
provision which cannot be waived or dispensed with on the ground of
estoppel and if such violation is permitted, then, it would ultimately
tantamount to repeal the provision which is inserted in the statutory rule
with a view to uphold constitutional ethos. Doctrine of estoppel is founded
on the principles of equity and the issues of constitutional validity cannot
be thwarted, by applying the doctrine of estoppel. Bearing in mind the
aforesaid principle, we are unable to agree with the decision of learned
Single Judge that the challenge made by the petitioners suffers from the
doctrine of estoppel.
25.
In the above conspectus, the conclusion is inevitable that the
official respondents have breached the mandatory provision embodied in
Clause(c) of sub-rule (s) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 (Second
amendment,2007) in following the carry forward rule to fill up the unfilled
vacancies in the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) from reserved category of
candidates in succeeding recruitment years including the current
recruitment under employment notification dated 30.10.2013, issued by
the Director of Health Services and the notification dated 15.07.2022
issued by the respondent no.3 in the writ petition. It is clearly held under
Clause(c) of sub-rule(8) of Rule 8 of SC & ST Rules, 1992 that unfilled
reserved backlog vacancies shall be carried forward only after the first
recruitment year in any posts and not in the succeeding years.
26.
Under Clause(c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992
the State is barred to apply carry forward rule to clear backlog vacancies of
reserved category candidates beyond next recruitment year. We make it
clear that “next recruitment year” means the year followed by the first
recruitment process in a particular year. As for example, a department
issues an employment notification in the year 2021 for filling up of 100
posts in a particular category. For this purpose, 50% have been kept
reserved for reserved category candidates as per the State’s roster. After
completion of the said selection process, the department finds only 30
candidates eligible for filling up the said posts identified for reserved
category candidates. Remaining 20 (twenty) unfilled posts, if kept vacant,
these will be treated as “backlog vacancies”. If the required numbers of
candidates are not available, then, the authorities concerned may make
further attempts to fill up the unfilled vacancies within the same year i.e.
initial/first recruitment year. Now, suppose, in the year 2023, Govt. has
created another 150 posts of the same category. Out of these 150 posts,
50% posts will be kept reserved for reserved category candidates and
further, 20 unfilled vacancies of 2021 will be added to determine the total
vacancies meant for reserved category candidates and it would be 75 +20
= 95 that is, 95 posts which will be kept reserved because it will be the
next recruitment year i.e. 2nd recruitment year followed by the first
recruitment year 2021. Again, suppose, out of 95 posts the department
may find 80 candidates suitable for appointment, which means that 15
vacancies belonging to reserved category have not been filled up.
Thereafter, the department again has issued fresh employment notification
in the year 2025 for filling up 50 vacancies of the same category of posts.
The department as usual will notify 50% vacancies for candidates
belonging to unreserved category. But, in that recruitment year, i.e.2025, if
the department tries to fill up the backlog vacancies of 15 which could not
be filled up in the year 2023, by way of following carry forward rule, then,
it will violate the mandatory provision as contemplated in Clause (c) of
sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 as amended by second
amendment, 2007.
27.
In the cases in hand, we find no inconsistency or irrationality
to the legislation brought in by the State Government under sub-Rule 8(c)
of Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007. The State Government was well aware
of the fact that the object and purpose of insertion of Article 16(4-B) by
way of Eighty-first Amendment of the Constitution of India is to enable
the State Governments to legislate its own law considering the socioeconomic scenario of the State as well as overall efficiency in
administration as enshrined in Article 335 of the Constitution of India.
28.
In the opinion of this court, when the State law-makers had
clear intention to apply carry forward rule for clearing the “backlog
vacancies” up to the next recruitment year, that is, after the initial
recruitment
year,
the
court
has
no
jurisdiction
to
read
and
construe/interpret it otherwise which will definitely defeat the object and
purpose of the legislation brought in by the State law-makers under SubRule 8(c) of Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007. We re-iterate that the State
legislature has thought it fair and just to apply the carry forward rule
only up to the next recruitment year and not years any further or
subsequent years.
29.
(emphasis supplied)
It is evident from the counter affidavits and additional counter
affidavits filed by the State-respondents as well as the submission of
learned G.A. that ‘backlog vacancies’ to fill up the post of reserved
category candidates are being carried forward for a number of recruitment
years after introduction of SC & ST Act and the Rules,1992. According to
us, it is inconsistent to and in contravention to Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of
Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007. Therefore, this is a continuous breach of a
statutory provision which escaped the notice of the executives who have
the primary duty to strictly adhere to the legislative decision encrypted in
the statute, and therefore, must be stopped here to prevent further breach
of legislative intent and object of the legislatures to protect the interest of
public in general for whose interest particular legislation was introduced.
The State-respondents have committed a serious error in law to identify
and keep 60 seats for reserved category candidates out of total 73 posts for
filling up the vacant posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy), which is the subject
matter in both the appeals; so also the subject matter of the writ petition
where out of 230 posts of Graduate Teachers, 201 numbers of posts were
kept reserved for SC and ST candidates. We may in the context of the
case, unhesitatingly hold that reservation in excess of 50% ceiling limit is
inconsistent and contrary to law as contemplated under Sub-Rule 8(c) of
Rule 8 of Rules, 1992.
30.
This Court in WP(C) No. 736 of 2022, by way of interim
order asked the respondents to continue the selection process, but, not to
declare the results of the examination. As we have already held in the
above writ appeals that ceiling limit of 50% cannot be breached in any
manner whatsoever, in the succeeding recruitment years beyond the
second year of recruitment followed by the first recruitment year. It is
evident that so many recruitment processes for recruitment of Graduate
Teachers in many subsequent recruitment years since the enactment of
“Rules, 1992” have already been undertaken for filling up reserved vacant
posts i.e. the backlog vacancies of Graduate Teachers by way of applying
the carry forward rule, which exercise, according to us, were carried out in
direct contravention to Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8 of the
Rules,1992. In our considered view, the mistakes already committed by
the State executives in filling up the posts of Graduate Teachers in the
State as aforestated is unrepairable; however, such illegalities committed
by the respondents-authorities during the previous years cannot be
permitted to perpetuate by continuous mistake.
31.
Here, we shall be failing to our solemn duty if we do not stop
the recurrence of such flouting of a statutory provision as enshrined in subrule 8(c) of Rule 8 of the Rules,1992. It is for this reason such illegal
exercise or practice must be stopped here i.e. from the present recruitment
year in question and for all times to come. Excessive reservation beyond
ceiling limit of 50% rule, if not permitted or supported by any law or
statute, is illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory.
32.
It is not unknown to this court that there is dearth of
competent and adequate Pharmacists (Allopathy) in the State of Tripura. If
the posts are allowed to remain vacant for non-availability of eligible
reserved category candidates for the years to come, then, the health
services, which the Government is necessarily to provide to its people, will
badly be affected.
Similarly, complaints against adequate numbers of teachers in
the schools are a regular phenomenon in the State. So, if the vacancies in
the posts of teachers are not filled up, then, the education system of the
State will also be adversely affected when right to education has been
made a fundamental right. Absence of adequate numbers of teachers will
frustrate the object the law-makers wanted to achieve through providing of
qualitative education.
33.
Before we conclude, we must say, that, it is settled
proposition of law that the number of backlog reserved vacancies form a
separate class and is treated as a distinct group and are excluded from the
ceiling limit of 50% reservation. In the instant cases, these backlog
reserved vacancies which are being carried forward in the recruitment year
under notification dated 30.10.2013 in WA No. 458/2020 and WA
No.460/2020, for filling up the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) and the
notification dated 15.07.2022 in WP(C) No.736/2022, for filling up the
posts of Graduate Teachers are illegally kept reserved in contravention to
sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of Rules, 1992. However, the mistake as discussed
in detail in the preceding paragraphs has been committed by the official
respondents in carrying forward the vacant reserved posts for years
together including the notification dated 30.10.2013, for which, according
to us, the appointments already made from this distinct group have not
been disturbed by this court. More so, we are in agreement with Ld. Single
Judge that no malpractice is found to be committed in the selection process
as alleged by the petitioners/appellants for filling up the posts of
Pharmacist (Allopathy), and in this respect, the common judgment and
order dated 15.09.2020 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.134 of 2015 and WP(C) No.135 of 2015 is not interfered with.
34.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, we pass
the following directions in WA No. 458/2020 & in WA No.460/2020:(i)
The action of the official respondents to reserve 60
posts out of 73 posts for filling up the posts of
Pharmacist (Allopathy) in the employment notification
dated 30.10.2013 is illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory
and in contravention to Clause (c) of sub-rule(8) of
Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 being in excess of ceiling
limit of 50% reservation.
(ii)
There shall not be application of carry forward rule in
the matter of appointment/filling up of the posts of
Pharmacist
(Allopathy)
under
the
employment
notification dated 30.10.2013.
(iii)
The posts which are in excess of ceiling limit of 50%
rule, shall be filled up by general category candidates,
if not already filled up by reserved category candidates,
that is, from the candidates belonging to the distinct
group. It is made clear that the appointments already
made in the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) by
applying the carry forward rule under notification dated
30.10.2013 shall not be disturbed. It is further made
clear that if any vacancies under the same notification
still exists and left vacant those shall be filled up by
general category candidates according to their merits
and in that case, the official respondents shall prepare
and publish the merit list of general category
candidates.
(iv)
The official respondents shall not apply the carry
forward rule in any of the future recruitment process
for filling up the vacant posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy).
34.1
Directions in WP(C) 736 of 2022
(i)
The employment notification dated 15.07.2022, issued
by the Member Secretary, Teachers Recruitment
Board, Tripura (TRBT), for filling up the posts of
‘Graduate Teacher’ for the Classes-IX-X, wherein, 201
posts have been kept reserved out of 230 posts, is also
interfered with to the extent that the number of
vacancies carried forward shall not be given effect to.
(ii)
The selection of reserved category candidates must be
limited to 50% for filling up the total number of posts
of ‘Graduate Teacher’ under the notification dated
15.07.2022. The respondents shall prepare the select
list following the said ceiling limit of 50% rule for
reservation.
(iii)
The official respondents shall not apply the carry
forward rule in any of the future recruitment process
for filling up the vacant posts of ‘Graduate Teacher’.
35.
In the light of the above observations and directions, the
impugned common judgment and order, dated 15.09.2020, passed in
WP(C) No. 134 of 2015 and WP(C) No. 135 of 2015 by learned Single
Judge is modified to the extent as indicated above.
36.
As a sequel, both the writ appeals, accordingly, stand
disposed in the aforesaid terms, and the writ petition [W.P.(C) 736 OF
2022] filed by the petitioner, stands allowed and disposed to the extent as
indicated above. In the above conspectus, the interim order dated
09.09.2022, passed in WP(C) No.736 of 2022, shall stand disposed.
JUDGE
sanjay
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review