Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLMC No. 5466 of 2023
(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India)
Pandaba Patra
….
Petitioner
….
Opposite Parties
-versus1. State of Orissa
2. Mr. Atal Choudhuri
3. Vice Chancellor, Veer Surendra
Sai University of Technology,
Burla, Sambalpur
Advocates appear in this case:
For Petitioner
: Mr. Surendra Mohanty, Advocate
For Opposite Parties
: Mr. Sarathi Jyoti Mohanty,
Additional Standing Counsel
(For Opposite Party No.1)
None
(For Opposite Party No.2)
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MISS JUSTICE SAVITRI RATHO
JUDGMENT
Dates of hearing and Judgment : 06.02.2026
Savitri Ratho, J.
This CRLMC has been filed with a prayer to quash
the criminal proceeding pending in the Court of learned SDJM,
Sadar, Sambalpur in GR Case No.3769 of 2019 which arises out of
Burla P.S. Case No.484 of 2019 and order dated 24.08.2023 passed
by the learned JMFC (I) (C.T.), Sambalpur.
BRIEF FACT
2.
The Petitioner is facing trial in a case where charge-sheet
dated 10.06.2020 has been submitted against him for commission
the offences punishable under Sections 500/507/294 of the Indian
Penal Code (in short, the IPC). Cognizance of the offences had been
taken by the learned SDJM, Sambalpur by order dated 02.11.2020.
This order had been challenged by the Petitioner in CRLMC
No.1691 of 2020 in this Court and the same had been disposed of on
02.05.2023 permitting the Petitioner to raise all the pleas urged in
the petition before the learned trial Court at the appropriate stage. It
appears that thereafter the Petitioner filed an application for
discharge which was partly allowed by the learned JMFC (I) (C.T.),
Sambalpur on 24.08.2023 by discharging the Petitioner from the
offences under Sections 294 and 507 of the IPC and holding that
there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the Petitioner for
commission of offence punishable under Section 500 of the IPC.
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER
3.
Mr. Surendra Mohanty, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the allegation made by the informant relates to
circulation of alleged defamatory emails. Such allegation even if
assumed to be true, attract the offence under section 500 IPC, which
is admittedly a non-cognizable offence and section 155 (2) of the
Cr.P.C mandates that no investigation can be conducted against the
accused in an offence that is non-cognizable without express
permission of the learned Magistrate. Therefore, the Investigating
Officer in order to bypass the said legal restriction as enshrined
under Section 155(2) CrPC, deliberately and purposely added
cognizable offence under sections 294 as well as offence under
Section 507 IPC and registered the FIR, even though the original
FIR by the complainant only mentioned alleged offence under
section 500 of IPC, which is a non-cognizable offence. Referring to
Section 199(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, he submits that
the learned Court below could not have taken cognizance of an
offence punishable under Chapter XXI of the IPC. Cognizance could
be taken only on the basis of the complaint of the person aggrieved.
His submission is that as Section 500 as well as Section 507 are
included in Chapter XXI of the Indian Penal Code, and as the
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
learned Court below has already held that the offence under Sections
294 and 507 of the IPC is not made out against the Petitioner, the
trial Court is proceeding against him for the offence under Section
500 of the IPC only, for which the proceeding against the Petitioner
should be quashed. He also submits that having been exonerated in
the departmental proceedings for the same allegation, the criminal
case cannot proceed on the same allegation against the Petitioner. He
submits that in the meanwhile three witnesses have been examined
by the prosecution and the petitioner has also cross examined them
but as the proceedings is not maintainable, it should be quashed. He
relies on the decision in the case of Dr. Minakelana Pani Vrs State
of Odisha, reported in 2022 (11) OLR-104.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF STATE
4.
Mr. S. J. Mohanty, learned Additional Standing Counsel
submits that the petitioner had earlier approached this Court in
CRLMC No. 1691 of 2020, which has been disposed of by this
Court without interfering with the order taking cognizance,
permitting the petitioner to raise all pleas, urged in the present
petition before the learned trial Court at the appropriate stage and
submits that it has not been stated that this plea was raised in the
discharge petition. The application filed for discharge in the Court
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
below has also not been annexed to this petition nor does the
rejection order reveal that the contention that proceeding under
Sections 500 IPC is not maintainable against the Petitioner on the
basis of an FIR, had been raised before the learned trial Court. He
also submits that it is a technical plea as no prejudice is caused to the
Petitioner.
5.
He submits that in view of the admitted position that charge
in the meanwhile has been framed against the Petitioner under
Section 500 of the IPC and three witnesses have been examined and
it being a settled position of law that once charge has been framed
and witnesses have been examined, the accused cannot be
discharged, the CRLMC should be dismissed. He further submits
that in view of the provision of Section 155(4) of the Cr.P.C., the
FIR has been rightly registered as Section 294 of the IPC is a
cognizable offence. Cognizance of offences under Section 294 of the
IPC, which is a cognizable offence, had also been taken along with
offences under Sections 500 and 507 of the IPC. So there is no
reason as to why the proceeding should be quashed, especially when
no prejudice has been claimed by the Petitioner.
6.
He also submits that the decision of this Court in the case
of Dr. Minaketana Pani v. State of Odisha, reported in 2022 (II)
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
OLR-104, no longer holds good in view of the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Karnataka Lokayuktta v.
Chandrasekhar and another : 2026 INSC 31 where this Court has
held that enquiry report in a disciplinary proceeding is not
conclusive of the criminal liability of the delinquent and cannot by
itself be a ground to quash criminal proceedings.
7.
Notice had been issued to the Opposite Party No.2 but in
spite of valid service of notice, no counsel has appeared on his
behalf.
STATUTORY PROVISION
8.
Section 155 and Section 199 of Cr.P.C. are extracted
below;
Section 155 – Information as to non-cognizable cases and
investigation of such cases.—
“(1) When information is given to an officer in
charge of a police station of the commission within
the limits of such station of a non-cognizable offence,
he shall enter or cause to be entered the substance of
the information in a book to be kept by such officer in
such form as the State Government may prescribe in
this behalf, and refer the informant to the Magistrate.
(2) No police officer shall investigate a noncognizable case without the order of a Magistrate
having power to try such case or commit the case for
trial.
(3) Any police officer receiving such order may
exercise the same powers in respect of the
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
investigation (except the power to arrest without
warrant) as an officer in charge of a police station
may exercise in a cognizable case.
(4) Where a case relates to two or more offences
of which at least one is cognizable, the case shall be
deemed to be a cognizable case, notwithstanding that
the other offences are non-cognizable.”
Sec 199- Prosecution for defamation-
“(1) No Court shall take cognizance of an offence
punishable under Chapter XXI of the Indian Penal
Code (45 of 1860) except upon a complaint made by
some
person
aggrieved
by
theoffence;
Provided that where such person is under the age of
eighteen years, or is an idiot or a lunatic, or is from
sickness or infirmity unable to make a complaint, or
is a woman who, according to the local customs and
manners, ought not to be compelled to appear in
public, some other person may, with the leave of the
Court, make a complaint on his or her behalf.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Code,
when any offence falling under Chapter XXI of the
Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860) is alleged to have
been committed against a person who, at the time of
such commission, is the President of India, the VicePresident of India, the Government of a State, the
Administrator of a Union territory or a Minister of
the Union or of a State or of a Union territory, or any
other public servant employed in connection with the
affairs of the Union or of a State in respect of his
conduct in the discharge of his public functions a
Court of Session may take cognizance of such offence,
without the case being committed to it, upon a
complaint in writing made by the Public Prosecutor.
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
(3) Every complaint referred to in Sub-Section (2)
shall set forth the facts which constitute the offence
alleged, the nature of such offence and such other
particulars as are reasonably sufficient to give notice
to the accused of the offence alleged to have been
committed by him.
(4) No complaint under Sub-Section (2) shall be
made by the Public Prosecutor except with the
previous sanction.
(a) of the State Government, in the case of a
person who is or has been the Governor of that State
or a Minister of that Government;
(b)of the State Government, in the case of any
other public servant employed in connection with the
affairs of the State;
(c)of the Central Government, in any other case.
(5) No Court of Session shall take cognizance of an
offence under Sub-Section (2) unless the complaint is
made within six months from the date on which the
offence is alleged to have been committed.
(6) Nothing in this section shall affect the right of the
person against whom the offence is alleged to have
been committed, to make a complaint in respect of
that offence before a Magistrate having jurisdiction
or the power of such Magistrate to take cognizance of
the
offence
upon
such
complaint.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
9.
In view of the admitted position that after framing of
charge three witnesses have been examined and cross-examined by
the Petitioner, I am not inclined to entertain this CRLMC. I am also
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
not inclined to discuss the submissions of the learned counsel and
give any finding, lest it prejudice the Petitioner or the prosecution
during trial
10.
As this Court had earlier permitted the Petitioner to raise all
his grounds at the appropriate stage, if the trial in the case is still
pending, it is open to the Petitioner to raise all contentions during
argument before the trial Court. It goes without saying that the
learned trial Court shall consider his contentions in accordance with
law.
11.
With the above observations, the CRLMC is disposed of.
(Savitri Ratho)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated, the 6th February, 2026/RKS
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RANJAN KUMAR SETHI
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT
Date: 10-Feb-2026 20:41:56
CRLMC No.5466 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review