Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for Judgment : 11.02.2026
Date of Pronouncement
: 07.05.2026
Date of uploading
: 07.05.2026
APHC010657252015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3520]
THURSDAY,THE SEVENTH DAY OF MAY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 6/2015
Between:
1. PALEM CHANDRAYUDU, S/O PEDDA BALAIAH @ BALAIAH, AGED
ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCC: DHABI-CUM-COOLIE, RESIDENT OF
BUSIREDDYPALLE VILLAGE, VEERAPUNAYUNIPALLE MANDAL,
KADAPA DISTRICT, PRESENTLY RESIDING NEAR CHURCH,
MARIAPURAM, KADAPA TOWN AND DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. A VIVEKANANDA REDDY ANOTHER, S/O NARASIMHA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT NOT KNOWN, BUT MAJOR, OWNER OF THE
TIPPER BEARING NO. AP 04 W 6793, RESIDENT OF
ARAVETIPALLE VILLAGE, MACHUNURU POST, PENDLIMARRY
MANDAL, KADAPA DISTICT.
2. SRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
MANAGAR, C/O NEW HERO HONDA SHOW ROOM, MARUTHI
NAGAR, NEAR RTC BUS STAND, KADAPA CITY AND DISTRICT.
(POLICY NO.10003/1/365942, VALID FROM 15.10.2012 TO
14.10.2013.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court against the
judgment and decree passed in O.P.No.98/2014 dt.19-09-2014 on the file of
the court of the MACT-cum-Family Court cum VI Addl Dist Judge, Kadapa
Kadapa Dist.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. D KODANDARAMI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. V HEMANTH KUMAR
2.
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.06 of 2015
JUDGMENT:
Introductory:
The Claimant in M.V.O.P.No.98 of 2014 on the file of the
Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-Family Court-cum-VI Additional District
Judge, Kadapa [for short „the learned MACT”], feeling dissatisfied with the
award and decree dated 19.09.2014 passed therein, where under the claim
against the 1st respondent alone was allowed while dismissing the same
against the 2nd respondent and a compensation of Rs.93,400/- only was
granted as against the claim made for Rs.2,00,000/-, filed the present
appeal, disputing the exoneration of the 2nd respondent from the liability and
the quantum of compensation awarded as inadequate.
2.
1st respondent is owner of the vehicle bearing No.AP 04 W 6793
[hereinafter referred as „the offending vehicle‟] and the 2nd respondent is the
Insurance Company, with which the offending vehicle was insured.
3.
For the sake of convenience, parties will be herein after referred as the
claimant/petitioner and the respondents as and how they are arrayed before
the learned MACT.
Case of the claimant/petitioner:4.
[i]
On 18.03.2013 while the claimant/petitioner was proceeding in
his auto, near Nallavanka situated on Kamalapuram to Ayyavaripalli main
road, the offending vehicle, owned by the 1st respondent came in an opposite
direction in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the said auto,
with the result petitioner and others sustained injuries.
[ii]
The injured including the petitioner were shifted to Government
Hospital, Proddatur. Fracture of right femur and other injuries were noted on
the body of the petitioner.
He has undergone surgery and three rods were
inserted and he stayed in the hospital for (16) days.
Thereafter, taken
treatment in a private hospital at Kadapa under the supervision of orthopedic
surgeon. He was advised to take treatment and medicines. He has spent
Rs.20,000/- towards medicines, treatment, transport, attendant and extra
nourishment, etc.. He lost grip, strength and unable to walk independently,
sit and squat properly, suffering permanent physical and functional disability.
[iii]
Petitioner was attending coolie works and feeding his family.
But due to the accident, he became disabled. Since the driver of the Tipper
is responsible for the accident, the 1st respondent being the owner and the
2nd respondent, with whom the offending vehicle was insured, are liable to
pay just compensation.
5.
The 1st respondent, owner remained ex parte.
Case of the 2nd respondent-Insurance Company:6.
[i]
Negligence of the driver of the auto is the cause for the accident
and there was no negligence on the part of the driver of the offending
vehicle.
[ii]
Compliance of the conditions of the Policy, manner of the
accident, age, occupation, income and disability shall be properly proved.
[iii]
The driver of the auto did not possess valid driving licence.
[iv]
There was overload in the auto and the same has contributed to
lose control and the auto turned turtle. The auto alone was involved in the
accident. There was no negligence on the part of the driver of the
Tipper/offending vehicle.
[v]
The petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
Evidence:7.
[i]
The petitioner was examined as PW.1.
One Dr.C.Sanjevaiah,
who treated the petitioner was examined as PW.2.
[ii]
Petitioner relied on the documents, Ex.A1-FIR, Ex.A2- wound
certificate, Ex.A3 -charge sheet, Ex.A4-disability certificate issued by RIMS
Hospital, Kadapa.
[iii]
Respondent relied on the evidence of RW1-J. Vijaykumar. RW2-
M. Mallikarjuna and Ex.B1- Insurance Policy, Ex.B2- legal notice, Ex.B3-
unserved
postal
cover,
Ex.X1-
letter
from
the
Deputy
Transport
Commissioner, Kadapa, Ex.X2- R.C. extract of vehicle bearing No.AP 04 W
6793. Ex.X3 - Permit history and Ex.X4 - Fitness Certificate.
Findings of the learned MACT:8.
[i]
No direct witnesses are examined for the Insurance Company,
relating to the accident. FIR was registered and charge sheet was also filed
against the driver of the Tipper /offending vehicle.
[ii]
The evidence of PW.1 gets supported by the documents Exs.A1
to A3. Evidence of RW.2 shows that driver of the offending vehicle did not
possess valid driving licence to drive the Tipper, with which it can be
accepted that the owner has entrusted the offending vehicle to the driver,
who did not possess the driving licence. Hence the Insurance Company
cannot be made liable and the petition is liable to be dismissed.
[iii]
In view of the wound certificate and the evidence of PW.2-
Doctor, disability assessed at 15%, treatment undergone by the petitioner,
the petitioner is entitled for compensation of Rs.93,400/- under various heads
viz.,
Rs.18,000/-
towards
pain
and
suffering,
Rs.3,000/-
towards
transportation, Rs.3,000/- towards extra nourishment and Rs.10,000/towards medical expenditure and Rs.59,400/- towards permanent disability.
Arguments in the appeal:
For the claimant/petitioner/appellant :-
9.
[i]
Dismissal of the claim against the 2nd respondent is not correct.
[ii]
The findings as to the absence of driving licence to the driver of
the offending vehicle is not proper.
[iii]
When it is clear that the driving licence No.DLAP 004158552004
was issued in the name of the driver – Suresh Reddy, as issued by the RTA
department.
[iv]
Learned MACT has erred in taking the disability at 15% instead
of 40%, which is mentioned in the Ex.A4-physical disability certificate, issued
by RIMS Hospital, Kadapa.
[v]
The compensation awarded is not just and adequate and require
enhancement.
For the Insurance Company/2nd respondent:10.
[i]
The findings of the learned MACT are correct.
[ii]
Negligence and involvement of offending vehicle is not shown.
[iii]
No interference is necessary.
[iv]
Exoneration of the 2nd respondent from liability is well reasoned
and the Insurance Company has discharged its burden by examining
RW.1 and RW.2 and placing Exs.B1 to B3 and Exs.X1 to X4.
11.
Perused the record. Thoughtful consideration is given to the
arguments advanced by both sides.
12.
The points that arose for determination in this appeal are –
1) Whether exoneration of the 2nd respondent from the liability by the
learned MACT under the impugned order and decree is proper?
2) Whether the compensation of Rs.93,400/- awarded by the learned
MACT under the impugned order and decree dated 19.09.2014 is
just and reasonable in the facts and circumstances? Or require any
modification? If so, on what grounds and to which extent?
3)
What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:13.
It is clear from the law and settled practice that any claim made for
compensation in terms of Motor Vehicles Act, the record maintained by the
Police in discharge of their official findings can be relied on.
In the context
of objections, it is also relevant to note that the appreciation of evidence in
answering the question of fact as to negligence in a motor accident claim and
other relevant aspects learned MACT can rely on the official records
adopting the theory of probability with a holistic approach.
Statutory and Precedential guidance in that regard are as follows:14
(i).
As per Section 176 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the State
Governments are entitled to make rules for the purpose of carrying effect to
the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act.
(ii).
In relation to claims before the learned MACT, Rule 455 to Rule
476 of the A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, vide Chapter No.11 provides
comprehensive guidance. As per Rule 476 of the A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules,
1989, the claims Tribunal shall proceed to award the claim basing on the
registration certificate of the vehicle, Insurance Policy, copy of FIR and Postmortem certificate etc.
15.
As per Rule 476 of the A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, the crime
record can be the basis. The official acts done are presumed to be proper
until a contrary is proved particularly when some statutory recognition is
given to such official records.
16.
It is relevant to note that in view of the summary nature and mode of
enquiry contemplated under Motor Vehicles Act and social welfare nature of
legislation the Tribunal shall have holistic view with reference to facts and
circumstances of each case.
It is sufficient if there is probability.
The
principle of standard of proof, beyond reasonable doubt cannot be applied
while considering a claim seeking compensation for the death or the injury on
account of road accident. The touch stone of the case, the claimants shall
have to establish is preponderance of probability only. The legal position to
this extent is settled and consistent.
17.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Bimla Devi and others Vs. Himachal
Road Transport Corporation1, in para 15 observed as follows:
2009 (13) SCC 530
“15.
In a situation of this nature, the Tribunal has rightly taken a
holistic view of the matter. It was necessary to be borne in mind that
strict proof of an accident caused by a particular bus in a particular
manner may not be possible to be done by the claimants. The claimants
were merely to establish their case on the touchstone of preponderance
of probability. The standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt could not
have been applied. For the said purpose, the High Court should have
taken into consideration the respective stories set forth by both the
parties..”
Reasoning and Findings :Accident - negligence and absence of Driving Licence:-
18.
[i]
Petitioner/PW1 is an eye witness to the accident.
He has
stated in clear terms as to the manner of the accident and negligence as to
the driver of the offending vehicle. There is no oath against oath with regard
to the manner in which the accident was occurred. RW.1 and RW.2 are not
the eye witnesses to the accident. The driver of the offending vehicle is not
examined. Result of the criminal case is not known. Charge sheet was laid
against the driver of the offending vehicle.
[ii]
It is relevant to note that charge sheet is not indicating the
absence of driving licence and the prosecution of the driver under Sections
180 or 181 of MV Act viz., relating to the offences of driving the vehicle
without a driving licence.
[iii]
Evidence of RW.1 and RW.2 is relied on by the Insurance
Company shows that there is no driving licence to the driver of the offending
vehicle. RW.1 is the legal officer in the Insurance Company. He stated that
1st respondent allowed the vehicle in question to be driven by the person, not
possessing effecting driving licence. He has referred the legal notice- Ex.B2,
got issued and absence of reply thereon. It is relevant to note that Ex.B2 is
returned unserved with an endorsement that the addressee is not at the
place shown in the address and he stays in Kadapa.
19.
Whether sending of notice is sufficient to discharge the burden of
proving absence of driving licence is an important question. The notice was
addressed to one A Vivekananda Reddy/1st respondent, owner of the
offending vehicle. No steps are taken to examine either the 1st respondent or
the driver of the offending vehicle by taking summons.
RW.1 during the
cross -examination stated that the Insurance Policy was in force and he has
also admitted that no document is produced to support the contention that the
vehicle is not having permit and the driver is not having valid driving license.
Therefore, the evidence of RW 1 is of no use.
20.
RW 2 is one M. Mallikarjuna Reddy, Stenographer in the office of the
Deputy Commissioner of Transport, Kadapa. His authorization is Exs.X1 and
Ex.X2 is the registration extract and Ex.X3 is the permit history and Ex.X4-is
Fitness Certificate. He stated that one Narravula Suresh Reddy, did not
possess any driving licence as on 18.03.2013. During the cross-examination,
it is elicited that by producing proof of residence, one can obtain licence from
any place. Here it is pertinent to note that absence of registration certificate
to the vehicle gets answered with Ex.X2 and X3 and mechanical defects gets
answered with Ex.X4. As per letter Ex.X1, the authorization copies of
registration certificate etc. are transmitted.
21.
The evidence of RW.2 as to absence of driving licence to one
Narravula Suresh Reddy is oral and he has simply stated that as per records
maintained in their office, said Suresh Reddy did not have any license.
Whether the same is sufficient to discharge of burden is next question. Motor
Vehicles Inspector's report is not called for and no steps are taken to place
the same by the Insurance Company, on whom the burden lies, particularly in
the context of the clamant being third party.
The plea is taken generally that
there is no proper registration certificate, no driving licence to the driver and
no fitness to the vehicle. The Insurance Company failed to prove that there is
no driving licence to the driver of the offending vehicle. Therefore, this Court
finds that the 2nd respondent - Insurance Company is also liable to pay the
compensation. The findings of the learned MACT contra are not sustainable.
Point No.1 is answered against the 2nd respondent and in favour of the
claimant.
Point No.2:Quantum of compensation:
23.
[i]
Ex.A4 is the Disability Certificate issued by the Rajendra
Institute of Medical Sciences, Kadapa on assessment by the Medical Board,
disability is stated at 40% and it is specifically mentioned in the document Ex.A4 that the document is issued for Court purpose.
[ii]
The evidence of Doctor-PW2, who treated the petitioner, is that
he is working as Assistant Professor in Orthopedic Department, RIMS,
Kadapa. He has examined the petitioner on 09.05.2014 and his findings are
as follows:
a) Non-union fracture shaft of right femur with implant in situ.
b) Osteoporosis of the surrounding bones of right hip and knee.
c) Painful and restricted movements of right hip and knee.
d) Unable to stand on the affected limb
e) Unable to squat and cross legged.
f) Antalgic gait present.
[iii]
Based on the above findings he has assessed the disability at
40%. During the cross-examination it is elicited that he did not treated the
petitioner and he has stated that the petitioner received one grievous injury
i.e. fracture shaft of right femur. He has denied the suggestion that the
petitioner is attending his duties as and how he earlier attending. He denied
the suggestion that the injuries are healed and that there is no disability. The
evidence of PW.2 indicates that the petitioner suffered injuries and suffering
permanent disability.
24.
[i]
From the evidence of PW1 as petitioner, it is clear that he has
suffered accident and undergone treatment.
His claim is that he was
attending coolie works. The age of the petitioner is around ‘50’ as per the
wound certificate as per PW2.
[ii]
When the Medical Board has assessed the disability at 40%, the
learned MACT, without any basis, reducing the same to 15% is not
sustainable. If the Tribunal was of the view that the said assessment was not
acceptable, it ought to have got the disability reassessed to have proper
basis. That could have been done even at the instance of the respondent.
Therefore, the disability is accepted at 40% as stated by PW.2 and
evidenced by the disability certificate vide Ex.A4. Income of the petitioner is
taken by the Tribunal at Rs.3,000/-. The Insurance Company contends that
the same is without any basis.
agricultural labour.
The petitioner claimed that he was an
However, upon considering the socio-economic
circumstances of the year of the accident i.e., 2013, Rs.3,000/- is accepted
as monthly income of the petitioner, inclusive of future prospects, for
assessing the compensation. Whereby the loss of income of the petitioner
can be taken at Rs.1200/- per month, which comes to Rs.14,400/- per
annum. Multiplier applicable for the age group of the petitioner is ‘11’.
Whereby the entitlement of the petitioner for compensation under the head of
permanent disability comes to Rs.1,58,400/-.
Precedential Guidance:
25.
A reference to parameters, for quantifying the compensation under
various heads, addressed by the Hon’ble Apex Court is found necessary, to
have standard base in the process of quantifying the compensation, to which
the claimant is entitled.
(i)
With regard to awarding just and reasonable quantum of
compensation, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Baby Sakshi Greola vs.
Manzoor Ahmad Simon and Anr.2, arising out of SLP(c).No.10996 of 2018
on 11.12.2024, considered the scope and powers of the Tribunal in awarding
just and compensation within the meaning of Act, after marshaling entire
case law, more particularly with reference to the earlier observations of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court made in Kajal V. Jagadish Chand and Ors.3,
referred to various heads under which, compensation can be awarded, in
injuries cases vide paragraph No.52, the heads are as follows:Amount (In ₹)
S. No.
Head
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Medicines and Medical Treatment
Loss of Earning Capacity due to Disability
Pain and Suffering
Future Treatment
Attendant Charges
Loss of Amenities of Life
Loss of Future Prospect
Special Education Expenditure
Conveyance and Special Diet
10.
Loss of Marriage Prospects
Total
(ii).
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxxx
_________
Rs. … xxxxxx
_________
Hon’ble Apex Court in Yadava Kumar Vs. Divisional Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited and Anr.,4 vide para No.10, by
referring to Sunil Kumar Vs. Ram Singh Gaud5,as to application of
multiplier method in case of injuries while calculating loss of future earnings,
in para 16 referring
2025 AIAR (Civil) 1
2020 (04) SCC 413
2010(10)SCC 341
2007 (14) SCC 61
to Hardeo Kaur Vs. Rajasthan State Transport
Corporation6, as to fixing of quantum of compensation with liberal approach,
valuing the life and limb of individual in generous scale, in para 17 observed
that :“The High Court and the Tribunal must realize that there is a distinction between
compensation and damage. The expression compensation may include a claim for
damage but compensation is more comprehensive. Normally damages are given
for an injury which is suffered, whereas compensation stands on a slightly higher
footing. It is given for the atonement of injury caused and the intention behind grant
of compensation is to put back the injured party as far as possible in the same
position, as if the injury has not taken place, by way of grant of pecuniary relief.
Thus, in the matter of computation of compensation, the approach will be slightly
more broad based than what is done in the matter of assessment of damages. At
the same time it is true that there cannot be any rigid or mathematical precision in
the matter of determination of compensation.”
(iii).
In Rajkumar Vs. Ajay Kumar and Another7, the Hon’ble Apex
Court summarized principles to be followed in the process of quantifying the
compensation after referring to socio economic and practical aspects from
which, the claimants come and the practical difficulties, the parties may face
in the process of getting disability assessed and getting all certificates from
either the Doctors, who treated, or from the medical boards etc. principles
summarized vide para No.19 are as follows:
“19. We may now summarise the principles discussed above:
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities arising from injuries), do
not result in loss of earning capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with reference to the
whole body of a person, cannot be assumed to be the
percentage of loss of earning capacity. To put it differently, the
1992(2) SCC 567
2011 (1) SCC 343
percentage of loss of earning capacity is not the same as the
percentage of permanent disability (except in a few cases, where
the Tribunal on the basis of evidence, concludes that the
percentage of loss of earning capacity is the same as the
percentage of permanent disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured claimant or who examined
him subsequently to assess the extent of his permanent
disability can give evidence only in regard to the extent of
permanent disability. The loss of earning capacity is something
that will have to be assessed by the Tribunal with reference to
the evidence in entirety.
(iv) The same permanent disability may result in different
percentages of loss of earning capacity in different persons,
depending upon the nature of profession, occupation or job, age,
education and other factors.”
(iv)
In Sidram vs. United India Insurance Company Ltd. and
Anr.8 vide para No.40, the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to
the general
principles relating to compensation in injury cases and assessment of future
loss of earning due to permanent disability by referring to Rajkumar’s case,
and also various heads under which compensation can be awarded to a
victim of a motor vehicle accident.
(v)
In Sidram’s case, reference is made to a case in R.D.
Hattangadi V. Pest Control (India) (P) Ltd.9. From the observations made
therein, it can be understood that while fixing amount of compensation in
cases of accident, it involves some guess work, some hypothetical
consideration, some amount of sympathy linked with the nature of the
2023 (3) SCC 439
1995 (1) SCC 551
disability caused. But, all these elements have to be viewed with objective
standards. In assessing damages, the Court must exclude all considerations
of matter which rest in awarding speculation or fancy, though conjecture to
some extent is inevitable.
26.
In the light of the precedential guidance and in view of the reasons and
evidence referred above, the entitlement of the petitioner/claimant for
reasonable compensation in comparison to the compensation awarded by
the learned MACT is found as follows:
Sl.
Head
No.
1.
Pain and suffering
Granted by the
learned MACT
Rs.18,000/-
Fixed by this
Appellate Court
Rs.20,000/-
Rs.3000/-
Rs.5,000/-
2.
Transportation
3.
Medical
expenditure/treatment and
Attendant charges
Extra nourishment
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.3,000/-
Rs.5,000/-
Loss of income due to
permanent disability
Total:
Rs.59,400/-
Rs.1,58,400/-
Rs.93,400/-
Rs.1,98,400/-
4.
5.
25.
For the reasons aforesaid and in view of the discussion made above,
the point framed is answered in favour of the claimant, concluding that the
claimant is entitled for compensation of Rs.1,98,400/- with interest @6%p.a.
and the order and decree dated 19.09.2014 passed by the learned MACT in
M.V.O.P.No.98 of 2014 require modification accordingly.
Point No.2:
26.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part, as follows:
(i) Compensation awarded by the learned MACT in M.V.O.P.No.98
of 2014 at Rs.93,400/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum is modified and enhanced to Rs.1,98,400/- with interest at
the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till the date of
realization.
(ii) Respondent Nos.1 and 2 are jointly and severally liable.
However, Respondent No.2/ Insurance Company is liable in
view of the Insurance Policy.
(iii) Time for payment/deposit of the balance amount is two (2)
months.
(a) If the petitioner/claimant furnishes the bank account number
within (15) days from today, Respondents No.2/ Insurance
Company shall deposit the amount directly into the bank
account of the petitioner/ claimant and file the necessary proof
before the learned MACT.
(b) If the petitioner/claimant fails to comply with (iii)(a) above,
Respondent No.2/Insurance Company shall deposit the
amount before the learned MACT and the petitioner/claimant is
entitled to withdraw the amount at once on deposit.
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.
27.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the appeal
shall stand closed.
____________________________
A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA, J
Date: 07 .05.2026
Pnr
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.06 of 2015
07.05.2026
Pnr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review