Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC040004382021
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/130/2021
Pakjen Puchung and 2 Ors
S/o Late Tinpu Puchung, village Hiri, PO/PS Mechuka, District Shi Yomi, AP
Taku Puchung
Age:
Occupation :
S/o Late Tajab Puchung
village Hiri
PO/PS Shi Yomi
District Shi Yomi
AP
3: Bojum Puchung
Age:
Occupation :
S/o Late Tatik Puchung
village Hiri
PO/PS Shi Yomi
District Shi Yomi
A
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and 2 Ors
represented by the Secretary, General Administration, Govt. of AP, Itanagar
2:The Additional Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Mechuka
Shi Yomi District
AP
2:
Page No.# 2/7
3:Tame Pupor
Age: 0
Occupation :
S/o Late Cadik Pupor
village Rapun
PO/PS Mechuka
District Shi Yomi
A
Advocate for the Petitioner
: T T Tara, D Loyi,Jumgam Jini,Adam Tatak,Gamken Bam
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
ORDER
Date : 16.02.2026
Heard Mr. J. Jini, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Ms. G.
Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for the State respondents
No.1 and 2 as well as Mr. T. Son, learned counsel for the respondent No.3.
2.
By this application, the petitioners have put to challenge the Kebang
decision/judgment and order dated 22.09.2020, passed by the Board of
Arbitrators, whereby the land dispute between the Pupor Clan and the Puchung
Clan was declined to be interfered with in view of the Kebang decision dated
26.11.2017 and the decision dated 13.12.2017 by the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Mechukha, as the dispute had already been decided, thereby the
land stretch from Yornyi boundary to Sinkom Singme has been declared to be
the land of the Pupor Clan, represented by respondent No. 3.
3.
Briefly put, the case of the petitioners is that the petitioners’ clan has been
in possession of the land called “Tali Arik” since time immemorial without any
disturbance from any corner. In the year 2017, a dispute has arisen between the
Page No.# 3/7
petitioners’ clan and the respondent No. 3’s clan over the said land. Accordingly,
several Kebangs were conducted; however, no conclusive decision was arrived
at. The matter was referred to the Arbitration Board for amicable settlement of
the case. In the arbitration, the parties agreed to undergo a Chicken Liver Test
on the basis of an undertaking, but it is claimed that the said Chicken Liver Test
was not conducted properly and that the same was not in accordance with the
prevalent custom. The Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017 has decided against
the petitioners and the same was upheld by the Additional Deputy
Commissioner vide order dated 13.12.2017 was passed against the petitioners.
Again the matter was referred to arbitration. Accordingly, a civil revision petition,
being CRP. No. 12/2018, was filed before this Court challenging the said decision
to refer the matter again even after it was upheld on appeal. During the
pendency of the civil revision petition, the impugned Kebang decision dated
22.09.2020 was passed; hence, the instant writ petition.
4.
Mr. Jini, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the order dated
22.09.2020, whereby purportedly a Board of Arbitrators was constituted in
respect of the land dispute of Tali Arik, was not in accordance with the
provisions of the Assam Frontier (Administration of Justice) Regulation, 1945, as
the Deputy Commissioner/ADC had not referred the matter to the Arbitrators in
terms of Section 38 of the said Regulation of 1945. The Board of Arbitrators was
constituted by the Chairman of Arbitration without any jurisdiction, as it is only
the Deputy Commissioner/ADC who is mandated under the law to constitute a
Board and refer the matter for arbitration. Mr. Jini, learned counsel, submits that
the impugned Kebang decision/judgment and order dated 22.09.2020 has been
passed ex-parte, that too when the matter was in seisin of the Hon’ble High
Court in CRP No. 12/2018. He therefore submits that the impugned Kebang
Page No.# 4/7
decision/judgment and order by the Board of Arbitrators dated 22.09.2020 may
be set aside and quashed.
5.
Ms. G. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, while
referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of respondent No. 2,
submits that in view of the complaints and counter-complaints from various
quarters during the survey carried out by the Land Management Department for
construction of the road from Tato to Mechukha, the ADC had constituted a
Board of Arbitrators comprising Shri Singlong Koje, Ex-ASM; Shri Tanil Komi, ExASM; and Shri Rapden Koje as members, including the concerned HGB/GBs of
the respective villages as members. Pursuant thereto, the Kebang decision
dated 22.02.2020 was passed by the Board of Arbitrators, whereby it was found
that the disputed land in question had already been settled by the decision of
the ADC, Mechukha, vide order dated 13.12.2017, and accordingly it was held
that a portion of the land stretch from Yornyi boundary to Sinkom Singme had
been decided in favour of the Pupor Clan, as decided earlier. Therefore, there is
no illegality in deciding the matter, that too when the matter had already been
settled by the earlier Kebang decision.
6.
Mr. Son, learned counsel for respondent No. 3, submits that the dispute in
respect of the land had already been settled by the decision dated 13.12.2017,
and the Board of Arbitrators, after consideration of the evidence and records,
decided that there was no reason to interfere with the decision already passed
by the ADC. Accordingly, the land stretch from Yornyi boundary to Sinkom
Singme has been declared in favour of the Pupor Clan represented by
respondent No. 3. He submits that the land claimed by the petitioners and
respondent No. 3 are two different and distinct lands, as the impugned order
does not disclose the land dispute to be Tali Arik; rather, it is shown to be a land
Page No.# 5/7
stretch from Yornyi boundary to Sinkom Singme.
7.
Rejoining the submissions, Mr. Jini, learned counsel for the petitioners,
submits that there is no dispute as regards the land known as Tali Arik, the
stretch of land mentioned in the impugned Kebang decision/judgment and order
dated 22.09.2020 is merely described as a stretch of land without mentioning
the exact name of the land in dispute.
8.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and have perused the material available on record.
9.
The disputed land in respect of Tali Arik appears to have been decided by
the Kebang on 26.11.2017, against which an appeal was preferred, and the
same was upheld by the ADC, Mechukha, vide order dated 13.12.2017.
Thereafter, another appeal was filed before the Deputy Commissioner, Aalo, and
the Deputy Commissioner, Aalo, by order dated 31.01.2018, again remanded the
matter back to the ADC, Mechukha. The said order was put to challenge, and
another order constituting the Board of Arbitrators was also challenged in CRP
No. 12/2018. During the pendency of CRP No. 12/2018, the impugned order
was passed whereby the Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017, as upheld by the
ADC vide order dated 13.12.2017, was declined to be interfered with, and
accordingly, a portion of the land stretch from Yornyi boundary to Sinkom
Singme was decided in favour of the Pupor Clan represented by respondent No.
3.
10. Upon consideration of the provision of law with regard to the constitution
and reference of a Board of Arbitrators as provided under Section 38 of the
Assam Frontier (Administration of Justice) Regulation, 1945 , it appears that such
constitution was not done in accordance with the mandate of the law. However,
Page No.# 6/7
by lapse of time, and upon repeal of the arbitration provisions as prescribed
earlier under the Assam Frontier (Administration of Justice) Regulation, 1945 ,
the dispute is now to be resolved either by way of an appeal or by a fresh suit.
11. The record reveals that the Chairman was appointed by the ADC; however,
the other members of the Board of Arbitrators were appointed by the Chairman
of the Ramo Area land dispute case, which is not in accordance with the
mandate of law. The initial Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017 having been put
to challenge by way of an appeal before the ADC, and the ADC having decided
the same issue by an order dated 13.12.2017, there could not have been any
further appeal by the parties before the Deputy Commissioner. Since no further
appeal could have been maintained before the Deputy Commissioner, the
consequential order referring the matter back to the ADC, who had already
decided the appeal against the Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017, is also not in
accordance with the provisions mandated under the law. The present impugned
order appears to have been passed consequent to a further appeal after the
decision of the ADC dated 13.12.2017. Thus, the Board of Arbitrators could not
have passed the Kebang decision/judgment and order dated 22.09.2020,
upholding Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017, and the order dated 13.12.2017
passed by the ADC, Mechukha, in a purported further appeal which is not
permissible under the law.
12.
In view of above, the Kebang decision/judgment and order dated
22.09.2020 is non-est, as the same has not been passed following due process
of law, particularly Section 38 of the Assam Frontier (Administration of Justice)
Regulation, 1945, in constituting the Board of Arbitrators and reference for
Arbitration. The Kebang decision dated 26.11.2017 and the order of Additional
Deputy Commissioner dated 13.12.2017 shall remain. However, it is provided
Page No.# 7/7
that any party aggrieved, may approach the appropriate forum, as may be
permissible under the law.
13. The writ petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review