The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
08. ln the absence of any cogent material showing that the petitioner had either custody of the Court file or an opportunity to tamper with the same, the allegation of fabrication remains purely speculative. Criminal prosecution cannot be sustained on conjectures or surmises, more so when the alleged act pertains to tampering with Court records, which are ordinarily beyond the control of a{itigant. Further, even if the entire material collected -=? during investigation is taken at its face varu. the essentiar ingredients of the alleged offences are not made :ut against the petitioner. No prima facie case is established to s .ow mens rea, overt acts, or direct involvement of the petitioner in the alleged substitution of documents. Continuation ol the criminal proceedings, in such circumstances, would amor,.rt to abuse of the process of law. The original dispute was Llrely civil and I commercial in nature, arising out of a loan tranr;; rction, and the same has already been amicably resolved betw: :rn the parties. Permitting the prosecution to continue, despite ::tilement and absence of incriminating material, would serve no I seful purpose. Therefore, the continuation of the criminal proc,-.:dings the petitioner-accused amounts to abuse of proo ss against of law and the same are liable to be quashed.
09. Accordingly, this Criminal petition is el:rwed and the proceedings against the petitioner_accused 20 18 on the file of the learned IAdditional in . C.No.3g6 of Judriat First Class Magistrate at Miryalaguda, are hereby quashed. As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applicatic,r ;, if any, shall stand closed SD/- I ,SRINIVASA REDDY AS:; IJTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// To, The Judicial First Class Magistrate at Miryalguda
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
13257 1
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 6543 OF 2024
Between:
Pailla Gopal Reddy S/o. Yadireddy, aged 37 years, Occ: Business, R/o. Plot No.
G-3, Sri Sai- Teja Nivas Apartments, Reddy Colony, Miryalguda, Nalgonda
District. t'
...Petitioner/Accused
AND
1 lV.A lt/lateem S/o M.A.A/ajeed, Aged 60 Years, Occ: Chief tvlinisterial Officer,
Princip.al JFCtVI Court, [t/iryalaguda, Nalgonda District.
...RespondenUDe-facto Complainant
2. State of Telangana, rep. by P.P. High Court at Hyderabad for the State of
Telangana and the State ofAndhra Pradesh.
...Respondent
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated tn
the lt/lemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
quash the proceedings in C.C. No.386 of 2018 on the file of I Addl. Judicial
l/agistrate of First Class at IViryalguda.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2024
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated in
the lVlemorandum of Grounds of Crimrnal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay of all further proceedings including the appearance of the petitioner in C C.
No.386 of 2018 on the file of I Addl. Judicial lvlagistrate of First class at Nrliryalguda,
pending quash petition.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds
of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri P Prabhakar Reddy,
Advocate for the Petitioner-accused and Sri M Ramachandra Reddy, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondent No.2-State and none
appeared for the Respondent No.1 .
The Court made the following: ORDER
lN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STA--:: OF
TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE JtI /VADI
SRIDEVI
CRIMINAL PET TION No.6543 ot 2)i'.4
DATED:
FEBRUARY 2026
Between:
Pailla Gopal Reddy
: r:titioner
AND
tr4.A. Mateem and Another
Ii::spondents
ORDER
This Criminal Petition is filed by the petitic -ter-accused
seeking to quash the proceedings against him in () r.).No.3g6 of
2018 on the file of the learned I Additional Judicra I First Class
Magistrate at Miryalaguda, registered for the olf rnces under
Sections 420, 466, 467, 468 of lndian penal Co, Ie (for short
'rPC').
02. Heard IVIr.P.Prabhakar Reddy, learnecl ;ounsel for
the petitioner-accused and tVlr.M.Ramachandra R,-. idy, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor for State-respor Cent No.2.
Though the notice served upon the respondent No.'l , none
appeared. perused the record.
03. The petitioner committed default in repayment of the
loan, and the outstanding amount due was Rs.43,19,058/- as on
O'l .03.2016. The Bank classified the cash credit account as a
Non-Performing Asset (NPA) on 30.04.2015. On21 .11 .20'1 5, the
petitioner approached the Bank and requested that no coercive
steps be taken. The then Branch Manager granted some time,
upon which the petitioner executed an undertaking letter dated
21 .11.2015, admitting
the liability and assuring payment of
Rs.25,00,000/-. ln furtherance of the same, he issued a post-
dated cheque dated 26.11.2015. The petitioner also requested
the Bank not to present the cheque immediately and sought
release of the property belonging to his wife, assuring that the
dues would be cleared. Believing the representation of the
petitioner, the Bank deferred presentation of the cheque'
However, when the petitioner failed to liquidate the dues, the
succeeding Branch Manager presented the cheque on
25.02.2016 for clearance. The cheque was returned unpaid with
the endorsement "Account Closed." Thereafter, the Bank caused
issuance of a legal notice dated 14'03.2016, which was duly
served on the petitioner. Subsequently, the petitioner filed a
quash petition before this Court in Crl.p.No.100i: of 2017, taking
a plea mainly in respect of another cheque be: rng No.410366,
contending that the said cheque was never pres:.ted and that no
statutory notice had been issued in relation fl.rr: r_,to. When the
Bank applied for certified copies of the record I was noticed, to
its surprise, that the original undertaking letter rl lted 21.11.2015
was missing from the Court file. ln its place, a sir,ilar undertaking
letter dated 27.11.2015 had been filed, corr aining identical
!'ecitals except that the assured amount of Rs. |5,00,000/_ was
altered to Rs.25,0004. The Bank, therefore. i lteges that the
petitioner, in collusion with certain section stalf fabricated and
substituted the document, thereby playing fraud rt lon the Court.
04. Learned counsel for the petitioner sut) .tits that, during
the pendency of the proceedings between fl^r petitioner and
lndian Overseas Bank, the parties entered intr> a sompromise.
Pursuant to the said setilement, the petitione laid the entire
outstanding amount. Consequenfly, the compl. rt filed by the
Bank was withdrawn on 26.06.2019, and the pet:ioner has
been
acquitted. It is further contended that, in :he course of
investigation, none of the witnesses examined b 1he prosecution
stated that the petitioner had taken away or r;ubstituted
original cheque or the undertaking retter from ti :: court
the
record.
According to the learned counsel'
the judicial file is not accessible
to the petitioner, and it is the Court
staff who were in custody of
Therefore'
the record and responsible for its maintenance'
petitioner' without fixing
fastening criminal liability upon the
responsibility on the persons who
is wholly unlustified' Learned
had actual control over the file'
counsel would further submit that
implicated
the petitioner has been falsely
entire material collected during
and that' even if the
investigation is taken at its face
value,theessentialingredientsoftheallegedoffencesarenot
attracted as against the
petitioner'
05. On the other hand' the learned Additional
Prosecutor for the State contended
by
factual aspects to be examined
there are triable issues and
the learned trial Court and it
proceedings against
not a fit case to quash the
is to be decided
this juncture and the matter
and
fledged trial by the trial Court
Public
is
the petitioner at
after conducting full-
prayed to dismiss this Criminal
Petition
06. The material on record discloses
availed a cash credit facility
that the petitioner had
from lndian Overseas Bank and
committeddefaultinrepayment,pursuanttowhichtheloan
Asset lt is not in
was classified as a Non-Performing
account
dispute that the petitioner issued a post-da1t d cheque and
executed an undertaking letter admitting liability .lpon dishonour
of the cheque, statutory proceedings were initia't rj. lt is also an
admitted fact that, during the pendency of the p :oceedings, the
petitioner and the Bank entered into a comprorr r;e, pursuant to
which the petitioner paid the entire outstanding dL::s. Consequent
thereto, the Bank withdrew the complaint on 26 (ri.2019 and the
petitioner was acquitted. Thus, the underlying I nancial dispute
between the parties stands fully settled. The cr- r: of the present
case revolves around the allegation that the ori 3 nal undertaking
letter dated 21 .11.2015 was missing from the Ccr 11 file and that a
similar undertaking letter daled 27 .11 .2015 r ,ith an altered
amount was substituted, thereby constituting raud upon the
Court. However, on a careful perusal of tlr charge sheet
material, this Court finds that none of the prose,r ution witnesses
have categorically stated that the petitioner hzrr access to the
Court record or that he had physically removed
: substituted the
original documents from the judicial file. lt is a natter of record
that Court files are maintained and handled by )ourt staff, and
the petitioner, being a litigant, has no direct or ur r ::stricted access
to the judicial record.
07. lt is to be noted that the petitioner had admitted his
liability and there were correspondence between the petitioner_
accused and the bank and the same was formed as record, which
shows that the petitioner-accused had no dishonest or fraudulent
intention of cheating from the beginning or inception, therefore,
the essential ingredient required to constitute the offence under
Section 420 of IPC is not made out. So also, in order to prove the
forgery or fabrication, the disputed documents i.e. undertakings
dated 21.11 .2015 and 27.112015 are not subjected to scientific
examination through forensic laboratory. The charge sheet does
not disclose about any initiation of departmental inquiry against
the concerned staff member who was in custody of the concerned
court file. All these inconsistencies in the case of the prosecution
goes to the root of the case and creates doubt over the veracity of
the allegations levelled against the petitioner-accused.
08. ln the absence of any cogent material showing that the
petitioner had either custody of the Court file or an opportunity to
tamper with the same, the allegation of fabrication remains purely
speculative. Criminal prosecution cannot be sustained on
conjectures or surmises, more so when the alleged act pertains to
tampering with Court records, which are ordinarily beyond the
control of a{itigant. Further, even if the entire material collected
-=?
during investigation is taken at its face varu. the essentiar
ingredients of the alleged offences are not made :ut against the
petitioner. No prima facie case is established to s .ow mens
rea,
overt acts, or direct involvement of the petitioner in the alleged
substitution of documents. Continuation ol the criminal
proceedings, in such circumstances, would amor,.rt to abuse
of
the process of law. The original dispute was Llrely civil and
I
commercial in nature, arising out of a loan tranr;; rction, and the
same has already been amicably resolved betw: :rn the parties.
Permitting the prosecution to continue, despite ::tilement
and
absence of incriminating material, would serve no I seful purpose.
Therefore, the continuation of the criminal proc,-.:dings
the petitioner-accused amounts to abuse of proo ss
against
of law and
the same are liable to be quashed.
09. Accordingly, this Criminal petition is el:rwed and the
proceedings against the petitioner_accused
20 18 on the file of the learned IAdditional
in . C.No.3g6 of
Judriat First Class
Magistrate at Miryalaguda, are hereby quashed.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applicatic,r ;, if
any, shall
stand closed
SD/- I ,SRINIVASA REDDY
AS:; IJTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Judicial First Class Magistrate at
Miryalguda
2. The Station House Ofricer, tvliryalguda I Town Police Station, Nalgonda
District.
3 Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad
lourl
4 One CC to Sri P Prabhakar Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
5 Two CD Copies
GNK/PSL
Y1o-,
HIGH COURT
DATED: 20t02t2026
-zr-
// t \)iR
ORDER
CRLP.No.6543 of 2024
oo
I
S
..ii €
1i
*
.St, I Cr
ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION
s ,{A
tr"
u
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review