Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010230492019
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(The High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh)
PRINCIPAL SEAT
WP(C) Nos. 7226/2019, 1413/2024, 1428/2024, 1449/2024 &
1462/2024
I.
WP(C) No.7226/2019
Pahumara Anchalik M.E. School,
Represented by its Headmaster Md. Hasen Ali,
S/o Late Kitab Ali,
Village & PO-Pahumara,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781308.
……Petitioner.
-Versus-
signed by
Deepjyoti Digitally
Deepjyoti Sarkar
Date: 2026.02.05
Sarkar
11:33:09 +05'30'
1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department,
Dispur, Guwahati, Pin-781006.
3.
The Secretary to the Government of Assam,
Finance Department, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
4.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati, Pin-781019.
5.
The Bodoland Territorial Council,
Represented by its Principal Secretary,
Kokrajhar, Dist.-Kokrajhar (BTC), Assam.
6.
The Director of Education,
Bodoland Territorial Council, Kokrajhar,
Dist.-Kokrajhar (BTC), Assam.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
7.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Barpeta, Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781301.
8.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Dhubri, Dist.-Dhubri, Assam.
9.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Baksa (BTC), Assam.
10.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Chirang (BTAD), Assam.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. M. Sarma.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Talukdar, SC, Elem. Edu.,
Ms. D.D. Barman, GA, Assam,
Ms. B. Bora, SC, BTC,
Mr. A. Chaliha, SC, Finance.
……Advocates.
II.
WP(C) No.1413/2024
1.
Sateswar Brahma,
Headmaster (Retired), Daimu M.E. School,
S/o Late Atharam Brahma,
Vill-Harigaon, PO-Kalipukhuri,
Dist.-Kokrajhar (BTC), Assam, Pin-783369.
2.
Binod Ch. Brahma,
Grade-IV (Retired), Daimu M.E. School,
S/o Late Saburam Brahma,
Vill-Harigaon, PO-Kalipukhuri,
Dist.-Kokrajhar (BTC), Assam, Pin-783369.
3.
Rajendra Ray,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Debargaon M.E. School,
S/o Late Kameswar Ray,
Vill-Nidani, PO-Bahalpur, Dist.-Dhubri,
Assam, Pin-783376.
4.
Dinabandhu Ray,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
……Advocate.
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Debargaon M.E. School,
S/o Late Lolit Ray,
Vill-Bahalpur, Jogipara Pt. I, PO-Bahalpur,
Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783376.
5.
Rukhila Basumatary,
W/o Late Premlal Narzari,
Headmaster of Karigaon M.E. School,
Vill-Karigaon, PO-Karigaon, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783373.
6.
Ujjhal Kr. Wary,
Assistant Teacher (Retired),
Karigaon M.E. School,
S/o Babendra Wary,
Vill-Dologaon, PO-Garubhasa, Dist.-Chirang,
Assam, Pin-783373.
7.
Maten Rajbongshi,
Assistant Teacher (Retired),
Karigaon M.E. School,
S/o Late Paramananda Roy,
Vill-Kaunia Bhasa (Ujanpara),
PO-Kalipukhuri, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783369.
8.
Aruna Barman,
Assistant Teacher (Hindi) (Retired),
Karigaon M.E. School,
D/o Late Swadhin Ch. Barman,
Vill-Patgaon, PO-Patgaon, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
9.
Amarsing Basumatary,
Assistant Teacher, Karigaon M.E. School,
S/o Late Lakshmiram Basumatary,
Vill-Haltugaon, PO-Haltugaon, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783370.
10.
Ramesh Ch. Mosahary,
Assistant Teacher, Karigaon M.E. School,
S/o Late Saitendra Moshahary,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Vill-Taronguri, PO-Haltugaon, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783370.
11.
Sabita Brahma,
Assistant Teacher (Hindi), Karigaon M.E. School,
D/o Late Budhiram Brahma,
Vill-Ghoramari, PO-Dotma, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783347.
12.
Amarendra Nath Basumatary,
Headmaster (Retired),
Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
S/o Late Dwarendra Nath Basumatary,
Vill-Hasraobari, PO-Ramfalbil, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
13.
Sushila Mushahary,
W/o Late Bongeswar Mushahary,
Assistant Teacher, Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
S/o Late Budhiswar Mushahary,
Vill-Athiabari Tinali, PO-Ramfalbil, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
14.
Rupendra Basumatary,
Assistant Teacher, Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
S/o Late Dhansing Basumatary,
Vill-South Lakshnabari, PO-Ramfalbil,
Dist.-Kokrajhar, Assam, Pin-783346.
15.
Samarendra Basumatary,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
S/o Late Istar Basumatary,
Vill-North Hasraobari, PO-Ramfalbil,
Dist.-Kokrajhar, Assam, Pin-783346.
16.
Sanamati Basumatary,
W/o Late Puranjoy Basumatary,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
Vill-Bhodiaguri, PO-Patgaon, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
17.
Pramode Ch. Basumatary,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
S/o Late Bidsingh Basumatary,
Vill-Saragaon, PO-Ramfalbil, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
18.
Jwngkli Narzary,
W/o Late Bhupen Ch. Narzary,
Grade-IV, Lakshnabari Tinali M.E. School,
S/o Late Kalam Narzary,
Vill-Athiabari Tinali, Po-Ramfalbil, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783346.
19.
Margaret Basumatary,
W/o Headmaster Late Samarendra Basumatary of
Simlaguri M.E. School, Vill-Simlaguri, PO-Dotma,
Dist.-Kokrajhar, Assam, Pin-783347.
20.
Jaymati Barman,
W/o Late Prafulla Kr. Barman,
Assistant Teacher of Simlaguri M.E. School,
S/o Surendra Barman,
Vill-Amtoli, PO-Chithila, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783354.
21.
Sachindra Ray,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Simlaguri M.E. School,
S/o Sunil Ch. Ray,
Vill-Lamapara, PO-Chithila, Dist.-Kokrajhar,
Assam, Pin-783354.
……Petitioners.
-Versus1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department,
Dispur, Guwahati, Pin-781006.
3.
The Secretary to the Government of Assam,
Finance Department, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
4.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati, Pin-781019.
5.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Kokrajhar, Dist.-Kokrajhar, Assam, Pin-781301.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. M. Sarma.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Talukdar, SC, Elem. Edu.,
Ms. D.D. Barman, GA, Assam,
Ms. B. Bora, SC, BTC,
Mr. A. Chaliha, SC, Finance.
……Advocates.
III.
WP(C) No.1428/2024
1.
Shri Hiten Chandra Patgiri,
Headmaster (Retired), Athiabari Girls M.E. School,
S/o Late Purna Ram Patgiri,
Vill-Pub Athiabari, PO-Athiabari,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781377.
2.
Shri Homeswar Das,
Headmaster (Retired), Athiabari Girls M.E. School,
S/o Late Baloram Das,
Vill-Paschim Athiabari, PO-Athiabari,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781377.
3.
Smt. Harmaya Patowary,
Assistant Teacher, Nava Milan High School,
S/o Late Jagat Ch. Patowary,
Village-Katanipara, PO-Athiabari,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781377.
4.
Habib Ullah,
Assistant Teacher, Nava Milan High School,
S/o Late Umar Uddin,
Vill-Sarumanikpur, PO-Sarumanikpur,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781329.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
……Advocate.
5.
Shri Makunda Tahbildar,
Headmaster (Retired), Jaymati Girls M.E. School,
S/o Abhay Charan Kalita,
Vill-Sarumanikpur, PO-Sarumanikpur,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781329.
6.
Md. Chamaun Ali,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Jaymati Girls M.E. School,
S/o Late Sader Ali,
Vill-Sarumanikpur, PO-Sarumanikpur,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781329.
7.
Shri Chakrapani Das,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Jaymati Girls M.E. School,
S/o Late Mehiram Das,
Vill-Sarumanikpur, PO-Sarumanikpur,
Dist.-Baksa BTR, Assam, Pin-781329.
……Petitioners.
-Versus1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department,
Dispur, Guwahati, Pin-781006.
3.
The Secretary to the Government of Assam,
Finance Department, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
4.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati, Pin-781019.
5.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Baksa, Dist.-Baksa, Assam, Pin-781329.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioners
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
:
Mr. M. Sarma.
……Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Talukdar, SC, Elem. Edu.,
Ms. D.D. Barman, GA, Assam,
Mr. A. Chaliha, SC, Finance.
……Advocates.
IV.
WP(C) No.1449/2024
1.
Nagendra Chandra Barman,
Headmaster (Retired), Bamuni Chotogirai M.E. School,
S/o Late Manindra Chandra Barman,
Vill-Chotogirairpar, PO-Barkanda,
Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783348.
2.
Hazrat Ali Sk.,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Bamuni Chotogirai M.E. School,
S/o Late Monser Ali Sk,
Vill-Chotogirairpar, PO-Barkanda,
Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783348.
3.
Jamser Ali Sk,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Bamuni Chotogirai M.E. School,
S/o Late Jalal Uddin Sk,
Vill-Khoraghat, PO-Barkanda, Dist.-Kokrajhar (BTAD),
Assam, Pin-783348.
4.
Jaynab Bibi,
W/o Late Mozibar Rahman,
Assistant Teacher, Bamuni Chotogirai M.E. School,
S/o Late Salimuddin Sk,
Vill-Bargirairpar, PO-Barkanda, Dist.-Dhubri,
Assam, Pin-783348.
5.
Lokesh Ch. Roy,
Headmaster, Jamduar Public M.E. School,
S/o Late Naresh Chandra Roy,
Vill-Tokrabandha, PO-Chirakuta, Dist.-Dhubri,
Assam, Pin-783348.
6.
Mozar Ali,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Jamduar Public M.E. School,
S/o Taripulla Sk,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Vill-Surjya Khata Pt.II, PO-Bilasipara,
Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783348.
7.
Amser Ali,
Headmaster (Retired), Ananda Nagar M.E. School,
S/o Late Shaibulla Sheikh,
Vill-Harkata Muslimpara, PO-Hatipota,
Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783348.
8.
Tapash Chandra Barman,
Assistant Teacher (Retired),
Ananda Nagar M.E. School,
S/o Late Usendra Barman,
Vill-Jamduar Pt.I, PO-Jamduar, Dist.-Dhubri,
Assam, Pin-783348.
……Petitioners.
-Versus1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department,
Dispur, Guwahati, Pin-781006.
3.
The Secretary to the Government of Assam,
Finance Department, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
4.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati, Pin-781019.
5.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Dhubri, Dist.-Dhubri, Assam, Pin-783348.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. M. Sarma.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Talukdar, SC, Elem. Edu.,
Ms. D.D. Barman, GA, Assam,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
……Advocate.
Mr. A. Chaliha, SC, Finance.
……Advocates.
V.
WP(C) No.1462/2024
1.
Shri Rabin Medhi,
Headmaster (Retired), Sanatan Sewashram Girls’ M.E. School,
S/o Late Basudev Medhi,
Vill-Niz Sathisamuka, PO-Sathisamuka,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781355.
2.
Bharat Ch. Nath,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Sanatan Sewashram Girls’ M.E. School,
S/o Late Tarani Nath,
Vill-Kharadhara, PO-Baramchari,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781355.
3.
Parul Talukdar,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Sanatan Sewashram Girls’ M.E. School,
W/o Durgeshwar Kalita,
Vill & PO-Sarumanikpur, Dist.-Baksa,
Assam, Pin-781329.
4.
Nipendra Nath Das,
Headmaster (Retired), Chaibari M.E. School,
S/o Late Bhuban Ch. Das,
Vill-Chaiabari, PO-Pub Rehabari,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
5.
Paban Chandra Das,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Chaibari M.E. School,
S/o Hareshwar Das,
Vill-Chaiabari, PO-Pub Rehabari,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
6.
Kabita Das,
W/o Assistant Teacher Late Bhabesh Ch. Das of
Chaibari M.E. School (since deceased),
Village-Akaya, PO-Akaya, Dist.-Barpeta,
Assam, Pin-781329.
7.
Durgeswar Das,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Chaibari M.E. School,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
S/o Late Sriram Ch. Das, Vill-Chaiabari,
PO-Pub Rehabari, Dist.-Barpeta,
Assam, Pin-781329.
8.
Ajit Kr. Das,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Chaibari M.E. School,
S/o Late Upendra Nath Das,
Vill-Chaiabari, PO-Pub Rehabari,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
9.
Niranjan Medhi,
Assistant Teacher, Chaibari M.E. School,
S/o Late Danoram Medhi,
Vill-Chaiabari, PO-Pub Rehabari,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
10.
Mukunda Ch. Baishya,
Headmaster (Retired), Bhattadev M.E. School,
Bichankuchi, S/o Lohit Baishya,
Vill-Kaljirapara, PO-Nityananda,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
11.
Nilima Devi,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Bhattadev M.E. School,
D/o Haraballav Dev Sarma,
Vill-Maripur Anandapur, PO-Nityananda,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
12.
Niran Ch. Das,
Assistant Teacher, Bhattadev M.E. School,
S/o Uddhab Das,
Vill-Bichankuchi, PO-Nityananda,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
13.
Kripanath Choudhury,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Bhattadev M.E. School,
S/o Bipin Choudhury,
Vill-Bang Gosaipara, PO-Nityananda,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
14.
Giridhar Roy,
Assistant Teacher, Bhattadev M.E. School,
S/o Sukhnaram Roy,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Vill-Bichankuchi, PO-Nityananda,
Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781329.
15.
Harendra Nath Ojakahar,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Swahid Jyotish Choudhury M.E. School,
Pipla, S/o Late Bandhuram Ojakahar,
Vill-Pipla, PO-Nityananda, Dist.-Barpeta,
Assam, Pin-781329.
16.
Rukmini Das,
Assistant Teacher (Retired), Swahid Jyotish Choudhury M.E. School,
Pipla, C/o Baloram Roy,
Vill-Saderi, PO-Saderi, Dist.-Barpeta,
Pin-781325.
……Petitioners.
-Versus1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department,
Dispur, Guwahati, Pin-781006.
3.
The Secretary to the Government of Assam,
Finance Department, Dispur,
Guwahati, Pin-781006.
4.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati, Pin-781019.
5.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Barpeta, Dist.-Barpeta, Assam, Pin-781301.
……Respondents.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. M. Sarma.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. B. Talukdar, SC, Elem. Edu.,
Ms. D.D. Barman, GA, Assam,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
……Advocate.
Mr. A. Chaliha, SC, Finance.
……Advocates.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Date(s) of Hearing
:-
06.11.2025, 11.11.2025,
18.11.2025, 21.11.2025
& 25.11.2025
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
25.11.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment :-
30.01.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment?
:-
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:-
Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. M. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioners.
Also heard Mr. B. Talukdar, learned standing counsel for the
respondents in Elementary Education Department and Ms. B. Bora,
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
learned standing counsel for respondents in Bodoland Territorial
Council (BTC), in WP(C) Nos. 7226/2019, 1413/2024, 1428/2024,
1449/2024 and 1462/2024.
2.
In all these five petitions, under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the petitioners have challenged the order, dated
12.06.2019, passed by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam
with further prayer for issuing direction to the respondentauthorities, more specifically the Director of Elementary Education,
Assam to modify the earlier orders of provincialising the services of
the petitioners and to pass fresh orders, giving effect to the
provincialisation of the services of the petitioners, with effect from
1991, when other similarly situated M.E schools had been brought
under the scheme of provincialisation in terms of the policy
guidelines laid down in notification, dated 05.10.1993, and further
to direct the respondent- authorities to grant all service benefits,
including
pensionary
benefits
available
to
the
petitioners,
consequent to such provincialisation of similarly situated M.E.
Schools, with effect from 1990-91, as may be applicable to the
petitioners in terms of the service conditions, governing their
employment, when the exercise of provincialisation was first carried
out at that time.
3.
Notably, vide impugned order, dated 12.06.2019, the Director
of Elementary Education, Assam has rejected the claim of the
petitioners, for giving effect to the provincialisation of the services of
the petitioners, with effect from 1991 and also to grant all service
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
benefits, including pensionary benefits, available to the petitioners
consequent to such provincialisation of similarly situated M.E.
Schools, with effect from 1990-91.
4.
As the issue involved in these batch of petitions are same and
the relief(s) claimed and the respondents are also almost same,
though however, the petitioners are different, but they are similarly
situated, and as agreed upon, this Court is inclined to dispose of
these batch of petitions by this common judgment and order.
Background facts:5.
The background facts leading to filing of the present five
petitions, being WP(C)/7226/2019, WP(C)/1413/2024, WP(C)/1428/
2024, WP(C)/1449/2024, and WP(C)/1462/2024, are almost the
same and are briefly stated as under:“The
petitioners
in
WP(C)
No.
1413/2024,
WP(C)/1428/2024, WP(C)/1449/2024, WP(C)/1462/2024
and the teachers of petitioner‟s school in WP(C) No.
7226/2019 were qualified to be appointed as Assistant
Teachers and they were selected and appointed as
Assistant Teachers in their respective schools, between
1985-87, which established as venture schools that were
recognized
between
1990-91,
by
the
respondent
authorities. And of the 6 teachers of the petitioner‟s school
in WP(C) No. 7226/2019, three have since been retired and
the
other
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
three
teachers
are
on
the
verge
of
superannuation. In the year 1991, the Government of
Assam took a policy decision to provincialise the services of
both teaching as well as non-teaching staff of 1255
numbers of Middle Schools (500 in the 1st phase & 755 in
the second phase) against the posts created and retained
by the Govt. in 1991. These 1255 numbers of schools
covered those schools which were recognized between
1983 and 1991. The venture schools, where in the present
petitioners were appointed, were also similarly situated on
factual count as per the policy vis-a-vis the 1255 Nos. of
schools identified by the Government for provincialisation,
and therefore, the petitioners expected to have their
services provincialised in terms of the policy decision of the
state.
Then in exercise of powers conferred, under Rule 5
and
of
the
Assam
Elementary
Education
(Provincialisation) Rules, 1977, the respondent-state had
issued a Notification, No. A (I) E.650/93/Pt/6, dated
05.10.1993, notifying detailed guidelines in terms of a
policy
decision,
for
provincialisation
of
venture
LP/ME/MEM/Junior Basic/ Senior Basic/MV Schools of
Assam, which came into force with immediate effect and
also covered the schools where the petitioners were
serving as Assistant Teachers after their respective schools
were duly recognized in the year 1990-91.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Thereafter, the respondent authorities, while giving
effect to the policy decision of provincialisation of venture
schools, in terms of the aforesaid notification, dated
05.10.1993, had adopted 'pick and choose' policy and
carried it out in a slipshod manner and left out schools
where the present petitioners were serving, from the ambit
of provincialisation, inspite fulfillment of all the laid down
criteria/guidelines by the said schools, that has been spelt
out in the said notification.
Thereafter, the District Elementary Education Officers
of different districts submitted detailed list of dropped
schools which were recognized during 1990-91, including
the petitioners' schools, for provincialisation, but the
necessary steps in that direction were not done.
Thereafter, on the demand being made by those
dropped schools, a meeting was held on 10.05.1999,
between the State Government, represented by a group of
Cabinet Ministers and high officials of the Education
Department and the representatives of the 'All Assam
Sikshak Karmachari Samannay Samity', that was the
representative body of those schools that had been left out
in the provincialisation exercise carried out earlier. After
such discussion a Memorandum of Settlement (12 point
charter of demands) was signed.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Then the respondent No.2 by a letter/communication
No.
BS/256/99/35,
dated
22.02.2000
(ANNEXURE-3)
reiterated the commitment of the Education Department to
the Chief Secretary to the Government of Assam for
provincialisation of the venture Schools, including the
petitioners' Schools, and at that time assured payment of
fixed pay and for that purpose necessary steps were
initiated for inspection and verifications etc. of the schools
and the infrastructure etc towards provincialisation of the
schools.
But, the respondent authorities had failed to act in
terms of the Memorandum of Settlement, signed on
10.05.1999, and did not take any steps for provincialisation
of those dropped schools. Being aggrieved, in such inaction
of the respondent authorities, the All Assam ME/MEM
(Recognised
1990-91)
School
Teachers'
Association
representing the petitioners schools along with other
similarly situated schools, numbering about 127 Nos. out of
235 Nos. schools left out filed a writ petition, being W.P.
(C)
No.1012/2004,
seeking
provincialisation
of
their
schools. Then this Court, vide order dated 17.2.2004,
(ANNEXURE – 5) had disposed of the said writ petition with
a direction to the Secretary, Education Department to
examine the matter and pass appropriate orders that may
be considered expedient in the given situation for
provincialistion of the schools in question.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Then the office bearers of All Assam ME/MEM
(Recognised
1990-91)
School
Teachers'
Association
submitted a detailed representation before the Respondent
No.2 on 22.03.2004, enclosing necessary particulars of the
schools showing the dates of establishment, permission,
recognition, land of the schools, medium of teaching,
particulars of teaching and non teaching staffs and order of
approval and such other relevant information needed to
facilitate the provincialisation of the schools that had been
arbitrarily
left
out
when
the
initial
exercise
of
provincialisation was carried out in 1990-91.
Then the Under Secretary, Education (Planning)
Department by a letter/communication No. PMA.135/
2004/99, dated 26.03.2004, had directed the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam to furnish a detailed report
along with information about the reasons for non
submission of proposal for provincialisation of these 127
Nos. of schools along with the 1255 numbers of schools,
during the year 1990, and as to whether the 127 numbers
of schools fulfilled all the terms and conditions for
provincialisation as per the existing Rules/guidelines etc.
and also requested to furnish specific views under the
existing norms and procedure. And the said 127 numbers
of schools also included the schools where the petitioners
were serving since their appointment.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
The
Director of Elementary Education finally
submitted a report to the Secretary, Education Department
stating inter-alia that Budget provision was made for 1255
numbers of schools and such proposal for provincialisation
of the remaining schools could not be submitted for want
of budget provisions for such provincialisation. The Director
also sought budget provisions to enable provincialisation of
the remaining schools left out of the exercise of
provincialisation already carried out, in terms of notification
dated 05.10.1993.
During the currency of the Assam Venture
Education Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act,
2011, the respondent-authorities had disregarded the legal
rights of the petitioners to have their services provincialised
even under the provisions of the said Act. Thus, between
1993 when the said notification was issued till the Assam
Venture
Education
Institutions
(Provincialisation
of
Services) Act, 2011 (the "Act" for short) was repealed by
judgment and order dated 23.09.2016 passed in W.P. (C)
No.3190/2012, the respondent-authorities failed to address
the bonafide and legitimate claim for provincialisation in
terms of the notification dated 05.10.1993, and thereby
caused serious prejudice to the rightful claim of the
petitioners for having their services provincialised when
their schools were recognised during 1990-91, and
thereafter, when the orders of provincialisation was finally
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
passed in May 2013, three teachers of the petitioner No. 1
school had either retired from service or were on the verge
of retirement.
Then, 43 M.E. Schools, including the schools where
the petitioners were serving, espousing identical and
similar issues, regarding the arbitrary non-inclusion of the
petitioners' schools from the ambit of the exercise already
undertaken by the state for undisclosed reasons, although
such schools fulfilled the criteria laid down by the state
while adopting the policy decision to provincialise all such
Middle Schools in 1990-91, had preferred one writ petition
being WP(C) No. 2432/11. During the pendency of the W.P
(C) No.2432/2011, the respondent-authorities assured the
petitioners that their claim for provincialisation would be
favourably considered subject to the withdrawal of the said
writ
petition. Based on such assurances, W.P (C)
No.2432/2011 was withdrawn before adjudication of the
same on merits.
And finally, the respondent-authorities, acting on their
assurances issued orders, provincialising the services of the
petitioners, under the provisions of the Assam Venture
Educational Institution's (Provincialisation of Services) Act,
2011 as amended against created and sanctioned posts,
vide Annexure-8 colly. But, the said orders provincialising
the services of the petitioners were made with prospective
effect only. As already stated, the schools where the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
petitioner's were appointed at the venture stage were
given, permission, DISE Code and recognition much before
1990-91
when
the
policy
decision
was
taken
to
provincialise 1255 numbers of Middle Schools. In fact, the
schools were established between 1976-79, and therefore,
ought to have been provincialised in 1990-91, after
recognition along with the other 1255 numbers of schools
that were brought within the ambit of provincialisation in
terms of the policy decision of the Government. However,
the authorities left out the M.E. schools where the
petitioner's were serving as teachers for no justifiable
reason necessitating the filing of 2 writ petitions before this
Court, the last being WP (C) 2432/2011. They had been
denied the benefit of provincialisation of their services from
1991, along with other similarly situated M.E schools, that
were provincialised in 1991. Again, with the provincialising
of their services only in 2013, the petitioners have been
denied pension and other retiral benefits as enjoyed by
those teaching staffs, whose services were provincialised at
that point in time between 1990-91. The denial of the
benefit of provincialisation from 1991 onwards must be
construed to be discrimination vis-a-vis those teachers who
had been granted the same benefit as far back as in 1991,
for which the petitioners were equally entitled to in terms
of the policy decision taken by the respondent state.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Due to denial of financial and other consequential
benefits of provincialisation, the Assam Dropped ΜΕ/ΜΕΜ
(1990-91) School Teachers Association had approached the
Supreme Court by filing Writ Petition (Civil) No.651 of
2015, but, the same was withdrawn on the ground of
availability of alternate remedies.
The petitioners then preferred representations on
22.05.2016, and 15.03.2017, agitating the issue regarding
the denial of benefits of provincialisation, with effect from
when
the
petitioners
became
eligible
for
provincialisation and for payment of pensionary benefits.
But, the said representations failed to evoke any response.
Then the petitioners, being left with no option available,
approached this Court by filing writ petition No. W.P.(C)
No. 6742/2018 (Sanatan Sewashram Girls ME School &
Ors. -vs- The State of Assam & Ors.). Then vide order
dated 29.10.2018, this
Court had disposed of the writ
petition by directing the respondent No. 4, to examine the
petitioner's representations and pass a speaking order on
the same within a period of one month and to
communicate the decision to the petitioners. And in
compliance of the said order dated 29.10.2018, passed by
this Court, the respondent No. 4 had passed the impugned
order, dated 12.06.2019 (Annexure- 14) rejecting the claim
of provincialisation of the petitioner w.e.f. 1991, on the
ground that there is no provision for giving consequential
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
service benefit including pensionary benefits, from the year
1991 i.e. from the date of recognition of the school
concerned
under
the
Assam
Venture
Educational
Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011 as
amended in 2012.
That the petitioners are aggrieved by the inaction of
the respondents in communicating their decision in respect
of claims raised by the petitioners, centering around the
grant of the benefit of provincialisation of their services
with effect from 1990-91, when similarly situated ME
schools were provincialised in terms of a policy decision
taken by the Government as well as to grant pensionary
benefits in as much as the effect of provincialising the
services of the petitioners only from 2013, has denied and
deprived pensionary benefit also. They have been singled
out for hostile discrimination for the reason that their
services ought to have been provincialised along with the
1255 numbers of Middle Schools, that came within the
ambit of the policy decision taken by the Government in
1990-91,
being
similarly
situated
judged
on
the
parameters/guidelines laid down for such provincialisation
and the denial, therefore, runs counter to the provisions of
Articles 14, 16, 21 of the Constitution of India.”
6.
The respondent No.4 has filed affidavit-in-opposition denying
the statement and averments made in the petition. It has taken a
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
stand
that
as
per
Assam
Venture
Educational
Institutions
(Provincialization of Services) Act, 2011 as amended in the year
2012, there were no provision for giving consequential service
benefit, including pensionary benefit from the year 1991. It is also
stated that the office had issued the order, under Memo
No.EPD/H/75/2018/102 dated 12/06/2019, in compliance of this
Court‟s order dated 29/10/2018, passed in WP(C) No.6742/2018,
wherein the claim of the petitioners for consequential service
benefits, including pensionary benefit, from the year 1991, was not
considered on the strength of the Assam Venture Educational
Institutions (Provincialization of Services) Act, 2011 as amended
2012 and accordingly rejected. It is also stated that the Assam
Venture Educational Institutions (Provincialization of Services) Act,
2011 as amended in the year 2012, has already been struck down
by this Court vide judgment and order, dated 23/09/2016, passed in
WP(C) No.3190/2012.
7.
The petitioner had filed his reply to the Affidavit-in-opposition,
filed by the respondent No.4, denying the statement and averment
made therein and reaffirmed the statements made in paragraphs 15
to 24 of the writ petition. It is also stated that the services of the
petitioners ought to have been provincialised along with the 1255
numbers of Middle Schools, that came within the ambit of the policy
decision taken by the Government in 1990-91, being similarly
situated to those schools. It is also stated that the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam had, on 24.09.2004, submitted a
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
detailed reply to the query raised by the Under Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Education Department vide letter dated
26.03.2004 (Annexure- 6 to the writ petition), furnishing details of
the remaining 127 numbers of similar schools, who were left out
during the exercise of provincialisation and that an amount of Rs.
1113.29 Lakhs were required to complete the said process.
However, despite this information and request, no action was
undertaken by the respondent authorities, for completion of the
exercise of provincialisation of the schools of the petitioners, which
goes to show that the exercise of provincialisation of the petitioners‟
schools ought to have been carried out with effect from 1990-91,
and also that the petitioners were clearly pursuing their grievances
before the authorities and before the Court, much earlier to their
provincialisation w.e.f. 01.01.2013, under the provision of the Act of
2011, which clearly goes on to prove that the respondent authorities
ought to have given the benefit of provincialisation of the
petitioner's w.e.f. 1990-91, as there is no clear provision in the Act
of 2011 to bar the authorities from giving such benefit. Moreover,
similarly situated schools were granted the benefit from 1990-91,
and thus, differential treatment is meted out to the petitioners,
which is in contravention of the provisions of Article 14, 16 and 21
of the Constitution of India. Further, as is already admitted that the
services of the petitioners were provincialised under the Act of 2011,
hence the aspect of nullifying of the same Act, does not come into
play in light of the above made submissions.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
8.
The respondent No.4 has filed an additional Affidavit-in-
opposition on 30.10.2025, pursuant to the direction issued by this
Court on 09.09.2025, to bring on record by way of an affidavit, with
regard to the claim of the petitioner on the basis of similarly situated
persons having been provincialised, and as the earlier affidavit in
opposition filed by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam
shows no whisper as regards the steps taken pursuant to the letter
dated 26.03.2004, issued by the Under Secretary to the Government
of Assam, Education (Planning) Department to the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam, Kahilipara.
It is stated that in the aforesaid letter dated 26.03.2004, the
Under Secretary to the Government of Assam had asked for detailed
report, along with instruction regarding(i)
Reasons for proposal for non-submission of proposal for
provincialisation of 127 numbers of schools along with 1255
numbers of schools proposed for provincialisation during 1990.
(ii)
Whether the 127 schools fulfilled the terms and conditions for
provincialisation as per the existing Rules / Guidelines and
procedures in force and how many schools are there in the
same
line.
A
detailed
report
indicating
year
wise
reorganization.
(iii)
A detailed particular regarding financial involvement towards
provincialisation of 127 numbers of Μ.Ε./Μ.Ε.Μ schools and
also for remaining schools as mentioned in the (2) above.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
And with regards to the letter dated 26.03.2004, issued by the
Under Secretary to the Government of Assam, Education (Planning)
Department submitted that the office file containing the aforesaid
correspondence is untraceable in the record room and as such it is
not in position to give any comments/ answer thereupon. It is also
stated that with regards the claim of petitioners that similarly
situated persons were provicialised in the year 1991, and they were
deprived for no reason, it is stated that the reason for nonrecommendation of the name of the petitioners/school can be
ascertained only after perusal of relevant records, since the relevant
records is untraceable, therefore, unable to comment thereupon.
It is also
stated
that
the
petitioners‟
services were
provincialized as per Assam Venture Educational Institutions
(Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011 as amended in 2012, and in
the said Act there was no provision for giving consequential benefits
with retrospective effect. The respondent No. 4 further submits that
subsequently, the said Act of 2011 was also struck down by this
Court vide order dated 23.09.2016, passed in WP (C) No.
3190/2012. Further, it is stated that having the Act of 2011 been
struck down, the new Act i.e. the Assam Education (Provincialisation
of Services of Teachers and Re-organisation of Educational
Institutions) Act, 2017, come into force wherein Section 8(2) of the
Act, clearly stated that no one can claim any benefits whatsoever, in
respect of past services rendered by them and hence the petitioners
herein are not entitled for any consequential benefits for their past
services rendered by them.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Submissions of learned counsel for the petitioners :9.
Mr. M. Sarma, the learned counsel for the petitioners, submits
that the petitioners had been serving as teachers since 1985, in the
M.E. Schools, which were recognised between 1990-91. Said schools
fulfilled all the criteria for provincialisation. The state respondents
had carried out an exercise of provincialising 1255 numbers of M.E.
schools in 1991. But, the schools of the petitioners were left out
along with 235 other schools, without just ground. He further
submits that a Memorandum of Settlement was also signed between
the State Government and the representatives of the All Assam
Sikshak
Karmachari
Samannay
Samiti
on
10.05.1999,
for
provincialisation of schools and other related issues. But, the same
also failed to yield any result. Then being aggrieved the petitioners
had preferred one W.P.(C) No. 1012/2004, for provincialisation of
the schools left out/dropped by the state respondents and by an
order dated 17.02.2004, this Court directed the Secretary, Education
Department to examine the issue and to pass appropriate orders for
provincialisation of the schools in question. As the respondents
failed to take any steps the petitioners had again filed one writ
petition, being W.P.(C) No. 2432/2011. However, the same was
withdrawn on the assurances given by the state to favorably
consider their claim for provincialisation.
9.1.
Mr. Sarma further submits that at last the services of the
petitioners were provincialised by orders passed by the Director,
Elementary Education on various dates in 2013. But, in the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
meantime, 3 out of 6 teachers of petitioner Pahumara Anchalik M.E.
School have already superannuated from service. He also submits
that the petitioners are aggrieved by the hostile discrimination
meted out to them, ever since 1991 when the exercise of
provincialisation was carried out covering 1255 numbers of M.E.
Schools, but left out the schools where the petitioners were serving
although these schools were similarly positioned and were entitled
to be covered by the decision taken in this regard.
9.2.
Further submission of Mr. Sarma is that the petitioners have
filed representations for resolving their unattended demands for
which the petitioners had filed another writ petition being W.P.(C)
No. 6742/2018, and the same was disposed of vide order dated
29.10.2018, directing the respondent authorities to consider the
grievances raised by the petitioners and pass appropriate orders.
And thereafter, vide impugned order, dated 12.06.2019, the claim of
the petitioners were rejected on the ground that there is no
provision
for
giving
consequential
service
benefit
including
pensionary benefits from the year 1991, i.e. from the date of
recognition of the school concerned under the Assam Venture
Educational Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011 as
amended in 2012, and as in the meantime the Act of 2011 was
repealed by judgment dated 23.09.2016, passed in W.P.(C) No.
3190/2012.
9.3.
Further, Mr. Sarma has pointed it out that the respondent
authorities, having failed to provincialise the services of the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
petitioners, in terms of the notification dated 05.10.1993, caused
serious prejudice to the petitioners and by rejecting their claim vide
impugned order dated 12.06.2019, the respondent authorities had
further intensified the same. He also pointed out that while similarly
situated schools were provincialised, during the year 1993, with
effect from 1991, the respondent had failed to explain and justify as
to why the petitioners‟ schools were left out and that their right
flows out of the policy decision of respondent authorities on the
year 1993. Mr. Sarma also pointed it out that the reasons assigned
in the impugned order, are arbitrary, unjust and liable to be
interfered with, as it violates the right of the petitioners guaranteed
under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Under such
circumstances, Mr. Sarma has contended to allow this petition.
9.4.
Mr. Sarma has referred following decisions in support of his
submission:(i)
E.P. Royappa vs. State of Tamil Nadu and
Anr., reported in (1974) 4 SCC 3,
(ii)
P.D. Agarwal and Ors. vs. State of U.P. and
Ors., reported in (1987) 3 SCC 622,
(iii)
Commissioner of Income Tax, U.P. vs. M/s
Shah Sadiq and Sons, reported in (1987) 3
SCC 516,
(iv)
Union of India and Ors. vs. Tushar Ranjan
Mohanty and Ors., reported in (1994) 5 SCC
450;
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
(v)
Chairman Railway Board and Ors. vs. C.R.
Rangadhamaiah and Ors., reported in (1997) 6
SCC 623;
(vi)
Thyssen Stahlunion GMBH vs. Steel Authority
of India Ltd., reported in (1999) 9 SCC 334;
(vii)
Hitendra Vishnu Thakur and Ors vs. State of
Maharashtra and Ors., reported in (1994) 4
SCC 602,
(viii) Confederation of Ex-Servicemen Association
and Ors. vs. Union of India and Ors.,
reported in (2006) 8 SCC 399,
(ix)
10.
Subhash H. Pophale vs. Oriental Insurance
Company Limited and its Estate Officer,
reported in (2014) 4 SCC 657.
Per contra, Mr. B. Talukdar, learned standing counsel for the
state respondents, has supported the impugned order, dated
12.06.2019. He submits that the services of the petitioner were
provincialised
under
the
provisions
of
the
Assam
Venture
Educational Institution's (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011
with prospective effect only. Mr. Talukdar also submits that there is
no provision for giving consequential service benefit including
pensionary benefits from the year 1991 i.e. from the date of
recognition of the school concerned, under the Assam Venture
Educational Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011 as
amended in 2012. He also submits that the Act of 2011 was
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
repealed and Assam Education (Provincialisation of Services of
Teachers and Re-organisation of Educational Institutions) Act, 2017,
come into force, wherein Section 8(2) of the Act, clearly stated that
no one can claim any benefits, whatsoever, in respect of past
services rendered by them and hence the petitioners herein are not
entitled for any consequential benefits for their past services
rendered by them.
10.1.
In support of his submission, Mr. Talukdar has referred
following decision:(i) WP(C)/4748/2021 (Assam High School Teachers
Association and Anr. vs. State of Assam and 3
Ors.)
11.
In his reply, Mr. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioners
submits that the case referred by Mr. Talukdar is distinguishable in
fact of the present case and as such the same is not applicable in
the case in hand. Mr. Sarma has also referred following decision of a
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court to contend that similar benefit, as
claimed by the petitioners herein, was granted to the petitioner in
said writ petition.
(i) WP(C)No./6013/2023 (Srimati Nabanita Mandal
vs. State of Assam and 6 Ors.).
Discussion and Analysis:WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
12.
Having heard the submission of learned Advocates of both
the parties, I have carefully gone through the petition and the
documents placed on record and also perused the impugned order,
dated 12.06.2019, (Annexure-14) passed by the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam by which he had rejected the claim of
the petitioners for giving effect to the provincialisation of the
services of the petitioners, with effect from 1991, and also to grant
all service benefits, including pensionary benefits available to the
petitioners, consequent upon such provincialisation of similarly
situated M.E. schools, with effect from 1990-91. Also gone through
the decisions referred by Mr. Sarma, learned counsel for the
petitioners and also by Mr. Talukdar, learned standing counsel for
the respondent authorities.
13.
From the contentions being made in the respective pleadings
of the parties and also from the submissions of learned counsel for
both the parties, following facts and circumstances emerges:(i)
The petitioners have been serving as teachers since
1985, in the M.E. Schools, which were recognised
between 1990-91.
(ii)
Said
schools
fulfilled
all
the
criteria
for
provincialisation.
(iii)
The state respondents had carried out an exercise of
provincialising 1255 numbers of M.E. schools in 1991.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
(iv)
But, the schools of the petitioners were left out, along
with 235 numbers of other schools without just
ground.
(v)
A Memorandum of Settlement was also signed
between
the
State
Government
and
the
representatives of the All Assam Sikshak Karmachari
Samannay Samiti on 10.05.1999, for provincialisation
of schools and other related issues. But, the same also
failed to yield any result.
(vi)
Then being aggrieved, the petitioners had preferred
W.P.(C) No. 1012/2004, for provincialisation of the
schools left out/dropped by the state respondents and
by an order dated 17.02.2004, this Court had directed
the Secretary, Education Department to examine the
issue
and
to
pass
appropriate
orders
for
provincialisation of the schools in question.
(vii)
As the respondents had failed to take any step for
provincialisation of the schools, the petitioners had
again filed one W.P.(C) No. 2432/2011. However, the
same was withdrawn on the assurances given by the
State respondents, to favorably consider their claim for
provincialisation.
(viii)
The services of the petitioners were provincialised by
orders passed by the Director, Elementary Education
on various dates in the year 2013. But, in the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
meantime 3, out of 6 petitioners, have already
superannuated from service.
(ix)
The petitioners are treated with hostile discrimination
ever since 1991, when the exercise of provincialisation
was carried out covering 1255 numbers of M.E.
Schools, but left out the schools where the petitioners
were serving although these schools were similarly
positioned and were entitled to be covered by the
decision taken in this regard.
(x)
The petitioners have filed representations for resolving
their unattended demands and the same failed to
evoke any response, for which the petitioners had filed
another writ petition being W.P.(C) No. 6742/2018
and the same was disposed of vide order dated
29.10.2018, directing the respondent authorities to
consider the grievances raised by the petitioners and
pass appropriate orders.
(xi)
Thereafter, vide impugned order dated 12.06.2019,
the claim of the petitioners were rejected on the
ground
that
there
is
no
provision
for
giving
consequential service benefit including pensionary
benefits from the year 1991, i.e. from the date of
recognition of the school concerned under the Assam
Venture Educational Institutions (Provincialisation of
Services) Act, 2011 as amended in 2012, and as in the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
meantime, the Act of 2011 was repealed vide
judgment dated 23.09.2016, passed in W.P.(C) No.
3190/2012.
(xii)
The right of the petitioners flows out of the policy
decision of respondent authorities in the year 1993.
(xiii)
The reasons assigned in the impugned order are
arbitrary, unjust and liable to be interfered with as it
violates the right of the petitioners guaranteed under
Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
14.
The impugned order, by which the claims of the petitioners
were rejected by the Director, Elementary Education, Assam,
respondent No. 4, is reproduced herein below for ready reference:‚GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION, ASSAM
KAHILIPARA, GUWAHATI-19
ORDER
Perused:-
Perused the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court order
dtd. 29/10/2018 passed in WP(C) No. 6742/2018
Sanatan Sewashram Girls ME School & 5 ors -VsState of Assam & ors, in which Hon'ble Court
directed the respondent No.4 ie the DEE. Assam
shall thereafter examine the petitioner's
representation and pass a speaking order.
Read:-
Read the writ petition submitted by the
petitioners in which they have claimed to give
benefits of provincialisation from the year
1991 i.e. from the year of recognition of their
school instead of 01/01/2013. Also read the
Assam Venture Educational in 2012.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Find:-
As per the Venture Assam Educational
Institutions (Provincialisation of Services)
Act, 2011 as amended in 2012, the proposal for
provincialisation of services of teaching and
non-teaching staff of Recognized UP school
including
the
petitioner's
school
were
submitted by the DEEO concerned along with the
recommendation of the concerned DLSC to this
office and this office sent the same to the
Govt. for sanction of posts. Accordingly, the
Govt. has sanctioned posts and this office
issued provincialisation order.
In
the
Assam
Venture
Educational
Institutions (Provincialisation of Services)
Act, 2011 as amended in 2012 there was no
provision for giving consequential service
benefit including pensionary benefits from the
year 1991 i.e. from the date of recognition of
the school concerned.
Decision:-
In view of the above, the claim of the
petitioners for given consequential service
benefit including pensionary benefit etc. from
the year 1991 cannot be considered as per the
aforesaid Act, hence rejected.
This has been issued in compliance of the
Hon'ble High Court order dtd. 29/10/2018 passed
in WP(C) No.6742/2018.
Sd/- S.K. Bhuyan
Director, Elementary Education, Assam,
Kahilipara, Guwahati-19.‛
15.
Thus, a bare perusal of the impugned order reveals that the
ground for rejection of claims of the petitioners, is that in the Assam
Venture Educational Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act,
2011, as amended in 2012, there was no provision for giving
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
consequential service benefit, including pensionary benefits, from
the year 1991, i.e. from the date of recognition of the school
concerned. The additional ground, that has been taken in the
affidavit in opposition filed by the respondent No. 4, is that the Act
of 2011, was repealed and Assam Education (Provincialisation of
Services
of
Teachers
and
Re-organisation
of
Educational
Institutions) Act, 2017, come into force, and Section 8(2) of the new
Act, clearly stated that no one can claim any benefits, whatsoever,
in respect of past services rendered by them and hence the
petitioners herein are not entitled for any consequential benefits for
their past services rendered by them.
16. But, it is the categorical submission of Mr. Sarma that the right
of the petitioners flows from the policy decision, adopted by the
respondent authorities in the year 1993, based on which similarly
situated
schools,
like
the
schools
of
the
petitioners
were
provincialised. Their right accrued under the old Act i.e. the Assam
Elementary Education (Provincialisation) Act, 1974 and the Assam
Elementary Education (Provincialisation) Rules, 1977, which were
prevailing at the relevant time, while the Act of 2011 and 2017 were
never come into existence. It is also his submission that there is no
retrospective application of Act of 2011 and 2017 and on such
count, the same cannot be applied retrospectively to negate the
claim of the petitioners that arose under the Act 1974 and the Rules
of 1977, which have never been repealed till date.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
17.
In order to appreciate the said submission of Mr. Sarma, this
Court deemed it necessary to peruse the Policy Decision of the year
1993, that has been annexed with the petition as Annexure-1. Said
Policy Decision was notified on 5th of October, 1993, and the same
extracted herein below:‚GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION (ELEMENTARY) DEPARTMENT
ORDERS OF THE GOVERNOR OF ASSAM
NOTIFICATION
Dated Kahilipara, the 5th October 93,
No. A(I)E.650/93/Pt/6. In exercise of the power
under Rules 5 and 7 of the Assam Elementary Education
(Provincialisation) Rules, 1977, the Governor of
Assam is pleased to notify the following Rules and
Guidelines and policy decision for provincialisation
of the Venture LP/ME/MEM/Junior Basic/Senior Basic/MV
Schools in the State of Assam which will come into
force with immediate effect.
1. Every inhabitant village shall have at least one
LP School. In case of urban areas this may be
relaxed by the State Govt. on the basis of the
need and population.
2.
In a village having more than two hundred
population, more LP Schools may be taken up at
the distance of 1.1 KM from the existing
School. In case of Junior Basic School, the
distance should be more than 3 KM and the
village should have more than 500 population.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
3. In case of LP and Junior Basic Schools, the
enrolment of students shall not be less than 40
(forty) and in case of ME, MV, Senior Basic,
MEM Schools, the enrolment shall not be less
than 90 (ninety) provided that this may be
relaxed by the State Govt. in suitable cases.
4. The teachers in Venture Schools may be retained
at the time of taking over, subject to
availability of sanctioned post, if they
possess the requisite qualifications prescribed
by the Govt. from time to time and provided
they have the age of recruitment and provided
such teachers have put in at least 2 (two)
years
of
continuous
service,
immediately
preceding the taking over of the School land
also further provided that the prescribe ratio
of students and teachers have been maintained
in the School.
5. An LP School in rural areas should posses at
least 2 bighas of land in one plot and 1 (one)
bigha
in
one
plot
in
urban
area.
An
ME/MEM/MV/Senior Basic School should posses at
least 2 (two) bighas of land in one plot in
urban area. This condition may. However, be
relaxed by the State Govt. in suitable cases.
6.
The DI of Schools shall take the advice of the
Advisory Board in selecting the LP and Junior
Basic Schools fulfilling the above conditions
for taking over and forward the list of the
Director, Elementary Education, Assam who will
get
the
approval
of
the
Govt.
for
provincialisation.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
The District Elementary Education Officer shall
follow the above procedure in cases of
ME/MEM/MV/Senior
Basic
Schools
for
provincialisation.
7.
The
venture
LP/ME/MEM/Junior
Basic/Senior
Basic/MV Schools shall be provincialised on the
basis of need of the community and priority of
establishment of the Schools subject to the
fulfillment of the above norms.
Sd./P.C. Sarmah,
Commissioner & Secretary to the Govt. of Assam,
Education Department.‛
18.
A bare perusal of the Notification dated 5th October, 1993,
indicates that the Governor of Assam was pleased to notify the aforesaid
Rules and Guidelines and policy decision in exercise of the power
conferred under Rules 5 and 7 of the Assam Elementary Education
(Provincialisation) Rules, 1977.
19.
From the additional affidavit, filed by the respondent No.4, it
appears that on 26.03.2004, the Under Secretary to the Government
of Assam, Education (Planning) Department has written a letter to
the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, Kahilipara asking
detail report along with instruction regarding(i)
Reasons
for
non-submission
of
proposal
for
provincialisation of 127 schools along with 1255
schools, proposed for provincialisation during 1990.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
(ii)
Whether the 127 schools fulfilled the terms and
conditions for provincialisation as per the existing
Rules / Guidelines and procedures in force and how
many schools are there in the same line. A detailed
report indicating year wise reorganization.
(iii)
A detailed particular regarding financial involvement
towards provincialisation of 127 Μ.Ε./Μ.Ε.Μ schools
and also for remaining schools as mentioned in the (2)
above.
The aforesaid affidavit also indicates that the office file,
containing the aforesaid correspondence, is untraceable in the
record room and as such it is not in position to give any comments/
answer thereupon. And with regards the claim of petitioners that
similarly situated person were provincialised in the year 1991 and
they were deprived for no reason, no comment for nonrecommendation of the name of the petitioners/school could be
given, since the relevant records is untraceable and the same could
have been ascertained only after perusal of relevant records.
20.
The respondent authorities, thus, could not give any answer
with regards to non-submission of the proposal for provincialisation
of 127 numbers of schools along with 1255 numbers of schools,
proposed for provincialisation during 1990, and as to whether the
127 numbers of schools, which includes the schools of the
petitioners‟, fulfilled the terms and conditions for provincialisation as
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
per the existing Rules / Guidelines and procedures in force and how
many schools are there in the same line.
21.
In absence of pleading of the respondent authorities, the
averments of the petitioners, so made in their petition that they
have been singled out for hostile discrimination, remained uncontroverted. Since the contentions being made by the petitioners
remained un-controverted, the same have to be accepted as
admission. In holding so, this Court derived authority from a
decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Naseem Bano v.
State of U.P., reported in 1993 Supp (4) SCC 46, wherein, it
has been held that when an averment in the petition is not
controverted by the respondent, the High Court should have
proceeded on the basis that the said averments had been admitted
by respondents.
22. Now, coming to the reason assign in the impugned order by
the respondent No.4, for rejection of the claim of the petitioners,
this Court finds that though in the Assam Venture Educational
Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011 as amended in
2012, there was no provision for giving consequential service benefit
including pensionary benefits from the year 1991, i.e. from the date
of recognition of the school concerned, this Court is of the view that
the said ground cannot be accepted in view of the fact that the right
of the petitioners accrued in the year 1993, when the Policy
Decision was adopted by the Government, in exercise of the power
conferred under Rules 5 and 7 of the Assam Elementary Education
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
(Provincialisation) Rules, 1977. Therefore, this Court afraid the
contention of the respondent authorities that in the Act of 2011,
there is no provision for giving consequential service benefit
including pensionary benefits from the year 1991, when the schools
were recognized, fails to withstand the legal scrutiny. It is to be
noted here that in the Act of 2011, there is also no provision to bar
the authorities from giving such benefits. The petitioners have
rightly contended this in their reply affidavit. Moreover, at the
relevant time, the Act of 1974 and the Rules of 1977 were in force
and the policy decision, based upon which the petitioners have
claimed the benefits was formulated by the Governor of Assam in
exercise of the power under Rules 5 and 7 of the Rules of 1977, and
the said Act and Rules are neither repealed nor overruled till date.
On this count also, the impugned order is liable to be interfered
with.
23. Regarding the other ground taken in the affidavit in opposition
filed by the respondent No.4, that the Act of 2011 was repealed and
Assam Education (Provincialisation of Services of Teachers and Reorganisation of Educational Institutions) Act, 2017, come into force,
and Section 8(2) of the new Act, clearly stated that no one can claim
any benefit, whatsoever, in respect of past services rendered by
them and hence the petitioners herein are not entitled for any
consequential benefits for their past services rendered by them, it is
an admitted position that such ground is not there in the impugned
order dated 12.06.2019.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
24.
It is well settled in a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Mohinder Singh Gill and Another vs. The Chief Election
Commissioner, New Delhi and Others, reported in (1978) 1
SCC 405, that the validity of the order must be judged by the
reasons so mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh
reasons in the shape of affidavit or otherwise and an order bad in
the beginning may, by the time it comes to Court on account of a
challenge, get validated by additional grounds later brought out.
25.
Yet, in another decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case
of the Manager, Government Branch Press and Another vs.
D.B. Belliappa, reported in (1979) 1 SCC 477, it is well settled
that the expression „matters relating to employment‟ under Article
16(1) of the Constitution of India is not confined to initial matters
prior to the act of employment, but comprehends all matters in
relation to employment, both prior and subsequent, to the
employment which are incidental to the employment and form part
of the terms and conditions of such employment, such as provisions
as to
salary, increments, leave, gratuity, pension, age
of
superannuation, promotion and even termination of employment. It
is further well established that Articles 14, 15(1) and 16(1) of the
Constitution of India form part of the same constitutional code of
guarantees and supplement each other and if any authority is
needed for the above enunciation, reference may be made to the
observations made in the case of General Manager Southern
Railway vs. Rangachari, reported in (1962) 2 SCR 586.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
26. Thus, the impugned order dated 12.06.2019, so passed by the
respondent No.4, suffers from the vice of arbitrariness and as such,
it is violative of Article 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution. It is worth
mentioning
in
this
context
that
in the
case
of
S.G.
Jaisinghani vs. Union of India [AIR 1967 SC 1427], a
Constitution Bench of Hon‟ble Supreme Court has observed as
under:‚14. … absence of arbitrary power is the first
essential of the rule of law upon which our
whole constitutional system is based. … the
rule of law from this point of view means
that decisions should be made by the
application of known principles and rules
and, in general, such decisions should be
predictable and the citizen should know where
he is. If a decision is taken without any
principle or without any rule it is
unpredictable and such a decision is the
antithesis of a decision taken in accordance
with the rule of law.‛
26.1.
Further, It is to be noted here that while dealing with the
issue of arbitrariness, Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of State
of Orissa v. Mamata Mohanty, reported in (2011) 3 SCC
436, held as under:‚59. The rule of law inhibits arbitrary action and
also makes it liable to be invalidated. Every
action of the State or its instrumentalities
should not only be fair, legitimate and above
board but should be without any affection or
aversion. It should neither be suggestive of
discrimination nor even give an impression of
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
bias, favouritism and nepotism. Procedural
fairness is an implied mandatory requirement
to protect against arbitrary action where
statute confers wide power coupled with wide
discretion on an authority. If the procedure
adopted
by
an
authority
offends
the
fundamental fairness or established ethos or
shocks the conscience, the order stands
vitiated. The decision-making process remains
bad.‛
26.2.
Here in this case, the impugned order, dated 12.06.2019
(Annexure –14) of the petition, is being challenged on account of
the same being arbitrary, under Article 14 of the Constitution of
India. And in that view of the matter, the same has to be tested by
applying the Wednesbury principle, in view of the decision of
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Om Kumar vs. Union of
India, reported in (2001) 2 SCC 386,where in it has been held
as under:‚68. Thus, when administrative action is attacked
as discriminatory under Article 14, the
principle of primary review is for the courts
by applying proportionality. However, where
administrative
action
is
questioned
as
‚arbitrary‛ under Article 14, the principle
of
secondary
review
based
on Wednesbury Principles applies.‛
26.3. However, when administrative action is challenged for being
arbitrary, it only „indirectly‟ violates the right to equality under Article
14. It is to be noted here that arbitrariness was established as a
ground of challenge by Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of E.P.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Royappa (supra), by giving Article 14 an expansive interpretation.
In the said case, it was observed that „from a positivistic point of
view, equality is antithetic to arbitrariness, and where an act is
arbitrary, it is implicit in it that it is unequal both according to
political logic and constitutional law, therefore violating Article 14.‟
26.4.
Therefore, when an administrative action is challenged on
grounds of arbitrariness, the courts play a secondary role in
examining whether the administrators in discharging their primary
role as adjudicators have adhered to the standards laid down in the
Wednesbury test. The courts cannot apply the more intrusive
proportionality test in such cases, limiting their intervention to
judging the reasonableness of the decision-making process on the
basis of the Wednesbury test.
26.5.
Mention to be made here that in the case of Associated
Provincial
Picture
House
Limited
vs.
Corporation, reported in (1947) 2 AII ER 680,
Wednesbury
the United
Kingdom, Court of Appeal held that the action of the administrative
authorities would be declared unconstitutional, if it meets the
following circumstances:1.
Consideration of irrelevant and extraneous factors.
2.
Neglect of relevant factors.
3.
Decision is irrational to a reasonable person and no
reasonable person in their wildest of dream would reach
that particular conclusion.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
26.6.
It is well settled that the impugned order has to be decided
not on its merit, but examine the process of making the same and
as held by Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of TATA Cellular
vs. Union of India, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651, the
Court has to examine (1) whether a decision making authority
exceeded its powers; (2) committed an error of law; (3) committed
a breach of the rules of natural justice; (4) reached a decision which
no reasonable tribunal would have reached, or; (5) abused its
powers.
26.7. In the instant case, the respondent No.4 had committed an
error of law in passing the impugned order by not considering the
relevant facts that has been mentioned in the letter dated
26.03.2004, written by the Under Secretary to the Government of
Assam, Education (Planning) Department to the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam, Kahilipara asking detail report along
with instruction regarding(i)
Reasons
for
non-submission
of
proposal
for
provincialisation of 127 schools along with 1255 schools
proposed for provincialisation during 1990.
(ii)
Whether the 127 schools fulfilled the terms and conditions
for provincialisation as per the existing Rules / Guidelines
and procedures in force and how many schools are there
in the same line. A detailed report indicating year wise
reorganization.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
(iii)
A detailed particular regarding financial involvement
towards provincialisation of 127 Μ.Ε./Μ.Ε.Μ schools and
also for remaining schools as mentioned in the (2) above.
Also, it has failed to take note of the fact that right of the
petitioners have accrued under Rules of 1977 and the Act of 1974,
which are still in force and their claim cannot be rejected taking
resort to the Act of 2011 and 2017, which were enacted
subsequently, and while no retrospective effect of the same are
given by the legislature.
26.8.
Further, it appears that the respondent No.4 has taken into
account irrelevant fact i.e. the Act of 2011 and of 2017 and Section
89(2) of the Act of 2017, while the right of the petitioners‟ accrued
under the Policy Decision adopted by the Government under Rules 5
and 7 of the Assam Elementary Education (Provincialisation) Rules,
1977.
27. This Court has also gone through the decisions referred by Mr.
Sarma, learned Counsel for the petitioners. In the case of Chairman
Railway Board
(supra), a Constitutional Bench of Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has held as under:‚20. It can, therefore, be said that a rule
which operates in futuro so as to govern future
rights of those already in service cannot be
assailed on the ground of retroactivity as
being violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution, but a rule which seeks to reverse
from an anterior date a benefit which has been
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
granted or availed of, e.g., promotion or pay
scale, can be assailed as being violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution to the
extent it operates retrospectively.‛
27.1. In para No. 24, Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held as under:24. In many of these decisions the expressions
‚vested rights‛ or ‚accrued rights‛ have been
used
while
striking
down
the
impugned
provisions which had been given retrospective
operation so as to have an adverse effect in
the matter of promotion, seniority, substantive
appointment, etc., of the employees. The said
expressions have been used in the context of a
right flowing under the relevant rule which was
sought to be altered with effect from an
anterior date and thereby taking away the
benefits available under the rule in force at
that time. It has been held that such an
amendment having retrospective operation which
has the effect of taking away a benefit already
available to the employee under the existing
rule is arbitrary, discriminatory and violative
of the rights guaranteed under Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution. We are unable to hold
that these decisions are not in consonance with
the decisions in Roshan Lal Tandon [AIR 1967 SC
1889 : (1968) 1 SCR 185 : (1968) 1 LLJ 576]
, B.S. Vedera [AIR 1969 SC 118 : (1968) 3 SCR
575 : (1970) 1 LLJ 499] and Raman Lal Keshav
Lal Soni [(1983) 2 SCC 33 : 1983 SCC (L&S) 231
: (1983) 2 SCR 287].‛
27.2. In the case of P.D. Aggarwal (supra), Hon‟ble Supreme
Court has held as under:‚15. The Office Memorandum dated December 7,
1961 introduces quotas for filling up vacancies
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
in the cadre of Assistant Engineers in the
Public Works Department as well as Irrigation
and
Local
Self
Government
Engineering
Departments by providing direct recruitment
through
competitive
examination
to
both
permanent and temporary vacancies of Assistant
Engineers (Civil, Electrical and Mechanical).
It has been provided therein that the quota of
50 per cent of the vacancies in the cadre of
Assistant Engineers in a year will be filled by
direct recruits through competitive examination
as well as it provides 25 per cent of the
permanent posts to be filled up by selection
from amongst temporary Assistant Engineers
recruited
through
the
Commission.
As
a
concession however, it has provided that the
quota of direct recruits through competitive
examination will be 25 per cent instead of 50
per cent as there are large number of temporary
Assistant Engineers from whom the selection can
be made to the vacancies in the permanent posts
of Assistant Engineers by selection. This
memorandum has subsequently been incorporated
in the amended rules of U.P. Service of
Engineers 1969. In Rule 5 of the said Rules
provision has been made for direct recruitment
both in permanent vacancies as well as in
officiating or temporary vacancies on the basis
of competitive examination conducted by the
Public Service Commission and the criteria laid
down is that those who are more meritorious
judged by the result of the examination and
occupy higher place will be recruited to the
permanent
vacancies
whereas
others
less
meritorious judged by their performance in the
competitive examination will be recruited to
the post of officiating or temporary vacancies
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
of Assistant Engineers. It has also been
provided therein that the temporary Assistant
Engineers already recruited in the department
in consultation with the Commission will be
permitted to compete in the examination and if
they can do well in the competitive examination
then they may be appointed in the permanent
posts of Assistant Engineers. This rule if
considered properly will clearly show that
direct recruits against permanent vacancies on
the basis of the competitive examination will
score a march over the Assistant Engineers who
have been appointed substantively in temporary
posts of the cadre and have become member of
the service. They will be deprived of having
their services reckoned from the date of their
substantive appointment to temporary posts for
the purpose of determination of seniority. In
accordance with the provisions of Rule 23 of
the amended rules of 1971 which has been
substituted for the old rules of 1936 seniority
in the service has to be determined by the date
of order of appointment in a substantive
vacancy. As a result this rule expressly debars
Assistant Engineers who have been appointed
long before the appointment of the direct
recruits under the amended rules of 1969 to
have their long years of service as Assistant
Engineers after being appointed substantively
and after being members of the service
fulfilling all the tests prescribed within the
meaning of Rule 3 of the rules of 1936 and also
under Rule 3(b) as amended by the 1969
amendment to be left out in fixation of
seniority. In other words these temporary
Assistant Engineers will ever remain temporary
though they have been rendering identical
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
service for long years and having same
educational qualification and long experience
in the service.
16. This memorandum dated December 7, 1961
was considered in Baleshwar Dass case [(1980) 4
SCC 226 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 531 : (1981) 1 SCR 449
: 1980 Lab IC 1155] by this Court and it was
held that ‚this GO was not arbitrary insofar as
it fixes the proportion of permanent vacancies
to be filled from various sources, and it has
statutory force being under Rule 6‛. It has
also been observed that: [SCC p. 238, SCC (L&S)
p. 544, para 22]
‚The office memorandum makes it clear that
direct recruitments will be made to ‘both
permanent and temporary vacancies of Assistant
Engineers’. But this scheme of 1961 cannot
stand in isolation and has to be read as
subordinate to the 1936 Rules. After all, the
1961 Memorandum cannot override the Rules which
are valid under Article 313, and so must be
treated as filling the gaps, not flouting the
provisions.‛
(emphasis in original)
Hence the said OM does not affect the
petitioners who have become members of the
Service and are entitled to have their
seniority reckoned from the date of their being
member of the Service according to Rule 23 of
the 1936 Rules. The 1969 Rules and 1971 Rules
have however, affected the rights of the
respondents who have become members of the
Service
being
substantively
appointed
in
temporary posts as Assistant Engineers inasmuch
as there has been an amendment effected in Rule
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
3(b) by providing that a member of the Service
meant a government servant appointed in a
substantive capacity to a post in the cadre of
the Service. Rule 3(c) also amends the earlier
provisions by meaning direct recruitment as in
the manner prescribed in Rules 5(a)(i) and
5(b)(i). Similar amendments have been made in
Rules 5 and 6. The effect of these amendments
is that Assistant Engineers who have become
members
of
the
Service
being
appointed
substantively in temporary posts will no longer
be members of the Service and will have to wait
till they are selected and appointed as
Assistant Engineers under Rule 5(a)(ii) against
quota fixed by Rule 6 for this purpose. This
creates serious prejudice to them and it also
creates uncertainty as to when they will be
selected and appointed against the quota set up
for such selection under Rule 5(a)(ii). The
amended Rule 23 lays down that a seniority will
be determined from the date of order of
appointment in substantive vacancy. These
amended Rule 23 lays down that seniority will
be determined from March 1, 1962 to the
existing
officers
i.e.
the
respondents
appointed
substantively
against
temporary
vacancies. It has been urged that government
has the power to amend rules retrospectively
and such rules are quite valid. Several
decisions have been cited of this Court at the
bar. Undoubtedly the Government has got the
power under proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution to make rules and amend the rules
giving retrospective effect. Nevertheless, such
retrospective amendments cannot take away the
vested rights and the amendments must be
reasonable, not arbitrary or discriminatory
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
violating
Articles
and
of
the
Constitution.
17. In
the
case T.R.
Kapur v. State
of
Haryana [1986 Supp SCC 584] (in which one of us
was a party) this Court observed: (SCC p. 595,
para 16)
‚It is well settled that the power to frame
rules to regulate the conditions of service
under the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution carries with it the power to amend
or alter the rules with a retrospective
effect: B.S. Vadhera v. Union of India [(1968)
3 SCR 575 : 1969 Lab IC 100 : (1970) 1 LLJ 499]
, Raj Kumar v. Union of India [(1975) 4 SCC 13
: 1975 SCC (L&S) 198 : (1975) 3 SCR 963] , K.
Nagaraj v. State of A.P. [(1985) 1 SCC 523 :
1985 SCC (L&S) 280] and State of J&K v. Triloki
Nath Khosa [(1974) 1 SCC 19 : 1974 SCC (L&S) 49
: (1974) 1 SCR 771 : (1974) 1 LLJ 121] . It is
equally well settled that any rule which
affects the right of a person to be considered
for promotion is a condition of service
although mere chances of promotion may not be.
It may further be stated that an authority
competent to lay down qualifications for
promotion, is also competent to change the
qualifications.
The
rules
defining
qualifications and suitability for promotion
are conditions of service and they can be
changed retrospectively. This rule is however
subject to a well-recognised principle that the
benefits acquired under the existing rules
cannot be taken away by an amendment with
retrospective effect, that is to say, there is
no power to make such a rule under the proviso
to Article 309 which affects or impairs vested
rights. Therefore, unless it is specifically
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
provided in the rules, the employees who are
already promoted before the amendment of the
rules, cannot be reverted and their promotion
cannot be recalled. In other words, such rules
laying down qualifications for promotion made
with retrospective effect must necessarily
satisfy the tests of Articles 14 and 16(1) of
the Constitution.‛
27.3.
In the case of Suhas H. Pophale (supra), Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has held as under:-
‚45. It has been laid down by this Court time
and again that if there are rights created in
favour of any person, whether they are property
rights or rights arising from a transaction in
the nature of a contract, and particularly if
they are protected under a statute, and if they
are to be taken away by any legislation, that
legislation will have to say so specifically by
giving it a retrospective effect. This is
because prima facie every legislation is
prospective (see para 7 of the Constitution
Bench
judgment
in Janardhan
Reddy v. State [1950 SCC 898 : AIR 1951 SC 124
: (1951) 52 Cri LJ 391] ). In the instant case,
the appellant was undoubtedly protected as a
‚deemed tenant‛ under Section 15-A of the
Bombay Rent Act, prior to the merger of the
erstwhile Insurance Company with a government
company, and he could be removed only by
following the procedure available under the
Bombay Rent Act. A ‚deemed tenant‛ under the
Bombay Rent Act, continued to be protected
under the succeeding Act, in view of the
definition
of
a
‚tenant‛
under
Section
7(15)(a)(ii) of the Maharashtra Rent Control
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Act, 1999. Thus, as far as the tenants of the
premises which are not covered under the Public
Premises Act are concerned, those tenants who
were deemed tenants under the Bombay Rent Act
continued to have their protection under the
Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999. Should the
coverage of their premises under the Public
Premises Act make a difference to the tenants
or occupants of such premises, and if so, from
which date?
54. Having noted the aforesaid observations, it
is very clear that in the facts of the present
case, the appellant's status as a deemed tenant
was accepted under the State enactment, and
therefore he could not be said to be in
‚unauthorised occupation‛. His right granted by
the State enactment cannot be destroyed by
giving any retrospective application to the
provisions of the Public Premises Act, since
there is no such express provision in the
statute,
nor
is
it
warranted
by
any
implication. In fact his premises would not
come within the ambit of the Public Premises
Act, until they belonged to Respondent 1 i.e
until 1-1-1974. The corollary is that if
Respondent 1 wanted to evict the appellant, the
remedy was to resort to the procedure available
under the Bombay Rent Act or its successor
Maharashtra Rent Control Act, by approaching
the forum thereunder, and not by resorting to
the provisions of the Public Premises Act.
60. It is true that Section 15 of the Public
Premises Act creates a bar of jurisdiction to
entertain suits or proceedings in respect of
eviction of any person in an unauthorised
occupation. However, as far as the relationship
between
Respondent
1,
the
other
general
insurance companies, LIC, nationalised banks
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
and
such
other
government
companies
or
corporations, on the one hand and their
occupants/licensees/tenants on the other hand
is
concerned,
such
persons
who
are
in
occupation prior to the premises belonging to
or taken on lease by such entities, will
continue to be governed by the State Rent
Control Act for all purposes. The Public
Premises Act will apply only to those who come
in such occupation after such date. Thus, there
is no occasion to have a dual procedure which
is ruled out in para 66 of Ashoka Mktg. [Ashoka
Mktg. Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank, (1990) 4
SCC 406] We must remember that the occupants of
these properties were earlier tenants of the
erstwhile insurance companies which were the
private landlords. They have not chosen to be
the tenants of the government companies. Their
status as occupants of the public insurance
companies has been thrust upon them by the
Public Premises Act.
64. As far as the eviction of unauthorised
occupants from public premises is concerned,
undoubtedly it is covered under the Public
Premises Act, but it is so covered from 16-91958, or from the later date when the premises
concerned become public premises by virtue of
the
premises
concerned
vesting
into
a
government company or a corporation like LIC or
the nationalised banks or the general insurance
companies like Respondent 1. Thus there are two
categories
of
occupants
of
these
public
corporations who get excluded from the coverage
of the Act itself. Firstly, those who are in
occupation since prior to 16-9-1958 i.e. prior
to the Act becoming applicable, are clearly
outside the coverage of the Act. Secondly,
those who come in occupation, thereafter, but
prior to the date of the premises concerned
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
belonging to a government corporation or a
company, and are covered under a protective
provision of the State Rent Act, like the
appellant herein, also get excluded. Until such
date, the Bombay Rent Act and its successor
Maharashtra Rent Control Act will continue to
govern the relationship between the occupants
of such premises on the one hand, and such
government companies and corporations on the
other. Hence, with respect to such occupants it
will not be open to such companies or
corporations to issue notices, and to proceed
against
such
occupants
under
the
Public
Premises Act, and such proceedings will be void
and illegal. Similarly, it will be open for
such occupants of these premises to seek
declaration of their status, and other rights
such as transmission of the tenancy to the
legal heirs, etc. under the Bombay Rent Act or
its successor Maharashtra Rent Control Act, and
also to seek protective reliefs in the nature
of injunctions against unjustified actions or
orders of eviction if so passed, by approaching
the forum provided under the State Act which
alone will have the jurisdiction to entertain
such proceedings.
70. For the reasons stated above, we allow this
appeal and set aside the impugned judgment and
order dated 7-6-2010 rendered by the High Court
of Bombay in Suhas H. Pophale v. Oriental
Insurance
Co.
Ltd. [Suhas
H.
Pophale v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2010)
5 Mah LJ 744 : (2010) 4 Bom CR 279] The said
writ petition shall stand allowed, and the
judgment and order dated 17-1-1996 passed by
the City Civil Court, Mumbai, as well as the
eviction order dated 28-5-1993 passed by
Respondent 2 against the appellant will stand
set aside. The proceedings for eviction from
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
premises, and for recovery of rent and damages
initiated by the first respondent against the
appellant under the Public Premises Act, 1971,
are held to be bad in law, and shall therefore
stand dismissed. We however, make it clear,
that in case the respondents intend to take any
steps for that purpose, it will be open to them
to resort to the remedy available under the
Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, provided
they make out a case therefor. The parties will
bear their own costs.‛
27.4.
Again in the case of Tushar Ranjan Mohanty (Supra),
Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held as under:‚14. The
legislatures
and
the
competent
authority under Article 309 of the Constitution
of India have the power to make laws with
retrospective effect. This power, however,
cannot be used to justify the arbitrary,
illegal
or
unconstitutional
acts
of
the
Executive. When a person is deprived of an
accrued right vested in him under a statute or
under the Constitution and he successfully
challenges the same in the court of law, the
legislature cannot render the said right and
the relief obtained nugatory by enacting
retrospective legislation.
15. Respectfully following the law laid down by
this Court in the judgments referred to and
quoted above, we are of the view that the
retrospective operation of the amended Rule 13
cannot be sustained. We are satisfied that the
retrospective amendment of Rule 13 of the Rules
takes away the vested rights of Mohanty and
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
other general category candidates senior to
Respondents 2 to 9. We, therefore, declare
amended Rule 13 to the extent it has been made
operative retrospectively to be unreasonable,
arbitrary and, as such, violative of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. We
strike down the retrospective operation of the
rule. In the view we have taken on the point it
is not necessary to deal with the other
contentions raised by Mohanty.‛
27.5.
Thereafter, in the case of M/S Shah Sadiq & Sons
(Supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held as under:‚14. Under the Income Tax Act of 1922, the
assessee was entitled to carry forward the
losses of the speculation business and set off
such losses against profits made from that
business in future years. The right of carrying
forward and set off accrued to the assessee
under the Act of 1922. A right which had
accrued and had become vested continued to be
capable of being enforced notwithstanding the
repeal of the statute under which that right
accrued unless the repealing statute took away
such
right
expressly
or
by
necessary
implication. This is the effect of Section 6 of
the General clauses Act, 1897.
15. In this case the ‚savings‛ provision in the
repealing statute is not exhaustive of the
rights which are saved or which survive the
repeal of the statute under which such rights
had accrued. In other words, whatever rights
are expressly saved by the ‚savings‛ provision
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
stand saved. But, that does not mean that
rights which are not saved by the ‚savings‛
provision are extinguished or stand ipso facto
terminated by the mere fact that a new statute
repealing the old statute is enacted. Rights
which have accrued are saved unless they are
taken away expressly. This is the principle
behind Section 6(c) of the General clauses Act,
1897. The right to carry forward losses which
had accrued under the repealed Income Tax Act
of 1922 is not saved expressly by Section 297
of the Income Tax Act, 1961. But, it is not
necessary to save a right expressly in order to
keep it alive after the repeal of the old Act
of 1922. Section 6(c) saves accrued rights
unless they are taken away by the repealing
statute. We do not find any such taking away of
the rights by Section 297 either expressly or
by implication.‛
27.6.
Again dealing with the issue, Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the
case of Hitendra Vishnu Thakur (supra), Hon‟ble Supreme
Court has held as under:‚26. ……………………………
………… From the law settled by this
Court in various cases, the illustrative
though not exhaustive principles, which
emerge with regard to the ambit and scope
of an Amending Act and its retrospective
operation may be culled out as follows:
(i) A statute which affects substantive rights
is presumed to be prospective in operation
unless
made
retrospective,
either
expressly or by necessary intendment,
whereas a statute which merely affects
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
procedure, unless such a construction is
textually impossible, is presumed to be
retrospective in its application, should
not be given an extended meaning and
should be strictly confined to its clearly
defined limits.
(ii) Law relating to forum and limitation is
procedural in nature, whereas law relating
to right of action and right of appeal
even though remedial is substantive in
nature.
(iii) Every litigant has a vested right in
substantive law, but no such right exists
in procedural law.
(iv) A procedural statute should not generally
speaking be applied retrospectively where
the result would be to create new
disabilities or obligations or to impose
new duties in respect of transactions
already accomplished.
(v) A statute which not only changes the
procedure but also creates new rights and
liabilities shall be construed to be
prospective in operation, unless otherwise
provided, either expressly or by necessary
implication.‛
27.7.
Again, in the case of Thyssen
Stahlunion
Gmbh
(supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held as under:‚28. Section 85(2)(a) is the saving clause. It
exempts
the
old
Act
from
complete
obliteration, so far as pending arbitration
proceedings are concerned. That would include
saving of whole of the old Act up till the
time of the enforcement of the award. This
(sic Thus)
Section 85(2)(a)
prevents the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
accrued right under the old Act from being
affected.
Saving
provision
preserves
the
existing right accrued under the old Act.
There is a presumption that the legislature
does not intend to limit or take away vested
rights unless the language clearly points to
the contrary. It is correct that the new Act
is a remedial statute and, therefore, Section
85(2)(a) calls for a strict construction, it
being a repealing provision. But then as
stated above where one interpretation would
produce an unjust or an inconvenient result
and another would not have those effects,
there is then also a presumption in favour of
the latter.‛
27.8.
In view of the aforesaid propositions of law, so laid down in
the cases discussed herein above, this Court is of the view that the
additional ground, so taken by the respondent No.4 in its additional
affidavit, cannot be accepted. Firstly, such ground finds no mention
in the impugned order dated 12.06.2019, and in view of the decision
of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of Mohinder Singh Gill
and Another (supra) that reason cannot be supplemented by
way of an affidavit. Secondly, the right of the petitioners‟ accrued
under the Policy Decision adopted by the Government under Rules 5
and 7 of the Assam Elementary Education (Provincialisation) Rules,
1977 which is still holding the field having not been repealed or
overruled till date, and the same cannot be negated by applying
either the Act of 2011 or the Act of 2017, in view of the decision
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
discussed above, especially in M/S Shah Sadiq & Sons (supra).
And that being so the argument, so advanced by Mr. Talukdar,
learned standing counsel for the respondent authorities, cannot be
acceded to.
28.
While similarly situated schools were provincialised in the year
1993, and the teachers of said school also receiving all such
benefits, denial of such benefit to the petitioners‟ school violates
their right guaranteed under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India, as held in the case of E.P. Royappa (supra). In such a
situation, the decision taken by the respondent No.4, adversely
affecting their interests, they have justifiable grievance in the light
of the doctrine of legitimate expectation, to receive similar benefit,
that have been granted to similarly situated schools and teachers.
28.1.
It is to be noted here that while dealing with the issue of
legitimate expectation, Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of
Confederation of Ex-Servicemen Assns. (supra), has held
as under:
‚33. We are also not impressed by the argument
that all medical benefits and facilities must
be provided to ex-servicemen under the doctrine
of ‚legitimate expectation‛. The doctrine of
‚legitimate expectation‛ is a ‚latest recruit‛
to a long list of concepts fashioned by the
courts for review of administrative actions. No
doubt, the doctrine has an important place in
the development of administrative law and
particularly law relating to ‚judicial review‛.
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Under the said doctrine, a person may have
reasonable or legitimate expectation of being
treated in a certain way by an administrative
authority even though he has no right in law to
receive the benefit. In such a situation, if a
decision
is
taken
by
an
administrative
authority adversely affecting his interests, he
may have justifiable grievance in the light of
the fact of continuous receipt of the benefit,
legitimate expectation to receive the benefit
or
privilege
which
he
has
enjoyed
all
throughout. Such expectation may arise either
from the express promise or from consistent
practice which the applicant may reasonably
expect to continue.
34. The expression ‚legitimate expectation‛
appears to have been originated by Lord
Denning,
M.R.
in
the
leading
decision
of Schmidt v. Secy. of State [(1969) 1 All ER
904: (1969) 2 WLR 337: (1969) 2 Ch 149 (CA)]
.In Attorney General of Hong Kong v. Ng Yuen
Shiu [(1983) 2 All ER 346: (1983) 2 AC 629:
(1983) 2 WLR 735 (PC)], Lord Fraser referring
to Schmidt [(1969) 1 All ER 904: (1969) 2 WLR
337: (1969) 2 Ch 149 (CA)] stated: (All ER p.
350 h-j)
‚The expectations may be based on some
statement or undertaking by, or on behalf
of, the public authority which has the
duty of making the decision, if the
authority has, through its officers,
acted in a way that would make it unfair
or inconsistent with good administration
for him to be denied such an inquiry.‛
(emphasis supplied)
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
35. In such cases, therefore, the Court may not
insist
an
administrative
authority
to
act judicially but may still insist it to
act fairly. The doctrine is based on the
principle that good administration demands
observance of reasonableness and where it has
adopted a particular practice for a long time
even in the absence of a provision of law, it
should
adhere
to
such
practice
without
depriving its citizens of the benefit enjoyed
or privilege exercised.‛
29. It is to be noted here that in WP(C)No./6013/2023 (Srimati
Nabanita Mandal vs. State of Assam and 6 Ors.), vide
Order dated 02.02.2024, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, while
dealing
with
the
issue
of
giving
retrospective
effect
of
regularization/provincialisation of service of the petitioner in that
case, held as under:‚16. In view of the said position and no reason
being assigned for the denial to the petitioner
of her regularization/ provincialization of
services with effect from the date of her
initial appointment; this Court is of the
considered view that the petitioner, in the
facts and circumstances involved, is entitled
for regularization/provincialization of her
services w.e.f. 01.11.1990.
17. In view of the said conclusion reached;
this writ petition stands disposed of requiring
the Secretary, Department of School Education,
Government of Assam, to pass appropriate orders
towards regularizing the services of the
petitioner w.e.f. 01.11.1990 in terms of the
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
proposal as put-up by the Director, Elementary
Education,
Government
of
Assam,
vide
communication, dated 25.11.2022.
The Secretary, Department of School
Education, Government of Assam, shall also take
note of the fact that teachers junior to the
petitioner, working in the said school were
considered for provincialization of their
services with effect from the dates of their
initial appointment which benefit was denied to
the petitioner. Necessary orders as would be
called for in the matter, be passed by the
Secretary, Department of School Education,
Government of Assam, within a period of 2(two)
months from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order. Page No.# 9/9 The order as
required to be passed by the Secretary,
Department of School Education, Government of
Assam, in terms of the directions contained
hereinabove; shall hold the field and shall
supersede the order, dated 10.03.2015, issued
by
the
Director,
Elementary
Education,
Government of Assam, towards regularizing the
services of the petitioner with prospective
effect.
18. The services of the petitioner now being
directed to be regularized w.e.f. 01.11.1990,
she would be entitled to the salaries as due to
her from the said date and further, she would
be covered by the provisions of the Assam
Service (Pension) Rules, 1969, and would also
be
eligible
for
pension
and
pensionary
benefits.‛
Conclusion :-
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
30.
Under the given factual and legal matrix, this Court finds
sufficient merit in this petition. And accordingly, the same stands
allowed. The impugned order dated 12.06.2019, stands set aside
and quashed. In view of the given factual and legal matrix, as
discussed in the preceding para, by a mandamus of this Court, the
Director, Elementary Education, Assam is directed to pass a fresh
order towards provincialisation of the services of the petitioners
w.e.f. the date when similarly situated 1255 numbers of schools and
services of teachers were provincialized, keeping in mind the
following facts and circumstances:
(i)
Right of the petitioners accrued in terms of the Notification
dated 05.10.1993, issued by the Governor of Assam in
exercise of power under Rules 5 and 7 of the Assam
Elementary
Education
(Provincialisation)
Rules,
1977,
which are Rules and Guidelines and Policy decision for
provincialisation
of
the
venture
LP/ME/MEM/Junior
Basic/Senior Basic/MV Schools in Assam.
(ii)
The Rules of 1977 was framed and the Act of 1974 i.e. the
Assam Elementary Education (Provincialisation) Act, 1974,
and this Act and Rules of 1977 have not been repealed by
the subsequent enactment.
(iii)
Since the right of the petitioners to provincialize their
services arose under the Rules of 1977 and the Rules and
Guidelines and Policy decision dated 05.10.1993, the same
cannot be decided under the Assam Venture Educational
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
Institutions (Provincialisation of Services) Act, 2011, as
amended in the year 2012, or under the Assam Education
(Provincialisation
of
Services
of
Teachers
and
Re-
organisation of Educational Institutions) Act, 2017, as no
retrospective effect is given to the same.
(iv)
It is well settled that right which are not saved by the
“savings” provision are extinguished or stand ipso facto
terminated by the mere fact that a new statute repealing
the old statute is enacted.
(v)
Since the schools, where the petitioners have been serving
and also served, left out of provincialisation without any
ground
when
the
respondent
authorities
have
provincialized 1255 numbers of ME schools in 1991, in
spite of being similarly situated, their rights, guaranteed
under Article 14, 16(1) of the Constitution of India stand
violated.
(vi)
There is no material to suggest that the present petitioners
and the schools in which they are serving and also served,
are not similarly situated with the teachers and schools of
1255 numbers of ME schools in the year 1991.
(vii) Because of non-provincialisation of schools and services of
the petitioners along with 1255 numbers of ME schools,
serious prejudice is caused to them and they have been
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
deprived of not only the salary, but also they will be
deprived of the pension and pensionary benefits.
31.
Let the aforementioned exercise be carried out with in a
period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of
this judgment and order. The petitioners shall obtain a certified copy
of this judgment and order and place the same before the
respondent authorities, within a period of one week from today.
32.
In terms of above this writ petition stands disposed of leaving
the partied to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
WP(C) 7226/2019 and batch
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review