Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DATED : 19.06.2018
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
1.
Pahalman Subba,
S/o Lt. Ran Bahadur Subba,
aged about 83 years,
R/o Diesel Power House,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok-737 101,
East District of Sikkim.
2.
Nawin Kiran Pradhan,
S/o Harka Bahadur Pradhan,
Aged 35 years,
R/o Sisa Golai, 10 N-H Way,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok-737 101,
East District of Sikkim.
3.
Tshering Wangchuk Lepcha,
S/o Kazi Lepcha,
Aged 38 years,
R/o Metro Point, Tadong,
P.O. Tadong & P.S. Ranipool.
… Petitioner (s).
Versus
1.
The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Service through The Secretary
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Having his office at Namnang,
Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
2.
The State of Sikkim,
Service through The Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having his office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
3.
Department of Law & Parliamentary Affairs,
Government of Sikkim,
Service through the Secretary,
Law & Parliamentary Affairs Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
4.
The Election Commission of India,
Service through the Sr. Principal Secretary,
Election Commission of India,
Having his office at Nirvachan Sadan,
Ashoka Road, New Delhi-110001.
5.
Shri Ugen Nedup Bhutia,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
29-Kabi Lungchuk (BL),
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
6.
Shri Shyam Pradhan,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
26-Arithang,
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
7.
Shri Hemendra Adhikari,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
19-Rhenock,
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
8.
Shri Gopal Baraily,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
18-West Pandam,
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
9.
Dr. Mechung Bhutia,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
24-Martam Rumtek (BL),
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
10.
Shri Pintso Chopel Bhutia,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
27-Gangtok (BL),
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
11.
Shri Timothy William Basnett,
Hon’ble Member of Legislative Assembly,
25-Upper Tadong,
Having his office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Namnang, Gangtok-737101.
… Respondent (s).
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sabyasachi Chatterjee and Mr. Pem Tshering
Lepcha, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. D.K. Siwakoti, Advocate for Respondent No. 1.
Mr. A. Mariarputham, Advocate General, Mr. J.B.
Pradhan, Addl. Advocate General with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Govt. Advocate, Mr. Santosh Kr.
Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Govt. Advocates for
Respondents No. 2 & 3.
Mr. Tashi Rapden Barfungpa, Advocate for Respondent
No. 4.
Mr. N. Rai, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Suraj Chettri,
Advocate for Respondents No. 5 to 11.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
JUDGMENT
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The first petitioner, stated to be a social activist and a
former Member of Union Parliament but not being a member of
any political party, the second and third petitioners, stated to be
social and political activists but not the members of any political
party, have come up with this petition seeking reading down of
Rules 6 and 7 of the Members of Sikkim Legislative Assembly
(Disqualification on ground of Defection) Rules, 1985 (hereinafter
referred to as ―the Rules of 1985‖), in the light of Article 191 (2)
and the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution of India.
Further a
direction is sought to cancel/quash/rescind the communication
being No. 516/SLAS/L&PA dated 02nd February 2017 of the
Additional
Secretary,
L&PA,
Sikkim
Legislative
Assembly
Secretariat, whereby the petition made by the first and second
petitioners along with three others, seeking disqualification of 5th
to 11th respondents on the ground of alleged defection, was not
admitted in terms of Rule 7 Clauses (1) and (2) of the Rules of
1985. The petitioners have further prayed for declaration that the
5th to 11th respondents be held as disqualified for being the
member of Sikkim Legislative Assembly on the ground of
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
defection, in addition other directions of interim nature during
pendency of the petition.
2.
The genesis of lis involved in this petition is that 32
members were elected in the General Election for Sikkim
Legislative Assembly held in the month of May, 2014. Out of 32
members, 10 members including the 5th to 11th respondents won
the election on Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM) tickets.
It is
stated that on 30th November 2015, the 5th to 11th respondents
switched over to the ruling party Sikkim Democratic Front (SDF)
and thereafter were appointed as Parliamentary Secretaries.
Their appointments, as Parliamentary Secretaries, were quashed
on 25th August 2017 by this Court in Pahlman Subba & others vs.
State of Sikkim & Others1. After a period of 13 months, the first
and second petitioners along with three other persons, namely,
Mr. T.B. Rai, Mr. Sonam Pintso Bhutia and Mr. Mohan Kr. Rai,
filed a petition addressed to the Speaker through the Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly on 25th January 2017 seeking
disqualification of the 5th to 11th respondents. It is apt to state
here that Mr. T.B. Rai did not sign the petition, as is manifest
from the petition. It is also relevant to mention at this stage that
the petition was not addressed only to the competent authority
i.e. the Speaker, but a copy was endorsed to the President of
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
India, Prime Minister of India, Chief Justice of India, Minister of
Law and Justice, Chairman, Law Commission of India, Chief
Election Commissioner and other three elected members of
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha. In addition, a copy was given to the
press and media also.
The Additional Secretary, Sikkim
Legislative Assembly Secretariat by the impugned communication
dated 02nd February 2017 informed the petitioners that the
petition dated 25th January 2017 could not be admitted in terms
of Rule 7 Clauses (1) and (2) of the Rules of 1985. After about
10 months, the 1st and 2nd petitioners, who submitted the
petition, with others before the 1st respondent, filed the instant
petition on 12th December 2017. It is relevant to state here that
the 3rd petitioner was not the petitioner before the Speaker.
3.
On perusal of the records, it is found that one more
letter was sent by Mr. P.S. Tamang, an elected member and
President, Sikkim Krantikari Morcha party to the Speaker,
seeking disqualification of 5th to 11th respondents on 29th
December 2015, however, we are not concerned with the said
letter in this petition.
4.
Mr. Sabyasachi Chatterjee, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners in the aforestated backdrop submits that the
petition dated 25th January 2017 was in the form of information
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
to the Speaker. The Speaker, should not have insisted on other
formalities and on having come to know about the defection by
the contesting private respondents, which was against the spirit
of Tenth Schedule of Constitution as well as Article 191 (2) of the
Constitution of India, ought to have declared them disqualified
cancelling their membership. The defection of 5th to 11th
respondents to the ruling party thereafter assuming the office of
Parliamentary Secretaries could not be termed as merger of
original party, which is exempted from the disqualification under
the Tenth Schedule. The action of the 1st respondent frustrates
the constitutional objectives. It is not necessary to be a Member
of Legislative Assembly to make a petition to the Speaker,
seeking compliance of provisions of the Tenth Schedule read with
Article 191 (2) of the Constitution of India. The petitioners, not
being members of any registered political party, filed the petition
to uphold the sanctity of the Constitutional mandate and protect
it from vice of defection.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that the Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985 was
passed with the sole objective to prevent evil of political
defection, which undermines the very foundation of democracy
and the principles which sustain it.
The Speaker, being the head
of Legislature, is under obligation to uphold constitutional values.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
On having come to know the alleged defection made by the 5th to
11th respondents, who were elected on the symbol of Sikkim
Krantikari Morcha and thereafter defected to the ruling party for
personal gain, without proper merger with the party, the first
respondent failed to discharge constitutional mandate and as
such it needs correction by this Court in this petition.
petitioners
are
discharging
their
fundamental
The
duties,
as
enshrined under Article 51A to abide and uphold the sanctity of
the Constitution. It is further stated that there was no merger of
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha with the Sikkim Democratic Front, the
ruling party, to escape from clutches of the anti-defection law.
6.
Referring to the judicial pronouncement in Speaker,
Orissa Legislative Assembly vs. Utkal Keshari Parida2, laid down
by the Supreme Court, wherein it was made clear that not only a
member of the House, but any person interested, would also be
entitled to bring to the notice of the Speaker the fact that a
member of the House had incurred disqualification under the
Tenth Schedule to the Constitution of India, learned counsel
would contend that the Speaker ought to have admitted the
petition and decided on merit.
Dismissal of it at threshold for
non-compliance of rules is illegal and as such relevant provisions
of Rules 6 and 7 deserve to be read down to facilitate all the
(2013) 11 SCC 794
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
persons
who
are
interested
in
upholding
the
values
of
Constitution of India, in this petition seeking disqualification of
defaulting members.
To garner support, Mr. Chatterjee referred and relied
7.
on the observations made by the Supreme Court in Ravi S. Naik
vs. Union of India and others3, Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh vs.
Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council and others 4, Jagjit Singh vs.
State of Haryana and others5, Rajendra Singh Rana and others
vs. Swami Prasad Maurya and others 6
and Speaker, Haryana
Vidhan Sabha vs. Kuldeep Bishnoi and others7.
Contesting, Mr. A. Mariarputham, learned Advocate
8.
General, appearing for the 2nd and 3rd respondents, referring to
the counter affidavit filed by the 3rd respondent would contend
that
the
Members
of
the
Sikkim
Legislative
Assembly
(Disqualification on ground of Defection) Rules, 1985 was made
in exercise of powers conferred on the Speaker of the House
under paragraph 8 of the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution to
regulate the procedure to work out the provisions of the Tenth
Schedule on 20th December 1985, gazetted on 23rd December
1985.
The petition of the 1st and 2nd petitioners along with three
1994 Supp (2) SCC 641
(2004) 8 SCC 747
(2006) 11 SCC 1
(2007) 4 SCC 270
(2015) 12 SCC 381
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
others, who have not approached this Court, was not admitted
on the ground that it was not in accordance with the requirement
of Rules 6 and rejected in terms of Rule 7 Clauses (1) and (2) of
the Rules of 1985.
It is further submitted by the learned
Advocate General that out of three petitioners herein, only 1st
and 2nd petitioners have joined with other three persons in the so
called petition before the Speaker.
Out of five petitioners, one
had chosen not to sign the petition before the Speaker and only
1st and 2nd petitioners have approached this Court under this writ
petition, along with third petitioner, who was not before the
Speaker.
9.
Mr. Mariarputham would next urge that Clause (1) of
Rule 7 of the Rules of 1985 prescribes that the Speaker shall
consider whether the petition complies with the requirements of
Rule 6. Clause (2) of Rule 7 of the Rules of 1985 contemplates
dismissal of the petition at the threshold, if the same does not
comply with the requirements of Rule 6.
Rule 6 of the Rules of
1985 provides that no reference of any question in respect of
disqualification of a member shall be made by a petition without
compliance of requirement of provisions of Rules.
The Rules
provides firstly that it be made in writing by any other member
addressed to the Speaker. Further, the petition shall contain a
concise statement of the material facts on which the petitioner
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
relies, be accompanied by copies of the documentary evidence, if
any, on which the petitioner relies. It should be duly signed and
verified by the petitioner in the manner laid down in the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908. Every annexure shall also be signed and
verified by the petitioner in the same manner as the petition.
The petition dated 25th January 2017 was defective, as firstly it
was not made by a member of the House; secondly, it was not
duly signed and verified by all the petitioners while making the
petition and also the documentary evidence duly signed and
verified was not annexed with the petition.
Thus, the petition
was rightly not admitted at the threshold itself and the Additional
Secretary was authorized to duly communicate the order to the
petitioners.
10.
The Advocate General would further submit that this
Court may not interfere with the petition at this stage, when the
Speaker has not decided the petition on merit in the light of
Article 212 of the Constitution of India.
The non-admission of
petition, which was not in accordance with the prescribed Rules,
is a legislative proceeding, which may not be examined by this
Court unless it is ultra vires, in violation of principles of natural
justice, mala fide or having been made in colourable exercise of
power based on extraneous material.
The question as to
whether the petitioners were competent to make a petition
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
before the Speaker, came up for consideration in Speaker, Orissa
Legislative Assembly, wherein the Supreme Court read down the
Rule 6 holding that not only a member of the House, but any
person interested, would also be entitled to bring to the notice of
the Speaker the fact of disqualification incurred by a member.
The other provisions of Rules are strictly in accordance with the
principles of natural justice, thus, the same may not be read
down, as pleaded by the petitioners. It is further contended that
the petitioners have not placed any material on record to indicate
that the procedural rules framed therein which facilitates proper
examination and inquiry are meant to destroy the objectives and
purpose of the Tenth Schedule, thus, the relief seeking reading
down of Rules 6 and 7 of the Rules 1985, be rejected.
11.
Mr. D.K. Siwakoti, learned counsel appearing for the
Speaker adopts the arguments put forth by the learned Advocate
General.
12.
Mr.
Tashi
Rapten
Barfungpa,
learned
counsel
appearing for the Election Commission of India states that the
Election Commission of India has nothing to say in the matter at
this stage.
13.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
private 5th to 11th respondents submits that the petition made by
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
the 1st and 2nd petitioners along with three others was filed
before the Speaker not with the purpose to uphold the
constitutional provision but to gain the publicity and also it was in
the
nature
of
complaint,
as
it
was
sent
to
other
high
constitutional functionaries. The motive was not fair and proper,
thus, the same was rightly rejected by the Speaker.
Mr. Rai,
learned Senior Counsel, adopting the arguments advanced by the
learned Advocate General on the other issues, submitted that the
petition was not in accord with the procedure and as such it was
rightly not admitted at the threshold itself.
There was no
irregularity or illegality in not considering the petition on the part
of the Speaker, thus, this Court may not entertain this petition at
this stage.
14.
On
anxious
and
conscientious
consideration
of
pleadings and submissions put forth by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, it is found that the 1st and 2nd
petitioners were the petitioners before the Speaker. Out of five
petitioners, two have chosen to file the present writ petition and
three have chosen not to join the present petition. Out of three,
one has not signed even the petition filed before the Speaker,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly.
It is also manifest that a copy of
the petition was endorsed to several constitutional functionaries
and also to press and media, which was not the requirement of
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
the procedure or of the constitutional provisions.
On further
examination of the original petition produced before us, it is
established that the petition was signed by four petitioners and it
was not duly verified, as required under the Rules. There were
no documents except a newspaper report which gave reasons to
the applicants therein to believe that 5th to 11th respondents have
switched over from the original party to the new party.
Newspaper report was neither authenticated nor duly signed and
verified. Even other annexures were also neither authenticated
nor duly signed and verified, as required under Rule 6 of the
Rules of 1985. Thus, it does not meet the requirement of Rule 6.
15.
The Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985
was enacted by the Parliament incorporating Article 191 (2),
providing for disqualification of a person for being a member of
the Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council of a State if he is
so disqualified under the Tenth Schedule.
The Tenth Schedule
was also incorporated by the said Amendment Act.
16.
Paragraph 2 of the Tenth Schedule prescribes for
―Disqualification on ground of defection‖, which reads as under: “2.
Disqualification on ground of defection.— (1)
Subject to the provisions of paragraphs 4 and 5, a member
of a House belonging to any political party shall be
disqualified for being a member of the House—
(a)
(b)
if he has voluntarily given up his membership
of such political party; or
if he votes or abstains from voting in such
House contrary to any direction issued by the
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
political party to which he belongs or by any
person or authority authorised by it in this
behalf, without obtaining, in either case, the
prior permission of such political party,
person or authority and such voting or
abstention has not been condoned by such
political party, person or authority within
fifteen days from the date of such voting or
abstention.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this sub-paragraph,—
(a) an elected member of a House shall be deemed to
belong to the political party, if any, by which he was set
up as a candidate for election as such member;
(b) a nominated member of a House shall,—
(i)
(ii)
where he is a member of any political party
on the date of his nomination as such
member, be deemed to belong to such
political party;
in any other case, be deemed to belong to the
political party of which he becomes, or, as the
case may be, first becomes, a member before
the expiry of six months from the date on
which he takes his seat after complying with
the requirements of article 99 or, as the case
may be, article 188.
(2) An elected member of a House who has been elected as
such otherwise than as a candidate set up by any political
party shall be disqualified for being a member of the House
if he joins any political party after such election.
(3) A nominated member of a House shall be disqualified for
being a member of the House if he joins any political party
after the expiry of six months from the date on which he
takes his seat after complying with the requirements of
article 99 or, as the case may be, article 188.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing
provisions of this paragraph, a person who, on the
commencement
of
the
Constitution
(Fifty-second
Amendment) Act, 1985, is a member of a House (whether
elected or nominated as such) shall,—
(i)
where he was a member of political party
immediately before such commencement, be
deemed, for the purposes of sub-paragraph
(1) of this paragraph, to have been elected as
a member of such House as a candidate set
up by such political party;
(ii)
in any other case, be deemed to be an
elected member of the House who has been
elected as such otherwise than as a candidate
set up by any political party for the purposes
of sub-paragraph (2) of this paragraph or, as
the case may be, be deemed to be a
nominated member of the House for the
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
17.
Paragraph
purposes of
paragraph.”
sub-paragraph
provided
for
(3)
of
this
non-application
of
qualification in case of split in original political party consisting of
more than one-third of the members of such legislature party.
Paragraph 3 was omitted subsequently by the Constitution
(Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003 and also paragraphs 4 and 5
were reframed as under:
“4.
Disqualification on ground of defection not to
apply in case of merger.— (1) A member of a House shall
not be disqualified under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 2
where his original political party merges with another
political party and he claims that he and any other members
of his original political party—
(a)
have become members of such other political party
or, as the case may be, of a new political party
formed by such merger; or
(b)
have not accepted the merger and opted to function
as a separate group,
and from the time of such merger, such other political party
or new political party or group, as the case may be, shall be
deemed to be the political party to which he belongs for the
purposes of sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 2 and to be his
original political party for the purposes of this subparagraph.
(2) For the purposes of sub-paragraph (1) of this
paragraph, the merger of the original political party of a
member of a House shall be deemed to have taken place if,
and only if, not less than two-thirds of the members of the
legislature party concerned have agreed to such merger.
5.
Exemption.— Notwithstanding anything contained
in this Schedule, a person who has been elected to the
office of the Speaker or the Deputy Speaker of the House of
the People or the Deputy Chairman of the Council of States
or the Chairman or the Deputy Chairman of the Legislative
Council of a State or the Speaker or the Deputy Speaker of
the Legislative Assembly of a State, shall not be disqualified
under this Schedule,—
(a)
if he, by reason of his election to such office,
voluntarily gives up the membership of the political
party to which he belonged immediately before such
election and does not, so long as he continues to
hold such office thereafter, rejoin that political party
or become a member of another political party; or
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
(b)
18.
if he, having given up by reason of his election to
such office his membership of the political party to
which he belonged immediately before such election,
rejoins such political party after he ceases to hold
such office.”
On bare perusal of the relevant paragraphs 2, 4 and 5
of the Tenth Schedule, it is evident that a member of a House
stands disqualified, if he has voluntarily given up his membership
of such political party or if he votes or abstain from voting in
such House contrary to any direction issued by the political party
to which he belongs or an elected member of a House who has
been elected as such otherwise than as a candidate set up by any
political party shall be disqualified for being a member of the
House if he joins any political party after such election.
19.
Paragraph 4 contemplates disqualification on ground
of defection not to apply in case of merger of original party with
another political party. The merger of the original political party
of a member of a House shall be deemed to have taken place if,
and only if, not less than two-thirds of the members of the
legislature party concerned have agreed to such merger.
It is
pleaded that there was no merger of the political party on
defection of two-thirds of the members of the concerned
legislature party i.e. Sikkim Krantikari Morcha.
The contesting
respondents 5th to 11, who are more than two-thirds of the
members of the concerned legislature party, have not formed
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
any separate party to merge with another political party. Thus,
Article 191 (2) clearly mandates that disqualification incurred by
a member under the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution shall be
disqualified for being a member of the Legislative Assembly.
20.
The Defection Rules of Goa Legislative Assembly, akin
to the present one, which were framed to regulate the procedure,
had fallen for consideration in Ravi S. Naik vs. Union of India3,
wherein the Supreme Court held as under: “18. ………… The Disqualification Rules have been framed
to regulate the procedure that is to be followed by the
Speaker for exercising the power conferred on him under
sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 6 of the Tenth Schedule to
the Constitution. The Disqualification Rules are, therefore,
procedural in nature and any violation of the same would
amount to an irregularity in procedure which is immune
from judicial scrutiny in view of sub-paragraph (2) of
paragraph 6 as construed by this Court in Kihoto Hollohan
case [1992 Supp (2) SCC 651] . Moreover, the field of
judicial review in respect of the orders passed by the
Speaker under sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 6 as
construed by this Court in Kihoto Hollohan case [1992 Supp
(2) SCC 651] is confined to breaches of the constitutional
mandates, mala fides, non-compliance with Rules of Natural
Justice and perversity. We are unable to uphold the
contention of Shri Sen that the violation of the
Disqualification Rules amounts to violation of constitutional
mandates. By doing so we would be elevating the rules to
the status of the provisions of the Constitution which is
impermissible. Since the Disqualification Rules have been
framed by the Speaker in exercise of the power conferred
under paragraph 8 of the Tenth Schedule they have a status
subordinate to the Constitution and cannot be equated with
the provisions of the Constitution. They cannot, therefore,
be regarded as constitutional mandates and any violation of
the Disqualification Rules does not afford a ground for
judicial review of the order of the Speaker in view of the
finality clause contained in sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph
6 of the Tenth Schedule as construed by this Court in Kihoto
Hollohan case [1992 Supp (2) SCC 651] .”
21.
In Dr. Mahachandra Prasad Singh vs. Chairman, Bihar
Legislative Council and others4, the Supreme Court held as
under: 18
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
“8.1. This authoritative pronouncement clearly lays down
that the decision of the Chairman or the Speaker of the
House can be challenged on very limited grounds, namely,
violation of constitutional mandate, mala fides, noncompliance with rules of natural justice and perversity and
further a mere irregularity in procedure can have no bearing
on the decision.
X
X
X
12.
Paragraph 8 gives the rule-making powers and it
provides that the Chairman or the Speaker of a House may
make rules for giving effect to the provisions of the Tenth
Schedule. Clause (d) of sub-para (1) of this rule provides
that the rule may provide the procedure for deciding any
question referred to in sub-para (1) of Paragraph 6
including the procedure for any inquiry which may be made
for the purpose of deciding such question. In exercise of the
power conferred by Paragraph 8 of the Tenth Schedule, the
Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council has made the Bihar
Legislative Council Members (Disqualification on Ground of
Defection) Rules, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as ―the
Rules‖). Rule 3 of the Rules provides that the leader of each
legislature party shall furnish to the Chairman a statement
in writing containing the names of members of such political
party. Sub-rules (1) and (6) of Rule 6 and sub-rules (1) and
(2) of Rule 7 read as under:
―6. References to be by petitions.—(1) No reference
of any question as to whether a member has become
subject to disqualification under the Tenth Schedule
shall be made except by a petition in relation to such
member made in accordance with the provisions of
this rule.
(2)-(5)
*
*
*
(6) Every petition shall be signed by the petitioner
and verified in the manner laid down in the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), for the verification
of pleadings.
7. Procedure.—(1) On receipt of a petition under
Rule 6, the Chairman shall consider whether the
petition complies with the requirements of that rule.
(2) If the petition does not comply with the
requirements of Rule 6, the Chairman shall dismiss
the petition and intimate the petitioner accordingly.‖
13.
It may be noted that under Paragraph 8, the
Chairman or the Speaker of a House is empowered to make
rules for giving effect to the provisions of the Tenth
Schedule. The rules being delegated legislation are subject
to certain fundamental factors. Underlying the concept of
delegated legislation is the basic principle that the
legislature delegates because it cannot directly exert its will
in every detail. All it can in practice do is to lay down the
outline. This means that the intention of the legislature, as
indicated in the outline (that is the enabling Act), must be
the prime guide to the meaning of delegated legislation and
the extent of the power to make it. The true extent of the
power governs the legal meaning of the delegated
legislation. The delegate is not intended to travel wider than
the object of the legislature. The delegate's function is to
serve and promote that object, while at all times remaining
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
true to it. That is the rule of primary intention. Power
delegated by an enactment does not enable the authority by
regulations to extend the scope or general operation of the
enactment but is strictly ancillary. It will authorise the
provision of subsidiary means of carrying into effect what is
enacted in the statute itself and will cover what is incidental
to the execution of its specific provision. But such a power
will not support attempts to widen the purposes of the Act,
to add new and different means of carrying them out or to
depart from or vary its ends. (See Section 59 in chapter
―Delegated Legislation‖ in Francis Bennion's Statutory
Interpretation, 3rd Edn.) The aforesaid principle will apply
with greater rigour where rules have been framed in
exercise of power conferred by a constitutional provision. No
rules can be framed which have the effect of either
enlarging or restricting the content and amplitude of the
relevant constitutional provisions. Similarly, the rules should
be interpreted consistent with the aforesaid principle.”
22.
In Jagjit Singh vs. State of Haryana and others5, the
Supreme Court again examined the powers of the Speaker vis-àvis the procedural rule prescribed therein and observed as
under:“11. The Speaker, while exercising power to disqualify
Members, acts as a Tribunal and though validity of the
orders thus passed can be questioned in the writ jurisdiction
of this Court or High Courts, the scope of judicial review is
limited as laid down by the Constitution Bench in Kihoto
Hollohan v. Zachillhu [1992 Supp (2) SCC 651] . The orders
can be challenged on the ground of ultra vires or mala fides
or having been made in colourable exercise of power based
on extraneous and irrelevant considerations. The order
would be a nullity if rules of natural justice are violated.
12.
The requirement to comply with the principles of
natural justice is also recognised in rules made by the
Speaker in exercise of powers conferred by para 8 of the
Tenth Schedule. The Speaker, Haryana Legislative
Assembly, made the Haryana Legislative Assembly
(Disqualification of Members on Ground of Defection) Rules,
1986 in exercise of power conferred by para 8 of the Tenth
Schedule. Rule 7(7), inter alia, provides that neither the
Speaker nor the Committee shall come to any finding that a
Member has become subject to disqualification under the
Tenth Schedule without affording a reasonable opportunity
to such Member to represent his case and to be heard in
person.”
23.
In Speaker, Orissa Legislative Assembly vs. Utkal
Keshari Parida2, the Supreme Court examined an identical
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
provision of Rule 6 of the Members of the Orissa Legislative
Assembly (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules, 1987
and held as under:
“18. The conundrum presented on account of the provisions
of the Tenth Schedule in addition to Rules 6(1) and (2) of
the 1987 Rules had fallen for consideration in Mahachandra
Prasad Singh case [(2004) 8 SCC 747] . Speaking for the
Bench, G.P. Mathur, J. (as His Lordship then was), observed
in para 16 of the judgment that the purpose and object of
the Rules framed by the Chairman in exercise of the power
conferred by Para 8 of the Tenth Schedule was to facilitate
the Chairman in discharging his duties and responsibilities
in resolving any dispute as to whether the Member of the
House had become subject to disqualification under the
Tenth Schedule. It was also observed that: (SCC pp. 76162, para 16)
―16. … The Rules being in the domain of procedure,
are intended to facilitate the holding of inquiry and
not to frustrate or obstruct the same by the
introduction of innumerable technicalities. Being
subordinate legislation, the Rules cannot make any
provision which may have the effect of curtailing the
content and scope of the substantive provision,
namely, the Tenth Schedule.‖
19. The aforesaid observation is precisely what we too have
in mind, as otherwise, the very object of the introduction of
the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution would be rendered
meaningless. The provisions of sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule
6 of the 1987 Rules have, therefore, to be read down to
make it clear that not only a Member of the House, but any
person interested, would also be entitled to bring to the
notice of the Speaker the fact that a Member of the House
had incurred disqualification under the Tenth Schedule to
the Constitution of India. On receipt of such information,
the Speaker of the House would be entitled to decide under
Para 6 of the Tenth Schedule as to whether the Member
concerned had, in fact, incurred such disqualification and to
pass appropriate orders on his findings.”
24.
In Speaker, Haryana Vidhan Sabha vs. Kuldeep
Bishnoi and others7, the Supreme Court held as under: “43. ………………. Under the scheme of Schedule X the
Speaker does not have an independent power to decide that
there has been split or merger as contemplated by Paras 3
and 4 respectively and such a decision can be taken only
when the question of disqualification arises in a proceeding
under Para 6. It is only after a final decision is rendered by
the Speaker under Para 6 of Schedule X to the Constitution
that the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of
the Constitution can be invoked.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
44. We have to keep in mind the fact that these appeals are
being decided in the background of the complaint made to
the effect that the interim orders have been passed by the
High Court in purported exercise of its powers of judicial
review under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, when
the disqualification proceedings were pending before the
Speaker. In that regard, we are of the view that since the
decision of the Speaker on a petition under Para 4 of
Schedule X concerns only a question of merger on which the
Speaker is not entitled to adjudicate, the High Court could
not have assumed jurisdiction under its powers of review
before a decision was taken by the Speaker under Para 6 of
Schedule X to the Constitution. It is in fact in a proceeding
under Para 6 that the Speaker assumes jurisdiction to pass
a quasi-judicial order which is amenable to the writ
jurisdiction of the High Court. It is in such proceedings that
the question relating to the disqualification is to be
considered and decided. Accordingly, restraining the
Speaker from taking any decision under Para 6 of Schedule
X is, in our view, beyond the jurisdiction of the High Court,
since the Constitution itself has vested the Speaker with the
power to take a decision under Para 6 and care has also
been taken to indicate that such decision of the Speaker
would be final. It is only thereafter that the High Court
assumes jurisdiction to examine the Speaker's order.”
25.
The principle of reading down deducible from the
aforestated promulgation of judicial pronouncements, is that the
statutory provision which fails to effectuate the objective and
purpose of the enactment may be read down to further objective
of the enactment as well as the Constitution. Rules 6 and 7 of the
Rules of 1985 are in the domain of procedure and intended to
facilitate the holding of inquiry and not to defeat or destruct the
objective of the Tenth Schedule by introducing the technicality.
Indisputably the rules are in the nature of subordinate delegated
legislation and cannot supplant the very object of the Tenth
Schedule, as the Tenth Schedule was added to the Constitution
to remove the evil of political defection which became a matter of
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
national concern and undermines the very foundation of the
democracy.
The Supreme Court in Speaker, Orissa Legislative
26.
Assembly2, read down the provisions of sub-rules (1) and (2) of
Rule
of
the
Members
of
Orissa
Legislative
Assembly
(Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules, 1987, holding
that not only a member of the House, but any person interested,
would also be entitled to bring to the notice of the Speaker the
fact that a Member of the House had incurred disqualification.
27.
Applying the well-settled principles of law to the facts
of the instant case, wherein the Rules of 1985 was framed by the
Speaker in exercise of the power conferred by paragraph 8 of the
Tenth Schedule to the Constitution of India, we proceed to
examine the relevant provisions of the Rules of 1985.
Rules 6
and 7 are extracted hereunder: ―6 (1) No reference of any question as to whether a
member has become subject to disqualification under the
Tenth Schedule shall be made except by a petition in
relation to such member made in accordance with the
provisions of this rule.
(2)
A petition in relation to a member may be made in
writing to the Speaker by any other member:
Provided that a petition in relation to the Speaker
shall be addressed to the Secretary.
(3)
The Secretary shall,
(a)
as soon as may be after the receipt of a
petition under the proviso to sub-rule (2)
make a report in respect thereof to the
House, and
(b)
as soon as may be after the House has
elected a member in pursuance of the proviso
to sub-paragraph (1) of paragraph 6 of the
Tenth Schedule place the petition before such
member.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
(4)
Before making any petition in relation to any
member, the petitioner shall satisfy himself that there are
reasonable grounds for believing that a question has arisen
as to whether such member has become subject to
disqualification under the Tenth Schedule.
(5)
Every petition –
(a)
shall contain a concise statement of the
material facts on which the petitioner relies;
and
(b)
shall be accompanied by copies of the
documentary evidence, if any, on which the
petitioner relies and where the petitioner
relies on any information furnished to him by
any person, a statement containing the
names and addresses of such persons and the
gist of such information as furnished by each
such person.
(6)
Every petition shall be signed by the petitioner and
verified in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), for the verification of
pleadings.
(7)
Every annexure to the petitioner shall also be signed
by the petitioner and verified in the same manner as the
petition.
7 (1) On receipt of a petition under rule 6, the Speaker
shall consider whether the petition complies with the
requirements of that rule.
(2)
If the petition does not comply with the
requirements of rule 6, the Speaker shall dismiss the
petition and intimate the petitioner accordingly.
(3)
If the petition complies with the requirements of rule
6, the Speaker shall cause copies of the petition and of and
of the annexures thereto to be forwarded, (a)
to the member in relation to whom the
petition has been made; and
(b)
where such member belongs to any
legislature party and such petition has not
been made by the leader thereof, also to such
leader, and such member or leader shall,
within seven days of the receipt of such
copies, or within such further period as the
speaker may for sufficient cause allow,
forward his comments in writing thereon to
the Speaker.
(4)
After considering the comments, if any in relation to
the petition, received under sub-rules (3) within the period
allowed (whether originally or on extension under that subrule), the Speaker may either proceed to determine the
question or, if he is satisfied, having regard to the nature
and circumstances of the case that it is necessary or
expedient to do so, refer the petition to the Committee for
making a preliminary inquiry and submitting a report to
him.
(5)
The Speaker shall, as soon as may be after referring
a petition to the Committee under sub-rule (4) intimate the
petitioner accordingly and make an announcement with
respect to such reference in the House or, if the House is
not then in session, cause the information as to the
reference to be published in the Bulletin.
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
(6)
Where the Speaker makes a reference under subrule (4) to the Committee, he shall proceed to determine
the question as soon as may be after receipt of the report
from the Committee.
(7)
The procedure which shall be followed by the
Speaker for determining any question and the procedure
which shall be followed by the Committee for the purpose of
making a preliminary inquiry under sub-rule (4) shall be, so
far as may be same as the procedure for enquiry and
determination by the Committee of any question as to
breach of privilege of the House by a member, and neither
the Speaker nor the Committee shall come to any finding
that a member has become subject to disqualification under
the Tenth Schedule without affording a reasonable
opportunity to such member to represent his case and to be
heard in person.
(8)
The provisions of sub-rule (1) to (7) shall apply with
respect to a petition in relation to the Speaker as they apply
with respect to a petition in relation to any other member
and for this purpose, reference to the Speaker in these subrules shall be construed as including references to the
member elected by the House under the proviso to subparagraph (1) of paragraph 6 of the Tenth Schedule.‖
28.
Rule 6 (2) of the Rules of 1985 prescribes that only
any other member of the Assembly may make petition in relation
to a member in writing to the Speaker. Rule 6 (3) (4) (5) (6)
and (7) deal with how a petition be made. Under Rule 6 (3) (a),
the Secretary, Legislative Assembly is required to make a report
in respect of making of petition to the House. Under clause (3)
(b) of Rule 6, a copy of the petition be supplied to such member
against whom a petition is made. Rule 6 (4) contemplates that
the petitioner making a petition must indicate reasonable reasons
for believing that a question has arisen in respect of a member
who has become subject to disqualification under the Tenth
Schedule. Rule 6 (5) provides for making a petition containing a
concise statement of the material facts and also the same be
accompanied by relevant documentary evidence. Rule 6 (6) and
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
(7) is made to ensure authenticity of the facts and documents
laid down by prescribing that the petition as well as the
annexures be duly signed and verified by the petitioner.
Rule 7 (1) provides that the Speaker shall consider
29.
whether the petition complies with the requirements of the Rule
6.
Sub-rule (2) of Rule 7 contemplates dismissal of the petition
if it is not in accord with Rule 6. Sub-rule (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) and
(8) of Rule 7 deal with requirements after admission of petition
while adjudicating the issue.
30.
On examination, we are of the view that Rule 6 (2)
does not achieve the object of the Tenth Schedule, as examined
by the Supreme Court in various cases and as such it may be
read down making clear that not only a member of the
Legislative
Assembly
but
any
other
person
interested
is
competent to make a reference (petition) to the Speaker for
initiating a process of disqualification of a member, who has
incurred it under Tenth Schedule. The other provisions of Rule 6
are mere procedural and do not obstruct or impede the objective
of the Tenth Schedule. Thus, it does not need any reading down.
Rule 7 (1) and (2) also need consideration.
31.
Indisputably, the procedural rules are in the domain of
procedure and may not supplant the constitutional provision. If
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
there is any irregularity in compliance of the procedure, the
defect
is
curable
and
the
petitioners
are
entitled
to
an
opportunity to make good the defect before rejecting the petition
under Rule 7 (2) of the Rules of 1985. Thus, Rule 7 (2) of the
Rules of 1985 is also read down to this effect that if a petition
fails to comply with the requirement of Rule 6, the petitioner be
granted an opportunity to cure the defect before dismissing the
petition at the threshold.
32.
At this stage, it is apt to state that the High Court is
competent to exercise its powers of judicial review under Article
226 and 227 of the Constitution, when the validity of the order of
the Speaker is in question in writ jurisdiction, as laid down by the
Constitution Bench in Kihoto Hollohan vs. Zachillhu 8 , when the
challenge is made on the ground of ultra vires or mala fides or
having been made in colourable exercise of power based on
extraneous and irrelevant considerations. That situation has not
arisen in this case, as no decision has been taken by the Speaker
yet on merit.
33.
As a sequitur, Rule 6 (2) and Rule 7 (2) are
explained hereinabove.
The impugned order dated 02nd
February 2017 is not faulted with, as the same was rendered
1992 Supp (2) SCC 651
WP (PIL) No. 14 of 2017
Pahalman Subba & Ors. vs. The Hon’ble Speaker,
The Sikkim Legislative Assembly & Ors.
in accordance with rules as it stood at the relevant time,
thus, no interference is warranted. Consequently the other
reliefs sought cannot be ordered at this stage, thus,
rejected.
34.
Resultantly, the writ petition is disposed of.
No
order as to costs.
jk/
Approved for Reporting
Internet
Judge
Chief Justice
19.06.2018
19.06.2018
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review