Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE &
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, J.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Writ Petition (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
1.
Pahalman Subba,
S/o Lt. Ran Bahadur Subba,
aged about 82 years,
R/o Diesel Power House,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok-737 101,
East District of Sikkim.
2.
Nawin Kiran Pradhan,
S/o Harka Bahadur Pradhan,
Aged 33 years,
R/o Sisa Golai, 10 N-H Way,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok-737 101,
East District of Sikkim.
3.
Sonam Pintso Bhutia,
S/o Samduk Bhutia,
Aged 31 years,
R/o Somdong House, Upper Lingdum,
P.O. Dhajey Dara & P.S. Gangtok.
… Petitioners.
Versus
1.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having his office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
2.
The Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having his office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
3.
Department of Home,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary to the Home Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
4.
Department of Law & Parliamentary Affairs,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Law & Parliamentary Affairs Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
5.
Sikkim Legislative Assembly Secretariat,
Through the Secretary to the Sikkim
Legislative Assembly,
Having office at Sikkim Legislative Assembly
Secretariat at Gangtok-737 101.
6.
Shri Bikram Pradhan,
Hon‟ble Government Chief Whip,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
7.
Shri Danorbu Sherpa,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Tourism & Civil Aviation Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Tourism & Civil Aviation Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Tadong-737 102.
8.
Shri Karma Sonam Lepcha,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Roads & Bridges Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Roads & Bridges Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Nirman Bhawan,
Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
9.
Smt. Tilu Gurung,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Power Secretariat,
Gangtok-737 101.
10.
Shri Sonam Dadul Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Rural Management & Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Rural Management & Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
11.
Shri Ugen Nedup Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Health Care & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Health Care & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
12.
Shri Shyam Pradhan,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Human Resources Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Human Resources Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
13.
Shri Hemendra Adhikari,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Forest, Environment & Wildlife Management
Department, Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Forest, Environment & Wildlife Management
Department, Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
14.
Shri Gopal Baraily,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Building & Housing and Transport Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
15.
Dr. Mechung Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Food Security & Agriculture, Horticulture & Cash
Crops Development, Animal Husbandry &
Veterinary Services & Fisheries and Irrigation &
Flood Control Departments,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
16.
Shri Pintso Chopel Lepcha,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Urban Development & Housing and Food, Civl
Supplies & Consumer Affairs Departments,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
17.
Shri Timothy William Basnett,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Social Justice, Empowerment & Welfare and
Water Security & Public Health Engineering
Departments, Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
18.
Shri Bek Bahadur Rai,
Hon‟ble Chairman,
Public Accounts Committee,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Through the Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
19.
Smt. Chandra Maya Subba,
Hon‟ble Chairperson,
Estimates Committee,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Through the Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Having office at Gangtok-737 101.
… Respondents.
AND
Writ Petition (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (A Registered Political Party)
(A)
Through its General Secretary (Legal Cell)
Mr. Tashi Dadul Kazi,
S/o Late D.N. Kazi,
Aged about 58 years,
R/o Lower Samdong,
P.O. Raley Kheshey, Gangtok-737101,
East District of Sikkim.
(B)
Through its Secretary (Headquarters),
Mr. Kamal Neopaney,
S/o Pravakar Neopaney,
Aged about 33 years,
R/o Lower Sichey, Gangtok-737101,
East District of Sikkim.
… Petitioners.
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
2.
Secretary,
Department of Home,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
3.
Secretary,
Department of Law & Parliamentary Affairs,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
4.
Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly Secretariat,
Gangtok-737 101.
5.
Shri Ugen Nedup Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Health Care & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Health Care & Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
6.
Shri Shyam Pradhan,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Human Resources Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Human Resources Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
7.
Shri Hemendra Adhikari,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Forest, Environment & Wildlife Management
Department, Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Forest, Environment & Wildlife Management
Department, Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
8.
Shri Gopal Baraily,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Building & Housing and Transport Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Building & Housing & Transport Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
9.
Dr. Mechung Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Food Security & Agriculture, Horticulture & Cash
Crops Development, Animal Husbandry &
Veterinary Services & Fisheries and Irrigation &
Flood Control Departments,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
10.
Shri Pintso Chopel Lepcha,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Urban Development & Housing and Food, Civl
Supplies & Consumer Affairs Departments,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
11.
Shri Timothy William Basnett,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Social Justice, Empowerment & Welfare and
Water Security & Public Health Engineering
Departments, Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
12.
Shri Danorbu Sherpa,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Tourism & Civil Aviation Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Kendra, Gangtok-737 10 .
13.
Shri Karma Sonam Lepcha,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Roads & Bridges Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Roads & Bridges Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Nirman Bhawan, Gangtok-737 101.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
14.
Smt. Tilu Gurung,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Power Secretariat, Gangtok-737 101.
15.
Shri Sonam Dadul Bhutia,
Hon‟ble Parliamentary Secretary,
Rural Management & Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Rural Management & Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok-737 101.
16.
Shri Bikram Pradhan,
Government Chief Whip,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Manan Kendra,
Gangtok-737 101.
17.
Shri Bek Bahadur Rai,
Hon‟ble Chairman,
Public Accounts Committee,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Through the Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Gangtok-737 101.
18.
Smt. Chandra Maya Subba,
Hon‟ble Chairperson,
Estimates Committee,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Through the Secretary,
Sikkim Legislative Assembly,
Gangtok-737 101.
… Respondents.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
In W.P. (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Mr. O.P. Bhandari, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. A. Mariarputham, Advocate General, Mr. Karma
Thinlay, Sr. Govt. Advocate with Mr. Santosh Kr.
Chettri, Asstt Govt. Advocate for Respondents No. 1,
2, 3 and 4.
Mr. D.K. Siwakoti, Advocate for Respondent No. 5.
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Ms. Tashi D. Sherpa and Ms. Panila
Theengh, Advocates for Respondents No.6 to 17.
Mr. N. Rai, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri,
Ms. Malati Sharma and Mr. Suraj Chhetri, Advocates
for Respondents No. 18 and 19.
AND
In W.P. (C) No. 63 of 2016
Mr. Raghavendra Kumar, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. A. Mariarputham, Advocate General, Mr. Karma
Thinlay, Sr. Govt. Advocate with Mr. Santosh Kr.
Chettri, Asstt Govt. Advocate for Respondents No. 1, 2
and 3.
Mr. D.K. Siwakoti, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Panila Theengh and Ms.
Tashi D. Sherpa, Advocates for Respondents No. 5 to
16.
Mr. N. Rai, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri,
Ms. Malati Sharma and Mr. Suraj Chhetri, Advocates
for Respondents No. 17 and 18.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(25.08.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
W.P. (PIL) No. 04 of 2016 (hereinafter referred to as
“the first petition”) is filed by public spirited persons, in the
nature of Public Interest Litigation, questioning the legality and
constitutionality of the Sikkim State Legislators‟ Appointment to
Different Authorities Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Act of 2006”), Sikkim Parliamentary Secretaries (Appointment,
Salaries, Allowances and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2010
(hereinafter referred to as “the impugned Act”) and further
extension of status of Cabinet Minister and the Minister of State
with facilities and privileges to the Chief Whip.
Subsequently,
the provision of Section 3A(bb) of the Sikkim Legislative
Assembly Members (Removal of Disqualifications) Amendment
Act, 2006, by way of amendment of the petition, was also
challenged.
The petitioners have further prayed for quashment
of consequential notifications and also a declaration disqualifying
the sixth to nineteenth respondents from being members of the
Sikkim Legislative Assembly, on the ground of holding office of
profit.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
2.
W.P. (C) No. 63 of 2016 (hereinafter referred to as
“the second petition”) was filed by Sikkim Krantikari Morcha, a
political outfit, seeking reliefs on similar terms, questioning the
validity of various statutory provisions, as stated hereinabove,
during the currency of the first petition.
3.
Both the writ petitions involve a common question of
law, and as such are being considered jointly and disposed of by
this common order.
4.
The High Court, on preliminary examination, framed
the following questions of law in the first petition on 29 th August
2016: “(i)
whether the Parliamentary Secretaries appointed under
provisions
of
(Appointment,
the
Sikkim
Salaries,
Parliamentary
Allowances
and
Secretaries
Miscellaneous
Provisions) Act, 2010 (for short “the Act of 2010”), are
holding office of profit;
(ii)
if the answer of the first question is affirmative, whether
they have incurred disqualification as Legislature under
provisions of Article 191(a) of the Constitution of India;
(iii)
whether the Act of 2010 providing for appointment of
Parliamentary Secretary is violative of the provisions of
Article 102 read with Article 191 of the Constitution of India
and Section 9 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951;
and
(iv)
Whether „Explanation‟ to the provisions of Article 102 with
Article 191 of the Constitution of India may be expanded by
the Sikkim Legislative Assembly Members (Removal of
Disqualifications) Amendment Act, 2006.”
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
5.
In the meantime, the Supreme Court examined an
identical issue in Bimolangshu Roy (Dead) through LRs vs.
State of Assam and Another1, on 26th July 2017, wherein the
question involved was the constitutional validity of Assam
Parliamentary Secretaries (Appointment, Salaries, Allowances
and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2004 (hereinafter referred to
as “the Assam Act”) and held as under: “54. Thus, it can be seen from the scheme of Article
194 that it does not expressly authorize the State
Legislature to create offices such as the one in
question. On the other hand, Article 178 speaks about
the offices of Speaker and Deputy Speaker. Article
179 deals with the vacation of those offices or
resignations of incumbents of those offices whereas
Article 182 and 183 deal with the Chairman and
Deputy Chairman of the Legislative Council wherever
the Council exists. In our opinion, the most crucial
article in this Chapter is Article 187 which makes
stipulations even with reference to the secretarial staff
of the Legislature. On the face of such elaborate and
explicit constitutional arrangement with respect to the
Legislature and the various offices connected with the
legislature and matters incidental to them to read the
authority to create new offices by legislation would be
a wholly irrational way of construing the scope of
Article 194(3) and Entry 39 of List II.
Such a
construction would be enabling the legislature to make
a law which has no rational connection with the
subject matter of the entry. “The powers, privileges
and immunities” contemplated by Article 194(3) and
Entry 39 are those of the legislators qua legislators.
55.
For the above-mentioned reasons, we are of the
opinion that the Legislature of Assam lacks the
competence to make the impugned Act. In view of the
above conclusion, we do not see it necessary to
examine the various other issues identified by us
earlier in this judgment. The Writ Petition is allowed.
The impugned Act is declared unconstitutional.”
2017 SCC online SC 813
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
Resultantly, it was held that the State Legislature is
not competent to make an Act for appointment of Parliamentary
Secretaries circumventing the mandate ordained under Article
164 (1A) of the Constitution.
7.
At the outset, Mr. O.P. Bhandari, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners in the first petition and Mr.
Raghavendra
Kumar,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioners in the second petition submit that the petitioners be
permitted to confine their challenge to the constitutional validity
of the Sikkim Parliamentary Secretaries (Appointment, Salaries,
Allowances and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2010 only in these
petitions, seeking further permission to withdraw the challenge to
the provisions of other Acts, with liberty to question the same in
a different writ petition, at an appropriate stage.
8.
Mr. A. Mariarputham, learned Advocate General, Mr.
N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Jorgay Namka and Mr. D.K.
Siwakoti, Learned counsel appearing for the respondents have no
objection,
accordingly,
the
petitioners
were
permitted
to
withdraw the challenge on the issue of constitutional validity of
the Sikkim State Legislators‟ Appointment to Different Authorities
Act, 2006, extension of status of Cabinet Minister and the
Minister of State with facilities and privileges to the Chief Whip,
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
and the provision of Section 3A(bb) of the Sikkim Legislative
Assembly Members (Removal of Disqualifications) Amendment
Act, 2006 and also the consequential notifications, reserving
liberty to the petitioners to agitate the same, if so advised,
afresh in accordance with law.
9.
Mr. O.P. Bhandari, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners in the first petition would contend that the State
Legislature
by
an
enactment
of
the
impugned
Act
has
overreached the Parliament to defeat the mandate as enshrined
in Article 164 (1A) of the Constitution.
It is further contended
that the Parliamentary Secretaries are not only granted the
salary and perks of a Minister, but also assigned departments to
discharge the duties and functions of Ministers, as is evident from
the notifications dated 28th May 2014 (Annexure P-5), 30th
November 2015 (Annexure P-10) appointing the 7th to 17th
respondents
as
Parliamentary
Secretaries
and
other
consequential notifications, dated 30th November 2015 (Annexure
P-8) and 30th April 2016 (Annexure P-11).
10.
Referring to the judicial pronouncement made by the
Supreme Court in Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1, Mr. Bhandari
would
contend
that
the
validity
of
the
appointment
of
Parliamentary Secretaries stand settled on declaration of law by
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
the Supreme Court holding that the State Legislature lack
competence to make such an enactment for appointment of
Parliamentary Secretaries to assist the Ministers to discharge the
duties and responsibilities of a member of the Cabinet, thus, the
impugned Act deserves to be quashed.
11.
Mr. Bhandari would further contend that the 7th to 17th
respondents in the first petition, who were appointed as
Parliamentary Secretaries have become disqualified even to
continue as Members of Legislative Assembly on the ground of
holding the office of profit, which is proscribed under Article 191
of the Constitution of India and as such the direction to the same
effect be passed.
12.
Mr. Raghavendra Kumar, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners in second petition adopts the argument put
forth by Mr. Bhandari and submits that the impugned Act
deserves to be quashed with an order to quash the consequential
notifications granting status, salary, allowance and perks to the
said respondents.
13.
Mr.
A.
Mariarputham,
learned
Advocate
General
appearing for the State-respondents, in all fairness, submitted
that the law in respect of legality and validity of the enactment
and also appointment of Parliamentary Secretaries stands settled
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
by the judicial pronouncement of the Supreme Court and as such
the State-respondents have nothing much to argue on the issue.
The other respondents have also not contested the issue.
14.
On consideration and examination of the submissions
put forth by the learned counsel as well as on perusal of the
pleadings and documents appended thereto, it is explicit that the
question of law as to whether the State Legislature has legislative
competence to make an Act, which authorize the Chief Minister
to appointment Parliamentary Secretaries and further assigning
the duties and responsibilities to assist the Cabinet Ministers is
well settled in Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1.
15.
Article 141 of the Constitution of India mandates that
the law declared by Supreme Court is binding on all courts. The
observation made by the Supreme Court in various cases affirm
the proposition that ratio decidendi of a judgment which
constitutes a binding precedent, as the same enunciated on
points arising or raised in the case directly has a precedential
value.
As such, the ratio decidendi laid down by the Supreme
Court in Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1 is binding on this Court.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
16.
The Supreme Court in Union of India and others
vs. Kantilal Hematram Pandya2, held as under: “6.
……………… The approach of the Tribunal is
patently objectionable and does not commend to us.
It attempted to circumvent the law laid down by this
Court on untenable reasons by stating that “we are
required to consider the case on merits” without in
fact so considering. The law laid down by this Court is
binding on all courts and tribunals. Indeed, the law as
declared by this court has to be applied to the facts of
a given case and not applied mechanically but we find
that in the present case the facts were so eloquent
that no scope was available with the Tribunal to get
over the opinion expressed by this Court in Harnam
Singh case [(1993) 2 SCC 162] and on the facts as
established on the record the Tribunal had no option
but to refuse relief to the respondent.”
17.
The State Legislature enacted the impugned Act,
namely,
Sikkim
Parliamentary
Secretaries
(Appointment,
Salaries, Allowances and Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2010 and
received the assent of the Governor on 16 th September 2010,
thereafter, the impugned Act was published in the Sikkim
Extraordinary Government Gazette dated 27th September 2010.
Section 2 (c) of the Act defines “Parliamentary Secretary” as
under:
“2(c)
(1995) 3 SCC 17
“Parliamentary Secretary” means a Political
functionary as may be appointed by the Chief
Minister for one or more departments and to assist
the Minister concerned of such department or
departments
in
effective
disposal
of
the
government business, pertaining thereto, or as
may be decided by the Chief Minister.”
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Section 3 empowers the Chief Minister to appoint Parliamentary
Secretaries and assign to each of them such duties and functions
as he may deem fit and proper.
Section 4 contemplates
granting of rank and status of a Minister of State to the
Parliamentary Secretary and also confers power to discharge
such functions and duties as assigned by the Chief Minister.
Section
is
in
the
same
term.
Section
provides
for
administration of oath by the Chief Minister. Section 7 provides
for grant of salary and allowances as are admissible to a Minister
of State. Section 8 provides that a Parliamentary Secretary shall
not draw salary and allowances as a Member of the Sikkim
Legislative Assembly, while drawing salary and allowances for the
office as Parliamentary Secretary.
Section 10 provides that all
other conditions of service of a Parliamentary Secretary shall be
governed by the Sikkim Ministers, Speaker, Deputy Speaker and
Members
of
Sikkim
Allowances) Act, 1977.
Legislative
Assembly
(Salaries
and
Except administration of oath, duties,
functions, salaries and allowances are at par with the State
Ministers.
18.
The
issue
as
to
whether
appointment
of
the
Parliamentary Secretaries infringes the provisions of Article 164
(1A) of the Constitution, came up for consideration before
various High Courts.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
19.
A Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab &
Haryana in Jagmohan Singh Bhatti vs. Union of India &
Others, etc.3, on an identical issue, held as under: “In the light of the above, it is quite evident that :(a)
The Governor of the State or the legislature has
no competence or legislative sanction to frame rules
regulating the conditions of appointment and services
of Chief Parliamentary Secretaries and Parliamentary
Secretaries for their functioning within the House of
the State Assembly.
Such posts are not part of
regular services of the State under the executive
forming part of the bodies involved in the governance
of the State;
(b)
The services under the State are entirely
different from services within the Assembly House.
Rules for governing the services under the State or its
executive can be made in exercise of powers conferred
by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution as
also under the authority conferred by Entry 41 of ListII of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, i.e. the
State List, which provides for: “State Public Services;
State Public Service Commission”. These evidently
relate to executive services under the State.
However, in case a person is working as a
Parliamentary Secretary under the State executive, he
shall not be disqualified for being a member of the
Punjab State Assembly in view of the provisions of the
Disqualification Act 1952 which provides that a person
shall not be disqualified for being chosen as, and for
being, a member of Punjab State Legislature by
reason for the fact that he holds the office of
Parliamentary Secretary or Parliamentary Under
Secretary under the Government of the State of
Punjab.
The holding of the office of Chief
Parliamentary Secretary, therefore, is evidently
contemplated under the Government of the State of
Punjab and not as a link between the Ministers and the
administrative Secretaries.
(c)
The provisions of Article 162 of the Constitution
relate to the extent of executive power of the State
and that the executive power of the State shall extend
to matters with respect to which the legislature of the
State has power to make laws. The power sought to
be derived by the officials respondents is in the
context of Article 309 of the Constitution. The 2006
(2016) 184 PLR 110
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Rules have been framed by the State in exercise of the
powers of Article 162 of the Constitution relate to
services under the State of the executive and not that
of the legislature.
(d)
The appointments of Chief Parliamentary
Secretaries are contrary to the Constitutional intent of
limiting the number of Ministers or the size of the
Cabinet. The appointments as made, therefore, are in
fact a roundabout way of bypassing the Constitutional
mandate of the provisions of Article 164 (1A) of the
Constitution and, therefore, have to be invalidated.
For the foregoing reasons, both the writ petitions are
allowed and the appointment of the private
respondents in both the petitions and their continuing
as Chief Parliamentary Secretaries are set aside,
invalidated and quashed. There shall, however, be no
order as to costs.”
20.
In Vishak Bhattacharya vs. The State of West
Bengal & Ors. 4 , the constitutionality of the West Bengal
Parliamentary Secretaries (Appointment, Salaries, Allowance and
Miscellaneous Provision) Act of 2012 came up for consideration in
the High Court at Calcutta, the Division Bench held the
enactment as unconstitutional.
21.
In the case before us, the learned Advocate General
and other learned counsel appearing for the parties have
emphatically not contested the issued in the light of the judicial
pronouncement
of
the
Supreme
Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1.
Court
on
issue
in
The Supreme Court examining
the provisions of the Assam Act, held as under:
the
W.P. 7326 (W) of 2013 and W.P. 8321 (W) of 2013
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“21.
However, the more accurate legal position is
expounded in Union of India & Others v. Shah
Goverdhan L. Kabra Teachers‟ College, (2002) 8 SCC
228 at para 6:
“In view of the rival submissions at the Bar, the
question that arises for consideration is whether
the impugned legislation can be held to be a law
dealing with coordinated development of
education system within Entry 66 of List I of the
Seventh Schedule or it is a law dealing with the
service conditions of an employee under the
State Government. The power to legislate is
engrafted under Article 246 of the Constitution
and the various entries for the three lists of the
Seventh Schedule are the “fields of legislation”.
The different entries being legislative heads are
all of enabling character and are designed to
define and delimit the respective areas of
legislative competence of the Union and the
State Legislatures. They neither impose any
restrictions on the legislative power nor
prescribe any duty for exercise of the legislative
power in any particular manner. It has been a
cardinal principle of construction that the
language of the entries should be given the
widest scope of which their meaning is fairly
capable and while interpreting an entry of any
list it would not be reasonable to import any
limitation therein.
The rule of widest
construction, however, would not enable
the legislature to make a law relating to a
matter which has no rational connection
with the subject-matter of an entry. When
the vires of enactment is challenged, the
court primarily presumes the constitutionality of
the statute by putting the most liberal
construction upon the relevant legislative entry
so that it may have the widest amplitude and
the substance of the legislation will have to be
looked into. The court sometimes is dutybound to guard against extending the
meaning of the words beyond their
reasonable connotation in anxiety to
preserve the power of the legislature.
22.
The jurisprudential basis for the “rule of widest
construction” is the hallowed belief that a Constitution
is drafted with an eye on future providing a continuing
framework for exercise of governmental power.
Therefore, it must be elastic enough to meet new
social,
political
and
historical
realities
often
unimagined by the framers of the Constitution.
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
23.
Chief Justice Marshall‟s celebrated statement in
McCulloch v. Maryland, 17 US 316 (1819) that “… we
must never forget that it is a constitution we are
expounding” is the starting point. It was a statement
made in the context of the interpretation of Article I of
the US Constitution which declares the authority of
“the Congress” to perform various functions
enumerated in sub-sections (1) to (17) of Section 8
and under sub-Section (18) “to make all laws
necessary and proper to carrying into execution of the
powers vested in the Congress by the preceding 17
sub-sections.”.
It is further held as under: “28.
The authority to make law flows not only from
an express grant of power by the Constitution to a
legislative body but also by virtue of implications
flowing from the context of the Constitution is well
settled by the various decisions of the Supreme Court
of America in the context of American Constitution. A
principle which is too well settled in all the jurisdictions
where a written Constitution exists. The US Supreme
Court also recognised that the Congress would have
the authority to legislate with reference to certain
matters because of the fact that such authority is
inherent in the nature of the sovereignty.
The
doctrine of inherent powers was propounded by Justice
Sutherland in the context of the role of the American
Government in handling foreign affairs and the
limitations thereon. [United States v. Curtiss – Wright
Export Corp., 299 U.S. 304, 81 L. Ed. 255]
29.
In substance, the power to make the legislation
flows from various sources: (1) express text of the
Constitution; (2) by implication from the scheme of
the Constitution; and (3) as an incident of
sovereignty.”
22.
Indisputably,
the
source
of
authority
to
make
legislation emanates from Article 246 of the Constitution in
respect of all the matters enumerated in each of the three lists
contained in Seventh Schedule.
23.
The Supreme Court in several cases have clearly and
repeatedly held that the entries in the various lists of the
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Seventh Schedule are not sources of legislative power but are
only indicative of the fields which the appropriate legislature is
competent to legislate.
It is apposite to refer to observations
made by the Supreme Court in various cases.
24.
In Harakchand Ratanchand Banthia and others
vs. Union of India and others 5, a Constitution Bench of the
Supreme Court held as under:
“8.
Before construing these entries it is useful to
notice some of the well-settled rules of interpretation
laid down by the Federal Court and by this Court in the
matter of construing the entries.
The power to
legislate is given to the appropriate Legislatures by
Article 246 of the Constitution. The entries in the
three lists are only legislative heads or fields of
legislation; they demarcate the area over which the
appropriate Legislatures can operate.
It is wellestablished that the widest amplitude should be given
to the language of the entries. But some of the
entries in the different lists or in the same list may
overlap or may appear to be in direct conflict with
each other. It is then the duty of this Court to
reconcile the entries and bring about a harmonious
construction. ………………………………”
25.
In Union of India vs. Shri Harbhajan Singh
Dhillon6, the Supreme Court held as under:
“22.
It must be remembered that the function of the
lists is not to confer powers; they merely demarcate
the legislative field. …………”
26.
Subsequently, in Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd.
and others vs. State of U.P. and others7, again a Constitution
Bench observed as under:
1969 (2) SCC 166
1971 (2) SCC 779
(1990) 1 SCC 109
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“67.
…………………………………… It is well settled that the
various entries in the three lists of the Indian Constitution
are not powers but fields of legislation. The power to
legislate is given by Article 246 and other Articles of the
Constitution. The three lists of the Seventh Schedule to the
Constitution are legislative heads or fields of legislation.
These demarcate the area over which the appropriate
legislatures can operate.
It is well settled that widest
amplitude should be given to the language of the entries in
three Lists but some of these entries in different lists or in
the same list may override and sometimes may appear to
be in direct conflict with each other, then and then only
comes the duty of the court to find the true intent and
purpose and to examine the particular legislation in
question. Each general word should be held to extend to all
ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly and
reasonably be comprehended in it. In interpreting an entry
it would not be reasonable to import any limitation by
comparing or contrasting that entry with any other in the
same list. It has to be interpreted as the Constitution must
be interpreted as an organic document in the light of the
experience gathered.
In the constitutional scheme of
division of powers under the legislative lists, there are
separate entries pertaining to taxation and other laws.
………………………………”
27.
It is a trite law that the true nature and character of
legislation is determined to which Entry it belongs, in its pith and
substance. The Supreme Court in Southern Pharmaceuticals
and Chemicals, Trichur and others v. State of Kerala and
others8 observed as under: “13.
In determining whether an enactment is a legislation
“with respect to” a given power, what is relevant is not the
consequences of the enactment on the subject-matter or
whether it affects it, but whether, in its pith and substance,
it is a law upon the subject-matter in question. ………”
28.
Gleaning through various entries in List-II of the
Seventh Schedule (State List), it is luculent that the creation of
post of Parliamentary Secretary is seemingly referable to Entries
37, 39 and 40 of the List-II.
(1981) 4 SCC 391
On critical examination, it is
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
evidently plain and clear that the Entries setting out the field of
legislation therein do not contemplate creation of posts of
Parliamentary Secretaries. The post of Parliamentary Secretaries
are clothed with the insignia of Ministers with their duties and
functions, which is subject to the limitation prescribed under
Article 164 (1A) of the Constitution of India. In case of Sikkim,
the maximum number of Council of Ministers cannot exceed
twelve.
29.
Article 164(1A) was incorporated in the Constitution
by the Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003 with
effect from 01st January 2004 restricting the number of Ministers
in the Council of Ministers, which reads as under :
“(1A) The total number of Ministers, including the
Chief Minister, in the Council of Ministers in a State
shall not exceed fifteen per cent. of the total number
of members of the Legislative Assembly of that State:
Provided that the number of Ministers, including the
Chief Minister in a State shall not be less than twelve:
Provided further that where the total number of
Ministers including the Chief Minister in the Council of
Ministers in any State at the commencement of the
Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003
exceeds the said fifteen per cent. or the number
specified in the first proviso, as the case may be, then
the total number of Ministers in that State shall be
brought in conformity with the provisions of this clause
within six months from such date (7th January, 2004)
as the President may by public notification appoint.”
30.
Article 164 (1) provides for the appointment of the
Ministers by the Governor on the advice of the Chief Minister. In
the case on hand, the Parliamentary Secretaries were appointed
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
as Ministers of State and became a part of Council of Ministers
without there being any appointment by the Governor, as
required.
31.
The Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok
Sabha while defining the term „Minister‟ states that it means a
Member of the Council of Ministers and includes a member of the
Cabinet Minister of State or Deputy Minister or a „Parliamentary
Secretary‟.
Likewise, Rule 2 of the Rules of Procedure and
Conduct of Business in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly defines
“Minister” means a member of the Council of Ministers, a Minister
of State or a Deputy Minister and “Member” means a Member of
the Sikkim Legislative Assembly.
Examining the provisions of
the impugned Act as well as subsequent notifications to give
effect thereto, it is apparent that the Parliamentary Secretaries
are privy to official information, all of them having access to
official files, official documents in the course of decision making
process by the Council of Ministers, and discharge the duties and
functions assigned to the Ministers.
As aforestated, the
Parliamentary Secretaries, partaking character of Ministers is
manifestly impermissible in the light of mandate enshrined under
Article 164(1A) of the Constitution and is unconstitutional. The
appointment of Parliamentary Secretaries under the impugned
Act is a pretence to circumvent the provisions of constitutional
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
provision, as incorporated in the Constitution of India by Ninetyfirst amendment.
Moreover, the Supreme Court has held in
Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1 that the State Legislature lacks the
competence to appoint Parliamentary Secretaries. In such view
of the matter, without examining further in detail, which is not
contended by either parties, we are of the considered view that
the issue of the constitutionality of the impugned Act is squarely
covered by the judicial pronouncement made by the Supreme
Court in Bimolangshu Roy (Dead)1.
32.
Accordingly,
consequential
the
notifications
impugned
deserve
to
Act
be
and
other
quashed.
The
Parliamentary Secretaries, so appointed under the Act shall cease
to function as Parliamentary Secretaries and shall also cease to
draw and avail salaries, allowances, perks, etc. as admissible
under the Act forthwith.
33.
A feeble attempt is made by the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners to submit that on account of
quashing of aforestated impugned Act, the respondents, who are
Members of the Legislative Assembly, be declared as disqualified
to continue as members.
Article 192 of the Constitution
mandates that the question as to the disqualification of a Member
shall be referred to the decision of the Governor and the decision
WP (PIL) No. 04 of 2016
Pahalman Subba & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
And
WP (C) No. 63 of 2016
Sikkim Krantikari Morcha Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
shall be final. In such view of the matter, we are not inclined to
pass any order on the issue.
34.
As
a
sequel,
Sikkim
Parliamentary
Secretaries
(Appointment, Salaries, Allowances and Miscellaneous Provisions)
Act, 2010 and consequential notifications are declared as
unconstitutional and, accordingly, quashed.
35.
In view of the aforestated backdrop, we are not
inclined to examine the other issues, which are not necessary at
this stage, for the fact that the petitioners have withdrawn the
challenge in the instant petition
36.
jk/pm
The petitions are allowed. No order as to costs.
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
Judge
Chief Justice
25.08.2017
25.08.2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review