Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
| 344? 1
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
IVIONDAY, THE NINETEENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
SECOND APPEAL NO: 460 OF 2025
Appeal under Sectron '100 of CPC aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated
13.06 2025 rn A.S.No. 14 of 2024 on the file of the Court of the Vl Additional Distrrct
Judge, at Sathupalli, confirming the judgment and decree dated 06.O2.2O24 in
O.S.No. 1 15 of 2016 on the file of the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, at Sathupalli.
Between:
Pagidipalli Isaaku, S/o Late Yesu, Aged about 58 years, occ Teacher R/o
lrladhira Village and N,4andal, Khammam District
...APPELLANT/APPELLANT-DEFENDANT
AND
Vemulapalli Veera Venkata Laxmi Narasimha Rao, S/o Arjuna Rao, Age. 54
years occ. Teacher R/o Madhira Village and lVlandal, Khammam District.
...RESPONDENT/RESPONDNET-PLAINTIFF
l.A. No.'1 oF 2025
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
pending
disposal of the second appeal, to suspend the Decree and Judgment Dated.
OG.O2.2024 in O.S No. 115 of 2016 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge at
Sathupalli.
Counsel for the Appellant : Sri. Gunturu Sushanth Kumar
Counsel for the Respondent : The Court delivered the following:
rl
IN THE COURT FOR THE STATE OF TEL I NGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOU RABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENU T A YARA
Second App eal No.46O of2025
19TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
Between:
Pagidipalli Isaakr-r
Appellant / appellant 7 r efeudant
and
Vemulapalli Veer:r Venkata Laxmi Narasimha Rao
...Re spondent/ respondt:tl ,r plarntiff
JUDGMENT:
Heard Sri G. Sushanth Kumar, learned t: r'-lnsel for the
appellant/ appellant/defendant, on the questiori of admission'
Perused the record.
2.
This Sccond Appeal is preferred by tlrr: appellant/
appellant/defendant aggrieved by the judgmer t and decree
dated 13.06.2025 in A.S.No. 14 of 2024 passerl
'r'7 the learned
VI Additional District Judge at Sathupalli (for ;-rort 'the First
Appeliate Court') conhrming the Judgment anrl Decree dated
\
\
06.02.2024 in O.S.No.115 of 2016 passed by the learned
Senior Civil Judge at Sathupalli (for short 'the Trial Court'),
rn'herein, a suit filed lor rccovery of money has been dccreed
and the same has been conhrmed by the First Appeilate Court
in appeal.
3.
The background facts of the case are that the
respondent/ plaintiff filed suit lor recovery of money on the
basis of a promissory note and the office copy of legal notice
issued to the appellant herein. The case of the respondent was
that the appellant borrowed Rs.4,0O,000 l- to be repaid with
interest at 24ol' per annum, but failed to repay the borrowed
amount. Thereafter, the appellant issued a cheque for
Rs.5,OO,0OO/- drawn on SBH, Madhira Branch and then the
same was submitted for realisation. The cheque was returned
with endorsement 'insufficient funds'. Therefore, a legal notice
was issued for repayment of the money followed by hling of a
complaint under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act,
which resulted in hling of charge sheet under C.C.No.272 of
2014. There was no hope of recovering the promissory note
i
I
\
J
arnount with interest and therefore, suit for rer:c' ery of money
has been filed
The appellant /defendant opposed the r.rit claim by
4.
I
denying the cause of action for filing the sr.rit' 'he appellant
claimed never to harre borrou''ed the amount of ls.4,0O,OO0/
to be repaid u'ith intercst, ne\rer executed the plt rnissory note,
and that the suit promissory note is not ;rrpported by
consideration. Further, it is alleged tl-rat thr: 'espondent is
doing money lending business without any licerL ;c to do so. ln
the process of doing money lending business, ll Lr: respondent
is collecting empty signed promissory notes all: blank signed
cheques from the borrowers who have obtainecl I ral from him.
The respondent had borrowed Rs.5O,0OC, - lrom the
respondent in the year 20 10, but the same he
I
been repaid.
Though the loan amount was repaid, the resp: rdent did not
return the cheque and the same has been fabri,; r.ted to Iile the
suit. Further, a list of cases wherein the resp<r rdent hled for
recovery of money are mentioned in the 'claint. More
particularly, complaint in C.C.Nos.27O of 201'1 27I of 2Ol4
I
I
\
and 269 ol 2014 have been listed to a11ege that the respondent
is engaged in money lending business without registering
under Money Lender Act. It is alleged that there are no bona
fides or prima facie case and therefore, the suit is liable to be
dismissed.
5.
Upon examining the casc of both the respondent and
the appellant, the Trial Court decreed the suit. The Trial Court
observed that the appellant clid not choose to examine any
witness and did not lead evidence ro show that Ex.A1
promissory note is a forged and fabricated document. There
was no enmity between the parties in order to have any motive
for lorging the suit promissory note. The oral evidence of pW1
and PW2 coupled with the documentary evidence in Ex.A1
promissory note, Ex. A,2 legal notice and
trx.A3
acknowledgment card were found to be sulhcient to discharge
the burden of proof of the respondent whereas there was no
evidence on behalf of the appellant to discharge his onus of
proof. The witness PW2 deposed that the suit transaction took
place in his presence and there was nothing contra elicited
(
I
during cross examination to doubt the veracity cI his evidence
There was no enmity or ill motivc suggested to FI y's 1 and 2 in
their cross examination in order to attribr,r t I motive for
labricating the suit promissory note. The evi lence of the
respondent as PW1 and the witness to the prort ssory note as
PW2 was corroborative and consistent in supp() 'l,inq the suit
claim and therefore, the suit was decreed. Agil ievcd by the
same, the appellant herein prelerred the Fir s t Appeal vide
A.S.No.14 of 2024 belore the First Appellate Cour ,
6.
The First Appeilate Court also appreciate: the evidence
on record on behalf of the respondent througl-r i'Ws 1 an:d 2
and'Exs.Al to A3 and absence of any docur---nts hled on
behalf of the appellant to prove money lending t - rnsactions by
the respondent. There r.r,as defence taken aboul a transaction
of Rs.SO,OOO/- between the parties wherein a trlank signed
cheque and blank signed promissory note were h ,rnded over to
the respondent. There is a defence takr: r that said
Rs.5O,00O/- was repaid but the respondent tz.: [r:d to return
the promissory note and the same was uscd f.:r filing the
a
present suit. In case, such misuse was done by the
respondent, the appellant herein ought to have initiated
criminal or civil proceedings against the appeliant, but such is
not the case. With respect to the respondent being a money
lender without license, it is held that there \ /as no evidence to
prove that the respondent was engaged in money lending
business. Also, though forgery ar-rd fabrication is alleged and
there was 1ibert1. to lead evidence to prove the same, the
appellant herein did not take steps to prove the same. Both
the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court have held that
there is no evidence on record to prove that the respondent is
engaged in money lending business witl-rout license. As such,
the appeal was also dismissed confirming the judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court. Aggrieved by the same, the
Second Appeal is preferred wherein thc following substantial
questions of law are raised:
a) Whether the judgment and decree is matntainable
without framing an issue about specihc defense
raised by the appellant/defendant in his written
statement i.e., whether the respondent/ plaintiff is
running money lending business in the absence of a
license under AP (Telangana Area) Motrrr - Lenders
Act?
b) Whether- the judgment and decree can be
maintainable in the absence of a license t nder A.P.
(Telangana Area) Money Lenders Act, 13'l') Irasli?
c) Whether, in the light of the admitted fact that
respon cl ent/ plaintiff himself admitted in his cross
examination stating that he is doing morL, l' lending
business, the trial Court and lou,er appt l zrte court
misleading the evidence sustainable?
d) Whether admitted facts in cross examinati r-r of PW 1
need not to be proved by placing evidence)
.
The above substantial questions of l:n ' do n<:t
qualify to be substantial questions of law for t re simple
reason that a1l the questions revolve around ,\ t-rether ()r
not the respondent is doing money lending bu; tress and
whether such an issue need to have been frarr:d b1, lhs
Trial Court and whether the Judgment ald - e cree are
maintainable without a money lending licence i - lavour of
the respondent and whether admission abo - [ lending
money to some of the borrowers in his cross t:;r rmination
1S
sufficient to prove that the respondent is r: rgaged 1n
money lending business
I
It
o
B.
It is a point to be noted that the Trial Court
addressed this issrre and has held that lenciing money to
colleagues does not qualify to be called as a money lending
business which requires license. Further, it is held that
the appellant did not lead any et,idence to prove that the
respondent is engaged in money lending br,tsiness. There is
a finding to the effect that the respondcnt was lending
money to acquaintances, but, there is no cvidencc to prove
that the respondent is engaged in mone5' ler-rding business
No such issue was framed and it is held that there was no
need to frame an issue to said effect. lt is held that the
issues that were framed were sufltcient to adjudicate the
controversy between the parties. Thus. lroth the Trial
Court and the First Appellate Court have addressed the
issue of whether or not the respondent was engaged in
money lending business sufficiently
9.
The learned counsel for appellant referred to
judgment of this Court in the case of Venkatesh Shinde v.
I
P. Rameshchand Bhandari and otherst, r""ht'r:in, it is
held that non-rcgistration of a person as mone\' lr rLder' the
suit b1' person lor rccovetl'of money liab1e to br
r;rllissccl'
rf sucl-r person does not hold license granted ur'r ' l section
3 (2) otA.P. (Tr:langana Area) Money lrnders Act
Said
or-der was rendered in a Civil Revision Pcrj ion filed
cl-rallenging thc dismissai of interlocutory appli': L-ion file c1
lor framing ol issues. ln case, the appellant lreitt u'its
palticular about framing of an issue about the ' 'spouder-lt
being a money lender without license, he ougl 1 to have
fi1cd an application before the Trial Court for frrl ning su<;h
an issue alter the issues were framed during t a1' f{avir-ig
failed to insist upon the Trial Court to fratr t an issue
about whether or not the respondent is a n)() rey ler-rder
without licensc, this issue cannot be agitater zLt Seco n d
\
Appeal stage.
10. A Second Appeal under Section 100 lf CPC is
maintainable only when there are substantial - -:.estions of
!
I
i
!
i
I
l
I
' loo(, (+t Al.D it')
r
l0
law to be adjudicated. In the instant case, the appellant
failed to raise any substanlial question of law. As alreadl,
discussed, the questions of lari, that :rre raised are
questions of fact about whether or not the rcspondent rs a
money lender and whether or not he is having registration
under the A.P. prlangana Area) Money Lenders Act. Due
I
,to. failure to raise supstantial questions of larv, there are no
merits in the Second Appeal and tl.re sanre is liable to be
dismissed
. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed at the
stage of admission. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if an1,, shall stand
closed.
SD/- P. GOWRI SHANKAR
-DEPUTY REGIST
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1 The Vl Additional District Judge, at Sathupalli. (With records)
2. The Senior Civil Judge, at Sathupalli.
3 One CC to Sri. Gunturu Sushanth Kumar, Advocate [OPUC]
4. iwo CD Copies
fu.
DLlPSI-
i; ir'l
/.,
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1910112026
: :-,:. '.1.
,.its J,ri)-.;:
( F.
JUDGMENT
SA.No.460 of 2025
oo
I ii:B 2026
t-
*
1ic
DISMISSED AT THE STAGE OF ADMISI;ION
G,,
6 v
z.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review