Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25284
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 45280 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
P.P. VINODKUMAR
AGED 60 YEARS
S/O ACHUTHAN, RESIDING AT KUDIYIRIKKAL HOUSE,
HS ROAD, CHERUPULACHERRY, PALAKKAD DISTRICT,
PIN - 679503
BY ADV C.DINESH
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, REVENUE (DEVASWOM)
DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, GOVT. PRESS P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
HOUSEFED COMPLEX, ERANHIPALAM P.O.,
KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673006
THE COMMISSIONER
MALABAR DEVASWAM BOARD,
MALABAR DEVASWAM BOARD OFFICE,
ERANJIPPALAM, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673006
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
MALABAR DEVASWAM BOARD,
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OFFICE,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679513
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER
PUTHANALKKAL BHAGAVATHY TEMPLE,
CHERPULASSERY PO, PALAKKAD DISTRICT,
PIN - 679503
INSPECTOR
MALABAR DEVASWAM BOARD,
OTTAPPALAM DIVISION, INSPECTOR’S OFFICE,
CHERPULASSERY PO, PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
HEREDITARY TRUSTEE
PUTHANALKKAL BHAGAVATHY TEMPLE,
CHERPULASSERY, PO, PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
MANIKANDHAN K
AGED 50 YEARS
S/O KRISHNAN, KOTTACHALIL HOUSE,
CHERPULASSERY, PO, PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
V.K VIJAKAKRISHNAN
AGED 54 YEARS
S/O BHASKARANKUTTY, RESIDING AT PULAKKATKUZHIYIL,
CHERPULASSERY, PO,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
V. KRISHNADASAN
AGED 56 YEARS
S/O V. APPU, RESIDING AT VATTAPAARMBIL,
CHERPULASSERY, PO, PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
M.P AYYAPPANKUTTY
AGED 62 YEARS
S/O, MV KUNJIRAMAN, RESIDING AT
MANDAKKARIPARAMBIL, CHERPULASSERY, PO,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
AJITH SANKAR K
AGED 47 YEARS
S/O VASUDEVAN K, RESIDING AT ATHULYAM,
KAIRALI NAGAR, CHERPULASSERY, PO,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN - 679503
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
BY ADVS.
R.RANJANIE
MAHESH V RAMAKRISHNAN
PRAVEEN K.S.(K/2191/2021)
SARATH SANKAR S.(K/002418/2023)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON
25.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The petitioner, who is a devotee of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy
Temple, Cherpulassery, which is a controlled institution under the
2nd respondent Malabar Devaswom Board, has filed this writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a
writ of mandamus commanding the 3rd respondent Commissioner,
Malabar Devaswom Board, to proceed with the appointment of nonhereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple, strictly in
terms of disqualification and eligibility clauses provided in Ext.P1
notification dated 28.06.2024 issued by the 3rd respondent
Commissioner and also the law laid down by this Court in
Muraleedharan M. and another v. Malabar Devaswom Board
and others [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], Chathu Achan K. v. State
of Kerala and others [2022 (6) KLT 388] and Anantha
Narayanan and another v. Malabar Devaswom Board and
others [2023 KLT OnLine 1195]. The petitioner has also sought
for a writ of mandamus commanding respondents 3 to 6 to consider
Ext.P3 representation dated 26.10.2024 and Ext.P6 representation
dated 04.12.2024 raising objections, in accordance with the
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
directions
contained
in
the
2025:KER:25284
judgment
of
this
Court
in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20] before proceeding
with the process of appointment of respondents 8 to 12 as nonhereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple.
2.
On 19.12.2024, when this writ petition came up for
admission, this Court passed the following order;
"The petitioner, who is a devotee of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy
Temple, Cherpulassery, which is a controlled institution under
the 2nd respondent Malabar Devaswom Board, has filed this
writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
seeking a writ of mandamus commanding the 3rd respondent
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, to proceed with
the appointment of non-hereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal
Bhagavathy Temple, strictly in terms of the disqualification
and eligibility clauses provided in Ext.P1 notification dated
28.06.2024 issued by the 3rd respondent Commissioner and
also the law laid down by this Court in Muraleedharan M.
v. Malabar Devaswom Board and others [2024 (6) KHC
SN 20], Chathu Achan K. v. State of Kerala [2022 (6)
KLT 388] and Anantha Narayanan and another v.
Malabar Devaswom Board and others [2023 KLT
OnLine 1195]. The petitioner has also sought for a writ of
mandamus commanding the 3rd respondent Commissioner
and the 6th respondent Inspector, Malabar Devaswom Board,
Ottapalam, Division, to consider Ext.P3 objection dated
26.10.2024 and Ext.P6 objection dated 04.12.2024, in
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
accordance with the directions contained in the decision of
this Court in Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20],
before proceeding with the process of appointment of
respondents
to
as
non-hereditary
trustees
of
Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple, Cherpulassery. In the writ
petition, it is alleged that respondents 8 to 12, who are going
to be appointed as non-hereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal
Bhagavathy Temple are active politicians and as such they
are
having
the
disqualifications
provided
in
Ext.P1
notification.
2. The decision of this Court in Muraleedharan M. [2024
(6) KHC SN 20] was under challenge before the Apex Court
in SLP(C)No.2911 of 2024, which ended in dismissal by the
order dated 13.12.2024.
3. Admit.
4. The learned Senior Government Pleader takes notice for
the 1st respondent. The learned Standing Counsel for Malabar
Devaswom Board takes notice for respondents 2 to 4 and 6.
5. Issue urgent notice by speed post to respondents 5 and 7
to 12, returnable by 13.01.2025.
6. The learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom
Board seeks time to get instructions as to whether the 3 rd
respondent Commissioner, has issued any circular in the
matter of appointment of non-hereditary trustees in temples
which are controlled institutions under the Board, taking note
of the directions contained in the decision of this Court in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20].
7. The selection process for the appointment of nonhereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple,
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
Cherpulassery,
pursuant
2025:KER:25284
to
Ext.P1
notification
dated
28.06.2024 issued by the 3rd respondent Commissioner, shall
be proceeded strictly in terms of the directions contained in
Paragraph
of
the
decision
of
this
Court
in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20]. However, the
consideration of the report of the Committee constituted for
a comparative assessment of the applicants with specific
reference to the eligibilities and disqualifications provided in
the guidelines dated 18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner
of the erstwhile Hindu Religious Charitable and Endowments
(Administration) Department, by the competent authority in
the 1st respondent Malabar Devaswom Board shall be
deferred for the time being. The files relating to Ext.P1
notification dated 28.06.2024 along with the report of the
said Committee shall be made available for the perusal of this
Court, in a sealed cover, on the next posting date."
3.
The order dated 19.12.2024 was followed by the order
dated 13.01.2025 which reads thus;
"In
paragraph
of
the
“SLP(C)No.2911
of
2024”
is
order
dated
suo
motu
19.12.2024,
corrected
as
“SLP(C)No.29188 of 2024”.
2. Pursuant to the order of this Court dated 19.12.2024 the
learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board has
made available for perusal of this Court the files relating to
Ext.P1 notification dated 28.06.2024 for appointment of nonhereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple,
Cherpulassery. Page No.53 of that file contains a report dated
26.12.2024 of the 4th respondent Assistant Commissioner,
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
addressed to the 3rd respondent Commissioner, after taking
note of the report dated 21.12.2024 of the 6 th respondent
Inspector, Ottappalam Division, wherein it is stated that
among the applicants, respondents 8 to 11 are active
politicians, who are disqualified from being appointed as nonhereditary trustees of the temple in question. As per the said
report, the applications of respondents 8 to 11, which are
supported by false affidavits, need not be considered in the
process of selection pursuant to Ext.P1 notification.
3. The learned counsel for respondents 8 to 12 seeks time to
file counter affidavit and three weeks' time granted.
4. The learned Standing Counsel to retain the files.
5. The learned Standing Counsel for the Malabar Devaswom
Board would submit that though the Commissioner, Malabar
Devaswom Board has not issued any circular taking note of
the directions contained in the judgment of this Court in
Muraleedharan M. v. Malabar Devaswom Board and
others [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], after the dismissal of
SLP(C)No.29188 of 2024 by the order dated 13.12.2024, the
directions contained in the said judgment are being complied
with, in letter and spirit, in all appointments to the post of
non-hereditary trustees to the temples which are controlled
institutions
under
Malabar
Devaswom
Board.
Said
submission made by the learned Standing Counsel for the
Board is recorded."
4.
On 07.02.2025, when this writ petition came up for
consideration, along with a connected matter, the learned Standing
Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board pointed out the order of the
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
Apex Court dated 20.01.2025 in SLP(C) Diary No.60879 of 2024,
arising out of the judgment of this Court in Muraleedharan M.
[2024 (6) KHC SN 20]. The said SLP is one filed by the Malabar
Devaswom
Board
and
its
officials,
after
the
dismissal
of
SLP(C)No.29188 of 2024. In SLP(C) Diary No.60879 of 2024, while
issuing notice to the respondents, the Apex Court confined the
scope of consideration only with respect to clauses (iii) and (iv) in
paragraph 154 of the judgment in Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6)
KHC SN 20] and the order of stay is also confined to that extent
alone.
5.
In the order dated 07.02.2025, this Court noticed the
submission made by the learned Standing Counsel for Malabar
Devaswom Board, after referring to the aforesaid order of the Apex
Court that, after complying with the procedure contemplated in
clauses (i) and (ii) of paragraph 154 of the judgment in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], i.e., consideration of
the objections after obtaining individual reports from the concerned
Divisional Inspector and comparative assessment of the applicants
with specific reference to the eligibilities and disqualifications
provided in the guidelines dated 18.05.2004 issued by the
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
Commissioner
erstwhile
Hindu
2025:KER:25284
Religious
and
Charitable
Endowments (Administration) Department shall be made by the
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board or the concerned Area
Committee, as the case may be. The learned Standing Counsel
sought time to place on record an affidavit of the Commissioner,
Malabar Devaswom Board, in this writ petition as well as in the
connected matter.
6.
Pursuant to the directions contained in the order of this
Court dated 07.02.2025, the 3rd respondent Commissioner,
Malabar Devaswom Board has filed a counter affidavit dated
19.02.2025. Paragraph 3 of that counter affidavit reads thus;
"3. It is submitted that, in obedience to the directions in the
judgment in Muraleedharan's case, Commissioner will place
a draft of the guidelines, before the 2nd respondent Board.
The guidelines will be framed by the Board, as supplementary
to the relevant provisions governing the appointment of Non
Hereditary Trustees, as envisaged in the HRCE Act and Rules.
By absorbing the spirit of the judgment and the objectives to
be fulfilled, the Board will be incorporating fresh guidelines,
for the process of selection of Non Hereditary Trustes to be
carried out by the Commissioner/Area Committee, or the
Board. It will be done only after consideration of the
objections and after obtaining individual reports from the
concerned Divisional Inspector and comparative Assessment
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
of the applicants, with specific reference to the eligibilities
and the disqualifications provided in the guidelines dated
18.05.2004, issued by the Commissioner of the erstwhile
Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (Administration)
Department. It is submitted that this respondent will take all
endeavours to see that the procedure for appointing the Non
Hereditary Trustees is made, more fair and transparent. It is
submitted that depending upon the final outcome of the
above referred SLP, pending before the Hon'ble Apex Court,
further guidelines will be formulated."
7.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned
Senior Government pleader for the 1st respondent and the learned
Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board for respondents 2
to 4 and also the learned counsel for respondents 8 to 12.
8.
In the writ petition it is contended that though the
disqualifications and ineligibilities of respondents 8 to 12, in terms
of Ext.P1 notification dated 28.06.2024 issued by the 3 rd
respondent Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, for being
appointed as non-hereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy
Temple, were brought to the notice of the 6th respondent Divisional
Inspector by submitting Ext.P3 objection dated 26.10.2024, which
was followed by Ext.P6 statement dated 04.12.2024, along with
supporting materials like Ext.P7 leaflet, which was followed by
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
Ext.P8 objection dated 06.12.2024 submitted by the 4th respondent
Assistant Commissioner, supported by Ext.P9 photographs of
respondents 8 to 12 attending political party meetings, the Board
and its officials are proceeding with the matter, ignoring the
objections raised by the petitioner, in violation of the law laid down
by this Court in the decisions referred to supra.
9.
In Suresh K. v. State of Kerala and others [2021
(2) KLT 885], a Division Bench of this Court observed that temple
or its precincts cannot be made a place where political parties
should look forward to give political asylum to their workers. The
Division Bench noticed that ours being a highly politically sensitive
State, hardly any person can be traced, who is completely apolitical
or who may not have his own independent political views. There
may be persons having permanent political ideologies or views
whereas there may be equal number of persons who hold views
according to the issues involved. Perhaps that may be the reason
why Kerala has become a State of political swinging. The Division
Bench made it clear that holding political views or sympathizing
with a political denomination cannot be held a disqualification for
nominating anyone to such a post. On the facts of the case on hand,
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
the Division Bench held that even assuming that respondents 7 to
9 have some political leaning or rather they are sympathizers of a
political party, that fact will not disentitle them to be considered for
appointment as non-hereditary trustees. There is clear distinction
between sympathizing with a political party and indulging in active
participation in the activities of the party. The taboo under subclause (g) of clause 3
of the notification issued by the
Commissioner will be attracted only if respondents 7 to 9 are active
politicians or are office bearers of a political party, for which
absolutely no evidence is forthcoming.
10.
In Chathu Achan K. v. State of Kerala [2022 (6)
KLT 388] a Division Bench of this Court in which one among us
[Anil K. Narendran, J] was a party noticed that the provisions of
Clauses 3 and 4 of the notification issued by the Commissioner
make it explicitly clear that, for appointment as non-hereditary
trustee of the temple, the applicant should be a regular worshipper
of the temple, who is prepared to actively work for the betterment
of the temple. He should be a permanent resident of the Taluk in
which the temple situates, who believe in idolatry. Persons who are
busy with their employment, office bearers of political parties,
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
active politicians or those indulging in active participation in the
activities of a political party cannot aspire appointment as nonhereditary trustee of the temple. Therefore, it is for the
Commissioner to take necessary steps to ensure that any
appointment made as non-hereditary trustee of the temples under
the control of Malabar Devaswom Board is strictly in terms of the
disqualification
and
eligibility
clauses
provided
in
similar
notifications. If found necessary, the format of the application for
appointment as a non-hereditary trustee in the temple under the
control of Malabar Devaswom Board has to be modified in an
appropriate
manner,
by
requiring
the
applicant
to
furnish
particulars in terms of the disqualification and eligibility clauses in
similar notifications. The Commissioner was directed to take
necessary steps in this regard, if found necessary, after placing
before the Malabar Devaswom Board, as expeditiously as possible,
at any rate, within a period of one month from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of that judgment.
11.
In N.K.E. Chandrashekharan Nampoodiripad v.
Commissioner,
Malabar
[2023:KER:55922]
-
Devaswom
judgment
Board
dated
and
others
08.09.2023
in
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
W.P.(C)No.29279 of 2023 - a Division Bench of this Court in which
one among us [Anil K. Narendran, J] was a party held that, in view
of the law laid down by this Court in Chathu Achan K. [2022 (6)
KLT 388], for appointment as non-hereditary trustee in TTK
Devaswom, which are controlled institutions under the Malabar
Devaswom Board, the applicant should be a regular worshipper of
the temple, who is prepared to actively work for the betterment of
the temple. He should be a permanent resident of the Taluk in
which the temple situates, who believe in idolatry. Persons who are
busy with their employment, office bearers of political parties,
active politicians or those indulging in active participation in the
activities of a political party cannot aspire to appointment as nonhereditary
trustees
of
TTK
Devaswom.
Therefore,
the
Commissioner has to ensure that any appointments made as nonhereditary trustee in TTK Devaswom, which is a controlled
institution under the Malabar Devaswom Board, are strictly in
terms of the disqualification and eligibility clauses provided in the
notification dated 10.07.2023.
12.
In Anantha Narayanan and another v. Malabar
Devaswom Board and others [2023 KLT OnLine 1195 : 2023
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
SCC OnLine Ker 1022], a Division Bench of this Court in which
one among us [Anil K. Narendran, J] was a party, held that when
clause 3(7) of the notification issued by the Commissioner for
appointment as non-hereditary trustees in the temples, which are
controlled institutions under the Malabar Devaswom Board, is
considered in the light of the interpretation given by this Court in
Chathu Achan K. [2022 (6) KLT 388], no person actively
involved in politics is eligible to be appointed as a non-hereditary
trustee in a temple.
13.
In Anantha Narayanan [2023 KLT OnLine 1195]
the Division Bench noticed that the Oxford Advanced Learners
Dictionary defines ‘politician’ as “a person whose job is concerned
with politics, especially as an elected member of the Parliament,
etc.” Such a technical meaning of the word ‘politician’ cannot be
accepted to understand clause 3(7) in the notification which says
that active politicians or persons holding official posts in any
political party are ineligible. The terms are used disjunctively. So
persons who are actively involved in politics, whether or not they
hold any post in a political party, are ineligible. On the facts of the
case on hand, the Division Bench noticed that respondents 6 to 8
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
therein have no case that they have any other profession. It is a
matter of common knowledge that the functioning of a political
party and selection/election of its office bearers is not similar to
public employment. Whichever be the political party, one who is
actively involved in the activities of that political party alone is
ordinarily selected/elected as an office bearer. Having been
selected as office bearers of the political party/DYFI before or soon
after the appointment as non-hereditary trustees, respondents 6
to 8 cannot contend that they were not active politicians. In the
constitution of DYFI, it is stated that a member of the DYFI can
work in any political party. That does not mean that the DYFI does
not have any political colour. Whether or not it has any affiliation
to any particular political party, what is evident from the
constitution is that the area of activities of DYFI is politics and
related activities. As such it cannot be said that the activities of
DYFI are non-political.
14.
In Anantha Narayanan [2023 KLT OnLine 1195]
the Division Bench noticed that, going by the parameters
prescribed in notification, persons who are convicted for more than
six months for offences involving moral turpitude are alone
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
ineligible to be non-hereditary trustees. It is, however, specifically
prescribed in the notification that persons who apply to be
appointed as non-hereditary trustees shall be idol worshippers and
persons having an interest in the advancement of the temple. They
should also be persons used to be involved in the affairs of the
temple. A person having reverence and adoration for a deity can
alone be treated as a worshipper. A person facing criminal
prosecution for an offence involving moral turpitude cannot be
considered a true worshipper of that standard required for a person
to be appointed as a trustee in a temple. A trustee is a person
obligated to conduct temple affairs in accordance with custom or
usage. In A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board
[(2007) 7 SCC 482] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court
explained the diligence and devotion a trustee of a temple should
have. When those are the necessary qualifications required for a
person to be appointed as a non-hereditary trustee, and the danger
of appointing unqualified and untrustworthy persons as trustees,
the Malabar Devaswom Board shall stipulate the eligibility criteria
in consonance with that. Therefore, the Malabar Devaswom Board
was directed to take a decision in that regard before proceeding
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
with any new appointment of non-hereditary trustees in the
temples under it.
15.
In Muraleedharan M. v. Malabar Devaswom Board
and others [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], a Division Bench of this Court
in which one among us [Anil K. Narendran, J] was a party, in view
of the provisions contained in Chapter II of the Madras Hindu
Religious and Charitable Endowments Act of 1951, as amended by
the Amendment Act of 2008, the Malabar Devaswom Board and the
authorities under the Board, including the Commissioner, have
essentially the duty and obligation to act in trust. In view of the
provisions contained in Section 24 of the Act, the trustee of every
religious institution is bound to administer its affairs and to apply
its funds and properties in accordance with the terms of the trust,
the usage of the institution and all lawful directions which a
competent authority may issue in respect thereof and as carefully
as a man of ordinary prudence would deal with such affairs, funds
and properties if they were his own. Therefore, in the matter of the
appointment of non-hereditary trustees in religious institutions, the
competent authority in the Board has a duty to act fairly, and the
fairness in the action must be demonstrable from the records and
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
also the decision. The decision taken by the competent authority
should disclose an assessment of the comparative merits and
demerits of the applicants, with specific reference to the
disqualification and eligibility clauses provided in the guidelines
dated 18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner of the erstwhile
Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (Administration)
Department, and the files should disclose the manner in which such
an assessment has been made by the competent authority. It is
after the decision of the Division Bench in K.P. Vasudevan
Namboothiri v. K.C. Vasudevan Namboothiri - judgment dated
01.04.2004 in O.P. No. 6131 of 2003 - that the Commissioner of
the
erstwhile
Hindu
Religious
and
Charitable
Endowments
(Administration) Department issued guidelines dated 18.05.2004
for the selection of non-hereditary trustees in the Malabar area
under the control of that Department. That guidelines were issued
by the Commissioner of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and
Charitable Endowments (Administration) Department, who was
exercising the powers under the Act of 1951, presently exercised
by the Malabar Devaswom Board, after its constitution by the
Amendment Act of 2008. Till the framing of statutory rules in the
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
exercise of the powers under the Act, the aforesaid guidelines
issued by the Commissioner of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and
Charitable
Endowments
(Administration)
Department,
would
govern the field.
16.
In Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20] this
Court held that, in view of the provisions contained in clause (a) of
the guidelines dated 18.05.2004, a person appointed as a nonhereditary trustee shall be ordinarily a resident in the Taluk in which
the temple is situated. As per clause (b), he shall be a person who
is in the habit of visiting the temple usually. As per clause (c), he
shall be a person believing in idol worship, and persons who are
actively working for the welfare of the temple/temples may be
given preference. In view of the provisions contained in clause (d)
of the guidelines, the following category of persons need not be
considered for appointment ordinarily (i) busy professionals; (ii)
active politicians and office bearers of political parties; (iii) persons
who had encroached Devaswom lands or against whom Devaswom
has filed cases in a court of law; and (iv) persons who had filed
litigations against the Devaswom. As per clause (e) of the
guidelines, when the comparative merits and demerits are difficult
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
to decide as above, the educational qualification shall be taken as
a determinant factor. As per clause (f) of the guidelines dated
18.05.2004, while making an appointment, as far as possible,
persons who can work as a team for the welfare and development
activities of the temple shall be appointed. As per clause (i) of the
guidelines, in case appointments are made, not in accordance with
these guidelines, the reason therefor shall be recorded. The report
of the officer conducting an enquiry as to the suitability of the
applicants shall contain specific remarks with regard to the above
points. Therefore, any appointments made by the 2nd respondent
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board or the concerned Area
Committee, as the case may be, as non-hereditary trustees of
Devaswoms/Temples which are controlled institutions under the
Malabar Devaswom Board, shall be strictly in terms of the
disqualification and eligibility clauses in the guidelines dated
18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner of the erstwhile Hindu
Religious and Charitable Endowments (Administration) Department
and the law laid down by this Court in Chathu Achan [(2022) 6
KLT 388] and Anantha Narayanan [2023 KLT OnLine 1195],
after eliminating active politicians and office bearers of political
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
parties, busy professionals, etc. from the zone of consideration.
17.
In Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20] this
Court considered the question as to whether the eligibility criteria
prescribed in the notification dated 19.01.2022 issued by the
Commissioner inviting applications for appointment as nonhereditary trustees of Sree Vairamcode Bhagavathi Temple are at
variance with the provisions under the Act of 1951. Relying on the
judgment of the Apex Court in Ashish Kumar v. State of Uttar
Pradesh [(2018) 3 SCC 55], the learned Senior Counsel for
Malabar Devaswom Board contended that when the eligibility
criteria prescribed in the notification dated 19.01.2022 issued by
the Commissioner are in variance with the provisions under Section
46 the Act, that guidelines would not take precedence over the
statutory provisions.
18.
In Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20] this
Court noticed that in view of the provisions contained in Chapter II
of the Act of 1951, as amended by the Amendment Act of 2008,
the Malabar Devaswom Board and the authorities of the Board,
including the Commissioner, have the duty and obligation to act in
trust. In view of the provisions contained in Section 24 of the Act,
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
the trustee of every religious institution is bound to administer its
affairs and to apply its funds and properties in accordance with the
terms of the trust, the usage of the institution and all lawful
directions which a competent authority may issue in respect thereof
and as carefully as a man of ordinary prudence would deal with
such affairs, funds and properties if they were his own. The
notification dated 19.01.2022 issued by the Commissioner, Malabar
Devaswom Board, is one issued in terms of guidelines dated
18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner of the erstwhile Hindu
Religious
and
Charitable
Endowments
(Administration)
Department. The said guidelines were issued pursuant to the
directions contained in the judgment of a Division Bench of this
Court in K.P. Vasudevan Namboothiri - judgment dated
01.04.2004 in O.P. No. 6131 of 2003 - when it was noticed that the
absence of guidelines or rules would lead to arbitrariness in the
matter of selection and appointment of non-hereditary trustees, an
assessment of the comparative merits and demerits of the
applicants has to be undertaken before appointing non-hereditary
trustees in a religious institution. In the said decision, the Division
Bench noticed that no qualification for non-hereditary trustees had
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
been prescribed. That guidelines were issued by the Commissioner
of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments
(Administration) Department, who was exercising the powers
under the Act of 1951, presently exercised by the Malabar
Devaswom Board, after its constitution by the Amendment Act of
2008. Till the framing of statutory rules in the exercise of the
powers under the Act, the aforesaid guidelines issued by the
Commissioner of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and Charitable
Endowments (Administration) Department, would govern the field.
Section 46 of the Act deals with disqualifications of trustees. As per
sub-section (1) of Section 46, a non-hereditary trustee shall cease
to hold his office if he acquires any of the disqualifications
enumerated in clauses (a) and (b) thereto. The qualifications
contained in the notification therein, which is in terms of guidelines
dated 18.05.2004, are not at variance with the provisions
contained in the Act of 1951. Therefore, the Division Bench repelled
as untenable, the contentions to the contra raised by the learned
Senior Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board.
19.
In Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20] this
Court issued certain directions in the matter of appointment of non-
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
hereditary trustees in Devaswoms/Temples, which are controlled
institutions under the Malabar Devaswom Board, in order to ensure
a fair and transparent mechanism for such appointment, taking into
consideration the requirements of the provisions contained in the
Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Institutions Act, till rules are
made for that purpose under the said Act. Paragraph 154 of the
said decision reads thus;
“154. Having considered the submissions made by the
learned Senior Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board on the
above aspect, we deem it appropriate to issue the following
directions in the matter of appointment of non-hereditary
trustees in Devaswoms/Temples, which are controlled
institutions under the Malabar Devaswom Board, in order to
ensure
a
fair
and
transparent
mechanism
for
such
appointment, taking into consideration the requirements of
the provisions contained in the Madras Hindu Religious and
Charitable Institutions Act, till rules are made for that
purpose under the said Act.
(i) The notifications issued for the appointment
as
non-hereditary
Devaswoms/Temples,
institutions
under
trustees
which
the
in
are
controlled
Malabar
Devaswom
Board, shall be published in a local daily having
wide circulation. The notification shall also be
published
in
the
notice
board
of
the
Devaswom/Temple, at a prominent place, for
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
the information of the devotees, and also in the
notice board of the concerned Local SelfGovernment Institution and the Village Office.
(ii) Once applications are received, the details of
the applicants shall be exhibited on the notice
board of the Devaswom/Temple, at a prominent
place, so as to enable the devotees to point out
the disqualifications, if any, of any of the
applicants, by submitting written objections
before the 2nd respondent Commissioner or the
concerned Area Committee, as the case may be,
furnishing therewith their name, address and
mobile number. Those objections shall also be
dealt with appropriately by the 2nd respondent
Commissioner
or
the
concerned
Area
Committee, as the case may be, after obtaining
individual reports on those complaints from the
concerned Divisional Inspector.
(iii)
In the case of Devaswoms/Temples in
which appointment of non-hereditary trustees is
made by the concerned Area Committee, the
evaluation of the applicants with reference to
the report of the concerned Divisional Inspector
shall be made by a Committee consisting of a
member of the Area Committee to be nominated
by
its
Chairman,
the
concerned
Assistant
Commissioner and the hereditary trustee of the
Devaswom/ Temple. In the absence of a
hereditary trustee, the Tantri or Melsanthi of the
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
Devaswom/Temple shall be a member of that
Committee. The said Committee shall have a
comparative assessment of the applicants with
specific
reference
disqualifications
to
the
provided
in
eligibilities
the
and
guidelines
dated 18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner
of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and Charitable
Endowments (Administration) Department and
the said assessment shall be the basis for the
appointment of non-hereditary trustees by the
concerned Area Committee.
(iv) In the case of Devaswoms/Temples in which
appointment of non-hereditary trustees is made
by the 2nd respondent Commissioner, Malabar
Devaswom
Board,
the
evaluation
of
the
applicants with reference to the report of the
concerned Divisional Inspector shall be made by
a Committee consisting of a member of the
concerned Area Committee to be nominated by
the Commissioner, the concerned Assistant
Commissioner and the hereditary trustee of the
Devaswom/ Temple. In the absence of a
hereditary trustee, the Tantri or Melsanthi of the
Devaswom/Temple shall be a member of that
Committee. The said Committee shall have a
comparative assessment of the applicants with
specific
reference
disqualifications
to
the
provided
in
eligibilities
the
and
guidelines
dated 18.05.2004 issued by the Commissioner
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
of the erstwhile Hindu Religious and Charitable
Endowments (Administration) Department and
the said assessment shall be the basis for the
appointment of non-hereditary trustees by the
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board.”
20.
As already noticed hereinbefore, on 07.02.2025, the
learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board pointed out
the order of the Apex Court dated 20.01.2025 in SLP(C) Diary
No.60879 of 2024, arising out of the judgment of this Court in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20]. The said SLP is one
filed by Malabar Devaswom Board and its officials, after the
dismissal of SLP(C) No.29188 of 2024. In SLP(C) Diary No.60879
of 2024, while issuing notice to the respondents, the Apex Court
confined the scope of consideration only with respect to clauses (iii)
and (iv) in paragraph 154 of the judgment in Muraleedharan M.
[2024 (6) KHC SN 20] and the order of stay is also confined to
that extent alone.
21.
In the order dated 07.02.2025, this Court noticed the
submission made by the learned Standing Counsel for Malabar
Devaswom Board, after referring to the aforesaid order of the Apex
Court that after complying with the procedure contemplated in
clauses (i) and (ii) of paragraph 154 of the judgment of this Court
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
in Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], i.e., consideration
of the objections after obtaining individual reports from the
concerned Divisional Inspector and comparative assessment of the
applicants
with
specific
reference
to
the
eligibilities
and
disqualifications provided in the guidelines dated 18.05.2004
issued by the Commissioner of erstwhile Hindu Religious and
Charitable Endowments (Administration) Department shall be
made by the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board or the
concerned Area Committee, as the case may be. After the order of
this Court dated 07.02.2025, the 3rd respondent Commissioner has
filed a counter affidavit dated 19.02.2025. Paragraph 3 of that
counter affidavit has already been extracted hereinbefore at
paragraph 6.
22.
The learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom
Board would submit that Exts.P4 and P6 objections made by the
petitioner pointing out the alleged ineligibility/disqualification of
respondents 8 to 12 for being appointed as non-hereditary trustees
of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy Temple, Cherpulassery, in the process
of selection pursuant to Ext.P1 notification dated 28.06.2024 shall
be considered by the 3rd respondent Commissioner, Malabar
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
Devaswom Board, taking note of the law laid down by this Court in
Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20], subject to the
interim order of the Apex Court dated 20.01.2025 in SLP(C) Diary
No.60879 of 2024.
Having considered the pleadings and materials on record and
also the submissions made at the Bar, we deem it appropriate to
dispose of this writ petition by directing the 3 rd respondent
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board to consider Exts.P6
statement and P8 objections made by the petitioner, along with
supporting documents like Exts.P7 and P9, pointing out the
ineligibility/disqualification of respondents 8 to 12, for being
appointed as non-hereditary trustees of Puthanalkkal Bhagavathy
Temple, Cherpulassery, in the process of selection pursuant to
Ext.P1 notification dated 28.06.2024, with notice to the petitioner,
the 5th respondent Executive Officer, the 7th respondent hereditary
trustee and also respondents 8 to 12, and after affording them an
opportunity of being heard, after taking note of the law laid down
by this Court in Muraleedharan M. [2024 (6) KHC SN 20],
subject to the interim order of the Apex Court dated 20.01.2025 in
SLP(C) Diary No.60879 of 2024. A decision in this regard shall be
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
taken, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of
one month from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment. In the process, the 3rd respondent Commissioner shall
also consider other objections, if any, received against the
applicants pursuant to Ext.P1 notification dated 28.06.2024 for
appointment
as
non-hereditary
trustees
of
Puthanalkkal
Bhagavathy Temple, Cherpulassery.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MSA
W.P.(C)No.45280 of 2024
2025:KER:25284
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 45280/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION BEARING
NO. J5-3326/2024/MDB DATED 28.6.2024
INVITING APPLICATION FOR NON- HEREDITARY
TRUSTEES FOR PUTHANALKKAL BHAGAVATHY
TEMPLE
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE BEARING NO.
121/2024/MDB DATED 14.10.2024 PUBLISHED
BY THE 6 TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED
26.10.2024 SUBMITTED BEFORE THE 6 TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 6
TH RESPONDENT DATED 16.11.2024
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 20.11.2024
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION SUBMITTED BY
THE PETITIONER DATED 04.12.2024
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE LEAFLET THAT CONFIRMS
THE 11 TH RESPONDENT’S CANDIDACY
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED
06.12.2024
Exhibit P9
THE PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING THE RESPONDENT
NO. 8 TO 12, ATTENDING THE POLITICAL
PARTY MEETINGS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review