Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010562582013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3368]
WEDNESDAY, THE 29th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B V L N CHAKRAVARTHI
CRIMINAL APPEL NO: 113/2013
Between:
1. P. LOKESWARA RAO, S/O LATE CHENGALA RAYUDU
SENIOR ASSISTANT GOVT.JR. COLLEGE R/O H.NO.26-1517
B.V.
NAGAR
NGO
COLONY
NELLORE
KONDAPURAM VILLAGE AND MANDAL NELLORE
DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. STATE
OF
AP,
THROUGH
ITS
DEPUTY
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE ANTI CORRUPTION
BUREAU NELLORE RANGE, NELLORE
...RESPONDENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying
that the High Court may be pleased to file this Memorandum of
Crl.A before this Honble Court being aggrieved by the Judgment dt
28-01-2013 made in CC No.9/2010 on the file of the court of the
Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases, Nellore
IA NO: 1 OF 2013(CRLAMP 205 OF 2013
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to suspend the execution of
Sentence passed in CC No.9/2010 dt 28-01-2013 on the file of the
court of the Special Judge for SPE & ACB Cases, Nellore and
release the petitioner on bail, Pending disposal of the above
appeal in the interest of Justice
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. M B THIMMA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. S. SYAM SUNDER RAO SC cum Spl P.P. For ACB
The Court made the following:
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.V.L.N. CHAKRAVARTHI
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.113 OF 2013
J U D G M E N T:
The appeal is preferred challenging the Judgment dated
28.01.2013 delivered by the Special Judge for SPE & ACB Cases,
Nellore in C.C.No.09 of 2010.
2.
The appellant was convicted for the offence under Sections
7 and 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988 (in short ‘the P.C. Act’).
He was sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a period of three (03) years and to pay a
fine of Rs.3,000/- (Rupees Three Thousand Only), in default to
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of three (03) months for
the offence under Section 7 of the P.C. Act, 1988. The appellant
was further sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a
period of three (03) years and to pay a fine of Rs.3,000/- (Rupees
Three Thousand Only), in default to undergo simple imprisonment
for a period of three (03) months for the offence under Section
13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of P.C. Act, 1988.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter referred
to as they were arraigned before the learned Special Court.
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
CASE OF THE PROSECUTION:
4.
The case of the prosecution is that the appellant/accused
has been working as Senior Assistant in KAC Government Junior
College, Stonehousepet at Nellore. PW-5 has been working as a
part-time Lecturer in the College. PW-1 is the husband of PW-5.
The accused for preparing salary arrears bill for the period from
September 2007 onwards relating to PW-5, demanded Rs.30,000/(Rupees Thirty Thousand Only) in the first week of March 2009,
when PW-1 approached the accused. The accused also
demanded a sum of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand Only)
in the second week of March 2009, when PW-1 again approached
the accused for preparation of the above bill. Later, the accused on
16.04.2009 informed PW-1 that the bill was passed by the
Treasury and amount was credited to the Bank Account of PW-5
and demanded gratification other than legal remuneration.
Therefore, PW-1 approached Inspector of Police, ACB at Nellore,
at 4:30 PM on 16.04.2009 and presented Ex.P6 Report. PW-9
registered the same as Ex.P14 FIR. On 17.04.2009, at 9:00 AM
after preliminary enquiry. He submitted Ex-P14 to the ACB Court
and copies to all concerned. He secured PWs-2 and 3 - mediators
at about 10:40 AM on 17.04.2009. He conducted pre-trap
proceedings in the presence of PW-1, PW-2 & PW-3 after
confirming contents of FIR under Ex.P8 - Pre-trap Proceedings.
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
5.
On 17.04.2009 at about 3:30 PM, PW-9 along with PWs-1 to
3 and others went to the office of the accused. PW-1 visited the
accused and paid a sum of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand
only) (MO-3) to the accused. The accused received MO-3 cash.
Therefore, PW-1 gave signal to PW-9 - The Inspector of Police,
ACB. Immediately, PW-9 along with mediators surprised the
accused and seized MO-3 cash and conducted further proceedings
vide Ex-P10. Later, PW-9 examined witnesses and recorded their
statements. Arrested the accused and produced him before the
Special Court. After completing investigation, he submitted report
to the Director General, ACB, Hyderabad for obtaining sanction
orders, after receipt of sanction orders, the then Deputy
Superintendent of Police, ACB at Nellore laid charge sheet on
10.06.2010.
6.
The trial Court charged the accused for the offence under
Sections 7 and 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the P.C. Act, 1988.
Charge was read over and explained to the accused. He pleaded
not guilty and claims to be tried.
EVIDENCE FOR THE PROSECUTION:
7.
PWs-1 to 9 were examined for the prosecution. During their
evidence, Exs-P1 to P16 were marked apart from MOs-1 to 8 for
the prosecution.
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
8.
The accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
regarding incriminating circumstances appearing against him from
the evidence for the prosecution. He denied the same as not true
and correct. No defense witnesses examined for the accused.
However, Exs.D1 to D16 were marked for the defense.
FINDING OF THE SPECIAL COURT:
9.
The Trial Court on consideration of the above evidence
convicted and sentenced the accused as mentioned above.
Therefore, the appeal came to be preferred challenging the
judgment of the trial Court by the appellant/accused.
10.
Heard Sri M.B.Thimma Reddy, learned counsel for the
appellant/accused and Sri S.Syam Sunder Rao, learned Standing
Counsel-cum-Special Public Prosecutor for ACB.
11.
In view of the rival submissions, the point that would arise for
consideration in this Criminal Appeal is as under:
“Whether the Trial Court Judgment is not sustainable
either on facts or in law”?
POINT:
12.
The specific case of the prosecution is that the accused
made demand for gratification other than legal remuneration to do
official favour i.e., prepare salary arrears bill of PW-5.
13.
PW-1 is the complainant. PW-5 is the wife of the
complainant, she has been working as part-time Lecturer in the
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
College mentioned above. There is no dispute about the fact that
the accused also worked as Clerk in the Establishment Section of
the College. PW-6 is the then Principal of the College. PW-4 is the
then Sub-Treasury Officer at Nellore.
ANALYSIS:
14.
The evidence of the Principal and Sub-Treasury Officer
would show that the Junior Lecturers who have been working parttime, are given benefit of regular pay scales as per the
Government Order. Accordingly, PW-5, who is working as parttime Lecturer in the College got the benefit of minimum time scale
pay as per Ex.P1. Later, on 29.11.2006, the Commissioner of
Intermediate Education issued proceedings under Ex.P2 intimating
that the minimum time scale cannot be applicable to the part-time
Lecturers in the College including PW-5. Therefore, PW-5 disputed
the proceedings and challenged the same before the Andhra
Pradesh Administrative Tribunal (‘in short ‘the APAT’) vide
O.A.No.7635 of 2006, dated 22.12.2003. It appears that Ex.P2 was
suspended vide Ex.P3 order passed by APAT. Therefore, the
Commissioner of Intermediate Education issued proceedings
Ex.P4 on 06.12.2008 to implement the orders of APAT.
15.
The evidence of Principal would show that he instructed the
accused to prepare the bill, and the accused immediately prepared
bill in March 2009 and placed the bill before the Principal. He
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
signed the bill and forwarded the same to the Treasury. In fact, the
evidence of the Principal would show that the accused himself had
presented the bill in the Treasury in March 2009. However, the
Treasury Authorities returned the bill, making certain remarks.
Then, the Principal immediately gave a reply to the remarks. The
accused again presented the bill in the Treasury, and it was
passed on the very same day, sent to SBI Main Branch at Nellore
and amount was also credited to the salary account of PW-5 on the
same day.
16.
Here, it is pertinent to note down that PW-1 also admit that
he came to know about credit of the amount to the account of
PW-5 when informed by the accused on 16.04.2009. It is important
to mention here that PW-1 presented the report, after amount was
credited to the account of PW-5. The evidence of PW-4,
Sub-Treasury Officer would corroborate the evidence of the
Principal that initially the bill was presented in March 2009 itself,
but it was returned by the Treasury for certain remarks and later, it
was resubmitted on 13.04.2009 clarifying the objection. On the
same day it was passed and forwarded to the Bank for further
action. Therefore, all the above facts and circumstances, coming
forth from the testimony of the Principal and the Sub-Treasury
Officer would show that no official work relating to salary of arrears
of PW-5 have been pending on the table of the accused on the
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
date of alleged demand on 16.04.2009 when PW-1 presented the
report to PW-9.
17.
In fact, the evidence of PW-1 mentioned above would show
that accused also know that bill presented in the Treasury was
passed and amount was credited to the account of PW-5. Hence,
there was nothing to hide from PW-1 or PW-5 that some work is
pending with the accused and he will process or complete the
same only if demand is satisfied.
18.
Therefore, all these facts and circumstances would show
that no official work was pending with the accused on the date of
report presented by PWs-1.
19.
It is also important to refer the evidence of PW-5. Admittedly
she was working as part-time Lecturer in the College at the
relevant point in time. She is the beneficiary under the disputed bill
to be prepare by the accused. She deposed that she approached
the accused several times in connection with preparation of the bill.
She did not depose anything that accused expressed any intention
to pay some amount to him, out of the bill amount or asked PW-5
to pay gratification other than legal remuneration to process the
bill. Surprisingly, PW-1, who is not the beneficiary or related to the
College, says he went to the College and met the accused, then
accused made the demand. As already mentioned above, the
evidence of Principal would show that due to the orders of
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
Commissioner of Intermediate Education under Ex.P2, bill could
not be prepared for some time.
20.
Later, after orders of APAT under Ex.P3, he instructed the
accused in March 2009 to prepare the bill. Accordingly, the
accused prepared the bill in March 2009 itself, and presented the
same in the Treasury, but the Treasury returned the bill raising
certain
objections.
Those
objections
were
also
answered
immediately and the bill was represented. If such is the case, what
made PW-1 to meet the accused and the accused making demand
for illegal gratification is not coming forth from the evidence.
PW-5 did not depose that accused at any time either in the month
of March or in April, when she met the accused, made any demand
for illegal gratification.
21.
Perusal of the entire evidence on record would show that
Ex.P2 is the root cause for the animosity between PW-1 and the
accused. In fact, the accused suggested to PW-1 and PW-5 that
they suspected the role of the accused for Ex.P2 proceedings. It
raises a doubt that PW-1 wanted to teach a lesson to the accused
suspecting that he was coming in the way of payment of minimum
pay scale to the part-time Lecturers working in the College and
accused is responsible for Ex P2. Waited for an opportunity to
take vengeance. Therefore, he waited till amount has been
credited to the account of his wife after orders of APAT under
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
Ex.P3. Soon after coming to know that amount has been credited
to the salary account of the wife i.e., PW-5, immediately, on the
very same day i.e., 16.04.2009 presented a report to PW-9 alleging
that accused made demand earlier and, on the day, i.e., on
16.04.2009, even though amount credited to the account of PW-5.
22.
These circumstances would throw a serious doubt over the
credit of the testimony of PW-1, to conclude that accused made
demand for gratification other than legal remuneration to process
the bill.
23.
In the light of evidence of the Principal that accused was
directed to prepare the bill, after Ex.P3 orders, and the accused
prepared the bill in the March itself; he himself presented the bill to
the Treasury; even after Treasury raised objections, the objections
were clarified immediately and bill was presented to the Treasury
would show that PW1 suspected that Ex.P2 was issued at the
instance of the accused and therefore, presented report to PW-9
suppressing the truth.
24.
In the light of above facts and circumstances, this Court is of
the considered opinion that it is not safe to rely on the sole
testimony of PW-1 to conclude that prosecution proved demand
and acceptance of bribe amount beyond reasonable doubt. PW-5
as already mentioned above did not support the version of PW-1
stating that the accused made a demand for bribe when she met
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
the accused several times. It is not known as to why the accused
did not make any such demand to PW-5.
25.
In the light of foregoing discussion when there is no other
evidence to conclude that prosecution successfully bring home the
demand or receipt of amount by the accused, conviction of the
appellant for the offence under Sections 7 and 13(2) read with
13(1)(d) of P.C. Act, 1988 is not sustainable.
26.
Another contention is that as per the evidence of PW-9, FIR
registered on 17.04.2009 at 9:00 AM at Nellore. Facts show that It
was prepared after post trap proceedings. Hence conviction is not
sustainable.
27.
Admittedly, the FIR was received in the Special Court at
about 4:25 PM in the evening on that day. PW-9 admit that FIR
could have been reached the Court within twenty minutes. PW-9
evidence would show that trap proceedings were concluded in the
evening on that day.
28.
It is pertinent to note down that Ex. P10 proceedings did not
contain the time and the name of the messenger through whom it
received in the Court by the Presiding Officer of the Court.
29. Rule 24 of The Criminal Rules of Practice and Circular
Orders, 1990, would speak that “Magistrates and Judges receiving
F.I. Rs shall initial each page and put the date stamp and time of
receipt. The name or number of the messenger shall also be
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
noted. If the F.I.R is received by the post, the envelope shall also
be initialed and preserved.
It would further speak that the same Rule applies
to Inquest Reports and other documents received from the
Police or other Prosecuting agencies.
30.
In the case on hand, Ex.P10 Post trap proceedings would
show that they were received by the Special Judge, ACB Court on
17.04.2009. But it does not contain the time and the name or
number of the messenger through whom it was received by the
Judge. FIR would show that it was received at about 4:25 PM on
17.04.2009 through PC 1394. Surprisingly, the very same Judge
did not mention the number or name of the messenger and time on
Ex.P10 proceedings for the reasons best known.
31.
All these circumstances would lead to a conclusion that
PW-9 waited till conclusion of Ex.P10 proceedings and then
registered FIR and sent it to the Court along with other
proceedings. Therefore, it was received in the Court in the evening
after trap proceedings. No reason much less tenable reason was
given by PW9 for the delay in sending the FIR to the Court.
Ordinarily it shall reach the Court in 20 minutes time, as deposed
by PW9. It casts a serious doubt on the veracity of the investigation
in the case, that FIR registered only after conclusion of the trap
proceedings.
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
32.
Therefore, FIR registered after the trap proceedings, is hit by
161 Cr.P.C, as laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in T.T.
Antony Vs. State of Kerala and Others 1 and no conviction is
sustainable in such cases.
CONCLUSION:
33.
In the light of foregoing discussion, the conviction and
sentenced imposed by the Trial Court is not sustainable either on
facts or in law.
RESULT:
34.
In the result, the Criminal Appeal is allowed. The order of
conviction recorded by the Special Judge for SPE & ACB Cases at
Nellore is set aside. The appellant/Accused is acquitted for the
offence under Sections 7 and 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the P.C.
Act, 1988. The fine amount if any, paid by the appellant/accused
shall be refunded to him, in accordance with law. This judgment be
certified to the Trial Court, as per Section 405 of Cr.P.C.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any,
shall stand closed.
JUSTICE B.V.L.N. CHAKRAVARTHI
29.07.2026
Pmk
2001(6) SCC 181
BVLNC,J
Crl.A.No.113 of 2013
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.V.L.N. CHAKRAVARTHI
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.113 of 2013
Date: 29.07.2026
Pmk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review