Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I
134421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERBAD
IVONDAY, THE NINETEENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
SECOND APPEAL NO: 327 OF 2025
Appeal under Section 100 of CPC aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree
dated 06.03.2025 in A.S.No. 141 of 2019 on the file of the Court of the Xl Additional
District & Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar, confirming the
judgment and decree dated 18.01.2018 in O.S. No. 1349 of 2008 on the file of the
Court of the ll Additional Senior Civil Judge R.R. District.
Between:
P. Lakshmi Narasimha Murthy, S/o. Late P.Narasimha Chary, Aged about 53
years, R/o. Flat No.102, Anita Towers, Street No.14, Himayatnagar, Hyderabad500 029.
...AppellanURespondent No. 2/Defendant No. 3
AND
G. Ranga Nayaki, W/o. G.Pursothama Chary, Aged about 59 years, Occ.
Service, Rl/o. Velammal Matric and Higher Secondary school, Poneeri Road,
Panjetty 5O1 204, Tamilnadu.
... Respondent No. 1/AppellanUDefendant No. 2
Smt. P.Laxmi, W/o. Late P.Narasimha Chary, Aged about 75 years, Occ.
House wife Ryo. H.No.3-2-295, SBH Colony, LB Nagar, RR Diskict.
... Respondent No. 2/Respondent No. 1/Plaintiff
Smt. M.Sridevi, W/o. M.Hari, Aged 39 years, Occ. House Wife, R/o. H.No.6_3219, Kanakadurga Street Ramgiri, Nalgonda District, Telangana.
state Bank of Hyderabad Emproyees cooperative Housino societv Ltd.. Reo'
Dy rrs \iecretary, Bahadurguda (Regd. No.T.8.848), office at SgH Staff
Cett
Guntoundry
Branch, Abids, Hyderabad.
Smt. P. Vani, w/o_ P. Nanda Kishore, Aged about 46 years, Occ. House hold
R:/o. H.No.3-2-295, SBH Colony, LB Na"gar, HyOeraOdO.
6. P. Sudershan, S/o. Late P. Nandakishore, Aged about 27 years, Rl/o. H.No.32-295, SBH Colony, LB Nagar, Hyderabad.
7. P. Manogya, D/o. Late P. Nandakishore, Aged about 25 years, R/o. H.No.3-2295, SBH Colony, LB Nagar, Hyderabad.
...Respondents No. 3 to 7/Defendants
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the Judgment and Decree passed in A.S No.l41 of 2019, dated
06-03-2025, on the file of the Court of the Xl Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Ranga Reddy District, pending disposal of the Appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant : Sri. B Ravindra Reddy
Counsel for the Respondents : Sri G. Sreenath
The Court delivered the following:
IN THE COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
Second Appeal No.327 of 2025
19TH DAY OF JANUARY
Between:
P' Lakshm i *
"'^''
,.
1:,$;:',li;t/ respondent No. 2 / derendant No. 3
and
G. Ranga Nayaki and 7 others
...Respondents/plaintiff/defendant Nos.2, 4 to B
JUDGMENT:
Heard Sri B. Ravindra Reddy, learned counsel lor
the appellant/respondent No.2/defendant No.3 and
Sri G. Sreenath, learned counsel for
respondent
No. 1/appeilant/ defendant No.2, on the question of admission.
Perused the record.
2.
This Second Appeal is preferred eggrieved by the
Judgment and Decree dated 06.03.2025 in A.S.No.741 of 2019
passed by the learned XI Additional District and sessions
Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar (for short the First
Appellate Court") setting aside the Judgment and Decree dated
18.01.20i8 in O.S.No.i349 ol 2008 passed by the learned II
Additional Senior Civil .Iudge, L.B.Nagar, Ranga Reddy District
(for short 'the Trial Court'), wherein, the suit for partition and
separate possession u,as dismissed i.e. r,ide judgment and
decree in First Appcal. the suit has been decreed.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred as
they are referred in the suit.
4.
The background facts of the case are that one
late P. Narasimha Chary was allotted with suit schedule
property by State Bank of H,yderabad Employees Co operative
Housing Society Ltd. Said late P. Narasimha Chary obtained
loan for construction of house and paid some installments to
defendant No.5 Bank. While things stood thus, on 04'05'1988,
saidlateP.NarasimhaCharydiedintestateleavingbehindthe
plaintiff (wife) and defendant Nos. I to 4 (children) as his legal
heirs. Defendant No.5 is State Bank of Hyderabad Employees
Co-operative Housing Society Ltd-, to which instalments were
paid by the plaintiff. After the plaintilf cleared the loan, No Due
Certificate was issued on 19.03.2008. Thereafter, defendant
Nos. 1 and 3 '"r'ho are sons ol the deceased late P. Narasimha
Chary approachcd delendant No.5 to register the suit Schedule
propert)' in their rlames r,r,hereas the plaintiff who is mother of
defendant Nos. 1 to 4 requested for partition of the suit schedule
property into five (5) equal shares. At that, defendant Nos. 1 and
3 claimed exclusive rights to the suit schedule property
Further, according to the plaintiff, the delendant No.1 tried to
alienate the suit schedule property to third parties by snatching
original docume nts.
5.
Per contra, the case of defendant Nos.1 and 3 (sons) is
that' partition was already effected through a oral Family
Arrangement dated II.OB-2OO2 and the same was also reduced
into writing. The suit schedule property was divided into three
(3) equal shares with one (1) share each allotted to the plaintiff,
defendant Nos.l and 3. No share was allotted to defendant
Nos.2 and 4 (daughters) as the plaintiff agreed to part her share
in equal halves to her daughters. Defendant Nos.2 and 4
(daughters) also agreed to such an arrangement to take half
.+
share each in their mother's share and thereby, acknowledged
Family Arrangement but did not sign the same. The loan
amount was paid by the plaintilf from the death benefits ol the
deceased P. Narasimha Chary. The defendant Nos. I and 3 never
approached delendant No.5 lor execution of sale deed as they
have adhered to the Familv Arrangement dated 11.08.2002.
Further, allegation about trying to alienate the suit schedule
property by snatching the title deeds is fa1sc. The plaintifl is in
possession of her share and defendant Nos. 1 and 3 are in
possession of their respective shares. During pendency of suit,
defendant No.1 died and defendant Nos.6 to B were brought on
record as his legal heirs.
6.
Defendant No.S Bank hled written statemcnt olfering to
register the suit schedule property as per judgment and decree
in the suit.
7.
During trial, the plaintiff got examined herself as PW1
and exhibited Exs.Al to A.4 consisting of legal heir certificate,
electricity bills dated 05.10.2002 and 08.03.2O03 and market
value certihcate. The defendants got examined DWs 1 to 3 and
('j
marked Ex.B1 Family Arrangement dated 11.08.2002. As per
evidence on record, the plaintiff adhered to her version and
plaint pleadings and the defendants have adhered to their
version. In proof of Family Arrangement, DW2 and DW3 are
examined who are brother-in-larv and brother of the plaintiff.
DW2 and DW3 acknor.r,ledged rvitnessing Family Arrangement
as per Ex.B1 dated 11.O8.2OO2.
B.
On the basis of this oral and documentary evidence, the
Trial Court arrived at a conclusion that partition has already
taken place and therefore, the same cannot be reopened and
consequently, dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the said
judgitrent and decree, the delendant No.2 filed appeal llt
A.S.No. l4L of 2Ol9 before the First Appellate Court.
9.
In appeal, after assessing the version presented by both
the plaintiff and delendants coupled with oral evidence of DW2
and DW3, the First Appellate court also arrived at a conclusion
that there was a Family Arrangement as per Ex.Bl dated
1l.Oa.2OO2, however, said partition was found to be illegal. The
First Appellate Court held that Family Arrangement/Bx.B1 to
the exclusion of some of the Class-l legal heirs is illegtrl and
therefore, allowed the appeal setting aside the judgment and
decree passcd by the Trial Court.
10. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by the
Appellate Court, defendant No.3 fi1ed the present Second Appeal
alleging that the pleadings and evidence unequivocally
established the Family settlement which is reduced into r,r'riting
under Ex.B 1 and it is in the knowledgc of all the legal heirs of
late P. Narasimha Chary. The defendant No.2 did not appear
before the Trial Court and thereby, denying an opportunitl' to
cross examine her on facts and documents and the finding u,ith
respect to Ex.Bi Family Arrangement.
11. In grounds of Second Appeal, it is contended that the
First Appellate Court decreeing the suit with a direction to allot
hve (5) equal shares is contrary to law and evidence on record.
The only reason for not considering Ex.B 1 is that defendant
Nos.2 and 4 have not signed Ex.B1. The appellant insisted that
there was partition and the plaintift has taken the entire
benehts of the deceased late P. Narasimha Chary. Even DW2
and DW3 who are brother-in-larv and brother of plaintiff have
deposed about Family Arrangement and in spite of their
e'",idence, the First Appellate Court has arrived at wrong
findings. According to defendant No.3 i.e. appellant herein, the
First Appellate Court ought to have remanded the matter
instead of passing the erroneous decree such that the parties
who failed to appear can contest the suit and u'ould face cross
examination. In that context, the lollowing substantial
questions of law are raised
a) Whether the First Appellate Court is right in
reversing the well considered judgment of the
trial court, on the only ground that the defendant
No.2 and 4 are not signatories to the Exhibit B1?
b) Whether the First Appellate Court grar.ely erred
in relying upon part of the evidence only i.e., the
Exhibit B 1 u'as not signed by the defendant
Nos.2 and 4, and gravely erred in not considering
the other evidence available on record i.e.,
evidence of DW2 who is brother-in-law' of the
plaintiff and DW3 rvho is the brother of the
plaintiff, the witnesses to the family
arrangement?
c) Whether the First Appeliate Court erred in not
considering the lact that the defendant Nos.2 and
4 have already received substantially amounts at
the time of their marriage and aiso from the
plaintiff out of the amounts received by her
towards the reliral benefits, death benefits,
insurarce and savings bonds of deceased Late p.
Narasimha Chary, ancl that to avoid subjecting to
i
ti
trial/cross examination in the suit, the defendant
Nos.2 and 4 have deliberately remained exparte
to the suit?
12. The above entirc sequence of the casc of the plaintiffmother on one hand the delendant Nos. 1 and 3 (sons)
undisputedly establishes the fact that it is late P. Narasimha
Chary who was allotted with the sr-rit schedule propert\.. He paicl
some installments and died on 04.05.1988. Thereafter'. his u'if-c
t. e.
plaintiff paid installments and obtained No Due Certilrcate
on 19.03.2OO8. Once the property belor-rgs to larte P. Narasimha
Chary, his wife and ai1 the four children u,ould have 1/5'h share
each in the suit schedule property.
13. To the contrary, according to defendant No.3 i.e. the
appellant herein and the deceased defendant No.1, the property
is already partitioned in the year 2OO2 into three equal shares
with onr: share each to two sons and wife of late P. Narasimha
Chary. The half share of the mother was to be further allotted
into equal halves to the daughters i.e. there was prior partition
but in unequal shares that too to the exclusion of the daughters
i.e. defe ndant Nos.2 and 4. While there is sufficient evidence to
prove Ex.B 1 Family Arrangement and its execution, the
q
question addressed by the First Appellate Court was whether
such a Family Arrangement to the exclusion of daughters was
valid in law. There was no issue about the lactual aspect of the
relationship between the parties, the manner of acquisition ol
suit schedule property and payment ol loans thereon. The only
factual dispute is with respect to the partition of the suit
schedule property and its manner. The mother sought partition
for division of suit schedule property into five equal shares
whereas the sons are claiming prior partition ir-rto three shares.
The Trial Court believed in prior partition but did not consider
its validity whereas the First Appellate Court rnhile believing the
prior partition considered the legal validity of such a partition
and came to a conclusion that any partition to the exclusion of
daughters is not valid or legal. It is held that Ex.Bl Family
Arrangement does not contain signature of daughters and their
absence belore the Trial Court does not mean that they have
relinquished their share. Since the daughters are also Class-l
iegal heirs, the First Appellate Court allowed the appeal.
14. I)uring arguments in the Second Appeal, the learned
courrsel lor the appellant contended that there ls an erroneous
conclusion by the First Appellate Court with respect to Ex.B I
Famil1, Arrangement dated 11.08.2002 that it is executed r,r,ith
consent of all the family members, to the knowledge of all the
famil-v- members in the presence of the brother-in-laq,, (DW2)
and brother (DW3) the plaintiff. The only lacuna if any is that
the signatures ol defendant Nos.2 and 4 were not obtained.
However, said Family Arrangement was also consented to by thc
daughters and therefore, reopening partition is not appnrpriate
15. Under Section 1OO of CPC, a Second Appeal
TS
maintainable only when there are substantial questions of law
to be considered by this Court. In the instant case, while there
was no second opinion about the Family Arrangement/ Ex.B 1
dated 1i.08.2002, the only point to be considered is whether it
was valid or invalid as per law. The Trial Court lailed to
consider the same whereas the First Appellate Court has rightly
held that any partition to the exclusion of daughters n ho are
Class-l legal heirs is illegal. The stand about defendant No.2
t1
who hled the First Appeal escaping cross examination is not a
ground for entertain the Second Appezrl. There was ample
evidence on behalf of the plaintiff-mother and the defendant
Nos. 1 and 3-sons and DW2, DW3 who are lamily members
There can be no more facts elicited about the gamut of facts
leading to filing of suit for partition. Unless and until there is a
written document in proof of defendant Nos.2 and 4
relinquishing their rights accepting to take ty'z share each from
the share of plaintiff, there can be no question of giving
:l
weightage to Ex.B1 Family Arrangement. In the absence of such
an evidence, the judgment and decree passed by the First
Appellate Court is in conformity with the law as well as 1ega1
precedents laid down by the Honble Supreme Court of India in
catena of judgments.
16. The substantial questions of law raised are questions ol
fact which were already considered by the First Appellate Court
and this Court in a Second Appeal cannot venture into fact
Iinding until there is perversity. There is no perversitv in the
!
ll
finding given b1, the First Appellate Court and therefore, the
Second Appe:rl is r.rot maintainable
17. Ir.r the re sult, the Second Appeal is dismissed at the stage
of admission. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
SD/- N. CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
EPUTY REGISTRAR
\
\
\
//TRUE COPY//
\
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Xl Additional District & Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy Diskict at L B
Nagar. (With records if anY)
2. The ll Additional Senior Civil Judge R R District'
3. One CC to Sri B Ravindra Reddy, Advocate [oPUCl
4. One CC to Sri G. Sreenath, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CD CoPies
DL/PSL
-----.-
I
I
I
HIGH COURT
I
DATED:.19t01t2O26
t
o
'r
lt
IlrE s
02' 120?E
JUDGMENT
*
SA.No.327 of 2025
DISMISSED
1TCil
STAGE
AT lHE
OF ADMISS\ON
@W
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review