Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3448 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3420 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 2510912023 Passed in E.P. No.113 of 2010 in in O.S. No. 411 of 2007 on the
file of the court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge-cum-Judicial ttlagistrate of First
Class, Bhongir.
Between:
1. P.Kousalya, Wo. Madhumohan Reddy, Aged about 44 years, Occ. Staff
Nurse Working at Modern Government tvlaternity Hospital, Petlaburj,
Hyderabad. Presently working as a Head nurse At Government Maternity
Hospital, Sultanbazar, Koti. Hyderabad
2. V.ttladhumohan Reddy, S/o. Late. Sathi Reddy, Aged about 55 years, Occ.
Business,'Both are R/o. F 502, G.Highlite Haveli, Street No.6, Habsiguda,
Hyderabad.
...Petitioners /Judgment Debtors
AND
1. Addagatla Narsaiah (Since Died) His LRs.
2. Addagatla Krishna Mohan, S/o. Late Narsaiah, Aged about 50 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. H.No.2-4-12315P1101, Satyanagar Colony, Uppal, Hyderabad.
3. Addagatla Anand Kumar, S/o. Late. Narsaiah, Aged about 45 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. H.No.2-4-123lSPl101, Satyam Plaza, Swaroop Nagar, Uppal,
Hyderabad.
4. Smt. Bethi Padma, Wo. B.Sudhakar, Aged about 53 years, Occ. Housewife,
R/o. H.No .12-1-46311/8, Lalapet, Secunderabad.
5. Smt. Chintala tvladhavi, Wo. C.Ganga Kishan, Aged about 51 years, Occ.
Housewife, R/o. H.No.2-310112, Mallikarjuna Nagar, Malkajgiri,
Secunderabad.
6. The Superintendent (Drawing Officer), Government Maternity Hospital,
Sultanbazar Koti, Hyderabad.
...Respondents
l.A. NO: I OF 20'23
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the effect and operation of the docket order dated 25-09-2023 in E.P. No.113 of
2010 in O.S. No 411 of 2OO7 passed by Principal Junior Civil Judge-cum-Judicial
lvlagistrate of First Class, Bhongir, until disposal of the main C.R.P.
Counsel for the Petitioners : Sri Apurva M Gokhale
Gounsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 5 : Sri Mohd Abdul Samad
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OT'TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION.NO.342O OF 2023
Dated: 6th FEBRUARY, 2026
BETWEEN :
1. P.Kousalya, W/o.Madhumohan Reddy and Another
... Petitioners-Judgment Debtors
AND
1. Addagatla Narsaiah (Since Died) His LRs.
2. Addagatla Krishna Mohan, S/o.Late Narsaiah,
Aged about 50 years, Occ: Business,
R/o.H.No .2-4-L23 ISP I 1O 1, Satyanagar Colony,
Uppal, Hyderabad and Others.
...Respondents
ORDER
1.1. The present Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is filed
under Section 115 of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for short CPC)
assailing the order passed by the learned Principal Junior Civil
Judge Cum Judicial Magistrate of First Class at Bhongir in
E.P.No.113 of 2OlO in OS.No.411of 2OO7, dated 25.09.2023.
L.2. Petitioners are the Judgment Debtors (for short UDRs) and
respondent Nos.l to 5 are the Decree Holders {for short 'DHRsJ.
2le
BRMR,J
cRP-34202023
Respondent No.6 is
the Superintendant (Drawing Officer),
Government Maternity Hospital, Sultan Bazar, Koti, Hyderabad.
2.
Respondent Nos.l to S-DHRs have filed E.P.No.113 of 2O1O
in OS.No..111 of 2OOT for recovery of Rs.77,196/- and the prayer
made in the E.P. is to attach the salary of JDR No.l (petitioner
No.1 here,in) and attach the movable properties of JDR No.2
(petitioner No.2 herein). The movable properties to be attached
against JI)R No.2 (petitioner No.2 herein) are television, wooden
tables (2 itr number), wooden chairs (4), ceiling fans (4), refrigerator
(1), steel e-lmirah (1), other movables at the time of attachment, in
total Rs.6.1,000/-.
3.
Petit-ioners-JDR Nos.1 and 2 filed counter. The learned trial
Court hasi passed order on 25.09.2023 attaching the salary of
petitioner No.1-JDR No.1 as per the Calculation Memo filed by the
DHRs (res,pondent Nos.1 to 5 herein) under Order 21 Rule 48 of
CPC by complying the provisions of Section 60 of CPC on payment
of process,
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the learned
trial Court has ordered the saiary attachment warrant of the
petitioner No.1-JDR No.l without going through the facts and
circumstar:rces of the case and also failed to appreciate the material
/'
./
3le
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
placed on record, violated the orders of the High Court in
CRP.MP.No.87 0f 2013 in cRP No.71 0f 2013, dated 21.01.2013.
Wherein the petitioner No.1-JDR No.1 has deposited total amount
of Rs.47,6961- uideTreasury challan No.64O1, dated 18.02.2013.
The E.P. amount is Rs.77,196 - Rs.47,696/- paid by the
petitioners-JDRs and the balance is Rs.29,5O0/- and prayed to set
aside the impugned order.
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent Nos.l to 5 submits that
the learned trial Court has rightly passed the order attaching the
salary of the petitioner No.1-JDR No.1 and no interference is called
for, prayed to dismiss the CRP.
6.
Learned counsel on record have filed their Calculation Memo
in support of their contentions
7.
Heard learned counsel on record, per-used the material.
8.
Now the point for consideration is : whether the order
passed by the learned trial Court suffers from any perversity or
illegality? If so, does it require interference of this court?
Point
g.
Petitioners-JDRs have filed copy of the salary attachment
warrant which is addressed to the Medical Officer, Office of the
4le
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
Government Maternity Hospital, Sulthan Bazar, Koti, Hyderabad
wherein ttre Drawing Officer was directed to withhold a sum of
Rs.77,196,/- subject to Section 60 of CPC from the salary of
petitioner l)[o.I-JDR No.1 within 24 months.
10. Recc,rd goes to show that the learned trial Court has earlier
passed an order in EP.No.113 of 2OLO in OS.No.411 of 2OO7 on
14.11.20112 attaching the salary of the petitioner No.1-JDR No.1.
Petitioners-JDR Nos.1 and 2 have filed CRP No.71 of 2013
challenginlg the order, dated 14.11.2012 in EP No.l13 of 2O10.
CRP filed by the petitioners was disposed of on I5.O2.2O17. The
order passed by this Court in the above said CRP is as under:
"4. L-e,arned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
petitioners deposited an amount of Rs.4O,OOO/- along with
costs as directed by this Court on 21.01.2013. The learned
couns,:l seeks eight weeks time to pay the remaining E.P.
amount.
5. Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the
resporrdents have no objection for granting of eight weeks
time l.o the petitioners for payment of the ba-lance E.P.
amourrt.
6. In view of the submissions made by the learned counsel for
both the parties, this Court is not inclined to express any
opinio:n touching the merits of the main case.
7. Haltng regard to the facts and circumstances of the case,
the petitioners are directed to pay the batance E.P. amrount
sls
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
within a period of eight (8) weeks from today, otherw'ise tl:e
order dated l4.ll.2}l2 passed in E.P.No.113 of 2010 in
O.S.No.411 of 2OOT holds good".
11. Petitioners-JDR Nos.1 and 2 have obtained interim stay ln
the present CRP on 20.11.2023 against the orders dated
25.09.2023. This Court has passed the following order while
granting interim stay which reads as under:
"In view of the facts and circumstances of the case and
considering the submissions made by learned counsel for
the petitioners, there shall be interim stay as prayed for
upon the petitioners depositing an amount of Rs.65,57O1along with costs to the credit of the trial Court within a
period of two (2) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of
the order".
t2. In pursuance of the orders of this Court on 2O.L7.2O23 rn
the present CRP, petitioners-JDRs have deposited an amount of
Rs.65,57O/- before the learned trial Court on O4.L2.2O23 uide
Bankers cheque No.L93247 .
13. Learned counsel for the petitioners-JDRs have filed
Calculation Memo stating that they ate entitled for refund of
Rs.13,65O/-, the calculation is as under:
!_...6le
Details of payment
Sl.No.
BRMR,J
cRP_342O2O2s
Amounts
AS Per Decree dated 12-082010
Decree amount:
Rs.5i,000/-
Cost Amount:
Rs.7,696/-
Plus l2o/o Per Annum from Rs. 17,500/Suit date to Decree:
Future Interest 60/oPA amount
13-08-20 I 0 to 12- l2-2OlO:
Rs. 1000/-
Total
Rs.77,L961-
As per Hon'ble High Court
Direction in CRP No.71 of
2013, Dated 2L-01-2OL3, Rs. 47,6961- (paid on
amount paid by the Judgment
Debtor Nos.1 & 2:
18-o2-2Or3l
Balance to be paid
Rs. 29,5O0/-
Future interest @ 60/o from Rs. 22420 / - {147.5 per
13-08-2013 tilt 28-tO-2025 month)
i.e., 2 years 8 months (152
months)
Total Balance due
Rs.51,920/ -
As per Hon'ble High Court
Direction in CRP No.3420 of Rs.65,570/- (Paid
2023, dated 2O-ll-2O25, 04-t2-2O231
on
Judgment Debtor paid
Additional amount paid
Rs.13,650/-
Total amount supposed to be
paid
Total amount paid
Balance to be refunded
Rs.99,616/Rs. 1,13,266/ -
Rs.13.650/-
L4. Respondent Nos.l to S-DHRs have also filed Calculation
Menqo stal.ing that the petitioners-JDR Nos.l ar,d 2 are still liable
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
7le
to pay an amount of Rs.8,780/- towards full satisfaction of the
decree. The calculation is as under:
"The suit is decreed on I2-O8-2O1O for Rs. 51,000/-
with cost and interest @ l2o/o p.a. from the date of filing
the suit till date of decree and thereafter @ 60/o per annum
till the date of realization on the principal amount of
Rs.50,000/-.
That the decreetal amount
Rs.51,OOO/-
The suit costs
Rs. 7,696/-
Interest from suit date till decree i.e.,
from 13-09-2OOT to l2-O8-201O for 35
months @ 12% on Rs. 51,000/- (51,OOO
X 12/100 X 35 = 17,850)
Rs. 17,85O/-
From 13-08-2010 to L2-|O-2O25 for 182
months @60/o
On Rs. 50,000/- (50,000 X 61100 X Rs. 45.50O/182=45,500)
Total
Rs. 1,22,0461-
Amount deposited 1 time
Rs.47,6961-
Amount deposited 2nd time
Rs.65.570/-Rs.1.13.266l-
The total due decreetal amount with Rs.\,22,O46/costs and interest Till 12-10-2025 is
The total amount deposited is
Rs.1.13.266l-
Balance
Rs.
.7aol-
Ble
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
15. As ;rer the orders of this Court in CRP No.71 by 2013, dated
L5.o2.2o17, tlr.e petitioners-JDRs were directed to pay the balance
E.P. amotrnt within a period of eight (8) weeks from today (i.e.,
l5.o2.2ol7l, otherwise the order dated 14.11.2or2 passed. in
E.P. No.113 of 2olo in oS No.411 of 2olr holds good. No amount
is mentioned in the above said order that what is the balance
amount.
16. on perusal of the order passed by the learned trial court it
only statec that the Decree Holders filed calculation Memo by
calculatin5l how much amount has to be attached and the oflice
was directed to issue attachment warrant as per the Calculation
Memo. Tht:re is no reference in the order with regard to the earlier
payments made by the petitioners-JDRs with regard to the amount
of Rs.47,6')61-. The order of the learned trial court is also silent
with regarrl to the earlier orders passed in the E.p. on 14.11 .2012.
Petitioners-JDR Nos.1 and 2 contended that they are entitled for
refund of Rs.13,650/- whereas, the respondent Nos.1 to S-DHRs
would contend that there is a balance of Rs.8,7g0/- towards full
satisfaction of the E.P. since the learned trial court has not
discussed anything in the impugned order with regard to the
payments made by the petitioners-JDRs, this court deems it
proper tg.,,remand the matter to the trial Court and take into
-
-----
/*-^-
sle
BRMR,J
cRP_3420_2023
consideration the payments made by the petitioners-JDRs i.e.,
Rs.47,696/- through Treasury Challan Receipt No.64O1 dated
18.02.2013 and Rs.65,570/- dated 04.12.2023 uide Bankers
Cheque No.193247 and pass a detailed order as per the amount
claimed by the respondent Nos.1 to S-DHRs in EP No.113 of 2AlO.
With the above said observations the impugned order is set aside
and the matter is remanded back to the learned trial Court for
fresh consideration.
L7. Civil Revision Petition is allowed and the order passed by the
learned Principal Junior Civil Judge Cum Judicial Magistrate of
First Class at Bhongir in EP No.113 of 2010 in OS No.411 of 2OO7,
dated 25.Og.2O23 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to
the trial Court for fresh consideration as indicated in the order
without costs.
Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated. Miscellaneous
application/s stands closed.
t
SD/. K.MADHAVI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFTCER
To,
1. Ih" Principal Junior Civil Judge-cum-Judicial Magistrate of First Class,
Bhongir
2. One CC to SriApurva M Gokhale, Advocate tOpUC]
3. One CC to Sri Mohd Abdul Samad AdvocatelOpuil
4. Two CD Copies
ADK/PSL
t
HIGH COURT
DATED i 0610212026
1:.IE S
()
ORDER
1 1 Htq 7q)f,
L)
CRP.N o.3420 of 2A23
*
ALLOWING THE GRP
WITHOUT COSTS
ab
\\
c
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review