Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC040014142023
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/502/2023
P.K Deb and 15 Ors.
C/o Director, Health and Family Welfare, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun,
P.O Naharlagun, Pin 791110. Mob. 98627813387 2: Rimik Riram
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
3: Radhe Gambo
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
4: Ripak Ngulam
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
5: Takhe Laling
Page No.# 2/12
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
6: Maga Reniya
Age:
Occupation :
D/o Late Shri Maga Techi
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
7: Ampi Bamin
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
8: Likha Yaje
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
9: Neelam Lel
Age:
Occupation :
S/o Shri Neelam Talri
permanent resident of Deed Village
P.O Deed
P.S Yachuli
District Lower Subansiri
Page No.# 3/12
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Duyu Munyia
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
11: Tage Tamin
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
12: Talam Har Neelam
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
13: Passang Pema
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
14: Nyilang Tajo
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 4/12
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
15: Dajar Mara
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110.
16: Pinkula Chetterjee
Age:
Occupation :
C/o Director
Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110
VERSUS
The State of AP and 10 Others
represented through the Chief Secretary), Civil Secretariat, Govt. of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar, P.O Itanagar 791111
2:The Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
High Power Committee on Pay Anomalies
Govt. of Arunachal pradesh
C/o Chief Secretary
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
P.O Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
3:The Members
Age: 0
Occupation :
High Power Committee
C/o Chief Secretary
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
P.O Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 5/12
4:The Member
Age: 0
Occupation :
The High Power Committee
C/o Chief Secretary
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
P.O Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:The Commissioner/Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
P.O Itanagar
Pin 791111
6:The Secretary Finance cum Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
High power Committee
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
P.O Itanagar
Pin 791111
7:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Personnel cum Monitoring and Operation
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
P.O Itanagar
Pin 791111
8:The Secretary to the Govt. of India
Age: 0
Occupation :
Ministry of Finance/ Vitt Mantralaya Department Expenditure/ Viaya Vibhag
(Implementation Cell)
Room 214
The Ashok
New Delhi.
9:The Director
Age: 0
Page No.# 6/12
Occupation :
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O
Naharlagun
Pin 791110
10:The State Programme Officer/Nodal Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
National Programme for Control of Blindness (NPCP)
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun
P.O Naharlagun
Pin 791110
11:The Secretary / Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Administrative Reforms and Training
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
PO Itanagar 79111
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tayum Son, Lishi Taj,T Torum
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), DSGI,Marto Kato,SC(Health),Taba Tagum
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
ORDER
05.01.2026
1.
Heard learned counsel Mr. T. Son for the petitioners; Mr. T. Tagum, learned
Standing Counsel for Health & Family Welfare and learned Government
Advocate, Ms. P. Sangeeta on behalf of learned counsel, Mr. S. Tapin.
2.
All the 16 petitioners of this petition have assailed the legality, validity and
the constitutionality of disparity in the pay scales with similarly placed
Page No.# 7/12
employees of the Department of Health & Family Welfare under the Government
of Arunachal Pradesh.
3.
It is submitted that the nature of work and responsibilities are same
between the Ophthalmic Assistants (in short O.A’s) and the Staff Nurse,
Auxiliary Nurse Midwives, Lady Health Visitor, General Nursing and Midwives and
Public Health Nurse who were extended the financial benefits including revised
pay scales, grade pay under Part-B and also classification of designation from
Group-C to Group-B (non-gazetted and non-ministerial) under 5th, 6th and 7th
Central Pay Commission recommendation.
4.
It is submitted that the present petitioners work and duties are at par with
their counter parts who are already enjoying the benefits of revised and
enhanced pay scales. The petitioners have been totally denied their legitimate
financial benefits, non-financial upgradations/enhancement of pay scales and
classification of Group-C to Group-B. Initially, the pay scales of the petitioners,
staff nurse, ANMs, LHVs, Public Health Nurse and Nursing sisters were
maintained in parity in so far the prescribed qualification, scale of pay between
the aforesaid employees and the present petitioners were concerned as they are
originally from the same Health Department.
5.
The present petitioners are highly aggrieved by the arbitrariness, malafide
and the illegality committed by the respondent authorities which appears to be
extremely discriminatory in nature as the nature and the policies adopted by the
State authorities with regard to the scale of pay between Group-C employees of
the Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
is in violation of the Doctrine of "Equal Pay for Equal Work" envisaged as a
constitutional goal under Article 39(d) of the Constitution of India.
6.
It is submitted that the Annexure-3 of the petition clearly reveals that the
Page No.# 8/12
petitioners were serving the departments since 1991 but they have not received
the enhanced pay from 1996 onwards, whereas, similarly placed counter-parts
from the same department have been receiving the enhanced pay even after
the 7th Pay Commission. It is submitted that the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh passed an order for implementation of Part-B Pay Scale under the 6th
Central Pay Commission for nurses serving under the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh w.e.f., 01.01.2006 from the entry scale but this enhanced benefit was
not entitled to the petitioners. The petitioners were also not granted the
benefits of the enhanced pay scale vide order No. MEST-2010/207 dated
29.12.2015.
7.
All the petitioners are serving in the capacity as Ophthalmic Assistants in
their respective places of posting.
It is further submitted that all the petitioners are qualified and they have cleared
their Class-XII Board examinations in the Science stream along with 3 years
Diploma course, whereas, the others who are enjoying the benefits according to
the up-to-date revised pay scales and who are counter-parts of the petitioners
are Class-8 pass employees. Thus, the petitioners are highly prejudiced and
aggrieved by the discriminatory conduct of the respondent authorities.
8.
Heard learned Government Advocate, Ms. P. Sangeeta on behalf of learned
counsel Mr. S. Tapin and Mr. T. Tagum, learned Standing Counsel, Health and
Family Welfare Department.
9.
It is submitted that a High Level Standing Committee on Pay Anomalies
have already been constituted. Learned counsel for the petitioners have also
drawn the attention of this Court to Annexure-A of the petition which is the
Revised Pay Rules of 2016 and implementation of the orders of the Government
of India regarding revision of pay scales as per 7th Central Pay Commission
Page No.# 9/12
Recommendation in the State of Arunachal Pradesh vide Memo No. FIN/Eii/28/2016/625 dated 15.12.2016. Thereafter, it is submitted that the petitioners
have not been granted revision as per 7th Pay Commission.
10.
The petitioners have relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Randhir Singh Vs. The Union Of India & Ors reported in (1982) 1 SCC 618,
wherein it has been held that:“ The counter-affidavit does not explain how the case of the drivers in the Police
Force is different from that of the drivers in other departments and what special
factors weighed in fixing a lower scale of pay for them. Apparently in the view
of the respondents, the circumstance that persons belong to different
departments of the Government is itself a sufficient circumstance to justify
different scales of pay irrespective of the identity of their powers, duties and
responsibilities. We cannot accept this view. If this view is to be stretched to its
logical conclusion, the scales of pay of officers of the same rank in the
Government of India may vary from department to department notwithstanding
that their powers, duties and responsibilities are identical. We concede that
equation of posts and equation of pay are matters primarily for the Executive
Government and expert bodies like the Pay Commission and not for courts but
we must hasten to say that where all things are equal that is, where all relevant
considerations are the same, persons holding identical posts may not be treated
differentially in the matter of their pay merely because they belong to different
departments. Of course, if officers of the same rank perform dissimilar functions
and the powers, duties and responsibilities of the posts held by them vary, such
officers may not be heard to complain of dissimilar pay merely because the
posts are of the same rank and the nomenclature is the same.
Our attention was drawn to Binoy Kumar Mukerjee v. Union of India and
Makhan Singh v. Union of India, where reference was made to the obser vations
of this Court in Kishori Mohanlal Bakshi v. Union of India describing the principle
of 'equal pay for equal work' as an abstract doctrine which had nothing to do
with Article 14. We shall presently point out how the principle, "equal pay for
equal work", is not an abstract doctrine but one of substance. Kishori Mohanlal
Bakshi v. Union of India is not itself of any real assistance to us since what was
decided there was that there could be different scales of pay for different
grades of a service. It is well known that there can be and there are different
grades in a service, with varying qualifications for entry into a particular grade,
the higher grade often being a promotional avenue for officers of the lower
grade. The higher qualifications for the higher grade, which may be either
Page No.# 10/12
academic qualifications or experience based on length of service, reasonably
sustain the classification of the officers into two grades with different scales of
pay. The principle of 'equal pay for equal work' would be an abstract doctrine
not attracting Article 14 if sought to be applied to them.
It is true that the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' is not expressly
declared by our Constitution to be a fundamental right. But it certainly is a
constitutional goal. Article 39(d) of the Constitution proclaims "equal pay for
equal work for both men and women" as a Directive Principle of State Policy.
'Equal pay for equal work for both men and women' means equal pay for equal
work for everyone and as between the sexes. Directive Principles, as has been
pointed out in some of the judgments of this Court have to be read into the
fundamental rights as a matter of interpretation. Article 14 of the Constitution
enjoins the State not to deny any person equality before the law or the equal
protection of the laws and Article 16 declares that there shall be equality of
opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to
any office under the State. These equality clauses of the Constitution must
mean something to everyone. To the vast majority of the people the equality
clauses of the Constitution would mean nothing if they are unconcerned with
the work they do and the pay they get. To them the equality clauses will have
some substance if equal work means equal pay. Whether the special procedure
prescribed by a statute for trying alleged robber-barons and smuggler kings or
for dealing with tax evaders is discriminatory, whether a particular
governmental policy in the matter of grant of licences or permits confers
unfettered discretion on the Executive, whether the take-over of the empires of
industrial tycoons is arbitrary and unconstitutional and other questions of like
nature, leave the millions of people of this country untouched. Questions
concerning wages and the like, mundane they may be, are yet matters of vital
concern to them and it is there, if at all that the equality clauses of the
Constitution have any significance to them. The Preamble to the Constitution
declares the solemn resolution of the people of India to constitute India into a
Sovereign Socialist Democratic Republic. Again the word 'Socialist' must mean
some-thing. Even if it does not mean 'to each according to his need', It must at
least mean 'equal pay for equal work'. "The principle of 'equal pay for equal
work' is expressly recognized by all socialist systems of law, e.g., Section 59 of
the Hungarian Labour Code, para 2 of Section 111 of the Czechoslovak Code,
Section 67 of the Bulgarian Code, Section 40 of the Code of the German
Democratic Republic, para 2 of Section 33 of the Rumanian Code. Indeed this
principle has been incorporated in several western Labour Codes too. Under
provisions in Section 31 (g. No. 2d) of Book I of the French Code du Travail,
and according to Argentinian law, this principle must be applied to female
Page No.# 11/12
workers in all collective bargaining agreements. In accordance with Section 3 of
the Grundgesetz of the German Federal Republic, and Clause 7, Section 123 of
the Mexican Constitution, the principle is given universal significance" (vide
International Labour Law by Istvan Szaszy, p. 265). The Preamble to the
Constitution of the Inter-national Labour Organisation recognises the principle
of 'equal remuneration for work of equal value' as constituting one of the
means of achieving the improvement of conditions "involving such injustice,
hardship and privation to large numbers of people as to produce unrest so great
that the peace and harmony of the world are imperiled". Construing Articles 14
and 16 in the light of the Preamble and Article 39(d), we are of the view that
the principle 'equal pay for equal work' is deducible from those Articles and may
be properly applied to cases of unequal scales of pay based on no classi-fication
or irrational classification though those drawing the different scales of pay do
identical work under the same employer.
There cannot be the slightest doubt that the drivers in the Delhi Police Force
perform the same functions and duties as other drivers in service of the Delhi
Administration and the Central Government. If any-thing, by reason of their
investiture with the 'powers, functions and privileges of a police officer', their
duties and responsibilities are more arduous. In answer to the allegation in the
petition that the driver-constables of the Delhi Police Force perform no less
arduous duties than drivers in other departments, it was admitted by the
respondents in their counter that the duties of the driver-constables of the Delhi
Police Force were onerous. What then is the reason for giving them a lower
scale of pay than others? There is none. The only answer of the respondents is
that the drivers of the Delhi Police Force and the other drivers belong to
different departments and that the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' is not
a principle which the courts may recognise and act upon. We have shown that
the answer is unsound. The clarification is irrational. We, therefore, allow the
writ petition and direct the respondents to fix the scale of pay of the petitioner
and the driver-constables of the Delhi Police Force at least on a par with that of
the drivers of the Railway Protection Force. The scale of pay shall be effective
from January 1, 1973, the date from which the recommendations of the Pay
Commission were given effect.”
Reverting back to this case, it is held that indeed the submission on behalf of
the petitioners that they deserve equal pay for equal work has substance.
Disparity in pay for equal work can be held to be discriminatory and disparity.
11.
After considering the submissions at the Bar with circumspection, it
Page No.# 12/12
appears that the petitioners’ grievance may be taken into consideration by the
High Powered Pay Anomalies Committee routed through proper channel and
thereafter, the respondent authorities including respondent No. 2 may consider
the grievance of the petitioners and pass necessary orders within 6 months from
the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
11.
In terms of the above observation, this petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review