Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010646372025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Wednesday, the Twenty ninth day of April
Two Thousand and Twenty Six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B.S.Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petition No: 3427 of 2025
Between:
...Petitioner
P. Chandra Kalavathi
and
Peram Vasudeva Reddy and others
...Respondents
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. K. Narsi Reddy
Counsel for the respondents:
Nil
Civil Revision Petition No: 3438 of 2025
Between:
...Petitioner
P. Chandra Kalavathi
and
Vasantham Siva Rami Reddy and others
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. K. Narsi Reddy
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
Counsel for the respondents:
Nil
Civil Revision Petition Nos: 3448, 3449 and 3535 of 2025
Between:
...Petitioner
P. Chandra Kalavathi
and
Peram Vasudeva Reddy and others
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. K. Narsi Reddy
Counsel for the respondents:
Nil
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
COMMON ORDER:
C.R.P. No. 3427 of 2025 is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India against the order dated 27.06.2025 dismissing I.A.
No. 165 of 2022 in O.S. No. 134 of 2017 on the file of the Court of the
Civil Judge (Junior Division), Tadipatri, filed by the defendant No.3
under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, r/w. Section 151 of
C.P.C. to send the disputed promissory notes, a copy of registered will
dated 06.06.2003 and the hand writings of M. Chenna Kesava Reddy
obtained in open Court to hand writing expert for its examination.
2.
C.R.P. No. 3438 of 2025 is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India against the order dated 27.06.2025 dismissing I.A.
No. 453 of 2021 in O.S. No. 100 of 2017 on the file of the Court of the
Civil Judge (Junior Division), Tadipatri, filed by the defendant No.3
under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, r/w. Section 151 of
C.P.C. seeking the similar relief as in I.A. No. 165 of 2020 in O.S. No.
134 of 2017.
3.
C.R.P. Nos. 3448, 3449 and 3535 of 2025 are filed under Article
227 of the Constitution of India against the common order dated
27.06.2025 dismissing I.A. Nos. 457, 459 and 460 of 2021 in O.S. No.
99 of 2017 on the file of the Court of the Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Tadipatri, all filed by the defendant No.3.
4.
I.A. No. 457 of 2017 is filed under Section 45 of the Indian
Evidence Act to send the disputed promissory note / Ex.A1, a copy of
registered will No. 4/2003, dated 06.06.2003, and the hand writing of
M. Chenna Kesava Reddy obtained in open Court to a hand writing
expert for examination of the signature. I.A. No. 459 of 2021 is filed
under Order VIII, Rule 1A (3) r/w 151 C.P.C. to receive a copy of the
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
registered will No. 4/2003, dated 06.06.2003. I.A. No. 460 of 2021 is
filed under Order XVIII, Rule 17 r/w. 151 C.P.C. to recall D.W.1 to
adduce evidence and mark the document.
5.
The case of the petitioner is, briefly, as follows:
a.
The revision petitioner herein is the defendant No.3 in O.S. Nos.
99, 100 and 134 of 2017. The three suits were filed for recovery of the
amount on promissory notes dated 06.10.2014, 14.07.2014 and
10.08.2014, each for Rs.1,00,000/-, allegedly executed by Moolinti Nagi
Reddy. As he died on 22.10.2016, the suits were filed against his legal
heirs viz., the defendants Nos.1 to 3. The defendant No.1 is the wife of
Late Moolinti Nagi Reddy, the defendants Nos. 2 and 3 are his son and
daughter.
b.
The plaintiff in O.S. Nos. 99 and 134 of 2017 is P. Vasudeva
Reddy. The plaintiff in O.S. No.100 of 2017 is V. Siva Rami Reddy.
c.
The suits were filed for recovery of the amounts of Rs.1,33,541/-,
Rs.1,34,861/- and Rs.1,33,958/- with future interest @ 12% per annum
respectively in O.S. Nos.134, 100 and 99 of 2017.
6.
The suits were opposed by the defendant No.3 / the petitioner
herein by filing written statements, briefly, stating as follows:
a.
This defendant’s father never borrowed any amount from the
plaintiff. The plaintiff in O.S. Nos. 99, 134 of 2017 i.e., P. Vasudeva
Reddy is brother of the defendant No.2’s wife and son of the defendant
No. 1’s brother. The plaintiff in O.S. No. 100 of 2017 i.e., V. Siva Rami
Reddy is maternal uncle of the defendant No. 2’s wife. The defendants
Nos. 1 and 2 colluded and created the suit promissory notes by forging
the signature of the deceased M. Nagi Reddy.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
b.
It is false that the defendants alone are the legal heirs of the
deceased M. Nagi Reddy. Late M. Nagi Reddy has another daughter by
name Venkata Krishnamma. She died on 24.01.2017.
c.
This defendant is physically handicapped woman. After the death
of father this defendant, this defendant and the other defendants have
been enjoying the joint family’s landed properties without any partition.
The defendants Nos. 1 and 2 have ill feeling against this defendant and
created the suit promissory notes to cause loss to this defendant.
Hence, it is prayed to dismiss the suits.
7.
Similarly, the defendant No.3 filed I.A.No.453 of 2021 in O.S. No.
100 of 2017 and I.A. No. 165 of 2022 in O.S. No. 134 of 2017.
8.
The petitioner / the defendant No.3 in all the interlocutory
applications contends that she recently had come to know that the
promissory notes were scribed by her paternal uncle M. Chenna
Kesava Reddy; that the registered will dated 06.06.2003 is in the
custody of the respondents Nos.2 and 3; that the said document is very
essential to compare the signature of her father with the disputed
signature in the suit promissory note and to send them to a hand writing
expert for comparison.
9.
The plaintiff filed counters opposing all the petitions stating that
the petitioner / the defendant No.3 filed the petitions at the fag end of its
disposal; that the contemporaneous standard admitted signatures and
writings of the executant of the suit promissory note, for the purpose of
comparison are not available; and that the photostat copy of the
document for the purpose of comparison is unacceptable. Hence, it is
prayed to dismiss the petitions.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
10.
After hearing both the parties, the trial Court dismissed all the
petitions filed for examination of the disputed signature observing that
registered will dated 06.06.2003 was executed more than a decade
prior to the alleged execution of the suit promissory notes and that the
will deed is not of the contemporaneous period and there is no material
on record to show that it is the sole available admitted signature of the
deceased. The trial Court further held that in the absence of
contemporaneous admitted signature of the deceased, reference to an
expert would not assist the Court in arriving at a conclusive finding and
that a Court is empowered under Section 73 of the Indian Evidence Act
to compare the disputed signatures on its own without necessarily
referring them to an expert. It is further observed by the trial Court that
the specimen handwriting of the alleged scribe M. Chenna Kesava
Reddy is neither admitted nor produced in any authenticated form, and
that his connection to the scribe of the promissory note is itself a matter
of dispute.
11.
The trial Court dismissed I.A. No. 460 of 2021 observing that the
petitioner has not shown any sufficient cause or due diligence for not
marking the will at an appropriate stage. I.A. No. 459 of 2021, which is
filed to receive the registered Will, dated 06.06.2003, was also
dismissed by the trial Court observing that the document has no
material bearing on the dispute.
12.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the petitions, these revision
petitions were filed contending that the trial Court ought to have
considered that the expert’s opinion is required to scientifically
scrutinize the signature to assist the Court and that no prejudice will be
caused to the other party even if signature is compared by a
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
handwriting expert with the admitted signature as the process is to
render justice on the basis of the pleadings substantiated by evidence.
13.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the trial
Court erred in dismissing the petitions without appreciating the
importance of the opinion of an expert to prove the defence and that it is
very essential for the defendant to put forth the defence.
14.
In spite of service of notice on the respondent No.1, there is no
appearance. The notice sent to the respondent No.1 was returned unserved with an endorsement ‘no such person in the address’.
15.
As can be understood from the contention of the petitioner, the
signature of late Mr. Nagi Reddy on the promissory note was denied
and the same is to be examined with his original signature available in
the registers of the office of the Sub-Registrar.
Having allowed the
petition in I.A. No. 742 of 2022 in O.S. No.100 of 2017 directing
production of the original register containing the signature of late M.
Nagi Reddy, the trial Court erred in dismissing the petitions seeking
opinion of the expert to compare the disputed signatures on the
promissory note with the original signature in the public register
containing the registered Will No. 4 of 2003 called for. Though Section
73 of the Indian Evidence Act empowers a Court to compare the
signatures, it is advisable that opinion of an expert is taken. Therefore,
insofar as the relief sought by the petitioner for opinion of an expert for
examination of the disputed signature of M. Nagi Reddy, the petitioner
can be granted the relief.
16.
The other relief claimed by the petitioner that the handwriting of
M. Chenna kesava Reddy be taken in the open Court for comparing it
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
by an expert, the petition is not clear as to what is to be compared with
the handwriting so taken.
17.
During the course of hearing, on clarification, the learned counsel
for the petitioner submitted that the content of the promissory note may
be examined with reference to the handwriting taken in the open Court.
18.
It is not the specific case that the content in the promissory note
was handwritten by M. Chenna kesava Reddy.
It is also not clear
whether who made the disputed signature of M. Nagi Reddy. Moreover,
M. Chenna kesava Reddy is not a party to the suits.
Either the
statement in the affidavit or the prayer sought is not clear. This Court is
of the view that this relief claimed by the petitioner is not required,
particularly, if the disputed signature of late M. Nagi Reddy on the
promissory note is examined by an expert.
19.
It is to be further noted that the relief seeking the opinion of an
expert to examine the disputed signature of late M. Nagi Reddy is
possible on receipt of original register from the Sub-registrar as called
for vide order in I.A. No. 742 of 2022. Therefore, the relief granted in
this regard is subject to availability of such record, since it is not known
whether such record was produced or can be produced in furtherance
of the direction given by the trial Court in I.A. No. 742 of 2022.
20.
Since certified copy of the Will is not useful for comparison of the
disputed signature, the relief in I.A. No. 459 of 2021 need not be
granted.
Consequently, the relief in I.A.No.460 of 2021 is also need
not be granted.
Moreover, the petition for production of the original
register for the said purpose has already allowed directing the SubRegistrar to produce the original record. Accordingly, C.R.P. Nos. 3448
of 2025 and 3535 of 2025 are liable to be dismissed.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
21.
In the result, C.R.P. Nos. 3427 of 2025, 3438 of 2025 and 3449 of
2025 are allowed in part, only to the extent of directing the expert to
examine the disputed signature of late M. Nagi Reddy with his admitted
signature in the public register containing the registered Will No.4 of
2003 in the office of the Sub-Registrar, provided such record is
produced.
22.
In the result, C.R.P. Nos. 3448 of 2025 and 3535 of 2025 are
dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
B. S. BHANUMATHI, J
Dated: 29.04.2026
NSM / RAR
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3427 of 2025 & batch
The Honourable Ms. Justice B.S.Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petition Nos: 3427, 3438, 3448, 3449 and 3535 of 2025
Dated: 29.04.2026
NSM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review