Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RC,J
CRLP
LP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
Date of reserved for orders : 06.08.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 13.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 14.10.2026
APHC010337462025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3332]
TUESDAY, THE 13th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT:THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 7888/2025
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
CRIMINAL PETITION No.7888 of 2025
Between:
1. POCHINAPEDDI BALASUBRAHMANYAM, S/O LATE P.PAPAYYA, AGE
55 YEARS. PRESENT WORKING AS SENIOR SUPERINTENDENTSUPERINTENDENT
RAILWAY MAIL SERVICE, MA DIVISION, MADURAI
MADURAI-625001
625001 PRESENT
RESIDING AT PLOT NO
NO-1
1 D, KAVIYAN APARTMENT, NEHRU NAGAR,
BYE-PASS
PASS ROAD,
MADURAI
MADURAI-625016,TAMILNADU.
625016,TAMILNADU.
EMAIL ID
DISCASSISTANCE@GMAIL.COM
MOBILE
NO.
NO.--9491198428.
PREVIOUS WORKED AS SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT OF POST
OFFICES,
BHIMAVARAM DIVISION, BHIMAVARAM
PREVIOUS
RESIDENT ADDRESS DOOR NO.4
NO.4-10/1,
10/1, SETTIBALIJA, RAMALAYAM
RAMALAY
SIDE, NEAR VIJAYA CLINIC,RAYALAM, BHIMAVARAM, DOOR NO.70NO.70
17A-29/2B,
29/2B, SASIKANTH NAGAR, KAKINADA.
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED
AND
1. THE STATE OF AP, ,REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI /ACB ,1,1
83-21/A,
21/A, MVP COLONY, SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM
VISAKAPATNAM-17
17 REP., BY ITS
SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR FOR CBI HIGH COURT, NELAPADU,
AMARAVATHI.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
2. SRI SALA RAMUDU, POSTMAN, HEAD POST OFFICE, PALAKOL534260, WEST GODAVARI DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH. MOBILE
NO. 6300284159.
...RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT(S):
Petition under Section 437/438/439/482 of Cr.P.C and 528 of BNSS
praying that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of
Criminal Petition, the High Courtmay be pleased to call for the records of CC No
12/2024 on the file of Hon’ble Special Judge for CBI Court, Vijayawada, and to
quash the proceedings and to grant
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C and 528 of BNSS praying that in the
circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition,the
High Court may be pleased pleased to dispense with filing of the certified copy
of the CC No 12/2024 on the file of Hon’ble Special Judge for CBI Court,
Vijayawada in the interest of justice
IA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C and 528 of BNSS praying that in the
circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition,the
High Court may be pleased pleased to order stay of all the proceedings in C.C.
No.12/2024 on the file of Hon’ble Special Judge for CBI Court, Vijayawada
including appearance of the petitioner, pending disposal of this Criminal Petition
and to pass
IA NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C and 528 of BNSS praying that in the
circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition,the
High Court may be pleased may be pleased to direct the office to amend the
cause title in respect of 1st respondent as Union of India Rep. by Inspector of
Police, CBI /ACB ,1-83-21/A, MVP Colony, Sector 8, Visakapatnam-17 Rep.,
by its Special Public Prosecutor for CBI, High court, Nelapadu, Amaravathi
instead of The State of A.P.,Rep. by Inspector of Police, CBI /ACB ,1-83-21/A,
MVP Colony, Sector 8, Visakapatnam-17 Rep., by its Special Public Prosecutor
for CBI High court, Nelapadu, Amaravathi. in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C and 528 of BNSS praying that in the
circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition,the
High Court may be pleased may be pleased to receive the aforesaid documents
i.e. (i) Copy of the Sanction Order for prosecution issued against the petitioner
Sri P Balasubrahmanyam, (ii) Copy of the petition filed by the petitioner before
the learned Trial Court seeking day-to-day trial, (iii) Copy of the order of this
Hon'ble High Court in CrI.RC. Nos. 1211 and 1212 of 2024, and (iv) Docket
orders of the learned Trial Court in C.C. No.12 of 2024 regarding the presence
of the accused before the Trial Court as additional documents for the just and
proper adjudication of the Criminal Petition and in the interest of justice..
Counsel for the Petitioner/accused:
1. PARTY IN PERSON
Counsel for the Respondent/complainant(S):
1. P S P SURESH KUMAR, Spl. Public Prosecutor for CBI
WRIT PETITION NO: 19734/2025
Between:
1. P BALASUBRAHMANYAM, I.PO.S.,
SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT,
RAILWAY MAIL SERVICE,
MA
DIVISION, MADURAI-625001
RESIDING AT PLOT NO-ID, KAVIYAN APARTMENT, NEHRU NAGAR,
BYE-PASS ROAD,
MADURAI-625016, TAMILNADU.
EMAIL ID
DISCASSISTANCE@GMAIL.COM MOBILE NO.-9491198428.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP., BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY, HOME DEPARTMENT, SECRATERIAT, VELAGAPUDI,
AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI /ACB ,1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
3. SRI R SUDHIRKUMAR, INVESTIGATION OFFICER AND INSPECTOR
OF POLICE CBI-ACB, VISAKHAPATNAM.
4. SRI R MANOHAR REDDY, INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI-ACB,
VISAKHAPATNAM-500017
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction particularly one in the
nature of Writ of Certiorari more (i) calling for the records relating to and
connected orders of the Petitioners arrest dated 19-12-2023 arising out FIR
No.RC.23(A)/2023 dated 19-12-2023 respondent and remand order dated 2012-2023 with the lodged by the and other consequent orders arising out of the
arrest and to declare the act of arrest as illegal and void ab initio as the arrest
was effected without service of grounds of arrest in violation of the mandate of
Section 47 of BNSS (Section-50 of Crpc) and the constitutional provisions of
Article-21 and 22 (1). (II) to declare the act of arrest as contemptuous of the
orders on arrest guidelines issued by the Honble Supreme Court between D K
Basu vs State of West Bengal (AIR 1997, SC 610) and to initiate contempt
proceedings against the respondents 3 and 4 and directing the competent
authority in the CBI to initiate departmental disciplinary action for the misconduct
on the part of the respondents 3 and 4 as ordered by the Honble Supreme
Court in D K Basu case (supra) and reiterated in its latest orders between Vijay
Pal Yadav vs Mamta Singh dated 26-03-2025 in the interest of justice and to
pass such
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased may
be pleased to dispense with the filing of the certified copy of the FIR No.RC
23(A)/2023 dated 19-12-2023, and pass to such
IA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
IA NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the office to amend the cause title in respect of 1st respondent as Union
of India Rep. by Inspector of Police, CBI /ACB ,1-83-21/A, MVP Colony, Sector
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
8, Visakapatnam-17 Rep., by its Special Public Prosecutor for CBI, High court,
Nelapadu, Amaravathi instead of The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep., by its
Principal Secretary, Home Department, Secrateriat, Velagapudi, Amaravathi,
Guntur District. in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased may
be pleased to strike off Respondent Nos. 3 & 4 from the array of parties and
dismiss the Writ Petition against Respondent Nos. 3 & 4 and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased May
be pleased to receive the aforesaid documents i.e.i) Copy of Remand Report
dated 20.12.2023 of the Honble Judge of Special Judge for CBI Cases,
Vijayawada,ii) Copy of Medical examination report dated 20.12.2023 conducted
in respect of the Petitioner Sri P Balasubrahmanyam, as additional documents
for the just and proper adjudication of the Criminal Petition and in the interest of
justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PARTY IN PERSON
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P S P SURESH KUMAR, Spl. Public Prosecutor for CBI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31644/2025
Between:
1. P BALASUBRAHMANYAM, I.PO.S.,
SENIOR SUPERINTENDENTRAILWAY MAILS AT PLOT NO-1D, KAVIYAN APARTMENT, BYE PASS
ROAD, NEHRU NAGAR, MADURAI-625016. TAMILNADU, MOBILE NO.
9491198428, EMAIL ID- DISCASSISTANCE@GMAIL.COM
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE UNION OF INDIA, REP., BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
HOME AFFAIRS. ROOM NO 113, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI110001.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
2. THE DIRECTORCBI, PLOT NO-5B, CGO COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD,
NEW DELHI-110003.
3. THE INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI /ACB ,1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17 REP., BY ITS SPECIAL PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR FOR CBI HIGH COURT, NELAPADU, AMARAVATHI
VISAKHAPATNAM-530017
4. SRI MURALI RAMBHA, THE THEN SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
CBI-ACB, NOW WORKING AS DEPUTY INSPECTOR-GENERAL OF
POLICE, 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY, SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
5. N RAGHAVENDRAKUMAR, DY SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB, 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
6. SRI R MANOHAR REDDY, INSPECTOR OF PLICE, CBI/ACB
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
7. SRI R SUDHIR KUMAR, INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI/ACB,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
8. SRI
N
JOGARAO,
INSPECTOR
OF
POLICE
CBI/ACB
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
9. SRI RAJU SINGH, ASSISTANT SUB-INSPECTOR OF POLICE CBI-ACB
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB, 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
10. SRI
CH
PRASADARAO,
HEAD
CONSTABLE,
CBI/ACB,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
11. SRI
A
SANKARARAO,
POLICE
CONSTABLE,
CBI/ACB,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB, 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
12. SRI B CHANDRASEKHAR, POLICE CONSTABLE, CBI/ACB,
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBI/ACB 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
13. SRI P ANILKUMAR
EMP CODE NO 657352, S/O LATE VARA
PRASAD, ASSISTANT MANAGER, UNION BANK OF INDIA, MAIN
BRANCH, JP ROAD, NEAR RAMU SWEETS, BHIMAVARAM-534201.
MOBILE NO-8374117295.
14. SRI G SATISHKUMAR EMP CODE NO 691209, S/O SRI G. DEMUDU,
ASSISTANT MANAGER, UNION BANK OF INDIA, BUDHAVARAM
MARKET BRANCH, BHIMAVARAM-534201. MOBILE NO-9985792920.
15. SRI SALA RAMUDU, S/O BASAVAKOTA SANKARAYYA, POSTMAN,
HEAD POST OFFICE, PALAKOL, W.GODAVARI DISTRICT., AP.
MOBILE NO, 6300284159, 9177855184.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, order or direction, more in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus, to declare the search operation of the CBI instituted on my
house on 19/20-12-2023 in relating to and connection with the CC.No.12/2024
on the file of Hon'ble Special Judge court for CBI cases, Vijayawada as illegal,
arbitrary, legally unsustainable and violative of the provisions of Article-14, 15,16
and 21 of the Constitution of India and to direct the Respondents 1 to 2 to initiate
criminal
prosecution and departmental disciplinary action against the
respondents 4 to 15 for having acted in deliberate defiance of the law and the
CBI manual provisions in intruding and searching my house at odd unearthly
hours in the name of search in violation of my fundamental rights and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents 1 to 2 to restrain the respondents 3 to 15 not to fabricate
any document relating to search operation now, pending disposal of the above
writ petition and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased May
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
be pleased to receive additional material papers as part and parcel of this Writ
Petition and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased May
be pleased to strike off the Respondent Nos. 4 to 15 from the array of parties and
dismiss the Writ Petition against the Respondent Nos. 4 to 15 and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PARTY IN PERSON
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P S P SURESH KUMAR, Spl. Public Prosecutor for CBI
WRIT PETITION NO: 32169/2025
Between:
1. P BALASUBRAHMANYAM, I.PO.S.,
SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT,
RAILWAY MAIL SERVICE, MA DIVISION, MADURAI-625001 RESIDING
AT PLOT NO-ID, KAVIYAN APARTMENT, NEHRU NAGAR, BYE-PASS
ROAD,MADURAI-625016,
TAMILNADU.
EMAIL
ID
DISCASSISTANCE@GMAIL.COM MOBILE NO.-9491198428
...PETITIONER
AND
1. UNION OF INDIA, REP. BY INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI /ACB ,1-8321/A, MVP COLONY, SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17 REP., BY ITS
SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR FOR CBI HIGH COURT OF A.P,
NELAPADU, AMARAVATHI
2. SRI R MANOHAR REDDY, TRAP LAYING OFFICER AND INSPECTOR
OF POLICE, CBI-ACB, C/O SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, CBI
BRANCH, VISAKHAPATNAM-530017.
3. SRI R SUDHIR KUMAR, INVESTIGATION OFFICER AND IN, CBI-ACB,
C/O SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, CBI BRANCH VISAKHAPATNAM530017.
4. SRI N RAGHAVENDRAKUMAR, DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF
POLICE, CBI-ACB, C/O SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, CBI BRANCH,
VISAKHAPATNAM-530017.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
5. SRI A SANKARARAO, HEAD
SUPERINTENDENT
OF
VISAKHAPATNAM530017.
CONSTABLE, CBI-ACB,
C/O
POLICE,
CBI
BRANCH
6. SRI N JOGARAO, INSPECTOR OF POLICE, CBI-ACB,
C/O
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, CBI BRANCH, VISAKHAPATNAM
530017.
7. SRI CH PRASADARAO, HEAD CONSTABLE, CBI-ACB,
C/O
SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, CBI BRANCH, VISAKHAPATNAM
530017.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus to declare that the cruelty perpetrated by the
respondents when the petitioner was in their custody as arbitrary, illegal and
violative of Articles-14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India and to further
declare the torture inflicted by the respondents as an act of infringement of
petitioner's fundamental rights by the respondents and an act of law breaking by
the law enforcers and consequently to direct the 1st respondent to launch
criminal prosecution against the respondents No. 2 to 7 herein for the physical,
mental and psychological torture inflicted by them and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the respondent No.1 to conduct any interrogation under CCTV coverage in
the presence of petitioner counsel, if such a contingency for interrogation arises,
pending disposal of the writ petition in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the 1 St
respondent to Launch criminal prosecution against the
respondents No. 2 to 7 arraigned herein for the physical, mental and
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
psychological torture inflicted by them, pending disposal of the writ petition in the
interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased May
be pleased to strike off Respondent Nos. 2 to 7 from the array of parties and
dismiss the Writ Petition against Respondent Nos. 2 to 7 and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PARTY IN PERSON
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. M UMA DEVI (CENTRAL GOVT COUNSEL)
2. P S P SURESH KUMAR, Spl. Public Prosecutor for CBI
WRIT PETITION NO: 34423/2025
Between:
1. P.BALASUBRAHMANYAM, I.PO.S.,, SENIOR SUPERINTENDENTRAILWAY MAILS AT PLOT NO-1D, KAVIYAN APARTMENT, BYE PASS
ROAD, NEHRU NAGAR, MADURAI-625016. TAMILNADU, MOBILE NO.
9491198428, EMAIL ID- DISCASSISTANCE@AMAIL.COM
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE UNION OF INDIA, REP., BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
HOME AFFAIRS. ROOM NO 113, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI110001.
2. THE DIRECTORCBI, PLOT NO-5B, CGO COMPLEX,
NEW DELHI-110003.
LODHI ROAD,
3. SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE CBIACB, 1-83-21/A, MVP COLONY,
SECTOR 8, VISAKAPATNAM-17
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, order or direction, more in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus to declare the issuance of press release dated 21-12-2023 in
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
official CBI handles of Twitter ( now known as X) and its official website as
ultravires the constitutional provisions of Article-21 relating to and in connection
with the CC.No.12/2024 on the file of Honble Special Judge court for CBI cases,
Vijayawada as illegal, arbitrary, legally unsustainable and violative of the
provisions of Article- 14, and 21 of the Constitution of India and to direct the
Respondents 1 to 2 to initiate criminal prosecution and departmental disciplinary
action against the
3rd respondent for orchestrating smearing campaign
damaging my reputation with false information and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
pass an interim order directing the respondents 1 and 2 for necessary action to
take down the damaging false information from all internet desks hosted by the
CBI on 21-12-2023 and 22-12-2023 and to issue a correctional press release
forthwith pending disposal of the above writ petition and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased May
be pleased to receive the aforesaid documents i.e.i) Copy of CBI Crime Manual 2020 regarding publicity in Media about the cases (page no.394 to 397),ii) copy
of Office Memorandum No.21/44/2008-PD/72 dated 09.01.2009 as additional
documents for the just and proper adjudication of the Writ Petition and in the
interest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PARTY IN PERSON
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. DILIP JAYARAM S (CENTRAL GOVERNMENT COUNSEL)
2. P S P SURESH KUMAR, Spl. Public Prosecutor for CBI
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
COMMON ORDER
Criminal Petition No.7888 of 2025 is filed under Section 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeking quashing of the proceedings
in C.C. No.12 of 2024 on the ground that the material collected by the CBI does
not legally establish the essential ingredients of demand and acceptance; that
the complaint is retaliatory; and that the investigation, recovery, electronic
evidence and sanction suffer from defects which make continuation of the
prosecution an abuse of process.
2. W.P.No.19734 of 2025 is filed questioning the legality of the petitioner’s
arrest in RC No.23(A)/2023 on 19.12.2023 alleging that the grounds of arrest
were not properly communicated and that the safeguards flowing from Articles
21 and 22(1) of the Constitution and the statutory provisions governing arrest
were violated and
sought consequential disciplinary action against the
concerned CBI officers.
3. W.P.No.31644 of 2025 is filed questioning the search conducted at the
petitioner’s residential premises on the night of 19/20.12.2023 on the grounds of
absence of lawful authorization, non-compliance with the safeguards governing
search and seizure, absence or improper association of independent witnesses,
irregular seizure of articles and non-supply or non-production of the search
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
records and thereby the petitioner seeks a declaration that the search was illegal
and consequential departmental action against the officers concerned.
4. W.P.No.32169 of 2025 is filed alleging that the petitioner was ill-treated
physically, mentally and psychologically while he was in CBI custody and during
the course of interrogation. Invoking Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution,
the petitioner seeks a declaration that the conduct of the respondent officials
violated his fundamental rights and a direction for criminal action against the
officers whom he has impleaded personally.
5. W.P.No.34423 of 2025 is filed challenging the press release issued by
the CBI concerning the registration of the case, trap, remand and seizure on the
ground that the publication contained false or prejudicial assertions, impaired his
dignity and reputation, and violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution and
the petitioner seeks consequential criminal and departmental action against the
officer responsible for the publication.
6.These five matters arise out of the same prosecution, namely C.C. No.12
of 2024 on the file of the learned Special Judge for CBI Cases, Vijayawada,
though the relief claimed in each proceeding is distinct, but the events are
interconnected. They are therefore, with the consent of parties, heard and
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
considered together to avoid repetition and are being disposed of by this
Common order.
7. The contents of the petitions and written submissions can briefly be
summarised as follows:
(i) The petitioner is an officer of the Indian Postal Service, Group-A cadre,
and at the relevant point of time was functioning as Senior Superintendent of
Post Offices, Bhimavaram Division. His case, in substance, is that the entire
controversy had its origin in departmental action taken by him against the de
facto complainant, Sri S. Sala Ramudu, who was working as a Postman.
According to the petitioner, information was received in the department
regarding the complainant's alleged involvement in a criminal case and
concerning his antecedents. The petitioner states that he caused the matter to
be verified through the departmental machinery and, acting in discharge of his
official and disciplinary functions, placed the complainant under suspension. He
maintains that the suspension was an administrative measure founded upon the
material available and was neither personal nor actuated by any improper
motive.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(ii) The de facto complainant became aggrieved by the suspension and
developed animosity towards him. According to the petitioner, the later
allegation of demand for illegal gratification was a retaliatory version brought
into existence after the departmental action taken against the de facto
complainant. He therefore asks the Court to examine the chronology beginning
with the complaint against the Postman, the departmental inquiry and
suspension, followed by the complainant's approaches to him and, thereafter,
the complaint to the CBI. His specific case is that the prior disciplinary dispute
with the de facto complainant supplies the motive for false implication and
materially affects the credibility of the subsequent accusation.
(iii) The prosecution material does not establish, in the manner required by
law, a demand for undue advantage, its acceptance by him, or the necessary
nexus between such alleged demand and an official favour. According to him,
the disciplinary process against the complainant had already been set in motion
and was proceeding in accordance with the applicable service rules, and there
was no pending favour which could legitimately be portrayed as being sold for
consideration.
(iv) The prosecution refers to demands on earlier dates, including
03.12.2023 and 17.12.2023, whereas the written complaint and FIR are dated
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
19.12.2023. He questions why, if a demand of such magnitude had in fact been
made, no immediate complaint was lodged. He also questions the prosecution
versions concerning telephonic information allegedly given to the Superintendent
of Police, receipt of a written complaint, transmission by email and the precise
stage at which the CBI treated the information as disclosing a cognizable
offence. According to him, the chronology of receipt, verification and registration
has not been presented with the clarity expected in a trap case.
(v) The records relating to receipt of information, preliminary verification,
assembly of officers and independent witnesses, arrangement of vehicles, travel
and arrival, preparation of pre-trap proceedings and commencement of the
operation must form one continuous and verifiable chronology. In his
submission, gaps or inconsistencies in those contemporaneous records are
material because the prosecution case substantially depends upon the integrity
of the trap proceedings.
(vi) The manner in which the conversation allegedly recorded by the
complainant on 17.12.2023 and the conversation said to have been recorded
during the trap on 19.12.2023 were created, received, copied, preserved and
transmitted. He contends that the original source devices, complete identifying
particulars, hash values, forensic images, dates and times of copying and an
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
uninterrupted chain of custody have not been satisfactorily demonstrated in the
material relied upon by the prosecution. According to him, where the prosecution
relies heavily upon digital conversations, the integrity of the source and every
material stage of preservation assumes significance.
(vii) the transcripts and recorded conversations, even if taken at face value
for the limited purpose of the petitions, do not clearly establish the specific
demand attributed to him. He submits that ambiguous words, gestures or
subsequent conduct cannot be substituted for proof of a conscious demand and
acceptance. His further grievance is that the prosecution has attempted to read
incriminating meaning into gestures and surrounding circumstances without
there being clear independent material showing that he asked the complainant to
pay money as consideration for revoking the suspension.
(viii) no money was recovered from his person, clothing, room, cupboard
or any place shown to be in his exclusive possession. The prosecution itself
states that the amount was ultimately found in an open vacant area adjacent to
the residential premises. The petitioner therefore contends that the mere fact
that currency bearing the pre-trap serial numbers was found in an open area
does not, without a reliable connecting link, establish that he had consciously
received and thereafter discarded it.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(ix) the sketch does not sufficiently depict all material physical features,
surrounding houses, balconies, access points, visibility and the exact place from
which the currency was recovered. He further relies upon the absence of his
signature on the recovery documents, as pleaded by him, and says that the
prosecution must establish by contemporaneous and independent material how
the amount travelled from the chair to the vacant site and how that movement is
attributable to him.
(x) the hand-wash results and the tests said to have been conducted on
the chair, bushes, grass or soil cannot by themselves establish the foundational
facts of demand and voluntary acceptance. He further raises objections
regarding the collection, sealing, preservation and forensic examination of
material objects and samples. His case is that scientific evidence can corroborate
a proved transaction, but cannot be used to fill a fundamental gap regarding the
alleged demand or the conscious receipt of money.
(xi) the sanctioning authority did not have before it, or did not properly
consider, the entire relevant material, including the conversations and forensic
material upon which the prosecution subsequently placed reliance. According to
him, sanction is not an empty formality and must reflect consideration of the
material necessary to decide whether prosecution should be authorized. He
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
therefore contends that the alleged non-consideration of vital material
demonstrates want of proper application of mind.
(xii) The petitioner, relies, inter alia, upon State of Haryana v. Bhajan
Lal1. His submission is that the allegations and the material, read as a whole, fail
to disclose
the essential
ingredients
of the offence,
contain inherent
improbabilities and have arisen in the background of a pre-existing grievance of
the complainant against the petitioner. He therefore seeks quashing of C.C.
No.12 of 2024 and contends that compelling him to face a full criminal trial on
such material would amount to abuse of process.
(xiii) In W.P. No.19734 of 2025, the petitioner challenges his arrest on
19.12.2023, contending that the grounds of arrest were not effectively and
meaningfully communicated when his liberty was curtailed. He disputes the CBI's
assertion that the Arrest-cum-Personal Search Memo was duly prepared and
supplied and submits that a later recital or signature cannot, by itself, cure
failure to communicate the real grounds at the proper time. Invoking Articles 21
and 22(1) of the Constitution, he contends that the safeguard exists to enable an
arrested person to understand the factual basis of arrest, obtain legal advice and
promptly challenge the deprivation of liberty.
.1992 Supp (1) SCC 335
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xiv) The petitioner further disputes the circumstances in which his
signatures were obtained and points to alleged inconsistencies regarding the
time of arrest, completion of post-trap proceedings and preparation of arrest
papers. Relying upon D.K.Basu vs. State of West Bengal2 and the other
arrest authorities cited by him, he submits that compliance must be
contemporaneous and demonstrable and that a subsequent remand cannot
retrospectively validate an arrest which was unconstitutional at its inception.
(xv) In W.P. No.31644 of 2025, the petitioner challenges the search
operation conducted at his residence during the night of 19/20.12.2023. He
pleads that no search warrant, written authorization or contemporaneously
recorded reasons authorizing the search were shown to him. He invokes the
safeguards governing searches under the Code of Criminal Procedure and the
relevant provisions of the CBI Manual and contends that a residential search,
particularly during night hours, cannot be treated as an unrestricted incident of
investigation.
(xvi) the requirements concerning independent witnesses, identification of
the search party, personal search of search-team members, presence and
participation of the occupants, preparation of a complete inventory, supply of the
. (1997) 1 SCC 416
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
search proceedings and forwarding of the necessary records to the competent
Magistrate were not followed in their true spirit. He further contends that a large
number of male officials remained in the residence during the night when his
wife was present, causing humiliation and intrusion upon privacy and dignity.
(xvii) he specifically disputes the justification for seizure of his identity card
and cash of Rs.1,80,000/-, apart from the alleged trap amount. According to
him, the subsequent order for return of the said cash supports his contention
that it was not incriminating material connected with the alleged offence. It is his
further case that seizure must have a demonstrable nexus with investigation and
that an indiscriminate description of articles as incriminating cannot substitute for
statutory justification.
(xviii) In W.P. No.32169 of 2025, the petitioner alleges physical, mental
and psychological ill-treatment while he was in CBI custody. He states that he
attempted to bring his grievance before the trial court through applications, but
according to him the complaints were not effectively taken on record or acted
upon. He invokes the constitutional protection of dignity and personal liberty and
relies upon decisions including D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal 3 and
.AIR 1997 SC 610
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
Arvinder Singh Bagga v. State of U.P.4, besides principles concerning
CCTV/video safeguards in custodial environments.
(xix) he prays the Court to treat the custodial allegations independently of
the merits of the corruption prosecution. His submission is that even a person
lawfully
arrested
retains
constitutional
protection
against
physical
or
psychological abuse and that law-enforcement officers cannot use custody as a
means of punishment or coercion. He therefore seeks appropriate declarations
and consequential directions, including action against the officers alleged to be
responsible.
(xx) In W.P. No.34423 of 2025, the petitioner challenges the press release
published by the CBI on its official website and social-media handle. His case is
that an investigating agency may communicate accurate procedural facts but
cannot publish statements which, expressly or by necessary implication, portray
an accused as guilty before adjudication. He particularly disputes the description
of recoveries and the characterization of seized material as incriminating,
contending that such publication affected his reputation, privacy, service career
and standing in society.
. (1994) 6 SCC 565
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xxi) he relies upon the constitutional protection of reputation and privacy
and the principles discussed in R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu5 and
Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa6. He contends that an official
communication carries institutional authority and is likely to be treated by the
public and media as reliable; therefore, according to him, greater care was
required to distinguish allegations from established facts. He seeks a declaration
regarding the legality of the release and consequential action against the
responsible officer.
(xxii) he requests that all five proceedings be viewed against a common
factual background. According to him, the departmental suspension preceded the
corruption complaint; the trap was followed in quick succession by arrest,
residential search and custody; and the official press release then placed the
CBI's version in the public domain. He argues that, although each petition raises
a distinct legal issue and seeks a distinct relief, the events are factually
interconnected and the legality of each later step must be assessed with
reference to the contemporaneous records and safeguards applicable to it.
. (1994) 6 SCC 632
. (1993) 2 SCC 746
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xxiii) his case is not founded on minor irregularities viewed in isolation. He
relies upon what he describes as cumulative defects in the origin of the
complaint, verification, digital evidence, alleged demand, alleged acceptance,
recovery, chemical testing, sanction, arrest documentation, search procedure,
custodial treatment and public communication. According to him, these matters
collectively disclose prejudice and justify constitutional and inherent-jurisdiction
scrutiny.
(xxiv) he is not asking the High Court to conduct a complete criminal trial
in the writ or quash proceedings. His submission is that the Court can examine
undisputed or prosecution-generated records to determine whether mandatory
constitutional and statutory safeguards were observed and whether the material
relied upon discloses the legal ingredients necessary for continuation of the
prosecution. On that basis, he seeks the separate reliefs claimed in the
respective petitions, while reserving all other remedies available in law.
8. The Central Bureau of Investigation filed counter affidavits. The
contents of the counter affidavits and written submissions can briefly be
summarized as under:
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(i) The respondent Central Bureau of Investigation while denying the
material averments of the petitions further contended that the prosecution arose
from a written complaint disclosing a cognizable offence. According to the CBI,
RC No.23(A)/2023 was registered on 19.12.2023 under Section 7(a) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act against the petitioner, then Senior Superintendent
of Post Offices, Bhimavaram Division, on the complaint of Sri S. Sala Ramudu,
Postman, Palakollu. The CBI's case is that the complainant's suspension supplied
the occasion for the petitioner to demand illegal gratification for revoking that
suspension and that the subsequent investigation yielded sufficient corroborative
material.
(ii) The complainant first approached the petitioner at his office on
01.12.2023 seeking revocation of the suspension and was asked to meet him at
his residence. According to them, during the subsequent interactions the
petitioner demanded an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- as illegal gratification, the
amount was negotiated/reduced, and by 17.12.2023 the demand stood at
Rs.2,50,000/-. The CBI relies upon the complainant's account of those meetings
and the conversation allegedly recorded by him on his mobile phone as material
supporting the antecedent demand.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(iii) It disputes the petitioner's suggestion that the complaint was merely
retaliatory because of the suspension. It states that the existence of a
departmental dispute or prior action against the complainant does not by itself
destroy the prosecution case where the later complaint contains a specific
allegation of demand and is followed by verification and trap proceedings.
According to the CBI, the complainant's credibility, motive and the petitioner's
defence are matters to be tested in evidence and cannot be conclusively
determined in proceedings seeking quashment.
(iv) The respondent-CBI submits that, after the complaint was received
and the allegations were verified, the FIR was registered and pre-trap
proceedings were conducted. It states that independent witnesses were
associated, the currency intended for the trap was noted and treated in
accordance with the procedure, and a digital voice recorder was given to the
complainant with instructions concerning the proposed transaction. The
complainant was thereafter sent to the petitioner's residence with Rs.2,50,000/and the trap team positioned itself in the vicinity.
(v) The complainant met the petitioner near the residential premises and
discussed revocation of the suspension. The prosecution version is that the
petitioner instructed the complainant regarding the place where the amount was
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
to be kept, whereupon the complainant placed the treated currency on a chair
near the balcony and thereafter gave the pre-arranged signal. The CBI relies
upon the recorded conversation, the complainant's statement and the
observations
of
the
independent
witnesses
as
mutually
corroborative
circumstances.
(vi) When the trap team reached the relevant place the money was no
longer on the chair and the grill door was locked from inside. According to the
prosecution, the petitioner, instead of immediately opening the door, moved
towards the balcony area and was observed carrying something. The CBI treats
this conduct as part of the chain of circumstances explaining why the tainted
amount was not found at the place where the complainant had initially kept it.
(vii) A search of the adjacent vacant area resulted in recovery of five
bundles of Rs.500/- denomination notes aggregating to Rs.2,50,000/-. It
emphasizes that the serial numbers of the recovered currency corresponded with
those recorded during the pre-trap proceedings. The currency was photographed
and seized under the post-trap proceedings in the presence of witnesses. The
CBI therefore disputes the petitioner's contention that the open nature of the
recovery site, by itself, severs the connection between the transaction and the
petitioner.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(viii) It relies upon the sodium-carbonate tests conducted on the
petitioner's hands. According to it, the solutions relating to both hands turned
pink and the samples were sealed and later sent for forensic examination. It
further states that samples connected with the chair and the place of recovery
were collected and that the CFSL examination confirmed phenolphthalein in the
samples sent for analysis. The respondent treats the scientific results as
corroboration of contact with the treated currency and of the events described in
the trap proceedings.
(ix) With respect to the electronic evidence, that the conversation recorded
on 17.12.2023 and the conversation connected with the trap proceedings were
preserved and sent for forensic examination through the competent court. It
relies upon the voice examination and identification material to contend that the
recorded voice was that of the petitioner. According to the respondent,
objections concerning transcription, interpretation, source devices, copying
procedure, hash values and chain of custody are matters of admissibility and
evidentiary weight which can be tested before the trial court.
(x)
The
complaint,
verification,
recorded
conversations,
pre-trap
memorandum, conduct at the scene, recovery of currency bearing the recorded
serial numbers, hand-wash results, independent witness accounts and forensic
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
reports cannot be dissected and examined in isolation. Its submission is that
these circumstances, when read cumulatively, constitute a prima facie case of
official favour, demand, acceptance and recovery and require a trial.
(xi) The respondent further submits that, after completion of investigation,
a charge sheet was filed before the competent Special Court along with the
documents relied upon by the prosecution. It invokes the settled limitations on
the High Court's jurisdiction at the quashing stage and argues that disputed
questions
concerning
the
truthfulness
of
witnesses,
interpretation
of
conversations, reliability of recovery, effect of forensic evidence and the
petitioner's defence should be adjudicated on evidence during trial rather than
through a mini-trial in the present proceedings.
(xii) It relies upon the statutory presumption under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, subject to proof of the foundational facts at trial, and contends
that the petitioner's attempt to obtain a final evaluation of the prosecution
evidence at the threshold is impermissible. It relies upon the authorities cited in
its submissions, including State of Bihar v. P.P. Sharma7, Kaptan Singh v.
State of Uttar Pradesh8, Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of
.1992 Supp (1) SCC 222
(2021) 9 SCC 35
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
Maharashtra9, Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P.10 and Neeraj Dutta
v. State (NCT of Delhi)11, for the propositions advanced by it concerning
investigation, quashing and proof in corruption cases.
(xiii) The respondent-CBI submits that, as regards W.P. No.19734 of 2025,
it specifically denies that the arrest was effected without communication of
grounds. Its case is that the petitioner was arrested at about 8:30 p.m. on
19.12.2023 after the alleged demand and acceptance of the bribe amount, that
the grounds of arrest were communicated, and that the Arrest-cum-Personal
Search Memo and the proceedings under the then applicable provisions of the
Code were prepared in the presence of independent witnesses. It states that the
petitioner signed the relevant documents and was supplied copies.
(xiv) The petitioner was produced before the Special Judge for CBI Cases,
Vijayawada, on 20.12.2023 and was remanded to judicial custody. It relies upon
the remand proceedings and contends that the petitioner did not then raise the
present challenge to the arrest in the form now pleaded. According to the CBI,
the writ petition was instituted much later, after filing of the charge sheet, and is
an afterthought intended to delay or divert the criminal proceedings.
.(2021) 19 SCC 401
.(2014) 2 SCC 1
.(2023) 4 SCC 731
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xv) It objects to the personal impleadment of the investigating and traplaying officers in the arrest writ petition. It states that no specific legally
sustainable case of personal misconduct is made out against them and refers to
its application seeking deletion of their names. The respondent contends that
adverse personal findings affecting serving officers ought not to be recorded on
generalized allegations, particularly where the official records are said to
demonstrate procedural compliance.
(xvi) The respondent-CBI submits that, as regards W.P. No.31644 of 2025
concerning the residential search, the search was undertaken after registration of
a cognizable case and in the immediate context of the trap and recovery
operation. According to it, the investigating officers had lawful authority to enter
and search the premises in order to recover the bribe amount and other material
connected with the offence. It disputes the petitioner's characterization of the
operation as an unauthorized exploratory search.
(xvii) The post-trap proceedings record the presence of independent
witnesses, the articles seized, participation of the petitioner and his wife and
delivery of a copy of the proceedings under acknowledgment. It therefore denies
the allegations that the occupants were excluded or that no proper record of
seizure was prepared. In its submission, questions concerning the precise
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
authorization, recording of reasons and procedural steps have to be examined
with the contemporaneous investigation records and cannot be decided merely
on the petitioner's denial.
(xviii) It disputes the inference sought to be drawn from the later return of
Rs.1,80,000/-. It contends that the legality of the search has to be judged on the
circumstances existing when the investigation was in progress and not solely by
whether every article seized was ultimately retained as evidence. The CBI further
objects to the impleadment of numerous officers, independent witnesses and the
complainant in their personal capacities and contends that bald allegations
cannot justify personal proceedings against them.
(xix) The respondent-CBI submits that, in W.P. No.32169 of 2025, it
emphatically denies the allegations of custodial cruelty, physical assault, mental
torture or psychological harassment. It characterizes the allegations as general,
unsupported and belated and contends that they were introduced to divert
attention from the corruption case. The respondent relies upon the remand
proceedings and states that the petitioner did not make the specific allegations
now advanced when produced before the Special Judge.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xx) The officers impleaded personally in the custodial-treatment writ
petition have not been assigned specific acts supported by contemporaneous
material. It denies that any officer indulged in the conduct alleged and states
that continuation of personal allegations against serving officials, without an
adequate factual foundation, adversely affects them. It has therefore sought
deletion of the individual officers and dismissal of the writ petition.
(xxi) The respondent-CBI submits that, with respect to W.P. No.34423 of
2025, the press release was issued under the applicable departmental circular
and the provisions of the CBI Manual governing media communication. According
to the respondent, the release did no more than communicate the fact of
registration of the case, the trap, remand and seizures made during
investigation. It denies that the communication pronounced the petitioner guilty
or exceeded the permissible limits of an official press statement.
(xxii) It particularly relies upon the fact that Rs.2,50,000/- in Rs.500/denomination notes, bearing serial numbers corresponding to the pre-trap
memorandum, was recovered during the operation. It also refers to the other
cash and identity card seized during the search. According to the respondent,
describing material seized during a criminal investigation as material connected
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
with the case did not amount to a judicial declaration of guilt and the petitioner's
challenge to the release is therefore misconceived.
(xxiii) The lapse of time between the events of December 2023 and
institution of the writ petitions. It contends that the petitions were filed after
substantial progress in the criminal case and after the charge sheet, and
therefore alleges that the petitioner is attempting to reopen each investigative
step through separate constitutional proceedings. The petitioner disputes that
characterization, but the CBI relies upon the timing as a circumstance relevant to
maintainability and bona fides.
(xxiv) The respondent-CBI submits that, in answer to the petitioner's
cumulative challenge, the five proceedings cannot be used to secure, indirectly, a
complete adjudication of the criminal case without trial. It accepts that arrest,
search, custody and official communication are governed by constitutional and
statutory safeguards, but asserts that those safeguards were observed and that
the contrary allegations involve seriously disputed facts. It therefore urges that
findings against individual officers should not be returned merely on competing
affidavits where original records and oral evidence may be required.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xxv) The respondent-CBI finally submits that there was a specific
complaint of demand for illegal gratification; the allegation was verified; a trap
was organized; the complainant carried treated currency; circumstances at the
petitioner's residence indicated acceptance and removal of the money; the same
currency was recovered from the adjoining area; chemical and forensic material
corroborated the transaction; and the investigation culminated in a charge sheet
disclosing a prima facie case. On that basis, the CBI seeks dismissal of the
criminal petition and the connected writ petitions and requests that the criminal
case be permitted to proceed before the competent Special Court in accordance
with law.
9. Heard the petitioner appearing in person and Sri P.S.P. Suresh Kumar,
learned Standing Counsel for Central Bureau of Investigation for respondents.
10 (i) The petitioner while reiterating the contents of the writ affidavit
would contend that the entire prosecution has to be examined in the background
in which the complaint came to be made. He was functioning as Senior
Superintendent of Post Offices, Bhimavaram Division, and had initiated
departmental action against the de facto complainant, Sri S. Sala Ramudu, a
Postman, after information concerning his alleged involvement in a criminal case
and his antecedents was received and verified departmentally. The complainant
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
was thereafter placed under suspension in exercise of official disciplinary powers.
It was argued that this prior departmental action is not an incidental fact but the
starting point of the controversy, because the complainant had a direct grievance
against the petitioner and therefore a clear motive to implicate him falsely. The
subsequent allegation that the petitioner demanded money for revocation of that
very suspension, according to the petitioner, must be scrutinised in the light of
this pre-existing hostility.
(ii) He further argued that the essential ingredients of the offence under
Section 7(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act are not established by the
material relied upon by the prosecution. That the prosecution must first show a
clear and conscious demand for undue advantage and acceptance of the same in
connection with an official act or favour. He contended that the disciplinary
process had already been initiated in accordance with service rules and that the
prosecution material does not clearly demonstrate any pending official favour
which was being offered for sale. Mere suspicion, an ambiguous conversation,
gestures or subsequent conduct, it was submitted, cannot take the place of proof
of a specific demand and conscious acceptance.
(iii) He further contended that the chronology of the alleged demands and
the complaint creates a serious doubt at the threshold. The prosecution refers to
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
alleged demands on 03.12.2023 and 17.12.2023, whereas the written complaint
and FIR are dated 19.12.2023. If such a substantial illegal demand had actually
been made earlier, the petitioner questioned why no immediate complaint was
lodged. He also relied upon alleged inconsistencies regarding telephonic
information to the Superintendent of Police, receipt and transmission of the
written complaint, verification of the allegation and the precise point at which the
CBI treated the information as disclosing a cognizable offence. In a trap case, he
argued, these are not insignificant details because the integrity of the entire
operation depends upon a clear and contemporaneously verifiable sequence of
events.
(iv) He further argued that the feasibility and timing of the CBI team's
movements require close scrutiny. According to him, receipt of information,
preliminary verification, assembly of officers and independent witnesses,
arrangement of vehicles, travel, arrival, preparation of pre-trap proceedings and
commencement of the trap should form a continuous chronology supported by
contemporaneous records. Any material gap or inconsistency in that sequence, it
was argued, affects the reliability of the prosecution version because the trap
proceedings constitute the principal foundation of the criminal case.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(v) He further argued that the electronic evidence does not furnish a safe
basis for continuation of the prosecution in the manner asserted by the CBI. He
questioned how the conversation allegedly recorded by the complainant on
17.12.2023 and the conversation said to have been recorded during the trap on
19.12.2023 were created, received, copied, preserved and transmitted. He
emphasized the alleged absence or inadequacy of particulars concerning the
original source devices, hash values, forensic images, dates and times of copying
and an uninterrupted chain of custody. Where recorded conversations are relied
upon to establish the foundational fact of demand, the petitioner argued that the
prosecution must be able to demonstrate the integrity of the source and
preservation process rather than asking the Court to presume authenticity.
(vi) He further argued that even the transcripts and conversations relied
upon by the prosecution, if read as they stand for the limited purpose of these
proceedings, do not unmistakably disclose the specific demand attributed to him.
According to him, words capable of more than one interpretation, gestures or
surrounding conduct cannot be enlarged into an express demand for illegal
gratification. He contended that the prosecution has attempted to infer an
incriminating meaning from circumstances without clear independent material
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
showing that he demanded Rs.2,50,000/- as consideration for revoking the
complainant's suspension.
(vii) He further argued that the prosecution version of acceptance and
recovery is inherently doubtful. Admittedly, according to the case placed before
the Court, the tainted currency was not recovered from his person, clothes,
room, cupboard or any place shown to be in his exclusive possession. The
amount was ultimately found in an open vacant area adjoining the residential
premises. He, therefore submitted that recovery of currency bearing the pre-trap
serial numbers from an open place may establish the identity of the notes, but it
does not by itself establish that he consciously received them and thereafter
threw or carried them to that place. A reliable connecting link between the
alleged placement of money, its alleged handling by the petitioner and its
ultimate recovery is indispensable.
(viii) He further argued that the recovery proceedings and scene sketch do
not satisfactorily establish the connecting link. He questioned whether the sketch
accurately depicts the surrounding houses, balconies, access points, visibility,
positions of the complainant and witnesses and the exact place of recovery. He
also relied upon the alleged absence of his signature on the recovery documents
and contended that the prosecution must explain through independent and
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
contemporaneous material how the currency allegedly moved from the chair to
the vacant site. In his submission, the missing or disputed procedural links
assume greater significance because the recovery was not from his body or
exclusive possession.
(ix) He further argued that the chemical tests cannot cure the alleged
failure to establish demand and voluntary acceptance. The hand-wash results
and tests said to have been conducted in relation to the chair, bushes, grass or
soil may, at their highest, be corroborative circumstances. They cannot
independently prove why contact occurred or establish the indispensable
foundational facts of a corruption offence. He also questioned collection, sealing,
preservation and forensic examination of the samples. Scientific evidence,
according to him, may support a transaction otherwise proved, but cannot be
used to fill a basic gap in the prosecution case.
(x) He further argued that the sanction for prosecution is vitiated by want
of proper application of mind. His case is that the sanctioning authority did not
have before it, or did not properly consider, all the material which later became
central to the prosecution, including the conversations and forensic material.
Sanction, he submitted, is a substantive statutory safeguard and not a
mechanical formality. If vital material necessary for an informed decision was
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
unavailable or not considered, the resulting sanction cannot be treated as an
independent and conscious authorization of prosecution. For this proposition he
relied upon the decision in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal.
(xi) He further argued that the cumulative defects bring the case within
the principles governing exercise of the High Court's power to prevent abuse of
process, including the principles relied upon from State of Haryana v. Bhajan
Lal. His contention is not that the High Court should conduct a full criminal trial,
but that the Court is entitled to look at prosecution-generated and undisputed
records to see whether the basic legal ingredients exist and whether mandatory
safeguards were observed. Where the accusation is allegedly born out of prior
hostility, the demand is disputed and ambiguous, recovery is from an open place,
and the supporting electronic and procedural links are challenged, compelling the
petitioner to undergo a full trial was argued to amount to abuse of process.
(xii) He further argued, in relation to W.P. No.19734 of 2025, that the
arrest on 19.12.2023 violated Article 22(1) because the grounds of arrest were
not meaningfully communicated when his liberty was curtailed. He disputed the
CBI's reliance on the Arrest-cum-Personal Search Memo, signatures and later
remand proceedings, submitting that these cannot substitute proof of timely and
effective communication. Relying on D.K. Basu, he contended that the
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
safeguard enables the arrestee to understand the accusation, consult counsel,
oppose remand and seek bail.
(xiii) He further submitted that the alleged inconsistencies in the time of
arrest and preparation of the arrest papers require scrutiny. In particular, he
distinguished the investigating officer's general 'reasons for arrest' from the
personal and factual 'grounds of arrest' which Article 22(1) requires to be
communicated to the arrested person.
(xiv) He further argued, in relation to W.P. No.31644 of 2025, that the
residential search during the night of 19/20.12.2023 was undertaken without
demonstrating a lawful warrant, written authorization or contemporaneously
recorded reasons. He submitted that the power of warrantless search is
exceptional and circumscribed by statutory safeguards, particularly when a
private residence is entered at night. The requirements of recording reasons,
specifying the object of search, associating independent witnesses, preparing a
complete inventory and supplying the proceedings are safeguards against
arbitrary invasion of privacy and cannot be treated as dispensable formalities. In
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
support, he relied upon Yakub Abdul Razak Memon v. CBI12 and Rajesh &
Anr. v. State of Madhya Pradesh 13.
(xv) He further contended that in ITC Ltd. v. State of Karnataka14, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court stressed upon scrupulous adherence to statutory search
procedure, the importance of independent witnesses and the need for recorded
reasons, and caution against courts condoning unlawful investigative methods.
In State of Rajasthan v. Rehman15, the petitioner relied upon the principle
that search is an exceedingly intrusive process and that Section 165 Cr.P.C.
requires reasonable grounds to be recorded in writing together with specification,
as far as possible, of the thing sought; failure to comply with material
requirements was treated as rendering the search illegal. The petitioner
submitted that these principles directly answer the CBI's attempt to treat the
residential search as a routine continuation of the trap. In support, he also relied
upon CBI v. State of Delhi; Shafi Mohammad v. State of Himachal
Pradesh16.
.(2013) 13 SCC 1
.2023 SCC OnLine SC 1202
.(2026) 4 SCC 603
. AIR 1960 SC 210
.(2018) 2 SCC 80
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xvi)He further contended that Union of India through CBI v.
Purnandu Biswas17 supports the proposition that investigative enthusiasm
cannot itself justify a residential search without lawful authority. He further relied
upon New Swadeshi Mills of Ahmedabad Ltd. v. S.K. Rattan & Ors. 18 for
the proposition that Section 165 confers a restricted and circumscribed power
and that recording reasons before a warrantless search is an important
mandatory safeguard protecting private rights. Dnyaneshwar S/o Kachru
Tondmal v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.19 was relied upon to emphasize
that, before entering a house, the investigating officer must record the grounds
and specify the things sought, and that unlawful intrusion can affect both privacy
and the reputation of the family.
(xvii) He further contended that the manner of recovery also falls foul of
safeguards discussed in Yakub Abdul Razak Memon v. CBI. He relied upon
the
observations
concerning
preparation
and
signatures
on
a
panchnama/recovery memorandum by the investigating officer, independent
panch witnesses and the concerned party, as well as the requirement of
recorded reasons and an appropriate search memorandum for a warrantless
. (2005) 12 SCC 576
. 1967 SCC OnLine Guj 142
.Orders dated 29.11.2019 of Bombay High Court (Aurangabad Bench) in Criminal Writ Petition No. 25 of 2019
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
search. He also relied upon Rajesh & Anr. v. State of Madhya Pradesh to
contend that evidence collected in complete defiance of law becomes seriously
vulnerable where the circumstances leave room for tampering or interpolation.
The alleged absence of his signature, dispute regarding presence and position of
witnesses and absence of videography were therefore said to be material, not
technical, objections. In support, he also relied upon Arvinder Singh Bagga v.
State of U.P., D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal.
(xviii) He further contended that videography would have provided an
objective account of the disputed search and recovery. He relied upon the
observation in CBI v. State of Delhi regarding videography of search
proceedings and upon Shafi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh
regarding videography of the scene of crime or recovery as a safeguard that
enhances confidence in investigative evidence. According to him, where the
prosecution itself depends upon a disputed movement of currency from a chair
to an open area, objective recording assumes particular importance. In support,
he relied upon Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh 20.
(xix) He further contended that seizure of his identity card and
Rs.1,80,000/- apart from the alleged trap amount demonstrates the over breadth
.(2021) 1 SCC 184
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
of the search. He submitted that the later return of the said cash supports his
contention that it lacked an incriminating nexus with the alleged offence. An
investigating agency may seize material genuinely connected with an offence,
but cannot convert a specific trap investigation into an unrestricted exploratory
exercise merely by describing every article taken from a residence as
incriminating.
(xx) The petitioner further argued, in relation to W.P. No.32169 of 2025,
that the allegation of physical, mental and psychological ill-treatment in CBI
custody is an independent Article 21 of the Constitution issue and cannot be
answered merely by referring to the merits of the corruption prosecution. Relying
upon Arvinder Singh Bagga v. State of U.P. and D.K. Basu v. State of
West Bengal, he submitted that custodial abuse includes mental and
psychological coercion and that custody cannot be used as punishment or as a
means of compelling information or submission.
(xxi) The Petitioner further relied upon the CCTV and audio-video
safeguards noticed in Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh and submitted
that objective recording assumes special importance when the alleged wrong
occurred inside an investigating agency's premises. According to him, his
attempts to raise the grievance were not effectively acted upon and, therefore,
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
the availability, preservation and production of CCTV or other electronic material
should be considered by the competent forum while examining the complaint.
(xxii) The petitioner further argued, in relation to W.P. No.34423 of 2025,
that the CBI press release crossed the permissible boundary between informing
the public about an investigation and conveying an impression of guilt before
adjudication. An official investigating agency may state procedural facts
accurately, but must carefully distinguish allegations and seizures from proved
facts. Describing material as incriminating, particularly when the legality and
relevance of the seizure itself are disputed, was said to have affected his
reputation, privacy, service career and standing in society.
(xxiii)Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India21 recognizes reputation
as an inseparable facet of Article 21, while R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil
Nadu recognizes privacy as implicit in life and liberty and protects the
individual's private sphere subject to the qualifications stated in that judgment.
He also relied upon Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa for the constitutional
court's power and obligation to grant public-law relief where a flagrant
infringement of Article 21 by State action is established. Since an official CBI
communication carries institutional authority and is likely to be treated by the
. (2016) 7 SCC 221
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
public as reliable, the petitioner argued that the agency owed a correspondingly
high duty of accuracy and restraint.
(xxiv) The petitioner finally argued that the five proceedings raise distinct
legal questions but arise out of one continuous factual sequence: departmental
suspension of the complainant, the corruption complaint and trap, arrest,
residential search, custody and thereafter the official press release. His case is
not founded upon one isolated irregularity but upon the cumulative effect of
alleged defects in the complaint, verification, electronic evidence, demand,
acceptance, recovery, chemical testing, sanction, arrest documentation, search
procedure, custodial treatment and public communication. He therefore prayed
that each relief be considered on its own legal footing while keeping the common
chronology in view, and that the Court grant the reliefs sought wherever the
contemporaneous record fails to demonstrate compliance with mandatory
constitutional and statutory safeguards.
11 (i) On the other hand, Sri P.S.P.Suresh Kumar, learned Standing
Counsel for
respondent–CBI while reiterating the contents of the counter
affidavits and written submissions argued that the petitions proceed by
fragmenting a prosecution which, when read as a whole, discloses a clear prima
facie case under Section 7(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The case
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
originated in a written complaint made by Sri S. Sala Ramudu, Postman,
Palakollu, on the basis of which RC No.23(A)/2023 was registered on 19.12.2023
against the petitioner, then Senior Superintendent of Post Offices, Bhimavaram
Division. According to the CBI, the complainant's suspension supplied the
occasion for the petitioner to demand illegal gratification for revoking the
suspension, and the complaint was thereafter followed by verification, trap
proceedings,
recovery,
chemical
tests,
electronic
material
and
forensic
examination.
(ii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the prior
departmental dispute does not establish false implication. According to the
prosecution version, the complainant approached the petitioner on 01.12.2023
seeking revocation of suspension and was asked to meet him at his residence;
during later interactions a substantial illegal gratification was demanded and the
amount ultimately stood at Rs.2,50,000/- by 17.12.2023. The CBI relies upon the
complainant's account and the conversation recorded on his (complainant)
mobile phone as material supporting the antecedent demand. Whether the
complainant was motivated by hostility, whether his account is truthful and what
weight should be attached to the defence of false implication are, the respondent
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
argued, matters for evidence at trial and cannot be conclusively decided in
quashing proceedings.
(iii) The learned Standing counsel further contended that after receipt and
verification of the complaint, the FIR was registered and pre-trap proceedings
were conducted in the presence of independent witnesses. The currency
intended for the trap was noted and treated in accordance with the procedure, a
digital voice recorder was provided to the complainant with instructions, and the
complainant proceeded to the petitioner's residence carrying Rs.2,50,000/-. The
trap team positioned itself nearby. These contemporaneous steps, according to
the CBI, answer the petitioner's attempt to portray the operation as fabricated or
procedurally unanchored.
(iv) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the events at the
residence provide the necessary link between demand, acceptance and recovery.
The prosecution case is that the complainant discussed revocation of suspension
with the petitioner and was instructed regarding the place where the money was
to be kept. The complainant accordingly placed the treated currency on a chair
near the balcony and gave the pre-arranged signal. The CBI relies upon the
recorded conversation, the complainant's statement and the observations of
independent witnesses as mutually corroborative circumstances. It was
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
submitted that acceptance in a trap case need not be reduced to the simplistic
requirement that the currency must be physically recovered from the accused's
pocket or hand if the surrounding evidence establishes conscious receipt or
handling.
(v) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the petitioner's
conduct immediately after the signal is a material circumstance. When the trap
team reached the relevant place, the money was no longer on the chair and the
grill door was locked from inside. According to the CBI, the petitioner did not
immediately open the door and moved towards the balcony area while carrying
or handling something. The prosecution treats this conduct as part of the chain
explaining how the tainted amount left the chair and came to be found in the
adjoining vacant area. The respondent submitted that the petitioner's alternative
explanation, and the exact inference to be drawn from this conduct, are
important questions for trial.
(vi) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that recovery of five
bundles of Rs.500/- notes aggregating to Rs.2,50,000/- from the adjacent vacant
area cannot be dismissed merely because the spot was open. The serial numbers
of the recovered notes corresponded with those recorded in the pre-trap
proceedings; the currency was photographed and seized in the presence of
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
witnesses. According to the CBI, the location of recovery must be considered
together with the preceding placement of the currency, disappearance of the
money from the chair, the petitioner's alleged movement towards the balcony
and the subsequent recovery of the very same identified notes. The prosecution
case is based on the cumulative chain, not on the recovery location in isolation.
(vii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the chemical
and forensic evidence supplies additional corroboration. It relies upon sodiumcarbonate tests in which the solutions relating to both hands of the petitioner
turned pink, the sealing and forwarding of those samples, collection of samples
connected with the chair and recovery area and the CFSL result confirming
phenolphthalein in the samples sent for analysis. The CBI does not treat the
scientific evidence as a substitute for demand; rather, it relies upon it as
corroborative material which, when read with the complaint, conversations, trap
proceedings, conduct and recovery, supports a prima facie inference of contact
with the treated currency.
(viii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that objections to
electronic evidence concerning source devices, transcription, copying, hash
values, chain of custody, interpretation and voice identification are matters
concerning admissibility, proof and evidentiary weight. The conversations of
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
17.12.2023 and 19.12.2023 were, according to the CBI, preserved and sent for
forensic examination through the competent court, and the prosecution relies
upon voice examination and identification material connecting the recorded voice
to the petitioner. At the stage of quashing, the High Court should not undertake
a forensic trial within a petition under its inherent or writ jurisdiction.
(ix) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the complaint,
verification, recorded conversations, pre-trap memorandum, conduct at the
scene, recovery of currency with matching serial numbers, hand-wash results,
independent witness accounts and forensic reports must be read together. If
each circumstance is isolated and attacked separately, the evidentiary picture is
artificially broken apart. Read cumulatively, the respondent submitted, the
material discloses the ingredients of official favour, demand, acceptance and
recovery sufficiently to require adjudication by the Special Court. In support, the
learned counsel relied upon the decisions in State of Bihar v. P.P. Sharma,
Kaptan Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh; Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt.
Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra.
(x) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that a charge sheet
has already been filed before the competent Special Court along with the
prosecution material and that the present challenge invites the High Court to
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
undertake a mini-trial. Questions such as whether the complainant is credible,
whether the conversations bear the meaning attributed to them, whether the
recovery is reliable, whether the chemical and forensic results establish contact,
and whether the petitioner's defence creates reasonable doubt require evidence,
cross-examination and adjudication at trial. They cannot be finally resolved
merely by comparing rival affidavits and competing interpretations of the
investigation record. In support, he relied upon Sandip Kumar Roy v. State of
West Bengal22 and Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh.
(xi) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that State of Bihar
v. P.P. Sharma supports judicial restraint in quashing criminal proceedings
where the allegations and investigation disclose a prima facie case and cautions
against converting quashing jurisdiction into an assessment of disputed evidence
or allegations of mala fides divorced from the prosecution material. Kaptan
Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh was relied upon for the principle that the
Court ordinarily examines whether the complaint/FIR and accompanying material
disclose an offence, while disputed facts and defence material requiring evidence
are matters for trial. Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra was relied upon for the settled caution that criminal investigation
.2026 LawSuit (Cal) 390
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
and proceedings should not ordinarily be interdicted at an early stage when a
cognizable offence is disclosed and that the extraordinary power to quash must
be exercised sparingly. In support, he relied upon the decision in Neeraj Dutta
v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi).
(xii) The learned Standing further contended that in Sandip Kumar Roy
v. State of West Bengal, a trap-case decision, supports refusal to quash where
the prosecution material relating to demand, trap, acceptance or recovery and
connected
evidence
raises
matters
requiring
trial.
Lalita Kumari v.
Government of Uttar Pradesh was relied upon for the law governing
registration of an FIR where information discloses a cognizable offence and the
limited role of preliminary inquiry in appropriate cases. On this basis, the CBI
submitted that the petitioner's attack on the timing of verification and
registration cannot, without a full evidentiary foundation, invalidate an otherwise
cognizable complaint and subsequent investigation.
(xiii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that Neeraj Dutta
v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) is particularly material to the corruption
prosecution. The CBI relies upon the principles governing proof of demand and
acceptance through direct as well as circumstantial evidence and the evidentiary
role of the statutory presumption once the foundational facts are established. It
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
was therefore argued that the petitioner's insistence upon one particular form of
direct proof or recovery from his person does not furnish a legal basis for
quashing when the prosecution proposes to prove the transaction through a
combination of oral, electronic, scientific and circumstantial evidence.
(xiv) The learned Standing Counsel with respect to W.P. No.19734 of
2025, argued that the arrest was lawful and that the grounds were
communicated at about 8:30 p.m. on 19.12.2023. The CBI relies upon the
Arrest-cum-Personal Search Memo, the petitioner's signatures, independent
witnesses, supply of copies and subsequent production before the Special Judge.
Relying upon Kasireddy Upender Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh 23, it
submitted that contemporaneous official records showing compliance cannot be
displaced in writ proceedings merely by a later factual denial.
(xv) The learned Standing Counsel further relied upon the remand
proceedings and the circumstance that the present challenge was raised later,
after substantial progress in the prosecution. It argued that the controversy as to
what was communicated, when it was communicated and how the arrest papers
were prepared is fact-sensitive and should not be converted into a declaration of
illegality on competing affidavits.
. (2026) 8 SCC 275
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
(xvi) The CBI also opposed personal findings against investigating officers
unless specific misconduct is established on reliable material and the officers
concerned are afforded an opportunity to answer it. It relied upon Amutha v.
Additional Principal Secretary, Home Department, Chennai 24 in support
of that submission.
(xvii) The learned Standing counsel further contended with respect to W.P.
No.31644 of 2025 that the residential search was not an unauthorized
exploratory exercise. It was undertaken after registration of a cognizable case
and in the immediate context of the trap and recovery operation. The
investigating officers, according to the CBI, possessed lawful authority to enter
and search for the bribe amount and other material connected with the offence.
The legality of that action must be judged in the circumstances confronting the
officers at that time, not by retrospectively isolating individual steps from the
ongoing trap operation.
(xiii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the post-trap
proceedings themselves record the presence of independent witnesses, the
articles seized, participation of the petitioner and his wife and delivery of a copy
of the proceedings under acknowledgment. The CBI therefore denied that the
.2022 LawSuit (Mad) 2288
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
occupants were excluded or that no proper seizure record was prepared.
Questions concerning the precise authorization, recording of reasons, presence
and role of witnesses and compliance with procedural requirements, it submitted,
must be tested against the original contemporaneous investigation records and
not decided solely on the petitioner's denial.
(xix) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the subsequent
return of Rs.1,80,000/- does not retrospectively render the search or seizure
illegal. During an investigation, officers may seize material which reasonably
appears relevant; the ultimate decision not to retain or rely upon every seized
article does not establish that the original search lacked lawful purpose. The CBI
similarly opposed personal proceedings against numerous officers, independent
witnesses and the complainant where specific acts of actionable personal
misconduct are not supported by adequate material.
(xx) The learned Standing Counsel, with respect to W.P. No.32169 of
2025, emphatically denied physical assault, mental torture or psychological
harassment. It relied upon the remand proceedings, the alleged absence of a
contemporaneous complaint in the form now advanced and the lack of specific
material assigning individual acts to particular officers. The CBI submitted that
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
the allegation must be proved before a competent forum and that serious
personal findings cannot be returned merely on broad or disputed assertions.
(xxi) The learned Standing Counsel further argued, with respect to W.P.
No.34423 of 2025, that the press release was issued in accordance with the
applicable departmental circular and provisions of the CBI Manual governing
media communication. The release, according to the respondent, communicated
the fact of registration of the case, the trap, remand and seizures made during
investigation; it did not pronounce the petitioner guilty. The CBI particularly
relied upon recovery of Rs.2,50,000/- in notes corresponding to the pre-trap
serial numbers and referred to other articles seized. Describing material as
connected with an investigation, it argued, is not equivalent to a judicial
declaration that the accused is guilty.
(xxii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that a departmental
press release must depend upon its contents and governing instructions, the CBI
submitted that communicating the existence and procedural status of a criminal
case cannot, without more, be equated with unconstitutional injury to reputation
or privacy. The petitioner's disagreement with the prosecution narrative does not
by itself transform a factual investigative communication into a declaration of
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
guilt. In support of his contention, he relied upon the decision in Youth Bar
Association of India v. Union of India 25.
(xxiii) The learned Standing Counsel further contended that the events
occurred in December 2023, whereas the connected writ challenges were
instituted after substantial progress in the criminal case and after filing of the
charge sheet. The CBI contended that the petitioner is attempting to reopen,
through separate constitutional proceedings, the complaint, trap, arrest, search,
custody and media communication and thereby secure indirectly a complete
adjudication of the criminal case without trial.
(xxiv) The learned Standing Counsel finally argued that constitutional and
statutory
safeguards
governing
arrest,
search,
custody
and
official
communication are not disputed as propositions of law; its case is that those
safeguards were observed and that the petitioner's contrary allegations involve
seriously disputed questions of fact. There was, according to the CBI, a specific
complaint of illegal demand, verification, a planned trap, treated currency carried
by the complainant, circumstances indicating acceptance and removal of the
money, recovery of the same identified currency from the adjoining area,
chemical and forensic corroboration and ultimately a charge sheet disclosing a
. (2016) 9 SCC 473
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
prima facie case. The respondent therefore prayed that the criminal petition and
connected writ petitions be dismissed, that no personal findings be entered
against officers on disputed allegations, and that C.C. No.12 of 2024 be
permitted to proceed before the competent Special Court in accordance with law.
12. Perused the material available on record, considered the written
submissions as well as arguments advanced on behalf of the parties and the
decisions relied upon by both sides.
13. At the outset, it is necessary to keep in view the limited scope of the
Court at the stage of quashing. In State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal
the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India balanced the protection of fair police
investigations with safeguards against malicious prosecutions. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed that an FIR cannot be quashed prematurely at the
threshold if its face-value allegations disclose a prima facie cognizable offense,
ruling that mere political rivalry or ulterior motives of a complainant do not
validate throwing out an otherwise legitimate case. However, the apex court
clarified that the inherent powers of High Courts under Section 482 of the CrPC
and Article 226 of the Constitution must be exercised sparingly and in the "rarest
of rare cases" to prevent the abuse of judicial processes. To guide the judiciary,
the Court formulated seven illustrative categories where quashing criminal
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
proceedings is legally permissible, such as when allegations fail to disclose any
offense, are absurdly improbable, carry an express legal bar, or are clearly driven
by manifest mala fides. Finally, while the Supreme Court upheld the validity of
the FIR itself, it quashed the specific investigation conducted by the Station
House Officer (SHO) because mandatory statutory norms requiring an authorized
senior officer to investigate corruption allegations were breached . the Supreme
Court explained the exceptional categories in which criminal proceedings may be
quashed, including cases where the allegations do not disclose an offence or
where the proceeding is manifestly attended by mala fides. At the same time,
the power is exceptional and cannot be used to decide disputed evidence as if
the Court were conducting a trial.
14. The CBI relies on State of Bihar v. P.P. Sharma, Kaptan Singh v.
State of Uttar Pradesh and Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra26. In State of Bihar v. P.P.Sharma, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
cautioned against using writ/inherent power to undertake a pre-trial assessment
of the charge-sheet evidence. In Kaptan Singh’s case, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed that disputed defence material and factual controversies are
ordinarily not to be decided as though evidence had been recorded at trial. In
.(2021) 19 SCC 401
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.’s case , the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that the High Court should ordinarily refrain from evaluating the reliability or
genuineness of allegations while exercising quashing jurisdiction where a
cognizable offence is disclosed.
15. The common principle emerging from these decisions is that, when the
complaint and the investigation material disclose a prima facie offence, the High
Court should not weigh rival evidence, decide credibility or conduct a mini-trial.
This principle is important here because the petitioner attacks almost every link in
the prosecution chain, while the CBI relies upon those very links as mutually
supporting circumstances.
16. The petitioner says that the complaint was a result of hostility because
he had earlier suspended the complainant. That circumstance is relevant and the
trial court will have to examine it carefully. But prior hostility can operate in two
ways: it may provide a reason for false implication, or it may provide the setting
in which an unlawful demand is alleged to have been made. At this stage, the
Court cannot finally choose between those two possibilities merely on affidavits.
17. The next and more important question is whether the material, if taken
at its face value, is wholly incapable of showing demand and acceptance. The
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
petitioner is right that demand of illegal gratification is a basic requirement of a
corruption charge and that mere recovery of money is not enough.
In B. Jayaraj v. State of Andhra Pradesh27, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India set aside the conviction of a public servant under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, ruling that proof of a demand for a bribe is mandatory to
establish guilt. In K.Shanthamma v. State of Telangana 28, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that demand and acceptance of illegal gratification must be
proved; mere recovery of the alleged bribe amount, in the absence of proof of
demand, is not sufficient for conviction under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
However, Neeraj Dutta v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court made it clear that demand and acceptance may be proved by
direct or circumstantial evidence, depending upon the facts. Therefore, the
absence of recovery from the petitioner's pocket or person is not, by itself,
decisive if the prosecution has other material which it proposes to prove at trial.
18. Here, the prosecution relies upon the written complaint, the alleged
earlier conversation, the trap conversation, the complainant's statement, the
placement of treated currency on the chair, the petitioner's alleged conduct
immediately thereafter, recovery of the same numbered notes from the adjoining
.(2014) 13 SCC 55
. (2022) 4 SCC 574
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
area, hand-wash results and forensic material. The petitioner disputes the
reliability and legal admissibility of almost every one of these circumstances.
Those objections are substantial matters for defence, but they require proof,
cross-examination and examination of the original records. They cannot be finally
decided in a quashing proceeding.
19. The petitioner's reliance on Union of India through Inspector, CBI
v. Purnandu Biswas does not alter this conclusion at the threshold. That
decision arose after evidence had been recorded and the Court was considering
whether demand and acceptance had in fact been proved. The observations
relied upon by the petitioner, including the contention that a residential search
without a warrant could not be justified by mere 'over-zealousness', remain
relevant to the legality and weight of the search evidence. But the present
criminal petition is not an appeal after trial. The prosecution material cannot be
rejected finally without evidence being tested.
20. The challenge to the electronic material also involves questions of
source device, copying, preservation, hash values, chain of custody, voice
identification and interpretation of the conversations. These are important
questions. But on the material presently placed, they are questions of
admissibility and evidentiary value which the Special Court for CBI can examine
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
at the proper stage. It would not be appropriate for this Court to decide, without
a full evidentiary record, that the electronic material is either conclusively
genuine or conclusively unusable.
21. The same reasoning applies to the sanction. The petitioner alleges nonapplication of mind and non-consideration of vital material. The CBI disputes
this. Whether the sanctioning authority had the required material and whether
the sanction suffers from a legal defect must be decided on the sanction order
and the record placed before the authority. On the present disputed material,
this Court is not persuaded that the prosecution is liable to be terminated at the
threshold on that ground alone.
22. For these reasons, Criminal Petition No.7888 of 2025 does not satisfy
the strict test for quashing. This finding does not mean that the prosecution case
is proved. It only means that there is material which requires a trial. Every
defence of the petitioner, including motive for false implication, absence of a
clear demand, the nature of recovery, electronic evidence, chemical tests,
sanction and procedural irregularities, is left open for consideration by the
Special Court without being influenced by the observations in this order.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
23. W.P.No.19734 of 2025 concerns the legality of the petitioner's arrest on
19.12.2023. The principal question is whether the petitioner was promptly and
meaningfully informed of the grounds of arrest as required by Article 22(1) of the
Constitution of India.
24. Article 22(1) protects personal liberty by enabling an arrested person
to consult counsel, oppose remand, seek bail and challenge the arrest. In D.K.
Basu v. State of West Bengal and Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P., the Hon’ble
Supreme Court emphasised that the power of arrest must be exercised lawfully
and with due regard to personal liberty.
25. In Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India29, the Supreme Court directed
that written grounds of arrest under the PMLA be furnished henceforth. Ram
Kishor Arora v. Directorate of Enforcement30, explained the prospective
nature of that direction. Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) 31,
considered the requirement under the UAPA. In Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of
Maharashtra32, the Court clarified that Article 22(1) applies to arrests under all
penal statutes.
.(2024) 7 SCC 576
.(2024) 7 SCC 599
.(2024) 8 SCC 254
.2025 INSC 1288
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
26. The grounds of arrest must convey the essential factual accusation so
that the arrested person can seek legal advice and challenge the arrest or
remand. They are distinct from the investigating officer’s reasons for making the
arrest. Mention of a penal provision alone may be insufficient, though disclosure
of the entire evidence or case diary is not required.
27. In Mihir Rajesh Shah, particularly paragraphs 45 to 58, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court required written communication of grounds in a language
understood by the arrested person. Where immediate written communication is
impracticable, oral communication may initially be made, followed by written
grounds within a reasonable time and at least two hours before production for
remand. Paragraph 58 expressly makes this uniform procedure applicable
henceforth. As the present arrest occurred on 19.12.2023, before that decision,
its later procedural direction cannot by itself be applied retrospectively to
invalidate the arrest. The Court must still examine whether meaningful grounds
were communicated in accordance with the safeguards applicable at that time.
28. When the material in the present case is examined on that basis, the
Arrest-cum-Personal Search Memo records RC No.23(A)/2023-CBI/ACB/VSP,
Section 7(a) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, and the date, time and place of
arrest. Under the column relating to reasons for arrest, however, it essentially
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
states that the petitioner was arrested "for having committed offence punishable
U/Sec.7(a) of PC Act, 1988". The memo does not, by itself, set out the factual
particulars of the alleged demand, the transaction, the trap, acceptance or the
petitioner's individual role in the alleged occurrence.
29. The proceedings under Section 50(1) and (2) Cr.P.C. similarly record
that the petitioner was arrested on 19.12.2023 at 20:30 hours for the offence
under Section 7(a), that the offence was non-bailable, and that he could seek
bail before the competent Court. Significantly, they further record that the
contents were read over to the petitioner and that he had been informed of the
grounds of arrest. They also bear the petitioner's signature and the signatures of
witnesses. The document further records intimation of the arrest to his wife and
departmental officials.
30. These contemporaneous documents cannot be disregarded. The
signatures of the petitioner and independent witnesses lend evidentiary support
to the CBI's case that arrest proceedings were in fact conducted and that
information was conveyed to the petitioner. At the same time, a signature proves
acknowledgment of the document according to its contents; it cannot, by itself,
supply factual particulars which are absent from the document. Likewise, the
recital that "grounds of arrest" were informed is relevant evidence of compliance,
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
but where compliance itself is disputed, the Court must ultimately ascertain, as
far as the available material permits, what was actually communicated.
31. Consequently, if the Arrest-cum-Personal Search Memo and the
Section 50 proceedings constituted the entire communication made to the
petitioner, the mere reference to Section 7(a) and the general statement that the
grounds were informed would raise a substantial question as to whether the
case-specific factual grounds contemplated by Article 22(1) were meaningfully
conveyed. On the other hand, the documents do not conclusively establish that
no further oral or written communication took place. The CBI's case is that the
grounds were explained to the petitioner and that the contemporaneous
proceedings, signatures of the petitioner, signatures of independent witnesses
and other records establish compliance.
32. The decisive question is therefore what was actually communicated,
when and in what manner. Its determination may require examination of original
records and evidence from persons present at the arrest. Although this Court can
protect fundamental rights under Article 226, it would be unsafe to resolve such
disputed facts solely on competing affidavits.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
33. Subsequent remand does not cure a constitutional defect in the
original arrest. Its legality must be judged by the law and circumstances
prevailing when the arrest was made.
34. The petitioner approached this Court on 15.07.2025, nearly nineteen
months after the arrest. Delay cannot validate an unlawful arrest, but is relevant
to discretionary relief under Article 226, particularly where the challenge requires
reconstruction of disputed events and criminal proceedings have intervened.
35. Thus, the constitutional right to meaningful communication of grounds
is unquestionable. However, the uniform written-supply procedure laid down
prospectively in Mihir Rajesh Shah cannot alone determine the legality of this
earlier arrest. The memo lacks detailed factual grounds, while the signed Section
50 CrPC proceedings record that grounds were explained. On the present
material, the Court cannot conclusively determine the substance of any
additional communication.
36. Having regard to the applicable law, the contemporaneous records, the
disputed facts and the substantial delay, the petitioner has not established
sufficient grounds in these writ proceedings to declare the arrest dated
19.12.2023 illegal or to grant consequential relief. This conclusion neither treats
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
remand as curing an unlawful arrest nor regards signatures as conclusive proof
of constitutional compliance.
37. The petitioner remains at liberty to raise any legally available
contention concerning the arrest before the competent forum on appropriate
material. Subject to this observation, W.P.No.19734 of 2025 is dismissed. No
order as to costs.
44. W.P. No.31644 of 2025 concerns the residential search. The law treats
search of a private residence as a serious invasion of privacy and therefore
insists upon compliance with the procedure prescribed by law. In State of
Rajasthan v. Rehman, the Supreme Court observed that search is 'a process
exceedingly arbitrary in character' and held that recording reasons under Section
165 Cr.P.C. is an important step; ignoring that requirement means ignoring a
material part of the law governing search.
45. The petitioner also relies upon ITC Ltd. v. State of Karnataka,
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the investigating agency must
follow the statutory procedure 'scrupulously' and that the means adopted during
a search must remain above board and that recording reasons before search or
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
seizure is an important safeguard. These principles cannot be diluted merely
because the investigation concerns an allegation of corruption.
46. The petitioner relied upon Yakub Abdul Razak Memon v. CBI,
regarding the importance of a properly prepared recovery memorandum and
independent panch witnesses and on Rajesh v. State of Madhya Pradesh,
where the Court noticed that evidence collected in complete defiance of law
becomes vulnerable when there is a possibility of tampering or interpolation. The
petitioner also relies on Shafi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh,
concerning videography as a measure which can improve confidence in the
collection of evidence.
47. These decisions support the importance of lawful search procedure.
They do not, however, permit this Court to declare the entire search illegal
merely because the petitioner disputes the CBI's version of authorization,
witnesses, signatures and supply of records. The CBI asserts that the search
formed part of the immediate trap and recovery operation and that independent
witnesses, seizure records and acknowledgment are available. The original
search record will therefore has to be examined by the court before which its
evidentiary effect arises. Any breach proved from that record can be given its
legal consequence by the competent court.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
48. In the decision in Radha Kishan v. State of Uttar Pradesh33 the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that an illegality in search does not automatically
make the seizure non-existent or vitiate the prosecution; the evidence may
require closer scrutiny.
49. The later return of Rs.1,80,000/- is a circumstance which the petitioner
may rely upon to question the necessity or relevance of that seizure. But later
return does not, by itself, establish that the entire search was unlawful at its
inception. W.P. No.31644 of 2025 therefore cannot be allowed on the basis of
disputed affidavits. The petitioner's objections to the search, seizure, panchnama,
witnesses, videography and admissibility or weight of the material are expressly
left open to be raised before the Special Court or other competent forum in
accordance with law.
50. W.P. No.32169 of 2025 stands on a distinct constitutional footing. The
legality of the corruption prosecution and the legality of the manner in which a
person is treated in custody are separate questions. Even a person against whom
there is strong prima facie material, and even a person whose arrest is otherwise
lawful, does not lose the protection of dignity and bodily and mental integrity
. AIR 1963 SC 822
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
under Article 21. Investigation authorizes lawful questioning; it does not
authorize punishment, intimidation, humiliation or coercion.
51. In Arvinder Singh Bagga v. State of U.P., relied upon by the
petitioner, the Hon'ble Supreme Court treated allegations of unlawful police
conduct and custodial abuse as matters requiring serious judicial scrutiny and
recognized that impermissible coercion is not confined to visible physical
violence. Mental or psychological pressure, intimidation and conduct calculated to
break the will of a person in custody may also engage constitutional protection.
In D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
emphasized that custodial safeguards exist because a person under the control
of investigating authorities is particularly vulnerable and that coercive methods
for extracting information are incompatible with Article 21.
52. The significance of these decisions is that a custodial complaint cannot
be rejected merely by saying that the underlying arrest or prosecution was
justified. Nor can the seriousness of an accusation dilute the standard of lawful
treatment. At the same time, an allegation of ill-treatment, particularly when
personal liability of named officers is sought, must ultimately be established on
reliable material. Constitutional concern requires careful scrutiny; it does not
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
dispense with proof or with a fair opportunity to the officers against whom
findings are sought.
53. In Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh, relied upon by the petitioner,
the Hon'ble Supreme Court issued and reinforced directions concerning CCTV
coverage and preservation in police and investigating premises so as to create
objective accountability. The importance of such material is evident in a case like
the present one: CCTV or other preserved electronic material may corroborate a
genuine complaint, but it may equally demonstrate that an allegation against
officers is unfounded. Where a custodial grievance is raised, therefore, the
existence, preservation period, location of cameras, availability of footage and
lawful production of such material may become relevant evidentiary questions
before the competent forum.
54. The CBI, however, emphatically denies any physical, mental or
psychological ill-treatment. It relies upon the remand proceedings and the
alleged absence of a contemporaneous complaint in the form now pleaded. That
circumstance is relevant, but it cannot be treated as conclusive by itself. A
person in custody may or may not be in a position to articulate a grievance
immediately; equally, a later allegation cannot be accepted merely because it
concerns custody. The proper approach is to examine the earliest available
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
complaint or application, remand papers, medical material if any, custody and
movement records, CCTV or other electronic material if preserved, and the
specific role attributed to each officer.
55. The petitioner's assertion that he attempted to place his grievance
before the trial court through applications is disputed and cannot be finally
accepted or rejected on affidavits alone. Likewise, the absence of an immediate
detailed complaint may affect the weight of the allegation but does not, standing
alone, answer whether ill-treatment occurred. The Court must avoid both
extremes: it should neither underestimate a custodial allegation merely because
the accused faces a corruption prosecution, nor condemn individual officers
without evidence and an opportunity of hearing.
56. The learned Standing Counsel relies upon Amutha v. Additional
Principal Secretary, Home Department, Chennai, to oppose personal
impleadment and adverse findings against officers in the absence of specific
sustainable material. The principle is relevant to the relief presently sought. A
declaration of personal misconduct, criminal liability or departmental culpability
against identified officers ordinarily requires a fact-finding process in which the
allegation, contemporaneous records and the officers' explanation can be tested.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
That exercise is not appropriately completed in this writ petition on the present
disputed record.
57. Accordingly, this Court does not record a finding that custodial illtreatment either occurred or did not occur. The allegation is treated as serious,
but unresolved. The petitioner is at liberty to pursue any complaint already made
or any remedy available in law before the competent Magistrate or other
competent authority. In such proceedings, the competent forum may, subject to
law and availability, call for and preserve relevant CCTV footage or other
electronic records, examine remand and medical records and consider the
specific allegations against the concerned officers. The matter shall be decided
independently on evidence, uninfluenced by the fact that the corruption
prosecution is pending.
58. W.P. No.34423 of 2025 is concerning the CBI press release. Reputation
is protected as part of dignity. In Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognized reputation as an inseparable facet of
Article 21. In R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court Court recognized privacy as implicit in life and liberty and described it as a
right to be let alone, subject to the qualifications stated in that judgment.
Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa, the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognizes the
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
power of constitutional courts to grant public-law relief where a flagrant violation
of Article 21 by State action is established.
59. These principles require an investigating agency to exercise care in
public communications. A press release may state that a case has been
registered, that a trap or arrest has taken place, that articles were seized, and
that investigation is pending. It should not present disputed allegations as finally
proved facts or use language which effectively declares an accused guilty before
trial. At the same time, Youth Bar Association of India v. Union of India
reflects the recognized public interest in procedural transparency concerning
criminal cases.
60. On the material placed in these proceedings, the Court is not satisfied
that the press release, read as a whole, furnishes a sufficient basis for directing
criminal or departmental action against an individual officer. The petitioner's
disagreement with the description of seized material and the prosecution version
can be adjudicated in the criminal case. However, the CBI shall ensure that any
future public communication concerning the pending case clearly describes
allegations as allegations and does not convey that the petitioner's guilt has
already been established.
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
61. This Court has referred to the above decisions only for the legal
principles relevant to the present stage. Nothing in this order shall be understood
as accepting the truth of the prosecution case or rejecting the petitioner's
defence. The Special Court shall decide C.C. No.12 of 2024 independently, on the
evidence produced before it, without being influenced by any prima facie
observation made in this common order.
62. In the above view of the matter,
(i) Criminal Petition No.7888 of 2025 is dismissed. All factual and legal
defences of the petitioner are left open to be urged before the learned Special
Judge for CBI Cases, Vijayawada.
(ii) W.P. No.19734 of 2025 is dismissed. The petitioner is at liberty to raise
every legally available contention and consequence of any proved arrest defect
before the competent forum.
(iii) W.P. No.31644 of 2025 is disposed of, leaving open the petitioner's
objections concerning authorization of search, recording of reasons, independent
witnesses, seizure procedure, videography, return of Rs.1,80,000/- and the
RC,J
CRLP No.7888/2025,W.P.Nos.19734, 31644, 32169 & 34423 of 2025
evidentiary effect of the search and seizure. Those questions may be raised
before the Special Court or other competent forum in accordance with law.
(iv) W.P. No.32169 of 2025 is disposed of without recording any finding on
the disputed allegation of custodial ill-treatment. The petitioner is at liberty to
pursue the remedies before the trial Court.
(v) W.P. No.34423 of 2025 is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs. Pending miscellaneous applications, if
any, shall stand closed.
___________________________
JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
th
13 October, 2026.
Note: LR copy be marked.
B/o
RR
Whether the order is :
Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No
Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No
RR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review