Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
GAHC010238122022
2026:GAU-AS:6852
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
MAC App./41/2023
1.
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. A
Company Registered and
Incorporated Under the Companies
Act, 1956, having its registered
Office At
Oriental House, A-25/27 Asaf Ali
Road, New Delhi- 2
With One Of Its Regional Office At
G.S. Road, Ulubari, Guwahati- 7,
Represented By its Regional
Manager
……..Appellant
-Versus-
MACApp.41/2023
1.
Niru Saikia
W/O Purnanda Saikia,
Village - Khatargaon, Nomi,
P.O.- Nagaon, P.S.- Nagaon Sadar,
District - Nagaon, Assam, Pin- 782001.
2.
Usha Saikia
W/O Sanjib Saikia
Village - Khatargaon Nomi
P.O.- Nagaon P.S.- Nagaon Sadar
District - Nagaon Assam Pin- 782001.
Page 1
Page |2
3.
Ranjit Nath
S/O Pulesh Nath
Village - Lungpung Gaon
P.O. and P.S.- Kamrup
Dist.- Nagaon Assam Pin- 782426
……Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
Advocate for appellants
:
Mr. R. C. Paul, Advocate
Advocate for respondents
:
Mr. I. A. Talukdar, Advocate
Date on which judgment is
reserved
:
20.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of
judgment
:
18.05.2026
Whether the
pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the
judgment
:
N/A
Whether the full judgment
has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
Judgment & Order
1.
Heard Mr. R. C. Paul, the learned counsel for the appellant
Insurance Company. Also heard Mr. I. A. Talukdar, the learned
counsel for the respondents /claimants.
2.
This Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
has been filed by the Oriental Insurance Company Limited
MACApp.41/2023
Page 2
Page |3
impugning the judgment and award dated 23.08.2022 passed
by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon in the MAC Case
No. 249/2006, whereby, the appellant was directed to pay a
compensation amount of Rs. 20,17,856/- to the claimants along
with an interest at the rate of 12% per annum.
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant appeal, in
brief, are that one Sanjeev Saikia was a professional driver of
the vehicle bearing Registration No. AS01Y5127 (Tata mobile
pick-up van), which is a goods carrying vehicle. On 26.03.2006,
some miscreants had hired the said vehicle with an intention to
commit theft of the vehicle and when the vehicle was going
towards Changjurai Potiapam reserve for loading vegetables,
the miscreants killed the driver and the handyman and
committed theft of the said vehicle. However, the villagers
appeared at the place of occurrence and apprehended the two
of the miscreants involved in the incident. In this regard, an FIR
was lodged and Jamunamukh Police Station Case No. 5/2006
under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code was registered.
4.
Thereafter, the mother, the father and the widow of the
deceased Sanjeev Saikia filed an application under Section 166
of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 before the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Nagaon, seeking compensation for death of
their son/husband. The said case was registered as MAC Case
No. 249/2006.
5.
The present appellant contested the claims case by filing a
written statement, wherein it took the usual defences which are
available to Insurance Company under the law. It also took the
plea of non-maintainability of the application under Section 166
MACApp.41/2023
Page 3
Page |4
of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988. Upon the pleadings of the
parties, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal framed the
following issues:
i.
Whether the claim petition is maintainable?
ii.
Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the vehicle No. AS01Y5127 (mobile
pick-up van)?
iii.
Whether the claimant is entitled to receive compensation,
and if so, to what extent and who is liable to pay the
same?
iv.
6.
To what reliefs/reliefs are the parties entitled to?
The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon, by judgment
dated 11.03.2015, had dismiss the claim case filed by the
claimants mainly on the ground that the claimants have failed
to show any negligence or fault on the part of the driver or
owner of the offending vehicle. Hence, it was held that they are
not entitled to get relief under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988.
7.
The Tribunal also held that as the annual income of the
deceased was more than Rs. 40,000/- the claim case also
cannot be converted into a case under Section 163A of the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, in view of the clear bar to that effect
laid down in law and clarified by the Apex Court in the case of
“Deepal Girishbhai Soni and Others Vs. United India Insurance
Company Limited” reported in (2004) 05 SCC 385.
8.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment of the Tribunal, the
mother of the deceased approached this Court by filing an
MACApp.41/2023
Page 4
Page |5
appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988. The
said appeal was registered as MAC Appeal No. 189/2015.
9.
By its judgment dated 07.03.2022, a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court had set aside the judgment dated 11.03.2015 passed by
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon in MAC Case
No. 249/2006 and allowed the appeal by relying on the
judgment of the Apex Court in the case of “Rita Devi and Others
Vs.
New India Assurance Company Limited and Another”
reported in (2000) 5 SCC 113. The Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court held that the claimants are entitled to compensation
because of the death of the deceased and remanded the case
back to the Tribunal for passing a fresh judgment in light of the
observations made in the said judgment.
10. In pursuant to the directions passed by this Court in the
aforementioned judgment, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Nagaon after getting the case back on remand, heard the
learned counsel for both sides and delivered a fresh judgment
on 23.08.2022 by allowing the claim petition of the claimants
and directing the present appellant to pay a compensation
amount of Rs. 20,17,856/- along with an interest at the rate of
12% per annum.
11. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon, the Insurance Company has
again approached this Court by filing the instant appeal.
12. Mr. R. C. Paul, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted
that the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon, in the
impugned judgment which was passed by it after remand of
the case back to it, has erred in computing the compensation
MACApp.41/2023
Page 5
Page |6
payable to the claimants under the provisions of Section 4 of
the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923. He submits that since
the claim petition was filed by the claimants under Section 166
of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, the computation of the
compensation payable to the claimants cannot be done under
the provisions of the Employees Compensation Act, 1923.
13. He submits that the claimants could have opted for seeking
compensation under Employees Compensation Act, 1923 and
could have filed claim application before the Commissioner,
Employees' Compensation, Nagaon. However, when they have
elected to pursue remedy under Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, they
cannot fall back again under the provisions of Employees'
Compensation Act, 1923 and the Tribunal has erred in mixing
up two jurisdictions and has acted beyond jurisdiction by
awarding compensation to the claimants under the provisions
of Employees' Compensation Act, 1923.
14. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that since
in the instant case, a case under Section 302/34 of the Indian
Penal Code was registered as Jamunamukh Police Station Case
No. 5/2006 and since the deceased died due to commission of
murder by the miscreants, the same cannot be regarded as an
accident arising out of use of a vehicle, therefore, Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
Nagaon
does
not
have
any
jurisdiction to grant compensation in such cases. He submits
that even if it is taken to be a case of accidental murder arising
out of the use of a vehicle, the claimants have failed to relieve
the burden that there was any fault or negligence on the part
of the driver or owner of the vehicle involved in this case.
MACApp.41/2023
Page 6
Page |7
15. He submits that in absence of any fault on the part of driver or
owner of the vehicle involved in the accidental murder, they
cannot be held liable to pay compensation. He submits that the
liability to pay compensation under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicle Act, 1988 is a fault liability, he submits that the Tribunal
has to first arrive at the conclusion that driver or owner of the
vehicle involved in the accident were at fault, only thereafter,
they may be made liable to pay any compensation. However, in
the instant case, he submits that the claimants have failed to
relieve the said burden.
16. He also submits that the case in hand can also not be
converted into a claim case under Section 163A of the Motor
Vehicle Act, 1988, where there is no necessity of relieving the
burden of proving fault on the part of the driver and owner of
the vehicle involved in this case. He submits that in the instant
case, the evidence on record clearly shows that the monthly
income of the deceased was Rs. 4,000/- and accordingly, the
annual income of the deceased crosses the bar of Rs. 40,000/per annum, which is to be considered for invoking jurisdiction
under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
17. The learned counsel for the appellants further submits that
though the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in its judgment
dated 07.03.2022 passed in MAC Appeal No. 189/2015 has
allowed the appeal filed by the Insurance Company, relying on
the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of “Rita Devi and
Others Vs. New India Assurance Company Limited and Another”
(Supra). However, it failed to take into consideration the fact
that in the case of “Rita Devi and Others Vs. New India
MACApp.41/2023
Page 7
Page |8
Assurance Company Limited and Another (Supra) the claim case,
with which the Apex Court was dealing, was filed under Section
163A of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, whereas, in the instant
case, the claim case has been filed under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988. He further submits that though the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has observed that the
claimants are entitled to compensation because of the death of
the deceased, however, it has not stated in the aforesaid
judgment as to under what provision the claimants are entitled
to compensation. He submits that the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Nagaon has also erred in directing the appellants to
pay the compensation without ascertaining as to whether its
liability has arisen to pay compensation under Section 166 or
under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
18. He submits that without doing so, the Tribunal had fallen back
on the provisions of Employees' Compensation Act, 1923, which
is a clear error of jurisdiction on the part of the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal. He, therefore, submits that the impugned
judgment and award passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Nagaon is liable to be set aside. In support of his
submission, the learned counsel for the appellant has cited
following rulings:
i.
Rita Devi and Others Vs. New India Assurance Company
Limited and Another reported in 2000 (5) SCC 113
ii.
United
India
Insurance
Company
Limited
Vs.
H.
Lalhmingliana and Another reported in 2006 2 GLT 538
MACApp.41/2023
Page 8
Page |9
iii.
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Lakshmi Thapa
and Others reported in (2014) 5 GLT 691
iv.
New India Insurance Company Limited Vs. Purnima Singha
reported in 2016 0 Supreme (GAU) 85
v.
Sarla Verma and Others Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
and Another reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121
vi.
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and
others reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680.
19. On the other hand, Mr. I. A. Talukdar, the learned counsel for
the respondents/claimants has submitted that the son/husband
of the claimants expired in an accidental murder when he was
driving the mobile pickup van and he did not have any enmity
with anyone. He further submits that in the said accidental
murder not only the driver of the said vehicle was killed but the
handyman was also killed, which indicates that the miscreants
who killed the deceased Sanjeev Saikia had no personal enmity
with him but he was killed only while the miscreants were
committing the theft of the vehicle and, as such, the murder of
the deceased Sanjeev Saikia was not a murder simpliciter but
an accidental murder arising out of use of the vehicle,
therefore, he submits that such an accidental murder may be
compensated under the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
as held by the Apex Court in the case of “Rita Devi and Others
Vs.
New India Assurance Company Limited and Another”
(Supra).
20. Mr. I. A. Talukdar, the learned counsel for the respondents/
claimants, however, very fairly submits that the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Nagaon has erred in applying the criteria for
MACApp.41/2023
Page 9
P a g e | 10
computing compensation under the provisions of the Workmen
Compensation Act, 1923. He submits that as the claim case was
filed by the claimants under the provisions of Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988, the Tribunal could not have fallen back upon the
provisions of the Workmen Compensation Act, 1923. He
submits that though, the claimants had the option of preferring
remedy against under any of the aforementioned statute,
however, once they opt for a particular statute, remedy against
another statute cannot be granted. In support of his
submission, he has cited a recent ruling of the Apex Court in
the case of “Mohammad Masood Vs. The New India Assurance
Company Limited and Another” (Civil Appeal No. 12567/2024,
judgment dated 26.09.2025).
21. The learned counsel for the respondents/claimants submits that
the claimants are struggling to get compensation in a genuine
case of death of their son/husband for last more than 20 years
and in the meanwhile, one of the claimants, namely, the father
of the deceased, has already expired. He further submits that
since the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as well as the Workmen
Compensation Act, 1923 are both beneficial legislations, he
prays for granting compensation to the claimants under the
appropriate law, taking into consideration beneficial aspects of
both the statutes as well as peculiar facts and circumstances of
this case.
22. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel
for both sides and have gone through the materials available on
record. I have also gone through the rulings cited by the
learned counsel for both sides.
MACApp.41/2023
Page 10
P a g e | 11
23. On going through the impugned judgment dated 23.08.2022,
passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon after the
case was remanded back to it, it appears that in paragraph No.
9 of the said judgment, it formulated the following points for
determination:
i.
Whether the deceased was an employee of opposite
party No.1?
ii.
Whether the deceased died in the course of his
employment
while
driving
the
vehicle
No.
AS01Y5128 (Mobile pick-up van) on a public way?
iii.
Whether the death of the deceased was due to use
of a vehicle in a public way?
iv.
Whether
the
claimants
are
entitled
to
compensation?
v.
To what amount the claimants are entitled to and
who will be liable to pay the said amount?
24. On a bare perusal of the points for determination formulated by
the tribunal in the impugned judgment, it appears that it has
not framed any issue as regards the determination of fault on
the part of the driver or owner of the vehicle involved in the
accident, which was done earlier by the Tribunal while passing
the judgment in the MAC Case No. 249/2006, at the first
instance, on 11.03.2015. At that time, it formulated the Issue
No. 2 which has already been mentioned in paragraph No. 5
hereinbefore, which is an important issue to be decided in
adjudicating an application under Section 166 of the Motor
MACApp.41/2023
Page 11
P a g e | 12
Vehicle Act, 1988. However, in the impugned judgment which
was passed by the Tribunal after the remand of the case, no
such issue has been formulated.
25. It is also pertinent to take note of the fact that even after the
remand of the case back to the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
it was adjudicating an application under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 and not a claim application under the
provision of Workmen Compensation Act, 1923. This Court is of
the considered opinion that the points for determination No. 2
formulated by the Tribunal, after the case was remanded back
to it, is not relevant while considering an application under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988. It appears that the
Tribunal has erred in not formulating a point for determination
with regard to the fault liability as is necessary in adjudication
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
26. Further, though, the Tribunal in paragraph No. 8 of the
impugned judgment has observed that the appropriate
provision applicable to the facts of the instant case is Section
167 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, read with Section 4 of the
Employees Compensation Act, 1923 and have converted the
claim case into Section 167 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988,
however, this Court is of the opinion that the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Nagaon has wrongly interpreted the provision
of Section 167 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
27. The provision contained in Section 167 of the Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988 is quoted herein below:
“167. Notwithstanding anything contained
in the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923
MACApp.41/2023
Page 12
P a g e | 13
(8 of 1923) where the death of, or bodily
injury to, any person gives rise to a claim
for compensation under this Act and also
under the Workmen’s Compensation Act,
1923, the person entitled to compensation
may without prejudice to the provisions of
Chapter X claim such compensation under
either of those Acts but not under both”.
28. A bare perusal of the aforesaid provision would indicate that it
is for the claimant to opt for seeking relief either under
Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 or under Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988, where on the death of a person or bodily injury to
any person give rise to a claim under both the Acts. The
provision contained in Section 167 of the Motor Vehicle Act,
1988 is an enabling provision for the claimant to opt for any of
the two Acts. However, when the claimant has opted for one of
the Acts, in the instant case Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, for
seeking compensation, he cannot fall back again upon the other
Act, i.e., Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923. Neither the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal can treat an application under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, to be an application
under the provisions of the Workmen Compensation Act and
adjudicate the claim case as if it is adjudicating an application
under Workmen Compensation Act, 1923. Section 167 of the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 clearly lays down a bar for the claimant
to seek compensation under both the Acts, i.e., Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988 as well as Workmen Compensation Act, 1923.
MACApp.41/2023
Page 13
P a g e | 14
29. Since the forum for seeking relief under both the Acts are
separate forums exercising jurisdiction in different spheres,
once the claimant chooses his option to exercise to seek
compensation under a particular Act, the forum recognized by
the provisions of the said Act shall only have the jurisdiction to
adjudicate upon such a claim. The Tribunal in the instant case
has erred in converting the claim case under Section 167 of the
Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, as if it is dealing with a claim case
under the provisions of the Employees Compensation Act,
1923.
30. Though, the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has observed that
claimants are entitled to compensation, however, it has not
clarified as to under what provision said compensation may be
granted. Otherwise also, the claimant's case for compensation
is not foreclosed as they are also entitled to get compensation
under the Victim Compensation Scheme of the Government.
They can still pray for compensation under the Victim
Compensation Scheme of the Government or for that matter
under any other law which enables them to do so.
31. However, to claim compensation under Motor Vehicle Act,
1988, it has to be first ascertained that whether their case falls
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, or under
Section 163A of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
32. In the instant case, considering the facts involved in the case,
though, it can be said that the death of deceased Sanjeev
Saikia was due to the result of an accidental murder and not a
murder simpliciter, and thus, a claim under the provisions of
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is maintainable, however, to get
MACApp.41/2023
Page 14
P a g e | 15
compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act,
1988, which is enacted on the basis of fault-based liability, the
burden of proving the fault of the driver or owner of the vehicle
involved in the accident is on the claimant. In the instant case,
said burden could not be relieved, and, therefore, the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, has erred in directing the appellant to
pay the compensation to the claimants without giving a finding,
as regards the fault or negligence on the part of either the
driver of the offending vehicle or the owner of the offending
vehicle. It is pertinent to mention that in its previous judgment
dated 11.03.2015, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal has
decided the said issue in negative.
33. The facts of the case in hand also do not justify converting the
claim case of the claimants under Section 163A of the Motor
Vehicle Act, 1988 as the annual income of the deceased was
more than Rs. 40,000/- per annum, which was the outer limit
of the annual income of the deceased for filing an application
under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988. The said
position of law has also been clarified by the Apex Court in the
case of “Deepal Girishbhai Soni and Others Vs. United India
Insurance Company Limited” (Supra).
34. As regards the question of applying the provisions of
Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 by the Tribunal for
computation of the compensation payable to the claimants, the
same is not the correct approach as the Apex Court has
observed in the case of “Mohammad Masood Vs. The New India
Assurance Company Limited and Another” (Supra) that once the
remedy under the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 was elected to be
MACApp.41/2023
Page 15
P a g e | 16
pursued by the claimant and the Tribunal adjudicated the
compensation, applying the criteria and fixing the income falling
back upon the parameters under the Workmen's Compensation
Act, 1923 was not permissible.
35. Therefore in the instant case also the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal had erred in deciding the claims case filed by the
claimants under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 on
the basis of the criteria laid down under Section 4 of the
Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 hence, the impugned
judgment of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon is not
sustainable.
36. In view of the discussions made and reasons stated in the
foregoing paragraphs, the impugned judgment passed by the
Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
Nagaon
by
awarding
compensation to the claimants under the provision of Section 4
of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 is liable to be set
aside.
37. Accordingly, the impugned judgment and award is hereby set
aside and this appeal is allowed.
38. Send back the records of the MAC Case No. 249/2006 to the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagaon along with a copy of
this Judgment.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
MACApp.41/2023
Date: 2026.05.19 16:46:38 +05'30'
Page 16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review