Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010272922023
2026:GAU-AS:16016
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/2379/2024
ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD
HAVING ITS REGIONAL OFFICE AT GUWAHATI , GS ROAD, ULUBARI,
GUWAHATI,, 781007 REPRESENTED BY THE DEPUTY MANAGER, GAUHATI
REGIONAL OFFICE, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI 781007
VERSUS
JAAN ALI AND ANR.
S/O JAHUR ALI,
RESIDENT OF BHAKUATEPA, PO RAOLI, PS SARTHEBARI, DIST BARPETA,
ASSAM 781311
2:SRI ABUL ALI
S/O AMESH ALI
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AMRATTARY
PO ANANDABAZAR
PS MUKALMUA
DIST NALBARI
ASSAM 78131
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. R D MOZUMDAR, MS. C MOZUMDAR,MR. S P SHARMA
Advocate for the Respondent : MS. S D SAIKIA (R-1), MR. A GOSWAM (R-2),MR. A
BISWAS,MR R KALITA(R-1),MR P K BASU (R-1)
Page No.# 2/10
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
ORDER
Date : 02-11-2026
Heard learned counsel Mr. R.D. Mozumdar for the Insurance Company and
learned counsel Mr. A. Biswas for the respondent No. 1.
2.
This application is filed by the Insurance Company under Section 5 of the
Indian Limitation Act, 1963, with prayer for condonation of delay of 328 (Three
Hundred and Twenty Eight) days delay in filing the appeal against the Judgment
and Order dated 07.11.2022 passed by the learned Commissioner, Employee’s
Compensation, Barepta in E.C. Case No. 143/2022.
3.
It is submitted that the delay has been duly explained through the
application. The judgment was passed on 07.11.2022 and the dealing counsel
provided his legal opinion on 18.01.2023, after 61 (Sixty One) days of passing
of the judgment. It is further contended that on receipt of the judgment,
something odd was discovered by the officials of the Applicant Company.
Though many cases were filed due to the accident, causing injury, no FIR was
registered in all the cases. In all the cases only G.D. Entry was made. No own
damage claim was filed against damage to the vehicle. Thus, some research
was conducted to delve deeper into the matter.
4.
It is further averred that the instant case was part of a pattern for filing
cases under the E.C. Act, 1923. In many cases the owner was same, vehicles
were different, whereas in many other cases the driver was same and the
vehicles were different. The time taken on the research led to the delay in filing
Page No.# 3/10
the connected appeal against the Judgment and Order dated 07.11.2022 passed
in E.C. Case No. 143/2022. The time taken on the research caused the delay,
but it was not intentional, as the Applicant Company had to get to the root of
the matter. Vide email dated 30.08.2023, the details of findings were sent to the
Legal Hub of the Regional Office for information. Recommendation was made to
file appeal. The Regional Office also took some time to go through the claim
petitions and documents. The copy of the email dated 30.08.2023 is marked as
Annexure-2.
5.
It is further contended that the Regional Office thought it prudent to take
legal opinion of the Advocate of the High Court, who provided the opinion on
03.10.2023 for filing the appeal. Meanwhile, the Office at Barpeta was asked to
provide if in any other cases, judgments were passed where such irregularities
had surfaced. The file was put up before the competent authority on 08.11.2023
for approval for filing the appeal and the approval was given on the same day.
Thereafter, the file was prepared and handed over to the learned counsel on
16.11.2023 for preferring the appeal. The counsel took a few days to prepare
the appeal and the appeal was finally filed on 01.12.2023.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 laid stress in his
argument that the delay has not been sufficiently explained. There was an
inexplicable delay in filing the appeal. Under Section 30 (2) of the E.C Act, 1923,
the period within which an appeal has to be filed is 60 (Sixty) days, whereas in
the instant case, the legal opinion was provided after 61 (Sixty One) days. It is
submitted that no letter has been filed to substantiate that the letter dated
18.01.2023 expressing the legal opinion was submitted by the applicant.
7.
It is also contended that the name of the learned counsel was also not
Page No.# 4/10
provided by the applicant. On mere statements, and without any substantiating
documents, it cannot be presumed that substantial grounds have been shown to
explain and justify the delay of 328 (Three Hundred and Twenty Eight) days. It
is also contended that the applicant is a company and there would be
forwarding letters as well as documents relating to the steps taken by the Office
while investigating into any fraudulent activities on the part of the respondent
No. 1. No documents have been produced nor any FIR has been registered
against any fraud allegedly committed by the respondents. Moreover, the merit
of the case relating to any fraudulent activities on the part of the respondent
No. 1 cannot be taken into consideration at this stage. This Court has to deal
only with the reasons of delay and this has not been properly explained by the
applicant with substantiating documents. This petition is liable to be dismissed
on the ground of inertia and laxity of the applicant. Merely on the statements of
the applicant, the applicant cannot claim that delay has been properly explained
and that there has been no malafide on their part.
8.
Further the learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has submitted that
the submissions of the learned counsel for the applicant that such cases have to
be referred for an SIT, holds no water, as the applicant had not affirmed that
they have filed any FIR against the respondent.
9.
It is further contended by the learned counsel for the respondent No. 1
that the applicant has stated that the opinion of two advocates has been taken,
but not once the names of the advocates have been disclosed by the applicant,
nor any documents to substantiate mere statements by the applicant have been
submitted.
10.
I have considered the submissions at the bar with circumspection.
Page No.# 5/10
11.
Learned counsel for the applicant has relied on the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Nagaland Versus Lipokao and Others reported in
20(2005) 3 SCC 752 wherein it has been held that :“14.
In G. Ramegowda, Major v. Spl. Land Acquisition Officer it was held that
no general principle saving the party from all mistakes of its counsel could be
laid. The expression "sufficient cause" must receive a liberal construction so as
to advance substantial justice and generally delays in preferring the appeals
are required to be condoned in the interest of justice where no gross negligence
or deliberate inaction or lack of bona fides is imputable to the party seeking
condonation of delay. In litigations to which Government is a party, there is yet
another aspect which, perhaps, cannot be ignored. If appeals brought by
Government are lost for such defaults, no person is individually affected, but
what, in the ultimate analysis, suffers is public interest. The decisions of
Government are collective and institutional decisions and do not share the
characteristics of decisions of private individuals. The law of limitation is, no
doubt, the same for a private citizen as for governmental authorities.
Government, like any other litigant must take responsibility for the acts,
omissions of its officers. But a somewhat different complexion is imparted to the
matter where Government makes out a case where public interest was shown to
have suffered owing to acts of fraud or bad faith on the part of its officers or
agents and where the officers were clearly at cross-purposes with it. It was,
therefore, held that in assessing what constitutes sufficient cause for purposes
of Section 5, it might, perhaps, be somewhat unrealistic to exclude from the
consideration that go into the judicial verdict, these factors which are peculiar
to and characteristic of the functioning of the Government. Government
decisions are proverbially slow encumbered, as they are, by a considerable
degree of procedural red-tape in the process of their making. A certain amount
of latitude is, therefore, not impermissible. It is rightly said that those who bear
responsibility of Government must have "a little play at the joints". Due
recognition of these limitations on governmental functioning - of course, within
reasonable limits - is necessary if the judicial approach is not to be rendered
unrealistic. It would, perhaps, be unfair and unrealistic to put Government and
private parties on the same footing in all respects in such matters. Implicit in
Page No.# 6/10
the very nature of Governmental functioning is procedural delay incidental to
the decision-making process. The delay of over one year was accordingly
condoned.
15. It is axiomatic that decisions are taken by officers/agencies proverbially
at slow pace and encumbered process of pushing the files from table to table
and keeping it on table for considerable time causing delay - intentional or
otherwise - is a routine. Considerable delay of procedural red tape in the
process of their making decision is a common feature. Therefore, certain
amount of latitude is not impermissible. If the appeals brought by the State are
lost for such default no person is individually affected but what in the ultimate
analysis suffers, is public interest. The expression "sufficient cause" should,
therefore, be considered with pragmatism in justice-oriented approach rather
than the technical detection of sufficient cause for explaining every day's delay.
The factors which are peculiar to and characteristic of the functioning of the
governmental conditions would be cognizant to and requires adoption of
pragmatic approach in justice-oriented process. The court should decide the
matters on merits unless the case is hopelessly without merit. No separate
standards to determine the cause laid by the State vis-a-vis private litigant
could be laid to prove strict standards of sufficient cause. The Government at
appropriate level should constitute legal cells to examine the cases whether any
legal principles are involved for decision by the courts or whether cases require
adjustment and should authorise the officers to take a decision or give
appropriate permission for settlement. In the event of decision to file appeal,
needed prompt action should be pursued by the officer responsible to file the
appeal and he should be made personally responsible for lapses, if any. Equally,
the State cannot be put on the same footing as an individual. The individual
would always be quick in taking the decision whether he would pursue the
remedy by way of an appeal or application since he is a person legally injured
while State is an impersonal machinery working through its officers or
servants.
16. The above position was highlighted in State of Haryana v. Chandra Mani
and Special Tehsildar, Land Acquisition v. K.V. Ayisumma. It was noted that
adoption of strict standard of proof sometimes fail to protract (sic) public
justice, and it would result in public mischief by skilful management of delay in
Page No.# 7/10
the process of filing an appeal. “
12.
In this case, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has drawn the
attention of this Court to an admitted and well known fact that Insurance
Companies, in a routine manner, file petitions with prayer for condonation of
delay and these petitions have to be diligently scrutinized.
13.
Learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 has relied on the decision of
this Court in The ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs Shri Rup Nath
Brahma Choudhury & another reported in 2017 (2) GLT 487 wherein it has been
held that :“5. Although the vague date of receipt of files by Regional Office and Head Office
is ignored, but as per the averments, once again the Head Officials deliberated
among themselves and took yet another advice from another advocate. If that be
so, it is apparent that the Head Office was taking an independent decision in the
matter of filing of the appeal, for which the entire process of moving the file from
table to table in Branch Office and Regional Office of the applicant and of
availing opinion from conducting advocate as well as learned advocate practicing
in the High Court, as portrayed by the applicant was a totally wasteful exercise,
which should not have been done in the first place. If the Head Office of the
Applicant has no trust on the officials at Branch level and Regional Office level as
well as upon the advice given by conducting Advocate and Advocate having High
Court practice ought not to have been allowed to spend even one moment over
the file after judgment and award has been passed by the learned tribunal. The
explanation is so vague that not even one person or authority is identified who
was instrumental in causing even a day’s the delay. Under the circumstances, if
the applicant allows the file to be moved from table to table of officials who have
no decision making authority to file an appeal and assuming the said officials had
any decision making authority, their decision in the matter was of no
consequence, then the applicants are doing so at their own risk.
Page No.# 8/10
6. The explanations as given in the herein before quoted paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 of
the instant application are not at all found to be satisfactory from a in surer like
the appellant, who are in a business of insuring citizens and goods in the Country,
have a social responsibility to see that at least they do not become a source of
prolongation of a litigation under the social and beneficial legislation.
Accordingly, this court is of the opinion that the reasons assigned as the cause of
delay establishes that the delay of 99 days has not been properly or satisfactorily
explained. The said causes are held not to constitute just, or proper, or good, or
sufficient cause for which the connected appeal could not be filed on time, rather
the said statements reflects that the applicant was casual in all stages of decision
making process in the Branch level, Regional Office level and in the Head Office
level. The present application is a stereotype application, which gives an
impression that the applicant had no intention to display any sense of
promptitude even where it affects its own interest or that the applicant has taken
for granted that delay would always be condoned even if applications are
prepared and filed in a casual and routine manner without satisfactorily
explaining the delay. Accordingly, the prayer for condonation of 99 days in
presenting the connected appeal is rejected.
7.
Before parting with the records, this court is of the view that save and
except a few cases, a majority of the insurance claims are generally on a pre-set
pattern and the appellant, who are in the business of insuring risk is supposed to
be equipped with some sort of mechanism to calculate the estimated award
expected in a case and, as such, it is for the applicant to devise a way and mean s
to expeditiously challenge those awards, to which they do not agree to. However,
this is only a passing remark, and the applicant is left to decide its own course
while taking steps in courts.”
14.
Relying on the judgment, it is submitted that in this case a delay of 99
(Ninety Nine) days was not condoned by this Court.
15.
Further the case referred to by the learned counsel for the respondent No.
1 is a case private to the respondent, whereas this is a case where involvement
Page No.# 9/10
of some drivers and owners in different litigations have been projected.
Annexure-2 clearly reveals that 15 (Fifteen) cases have surfaced during an
enquiry by the Insurance Company and examples of several cases have been
projected where in 4-5 cases, the insured Mamraj Khan is the owner of the
vehicles which have met with the accident. In EC Case No. 108/2022, 109/2022,
56/2023 and 57/2023, the insured vehicle bears Registration No. AS 15 C 8902
and the insured is Mamraj Khan. In EC Case No. 122/2022 and 123/2022, the
insured vehicle bears Registration No. AS 15 C 7340, but the insured is Mamraj
Khan. Both the vehicles of Mamraj Khan met with accident, out of which EC
Cases arose and compensation have been withdrawn by the claimants. There
are 4-5 odd cases where the insured vehicles were driven by the same driver
i.e. Moktar Ali and several claim petitions have been registered.
This reveals the fraudulent practice of the respondents. It is further
contended that names of three doctors have surfaced, who issued certificates in
the cases mentioned in Annexure-2 and the names of the doctors are as follows
:1.
Dr. Pranab Jyoti Das
2.
Dr. Santanu Das
3.
Dr. Hasmat Ali
16.
After scrutinizing the application, it can be safely held that the reasons of
delay have been duly explained. There is no lack of bonafide. It is not true that
the statements have not been substantiated by any documents. Annexure-2 is
sufficient to substantiate the submissions that a thorough investigation was
Page No.# 10/10
taken up, which reveals some fraudulent activities while claiming compensation
in the EC Cases mentioned in Annexure-2.
17.
A pragmatic view indeed has to be taken. The delay has been explained,
but this Court will not resort to technicalities by seeking explanation of delay of
each and every day.
18.
In the light of the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of State of
Nagaland Versus Lipokao and Others (supra), it is held that the delay was the
result of the enquiry into the allegedly fraudulent activities and the appeal is
required to be heard on merits considering public interest. This Court also
cannot be oblivious of the fact that this case relates to enquiry by the Insurance
Company in its official capacity and pushing of files and red tapism cannot be
ruled out. It is further clarified that this order will not affect the merits of the
connected appeal as the allegation of allegedly fraudulent activities has to be
dealt with substantiating evidence.
19.
In view of the foregoing discussions, the delay of 328 (Three Hundred and
Twenty Eight) days is condoned.
20.
This Interlocutory Application is allowed.
21.
Registry to register the connected appeal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review