Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010240932018
2026:GAU-AS:10046
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
MAC App./146/2021
1. Oriental Insurance Company Limited
Having Its Gauhati Regional Office
At Guwahati, Ulubari,
Kamrup (M) represented by the
Asstt. Manager, Gauhati, Gauhati
Regional Office, Ulubari,
Guwahati-781007, Kamrup (M), Assam.
-Versus-
MAC App./146/2021
…..Appellant
1.
Jaynab Nessa
W/O. Lt. Ashan Ali,
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon, P.S. Kalgachia,
P.O. Kalgachia, Dist. Barpeta, Assam,
Pin-781319.
2.
Khatun
D/O. Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia, P.O. Kalgachia
Dist. Barpeta, Assam
Pin-781319
Page 1
3.
Zmina
Khatun
:D/O. Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia, P.O. Kalgachia
Dist. Barpeta, Assam
Pin-781319
4.
Amirul
Islam
S/O.
:
Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia P.O. Kalgachia
District - Barpeta Assam Pin-781319.
5.
Rubul
Aminn
S/O.
:
Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia, P.O. Kalgachia
Dist. Barpeta, Assam
Pin-781319.
Being minor represented by his Mother Opp.
No.1
6.
Farida Khatun
D/O. Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia, P.O. Kalgachia
Dist. Barpeta, Assam
Pin-781319.
Being minor represented by her Mother Opp.
No.1
7.
Mamiron Bewa
M/O. Lt. Ashan Ali
R/O. Vill. Chawracharagaon
P.S. Kalgachia, P.O. Kalgachia
Dist. Barpeta, Assam
Pin-781319
……Respondents
MAC App./146/2021
Page 2
For Appellant
For Respondent(s)
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
:
Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, Advocate
:
Mr. S. Ahmed, Advocate
:
08.05.2026
:
22.07.2026
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Heard Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the appellant. Also
heard Mr. S. Ahmed, learned counsel for the respondents/claimants.
2.
This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has
been preferred by the appellant M/s Oriental Insurance Company
Limited impugning the judgment and award dated 05.06.2018
passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Barpeta in
MAC Case No. 132/2017, whereby the appellant Insurance Company
was directed to pay a compensation amount of Rs. 11,44,000/- to
the claimants along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum.
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant MAC Appeal, in
brief, are that on 28.11.2016, the husband of the respondent No. 1
/claimant No.1, namely, Ashan Ali was returning from Tinsukia to
Barpeta road as a passenger in tourist bus bearing Registration No.
AS15C6269.
4.
When the said bus reached Bezkuchi at National Highway No. 31, it
suddenly met with an accident due to rash and negligent driving of
the driver of the said bus. As a result of the said accident, the
MAC App./146/2021
Page 3
husband of the respondent No.1, namely, Ashan Ali sustained
serious injuries on his person and he died on the spot.
5.
Thereafter,
the
wife/daughters/sons/mother
of
the
deceased
approached the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Barpeta and jointly
filed an application under Section 16 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
claiming compensation for death of their husband/father/son in the
aforementioned motor vehicular accident. The said claim case was
registered as MAC Case No. 132/2017 at Motor Accident Claim
Tribunal, Barpeta.
6.
The owner and driver of the offending vehicle contested the claim
of the claimants by filing their written statement. The present
appellant/Insurance Company also contested the claim of the
respondent by filing written statement, wherein it has denied any
liability for payment of compensation to the claimant.
7.
Upon pleading of the parties, the Motor Accident Claim Tribunal,
Barpeta had framed the following issues:
i.
Whether the alleged motor accident had taken place on
29.11.2016 at 04.45 a.m. at Bezkuchi, Patacharkuchi due to
rash and negligent driving on the part of the Driver of the
vehicle bearing Reg. No. AS-15/C-6269 (Tourist Bus) and in
consequence of that Ashan Ali had died?
ii.
Whether the vehicle bearing Reg. No. AS-15/C-6269 (Tourist
Bus) was duly insured with the opposite party no. 3 under
valid insurance policy at the relevant time of accident?
MAC App./146/2021
Page 4
iii.
Whether the claimant is entitled to get compensation, if so, to
what extent and by whom payable?
iv.
To what other relief/reliefs the claimant is entitled to in law
and equity?
8.
The claimant No. 1 examined herself as a witness in support of the
contentions raised in the claims case as a witness for the claimants
and
also
exhibited
certain
parties/respondents/present
documents.
appellant,
namely,
The
opposite
the
Insurance
Company as well as the owner and driver of the offending vehicle
did not adduce any evidence against the claim of the claimants.
9.
Ultimately, by the judgment and award, which has been impugned
in this appeal, the claimants were awarded compensation in the
manner as has been described in the foregoing paragraphs of this
judgment.
10.
Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, the learned counsel for the appellant submits
that the impugned judgment and award is liable to be set aside and
modified as the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Barpeta has erred
in assessing the age of the deceased as 50 years and chosen the
multiplier of 13 for computation of the compensation awarded to
the claimant. She submits that since the deceased was above the
age of 50 years the multiplier ought to be selected for computing
the compensation to be awarded to the claimants should have been
11 and not 13. She submits that by taking multiplier 11, the
compensation to be awarded to the claimants is required to be
MAC App./146/2021
Page 5
recalculated and, accordingly, the impugned judgment is required to
be set aside and modified.
11.
She further submits that since the age of the deceased was 51
years, he falls within the age group of 51-60 years and as such, any
addition to the income of the deceased against the head future
prospects should have been 10% and not 25% as calculated by the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal.
12.
She also submits that while granting the compensation to the
claimants the Tribunal has imposed interest on the entire amount of
compensation without excluding there from the interest on future
prospects. She submits that since the future prospects is something
to which the claimants would have been entitled only a future date
therefore, no interest can be imposed on any benefit accrued on the
future prospects.
13.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal also erred in awarding maintenance
against the head - loss of love and affection to mother and five
siblings to the tune of Rs. 60,000/- which was in addition to Rs.
40,000/- awarded to the claimants in respect of loss of consortium.
14.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the from
Exhibit-3 exhibited by claimant No. 1 i.e., pass certificate of High
School Examination of deceased Ashan Ali from where it appears
that on 1st day of March 1983, the age of deceased was 16 years 10
months. Accordingly, she submits that the age of the deceased on
the date of ill-fated accident when he died on the spot of the
MAC App./146/2021
Page 6
accident i.e., on 28.11.2016 would be 51 years and as such,
multiplier of “13” chosen by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal to
compute the quantum of compensation for loss of dependency of
the claimants is erroneous and the same is required to be interfered
with by this Court. In support of her submission, the learned
counsel for the appellant has cited the following rulings:
i.
Ranjana Prakash and Others Vs. Divisional Manager and
Another reported in (2011) 14 SCC 639
15.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Ahmed, the learned counsel for the
respondent/claimant has submitted that the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Barpeta has calculated the compensation, which is payable
to the claimant on account of death of their husband/father/sons
respectively, on a lower side. He submits that the claimant No.1 is
the wife of the deceased and as such, entitled to compensation on
account of loss of spousal consortium whereas claimant Nos. 2 to 6
are the daughters/sons of the deceased and as such they are
entitled to get compensation on account of loss of parental
consortium. Whereas the claimant No. 7 is the mother of the
deceased and as such, she is entitled to compensation on account
of loss of filial consortium. He submits that in pursuant to the
guidelines issued by the Supreme Court of India in the case of
“National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others”
reported in (2017) 16 SCC 689. Each of the claimant is entitled to the
compensation of Rs. 40,000/- each on account of loss of consortium.
16.
He submits that though no Cross Objection has been filed by the
claimants in this appeal, however, he submits that there are catena
MAC App./146/2021
Page 7
of judgments, which provide that when ends of justice demands the
Courts may even enhance the compensation which it finds to the
just compensation to the claimants even in absence of any Cross
Objection. In support of his submission, he has cited the following
rulings: i.
Pannalal Vs. State of Bombay and others reported in 1963 0
Supreme (SC) 34
ii.
The Managing Director, Tamilnadu State Transport Corporation
Vs. Kanappan @ Kannan and Another (Judgment dated
17.02.2017 in CMA No.253/2017 of the High Court of Madras)
iii.
Nagappa Vs. Gurudayal Singh and others reported in (2003) 2
SCC 274
17.
I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for
both sides and have gone through the materials available on record.
I have also gone through the rulings cited by the learned counsel
for both sides in support of their respective submissions.
18.
The point to be determined in this appeal is as to whether the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Barpeta was correct in assessing
the quantum of compensation awarded to the claimants.
19.
At the outset, it is pertinent to state that this Court is not convinced
with the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellant that
the multiplier to be taken, by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
for computing the compensation to which the claimants are entitled
has been wrongly taken as 13 instead of 11. The reason for the
same is that as per the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
MAC App./146/2021
Page 8
“Sarla Verma and Others Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
Another” reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121, the multiplier of 13 is to be
used for the age group of 46 to 50 years and 11 is to be used for
age group of 51 to 55 years for computing the compensation. In the
instant case, the age of the deceased was 16 years 10 months on
the 1st day of March 1983, as such, his date of birth would be 1st
May 1966. Taking into account the said date of birth, his age on the
date of accident, i.e., on 28.11.2016 would be 50 years 6 months
and 27 days. Thus, the deceased had not attained the age of 51
years on the date of his death, as such, the multiplier to be chosen
for computation of compensation cannot be for the age group of 51
years to 55 years. It has to be as per the age group of 46-50 years.
This Court is therefore, of the considered opinion that the Tribunal
made no mistake in choosing the multiplier “13” for computing the
compensation to be awarded to the claimants.
20.
The second point raised by the learned counsel for the appellant is
as to whether in view of the fact that the deceased was more than
50 years of age, an addition of 25% to his annual income on
account of loss of future prospects was justified while computing
the compensation to be awarded to the claimants.
21.
The Apex Court has held in the case of “National Insurance
Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others” (Supra) that an
addition of 25% of the established income of the deceased towards
the future prospects where the deceased was between the age of
40 to 50 years would be reasonable. Moreover, in the case of Sarla
Verma (Supra), the Apex Court has categorically observed that there
MAC App./146/2021
Page 9
should be no addition, where the age of the deceased is more than
50 years. In the instant case, it appears that the deceased was
aged about 50 years 6 months and 27 days on the date of the
accident, as such, on the date of his death, the deceased was more
than 50 years, as such, this Court is of the view that the Tribunal
had erred in adding 25% of the established income of the deceased
towards future prospects, while computing the compensation
payable to the claimants.
22.
As regards payment of compensation on account of loss of
consortium, the Supreme Court of India has observed in the case of
“Magma General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Nanu
Ram” reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130 as follows:
“21. A Constitution Bench of this Court in Pranay
Sethi [National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi,
(2017) 16 SCC 680 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 248 :
(2018) 2 SCC (Cri) 205] dealt with the various heads
under which compensation is to be awarded in a
death case. One of these heads is loss of
consortium. In legal parlance, “consortium” is a
compendious term which encompasses “spousal
consortium”, “parental consortium”, and “filial
consortium”. The right to consortium would include
the company, care, help, comfort, guidance, solace
and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it would include
sexual relations with the deceased spouse:
[Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4
SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1
SCC (L&S) 149]
21.1. Spousal consortium is generally defined as
rights pertaining to the relationship of a husbandwife which allows compensation to the surviving
MAC App./146/2021
Page 10
spouse for loss of “company, society, cooperation,
affection, and aid of the other in every conjugal
relation”. [Black's Law Dictionary (5th Edn., 1979).]
21.2. Parental consortium is granted to the child
upon the premature death of a parent, for loss of
“parental aid, protection, affection, society,
discipline, guidance and training”.
21.3. Filial consortium is the right of the parents to
compensation in the case of an accidental death of a
child. An accident leading to the death of a child
causes great shock and agony to the parents and
family of the deceased. The greatest agony for a
parent is to lose their child during their lifetime.
Children are valued for their love, affection,
companionship and their role in the family unit.
22. Consortium is a special prism reflecting changing
norms about the status and worth of actual
relationships. Modern jurisdictions world-over have
recognised that the value of a child's consortium far
exceeds the economic value of the compensation
awarded in the case of the death of a child. Most
jurisdictions therefore permit parents to be awarded
compensation under loss of consortium on the death
of a child. The amount awarded to the parents is a
compensation for loss of the love, affection, care
and companionship of the deceased child.
23. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial legislation
aimed at providing relief to the victims or their
families, in cases of genuine claims. In case where a
parent has lost their minor child, or unmarried son or
daughter, the parents are entitled to be awarded loss
of consortium under the head of filial consortium.
Parental consortium is awarded to children who lose
their parents in motor vehicle accidents under the Act.
A few High Courts have awarded compensation on
this count [ Rajasthan High Court in Jagmala
Ram v. Sohi Ram, 2017 SCC OnLine Raj 3848 : (2017)
4 RLW 3368; Uttarakhand High Court in Rita
MAC App./146/2021
Page 11
Rana v. Pradeep Kumar, 2013 SCC OnLine Utt 2435 :
(2014) 3 UC 1687; Karnataka High Court
in Lakshman v. Susheela Chand Choudhary, 1996 SCC
OnLine Kar 74 : (1996) 3 Kant LJ 570] . However,
there was no clarity with respect to the principles on
which compensation could be awarded on loss of filial
consortium.
24. The amount of compensation to be awarded as
consortium will be governed by the principles of
awarding compensation under “loss of consortium” as
laid down in Pranay Sethi [National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 : (2018) 3
SCC (Civ) 248 : (2018) 2 SCC (Cri) 205] . In the
present case, we deem it appropriate to award the
father and the sister of the deceased, an amount of
Rs 40,000 each for loss of filial consortium.”
23.
It also appears that though the deceased late Ashan Ali left behind
his wife, five children and his mother at the time of his death, all of
whom
have
suffered
loss
of
consortium,
namely,
spousal
consortium, parental consortium and filial consortium, however, the
Tribunal has awarded only Rs. 40,000/- towards loss of consortium.
Though, it is not clarified in the impugned judgment, it appears that
the said amount was awarded towards loss of spousal consortium.
The children and the mother of the deceased are also entitled to get
compensation on account of loss of consortium, namely, parental
consortium/filial consortium. However, no separate amount is
required to be paid on account of love and affection to the mother
and the children, as has been done in the impugned judgment.
24.
As regards the question as to whether the Appellate Court can grant
relief to the respondent in absence of a Cross Objection under
Order 41 Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the Apex
MAC App./146/2021
Page 12
Court has held in the case of Pannalal Vs. State of Bombay and
others (Supra) that even in absence of a cross objection, the
Appellate Court has power to grant relief to a party entitled to the
same, in exercise of its powers under Order 41 Rule 33 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908. Since the aforesaid case has been decided
by the constitution bench of five Hon’ble Judges of the Apex Court,
it is binding of all courts, including the Apex Court (of benches of
lesser number of Judges). As such, this Court is of the considered
opinion that under the facts and circumstances of this case, each of
the claimants/respondents is also entitled to get compensation on
account of loss of consortium in view of the judgement of the Apex
Court discussed in the foregoing paragraphs of this judgment.
25.
In view of the discussions made in the foregoing paragraph, the just
compensation to which the claimants are entitled to on account of
death of their husband/father/son is computed in the following
manner:
Sl. No.
Description
Amount (in Rs.)
i.
Monthly income of the deceased
6,500/-
ii.
1/5th Deduction from (i) on account of
personal expenses of the deceased
1,300/-
iii.
Monthly income after deduction (i-ii)
5,200/-
iv.
Annual income (iii x 12)
62,400/-
v.
Compensation for loss of dependency by
multiplying the multiplicand (Rs.62,400/-)
with the multiplier 13
8,11,200/-
vi.
Compensation on account of loss of
consortium to each of the claimant
(40,000 x 7)
2,80,000/-
vii.
Compensation on account of loss of
15,000/-
MAC App./146/2021
Page 13
Sl. No.
Description
Amount (in Rs.)
estate
viii.
Compensation on account of funeral
charges
ix.
Total Compensation (v+vi+vii+viii)
15,000/11,21,200/-
Total =Rupees Eleven Lakh Twenty-One Thousand and Two
Hundred only
26.
In view of the discussions made and the reasons stated in the
foregoing paragraphs, the claimants/respondents are entitled to get
compensation amount of Rs. 11,21,200/- (Rupees Eleven Lakh
Twenty-One Thousand and Two Hundred only) with an interest at the
rate of 9% per annum. Since, the appellants have been earlier
directed to deposit 75% of the awarded amount as condition for
grant of stay of the execution of the impugned judgement and
award dated 05.06.2018, the appellant Insurance Company is
directed to deposit the remaining outstanding amount against the
awarded compensation, in terms of this judgment, before the
Registry of this Court within four weeks from the date of this
judgment. On such deposit, the same shall be disbursed to the
claimants/respondents after proper verification.
27.
Send back the records of MAC Case No. 132/2017 to the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal along with a copy of this judgment.
MAC App./146/2021
Page 14
28.
This appeal is, accordingly, partly allowed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Amita Sharma
2026.07.23
16:50:42 +05'30'
MAC App./146/2021
Page 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review