Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18939/2025
Oriental
Insurance
Company
Limited,
Through
Its
Branch
Manager, Yash Tower, Bajaj Road, Sikar, Tehsil And District Sikar.
----Petitioner
Versus
Dharma Ram Son Of Chola Ram, Aged About 51 Years, Resident
Of Gram Basni Saija, Tehsil - Merta City, District Nagaur,
Presently Residing At Behind Hero Honda Agency, Jaipur Road,
Sikar, Tehsil And District Sikar.
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Firoz Akhtar Ansari
Ms. Nistha Jain for
Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singhal
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAMEER JAIN
Judgment
07/04/2026
1.
The present petition has been filed against the award dated
19.09.2025, whereby an award of Rs.7,50,000/- with additional
litigation cost of Rs.5,000/- has been passed.
2.
Learned
counsel
for the petitioner
has
submitted the
impugned order is passed by Permanent Lok Adalat. It is fairly
conceded by the learned counsel that tractor was attached to a
thresher which was not insured and the accident occurred on
account of usage of thresher which was not part of the insurance
cover. It is submitted that the learned Tribunal has not dealt the
plea of the petitioner in appropriate manner.
3.
Heard and perused the award order.
(2 of 6)
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
4.
[CW-18939/2025]
This Court upon hearing the contentions put forth by the
learned counsel, and upon scanning the material available on
record, this Court is not inclined to interfere in the instant matter,
for the reasons noted hereinbelow:
2.1
That the scope of interference is minuscule and need to
invoke the writ or extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court is limited.
It is opined that in order to invoke such jurisdiction under
constitutional
provisions,
warrants
apparent
malafides,
arbitrariness and illegality. The said view is substantiated from the
ratio encapsulated in Life Insurance Corpn. of India and ors.
v. Asha Goel (Smt.) and another: (2001) 2 SCC 160, relevant
extract from which is reproduced as under:
"10.
Article
of
the
Constitution
confers
extraordinary jurisdiction on the High Court to issue
high
prerogative
writs
for
enforcement
of
the
fundamental rights or for any other purpose. It is wide
and expansive. The Constitution does not place any
fetter on exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction. It is
left to the discretion of the High Court Therefore, it
cannot be laid down as a general proposition of law
that in no case the High Court can entertain a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution to enforce
a claim under a life insurance policy. It is neither
possible nor proper to enumerate exhaustively the
circumstances in which such a claim can or cannot be
enforced by filing a writ petition. The determination of
the question depends on consideration of several
factors like, whether a writ petitioner is merely
attempting to enforce his/her contractual rights or the
case
raises
important
questions
of
law
and
constitutional issues, the nature of the dispute raised;
the nature of inquiry necessary for determination of
(3 of 6)
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
[CW-18939/2025]
the dispute etc. The matter is to be considered in the
facts and circumstances of each case. While the
jurisdiction of the High Court to entertain a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot be
denied altogether, courts must bear in mind the selfimposed
restriction
consistently
followed
by
High
Courts all these years after the constitutional power
came into existence in not entertaining writ petitions
filed for enforcement of purely contractual rights and
obligations which involve disputed questions of facts.
The courts have consistently taken the view that in a
case where for determination of the dispute raised, it is
necessary to inquire into facts for determination of
which it may become necessary to record oral evidence
a proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution, is
not the appropriate forum. The position is also well
settled that if the contract entered between the
parties provide an alternate forum for resolution
of disputes arising from the contract, then the
parties should approach the forum agreed by
them and the High Court in writ jurisdiction
should not permit them to bypass the agreed
forum
of
dispute
resolution
At
the
cost
of
repetition it may be stated that in the above
discussions we have only indicated some of the
circumstances in which the High Court have
declined to entertain petitions filed under Article
of
the
Constitution
for
enforcement
of
contractual rights and obligation; the discussions
are not intended to be exhaustive. This Court
from time to time disapproved of a High Court
entertaining a petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution
in
matters
contractual
rights
and
of
enforcement
obligation
of
particularly
where the claim by one party is contested by the
other and adjudication of the dispute requires
(4 of 6)
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
[CW-18939/2025]
inquiry into facts. We may notice a few such cases;
Mohd. Hanif v. State of Assam; Banchhanidhi Rath v.
State
of
Orissa;
Rukmanibai
Gupta
v.
Collector,
Jabalpur; Food Corpn. of India v. Jagannath Dutta and
State of H.P. v. Raja Mahendra Pal."
(Emphasis laid)
2.2
That in the matter at hand there is no apparent
illegality and that the learned Trial Court upon assiduous scanning
of the vital aspects of the matter at hand has given its conscience
opinion.
The
relevant
upheld
opinion
of
the
award
19.09.2025 is reproduced herein under:
“हमने उभयपक के ववदान अवधवकागण की बहस पर मनन वकया तथा अवभले ख
का पररशीलन वकया।
अवभलेख के पररशीलन से ववपकी बीमा कमनी दारा पाथर के वाहन की पेकेज
पॉवलसी एनेकर 1 जारी की गई है , जो वदनां क 12.08.2021 से 11.08.2022
तक की अववध की है , जो बीमा पॉवलसी संखा 243701/31/2022/484 है
तथा वाहन संखा आरजे 21 आरएच 0705 की यह बीमा पॉवलसी है , वजसमे
ऑनर ड् ाईवर का भी वपवमयम वलया हआ है तथा एनेकर 3 है तथा पाथर के दावहने
हाथ का एमचु एशन वकया गया है , जो कलोकोमीटर वडसएवबवलटी का है , जो
राजसान सरकार के वचवकता ववभाग दारा जारी वकया गया है , वजसमे 80
पवतशत साई ववकलां गता होना आया है , वजसका पमाण पत एनेकर 4 है तथा
पुवलस थाना गोटन की ररपोटर मे ट् े कर के थेसर मे हाथ कटना आया है , वजसकी
जां च ररपोटर एनेकर 5 है तथा ववपकी बीमा कमनी को वदया गया वववधक नोवटस
एनेकर 6 है तथा शीराम असताल की वडसचाजर वटवकट एनेकर 7 है , वजसमे
वदनां क 17.10.2021 को पाथर का एडवमशन होना तथा वदनां क 18.10.2021
को पाथर का ऑपरे शन होना तथा वदनां क 28.10.2021 को पाथर को वडसचाजर
करना आया है , वजसमे कश इं जरी वलखा हआ है तथा शीराम असताल के वबल
वाउचर 91,340/- रपए के है , जो वक एनेकर 8 है , तो अवभले ख से यह तो
सावपत ससवत है वक पाथर जब ट् े कर मय थे सर से मूंग वनकाल रहा था तो थे सर की
वगरारी मे उसका दावहना हाथ आ जाने से दावहने हाथ का एमचुऐशन वकया गया
है , वजसमे 80 पवतशत साई ववकलां गता होना पाथर के आया है तथा पुवलस जां च
ररपोटर से भी ट् े कर के थेसर से हाथ कटना आया है तथा एनेकर 4 पमाण पत से
लोकोमीटर ववकलां गता होना आया है तथा कश इं जरी होना मेवडकल ररपोटर से
पकट है तथा पाथर के दावहने हाथ का एमचु एशन करना मेवडकल ररपोटर से पकट
है तथा यहां दु ररटना पाथर जो वक वाहन संखा आरजे 21 आर एच 0705 का
dated
(5 of 6)
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
[CW-18939/2025]
पंजीकृत सामी है एवं चालक भी है , वजसके दु ररटनातक साई ववकलां गता होना
आया है तथा ऑनर कम ड् ाईवर का बीमा वपवमयम ववपकी बीमा दारा एनेकर 1
पॉवलसी से वलया गया है । अब जहां तक बीमा कमनी के ववदान अवधवका का यह
तकर है वक ट् े कर के लगी हई थे सर मशीन से 1 दु ररटना हई है तथा थेसर मशीन
का बीमा नहीं था। इस तकर के संबंध मे नायालय का ववनम मत यह है वक कृवष
कायर के वलए ट् े कर के साथ सहायक उपकरण के तौर पर यानी असेसरी के रप
मे थेसर मशीन होती है , जो कृवष कायर के वलए होती है । थेसर का अलग से बीमा
करवाया जाना आवशक हो, ऐसी कोई वववधक पसंगवत ववपकी बीमा कमनी के
ववदान अवधवका दारा पकट नहीं की गई है , इसवलए थेसर सहायक उपकरण होने
से ट् े कर से यह दु ररटनातक ववकलां गता होना सावपत ससवत है । अतः ववपकी बीमा
कमनी के ववदान अवधवका के इस तकर मे कोई वववधक सार नजर नहीं आता है ।”
2.3
That the amount as awarded by the Permanent Lok
Adalat is justified vis-a-vis the facts and circumstances of the
matter and the same ought not to be interfered by the High Court,
under its supervisory or writ jurisdiction, as this Court is of a
considered opinion that for redressal and awarding such amount,
minute
disputed
question
of
facts
are
addressed
and
the
appropriate authority to carry out the said exercise is the trial
court. It is also noteworthy that the orders passed by the
Permanent Lok Adalat are conclusive, and final in nature, as per
the scheme and objective of the Legal Services Authorities Act,
1987, more specifically Section 22E, which is reproduced as
under:
"22E. Award of Permanent Lok Adalat to be
final.—(1) Every award of the Permanent Lok
Adalat under this Act made either on merit or in
terms of a settlement agreement shall be final and
binding on all the parties thereto and on persons
claiming under them.
(2) Every award of the Permanent Lok Adalat under
this Act shall be deemed to be a decree of a civil
court.
[2026:RJ-JP:14445]
(6 of 6)
[CW-18939/2025]
(3) The award made by the Permanent Lok Adalat
under this Act shall be by a majority of the persons
constituting the Permanent Lok Adalat.
(4) Every award made by the Permanent Lok Adalat
under this Act shall be final and shall not be called
in question in any original suit, application or
execution proceeding.
(5) The Permanent Lok Adalat may transmit any
award made by it to a civil court having local
jurisdiction and such civil court shall execute the
order as if it were a decree made by that court."
3.
In summation of the abovenoted, it can be jot down that the
orders passed by the Permanent Lok Adalat, ought not to be
judicially reviewed unless there is apparent arbitrariness or the
order is ex facie non speaking; that when the amount awarded is
justified, and the order passed by the Permanent Lok Adalat
covers all the parameters of vital consideration and circumstances,
rather is sans any perversity, arbitrariness, violation of natural
justice, malafides; that in view of ex facie non-arbitrariness and
the view laid down in Life Insurance Corpn. of India (supra),
that as per the mandate of Section 22E of the governing statute,
which makes it categorically clear that the orders passed by the
Permanent Lok Adalat are conclusive and final in nature, this Court
is not inclined to entertain the present petition.
4.
In view of the aforementioned, the instant petition is
dismissed being bereft of any merits and no apparent arbitrariness
in the order impugned. Pending applications, if any, shall stand
disposed.
(SAMEER JAIN),J
CHANDAN /87
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review