Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Case No. CM(M) No. 381/2023
Reserved on : 16.09.2025
Pronounced on : 06.06.2026
Uploaded on : 09.06.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Oriental Insurance Co Ltd.
Divisional office Srinagar
2. Branch Manager,
Oriental lnsurance Co. Kulgam
Through their Incharge TP Hub Jammu
Mrs. Savita Bakhshi
....Petitioner/Appellant
Through:- Mr. N .A. Dendru, Advocate
V/s
1.Mohammad Yousuf Bhat
S/O Mohammad Ramzan Bhat
R/O Arwani Bijbehara Anantnag.
2. Manager
Ellaquai Dehati Bank,
Branch Arwani Bijbehara.
…..Respondent(s)
Through:CORAM:
Mr. Aijaz Ahmad Katoo, Advocate
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
PER SINDHU SHARMA-J
1.
The petitioners are aggrieved of the order dated
24.11.2023 passed by the learned J&K State Consumer
Disputes Redressal Commission, Srinagar (hereinafter “the
State Commission”) in Appeal titled Oriental Insurance Co.
CM(M) 381 of 2023
Ltd. v. Mohammad Yousuf Bhat & Anr., whereby the
application for condonation of delay was disallowed and
order dated 28.12.2018 passed by the District Consumer
Disputes Redressal Forum, Anantnag was sustained and the
appeal of the petitioners came to be dismissed as not
maintainable.
2.
Briefly stated, the District Forum, Anantnag, vide order
dated 28.12.2018, allowed the complaint of the respondent
and directed the petitioners–Insurance Company to pay
damage to the respondent to the extent of ₹3.50 lac (three
lacs fifty thousand only) together with interest @ 6% from the
date of filing of complaint along with ₹10,000/- as mental agony
and harassment and ₹5,000/- as litigation charges.
3.
Aggrieved thereof, the petitioners preferred an appeal
before the State Commission under Section 13 of the Jammu
& Kashmir Consumer Protection Act, 1987 on 17.04.2019,
accompanied by an application for condonation of delay. The
State Commission, vide order dated 10.05.2019, allowed the
said application, subject to payment of cost of ₹1500/-. The
said order reads as under:“10.05.2019. Parties present. There is an application
seeking condonation of delay. The objections have been
filed. For the reasons stated in the application, the delay
is condoned subject to payment of ₹1500/-. P.O.A on
CM(M) 381 of 2023
behalf of respondent’s counsel is taken on record. Record
be summoned from DR concerned. List on 10.07.2019.”
4.
The record shows that thereafter case was listed on
10.07.2019
and 23.07.2019, when both parties
were
present, however, the petitioners failed to deposit the cost as
directed. Thereafter, the case was listed on 09.08.2019 &
22.10.2019.Consequently, the conditional order allowing the
application for condonation of delay became infructuous,
leading
to
dismissal
of
the
appeal.
The
learned
Commissioner held that since costs as directed have not
been paid thus, order of condoning the delay has become
infructuous thereafter, proceeded to revive the application.
The Commissioner thereafter, proceeded to decide the
application for condonation of delay afresh and dismissed
the application being without any merit.
5.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused
the material on record as well as record of the State
Commission.
6.
We are of the view that the petition deserves to be
dismissed through not for the reasons stated in the
impugned order.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the
cost could not be deposited due to prevailing law and order
conditions in the Kashmir Valley following the abrogation of
CM(M) 381 of 2023
Article 370 of the Constitution of India. It is further
contended that on 24.11.2023, the petitioners offered to
deposit the cost of ₹1500/- but the same was declined by
the State Commission. It is submitted that the delay in filing
the appeal was only ten days, caused due to the time taken
for obtaining the certified copy of the District Forum’s order
(received on 06.03.2019) and internal approvals from the
controlling office at Jammu, along with the mandatory predeposit. Hence, the dismissal of the appeal on such a
technical ground is argued to be unjust.
8.
The record of the State Commission shows that the
application
for
condonation
of
delay
was
allowed
conditionally, subject to payment of costs of ₹1,500/-. The
petitioners, despite being aware of the condition and being
present on subsequent dates, failed to comply the order or to
seek any extension of time or modification of the condition.
9.
The conditional order dated 10.05.2019 was not
complied
with
by
the
petitioners
despite
sufficient
opportunities. The plea of law and order issues in August
2019 cannot explain non-compliance during May to July
2019. The cost imposed was nominal, and no material has
been produced to show that circumstances beyond control
prevented compliance. Further, there is no proof that
CM(M) 381 of 2023
anything serious or unavoidable stopped the petitioners
from following the order between 10 May 2019 and 23 July
2019.
10. The State Commission, instead of dismissing the
application for not satisfying the condition of condoning the
delay has held that the order condoning the delay is
infructuous and proceeded to revisit the application and
decide the same. This would not be proper in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
11.
We are of the opinion that the conditional order had
lapsed due to non-fulfilment of the pre-condition and
consequently, the appeal was to be dismissed on that
ground.
12. When a delay is condoned subject to the condition of
payment of costs, the order does not become effective unless
the costs are paid. The condition imposed by the court is not
a mere formality. If the party fails to comply with the
condition within the time allowed or within such further
time as may be granted, the benefit of the order cannot be
availed of, and the appeal or proceeding remains barred by
limitation.
In
State
of
Maharashtra
v.
Super
Max
International Pvt. Ltd., (2009) 9 SCC 772, the Hon”ble
Supreme Court in para 44 observed as under:-
CM(M) 381 of 2023
“ ……In an appeal or revision, stay of execution of
the decree(s) passed by the Court(s) below cannot be
asked for as of right. While admitting the appeal or
revision, it is perfectly open to the Court, to decline
to grant any say or to grant stay subject to some
reasonable condition. In case stay is not granted or
in case the order of say remains inoperative for
failure to satisfy the condition subject to which it is
granted, the tenant in revision will not have the
protection to any of the provisions under the Rent
Act relied upon by Mr. Latit and in all likelihood
would be evicted before the revision is finally
decided. In the event the revision is allowed later on,
the tenant’s remedy would be only by way of
restitution.”
13. Again
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled
Shivamma (Dead) by Lrs vs. Karnataka Housing Board
and ors, 2025 INSR 1104, in para 59 observed as under:“59.Rules of limitation are not meant to destroy the
rights of parties. They are meant to see that parties do not
resort to dilatory tactics, but seek their remedy promptly.
The object of providing a legal remedy is to repair the
damage caused by reason of legal injury. The law of
limitation fixes a lifespan for such legal remedy for the
redress of the legal injury so suffered. Time is precious
and wasted time would never revisit. During the efflux of
time, newer causes would sprout up necessitating newer
persons to seek legal remedy by approaching the courts.
So a lifespan must be fixed for each remedy. Unending
period for launching the remedy may lead to unending
uncertainty and consequential anarchy. The idea is that
every legal remedy must be kept alive for a legislatively
fixed period of time. The law of limitation is thus founded
on public policy. [See: N. Balakrishnan v. M.
Krishnamurthy, (1998) 7 SCC 123]”
14. A Hon’ble Division Bench of Delhi High Court in case
titled
Delhi
Development
Authorty
vs.
Mis
Durga
Construction Co.(2013) 139 DRJ 133(del) in para 16
observed as under:“In our view, filing of application and re-filing of the
same after removing defects, stand on completely
CM(M) 381 of 2023
different footings in so far as the provision of
limitation is concerned. It is now well-settled that
limitation does not extinguish an obligation but
merely bars a party to take recourse to courts for
availing the remedies as available to the party. Thus,
in the event a party fails to take expeditious steps to
initiate an action within the time as specified, then
the courts are proscribed from entertaining such
action at the instance of such a party.”
15. In the present case, the delay was condoned by the
State Commission vide order dated 10.05.2019 subject to
payment of cost of ₹1500/- and the case was adjourned to
10.07.2019, thereafter to 23.07.2019. On the said two dates
the petitioners were present and aware about the fact of
deposit of the costs, yet made no effort to comply with the
same. The petitioners lack of follow-up on the case cannot
simply be justified by citing the prevailing law and order
conditions in the Kashmir Valley following the abrogation of
Article
of
the
Constitution
of
India,
especially
considering that Courts continued to operate through online
platforms and electronic communication. There is no
convincing reason provided for why the petitioners could not
utilize these options. The petitioners had entered appearance
on the following dates, therefore, has the responsibility to
track the developments of their case. The petitioners were
aware of the orders and proceedings, but opted not to
deposit the costs within time.
CM(M) 381 of 2023
16. Therefore, we find that the appeal deserves to be
dismissed
on
account
of
non-compliance
with
the
conditional order dated 10.05.2019 passed by the State
Commission, which was well within its jurisdiction and is
supported by settled principles of law.
( Shahzad Azeem)
Judge
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
JAMMU
06.06.2026
Bir
Whether approved for reporting: Yes/No
CM(M) 381 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review