Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MAC. App. No.75 of 2022
1.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Agartala Division, H.G. B. Road,
Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura, represented by
its Divisional Manager (insurer of vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-01-P-1787 bolero maxi truck).
…..Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Smti. Shova Rani Saha, wife of late Sankar Saha.
2.
Miss. Sonai Saha, daughter of late Sankar Saha, both are residents of
East Shibnagar, Kalitala, near Anik Club, P.S. East Agartala,
District: West Tripura.
.......Claimant-respondents.
3.
Sri Sajal Bhowmik, son of Haripada Bhowmik, C/O Joyguru
Cement near Satsangha Ashram Routhkhola, Bishalgarh, P.S.
Bishalgarh, District: Sepahijala.
(Owner of No.TR-01-P-1787 bolero maxi truck)
4.
Abu Taher, son of Jakir Hossain of Tarapukur, Sonamura, P.S.
Sonamuar, District: Sepahijala.
(Owner by purchase of No.TR-01-P-1787 bolero maxi truck)
.....Owner-respondents
5.
Md. Sarif Miah, son of Md. Subha Miah of Palwanbari, Sonamura,
P.S. Sonamura, District: Sepahijala.
(Driver of No.TR-01-P-1787 bolero maxi truck)
.....Driver-respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. P.S. Roy, Advocate.
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. V. Poddar, Advocate.
Mr. B. Paul, Advocate.
YES/NO
Judgment and order dated 2nd May, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the appellantinsurance company. Also heard Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel,
Ms. V. Poddar, learned counsel and Mr. B. Paul, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the MV. Act,
1988 against the award dated 28.03.2022 passed by the learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.4 West Tripura, Agartala in connection
with T.S. (MAC) 226 of 2015.
[3]
Brief facts leading to this case is that on 16.10.2014 at about
11.30 a.m. Debu Saha (deceased) was standing by the side of the Agartala
Sonamura Road at Melaghar market in front of Madan Mohan Pharmacy while
he found the vehicle bearing No. TR-01-P-1787 was coming with high speed
in rash and negligent manner from Agartala side and he signed the driver to
slow down the speed of vehicle but in the mean time the vehicle ran over the
deceased and fled away towards Sonamura side. As a result, the victim
sustained severe injuries on various parts of his body and instantly he was
taken to Melaghar Hospital by local people wherefrom he was shifted to
BRAM Hospital, Hapania and there the attending doctor declared him dead.
Subsequently, his post mortem examination was done in the AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala. Hence, the claimant petitioners beingthe mother and
younger sister of the deceased Debu Saha filed this suit seeking
compensation to the tune of Rs.49,29,000/-. It has been further stated that the
accident occurred due to reckless and irresponsible driving of the vehicle by its
driver. That the deceased was of the age of 26 years and being manager of a
contractor used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month.
[4]
The O.P. No.1, owner of the offending vehicle has contested the
suit by filing written statement and apart from denying all the allegations has
contended that he was the owner of the offending vehicle and at the time of
accident the vehicle was driven by a person having valid driving licence and
the vehicle was insured with the O.P. No.4 the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. O.P.
No.1, therefore, urged for fixing the liability of his insurer to pay the
compensation, if any. However, the O.P. No.1 contended that he sold out the
vehicle to another person prior to the date of accident.
[5]
Accordingly, a police case vide Melaghar P.S. Case No.85 of
2014 under Sections-279/304 (ii) of IPC & 187 of M.V. Act was registered.
The learned Court below after hearing the parties and having perused the
material evidence on record has observed as under:
“In the result, claim is awarded in following terms:
(i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of
Rs.22,24,000/-(Twenty two lacs twenty four thousand) only along with
9%
simple interest per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e. w.e.f.
26.08.2015 till the date of realization thereof.
(I) Out of the total compensation an amount of Rs.44,000/- awarded
as loss of consortium, shall be given only to the claimant petitioner No.1
i.e. mother of deceased.
Rest amount shall be divided in equal share.
(ii) 50% of the share of the claimant petitioner Nos.1 and 2 each in the
award be invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificates from
any
Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5 years with a liberty to the
claimant
petitioner Nos.1 and 2 to withdraw the monthly interest from their own
accounts and no loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal shall be
allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal.
The O.P. No. i.e. the Oriental Insurance Company Limited shall
deposit the awarded amount along with interest thereon within one month
from this day with this Tribunal.”
[6]
Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
insurance company has submitted that the learned tribunal considered the
monthly income of the deceased as Rs.15,000/- which is very high. Moreover,
the claimant respondents did not submit any documents regarding the
profession as well as income of the deceased and as such, the learned tribunal
assessed the income with the higher side and ought to have considered the
income of the deceased. In the claim petition the claimant respondent
contended that the deceased was the manager under PW-3 but, PW-3 has stated
that he was a supervisor of his work place. So, supervisor and manager is not
same profession and as such, the same may be interfered with.
[7]
The learned tribunal has awarded loss of consortium of
Rs.40,000/- wherein the mother of the deceased is the claimant and she is not
entitled to get any amount of consortium which is awarded illegally. Hence,
this amount of consortium of Rs.40,000/- may be deducted from the awarded
compensation.
[8]
In view of above, let us re-look in the evidence as let in by the
parties in the present appeal. During argument Ld. Counsel appearing for the
respondents submitted that Debu Saha died in the road traffic accident which
occurred only due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle and
hence, the claimant-petitioners are entitled to get compensation. It is also
submitted by Ld. Counsel that the deceased was the only earning member of
the family and he was of the age of only 26 years and used to earn about
Rs.15,000/- per month, so adequate compensation may be awarded.
[9]
As per the claim petition victim Debu Saha died in the road
traffic accident occurred on 16.10.2014 at about 11.30 a.m. while he was
standing by the side of Agartala-Sonamura Road at Melaghar market in
front of one Madan MohanPharmacy, at that time the offending vehicle
bearing registration No.TR-01-P-1787came in a high speed in rash and
negligent manner from Agartala side and he signed the driver to slow
down speed of the vehicle but ultimately the vehicle ran over him
and fled away towards Sonamura side. As a result, victim Debu Saha
sustained serious bleeding injury and instantly taken to Melaghar
Hospital wherefrom he was shifted to BRAM Hospital, Hapania where
the attending doctor declared him dead.
[10]
The version of the claim petition has been corroborated by
the evidence of PW1 namely, Smt. Shova Rani Saha, mother of the
deceased, and also by the evidence of eye witness namely, Sri Bihag
Saha (PW2) and the opposite parties failed to extract anything contrary
during the cross examination of those petitioner witnesses. The version of
the
witnesses
has
been
further
corroborated
by
Ext.1
i.e. printed form of FIR and the ejahar submitted with the O.C. Melaghar
P.S. as well as by Ext. 3 i.e. charge sheet and Ext.4 i.e. certified copy of
post mortem report. Moreover, from the evidence of OPW-1 Sajal
Bhowmik, owner of the offending vehicle, it is also found that the owner
confirmed the fact of accident as alleged by the claimant petitioners
[11]
It has been established by the claimant petitioners that the
death of deceased was caused due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of offending vehicle. Therefore, the claimant petitioners i.e. the
mother and unmarried sister of the deceased are entitled to have the
compensation under the beneficial legislation, namely the M.V. Act as
the claimant petitioners were dependent on the income of the deceased as
stated in their claim petition and the fact was not disputed
by any party. In the claim petition the age of the deceased was mentioned
as 26 years. In support of such contention birth certificate of the deceased
has been exhibited from which it appears that deceased Debu Saha took
birth on 25.9.1988. So, at the time of accident i.e. on 16.10.2014 he was
26 years old.
[12]
As per the claim petition, deceased Debu Saha was earning
Rs.15,000/- per month from a private job. It was pleaded that Debu Saha
was manager of a contractor namely, Sri Rajesh Nag of Melaghar by
profession. Said fact has been corroborated by the evidence of PW1 as
well as by the evidence of PW3 i.e. RajeshNag who deposed admitting
that Debu Saha was a supervisor of his work place having monthly salary
of Rs.15,000/-. During his cross examination though it was admitted by
him that he was not able to produce any document in support of such
version, but he issued one salary certificate in his own pad putting his
signature and seal certifying that Late Debu Saha used to work under him
since 2008 having monthly salary of Rs.15,000/-.
[13]
First of all, in the examination in chief of PW-3 clearly
speaks that Lt. Debu Saha was a supervisor of his workplace and used to
supervise all sites. In the claim petition it was averted that Lt. Debu Saha
was a manager ofPW3. Thus, only on the differences of literal meaning
of supervisor and manager this Tribunal cannot doubt the credibility of
the evidence of PW3. Lastly, not submitting the enlistment number of
PW-3
cannot
be
treated
as
a lacuna to
accept
the salary
certificate issued by him which was exhibited before the Tribunal without
any objection from the other side. Moreover, O.P. No.4 was not
permitted under Section-170 of M.V. Act to contest the suit on the above
mentioned factual aspects. Thus, the argument raised by the Ld. Counsel
of the O.P. No.4 is not tenable in law and from the evidence on record as
discussed above, it is sufficiently proved by the claimant petitioners that
at the time of death Late Debu Saha had an income of Rs.15,000/per month. The deceased was being at his age less than 40 years having
fixed salary there should be 40% addition in his income.
[14]
In view of the law laid down in Sarla Varma's case (AIR
2009 SC 3104) for the age group of 26 to 30 the appropriate multiplier is
M-17 and being a bachelor deduction as personal and living expenses
will be 50%. Now, regarding granting of compensation for loss of
consortium is not only limited to the spouse but also it extends to the
parents and children. But it does not extend to other dependents like
unmarried sister, brother etc. So, the claimant petitioner No.1 being the
mother of deceased alone is entitled to get compensation for loss of
consortium at the rate of Rs.40,000/-. Thus, the calculation will be (VIII)
Loss of consortium = Rs. 40,000/-.
[15]
But in view of Pranay Sethi case as mentioned above, the
reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs.15,000/-, Rs.40,000/- and
Rs.15,000/- respectively. The aforesaid amounts should be enhanced at
the rate of 10 percent in every 3 years. The judgment was passed in the
year 2017 and so three years has already been elapsed from the date of
passing
judgment
of
Pranay
Sethi
case.
Thus,
reasonable
compensation which is to be given under the conventional heads shall
increase 10%.
[16]
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears that the
O.P. No.1being owner of the offending vehicle claimed that his vehicle
was insured with the O.P. No.4. In support of such claim he has proved
the policy of insurance (Ext.A) which was valid at the time of accident.
But, it was pleaded by O.P. No.1 that prior to the accident he sold out the
vehicle to one Raju Bhowmik and in support of such contention he
exhibited one notarized affidavit sworn for the purpose of transfer of
ownership. From the said document it is found that on 15.5.2014 the
affidavit was sworn for the purpose of transfer of ownership of the
offending vehicle which was prior to the date of accident. But in the
recitals of the agreement it was mentioned that the papers of the vehicle
would remain same till completion of payment of monthly installments of
loaned amount by O.P. No.1 which was taken at the time of
purchasing of the vehicle. Thus, it is clear that the documents regarding
the ownership of the vehicle remained same i.e. in the name of O.P. No.1
at the time of accident as no document submitted by O.P. No.1 to show
that the final monthly installment has been paid prior to the accident.
[17]
The O.P. No.1 besides the insurance certificate issued in his
name by O.P. No.4, submitted another insurance certificate issued in the
name of one Jayanti Dutta (Saha) for the same vehicle having validity on
the date of accident issued by O.P. No.4. But there is nothing on record
about the details of said Jayanti Dutta (Saha). However, the Tribunal has
not gone to that issue to decide the genuineness of second insurance
certificate which was issued in the name of Jayanti Dutta (Saha) as the
first insurance certificate i.e. Ext.A clearly shows that on the date of
accident the offending vehicle was insured with the Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. issued in the name of O.P. No.1 Sajal Bhowmik. It is also not
the case of the O.P. No.4 that the vehicle was not insured with them. It is,
therefore, held that the O.P. No.4 being insurer is liable to satisfy the
award. Accordingly, liability is fastened on OP No.4, Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd.
[18]
In view of above arguments advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant, this Court is of the view that the learned
Court below has assessed the compensation in a reasonable and
justifiable way. But the interest rate as adopted by the Court below is not
justifiable and needs to be interfered with.
[19]
This Court in all matters is fixing 7.5% interest and to
maintain uniformity while comparing the bank rate of interest which is
also much less. Consequently, the claimants would be entitled
compensation as assessed by the learned Court below along with 7.5%
interest per annum, with effect from the date of presentation of the claim
petition till the date of actual payment. Thus, the appellant insurance
company is liable to pay the total amount as awarded by the Tribunal
below in favour of the claimant-respondents within a period of 30 days
from today. However, it is made clear that if the amount is already
deposited, the claimant-respondents are at liberty to withdraw the same
unconditionally.
[20]
In view of above discussion and observation, the present
appeal stands allowed and disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous
applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the decree accordingly
and thereafter, send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review