Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010250012018
2026:GAU-AS:8671
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./986/2018
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT ORIENTAL HOUSE A-25/27,ASAF ALI
ROAD, NEW DELHI, 110002, AND REGIONAL OFFICE AT GUWAHATI 7,
REPRESENTED BY THE REGIONAL MANAGER
VERSUS
SMT REKHA MONI PHUKAN AND 4 ORS
W/O LATE SUNMONI PHUKAN
RESIDENT OF NO. 2, GANDHAKORY GAON(SARUPATHAR)
PO CHUKIAPATHAR, PS SARUPATHAR
DIST GOLAGHAT, ASSAM.
2:MASTER UDAYJYOTI PHUKAN
SON OF THE DECEASED
RESIDENT OF NO. 2
GANDHAKORY GAON(SARUPATHAR)
PO CHUKIAPATHAR
PS SARUPATHAR
DIST GOLAGHAT
ASSAM.
3:MRS DIPALI PHUKAN
MOTHER OF THE DECEASED
RESIDENT OF NO. 2
GANDHAKORY GAON(SARUPATHAR)
PO CHUKIAPATHAR
PS SARUPATHAR
DIST GOLAGHAT
ASSAM.
4:VICHA KRAHO ANGAMI
Page No.# 2/11
S/O THOSE KRAHO ANGAMI
R/O AGRI COLONY
LOWER NAGALAND
KOHIMA
797001
OWNER OF THE OFFENDING SUPER BUS
5:SRI KISHOR YADAV
S/O LATE CHOUKOURI YADAV
R/O GOLAGHAT ROAD DIMAPUR
NAGALAND DRIVER OF THE OFFENDING SUPER BU
Advocate for the Petitioner
MOCHAHARI
: MR. S DUTTA, MS. M CHOUDHURY,MS M GAZLOO,MS S
Advocate for the Respondent : MS D BORGOHAIN (R-1, 2,3), MS. B PHUKAN (R-1, 2, 3),MS. K
BARUAH (R-1,2,3),MR. P GOHAIN (R-1,2,3)
BEFORE
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
Advocates for the appellant
Advocate for the respondents
Nos. 1,2&3
: Ms. M. Choudhury
: Mr. A.K. Gupta and Mr. P.
Gohain
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
16.06.2026
:
Full judgment.
:
Yes.
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced
Page No.# 3/11
JUDGEMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
This is an appeal under 173 of the MV Act 1988 against the Judgment and
Award dated 14.08.2018 passed by the learned MACT No.02 Kamrup(M),
Guwahati in MAC Case No. 285/2013 awarding Rs.12,19,864/- with interest at
the bank rate for fixed deposits per annum from 23.06.2016 within three
months of the judgment. It was also directed that in the event of failure to
make the payment within the stipulated period, the compensation amount shall
bear additional interest @ 1% per annum from the date of filing the claim
petition.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant, Ms. M. Choudhury as well as
learned counsel, Mr. A.K. Gupta and learned counsel, Mr. P. Gohain for the
respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3,
3.
The facts of the instant case is that the claimants in the MAC Case No.
285/2013 is the wife, son and mother of the deceased who was travelling
towards Sarupathar from Dibrugarh Brahmaputra Hospital driving Tata Sumo
B/R No.AS-05-B-0397 when a Super Bus vehicle B/R No. NL-01/B-0727 coming
from the opposite direction knocked down the Tata Sumo and as a result the
driver-cum-owner of the Tata Sumo sustained injuries and died on the spot.
4. The appellant/insurer entered appearance and filed written statement as well
as an additional written statement taking the plea that the Tata Sumo which
was driven by the deceased in a rash and negligent manner hit the Super Bus
and as such the accident occurred due to contributory negligence of the drivers
of both the vehicles. It was the further plea of the appellant/insurer that the
driver of the Super Bus was only authorized to drive MC, LMV, MGV, and HGV
whereas the Super Bus was a passenger carrying vehicle and therefore the PSV
Page No.# 4/11
endorsement was mandatory. It was contended that as the DL did not have the
required PSV endorsement there is willful violation of the policy conditions and
therefore the appellant/insurer is not liable to pay any compensation to the
claimants.
5. After hearing the parties, the learned Tribunal passed the impugned
judgment and award dated 14.08.2018 fastening the liability on the appellant.
6.
Being aggrieved with the impugned Judgment and award, the appellant has
come before this Court on the ground that the learned Tribunal illegally held the
appellant liable amongst other grounds.
7.
The appellant has filed this appeal on the ground that the driver who drove
the Super Bus passenger vehicle at the time of the accident had no valid and
effective driving license as it was without PSV endorsement and as such there is
violation of terms and conditions of the policy. Another ground is that the
Tribunal has arbitrarily accepted the income of the deceased as Rs 6500/- per
month without any evidence as regards occupation or monthly income. Another
ground taken by the appellant is that the Tribunal wrongly calculated the future
prospect of the deceased as 40% inasmuch as the claimant had failed to prove
the established income of her deceased husband at the time of the accident.
When there is no evidence with regard to income it is settled law that notional
income of Rs.3000/- has to be taken.
8.
It is the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the
Tribunal had misinterpreted the principle of law in Mukund Dewangan Vrs.
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd, (2017) 14 SCC 663 as in the
aforementioned case the Supreme court had only held that a driver holding a
valid license to drive a LMV does not require a separate endorsement to drive a
Page No.# 5/11
transport vehicle that is classified as an LMV and that the absence of such
endorsement does not invalidate the driver’s license or exonerate the insurance
company from liability. Therefore, learned counsel submits that the facts are
entirely different in the instant case and no liability could have been imposed
upon the appellant as the Super Bus was above the weight of 7500 kg and it
was a passenger vehicle and the appellant should have been exonerated of its
liability to pay compensation and in fact no award could have been passed
against the appellant.
9.
Learned counsel further submits that the appellant is not liable to indemnify
the insured. It is prayed that the monthly income should also be taken as
Rs.3900/- per month basing on the Minimum Wages Notification of the
Government of Assam for 2012 as the income was not proved and occupation
was not proved. Learned counsel further submits that since the income is not
established the learned tribunal should not have added the future prospect,
however, the tribunal has added 40% towards future prospects. Nevertheless,
taking into account the involvement of a third party, an opportunity should be
given to the appellant to pay and recover from the owner/insured. Learned
counsel accordingly, prays that the impugned Judgment and award may be duly
modified by this Court.
Learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the case of:-
i) Pappu and Others Vs. Vinod Kumar Lamba and Another, (2018) 3 SCC 208
ii) Syed Basheer Ahamad and Ors Vs. Mohd. Jameel and Anr, (2009) 2 SCC 225
iii) Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs. Nanjappan and Others, (2004) 13
SCC 224
iv) Judgment and Order dated 01.10.2019 in The Oriental Insurance Company
Page No.# 6/11
Limited Vs.Smti. Champabati Ray and 5 Ors.
v) Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Prem Devi Bothra, 2024
Supreme (Gau) 493
vi) Order dated 06.02.2020, in MACApp./565/2019
vii) Judgment and Order dated 02.03.2023 in MACApp./989/2018
viii) Judgment dated 05.12.2024 in MACApp./132/2020
ix) Judgment dated 07.03.2022 in MACApp./33/2017.
10. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the claimant/ respondent has
submitted that neither the factum of the accident nor the death of the deceased
in the accident is disputed by the appellants. Learned counsel submits that the
deceased was a driver and he used to drive his own Tata Sumo vehicle for hire
purposes. It is stated that the driving license of the deceased was exhibited as
Exhibit-6 and the registration certificate of the Tata Sumo in the name of the
deceased is Exhibit-8. He has submitted that the driving license of the driver of
the offending super bus also shows that the driver was authorized to drive
heavy goods vehicle (HGV). He submits that the super bus can also come under
the category of heavy goods vehicle and therefore, the endorsement of PSV
Passenger vehicle is not mandatory in the present case. Regarding the income
of the deceased, the learned counsel submits that the driving license and the
registration certificate of the Tata sumo have been exhibited during the trial.
The claimant No.1/wife of the deceased also proved the income certificate as
exhibit-7 wherein the Government Goan Bura of the deceased’s village certified
that the deceased was earning Rs.8000/- per month. However, the tribunal had
held the monthly income as Rs.6500/- per month which is just as proper as
even going by the minimum wages in the year 2012, the monthly income of a
Page No.# 7/11
skilled person in private transport can be calculated as Rs.6240/- per month.
Learned counsel for the claimant/respondent relies on the case of Kirti and
Another Vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited, AIR 2021 Supreme
Court 353, wherein the Supreme Court held that even if the claimants are
unable to produce any documents to prove the income of the deceased nor
could they establish his employment as a teacher that does not justify adoption
of the lowest tier of minimum wage while computing his income. From the
statement of witnesses and documentary records and circumstances of the
accident, it was apparent that the deceased was comparatively more
educationally qualified and skilled. Further, he maintained a reasonable standard
of living for his family as evidenced by his use of a motor cycle for commuting.
Thus, at the very least, the minimum wage as applicable to skilled workers in
the state of Haryana during 2014 ought to have been applied. As preserving the
existing standard of living of a deceased’s family is a fundamental endeavor of
motor accident compensation law. Similarly, in the instant case learned counsel
submits that the entire documents on record shows that the deceased was
using his own tata sumo vehicle for hire which he used to drive himself and
therefore, it is only proper that the tribunal has taken the monthly income as
Rs.6500/-. Learned counsel for the claimant/respondent therefore submits that
the Tribunal has not committed any illegality and prays that the instant appeal
may be dismissed as having no merit.
11. This Court has considered the submission made by the learned counsel for
the parties, perused the pleadings and the Trial Court Records. The principle of
law laid down in Mukund Dewangan (Supra), is that a driver holding a valid
license to drive a light motor vehicle (LMV) does not require a separate
endorsement to drive a transport vehicle that is clarified as an LMV and the
Page No.# 8/11
absence of such endorsement does not invalidate the driver’s license or
exonerate the insurance company from liability. Therefore, it is the view of this
Court that the learned Tribunal could not have relied on the case of Mukund
Dewangan to arrive at a finding that the instant case is covered by the
aforementioned judgment of the Supreme Court. In the instant case, the
offending vehicle was a super bus, meaning, it was a heavy passenger vehicle
and a transport vehicle license was required. In the case of M/S Bajaj
Alliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Rambha Devi and
Others, Civil Appeal No.841/2018, reported in 2024 INSC 840, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court considered the question as to whether a person holding
a LMV License can lawfully drive a transport vehicle whose gross vehicle weight
does not exceed 7500 Kg. the Supreme Court affirmed that such a LMV License
is sufficient and no separate transport endorsement is required for that class of
vehicle. In other words a driver holding a LMV license can legally drive a
transport vehicle weighing up to 7500 Kg without any additional endorsement or
separate license for transport vehicles. However, the implications for vehicles
exceeding 7500 Kg gross weight based on the M/S Bajaj Alliance Vrs. Rambha
Devi case would mean that a separate transport vehicle license is mandatory. In
the instant case, the offending super bus falls in the category of the earlier
Heavy Passenger Motor Vehicle/HPMV. After the 1994 amendment to the MV Act
the old class wise endorsements such as HPMV or HPV/PSV have largely been
replaced by the broader category “Transport Vehicle/TRANS. The license now
generally specifies the class of vehicle and whether it’s a transport vehicle. For a
super bus vehicle above 7500 kg a separate transport endorsement remains
mandatory. Evidently, the driving license of the driver of the super bus did not
have the transport vehicle endorsement. This Court is therefore, of the view that
Page No.# 9/11
the case of Mukund Dewangan (Supra), is relevant only with regard to vehicles
with less than 7500 Kg gross weight. This Court therefore, holds that the
learned tribunal could not have fastened the liability to pay the compensation on
the appellants as there was a clear violation of policy conditions.
12. With regard to the monthly income this Court is of the view that the
claimant/respondents were able to prove on the touchstone of preponderance of
probability that the deceased was maintaining a reasonable standard of living
for his family as can be seen by his use of a Tata Sumo for hire purposes and
also the income certificate issued by the Village Gaon Bura. Thus, the amount of
Rs.6500/- as monthly income is just and proper. In the case of National
Insurance company limited Vs. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 , the
Supreme Court held that when the deceased was self-employed or, on a fixed
salary an addition of 40% of the established income should be the warrant
where the deceased was below the age of 40 years. Since the deceased in the
present case was 35 years old, the tribunal has rightly added 40% towards
future prospect. Therefore, the calculations made by the learned tribunal under
various heads is upheld and not interfered with.
13. The Appellant/Insurance Company is directed to deposit the balance
amount of the compensation before the Tribunal within 60 (sixty) days from the
date of receipt of this order.
14. The appellant insurance company shall be at liberty to recover the awarded
amount from the owner/insured in due course. Before releasing the awarded
amount, the learned tribunal shall issue a notice to the insured owner of the
vehicle/super bus, who shall be required to furnish security for the entire
amount that the insurer will pay to the claimant, in accordance with the law laid
down in Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs. Shri Nanjappan and
Page No.# 10/11
Others, (2004) 13 SCC 224. The offending vehicle shall be attached as part
of the security. If necessary, the executing court shall take assistance from the
concerned Regional Transport Authority. The executing court shall also pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law regarding the manner in which the
insured owner of the vehicle shall made payment to the insurance company.
15. It is observed that the learned Tribunal had also directed for an additional
interest at 1% p.a. from the date of filing the claim petition in the event of
failure to make the payment within the stipulated period. This condition is set
aside. It is also directed that there shall be no interest on the future prospects.
The payment of interest on the compensation amount with effect from
23.06.2016 is not interfered with.
16. It is submitted by the parties that 50% of the awarded amount has already
been deposited by the appellant in pursuance of the order of this Court dated
17.12.2018 passed in I.A(C)./4117/2018. The said amount has further been
withdrawn by the claimant/respondents in view of the order dated 06.03.2019
passed in I.A(C)./617/2019. Therefore, the claimant/respondents have already
received an amount of Rs.6,09,932/-(Rupees six lakh nine thousand nine
hundred thirty-two). The balance amount of the compensation shall be
deposited by the appellants/Oriental Insurance Company before the Tribunal as
directed above in accordance with the instructions of the Tribunal.
17. The Registry shall refund the statutory deposit of Rs.25,000/- to the
appellant.
18. Consequently, the appeal is disposed of with the above modifications and
directions.
19. Registry to return back the trial court records expeditiously.
Page No.# 11/11
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review