The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Perused the Order passed by the Commissioner, wherein the Commissioner considered the fact that R.W.1 who was examined on behalf of Appellant herein has admitted that at the time of the accident the insurance policy was in force, that on the date of the accident the deceased was working as Driver of the lorry of O.P.No.1 and the cause of death is due to fall from the top of the lorry, as such, the claimants proved the employee and employer relationship and it is also fact that it is clearly mentioned in the F.I.R., inquest report and also as per the evidence of A.W.2 about employment, accident, injuries and death of the deceased and as such, this Court do not find any merits and is not inclined to interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal. Therefore, the Appeal is liable to be dismissed.
8. Accordingly, the C.M.A., is dismissed upholding the order passed by the Tribunal. No costs. Dated:28.01.2026 CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1176/2017 Dated:28.01.2026
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010901242017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1176/2017
Between:
1. THE MANAGER, ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO., LTD., D NO.4-13-25, 1ST
FLOOR, OPP. HARIHARAMAHAL, KORETIPADU, GUNTUR.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. PATAN MEERABI, W/O LATE NAGUL MEERA, R/O DIDUGUBAVI
CENTER, OLD MANGALAGIRI, MANGALGIRI TOWN, GUNTUR
DISTRICT.
2. V AJAY KUMAR, S/O. VEERASWAMY, OWNER OF LORRY NO.AP-07
TT-8499, R/O 4-158, ETUKUR POST, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. V RAGHU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. U KANAKA RAJU
2.
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1176/2017
J U D G M E N T:
1.
The present Appeal has been preferred by the Insurance Company
aggrieved by the Order passed by the Commissioner of Employees
Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Tenali, dated 26.04.2017
in W.C.No.27 of 2012.
2.
i.
Brief facts of the case are that:-
A Claim Petition was filed by the applicants stating that one Patan Nagul
Meera was working as Driver under Opposite Party (O.P.) No.1 on his Lorry
bearing Registration No. AP07 TT 8499 and the Opposite Party (O.P.) No.2 is
the Insurer for that vehicle and he received personal injuries in an accident
arising out of and in the course of his employment on 14.09.2011 and died on
21.09.2011 while undergoing treatment at Gunturu Hospital. The deceased was
aged about 36 years and was getting wages of Rs.6,000/- per month besides
batta of Rs.250/- per day by the time of his death.
ii.
O.P.No.1 who is the Owner of the Lorry remained ex-parte in the case.
iii.
O.P.2 filed his Counter by denying most of the averments made in the
Petition filed by the applicants stating that the applicants are put to strict proof of
the same with the authenticated documentary evidence. The said Lorry was not
insured with O.P.No.2 by the date of accident, the amount claimed as
compensation is highly excessive and without any basis, the deceased slept over
the load on the lorry and fell down due to his negligence only and hence prayed
to dismiss the petition with costs against O.P.No.2.
iv.
Basing on the said pleadings, the Court below framed the following issues.
1) Whether the deceased was a workman as per the provisions of the Act
and he died due to personal injuries he received in an accident arising out
of and in the course of his employment? Or not, under Opposite party -1 as
H.V Driver?
2) Amount of compensation payable? To the applicants.
3) Who are liable to pay the compensation?
v.
On behalf of the Applicants, wife to the deceased was examined as A.W.1,
Owner of the Lorry was examined as A.W.2 and Ex.A.1 to Ex.A.12 documents
were marked.
vi.
One V.Umadevi was examined as R.W.1 on behalf of opposite party No.2
and Ex.B.1 and Ex.B.2 documents were marked.
vii.
The Court below duly considering the evidence of R.W.1 who categorically
deposed that by the time of accident the Insurance Policy was in force and on the
date of accident the deceased was working as the Driver of Lorry of O.P.No.1
and the cause of death was due to fall from the top of the lorry and also
considering the fact that it is clearly mentioned about the employment, accident,
injuries and death etc., of the deceased in the F.I.R., inquest report and evidence
of A.W.2 etc., the claimants proved their case beyond reasonable doubt and held
that the O.P.No‟s.1 and 2 are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation
of Rs.5,91,621/- to the claimants as against the claim of Rs.6,00,000/-.
3.
Challenging this, the present Appeal is preferred by the O.P.No.2
i.e., the Insurance Company on the ground that the Commissioner failed to
consider that in the final report filed by the police before the concerned Criminal
Court, which was marked as Ex.B.2, it was clearly mentioned that basing on the
statement of the Cleaner who was examined as L.W.5 “that on 14.11.2011 night
the lorry reached to the check-post of Purushothampuram wherein the deceased
asked the Cleaner to check the lorry papers and he went to the top of the lorry
and slept there. At about 23 hours, he fell down from the lorry, sustained injury
on head and accordingly died on 21.09.2011 while undergoing treatment in
Gunturu Hospital”.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant has argued that the accident was
occurred because of the negligence of the deceased, as such, no liability can be
fixed as against the Insurance Company.
5.
This Court relief on the Judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of
India in MST. Param Pal Singh through Father … Appellant Versus national
Insurance Co. & Anr… Respondents, Civil Appeal No.9084 of 2012 @
SLP(C) No.16063 of 2007, decided on 14.12.2012, wherein at paragraphs
No.27 and 28 it was held as follows:“27. Applying the various principles laid down in the above decisions to the facts
of this case, we can validly conclude that there was CAUSAL CONNECTION to
the death of the deceased with that of his employment as a truck driver. We
cannot lose sight of the fact that a 45 years old driver meets with his unexpected
death, may be due to heart failure while driving the vehicle from Delhi to a distant
place called Nimiaghat near Jharkhand which is about 1152 kms. away from
Delhi, would have definitely undergone grave strain and stress due to such long
distance driving. The deceased being a professional heavy vehicle driver when
undertakes the job of such driving as his regular avocation it can be safely held
that such constant driving of heavy vehicle, being dependant solely upon his
physical and mental resources & endurance, there was every reason to assume
that the vocation of driving was a material contributory factor if not the sole cause
that accelerated his unexpected death to occur which in all fairness should be
held to be an untoward mishap in his life span. Such an „untoward mishap‟ can
therefore be reasonably described as an „accident‟ as having been caused solely
attributable to the nature of employment indulged in with his employer which was
in the course of such employer‟s trade or business.
28. Having regard to the evidence placed on record there was no scope to hold
that the deceased was simply travelling in the vehicle and that there was no
obligation for him to undertake the work of driving. On the other hand, the
evidence as stood established proved the fact that the deceased was actually
driving the truck and that in the course of such driving activity as he felt
uncomfortable he safely parked the vehicle on the side of the road near a hotel
soon whereafter he breathed his last. In such circumstances, we are convinced
that the conclusion of the Commissioner of Workmen‟s Compensation that the
death of the deceased was in an accident arising out of and in the course of his
employment with the second respondent was perfectly justified and the
conclusion to the contrary reached by the learned Judge of the High Court in the
order impugned in this appeal deserves to be set aside. The appeal stands
allowed. The order impugned is set aside. The order of the Commissioner for
Workmen‟s Compensation shall stand restored and there shall be no order as to
costs”.
6.
The above cited judgment facts are squarely applicable to the
present case facts. In the present case also as per the statement of cleaner “that
on 14.11.2011 night the lorry reached to the check-post of Purushothampuram
wherein the deceased asked the Cleaner to check the lorry papers and he went
to the top of the lorry and slept there. At about 23 hours, he fell down from the
lorry, sustained injury on head and accordingly died on 21.09.2011 while
undergoing treatment in Guntur Hospital”. While he was on duty, during sleep,
unfortunately the deceased fell down, received injuries and died while
undergoing treatment.
7.
Perused the Order passed by the Commissioner, wherein the
Commissioner considered the fact that R.W.1 who was examined on behalf of
Appellant herein has admitted that at the time of the accident the insurance
policy was in force, that on the date of the accident the deceased was working as
Driver of the lorry of O.P.No.1 and the cause of death is due to fall from the top of
the lorry, as such, the claimants proved the employee and employer relationship
and it is also fact that it is clearly mentioned in the F.I.R., inquest report and also
as per the evidence of A.W.2 about employment, accident, injuries and death of
the deceased and as such, this Court do not find any merits and is not inclined to
interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal. Therefore, the Appeal is liable to
be dismissed.
8.
Accordingly, the C.M.A., is dismissed upholding the order passed by
the Tribunal. No costs.
______________________
SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Dated:28.01.2026
KS
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1176/2017
Dated:28.01.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review