The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
30. In the case of Ravikumar Dhansukhlal Maheta & Anr. v. State of Gujarat & Ors., reported in 2024 SCC Online 972, para 81, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that “…no government servant can claim promotion as their right because the Constitution does not prescribe criteria for filling seats in promotional posts…”. A coordinate bench of this Court in the case of Andrew Shabong & Ors. v. State of Meghalaya & Ors. reported in 2023 SCC Online Meg 12 at para 10 has also observed as follows: “10. Promotion to a higher post in the instant case is not a case of functional promotion, but as can be seen involves a process of selection and recommendation by a duly constituted DPC. A mere existence of a vacancy therefore, will not create a vested right for an eligible employee to claim for appointment on promotion to the said post, especially when the same has to be finalized through a selection process. A case that is relevant and has a bearing on the point in issue wherein leading cases have been digested is the case of Union of India v. K.L. Taneja and other similar cases [WP(C) No. 8102/2012] decided by the Delhi High Court on 12.04.2013. In this judgment which has great persuasive value, after analyzing many cases on this point, at Para-21, it has been held as follows:“21. The cornucopia of case law above noted brings out the position:(i) Service Jurisprudence does not recognize re…
31. In the light of the authorities cited above which is found acceptable, this Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner has not been able to make out a case as prayed for in this petition. The same is hereby rejected.
32. Petition disposed of. No costs. Judge Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:761
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 256 of 2021
Date of Decision: 22.08.2024
Shri. Omingchael Khardewsaw
Aged about 56 years
Son of Shri. Osparwell Lyngkhoi
R/o Upper New Nongstoin-II, village-Nongstoin-793119,
West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
……..Writ Petitioner
-Versus1. State of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary, Shillong
2. Deputy Commissioner,
Mawkyrwat
South
West
Khasi
Hills
District,
3. Block Development Officer Ranikor C&RD Block,
South West Khasi Hills Meghalaya
……Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. P. Biswakarma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Abraham, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:761
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner, working as a Gram Sevak having been
appointed on 09.03.1988 on Adhoc basis and later being regularised in
the same post vide office order dated 27.07.1990, his service thereafter
was confirmed against the permanent post of Gram Sevak on the
strength of the order dated 07.03.2000, has now approached this Court
with this instant writ petition seeking promotion to the higher post of
Senior Gram Sevak w.e.f. the year 2019.
2.
According to Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel
appearing for the petitioner, the case of the petitioner is that he was
appointed as Gram Sevak in the then united District of West Khasi Hills
having gone through the regular process of appointment.
3.
In the year 2013, the Deputy Commissioner, West Khasi Hills
District had published a draft inter se seniority list in respect of Gram
Sevaks and the name of the petitioner figured at serial number 15 of
such gradation list.
4.
However, in the meantime, a new District, named as South
West Khasi Hills District was carved out of the West Khasi Hills
District and those employees, including the petitioner herein who were
holding the post of Gram Sevak in the undivided West Khasi Hills
District were shifted to the new district and continued to work as Gram
Sevak in the said district.
5.
There being no promotional avenue available to the petitioner
2024:MLHC:761
and others holding the post of Gram Sevak, the Assured Career
Progression Scheme (ACPS) was extended to the petitioner which was
conveyed to him and others vide Office Order dated 30.07.2015,
wherein he was granted the 1st financial upgradation w.e.f. 22.02.2010.
6.
It is also the submission of the learned Sr. counsel that the
petitioner in course of his service had also officiated as Senior Gram
Sevak w.e.f. 01.11.2017 on retirement of Shri. G.J. Sangma as Senior
Gram Sevak, Ranikor C&RD Block. Again, on Shri. W. Shylla being
appointed as Senior Gram Sevak, Ranikor in 2019, whereupon he
retired from service in the year 2019 itself the petitioner was once again
directed to officiate as Senior Gram Sevak, Ranikor.
7.
The learned Sr. counsel went on to submit that within the
South West Khasi Hills District as on November and December 2019,
on the retirement of Shri. Brassly Thabah as Senior Gram Sevak of
Mawkyrwat C&RD Block on 30.11.2019 two posts of Senior Gram
Sevak that is one for Mawkyrwat and another for Ranikor C&RD Block
are lying vacant and the petitioner being No. 2 in the inter se seniority
list of Gram Sevak of South West Khasi Hills District had anticipated
that he would be promoted to the post of Senior Gram Sevak but was
never promoted as such in spite of having served as Gram Sevak for 33
years.
8.
The learned Sr. counsel has submitted that as per Rule No. 7
Sub-Rule 3 of “The Meghalaya Community and Rural Development
Gram Sevaks/Gram Sevikas Services Rules, 2008” it is provided that
appointment to the post in the category (iii) under A & B of Sub-Rule
2024:MLHC:761
(1) of Rule 4 shall be made by promotion from the select list approved
under Sub-Rule (4) of Rule 10 from amongst the members of the
service holding the post of Gram Sevak/Gram Sevika who have
rendered not less than 5(five) years of continuous service in the post on
the first day of the year in which the selection is made. The petitioner in
spite of serving for almost 33 years in the same post has not been
considered for promotion, reiterates the learned Sr. counsel.
9.
The petitioner has then made a representation dated
17.05.2021 before the relevant authority that is the Deputy
Commissioner, South West Khasi Hills District with a prayer for
consideration of his promotion on the ground that a vacancy in the post
of Senior Gram Sevak is lying vacant in the Ranikor C&RD Block as
well as another in Mawkyrwat C&RD Block. In the said representation
he has also pointed out that till date no updated gradation list as per the
rules has been brought out and the only gradation list that was issued
was dated 06.06.2008 applicable to the then parental district of West
Khasi Hills and since the bifurcation of South West Khasi Hills District
was made, no separate gradation list for the new district has been
brought out to the detriment of all the serving Gram Sevaks including
the petitioner.
10.
The petitioner has however admitted that vide office order
dated 12.07.2021 a draft of seniority list as on 12.07.2021 in respect of
the Gram Sevaks and Gram Sevikas under the office of the Block
Development Officer, Mawkyrwat and Block Development Officer,
Ranikor within the South West Khasi Hills District was published with
the name of the petitioner figuring at Sl. No. 1 of the said list.
2024:MLHC:761
11.
It is also the submission of the learned Sr. counsel that the
respondent/Deputy Commissioner, South West Khasi Hills District vide
office memorandum dated 15.07.2021 has granted the 3rd Financial
Upgradation under the Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP)
Scheme to some employees including the petitioner, who apparently
have not been promoted till then. However, the petitioner being entitled
to promotion under the Rules has not yet availed such financial
upgradation.
12.
The learned Sr. counsel has contended that the relevant
respondent authorities have not considered the fact that in order of
seniority, when Shri. G.J. Sangma retired on 29.02.2016 as the Senior
Gram Sevak the second senior most person, that is, Shri. W. Shylla who
was already working as Gram Sevak Grade-I since 2011 should have
been promoted as Senior Gram Sevak and in that order, the petitioner
would have been promoted as Gram Sevak (Grade-I) in the year 2016
itself and accordingly, in due course as per the provision of the relevant
rules in the later part of 2021 on completion of 5(five) years of service
and on two posts of Senior Gram Sevak being vacant, the petitioner
would have been promoted as Senior Gram Sevak. This chain of events
however did not occur solely on the ground that no Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) was held at the relevant point of time, and
although as contended by the respondent that the DPC was held on
31.01.2019 but the same could not be concluded due to non-receipt of
ACRs of the eligible Gram Sevaks including the petitioner, the
petitioner and other eligible employees not being responsible for such
state of affairs, non-consideration of promotion to the petitioner at the
2024:MLHC:761
relevant point of time is a denial of his fundamental and legal rights.
13.
The learned Sr. counsel has accordingly prayed that this
petition may be allowed and the petitioner who has since retired from
service in the month of September 2023 may be granted notional
promotion with all consequential financial benefits.
14.
In support of his case the learned Sr. counsel has cited the
following authorities:
i.
Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab, (1999) 7 SCC 209, para
22;
ii.
State of Mysore v. C.R. Sheshadri, (1974) 4 SCC 308,
para 1 & 2;
iii.
P.N. Premachandran v. State of Kerela, (2004) 1 SCC
245, para 9;
iv.
Union of India v. Hemraj Singh Chauhan, (2010) 4 SCC
290, para 37 & 38.
15.
Per contra, Mr. H. Abraham, learned GA appearing for the
State respondent in his submission has not contradicted the statement of
facts made as regard the appointment of the petitioner to the post of
Gram Sevak in the year 1988 and that his services against the
permanent post of Gram Sevak was confirmed vide relevant order dated
07.03.2000. There is also no denial of the fact that on the bifurcation of
the erstwhile West Khasi Hills District into two districts that is, the
present West Khasi Hills District and South West Khasi Hills District
2024:MLHC:761
the petitioner was relocated to serve as Gram Sevak in the office of
Block Development Officer, Ranikor C&RD Block.
16.
The learned GA has also submitted that the petitioner has been
allowed to officiate as Senior Gram Sevak in the Ranikor C&RD Block
in the first instance on the post being left vacant upon the then
incumbent having retired. Again, for the second time the petitioner was
allowed to officiate in the post of Gram Sevak in view of the retirement
of the then Senior Gram Sevak, Shri. W. Shylla.
17.
As to the contention of the petitioner that he was not
considered for promotion at the relevant period, that is in the year 2019
when there are two vacant posts of Senior Gram Sevak, being eligible
to the same by virtue of his seniority, the learned GA has submitted that
in fact the DPC to consider the promotion of the eligible candidates
from amongst the Gram Sevak was conducted on 31.01.2019, however
the same could not be completed as some of the Annual Confidential
Reports of the candidates for the year 2016-17 are found to be
inadequate and as such any move for promotion was put on hold till the
process is complete.
18.
Eventually, on 27.09.2021 the DPC was once again convened
to consider the promotion of Gram Sevak and in compliance with the
relevant rules of “The Meghalaya Community and Rural Development
Gram Sevaks/Gram Sevikas Services Rules, 2008”, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Gram Sevak (Grade-I) from the post of Gram
Sevak. As per the said Service Rules, Rule 7(3) provides for the mode
of promotion of those members of the service holding the post of Gram
2024:MLHC:761
Sevak/Gram Sevika and such Rules stipulates that an eligible candidate
would be considered for selection only if he/she has rendered not less
than 5(five) years of continuous service in the post on the first day of
the year in which the selection is made.
19.
It is the contention of the learned GA that the petitioner was
promoted as Gram Sevak (Grade-I) by virtue of the office order
No.SWK/ESTT-27/2012/Vol-II/41 dated 28.09.2021 and as such he
could not have been promoted to the post of Senior Gram Sevak since
he has not completed 5(five) years of continuous service in that post
having retired from service in the month of September 2023.
20.
Another contention raised by the learned GA is that there is no
discrimination made by the Department or the Government for that
matter since in course of his tenure of service he was also granted
financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme vide relevant order
No.SWK/ESTT/50/2013/66 dated 30.07.2015 when in fact by the said
order the petitioner was granted two financial upgradations that is the
first and second ACP. Again, vide office order dated 15.07.2021, the
Deputy Commissioner, South West Khasi Hills District had conveyed
the grant of the 3rd Financial Upgradation under the Modified Assured
Career Progression (MACP) Scheme.
21.
The learned GA has finally submitted that the claim of the
petitioner is without any basis and this petition being devoid of merit
may be dismissed as such.
22.
From the facts and circumstances which have emerged from
the argument advanced by the learned counsels of the respective
2024:MLHC:761
parties, what can be understood is that the petitioner having been in
service for about 33 years or so, he is entitled to be promoted in the
normal course of his employment, but the same was denied to him.
23.
According to the service rules applicable to the petitioner, that
is, “The Meghalaya Community and Rural Development Gram
Sevaks/Gram Sevikas Services Rules, 2008”, at Rule 4 is found the
hierarchy of posts within the service, the categories of post starts with
Gram Sevaks/Sevikas, the next higher post being Gram Sevaks (GradeI) and the next being Senior Gram Sevak and at the top of this hierarchy
is the post of Extension Officers (General).
24.
As has been pointed out by the learned counsels, the relevant
rule which deals with the issue of promotion is Rule 7 under the
heading “Method of Recruitment”. It is pertinent to note that the
eligibility condition for promotion from one stage to the next higher
stage is continuous service of 5(five) years in a particular post. For
example, for a Gram Sevak to be promoted to the next higher post of
Gram Sevak (Grade-I), he has to be in continuous service as a Gram
Sevak for the preceding five years. Nothing in the rules is found that a
Gram Sevak even by dint of his prolonged stagnation in that post
exceeding the stipulated five years period, he can be considered for
promotion to the next higher post than the one he ought to have been
promoted, again as an illustration, one can imagine a situation where a
Gram Sevak who was not given promotion after being in the said post
for five year or more, perhaps even for ten years or so, if considered
for promotion at a later period of time, be eligible to get double
promotion on this ground alone as the rules does not provide for the
2024:MLHC:761
same.
25.
What is also noticed is that the petitioner throughout has
sought for promotion to the post of Senior Gram Sevak when at the
relevant period he was still holding the post of Gram Sevak, the next
promotional post being that of Gram Sevak (Grade-I). It is also the
prayer of the petitioner that since the District Departmental Promotion
Committee has not been constituted the same ought to be constituted
within a period of three months.
26.
Again, on perusal of this petition it is seen that the same was
filed on 22.09.2021. The State respondent in its affidavit-in-opposition
filed through the respondent No. 2 at para 14 of the same has stated that
the earlier DPC could not be convened due to unavailability of adequate
ACRs of the petitioner however on 27.09.2021, the DPC was convened
for promotion of Gram Sevak and accordingly the petitioner being
found qualified was promoted to the post of Gram Sevak (Grade-I) the
same being confirmed vide order No.SWK/ESTT-27/2012/Vol-II/41
dated 28.09.2021. Such promotion being a subsequent event after the
filing of this petition, the same was not challenged by the petitioner to
the extent that a prayer for amendment of the petition to incorporate
such challenge was never made by the petitioner. At most, the petitioner
at para 8 of his rejoinder affidavit has only indicated that his promotion
as Gram Sevak (Grade-I) is highly belated which ought to have taken
place in the year 2016. This however, would not dilute the fact that as
on 28.09.2021, the petitioner has been promoted to the post of Gram
Sevak (Grade-I). According to the 2008 Rules (supra) he could only be
considered for promotion to the post of Senior Gram Sevak after a
2024:MLHC:761
period of continuous service of 5(five) years in the post of Gram Sevak
(Grade-I).
27.
It may also be pointed out that during the tenure of his service
when the petitioner was stagnated in the post of Gram Sevak, he was
accorded two financial upgradations under the ACP Scheme and again
on 15.07.2021 he was granted the 3rd Financial Upgradation under the
Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP) Scheme. Therefore, it
cannot be said that the petitioner was put at a disadvantaged situation in
his service career as far as adequate financial benefits are concerned.
28.
In the case of Hemraj Singh Chauhan (supra) cited by the
learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner at para 38 of the same the
observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court is that the legitimate
expectation of the respondents therein to be considered for promotion
has been defeated by the unreasonable inaction on the part of the
Government which stood in the way of the respondents’ chances of
promotion. In this instant case as has been observed herein above, the
Government in spite of delay in the constitution of the DPC (that too,
not without reasons), has granted regular financial upgradations to the
petitioner and as such, the issue of legitimate expectation would not be
applicable to his case.
29.
Again, in the case of P.N. Premachandran (supra) the petitioner
has raised the issue of retrospective promotion being applicable to him
as is noticed in the observation made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court at
para 7 of this case under the facts and circumstances of that case, which
in view of the factual situation in the case of the petitioner the same
2024:MLHC:761
ratio would not apply. Even reliance of the petitioner in the case of C.R.
Sheshadri (supra), the proposition propounded by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court at para 1 and 2 of the same, speaking of notional promotion, the
said principle would not be applicable to the petitioner under the facts
and circumstances of his case.
30.
In the case of Ravikumar Dhansukhlal Maheta & Anr. v. State
of Gujarat & Ors., reported in 2024 SCC Online 972, para 81, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that “…no government servant
can claim promotion as their right because the Constitution does not
prescribe criteria for filling seats in promotional posts…”. A coordinate
bench of this Court in the case of Andrew Shabong & Ors. v. State of
Meghalaya & Ors. reported in 2023 SCC Online Meg 12 at para 10 has
also observed as follows:
“10. Promotion to a higher post in the instant case is not a case
of functional promotion, but as can be seen involves a process
of selection and recommendation by a duly constituted DPC. A
mere existence of a vacancy therefore, will not create a vested
right for an eligible employee to claim for appointment on
promotion to the said post, especially when the same has to be
finalized through a selection process. A case that is relevant
and has a bearing on the point in issue wherein leading cases
have been digested is the case of Union of India v. K.L. Taneja
and other similar cases [WP(C) No. 8102/2012] decided by the
Delhi High Court on 12.04.2013. In this judgment which has
great persuasive value, after analyzing many cases on this
point, at Para-21, it has been held as follows:“21. The cornucopia of case law above noted brings out
the position:(i)
Service Jurisprudence does not recognize
retrospective promotion i.e. a promotion from a
back date.
2024:MLHC:761
(ii) If there exists a rule authorizing the Executive to
accord promotion from a retrospective date, a
decision to grant promotion from a retrospective
date would be valid because of a power existing to
do so.
(iii) Since mala fides taints any exercise of power or an
act done, requiring the person wronged to be placed
in the position the person would find himself but
for the mala fide and tainted exercise of power or
the act, promotion from a retrospective date can be
granted if delay in promotion is found attributable
to a mala fide act i.e. deliberately delaying holding
DPC, depriving eligible candidates the right to be
promoted causing prejudice.
(iv) If due to administrative reasons DPC cannot be
held in a year and there is no taint of malice, no
retrospective promotion can be made.”
31.
In the light of the authorities cited above which is found
acceptable, this Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner
has not been able to make out a case as prayed for in this petition. The
same is hereby rejected.
32.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2024.08.22 17:56:46
PDT
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review