The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. It further appears from the submissions of the parties that, previously, several revisional applications have been disposed of by this court and the co-ordinate bench. Therefore, this court finds this revisional application has merit and is eligible to be allowed.
22. Accordingly, CRR 3533 of 2017 is, thus, allowed. Connected applications, if any, are also thus disposed of.
23. Consequently, the proceeding of Case No. C/319 of 2016 under Sections 14(1A), 14A (1) and 14(2A) of the Employees’ Provident Fund & Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 pending before the Court of the Learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, 1 st Court, Barrackpore is hereby quashed and Order passed therein dated July 12, 2016 by which the Learned Magistrate took cognizance against the present petitioners is also set aside.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
C.R.R. 3533 of 2017
Om Prakash Saxena & Others
Versus
State of West Bengal & Another
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Pawan Kumar Gupta, Adv.
Mr. Awadesh Kr. Rai, Adv.
Ms. Sofia Nesar, Adv.
Mr. Santanu Sett, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Saryati Datta, Adv.
Mr. Tirupati Mukherjee, Adv.
Heard on
:
02.01.2026
Judgment on
:
14.01.2026
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J:
1.
The instant Criminal Revisional application has been filed under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, by the
petitioners who are the accused persons, seeking quashing of the
proceeding being Case No. C/319 of 2016 under Sections 14(1A),
14A(1) and 14(2A) of the Employees’ Provident Fund & Miscellaneous
Provisions Act, 1952, pending before the Court of the Learned
Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, 1st Court, Barrackpore, including the
Order dated July 12, 2016. By the said order, the Learned Magistrate
took cognizance of the offences against the present petitioners.
FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
The brief facts, leading to filing of this instant Criminal Revisional
application, are that one Sanjay Biswas, Enforcement Officer,
Employees’
Provident
Fund
Organization,
Sub-Regional
Office,
Barrackpore lodged a petition of complaint against the present
petitioners contending therein that the accused persons, being the
Directors, were in charge of establishment, namely, M/s Bengal
Waterproof Limited having its registered officer at “MMS Chambers”,
1st Floor, 4A, Council House Street, Kolkata – 700 001 and were
responsible for the conduct of its business. In the discharge of such
responsibilities, they took part in the running of the business. They
are bound to comply with the provisions of the Employees’ Provident
Fund & Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 and the scheme in
respect of the said establishment. The accused persons, however,
failed to submit the monthly returns for the period 08/2013 to
10/2013 under the provisions of Clause 16 of Appendix “A” to
Paragraph 27AA of the Employees’ Provident Fund Scheme, 1952.
Therefore,
they
committed
an
offence
under
Sections
14(1)/14(1A)/14(1B)/14(2A)/14A (1)/14A (2)/14AA of the Employees’
Provident Fund & Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952.
3.
It is the contention of the petitioners that the complaint, made by the
Officer is totally false and fabricated. No such offence has been
committed by the present petitioners. The opposite party no. 2 has
suppressed the entire material facts before the Learned Magistrate to
the effect that M/s Bengal Waterproof Limited has been nonoperational since 2013. All the employees of the said establishment
resigned from the establishment in the month of November, 2011.
The fact of resignation was also brought to the notice of the opposite
party no. 2. Accordingly, the opposite party no. 2 has released the
funds held under the Provident Fund deposit scheme for final
settlement of the fund’s dues to all the employees. All payments have
been made to all the employees according to their entitlements. Not a
single complaint has been made by any of the employees of the said
establishment against the petitioners. As such, the entire complaint
is false and misconceived and proceeding therein is liable to be
quashed at the threshold. After receiving such petition of complaint,
the Learned Magistrate took cognizance and issued process against
the present petitioners without applying the statutory provision of
Section 468 of the Cr.P.C. for making a complaint after expiry of the
period
of
limitation.
Hence,
this
instant
Criminal
Revisional
application.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS: 4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the issues raised
herein are substantially identical to those which fell for consideration
before this Court earlier, in CRR 3772 of 2017, with CRR 2963 of
2017, with CRR 3054 of 2017 [Om Prakash Saxena and Ors. v.
State of West Bengal and Anr.], wherein similar prayers of the
petitioners were allowed. A similar set of matters also fell for
consideration before a coordinate bench of this Court, in CRR 2962
of 2017, with CRR 3051 of 2017 [Om Prakash Saxena and Ors.
v. State of West Bengal and Anr.] etc., wherein the Co-ordinate
Bench has also allowed the prayer of the petitioners. Considering the
absence of any distinguishing facts, learned counsel has urged this
Court to rely on these decisions and adopt the same reasoning and
allow the prayer of the petitioners as similar as the order passed in
the aforesaid cases.
5.
It is further argued that the instant criminal proceeding is initiated
after the expiry of the limitation period. Accordingly, the Order of
taking cognizance, by the Learned Magistrate is barred by limitation
under Section 468 of the Cr.P.C.
6.
Finally, it was submitted that even for the sake of argument, if it is
assumed that the complainant alleges that the establishment has not
submitted the returns on time, the company has deposited the
amount to the provident fund deposit scheme in time. The
establishment could not submit the return because the portal does
not permit the establishment to submit the return in time in view of
the Hon’ble High Court’s order passed in another proceeding being
WP No. 15191(W) of 2011. Prior to lodging of the said complaint, no
opportunity was given to the petitioners to explain the reason as to
why they did not file returns.
7.
It is further submitted that on the similar set of allegations made by
the same complaint against this establishment, this Court in CRR
No. 3262 of 2017 WITH CRR No. 3263 of 2017 (Om Prakash
Saxena & Ors. Vs. The State of West Bengal) disposed of and
quashed the entire proceeding only on the ground that the complaint
is barred by limitation and the Learned Magistrate mechanically had
taken cognizance beyond the period of limitation which is barred
under the provisions of Section 468 of the Cr.P.C.
8.
The learned counsel also drew attention to the constitution of the Adhoc Committee for enhancing coverage and reducing litigation. The
Hon’ble Chairman, Central Board of Trustees, Employees’ Provident
Fund (CBT, EPF) directed the constitution of the above committee
from amongst members of the CBT, EPF to give recommendations for
enhancing coverage and reducing litigation and the said committee
was constituted vide order dated 27.11.2021. For enhancing coverage
and reducing litigation, the following recommendations of the
Committee were approved by CBT in its 230 th meeting:“(i) to ensure a universal social security coverage by enrolling
all employees upto the wage ceiling;
(ii) recommend to Central Government to frame and assign
administration of scheme for Gig and platform workers, to
EPFO;
(iii) Regional Committees to be scheduled by a fixed calendar,
to meet at least four times every year with standing agenda
on coverage and litigations;
(iv) to prepare a comprehensive legal framework for litigation
management.
(v) withdraw prosecutions related to non-filing of returns
and/or non-submission of KYC; and
(vi) rationalise the rate of damages.”
9.
Therefore, a proposal was given to withdraw the prosecution, with
regard to non-filing of returns and/or non-submission of KYC
because the Committee noted that several prosecutions were going on
in respect of default of non-filing of the return and non-submission of
KYC in different counts and finally the Committee recommended that
the Board may consider the proposal to review the case to withdraw
prosecutions related to non-filing of the returns and/or nonsubmission of KYC to avoid the waste of the Government Exchequer.
As such, the present complaint appears merely an attempt to harass
the present petitioners. If the said proceeding is allowed to be
continued, it would amount to a sheer abuse of process of law and for
securing the ends of justice, the entire proceeding is liable to be
quashed.
10. None appears on behalf of the opposite party no. 2 at the time of call
and no accommodation was sought for.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE STATE:11. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State candidly and on his
usual fairness also conceded that in the identical and similarly
situated several cases, this bench and the co-ordinate bench have
passed the judgment and quashed the proceedings on the ground
that the complaint was made beyond the period of limitation as
prescribed under Section 468 of the Cr.P.C. He finally left the matter
to the discretion of this court.
DISCUSSIONS, ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION OF THIS COURT:
12. After considering the submissions of learned counsels for the parties
and upon perusal of the materials on record, this Court finds that the
opposite party no. 2 has filed a petition of complaint before the
Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate at Barrackpore on
09.06.2016 against the present petitioners, alleging that they were
Directors of M/s Bengal Waterproof Limited. In the said complaint,
paragraph nos. 3, 4, and 5 are mentioned as under: “3.
That
the
accused
–
being
employers
of
the
establishment failed to submit monthly returns in Form5(PS) for the period 08/2013 to 10/2013 under the provision
of clause 16 of Appendix “A” to paragraph 27AA of the EPF
Scheme, 1952. They have thus committed offences under
Section 14(1A), 14A (1), 14(1B), 14(2), 14 [(2A)] read with
paragraph 76 of the EPFS’52, read with paragraph 41(b) of
EPFS’71, read with paragraph 42(b) of EPS’95 & read with
paragraph 29(b) of the EDLI’76.
4. That I further submit that as the accused Nos. one to six
were during the relevant period in charge of the said
establishment and were responsible to it for the conduct of its
business, they have in view of the facts and circumstances
stated above committed offences under Section 14(1A) read
with Section 14A (1) & 14[(2A)] of the Act’52.
5. That I submit that the accused Nos. one to six are
Directors of the said establishment which is a establishment
within the meaning of the said Act and the offence(s)
mentioned above have been committed by the company with
the consent or connivance of or is attributable to neglect on
part
of
Director(s)/Manager/Secretary/Officer(s)/Members
such
of
the
Board of Trustee of the Company and as such they are
punishable under Section 14(1A) and 14(1B) read with
Section 14A(2) of the Act, 1952.”
13. Clause 16 of Appendix “A” enumerates “The Board of Trustees and
the employer shall file such returns monthly/annually as may be
prescribed by the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation within the
specified time limit, failing which it will be deemed as a default and
the Board of Trustees and employer will jointly and separately be
liable for suitable penal action by the Employees’ Provident Fund
Organisation.”
14. Therefore, according to this provision, the Board of Trustees of the
employer shall file returns monthly/annually as prescribed by the
Employees Provident Fund organisation within a specific time limit. It
has been alleged that the petitioners have not complied with the
provisions and have failed to file returns for the aforesaid period in
time.
15. From the perusal of the order passed by the Learned Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate at Barrackpore dated 12.07.2016, it appears the
Learned Magistrate has taken cognizance of the offence punishable
under Sections 14(1A), 14A(1) and 14(2A) of the Employees’ Provident
Fund & Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. However, not a single
reason, whatsoever has been recorded in the said order, and simply
cognizance was taken on the basis of the petition of complaint.
16. The alleged offence of non-filing of returns was committed in the year
2013, but the complaint was lodged in the year 2016. Section 468 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has specified that the
Magistrate can take cognizance of offence within one year, if the
offence is punishable with imprisonment for a term not exceeding one
year. The period of limitation mentioned in Section 468 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 as follows: “468. Bar to taking cognizance after lapse of the
period of limitation. — (1) Except as otherwise provided
elsewhere in this code, no court shall take cognizance of an
offence of the category specified in sub-section (2), after the
expiry of the period of limitation.
(2) The period of limitation shall be—
(a) six months, if the offence is punishable with fine only;
(b) one year, if the offence is punishable with imprisonment
for a term not exceeding one year;
(c) three years, if the offence is punishable with imprisonment
for a term of exceeding one year but not exceeding three
years.”
17. Upon perusal of the aforesaid provision, it is revealed that the
Learned Magistrate has taken cognizance beyond the period of
limitation, which is barred by the provision of Section 468 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
18. Learned Magistrate has taken cognizance of offence beyond the
period of limitation and the order of taking cognizance under Sections
14(1A), 14A(1) and 14(2A) of the Employees’ Provident Fund &
Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, without assigning any reason, is
bad in law.
19. It is relevant to mention that the Ad-hoc Committee constituted upon
the direction of the Hon’ble Chairman, Central Board of Trustees,
Employees’ Provident Fund, is of the view that the complaint lodged
by the Authority with regard to non-filing of returns and submission
of KYC should be withdrawn to reduce the litigation of Employees
Provident Fund Organization and to save the Government Exchequer.
20. Considering the above facts and circumstances, this Court is of the
view that if the proceeding is allowed to be continued, it would be a
futile exercise. Every possibility of conviction is remote and bleak,
and continuation of such criminal cases would put the accused to
great oppression and prejudice and extreme injustice would be
caused to them by not quashing the criminal proceeding.
21. It further appears from the submissions of the parties that,
previously, several revisional applications have been disposed of by
this court and the co-ordinate bench. Therefore, this court finds this
revisional application has merit and is eligible to be allowed.
22. Accordingly, CRR 3533 of 2017 is, thus, allowed. Connected
applications, if any, are also thus disposed of.
23. Consequently, the proceeding of Case No. C/319 of 2016 under
Sections 14(1A), 14A (1) and 14(2A) of the Employees’ Provident Fund
& Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 pending before the Court of the
Learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, 1 st Court, Barrackpore is
hereby quashed and Order passed therein dated July 12, 2016 by
which the Learned Magistrate took cognizance against the present
petitioners is also set aside.
24. Case Diary, if any, is to be returned to the learned Advocate for the
State.
25. Let a copy of this Judgment and Order be sent to the Learned Court
below for information.
26. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
27. All parties will act on the server copies of this Judgment and Order
uploaded on the official website of this Hon’ble High Court.
28. Urgent photostat certified copy of this Judgment and Order, if applied
for, is to be given as expeditiously to the parties on compliance of all
legal formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J)
P. Adak (P.A.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review