Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: WP(C) No. 71/2022
CM No. 1890/2026
Reserved on : 08.09.2026
Pronounced on :18.09.2026
Uploaded on:18.09.2026
Om Parkash Shan, age 78 years
S/O Sh. Dharm Singh,
R/O Village Kukerwas,
Tehsil Dhrabshalla,
District Kishtwar.
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Achal Sharma, Advocate
Vs.
1. UT of J&K through Commissioner/
Secretary, Animal/Sheep Husbandry
Department,
Civil
secretariat,
Jammu/ Srinagar.
2. Director,
Sheep Husbandry Department,
Jammu.
3. District
Sheep
Husbandry
Department, Kishtwar.
4. Deputy Commissioner, Kishtwar.
…. Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, through the medium of the present petition, has sought
a direction upon the respondents to release the assessed rent in his
favour in respect of the house comprising three rooms and one
WP(C) No.71/2022
verandah, situated at Village Kukerwas, Tehsil Dhrabshalla, District
Kishtwar.
2. According to the case of the petitioner, the Sheep Husbandry
Department started a Sheep Extension Centre at Loundri in the year
1976, and the said Centre started functioning in the house belonging
to the father of the petitioner. In January 1982, the Centre started
functioning in a pucca house/building belonging to the petitioner, and
by that time, he was separated from the family. It has been submitted
that the respondent-department was occupying three rooms and one
verandah of his house. When the rent was not being assessed by the
respondents, the petitioner approached them, whereafter, vide
communication dated 19.04.2014, respondent No. 3 made a request to
the Executive Engineer, R&B Division, Kishtwar, to assess the rent of
the building with effect from 01.01.1982. Along with the said
communication, a rough sketch of the building in occupation of
respondent No. 4 was also annexed. Pursuant thereto, respondent No.
2, who happens to be the Chairman of the District Rent Assessment
Committee, made assessment of the rent in respect of the building of
the petitioner vide its communication bearing No. DCQ/SQ/525-49/14
dated 22.09.2014. Vide the said communication, the District Rent
Assessment Committee made an assessment of 31 buildings,
including the building of the petitioner, which was occupied by the
respondent-department.
3. It has been submitted that vide communication dated 20.04.2015,
respondent No. 3 brought to the notice of respondent No. 2, the order
regarding assessment of the rent made by the District Rent
WP(C) No.71/2022
Assessment Committee with a request to settle case of the petitioner.
It has been further submitted that despite clear-cut recommendations,
the assessed rent was never released in favour of the petitioner, which
prompted him to approach the respondents as well as the Minister
concerned, seeking release of the arrears of rent. When nothing was
done by the respondents, the petitioner was compelled to file the
instant writ petition.
4. The respondents have filed objections to the writ petition, in which it
has been submitted that the rent in favour of father of the petitioner,
Shri Dharam Singh, was drawn for the period from January 1982 to
February 2000. While admitting the authenticity of the documents
placed on record by the petitioner along with the writ petition, the
respondents have submitted that the question of assessment and
payment of rent in favour of the petitioner does not arise, as the
amount due to the petitioner has already been paid to him and the
premises was vacated in the year 2016.
5. It seems that during pendency of the writ petition, the respondents
sought permission to file a supplementary affidavit along with the
documents. The permission was accorded, and the respondents filed
the supplementary affidavit along with the documents annexed
thereto.
6. In the supplementary affidavit, the respondents have submitted that
when the petitioner approached for release of house rent in respect of
the accommodation occupied by the respondent-department for the
establishment of Sheep Extension Centre at Loundri with effect from
January 1982 to March 2016, a Committee was constituted by
WP(C) No.71/2022
Director, Sheep Husbandry Department, Jammu, vide Order No. 02SHDJ of 2018 dated 03.04.2018, to conduct a thorough inquiry into
the matter. It has been submitted that the Committee conducted a
thorough inquiry into the matter, and its members also visited the area
on 16.04.2018 and 17.04.2018. As per the report of the Committee,
the Sheep Extension Centre, Loundri, is presently functioning in the
house of Nissar Ahmed, as the Centre was shifted from the house of
the petitioner on 30.03.2016 on public demand.
7. It has been submitted that, after verifying the available records, it was
revealed that the rent had been released in favour of Dharam Singh,
Mohan Lal and Om Parkash from time to time. According to the
respondents, the rent for the period from January 1982 to February
2000 has been released in favour of Dharam Singh, father of the
petitioner, whereafter, on the basis of the attorney dated 25.02.1997
executed by Dharam Singh in favour of his son, namely, Mohan Lal,
the rent was released in favour of Mohan Lal, who happens to be the
brother of the petitioner, with effect from March 2000 to May 2012. It
has been further submitted that the rent with effect from June 2012 to
March 2016 has been released in favour of the petitioner. A copy of
the disbursement sheet has been annexed with the supplementary
affidavit.
8. According to the respondents, during the inquiry, the petitioner
produced the title verification certificate issued by the Tehsildar,
Drabshalla, dated 14.08.2015, and as per the said certificate, three
rooms and one verandah of the house of the petitioner were under the
occupation of the Sheep Husbandry Department. He produced a copy
WP(C) No.71/2022
of the attorney executed by Mohan Lal in his favour on 07.01.2018. It
has been submitted that the District Sheep Husbandry Officer,
Kishtwar, vide communication dated 24.02.2016, intimated that only
one room was occupied by the Department and that the rent had been
drawn in respect of the building at the rate of Rs. 95/- per month up to
March 2016. It has also been submitted that the District Sheep
Husbandry Officer, Kishtwar, had issued instructions to all the
employees posted at different Sheep Husbandry Centres to vacate all
such accommodations where the rent exceeded Rs. 300/- per month.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and I have also gone
through the pleadings and the documents placed on record by the
parties.
10.From the pleadings of the parties and the documents placed on record,
it comes to fore that the premises belonging to the petitioner/his
family, which includes his father and brother, situated at Loundri, was
occupied by the respondent-department for operating the Sheep
Extension Centre with effect from January 1982. To this extent, there
is no dispute between the parties.
11.According to the respondent-department, only one room of the
premises was occupied by it for operating the said Centre, whereas it
is the positive case of the petitioner that the Centre was functioning
from three rooms and one verandah of the building belonging to the
petitioner. To substantiate this fact, the petitioner has placed on record
a copy of the communication dated 19.04.2014 addressed by
respondent No. 3 to the Executive Engineer, R&B Division, Kishtwar,
which is accompanied by a rough sketch of the portion of the building
WP(C) No.71/2022
occupied by the respondent-department. In the said rough sketch, it
has been certified that the department has occupied three rooms and
one verandah for the Sheep Extension Centre, Loundri, belonging to
the petitioner. The certificate is signed by the District Sheep
Husbandry Officer, Kishtwar, and is countersigned by the Assistant
Executive Engineer of the concerned Sub-Division. In the objections
filed by the respondents, the authenticity of this communication has
not been disputed by them.
12.While filing the supplementary affidavit, the respondents have taken a
stand that, as per the report of the Stock Assistant, Sheep Extension
Centre, Loundri, only one room has been occupied by the
respondents, regarding which the rent has been disbursed up to March
2016. The respondents have also placed on record a copy of
communication dated 24.02.2016 of the District Sheep Husbandry
Officer, Kishtwar, according to which instructions have been issued to
the employees posted at different Sheep Extension Centres to vacate
all such accommodations where the rent exceeds Rs. 300/- per month.
13.The respondents, without disputing the authenticity of the
communication dated 19.04.2014 issued by respondent No. 3 and the
certificate of occupancy annexed thereto, cannot now take a different
stand and claim that only one room was under their occupation. The
respondents may have issued instructions to their officials to vacate
those premises where the monthly rent is more than Rs. 300/- per
month, but those instructions, it seems, were issued in February 2016,
and by that time, as per the material on record, the authenticity
whereof has not been disputed by the respondents, the respondent-
WP(C) No.71/2022
department had continued to occupy three rooms and one verandah of
the building belonging to the petitioner right from the year 1982 up to
the date of its vacation in March 2016.
14.Apart from the above, the District Rent Assessment Committee,
Kishtwar, which is headed by the Deputy Commissioner, Kishtwar,
had assessed the rent in respect of the premises of the petitioner,
which was under the occupation of the Sheep Husbandry Department.
The assessment was made vide order dated 22.09.2014 on the basis of
the occupancy certificate issued by the respondent-department. As per
the said order, the rent in respect of the premises of the petitioner was
approved at the rate of Rs. 120/- per month with effect from
01.01.1982 to 31.12.1986, @ Rs. 190/- per month with effect from
01.01.1987 to 30.11.1994, @ Rs. 460/- per month with effect from
01.12.1994 to 28.02.1999, @ Rs. 680/- per month with effect from
01.03.1999 to 31.03.2002, @ Rs. 930/- per month with effect from
01.04.2002 to 30.11.2005, @ Rs. 1,210/- per month with effect from
01.12.2005 to 31.05.2010, @ Rs. 1,730/- per month with effect from
01.06.2010 to 31.05.2013, and Rs. 2,510/- per month with effect from
01.06.2013 onwards. The authenticity of this document is also not in
dispute.
15.On the basis of the aforesaid rent assessment report, respondent No. 3
made a recommendation to respondent No. 2 to release the balance
amount of rent in favour of the petitioner and to allocate the funds in
this regard. In fact, in the said communication, respondent No. 3 made
a reference to the report of his predecessor with regard to the
occupancy of three rooms and one verandah of the house of the
WP(C) No.71/2022
petitioner by the respondent-department since the year 1982. Along
with the said communication, respondent No. 3 annexed the Due
Drawn Statement of Sheep Extension Centre, Loundri, in respect of
the rent of the petitioner, according to which an amount of Rs.
2,82,020/- was outstanding on account of rent in terms of the rent
assessment made by the District Rent Assessment Committee,
Kishtwar. While compiling the said statement, respondent No. 3 took
into account the amount of rent already disbursed in favour of the
petitioner.
16.On the basis of the aforesaid overwhelming material on record,
comprising official communications addressed by the respondentdepartment and the report of the District Rent Assessment Committee,
the mere denial of claim of the petitioner by the respondents on the
basis of the report of the Committee constituted in the year 2018, after
the premises had already been vacated by the respondent-department,
is of no value. It is true that the petitioner and his family members
have received the rent in respect of the premises in question from
January 1982 to March 2016, but the said rent was assessed on the
basis of the pre-revised rates and on the basis that only one room was
in occupation of the respondent-department. The petitioner, in view of
the material on record, is entitled to receive the balance amount of
rent at the enhanced rates as assessed by the District Rent Assessment
Committee vide its order dated 22.09.2014 for three rooms and one
verandah, which, as per the material on record, were in occupation of
the respondent-department.
WP(C) No.71/2022
17.Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed, and the respondents are
directed to calculate the amount of rent due to the petitioner in terms
of the order of the District Rent Assessment Committee dated
22.09.2014 for the period w.e.f. 01.01.1982 up to March 2016. After
deducting the amount already paid to the petitioner/his family, the
balance amount shall be paid to the petitioner after verification of his
title. The entire exercise shall be conducted by the respondents within
a period of two months from the date of this order. In case the amount
due is not paid to the petitioner within the aforesaid period, the same
shall carry interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of this
writ petition till its realization.
18.Disposed of as above along with connected CM(s), if any.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
18.09.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.09.18 16:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
WP(C) No.71/2022
Yes.
No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review