Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 100
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
ATJAMMU
Reserved on 19.08.2026
Pronounced on 27.08.2026
Uploaded on 27.08.2026
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
Om Parkash Kalsotra
Age 86 Years.
S/o Sh. Hari Saran Kalsotra
H. No. 135, Ward No. 4.
Udhampur. Through his Attoreny
Holder Sh. Sanjay Bushan.
.... Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: - Mr. Sunny Mahajan, Advocate.
v/s
1. UT of J&K Through Secretary to
Government, Agriculture Production
and Co-operative and Horticulture,
Government of J&K, Jammu.
2. Director, Horticulture, Planning and
Marketing, Narwal, Jammu.
3. District Development.
Commissioner Udhampur
4. Area Marketing Officer, Horticulture
Planning and marketing Department,
Udhampur.
5. Municipal Council Through
Executive/Chief Executive Officer,
Municipal Council, Udhampur .
6. Kasturi Lal vaid S/o lt. Nand Mahajan
R/o Near, SBI Satani Dhau Road Tehsil
Udhampur, District Udhampur.
7. Sh. Amit Vaid S/o Lt. Sh. Kishori Lal
Vaid
R/o Near SBI, Satani Dhau Road,
Udhampur.
8. Sh. Sachin Mangotra S/o Lt. Sh. Tilak
Raj Mangotra,
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
.... Respondent(s)
R/o Ward No. 05 House No. 51,
Barrian, Near Kali Mata Mandir, Tehsil
Udhampu District Udhampur.
9. Sh. Karun Mahajan S/o Lt. Sh. Sham
Lal Gupta, R/o Ward. No. 09 H No. 30,
Padha Gali, Tehsil Udhampur,District
Udhampur.
Through: - Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA.
Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina, 6 to 9
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, through the present writ petition, seeks allotment of a shop
site at the Fruit and Vegetable Mandi, Kaller Hemmati, Udhampur. His
grievance, in substance, is that despite having applied pursuant to the
notification issued in the year 2004 and despite successive directions of
this Court requiring consideration of his claim, he has been denied
allotment while similarly situated applicants have been accommodated.
2. The controversy has a protracted history. On 14.06.2004, the Director,
Horticulture Planning and Marketing, Jammu, Government of Jammu and
Kashmir, issued a notice inviting applications for allotment of shop sites
at the Fruit and Vegetable Market, Udhampur. The petitioner applied
pursuant thereto. The process culminated on 13.12.2010 in allotment of
85 shop sites.
3. The said allotment became subject matter of several writ petitions,
including OWP No. 1539/2010 filed by the petitioner along with four
others. The stand of the respondents therein was that petitioner No. 1
could not be considered for allotment as he was not a member of the
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
concerned Fruit and Vegetable Association, Udhampur; had not been
identified by the concerned Marketing Manager; had not furnished
particulars of his trade turnover; and was not a direct affectee of the Fruit
and Vegetable Mandi.
4. By judgment dated 29.08.2013, this Court disposed of nine writ petitions,
including the petition filed by the petitioner, with a direction to the
respondents to examine the grievances of the petitioners and pass fresh
orders. Pursuant thereto, the respondents reconsidered the claims of 32
petitioners and, in the year 2014, enhanced the number of allotments from
85 to 109. The petitioner, Om Parkash Kalsotra, was, however, not
allotted a shop site, allegedly on account of insufficiency of documents.
5. Aggrieved, the petitioner instituted OWP No. 766/2014. By judgment
dated 15.10.2019, this Court directed the respondents to re-examine his
case in the light of the prescribed eligibility criteria and the documents
placed on record and, in the event of his being found eligible, to accord
him the same treatment as had been directed in favour of the petitioners in
OWP Nos. 380/2014 and 888/2013.
6. Alleging non-compliance with the aforesaid judgment, the petitioner
instituted contempt proceedings bearing CCP(S) No. 305/2020. During
their pendency, six shop sites were allotted on 12.03.2020. Thereafter, on
19.03.2020, the respondents informed the Court that, out of the five
petitioners whose cases had been examined, only petitioner No. 1 had
been found eligible, whereas the remaining four were found ineligible.
Notwithstanding such finding of eligibility, the petitioner was not allotted
a shop.
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
7. The petitioner's claim was thereafter rejected by communication dated
18.08.2022 on the ground that no space was available in the Fruit and
Vegetable Mandi, Udhampur, and, consequently, allotment of a shop site
in his favour was not possible in the prevailing circumstances. It is this
continued denial of allotment that has led to the institution of the present
petition, WP(C) No. 2349/2022.
8. The case set up by the petitioner is that he had remained eligible
throughout and that his claim was repeatedly overlooked despite
successive directions of this Court. Particular emphasis is laid on the fact
that six shops were allotted on 12.03.2020, whereas his eligibility was
acknowledged only a week thereafter, on 19.03.2020, when the
respondents took the stand that no shop was available. It is further urged
that, notwithstanding the subsequent stand that all available shop sites
stood exhausted, four persons were handed over shops on 22.04.2024.
9. According to the petitioner, the aforesaid sequence of events demonstrates
that his claim was not dealt with fairly and that similarly situated persons
were accorded preferential treatment. He alleges that the respondents
adopted a pick-and-choose approach and discriminated against him on
account of his repeated recourse to judicial proceedings.
10.The respondents contest the petition. Their case is that the petitioner's
eligibility could be established only in the year 2020 and that, by then, no
shop site was available. They further contend that approximately 274
applications had been received, comprising 148 applications from
Udhampur, 109 from Jammu, 5 from Reasi, 9 from Ramban and 3 from
Doda, initially against 85 shops. Upon scrutiny, eligible applicants were
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
allotted shops on 07.02.2014. The petitioner's case, according to them,
could not be considered at that stage as he failed to appear before the
Committee despite notices.
11.The respondents further plead that the Mandi had become overcrowded
and that, by the year 2022, all 119 carved-out shop sites stood allotted. As
regards the six allotments made on 12.03.2020, it is submitted that those
allotments were made in compliance with orders of this Court dated
09.03.2018, 23.04.2018 and 15.10.2019. Likewise, the action dated
22.04.2024 concerning four persons is stated not to constitute fresh
allotment; according to the respondents, those persons had already been
allotted shops in the year 2010 and possession alone was handed over to
them pursuant to subsequent Court orders.
12. During the pendency of the present petition, the four persons who were
handed over shops on 22.04.2024 were impleaded as respondent Nos. 6 to
9. They have also contested the petition.
13. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
14. The material facts are substantially undisputed. The petitioner has been
pursuing his claim since the year 2004 and the present proceedings
constitute the third round of writ litigation. His earlier petitions, OWP
Nos. 1539/2010 and 766/2014, resulted in directions requiring the
respondents to examine his claim. Of particular significance is the
judgment dated 15.10.2019, whereby the respondents were specifically
directed to examine the documents produced by the petitioner and, if he
was found eligible, to accord him the same treatment as the petitioners in
OWP Nos. 380/2014 and 888/2013.
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
15. The petitioner had also asserted in the earlier proceedings that he
deposited an amount of Rs.20,000/- by way of demand draft along with
his application in the year 2004 and that the amount was neither returned
nor his application finally rejected. It was in this backdrop that this Court
considered it appropriate to direct a fresh examination of his eligibility.
16. Pursuant to the judgment dated 15.10.2019, the respondents ultimately
examined the petitioner's case and found him eligible. What assumes
significance, however, is the chronology in which the exercise was
undertaken. Six shop sites were allotted on 12.03.2020, whereas the
petitioner's eligibility was acknowledged only on 19.03.2020, when the
respondents simultaneously took the position that no shop was available
for allotment.
17. The respondents seek to justify the allotments dated 12.03.2020 on the
ground that they were made pursuant to earlier orders of this Court. That
explanation, by itself, does not answer the material issue arising for
consideration, namely, why the petitioner's case, which was also required
to be examined pursuant to the judgment dated 15.10.2019, was not
considered contemporaneously with the cases of the other petitioners
before the available shops were allotted.
18. This aspect assumes greater significance in the light of communication
dated 20.02.2018 addressed by the Deputy Director, Horticulture Planning
and Marketing, Jammu, to the learned Additional Advocate General. The
communication recorded that four shops were then available in the
Udhampur Market and could be allotted to four eligible petitioners, while
the remaining petitioners, if found eligible, could be accommodated in
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
Phase-II of the Market, for which necessary steps had already been
initiated. The communication thus indicates that accommodation of
eligible litigants, including through further development of the Market,
was under contemplation.
19. The governing principle is well settled. In R.D. Shetty v. International
Airport Authority of India, AIR 1979 SC 1628, the Supreme Court
held, in substance, that the State, while dealing with public property or
entering into contractual relations, cannot act arbitrarily or discriminate
between similarly situated persons. State action must conform to a
discernible
standard
founded
upon
reasonableness
and
non-
discrimination. The distribution of State largesse is, therefore, subject to
the discipline of Article 14 of the Constitution.
20. Tested on the aforesaid principle, the manner in which the petitioner's
claim was dealt with does not inspire confidence. The respondents were
under a specific judicial direction dated 15.10.2019 to examine his
eligibility and, if found eligible, to accord him treatment similar to that
extended to the petitioners in OWP Nos. 380/2014 and 888/2013. Yet, his
case was not finally considered until after six shop sites had been allotted
on 12.03.2020. No satisfactory explanation has been placed before this
Court as to why his eligibility could not have been determined before
those allotments were made.
21. The respondents have also taken somewhat inconsistent positions
regarding the petitioner's non-consideration in the year 2014. At one
stage, their case is that he did not satisfy the eligibility requirements; at
another, it is asserted that his claim could not be considered because he
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
failed to appear before the Committee despite notices. These explanations,
viewed in the context of the petitioner's application having remained
pending for years and his deposit of Rs. 20,000/- having admittedly not
been refunded, do not satisfactorily explain why his claim was not finally
determined at the relevant time.
22. The subsequent increase in the number of shop sites is also of relevance.
Initially 85 shops were allotted; the number was thereafter increased to
109 and, according to the respondents themselves, by the year 2022 as
many as 119 carved-out shops had been allotted. The record, as presented
before this Court, does not satisfactorily disclose how the additional ten
shop sites, beyond the 109 earlier allotted, came to be dealt with or
whether the petitioner's claim was considered when those sites became
available.
23. Insofar as the action dated 22.04.2024 is concerned, the respondents
have clarified by way of statement of facts that the four persons concerned
had already been allotted shops in the year 2010 and that only possession
was handed over to them in 2024 pursuant to Court orders. In view of this
clarification, the action dated 22.04.2024 cannot, by itself, be treated as
constituting four fresh allotments. It nevertheless demonstrates that
implementation of earlier allotment rights and judicial directions
continued even at a later stage.
24. The decisive circumstance remains that, when the petitioner's eligibility
was eventually determined pursuant to the judgment dated 15.10.2019, he
was found eligible. Yet the exercise was undertaken only after available
shops had been allotted to other petitioners. The respondents have failed
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
to furnish a satisfactory explanation for not considering his case
contemporaneously with those persons, particularly when his entitlement
to consideration flowed from the same judicial process.
25. The petitioner cannot claim an indefeasible right to allotment merely by
reason of having submitted an application. He was, however,
unquestionably
entitled
to
fair,
timely
and
non-discriminatory
consideration of his claim in accordance with the prescribed criteria and
the directions issued by this Court. The distinction is material. While
eligibility by itself may not confer an absolute right to allotment, an
eligible applicant cannot be deprived of a meaningful opportunity of
consideration by postponing the determination of his claim until the
available sites stand exhausted.
26. The plea of legitimate expectation raised by the petitioner must also be
appreciated in this context. His application remained alive for a
considerable period; the amount deposited by him was not refunded;
successive orders of this Court required examination of his claim; and,
ultimately, the respondents themselves found him eligible. These
circumstances legitimately entitled him to expect that his claim would be
dealt with fairly and on the same footing as those similarly situated. Such
expectation does not translate into an automatic right to allotment, but it
reinforces his right to a fair and non-arbitrary decision-making process.
27. Even if the respondents' contention that the petitioner's eligibility came to
be conclusively established only in the year 2020 is accepted, it does not
explain why the exercise directed by this Court on 15.10.2019 was not
completed before allotments were made on 12.03.2020. Nor does it
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
satisfactorily explain why his application, pending since 2004, remained
unresolved for such an extraordinary period despite repeated litigation and
judicial intervention.
28. Administrative authorities dealing with public property are bound to act
fairly, transparently and consistently. Their discretion cannot be exercised
in a manner that results in similarly situated persons receiving materially
different treatment without a rational basis. Equally, a citizen cannot be
placed at a disadvantage merely because he has resorted to judicial
remedies for enforcement of his claim.
29. Viewed cumulatively, the prolonged pendency of the petitioner's claim,
the successive judicial directions requiring its consideration, the allotment
of available shops immediately before his eligibility was formally
acknowledged, and the absence of a satisfactory explanation for the
timing and manner of such consideration establishes that the petitioner's
case was not dealt with in a fair, timely and transparent manner. The
impugned action, therefore, fails to satisfy the requirements of
reasonableness and non-arbitrariness embodied in Article 14 of the
Constitution.
30. Consequently, the repeated denial of meaningful consideration to the
petitioner, despite the direction contained in the judgment dated
15.10.2019 and his subsequent recognition as an eligible applicant, cannot
be sustained. The matter, therefore, warrants appropriate interference by
this Court so as to remedy the prejudice occasioned to the petitioner by
the arbitrary manner in which his claim has been dealt with.
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
31. For the foregoing reasons, this petition is allowed. A writ of mandamus
is, accordingly, issued directing the respondents to accord meaningful
consideration to the case of the petitioner for allotment of a shop site at
the Vegetable & Fruit Mandi, Udhampur, in accordance with the
applicable rules and policy, and to take a reasoned decision thereon within
a period of six months from the date a copy of this order is made available
to them by the petitioner. The petition is, accordingly, disposed of, along
with all connected applications, if any.
32. In view of the order passed in the main petition, nothing survives in the
contempt petition. Contempt proceedings are closed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
Jammu
27.08.2026
Javid Iqbal.
Whether the judgment is speaking:
Whether the judgment is reportable:
WP(C) No. 2349/2022
C/W
CCP(S) No. 305/2020
Yes.
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review