The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Reverting to the facts of the present case in light of the above aforesaid proposition, it is quite vivid that the petitioner has been served with a show cause notice dated 02.08.1999 (Annexure-P/04) and, to which, he filed his reply/explanation and request for closure of the enquiry proceedings, but thereafter nothing has been done and straightway order dated 31.10.2000 has been passed holding Page No.7 of 8 WPS-10889-2019 him guilty of the misconduct and imposing minor penalties: (i) stoppage of two annual increments with cumulative effect and (ii) recovery for an amount of Rs.76,712/-, which is contrary to the principle of law laid down by this Court in the matter of Ajeet Singh Jat (supra). Mere issuance of show cause notice would not amount to proposal to take action against the delinquent and it would also not amount to serving of imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour on which action is proposed to be taken under Rule 16(1)(a) of the Rules of 1966 and there is complete non-compliance of Rule 16(1)(b) of the said Rules, as no opinion has been recorded by the disciplinary authority that as to why inquiry is not necessary; taking the representation submitted by the Government servant under clause (a) and the record of inquiry, if any, held under clause (b) into consideration. No enquiry was held and nothing further was done and straightway the order has been passed. As s…
10. Even otherwise, there is one more reason for not for not upholding the impugned orders. On the date of the order directing recovery of money i.e. 31.10.2000, the petitioner has already been inflicted with minor penalty of stoppage of 02 annual increments Page No.8 of 8 WPS-10889-2019 with cumulative effect for the said misconduct by the competent authority and, therefore, for one act of misconduct, a Government servant cannot be inflicted with two minor penalties simultaneously, one is withholding of two increments with cumulative effect and another is recovery of Rs.76,712/-, which fall within the meaning of ‘minor penalties’ under Rule 10(iii) and (iv) of the Rules of 1966. As such, imposition of two minor penalties for one act of misconduct cannot stand together and, as such, on this ground also the impugned order of punishment dated 31.10.2000 is liable to be quashed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.1 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
2026:CGHC:977
Digitally
SAIFAN signed by
KHAN SAIFAN
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
KHAN
WPS No. 10889 of 2019
Om Pal Singh Deshwal S/o Late Bhullan Singh Aged About 69 Years
Retd. Deputy Milk Commissioner, R/o A - 11 Priya Darshini Colony,
Nonia Kerval, Chindwada ( M P ), District : Chhindwara, Madhya
Pradesh
... Petitioner
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
Veterinary, Mahanadi Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar Post
Office And Police Station Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar, District - Raipur
Chhattisgarh., District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Secretary, Department Of Veterinary, Mahanadi Mantralaya,
Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar, Post Office And Police Station Naya
Raipur, Atal Nagar, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh., District :
Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Director, Directorate Of Veterinary, Indrawati Bawan, Naya
Raipur, Atal Nagar, Post Office And Police Station Naya Raipur, Atal
Nagar, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh., District : Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
4 - Milk Commissioner, Dairy Development, Raipur Chhattisgarh.,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
[Cause-title taken from Case Information System (CIS)]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
:
Mr. Anuroop Panda, Advocate
For Respondents-State
:
Mr. Sharad Mishra, Panel Lawyer
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Single Bench: Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal
(Order on Board)
07.01.2026
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition under Article 226 of
Page No.2 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
the Constitution of India mainly taking exception of order dated
31.10.2000 (Annexure-P/01), by which, minor penalties under Rules
10 (iii) & (iv) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Classification,
Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 (for short the “Rules of 1966”) have
been imposed upon him and the appeals preferred against the said
punishment order has also been dismissed vide orders dated
30.10.2009 (Annexure-P/02) & 16.09.2019 (Annexure-P/03).
2.
The aforesaid challenge has been made on the following factual
backdrop:
2.1
Initially on 12.01.1972, the petitioner was appointed on the
post of Assistant Milk Distribution Officer with the respondent and,
on 01.05.1974, he was promoted to the post of Shift Manager and
subsequently in the year 1985 as Manager in Government Milk
Society, Rajanandgaon. On 03.01.2000, the services of the petitioner
absorbed in the Department of Veterinary. However, during his
posting as Manager in Government Milk Project, Rajnandgaon, on
02.08.1999, the petitioner was served with a show cause notice
(Annexure-P/04) issued by the competent authority leveling charges
of 5 financial irregularities against him, against which he filed reply
dated
13.09.1999
(Annexure-P/06)
explaining
that
no
irregularities/miss-conduct has been committed by him and the
enquiry proceedings be closed.
2.2
Thereafter, no major or minor enquiry proceeding was
Page No.3 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
conducted in the matter and finally impugned order of punishment
dated 31.10.2000 (Annexure-P/01) has been passed by the competent
authority and direction for stoppage of two annual increments with
cumulative effect and order of recovery for an amount of Rs.76,712/has been issued against the petitioner. Against which, he preferred
an appeal before the appellate authority and same also stood
dismissed vide order dated 30.10.2009. After which, the petitioner
preferred WPS-1656-2010 before this Court and same was disposed
of vide order dated 29.06.2018 with an observation that the order
dated 30.10.2009 (Annexure-P/02) is not sustainable and the matter
was remitted to the appellate authority to decide the appeal of the
petitioner on its merits by dealing all the grounds and contentions
raised by him. Thereafter, the appellant authority again rejected the
appeal
of
the
petitioner
vide
order
dated
16.09.2019
(Annexure-P/03). Challenging the aforesaid punishment order dt
31.10.2000 (Annexure-P/01) and orders passed by the appellate
authority
30.10.2009
(Annexure-P/02)
&
16.09.2019
(Annexure-P/03), the present writ petition has been filed by the
petitioner.
3.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
submits
that
the
respondents are absolutely unjustified in passing the impugned
orders under the facts and circumstances of the present case. He
vehemently argued that the procedure contemplated under Rule
16(1) of the Rules of 1966 for imposing minor penalties has not been
Page No.4 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
complied with and full opportunity to defend his case has not been
afforded to the petitioner. Mere issuance of show case notice would
not amount to providing reasonable opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner in terms of Rule 16(1) of the Rules of 1966. As such, the
impugned order imposing penalties of stoppage of two annual
increments with cumulative effect and order of recovery for an
amount of Rs.76,712/- issued against the petitioner dt. 31.10.2000,
affirmed by the appellant authority vide orders dated 30.10.2009 &
16.09.2019, is bad, illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction and with
authority of law and, therefore, the same is liable to be set aside.
Learned counsel places reliance on the decision of this Court in the
matter Ajeet Singh Jat v. State of Chhattisgarh1.
4.
On the other hand, learned State counsel supported the
impugned orders and prays for dismissal of this petition.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their
rival submission made hereinabove and went through the record
with utmost circumspection.
6.
Rule 10(i) to (iv) of the Rules of 1966 provides for minor
penalties which states as under: “10. Penalties.—The following penalties may, for good
and sufficient reasons and as hereinafter provided, be
imposed on a Government servant, namely:—
Minor penalties :—
(i) Censure;
(ii) Withholding of his promotion;
1 WPS-4980-2009, decided on 01.07.2021
Page No.5 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
(iii) recovery from his pay of the whole or part of
any pecuniary loss caused by him to the
Government by negligence or breach of order;
(iv) withholding of increments
stagnation allowance;”
7.
of
pay
or
Rule 16 of the Rules of 1966 provides procedure for imposing
minor penalties which states as under: “16. Procedure for imposing minor penalties.—(1)
Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 15, no
order imposing on a Government servant any of the
penalties specified in clauses (i) to (iv) of Rule 10 and
Rule 11 shall be made except after(a) informing the Government servant in writing
of the proposal to take action against him and of
the imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour on
which it is proposed to be taken, and giving him a
reasonable
opportunity
of
making
such
representation as he may wish to make against
the proposal;
(b) holding an inquiry in the manner laid down in
sub-rules (3) to (23) of Rule 14, in every case in
which the disciplinary authority is of the opinion
that such inquiry is necessary;
(c) taking the representation, if any, submitted by
the Government servant under clause (a) and the
record of inquiry, if any, held under clause (b) into
consideration;
(d) recording a finding on each imputation of
misconduct or misbehaviour; and
(e) consulting the commission
consultation is necessary.
(1-a) xxx
where
such
xxx xxx
(2) The record of the proceedings in such cases
shall include(i) a copy of the intimation to the Government
servant of the proposal to take action against him;
Page No.6 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
(ii) a copy of the statement of imputation of
misconduct or misbehaviour delivered to him;
(iii) his representation, if any;
(iv) the evidence produced during the inquiry;
(v) the advice of the commission, if any;
(vi) the findings on each imputation of misconduct
or misbehaviour; and
(vii) the orders on the case together with the
reasons therefor.”
8.
A careful perusal of the aforesaid Rule would show that the
punishment of withholding of increment which is minor penalty can
be imposed on any Government servant only after informing him
under Rule 16(1)(a) of the Rules of 1966 in writing of the proposal to
take action against him and of the imputations of misconduct or
misbehaviour on which it is proposed to be taken, and after giving
him a reasonable opportunity to make representation as he may
wish to make against the proposal and after taking into
consideration such representation, if any. Rule 16(1)(a) of the Rules
of 1966 prohibits imposition of any penalty without serving a chargesheet on the delinquent and giving him reasonable opportunity to
defend.
9.
Reverting to the facts of the present case in light of the above
aforesaid proposition, it is quite vivid that the petitioner has been
served with a show cause notice dated 02.08.1999 (Annexure-P/04)
and, to which, he filed his reply/explanation and request for closure
of the enquiry proceedings, but thereafter nothing has been done
and straightway order dated 31.10.2000 has been passed holding
Page No.7 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
him guilty of the misconduct and imposing minor penalties: (i)
stoppage of two annual increments with cumulative effect and (ii)
recovery for an amount of Rs.76,712/-, which is contrary to the
principle of law laid down by this Court in the matter of Ajeet Singh
Jat (supra). Mere issuance of show cause notice would not amount to
proposal to take action against the delinquent and it would also not
amount to serving of imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour on
which action is proposed to be taken under Rule 16(1)(a) of the Rules
of 1966 and there is complete non-compliance of Rule 16(1)(b) of the
said Rules, as no opinion has been recorded by the disciplinary
authority that as to why inquiry is not necessary; taking the
representation submitted by the Government servant under clause
(a) and the record of inquiry, if any, held under clause (b) into
consideration. No enquiry was held and nothing further was done
and straightway the order has been passed. As such, the contention
of learned counsel for the petitioner that the order imposing
punishment passed on 31.10.2000 is in teeth of the provisions
contained in Rule 16(1) of the Rules of 1966 holds water and
accordingly, order dated 31.10.2000 deserves to be set aside. It is
held accordingly.
10.
Even otherwise, there is one more reason for not for not
upholding the impugned orders. On the date of the order directing
recovery of money i.e. 31.10.2000, the petitioner has already been
inflicted with minor penalty of stoppage of 02 annual increments
Page No.8 of 8
IN
WPS-10889-2019
with cumulative effect for the said misconduct by the competent
authority and, therefore, for one act of misconduct, a Government
servant cannot be inflicted with two minor penalties simultaneously,
one is withholding of two increments with cumulative effect and
another is recovery of Rs.76,712/-, which fall within the meaning of
‘minor penalties’ under Rule 10(iii) and (iv) of the Rules of 1966. As
such, imposition of two minor penalties for one act of misconduct
cannot stand together and, as such, on this ground also the
impugned order of punishment dated 31.10.2000 is liable to be
quashed.
11.
In the result, the writ petition is allowed. Impugned order of
punishment dt. 31.10.2000 (Annexure-P/01), affirmed by the orders
passed by the appellate authority dated 30.10.2009 (Annexure-P/02)
& 16.09.2019 (Annexure-P/03), is hereby quashed/set side. No order
as to cost(s).
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
s@if
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review