Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved for orders on
Pronounced on
Date of uploading
: 24.08.2026
: 18.09.2026
:18.09.2026
Whether only operative part
of the judgment is pronounced
or whether full judgment is
pronounced
: FULL.
APHC010879762017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
APPEAL NO: 2772 of 2017
Oleti Diwakar Naidu, Kadapa District
...Appellant
Vs.
M/s. Pioneers Builders Ltd, Anantapur Dist and
Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
:18th September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellant:
MR. M S P KAMARAJU
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
MRS. A JAYANTHI
***
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
The injured claimant preferred present appeal under Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,1988 (for short “the Act”), being
dissatisfied with the amount of compensation determined vide
Award, dated 27.09.2016, passed in M.V.O.P. No.338 of 2015 by
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional
District Judge, Kadapa (for short “the Tribunal”).
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter are referred
to as they were arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the Tribunal.
3.
Facts in brief are as follows:
(a) Claimant, aged 39 years, was working as Purchase In-
charge in Star Alfa General Trading Company at Kuwait and earning
about ₹1,50,000/- per month. While in India, on 13.10.2014, he, along
with others, was proceeding in a car bearing registration No.AP-04 AR7389 from Rajampet to Tirupati.
At about 02.30 p.m., when they
reached Anjaneyapuram village, lorry bearing registration No.KA 21A
0232 driven by its driver, suddenly turned towards the road from a
static position without any prior indication or signal, resulting in both
vehicles dashing against each other. Claimant and other inmates of
car sustained injuries, and one Mr. M. Subbarayudu, succumbed due
to severe injuries. They were all shifted to Government Hospital at
Tirupati and then to private hospital for better treatment. Claimant
underwent surgery to his left hip, and steel rods were inserted,
nevertheless, he sustained disability. The doctors certified that
claimant suffered 40% functional disability.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
(b) The incident was reported to police, and Crime No.174 of
2014, for the offences under Sections 279, 337, 338 and 304-A of IPC
and also Sections 134(a) and (b) r/w.187 of the M.V. Act was
registered against the driver of offending lorry. After investigation,
police laid charge sheet against the driver of the offending lorry.
(c) Claimant incurred various amounts towards medical
expenditure and also on account of permanent disability, he was not
continued in the employment and deprived of earnings, therefore,
claim was laid seeking compensation of ₹50,00,000/- along with
interest.
4.
1strespondent, owner of lorry, filed written statement denying the
occurrence of accident as well as claimant sustaining injuries besides
death of another person. Further, even otherwise, it was also pleaded
that the accident, if any, that occurred was due to rash and negligent
driving of driver of car and not that of driver of lorry. The nature of
injuries and treatment availed by claimant were also denied, besides
disputing the avocation, age, and income of claimant.
5.
2ndrespondent, insurer, filed written statement, inter alia,
pleading that the driver of car was at fault due to his negligence,
without noticing that lorry was taking turn, dashed the same. Since
there was collision between vehicles, the negligence was solely
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
attributable to driver of car. It was also pleaded that the injury
sustained and medical treatment availed were false and that there was
no permanent disability as such, therefore, claimant was not entitled
for compensation in any manner. The insurer also filed additional
written statement, after enhancement of claim from ₹15,00,000/- to
₹50,00,000/-, denying the avocation of injured, as well as the claim
basis as per Indian currency to be excessive and exorbitant for
sustaining simple injuries.
6.
3rdrespondent, driver of offending lorry, remained ex parte.
7.
Basing on the aforesaid pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues:
“1. Whether the petitioner sustained injuries in a motor
vehicle accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the lorry bearing No.KA21A 0232 on 13.10.2014?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation, if so to
what amount and from whom?
3. To what relief?”
8.
Claimant examined PW.1 to PW.4 and marked Exs.A1 to A9 and
Ex.A1. No oral or documentary evidence was adduced on behalf of
respondents.
9.
The Tribunal, after appreciating both oral and documentary
evidence on record, answered first issue in favour of claimant, holding
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
that he sustained injuries in the accident occurred due to negligent
driving of driver of offending lorry. For coming to such conclusion,
Tribunal relied on Ex.A1 FIR and Ex.A2 charge sheet, coupled with
evidence of PW1 himself. Insofar as the quantum of compensation,
though, claimant pleaded that as Purchase In-charge, he was earning
550 Kuwaiti dinars per month, which is equivalent to ₹1,15,000/- per
month in Indian currency and PW.4, claiming to be representative of
employer of claimant, examined and Ex.A5 salary certificate was
produced, the Tribunal disbelieved the same, however, determined
income of claimant at ₹15,000/- per month on notional basis. As
claimant was aged 39 years, it applied multiplier of 15 for the purpose
of assessing future earnings. Based on the evidence of PW.2 and
PW.3, doctors who treated the claimant and issued disability certificate
under Ex.A9, functional disability was assessed as 40%. Further,
considering medical treatment availed by the claimant, ₹88,000/- was
awarded towards medical expenditure. Thus, in all, the Tribunal
awarded the following amounts along with interest at the rate of 9%.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Medical treatment
Loss of income
Towards pain and suffering
Transport charges
Towards permanent disability
Loss of future earnings
Total
₹ 88,000.00
₹ 30,000.00
₹ 50,000.00
₹ 25,000.00
₹ 50,000.00
₹10,80,000.00
₹13,23,000.00
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
10.
Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation so determined,
present appeal is preferred.
11.
The insurer is not in appeal either on liability or quantum.
Therefore, there is no dispute with regard to occurrence of accident
and negligence of driver of offending lorry.
12.
Heard
Mr.M.S.P.
Kamaraju,
learned
counsel
for
appellant/claimant and Mrs.A.Jayanthi, learned counsel for 2nd
respondent-insurer.
13.
The main contentious point between the parties in the present
case is with regard to income of claimant. As per claimant, as
Purchase In-charge, working at Kuwait, he was earning 550 Kuwaiti
dinars per month. In support, claimant relied on Ex.A5 salary
certificate, Ex.A8 attested passport, besides examining PW.4, General
Manager of Star Alfa General Trading Company, Kuwait. As per the
said evidence, it was claimed that the factum of claimant being at
Kuwait in various spells from the year 2009 onwards stands
substantiated (basis Ex.A8 passport) and further was paid salary of
550 Kuwaiti dinars per month (basis Ex.A5 salary certificate). In the
evidence of PW.4, it was categorically stated that claimant was
working as Purchase In-charge since 01.09.2009 and was earning 550
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
Kuwaiti Dinars per month and on account of the accident and injury
suffered, he was unable to perform the duties of Purchase In-charge,
thus, stopped attending to the job. He also confirmed issuance of
Ex.A5 salary certificate. However, during the cross-examination, he
admitted that claimant never worked under him and he did not pay
salary and further that there is no proof filed to establish that claimant
was paid salary through bank transfer in any of the commercial banks
at Kuwait. Considering aforesaid evidence, Tribunal has completely
disbelieved the version of claimant, and assessed his income on
notional basis at ₹15,000/- per month.
14.
On deeper scrutiny and examination of aforesaid evidence, we
are of the view that Ex.A8 demonstrates that claimant was staying at
Kuwait for substantial period from 2006 onwards till the occurrence of
accident. He visited India once in a while. Thus, the stay of claimant at
Kuwait clearly stands established. Insofar as the avocation and income
are concerned, Ex.A5 is one piece of evidence certifying that claimant
was working as Purchase In-charge since 01.09.2009 till the
occurrence of accident. It also indicates that claimant was paid 550
Kuwaiti dinars per month. PW.4, who issued the said certificate, was
examined to confirm the same. However, in the cross-examination,
there is a slight inconsistency with regard to the method and manner of
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
payment of salary. We cannot completely disbelieve and discard
aforesaid evidence and be oblivious to the situation of a person staying
at Kuwait for substantial period without minimum earnings to sustain
himself and also family. The family of claimant was residing at his
native place in India, therefore, claimant was visiting the family on and
off.
15.
Keeping in mind aforesaid evidence and having regard to the
facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the view that the
claimant was gainfully employed and earning 550 Kuwaiti dinars per
month. The Tribunal was not justified in disbelieving aforesaid
evidence and merely assessing the income on a notional basis. Having
said that, the other issue that needs to be addressed is whether the
income earned in foreign currency be converted to Indian Rupees and
determine the multiplicand basis the principles and ratio laid down in
various judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court in regard to compensation.
The three-Judge Bench of Hon'ble Apex Court in United India
Insurance Company Limited v. Satinder Kaur1, considering the case
of deceased who was living and earning in a foreign country i.e. Qatar,
assessed the income taking into account the local currency and then
applied exchange rate prevailing in India. Further, 50% of the same
was deducted towards personal expenses because of the higher cost
(2021) 11 SCC 780
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
of living there. Though learned counsel for respondent insurer brought
to our notice judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Tharunoju
Eshwaramma v. K. Ram Reddy2, which, after referring to various
other judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court on the very same point,
referred the issues to be decided by a larger bench for authoritative
pronouncement.
With great respect, having regard to the fact that
injured has not been retired as on date, we follow the three-Judge
Bench judgment in Satinder Kaur1.
16.
Accordingly, we assess the income of claimant at 550 Kuwaiti
dinars, and by applying conversion rate as applicable on the date of
accident i.e., 1 KWD =₹211/-, the income is worked out as ₹1,16,050/per month, which is equivalent to 550 Kuwaiti dinars, thus, annual
income comes to ₹1,16,050/- x 12 = ₹13,92,600/-.
17.
The nature of injuries is described in Ex.A3 wound certificate
and Ex.A9 certificate of disability. As per Ex.A9, nature of disability is
“post-traumatic
acetabular
old
fracture
left.
Acetabular
post
dislocation, hip operated, heel was found painful, restricted movement.
Hop last ask to squeeze and sitting in the Indian type toilet. 40%
disability”. Further, it was certified that claimant sustained 40%
disability and even PW.3 doctor who issued the same also deposed in
2025 LiveLaw (SC) 1053
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
similar manner. Thus, the Tribunal has assessed the functional
disability at 40%.
18.
In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar3, Hon’ble Apex Court, while
dealing with assessment of permanent disability, observed as under:
“10. Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a
result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under the head
of loss of future earnings would depend upon the effect and
impact of such permanent disability on his earning capacity. The
Tribunal should not mechanically apply the percentage of
permanent disability as the percentage of economic loss or loss
of earning capacity. In most of the cases, the percentage of
economic loss, that is, the percentage of loss of earning capacity,
arising from a permanent disability will be different from the
percentage of permanent disability.
Some Tribunals wrongly
assume that in all cases, a particular extent (percentage) of
permanent disability would result in a corresponding loss of
earning capacity, and consequently, if the evidence produced
show 45% as the permanent disability, will hold that there is 45%
loss of future earning capacity. In most of the cases, equating the
extent (percentage) of loss of earning capacity to the extent
(percentage) of permanent disability will result in award of either
too low or too high a compensation.
11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect
of the permanent disability on the earning capacity of the injured;
and after assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of a
percentage of the income, it has to be quantified in terms of
money, to arrive at the future loss of earnings (by applying the
standard multiplier method used to determine loss of
dependency). We may however note that in some cases, on
appreciation of evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find
that the percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of the
permanent disability, is approximately the same as the
percentage of permanent disability in which case, of course, the
Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for determination of
compensation. (See for example, the decisions of this Court
in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. [(2010)
10 SCC 254 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1258 : (2010) 10 Scale 298]
and Yadava Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10
SCC 341 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1285 : (2010) 8 Scale 567] )”
(2011) 1 SCC 343
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
19.
Therefore, in the present case, the Tribunal has merely
considered the disability as found in Ex.A3 and Ex.A9 and as
corroborated by PW.3, to be 40%, without examining as to the extent
such disability would impact the functional capacity for continuing with
the nature of duties the injured was engaged.
When it comes to
assessing the compensation in the context of injury suffered, what
matters is the extent by which the functions of an injured person
suffers, and not what the doctor may have judged in terms of medical
standards. The functional aspect of disability arising out of injury has
correlation with the age of injured, his occupation, engagement in work
or avocation, the adversarial effect on the earning capacity of the
injured, which would again depend upon the nature of work or earning
activity with which and in which the injured is engaged and such other
relevant considerations.
20.
The appellant in the present case claims to be working as
Purchase in-charge in a company dealing with sale of electronic
goods. The nature of job and duties assigned to him, though, are not
specifically pleaded, as the duties of Purchase in-charge essentially
require a person to be good at negotiating the purchases without much
mobility, therefore, we are of the view that functional disability of the
injured can be assessed as 25%.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
21.
Except for aforesaid amount, which is now being considered and
decided, there is no dispute with regard to other pecuniary and nonpecuniary damages awarded.
In view of the same, the revised
compensation awarded to appellant/claimant stands as follows:
1.
Annual income:
₹13,92,600/-
₹1,16,050/- x 12
2.
Future prospects (40%)
₹ 5,57,040/-
3.
₹13,92,600+₹5,57,040=₹19,49,640 minus ₹ 9,74,820/50% towards personal & family expenses
4.
Multiplier “15” being 39 years old
₹1,46,22,300/-
₹9,74,820/- X 15
5.
Towards loss of future earnings with ₹ 36,55,575/functional
disability
@
25%
on
₹1,46,22,300/-
6.
Medical treatment
₹
88,000.00
7.
Loss of income for treatment period
₹
30,000.00
8.
Towards pain and suffering
₹
50,000.00
9.
Transport charges
₹
25,000.00
Total
22.
₹38,48,575/-
In the result, this appeal is allowed, and the quantum of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced to ₹38,48,575/with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till
the date of realization. The 2ndrespondent - Insurer is directed to
deposit the enhanced compensation, after deducting the amount, if
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. No.2772 of 2017
any, already deposited, within a period of four weeks from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order. On such deposit being made, the
appellant is entitled to withdraw the same. There shall be no order as
to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review