The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. 01.2020 has observed in the following manner: “The claimant petitioner is entitled to get Rs.6,68,800/(Rupees Six Lakh Sixty eight thousand eight hundred ) only in total. The Opposite parties are directed to pay the aforesaid amount within a period of 45 days from today to the claimant petitioner and the amount paid if any, shall be deducted from the total compensation. If the Opposite parties fails to pay the aforesaid amount within the stipulated time the amount shall carry interest @ 9% per annum from the date of expiry of 45 days till deposit of the amount.” [22] Aggrieved by the said judgment and order dated 14.01.2020, the petitioners herein have approached this court filing the instant civil revision petition. [23] Mr. R. Dasgupta, counsel for the ONGC-petitioners argued on the point of limitation and jurisdiction and unreasonable fixation of amount of compensation. [24] While discussing on the point of limitations, the counsel for ONGC-petitioners has not placed anything on record to show that on which date the copy of the award has been served on the claimants and whether the limitation period of 90 days was within or after in filing of the claim before the court below. Hence, the point on limitation is negative. [25] While discussing on the point of jurisdiction, this court is of the view that the District Judge under the Land Acquisition Act, 1984 is empowered to ent…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP 44 of 2020
1. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd
Jiban Bharati Building, New Delhi-110001
2. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director
ONGC Ltd., 7th Floor Jiban Bharati Building,
New Delhi-110001
3. The Asset Manager
ONGC Ltd., Tripura Asset, Agartala,
Tripura (West) Pin - 799014
-----Petitioner
Versus
1. Smt. Kiranbala Debbarma
W/o Lt. Bikram Debbarma,
Resident of Konaban,
P.S Madhupur, Dist - Sepahijala
-----Respondent
2. The Competent Authority (RoU),
The Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited
Quarter No.B-78, South Colony,
P.O-Badharghat P.S.-Amtali, Agartala,
District.- West Tripura Pin-799014
-----Pro-Respondent-Opposite Party
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. R. Dasgupta, Adv.
: Mr. A L. Saha, Adv.
Mr. K. Pandey, Adv.
: 18.04.2022
: 19.04.2022
: No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an application under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India against the judgment dated 14.01.2020 passed in Civil Misc (PMP)
28 of 2014 between Smt. Kiranbala Debbarma, Claimant-petitioner and
the Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited and 3 others, whereby and
whereunder the learned Additional District Judge, Sepahijala, Bishalgarh
fixed compensation for 176 nos of segun trees of girth and trees having
3ft o” inches and 1 frt 0” @ Rs.3,800/- per tree. The petitioners also
preferred this application for exercising the supervisory jurisdiction of the
Hon’ble High Court against the Order passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, Sepahijala, Bishalgarh in Civil Misc (PMP) 28 of 2014
between Smt. Kiranbala Debbarma claimant-petitioner and the Oil &
Natural Gas Corporation Limited and 3 other respondents, whereby and
whereunder the learned Addl. District Judge, Shipahijala, Bishalgarh
fixed compensation for176 nos of Segun trees of girth and trees having
3’ ft 0” inches and 1 0” inches @ Rs.3800/- per tree in violation of the
provisions of Petroleum & Minerals Pipelines Act, 1962 (P&MP Act, 1962)
and the Petroleum & Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in
Land) Rules, 1962.
[2]
For the sake of brevity the parties are referred to as in the
cause title of Civil Misc.(PMP) 28 of 2014. Brief facts of the present case
are that the claimant is the owner of the land under plot no.138/3060
and 138/3061 under Khatian no. 1173 of Mouja Konaban measuring
2.80 acres of land and she was enjoying the possession of the land by
planting rubber trees and other valuable trees including fruits by
investing good amount of money. On 06.03.13 gazette notification
was
made
land
by the
appertaining to
Respondents
for acquiring
1.00
acres
of
the aforesaid plot in possession of the claimant
petitioner for the purpose of laying down of gas pipe line for the use of
Thermal Project in Palatana, Udaipur of the then South Tripura District,
now Gomati District as per provision of Section 3(1) of the Act and as
per provision of section 5(1)(2) of the Act objection was invited from the
claimant petitioner against the aforesaid acquisition and the
claimant
petitioner submitted objection claiming compensation of Rs.15,00,000/for 200 numbers of damaged Teak trees and Rs. 10,00,000/- as cost
of the acquired land. But the competent authority did not consider the
aforesaid claim of the claimant
petitioner
and
by
order dt.
03.02.2012 gave compensation amounting to Rs.1,11,000/- for the
damaged Teak trees.
[3]
The claimant
compensation
amount
petitioner
claimed
trees =Rs.15,00,000/- and
being
dissatisfied with
Rs.7500/- X 200
Rs.10,00,000/-
nos
aforesaid
of
Teak
per kani for the acquired
land.
[4]
On the other hand the Opposite parties contested this case
by
filing Written Objection and they stated that the compensation
for the aforesaid trees and the acquired land assessed by OP No. 4 was
accepted by the claimant petitioner as adequate, reasonable and
sufficient.
[5]
In view of the pleadings of the parties the following issues
were framed in connection with this case:
1)
Whether
the
competent
authority
adequately
determined the compensation for damage of Teak Trees
including land value for laying petroleum and minerals
Pipelines under the land of the claimant petitioner ?
2)Whether the claimant petitioner is entitled to have any
further compensation and if so, to what extent ?
[6]
The claimant petitioner adduced herself as witness and she
submitted examination in chief by affidavit in this case and she was
cross examined by the OP side. The claimant petitioner also adduced the
following document:
1) Notification dt. 22.9.1999 of the Forest Department,
Govt. of Tripura.
[7]
On
the
Brindaban Debnath
other
hand
adduced
Sri
Subal
themselves
their examination in chief by affidavit and
Debbarma
and
Sri
as OPWs and submitted
they were cross examined
by the petitioner.
The OP side also adduced the following documents:
1) Exhibit A:Gazette Notification dt. 6.3.13.
2) Exhibit B:Copy of the field inquiry report dt. 28.1.12.
3) Exhibit C :Letter dt. 25.2.2005 of the Revenue
Department regarding rate of standing trees.
4) Exhibit D:Application of the petitioner dt. 29.12.11.
5) Exhibit E:Copy of the award dt. 3.2.12.
6) Exhibit F:Copy of payment sheet.
7) Exhibit G:Copy of indemnity bond with NOC of the
petitioner.
8) Exhibit H:Assessment of base value of land.
[8]
Thereafter the record was transferred to this Court due to
change in the jurisdiction after creation of the Sepahijala Judicial District.
[9]
As both the issues deal with the crux of the case and
therefore were taken up for together for decision.
[10]
The claimant petitioner filed the application u/s 10 of the Act
being dissatisfied with the compensation granted by the competent
authority for damaging the Teak trees. Section 10 of the Act talks about
compensation and it says that any person who has sustained damage or
loss due to laying down of the pipeline by the competent authority is
entitled to get compensation from that competent authority and for such
type of matter the District Judge or equivalent is competent to
determined the compensation due to removal of trees, standing crops
etc.
[11]
In the case in hand the Opposite parties for the purpose of
laying down the pipelines for use
in the Palatana Project at Udaipur
acquired a portion of the land of the claimant petitioner and on that land
there were Teak and the claimant petitioner sustained loss due to laying
down of the pipeline on that land as
200 numbers of
damaged in that process and against
that
trees were
the Ops granted
compensation of Rs. 1,11,075/- to the claimant petitioner. But the
claimant petitioner expressed her dissatisfaction on the plea that the
compensation was not adequate and she filed the instant application for
enhancement of the compensation.
[12]
The OP side failed to adduce any document to substantiate
their contention that the claimant was duly intimated. Although they
adduced Exhibit F which is the payment receipt of award to the affected
people and it reveals that the claimant petitioner at serial no. 4 received
compensation of Rs. 1,11,075/- on
13.2.12. The OP side also adduced
another payment receipt regarding compensation for the acquired land
and it reveals that the petitioner was given Rs.9000/- as compensation
for the acquired land on the same date and her signature is also there
but facts remains that as per the provision of Rule 5 of PMP Rules 1963 it
is duty upon the competent authority to give intimation of award to the
petitioner in proper way and in the case in hand no such intimation was
given.
[13]
In this regard this court while disposing CRP cases no. 12 of
2016, 142 of 2015, 50 of 2015, 54 of 2015, 54 of 2016 and 59 of 2016
by order and judgment dt. 29.9.16 in para no. 37 gave specific
observation that limitation to file application before the District Judge for
enhancement of compensation in terms of section 10(3) of the PMP Act
will commence only on receipt of the intimation.
[14]
Therefore, in the instant case the limitation of 90 days
cannot be taken into consideration as the competent authority did not
give due intimation to the petitioner about the award. So far non joinder
of party is concerned, the inclusion of ONGC Ltd., a Union Govt.
concerned as necessary party no. 1 & 2 is sufficient to hold that the
Union Govt. was duly made the party in this case.
[15]
The Ops while making assessment regarding loss of Teak
trees on that land came to conclusion that the claimant petitioner is
entitled to get Rs.1,11,075/- in total with the break up as follows :
@ Rs. 800 X
135 nos of
Teak
trees (3' - 0'')= Rs.
1,08,000/- and Rs. 75/- X 41 nos of Teak trees (1'- 0')=
Rs.3075/- .
[16]
The
claimant
petitioner
on
the
other
hand
claimed
enhancement of compensation for the rubber trees and cost of the
acquired land. @ Rs. 7500/-- X 200
nos of
Teak trees and
Rs.10,00,000/- per kani for the acquired land. In order to substantiate
the case the claimant petitioner adduced
Exhibit 1 series which is a
notification dt. 22.9.1999 of the Forest Department regarding sale-price
of timber/forest produce.
[17]
On perusal of the aforesaid document it is found that the
value of one Teak tree was assessed depending on the size of the girth.
In the case in hand it is evident from the order of
award
that 176
numbers of Teak trees were damaged and out of them 135 nos of trees
were of 3 feet size and the remaining 41 trees were of 1 feet
[18]
size.
The aforesaid Notification of the Forest Department reveals
that the minimum rate for a Teak tree is Rs.2980/- and depending on
the size the rate rises up to Rs.9000/- per tree. In the case in hand even
if we calculate the price of each tree @ Rs.2980 X 176 numbers of trees,
the petitioner is entitled to get Rs.5,24,480/- as compensation. Since we
have to arrive at a reasonable price to compensate the
the loss,
petitioner for
I consider it appropriate that compensation @ Rs,3,800/- per
tree will be just and appropriate in this case.
[19]
Therefore, the rate assessed by the competent authority as
compensation for the Teak trees was on the lower side and the petitioner
is entitled to get
compensation @ Rs. 3800/- X
176 nos of
Teak
trees = Rs. 6,68,800/-.
[20]
So far cost of the acquired land is concerned, it is
evident from Exihibit F that Rs.9000/- @10 %
as cost of the land was
given to the petitioner as compensation and considering the nature and
class of the land as well as the
location the court below was of the
view that the compensation of Rs.9000/- was adequate and need no
enhancement.
Accordingly both the issues are answered in affirmative.
[21]
Finally, the court below by the impugned order dated
14.01.2020 has observed in the following manner:
“The claimant petitioner is entitled to get Rs.6,68,800/(Rupees Six Lakh Sixty eight thousand eight hundred )
only in total. The Opposite parties are directed to pay the
aforesaid amount within a period of 45 days from today to
the claimant petitioner and the amount paid if any, shall
be deducted from the total compensation. If the Opposite
parties fails to pay the aforesaid amount within the
stipulated time the amount shall carry interest @ 9% per
annum from the date of expiry of 45 days till deposit of the
amount.”
[22]
Aggrieved by the said judgment and order dated 14.01.2020,
the petitioners herein have approached this court filing the instant civil
revision petition.
[23]
Mr. R. Dasgupta, counsel for the ONGC-petitioners argued on
the point of limitation and jurisdiction and unreasonable fixation of
amount of compensation.
[24]
While discussing on the point of limitations, the counsel for
ONGC-petitioners has not placed anything on record to show that on
which date the copy of the award has been served on the claimants and
whether the limitation period of 90 days was within or after in filing of
the claim before the court below. Hence, the point on limitation is
negative.
[25]
While discussing on the point of jurisdiction, this court is of
the view that the District Judge under the Land Acquisition Act, 1984 is
empowered
to
entertain
the
claims
and
passing
an
award
of
compensation. But whereas in pursuant of the notification dated 24th
July, 2018 the powers have been delegated from all District Judges to all
Additional District Judges for resolving the disputes relating to the
fixation of the compensation.
[26]
Further with regard to the separation of judicial districts this
court is of the opinion that wherever the dispute is falling in the judicial
district of the other judicial district, mere making an argument before
the court in a routine manner that the application cannot be entertained
on the grounds of courts having no jurisdiction cannot be accepted in all
pending cases. The ONGC- petitioners have not placed on record any
orders obtained by high court in the form of transfer of ONGC cases from
one district court to other district court having territorial jurisdiction.
Hence, no case on the point of jurisdiction. The Administrative
instructions of High Court of Tripura in respect of giving additional
responsibilities to lower judiciary is not relevant to the facts of the case
on the point of jurisdiction.
[27]
Hence, this court is of the view that the interest awarded by
the court below of 9% is converted into 6% as per section 11(2)
Petroleum & Minerals Pipelines Act, 1962 (P&MP Act, 1962) and the
Petroleum & Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land)
Rules, 1962.
[28]
In view of the above discussion, the civil revision petition
stands allowed to the extent as indicated above. It is needless to say
that the rest portion of the order dated 14.01.2020 shall remain intact.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review