Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:508
Serial No.01
Supp. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 34 of 2024
Date of Decision :07.06.2024
Sri. Odimar Syiemsad,
Aged about 51 years,
Son of Late J.Syiemiong,
Resident of Langkyrding Mihngi,
Block – 3, East Khasi Hills District,
Shillong – 793012, Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Meghalaya
Represented by the
Commissioner & Secretary,
Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation Limited,
Office of the Chief Engineer (C)
Maintenance and Small Hydro,
Lumjingshai, Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
2.
Sri. H.W.Lyngdoh Mawnai,
Chief Engineer (C)
Maintenance and Small Hydro,
Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation Limited,
Meghalaya, Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
3.
The Director (Generation),
Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation Limited,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
2024:MLHC:508
4.
The Director (Transmission),
Meghalaya Power Transmission
Corporation Limited,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
5.
The Secretary,
Special Purpose Vehicle Society,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
6.
The Company Secretary,
Meghalaya Electric Corporation Limited,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
7.
The Chief Accounts Officer,
Meghalaya Electric Corporation Limited,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
8.
The Executive Engineer (MIS),
Meghalaya Electric Corporation Limited,
Short Round Road,
Shillong – 793001.
9.
Sri Taibin Warjri,
Cleve Colony, Shillong – 793003.
10.
Smti. Connie F. Sawkmie,
Proprietor,
M/s. Shrolenson Marbaniang,
Cleve Colony,
Shillong – 793 003.
11.
Sri. Collinstar Sawkmie,
Cleve Colony, Shillong – 793 003.
…Respondents
2024:MLHC:508
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S.Dutta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. I.Lahiri, Adv.
Ms. I.Das, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A.S.Pandey, Adv.
Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Adv. for R 2-8.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner, a registered Class-I Contractor under the
Meghalaya Power Generation Corporation Limited, by way of the instant
petition is challenging the issuance of a work order dated 15-02-2024, in
pursuance to a tender notice dated 04-07-2023, in favour of the private
respondent No. 9.
2.
The brief facts are that the Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation on 04-07-2023, had issued a tender notice for construction of
a multi-purpose Indoor Stadium at Nongtrai Village, Mawsynram, East
2024:MLHC:508
Khasi Hills, for an estimated value of ₹ 2,87,89,896.00, for bidding
through e-tender, on a two-bid system (technical and financial) from
registered Class-I Contractors, under the Meghalaya Power Generation
Corporation Limited. The petitioner along with 4 others (respondents No.
9, 10 & 11) and one Shri. Mostophar Kharkongor, participated in the bid
process and on 26-07-2023, when the bids were opened, it was found that
respondents No. 9, 10 & 11 and Shri. Mostophar Kharkongor, had quoted
identical rates, whereas the bid of the petitioner was fractionally higher.
The petitioner thereafter, being surprised that there was no system of
technical evaluation, represented before the respondents and on not
receiving any positive response, caused him to file further representations
and letters, but however, by a work order dated 15-02-2024, the contract
was awarded to the respondent No. 9, one of the tenderers who had quoted
identical rates. Being aggrieved thereby, the writ petitioner has approached
this Court.
3.
Mr. S.Dutta, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. I.Lahiri, learned
counsel for the petitioner, has submitted that the selection of the
respondent No. 9, is vitiated with arbitrariness and malafide, as firstly, the
identical quotation of rates by the respondents No. 9, 10 & 11, hints at a
cartel being formed by the respondents and secondly, the selection of
respondent No. 9, from amongst the 3 bidders who had quoted identical
2024:MLHC:508
rates, clearly shows nepotism on the part of the respondents, inasmuch as,
there is no justification as to how his bid was superior to the rest. It has
also been submitted that the validity of 90 days had expired in October
2023, and as such, the award of the work order could not have been issued
in February 2024.
4.
It has further been submitted that the contract being an item rate
contract, it was not possible to quote the exact same rates and arrive at the
quoted price as given in the tender. He submits that the bid of the
petitioner was only ₹1.34 paise higher than the quoted rate, and that if all
bidders are equal, at least they should have all been invited for negotiations
instead of the respondent No. 9 being arbitrarily selected, and allotted the
work. The learned Sr. counsel has also contended, that the evaluation of
the technical bid, is a condition precedent to evaluation of financial bids
and the respondents, by not adhering to the same has vitiated the entire
tendering process.
5.
On another limb of submission, the learned Sr. counsel submits that
as is apparent from a meeting dated 07-02-2024, held in the office of the
respondent No. 3, the minutes of which have been annexed to the affidavitin-opposition, the tendering committee as well as the 4 other bidders who
had quoted identical rates, came to a mutual understanding by coming to a
resolution that the respondent No. 9, be awarded the work which is
2024:MLHC:508
unheard of, in any tender process. The role of the tender committee in the
entire sequence of events, he submits, is against all norms and practices
which should be adhered to in any competitive bidding process, inasmuch
as, work was awarded to one of the bidders quoting identical rates, on the
basis of undertakings given by the other bidders. It is contended that the
tender committee, is not even empowered to enter into such negotiations
with any of the bidders for finalization of the award, as the said power
vests with the employer of the contract, that is, the respondent No. 2 (Chief
Engineer). The learned Sr. counsel has also referred to the affidavit filed
indicating service upon the private respondents, and submits that the said
respondents all belong to the same family, and in fact, 2 amongst the 3
notices were received by the same person and that the 4 tenderers coming
from the same family, had made the entire tender process a family affair. It
is further contended that the entire exercise entered into by the tender
committee, is against all canons of the guiding principles laid down for all
government contracts such as, the General Financial Rules of 2017, as well
as the Manual for Procurement of Works, 2022 issued by the Government
of India, Ministry of Finance, which have been a standard referral
document for such contracts or public procurement, and also the procedure
laid down by the Government of Meghalaya in their web portal “Tenders
Meghalaya”. It is lastly submitted that the argument of the respondents that
2024:MLHC:508
the contract was awarded to the lowest bidder, is inconsequential in the
instant discussion, inasmuch as, the bid of the petitioner was higher by
only a mere ₹1.34 paise in a contract amounting to over ₹ 2,87,89,896.00.
As such, he submits, the entire exercise which has been done by the
respondents being irrational, arbitrary and malafide, the impugned work
order is liable to be struck down.
6.
In support of this arguments, learned Sr. counsel has relied upon the
case of B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd. vrs. Nair Coal Services Ltd. & Ors.
reported in (2006) 11 SCC 548.
7.
In reply, Mr. A.S.Pandey, learned counsel on behalf of the
respondents No. 2-8 has submitted that the petitioner‟s bid was INR 1.34
paise more than the lowest bidder, and as such, the petitioner has no locus
to jeopardize the tender process. He then submits that the tender notice
dated 04-07-2023, categorically mentions that the estimated tender value
for the project is INR 2,87,89,896.00, and that this estimated value, is the
minimum price of the bid which was quoted by the 3 private respondents.
The learned counsel has referred to Clause 4 (iii) of the tender document
under the heading „Financial Bid‟ which stipulates that tender(s) quoting
below the estimated costs of the work will not be accepted, and submits
that the submission of identical bids which is the lowest bid, therefore does
not amount to any cartelization. He submits that the mere submission of
2024:MLHC:508
identical bids by the bidders that too, at the estimated or minimum value of
the project cannot and will not lead to any prejudice being caused to public
interest. He then submits that as 3 out of 4 bidders having identical bids
agreed to withdraw in favour of respondent No. 9, there was no other
criteria needed to determine, or to resolve the tie of the identical bids.
8.
Learned counsel then submits that the petitioner has no legal or
fundamental right to institute the present writ petition, as it is settled law
that even the highest or lowest bidder, has no vested right for award of
contract, and therefore, the petitioner who is not the lowest bidder does not
possess any right to interfere with the tender process. The learned counsel
has in the affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents 2 to 8 cited the
following decisions on locus and on the limited scope of judicial review in
tender matters, and how undue interference in such contractual matters
affects public interest.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
M/s A.M.Yusuf vrs. Mumbai Municipal Corporation & Ors.
W.P. (Civil) No. 2666 of 2008, vide judgment dated
11.12.2008.
Vinoy Kumar vrs. State of U.P & Ors. (2001) 4 SCC 734.
State of Orissa vrs. Ram Chandra Dev & Another AIR 1964
SC 685 para 8.
Tata Motors Ltd. vrs. Brihan Mumbai Electric Supply &
Transport Undertaking (BEST), 2023 SCC Online SC 671.
N.G.Projects Ltd. vrs. Vinod Kumar Jain, (2022) 6 SCC 127.
Jagdish Mandal vrs. State of Orissa (2007) 14 SCC 517.
2024:MLHC:508
9.
He lastly submits that where the relationship is governed purely in
terms of contract as in the instant case, a writ would not lie to enforce such
civil liability, and that relief under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
is based on the existence of a legal or fundamental right, and its violation
thereof. As such, he prays that the writ petition be dismissed.
10.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, and also having
perused the materials on record, it is seen that the entire controversy is
with the tender proceedings, especially on the manner of award of contract
by the respondent No. 2 in favour of the respondent No. 9. Coming to the
crux of the matter, the settlement of the work with the respondent No. 9, it
is seen was arrived at in a meeting held on 07-02-2024, in the office
chamber of the respondent No.3, wherein the respondent No. 3 as the
Chairman of the tender committee and in the presence of the bidders that
is, respondents No. 9, 10 & 11 and one Mostophar Kharkongor, resolved to
award the contract to respondent No. 9. The meeting, it appears, was
convened to decide on who was to be favoured with the contract, as all the
above noted 4 bidders had quoted the rate at par i.e. ₹2,87,89,896.00 and
considered L-1 bidders. This aspect deserves consideration and
examination by this Court, inasmuch as, it has been stated on affidavit and
not rebutted by the respondents, that respondents No. 9, 10 & 11, all
2024:MLHC:508
belong to the same family. The petitioner at para 2 of the affidavit
indicating service has stated as follows:“2. That by an order dated 13/03/2024; this
Hon’ble Court directed the petitioner to serve
notices upon the private respondents No. 9, 10
& 11 namely Sri. Taibin Warjri, Smti. Connie
F. Sawkmie and Sri Collinstar Sawkmie
through dasti. It is pertinent to mention herein
that Sri. Taibin Warjri (respondent No. 9) is the
son of Sri. Collinstar Sawkmie (respondent No.
11). It is also mentioned that Smti. Connie
F.Sawkmie (respondent No. 10) and Sri.
Collinstar Sawkmie are related as brother and
sister. However, in pursuance thereof, notices
dated 15/03/2024 were served on the same date
to all the three private respondents through
dasti mode. It may be noted that two amongst
the three notices were received by the same
person, that is, one Mrs. S. Warjri and the third
notice by one Damaian Kynter.”
Apart from the above, the acknowledgment notices as seen from the
registered A/D cards also show that the said respondents also reside in the
same address or locality. These facts and events which show that there is
apparent collusion and manipulation, is no doubt very disturbing as tender
matters concern the distribution of public largesse and as such demand a
high degree of transparency and probity, on the part of the authorities who
decide on such matters.
11.
In the instant case, it appears that the tender committee had taken
upon itself the task of settling the contract, when in fact the same is within
the discretion of the owner of the contract, or the authority that had floated
2024:MLHC:508
the NIT. Reverting back to the meeting dated 07-02-2024, it is observed
that there is no mention about the technical aspect of the bids being
examined, even though the NIT had clearly invited bids in a 2-bid system.
No discussion is present or materials produced to attest to the fact that the
conditions given in clause 3 of the Detailed Tender Notice dealing with the
technical aspect were noted or discussed. Further, the circumstances and
manner as to how the invitations were extended to the bidders by the
tender committee, the authority under which the meeting was convened,
and the contract settled summarily in the meeting itself, defies logic and
reasoning.
12.
The submission of identical rates by the 4 tenderers is against the
basic principles of competitive bidding and is contrary to the purpose and
concept of an open tender system. Such practices need to be discouraged
and, in the event, as has occurred in the present case, especially in an item
wise contract, a detailed cost analysis should have been gone into by the
tendering committee, to arrive at the most suitable bidder as all the rates
quoted were identical. Though it has been submitted that there has been no
cartelization, and that no loss would be caused to the public exchequer as
the 4 bidders had quoted the estimated value as given in the NIT, however
the fact that, without there being any other evaluation of the bids on the
technical aspect, more so when all the bids were identical, and the
2024:MLHC:508
settlement arrived at by inviting the bidders to negotiate and come to an
understanding among themselves speaks otherwise.
13.
Though it is settled law that a writ court should refrain or restrain
itself from interfering in tender matters, inasmuch as, the same are
essentially commercial functions and the principles of equity should not be
brought into play and judicial review be not invoked as it would be
inimical to public interest and policy, the converse however, also holds
true, as it is also settled law that judicial review would apply to prevent
arbitrariness and illegality. As held in the case of Tata Cellular vrs. Union
of India (1994) 6SCC 651, the duty of the Court is to confine itself to
whether a decision making authority exceeded its powers, committed an
error in law, committed a breach of the rule of natural justice, reached a
decision which no reasoned tribunal would have reached, or whether if
there was an abuse of powers. In the instant case, what is patently seen
from the facts and discussions made hereinabove, is that there is a serious
flaw in the decision making process, inasmuch as, there exists elements
and instances of procedural impropriety, irrationality, arbitrariness and
unreasonableness on the part of the tender committee which has gone
beyond its jurisdiction and mandate, apart from the award of contract also
being the product of cartelization.
2024:MLHC:508
14.
In the considered view of this Court, the fact that the writ petitioner
technically is not the L-1 bidder as his bid was ₹1.34 paise more than the
bids of the respondents No. 9, 10 & 11 will not take away his rights to
question the tender process, inasmuch as, the issue of technical evaluation
had been raised by the writ petitioner through various letters dated 18-102023, 30-10-2023, 01-12-2023, which have been annexed at Annexures V,
VI and VIII to the writ petition, but however, received no response from
the respondents.
15.
It may be further added herein, that the very fact that the
respondents No. 9, 10 & 11 have chosen to stay away and not participate in
the instant proceedings inspite of receipt of notice, fortifies the statements
and averments that have been made by the writ petitioner in the writ
petition on the aspect of bid rigging and cartelization, as also the vitiation
of the entire tender process.
16.
For the reasons aforementioned, and in the facts and circumstances
of the case, the instant writ petition is allowed and the impugned work
order dated 15-02-2024, awarded to the respondent No. 9, is set aside and
quashed.
17.
Writ petition accordingly stands closed and disposed of.
2024:MLHC:508
18.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
07.06.2024
signed by SAMANTHA
SAMANTHA ANNA Digitally
ANNA LIYA RYNJAH
Date:
2024.06.07
13:31:18 +05'30'
LIYA RYNJAH
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review