Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA
CRIMINAL PETITION No.103533 OF 2024
(482(CR.PC)/528(BNSS))
BETWEEN:
O.N. NAGRAJ S/O. LATE OBANNA
AGE. 65 YEARS, OCC. PENSIONER,
PRESENT ADDRESS R/O. 12, FF 02
4TH FLOOR, 3RD CROSS, M.L.A. LAYOUT,
KALENA AGRAHARA BANNERGHATTA ROAD,
GOTTIGERE POST BENGALURU-560076.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. K.L. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE CENTRAL BUREU OF INVESTIGATION,
BANK AND SECURITIES FRAUD CELL,
NO. 36, CBI COMPLEX,
II FLOOR, BELLARY ROAD,
GANGANAGAR, BENGALURU-560032.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. NEELENDRA D. GUNDE, ADVOCATE)
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench.
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482 OF
CR.P.C.
(528 OF BNSS), PRAYING TO ALLOW THIS CRIMINAL
PETITION AND QUASH ORDER DATED 08.08.2024 PASSED BY III
ADDL.DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, DHARWAD (SPL.JUDGE FOR
CBI/ACB/KLA CASES) IN SPL.CBI C.C. NO.24/2013 AND DISCHARGE
THE PETITIONER/ACCUSED NO.1 FROM OFFENCES PUNISHABLE U/S
420, 467, 468, 471 AND 511 R/W SECTION 120-B OF IPC SECTIONS
7, 13(2) AND 13(1) (D) OF PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
THIS CRIMINAL PETITION COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.SRISHANANDA)
Heard Sri.K.L.Patil, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Sri.Neelendra D. Gunde, learned counsel for the respondent
/Central Bureau of Investigation (hereinafter ‘CBI’ for short).
2.
Present petitioner is accused No.1 who was the Branch
Manager of Union Bank of India, Ballari, who has been charge
sheeted for the offences punishable under Section 120B read
with Section 420, 467, 468, 471 of Indian Penal Code.
3.
He has approached this Court with the following prayer by
filing a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure:
“WHEREFORE, it is most humbly prayed that this Hon’ble
Court be pleased to allow this Criminal petition and quash
Order dated 08.08.2024 passed by III Addl. District and
Sessions Judge, Dharwad (Spl. Judge for CBI/ACB/KLA
Cases) in Spl. CBI CC No.24/2013 and discharge the
petitioner/accused No.1 from offences punishable under
Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 511 r/w Section 120B of
IPC and Sections 7, 13(2) and 13(1)(d) of Prevention of
Corruption Act, in the interest of justice and equity.”
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
4.
Facts in the nutshell which are utmost necessary for
disposal of the present petition are as under:
4.1
Accused No.8-M/s Rytu Depot Cold Storage Pvt. Ltd., filed
an application for sanction of loan with the Union Bank of India,
Ballari Branch.
4.2
Loan application was serviced and as against the security
of the immovable property, loans were being sanctioned at
different interval of time.
4.3
Loan account was serviced without proper sanction from
the Board, as the branch did not have the power to sanction the
loan beyond the prescribed limit.
Therefore, the loan request
was recommended by the branch to the higher authorities.
4.4
It is alleged that the loan became irregular and at that
juncture, an internal enquiry was held in the bank by the
Vigilance Department of the Union Bank of India and they found
lot of irregularities in servicing the loan request of accused No.8.
A report came to be filed in this regard.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
4.5
Based on the report, the Board of Union Bank of India
decided to initiate criminal action against accused No.8 and other
employees of the Union Bank of India who are all responsible for
recommendation of the loan and present petitioner is named as
accused No.1 in the First Information Report and arraigned as
accused No.1 in the charge sheet after collecting necessary
materials that he is also responsible for illegal servicing of the
loan request of accused No.8.
4.6
In the meantime, the recovery proceedings were also
initiated for the amounts that were due to the Union Bank of
India and accused No.8 opted for the one time settlement
scheme and it is submitted that entire loan amount is now
settled and as such, there is no civil liability.
4.7
After the charge sheet came to be filed, learned Special
Judge took cognizance of the offences alleged against the
accused persons and registered the case and proceeded with the
case.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
5.
An
Application
seeking
discharge
of
the
present
petitioner/accused No.1 seeking discharge. Same was opposed
by the CBI by filing written objections.
6.
Learned Trial Judge after considering the objections filed by
the CBI, dismissed the application filed by the present petitioner
by order dated 08.08.2024.
7.
Being aggrieved by the same, petitioner has filed the
present petition on the following grounds:
• It is submitted that the order passed by Trial court
dismissing
the
discharge
application
filed
by
the
petitioner is contrary to the facts and material placed on
record. Hence, interference of this Hon'ble court is
warranted.
• It is submitted that, petitioner was working as Branch
Manager of the Union Bank, Bellary. An application was
submitted for the construction of cold storage. After
collecting all the necessary documents and after verifying
the
genuineness
of
the
documents,
Petitioner
had
forwarded the loan application to higher authority for
sanction of the loan. The higher authorities after cross
verifying all the necessary papers and securities provided
by the borrower, sanctioned the loan amount to the
borrower. Therefore, absolutely there is no role of
petitioner in sanctioning the loan to the borrower,
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
therefore petitioner cannot be held liable, and he cannot
be prosecuted for the offences punishable under the
provision of prevention of corruption Act and other
provisions of IPC as alleged by the prosecution. Hence,
interference of this Hon'ble court is warranted.
• It is submitted that, at the time of applying for the loan
by M/s Rytu Depot cold Storage (P) Ltd for the
construction of the cold storage, the construction work
had already started and the borrower had already
invested an amount of Rs. 84.50 Lacs. The loan
application forwarded by the petitioner had specifically
mentioned that, construction work has started and the
engineer has issued a work certificate to the effect. The
higher authorities have sanctioned the loan amount to
the M/s. Rytu Depot cold Storage (P) Ltd, after satisfying
themselves considering the fact that work has already
started. Therefore, the allegation that, petitioner has
disbursed
the
entire
amount
without
verifying
the
progress of the work cannot be said as irregularity and
conspiracy to cheat the bank. Therefore, this aspect of
the matter is not considered by the trial court.
• It is further submitted that, the Regional office Bangalore
had sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 261.60 Lacs to M/s
Rytu
Depot
cold
Storage
P
Ltd
(RDCSPL).
While
forwarding the said loan proposal, the petitioner had
informed that "the firm has already started construction
and invested around Rs. 84.50 Lacs". The same was also
supported by the "Invested certificate" dated:24-12-
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
2006 issued by the Chartered Accountant M/s Anil Kumar
and investment certificate dated 28.12.2006 of Rs. 81.85
Lacs issued by Sri C.B Srinivas Reddy a chartered
engineer. Vide "Pre-inspection" Certificate dated: 28-122006 the petitioner had informed the Regional office that
an amount of Rs. 84.50 has been already invested by the
firm. Further the chartered accountant had confirmed
that the M/s Rytu Depot cold storage had invested an
amount of Rs. 114.60 lacs towards construction done till
13-03-2007
vide
investment
certificate
dated
13.03.2007. further, on 17-03-2007, the contractor M/s
Chandrala
Construction
who
had
entered
in
to
"Memorandum of understanding" dated 15-03-2007 with
the company to undertake the labour contract works,
vide their "investment Certificate" dated: 17-03-2007
had confirmed that the work has reached up to roof slab
level and the total cost involved was Rs. 131.20 Lacs.
Upon side inspection, it was found to be true that the
work had reached up to roof stage and after deducting
25% margin as per sanction term, an amount of Rs.
103.50 lacs was released against the already invested i.e
Rs. 131.20 Lacs. This aspect clearly shows that the
petitioner has taken due care and caution while releasing
the loan amount and absolutely and there are no
irregularities committed by the petitioner. Hence, the
petitioner cannot be held liable. This aspect of the matter
is not considered by the trial court. Hence, interference
of this Hon'ble court is warranted.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
• It is also submitted that the detailed estimate for the total
project was prospered by Sri. C.B Srinivas Redddy, a
Chartered Engineer & Valuer who specialize in the said
field. He is not a contractor, but only a consultant. Vide
their letter dated 17-03-2007 M/s C.B Srinivas Reddy
had confirmed this fact. The company RDCSPL and
entrusted
the
construction
work
to
M/s
Chandrala
Construction as intimated by them to the Branch vide
their letter dt: 17-03-2007, which was also evident from
the memorandum of understating produced to the
Branch. As per letter dated: 17-03-2007, RDCSPL had
instructed the Branch to release the funds to the
contractor being M/s Chandrala Construction. Finally, on
17-03-2007 after release of the installment to the
contractors, the Branch vide letter no, BLY/822/07
dated: 17.03.2007, had informed the Regional office that
the
Branch had made payment
to
M/s
Chandrala
Constructions. The Chief Manager, Credit Department
and the Banks Technical officer have inspected the
project of the borrower at the stage of completion,
thought it was the duty of the credit department and
credit grid department who have conducted the above
mentioned diligence, it is at the insistence of the
petitioner that the concerned officers have inspected the
project site. It is therefore submitted that the loan
amount disbursed was in proportionate to the progress of
the work and that there has been no malafide intention
or
violation
in
the
loan
sanction
terms
for
the
disbursement of funds. The funds were disbursed after
visiting the construction site and the disbursal was in
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
accordance with the progress of the work and also
Regional
office
and
Filed
General
Manager
office
substantiated the payments made to M/S Chandrala
constructions and informed to Central office that there is
no wrongful diversion of fund.
• It is submitted that, on 17-03-2007 the borrower made a
request letter to the Bank, requesting the bank to
release the loan amount in favour of M/s Chandrala
Construction as per Memorandum of understanding
entered
between
borrower
and
M/s
Chandralal
construction. The petitioner as per memorandum of
understanding released the loan amount in favour of M/s
Chandrala Construction and the same was brought to the
notice of higher authority. This aspect of the matter is
not considered by the trial court. Asthe Borrower
invested around Rs.131.20 lakhs during October 2006 to
17.3.2007 towards constructions from own source of
funds and personal borrowing. As the amount released to
M/s
Chandrala
Constructions
was
invested
by
the
borrower only and M/s Chandral Constructions was not
undertken the work, as per the advice of the auditor, the
borrower obtained an amount of Rs.102.20 lakhs from
M/s Chandrala construction and credited to M/s Rytu
Depot cold storage current account. Borrower made
payment to dealers who had supplied the material for
construction work and M/s Lakshmi Iron Mart from whom
he had borrowed on 14.3.2007 for closure of housing
loans and ware house loan. Hence this can not be treated
as neither misutilisation nor borrower has not brought
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
the margin. The same has been justified by both the
Regional office and FGMO.
• Reasons for disbursing in advance; Borrower wants to
complete the construction of cold storage work by
December 2007 to make use of the current year
harvesting season. If it is delayed for 2-3 months he will
miss that harvesting season and he has to wait for next
year's harvesting season.
There will be an interest
burden on him and without earning any income in this
season, payment of interest & installment will be difficult
Quotations
obtained
months
back
at
the
time
submitting proposal and are valid for only 3 months, if he
does not make the payment now 10 to 15 percent price
will be hiked and because of this Rs.10 to 15 lakhs extra
burden will be there. Without receiving the Advance
payment none of the suppliers will keep ready the goods
and will not supply the goods in time. Borrower also
informed that, as the Bank interest is less, if Bank makes
the payment in advance above said all problems will be
solved. O.N.Nagaraja, being Branch Manager, in his best
judgment and to facilitate the borrower to tide over
above problems released the amount in advance. So for
the purpose of keeping the goods ready and to supply in
time as and when required without any delay to
complete the cold storage in time. O.N.Nagaraja has
disbursed the amount in advance
only
with good
intention at the interest of the Bank, Borrower and
Farmers to complete the cold storage at the earliest and
make use of the same in the current harvesting season.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
• It is further submitted that the petitioner was transferred
on 15th June 2007 within three months from the date of
first disbursement. This was routine transfer due to the
completion of three years of service in that Branch and
was transferred as Branch manager of the transfer, the
Bank had sanctioned an SOD limit of Rs. 75-00 lacs and
upon completion of the project, a working capital short
term loan of Rs. 225-00 lacs was sanctioned to M/s Rytu
Depot Cold storage Pvt. Which was after 2 years of the
transfer of the petitioner from Bellary Branch. The above
two subsequent development are a standing confirmation
to the fact that during the period of the petitioner as the
Branch Manager of Bellary Branch was in order and while
disbursing the sanctioned Term Loan, there had been no
malafide intention, nor dereliction of duty, and that the
petitioner had performed his duties in good faith and
without negligence. It is a standing fact disbursing the
loan. As per the laid down procedures of Reserve Bank of
India ,additional loans can be sanctioned and released
only and only if the first or the previous loans sanctioned
are in order. Further, the release of subsidy of Rs. 25-00
lacs by NABARD also establishes the fact that the first
loan was properly sanctioned, disbursed and utilized. The
investigation report is also silent on this aspect of the
matter. Hence, interference of this Hon'ble court is
warranted.
• It is submitted that absolutely there is no material on
record to show that petitioner has forged the documents
for the purpose of sanction of loan. The prosecution in
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
not able to point out which part of the documents and in
what manner the documents are forged. It is submitted
that whatever the documents submitted by the customer
of the Bank was sent to the Regional office for sanction
of the loan. The Regional office has considered the
proposal of the loan and sanctioned the same without
calling for additional documents. Therefore, the charge
leveled against the petitioner for commission of the
offence of forgery is not attracted. This aspect of the
matter is not considered by the trial court.
• The learned sessions judge has failed to consider the fact
that the prosecution has failed to produce any oral and
documentary evidence to prove the commission of
offence U/s 7, 13 (2) R/w 13 (1) (d) of PC Act and other
alleged offences. It is submitted that absolutely there is
no prima facia case regarding the illegal gratification and
absolutely there is no statement or document to prove or
to
show
that
petitioner
has
received
any
illegal
gratification. Therefore the provision of PC Act is not
attracted.
• It is submitted that closure of the housing loan was one of
the condition laid down by the competent authority while
sanctioning the loan of Rs. 261.60 Lacs to M/s. Rytu
Depot cold storage Pvt. Ltd. This was to be complied
before the release of the loan. Hence, the borrower M/s
Rytu Depot cold Storage Pvt. Ltd had closed the housing
on 14/03/2007. The disbursal of the loan to M/s Rytu
Depot cold storage Pvt. Ltd took place on 17-03-2007. It
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
is submitted here that since the loan was disbursed as
reimbursement for the works which have been already
undertaken by investing their own funds, the same is in
order and there has been no diversion of funds as
alleged by the prosecution. Hence, absolutely there is no
material to show that there is diversion of funds.
• Petitioner's Bank's Regional office and filed General
Manager Office vide their letter No. Ro:CR:1174:08
dated 28.08.2008 and FGMO vide their letter No. FGMO:
AUD: 1971:08 dated: 11.09.2008 respectively have
already confirmed that there is no wrongful diversion of
funds by borrower, and has justified the action of the
petitioner in disbursing the part of the loan amount
directly to M/s Chandrala Constructions. Further, the
Regional office has also justified that the petitioner has
ensured investment of margin by the borrower.
• The Petitioner's Banks after through investigation and
inquiry has found that nothing was brought on record of
the inquiry to cast any aspersions on the petitioner's
Honesty/integrity,
CO:IRD:5246/2014
Accordingly
Bank
vide
order
No.
2nd
Sept
has
now
dated
reduced the charges of major penalty of Reduction in
Grade-MMGS III To MMGS-II restored the petitioner in
MMGS-III.
• The wing of the RBI being the NABARD has approved the
project of the borrower and even released advance
capital subsidy of Rs.25 Lacs on 20/07/2009 after due
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
appraisal and evaluation of the economic viability of the
project and completion of the project. The NABARD have
already asserted that the project is satisfactory for
availing
financial
assistance,
promoters
have
rich
experience with sound financial backgrounds. Besides,
NABARD has also observed that the project of the
borrower complies with the specification/requirement of
the Dept. of Food processing and as such, he is entitled
for capital subsidy. It is based on these aforesaid
mentioned recommendations of the Nodal agency being
NABARD that the credit department has recommended
the project for availing credit facility and such other
facility from the Bank.
• It is important to mention here that, the project of
construction of the cold storage was completed, the term
loan which was sanctioned was properly utilized by the
borrower and absolutely there is no material on record to
show that project did not complete nor there is misuse of
funds. However, the prosecution alleges that the working
capital which was sanctioned to the borrower was misutilized. It is important to mention here that, at the time
of sanction of working capital this petitioner was not the
Branch
Manager
of
Bellary
Branch
and
he
was
transferred to another branch viz, Kalkere. The petitioner
is in no way concerned with sanctioning of SOD and
working capital to the borrower. The loan amount
released by the petitioner in favour of M/s Chandrala
construction was properly utilized by the borrower and it
is evident from the records also. Therefore, there are no
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
offences committed by the petitioner as alleged by the
prosecution. This aspect of the matter is not considered
by the trial court. Hence, interference of this Hon'ble
Court is warranted.
• In the instant case, since the facility sought by the
borrower was beyond the sanctioning powers entrusted
with the branch, the power of sanction of limits was
vested with the Regional office which involved complete
scrutiny, due diligence, ascertaining certain worthiness of
the borrower and if these parameters are in line with the
Bank
Policy
and
RBI
Guidelines,
then
the
Credit
department will consider the proposal and put up to the
credit grid which is independent evaluating authority
created by the Bank specifically for such purpose. All the
evaluation is undertaken by the above stated department
independent of each other strictly as per Banking Norms.
• As per the laid down procedure to be followed, the Branch
on receipt of the application of the customer collected
the relevant records and made the visit to the place of
Business and Collected the required information. The
Bank had obtained the Legal opinion regarding the title
from the empanelled Advocate of the Bank in respect of
the security and the market value of the property was
obtained from the authorized valuer of the Bank. The
Petitioner who was the then Branch head collected the
records and obtained the legal opinion regarding the title
of the property which is proposed as the security for the
loan to be advanced. The petitioner has submitted the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
entire records in respect of the proposed loan which are
provided and collected by him and recommended to the
delegated authority at Regional office of the Bank for the
sanction of the loan. The role of the petitioner is limited
and restricted. Hence, he cannot be held liable for
offences alleged by the prosecution.
• It is submitted that, even if the entire charge sheet is
perused it will disclose the offence as alleged by the
prosecution against the petitioner. Hence, interference of
this Hon'ble Court is warranted.
• Thus viewed from any angle, dismissal of discharge
application is contrary to law and needs to be set aside.
• Borrower N.Sri Hari, Managing Director of M/s Rytu Depot
Cold Storage who forged the documents like ware house
/cold storage receipts and loan documents for the short
term loan availed Rs.2.25 crore and cheated the Bank
committed suicide subsequently. This loan was neither
recommended nor disbursed by O.N. Nagaraja. This was
done only after the transfer of O.N.Nagaraja.
• His wife Vijaya Lakshmi who is also one of the Directors
has closed all the loan accounts under OTS and got
discharged from all charges.
• Asset
Recovery
settlement
Branch,
certificate
to
Bangalore
the
has
borrower
no.ARB/199/2017 dated 01.07.2017.
issued
vide
a
letter
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
• Bellary branch has released mortgaged documents of M/s
Rytu Depot Cold Storage, handed over the keys and
physical possession of cold storage.
• There was no criminal intent of whatsoever nature as
alleged by CBI. CBI also has failed to produce any
evidence or documents in support of its allegations
against O N Nagaraja. Whatever they have produced in
support of criminal charges pertains to the period
subsequent to his transfer from branch.”
8.
Sri K.L.Patil, learned counsel for the petitioner reiterating
the grounds urged in the petition contented that petitioner is not
the sanctioning authority.
He has only recommended the loan
request of the accused No.8 to the higher authorities and based
on the directions received in writing from the higher authorities,
he has serviced the loan of the accused No.8.
Therefore, no
criminality can be attributed insofar as the accused No.1 is
concerned.
9.
He submits that, at the most the petitioner has only
adhered to the instructions of the official superiors and that by
itself would not result in any criminality. Thus, charges against
the petitioner is incorrect and sought for allowing the petition.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
10.
the
Per contra, Sri Neelendra D. Gunde, learned counsel for
respondent
would
support
the
impugned
judgment
contending that beyond the permissible limit and scope of the
branch, the loan request of accused No.8 has been serviced by
improper noting on the proposal of the accused No.8 by the
Branch Manager.
11.
Therefore, prima facie he is in hand in glove in the
alleged fraud which has to be established during the trial and
therefore sought for dismissal of the petition.
12.
Having heard the arguments of both sides, this Court
perused the material on record.
13.
On such perusal of the record, it is crystal clear that the
loan service to accused No.8 is beyond the permissible limit of
the Branch of Union Bank of India, Ballari.
14.
Further,
the
contentions
urged
on
behalf
of
the
petitioner that he only adhered to the instructions of the Official
Superiors is a defence that has to be established during the trial
by placing necessary material evidence on record.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:669
CRL.P No. 103533 of 2024
HC-KAR
15.
Suffice to say that the material collected by the
Investigation Agency, that too based on the Internal Enquiry
Report, would be sufficient enough to frame the charges against
petitioner.
16.
The grounds urged in the petition are more in the
nature of defence and same needs to be urged in the trial in
accordance with law.
17.
Reserving such liberty to the petitioner, petition is
dismissed.
Sd/(V.SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
kcm
CT:CMU
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 21
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review