Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE ZIYAD RAHMAN A.A.
FRIDAY, THE 31ST DAY OF JANUARY 2025 / 11TH MAGHA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 14337 OF 2024
PETITIONER/S:
O.A.MOHAMMED KUNHI,
AGED 82 YEARS
S/O.O.A.ALIKUNHI, RESIDING AT FLAT NO.7A,
PINEWOOD,SKYLINE CITY PARK, JAWAHAR NAGAR, KADAVANTHRA,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN - 682020
BY ADV SAFEER BAWA A.S.
RESPONDENT/S:
THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,
CIVIL STATION, CIVIL LINES ROAD, AYYANTHOLE (P.O.),
THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN - 680003
THE LOCAL LEVEL MONITORING COMMITTEE,
REPRESENTED BY THE AGRICULTURAL OFFICER,OFFICE OF THE
PRINCIPAL AGRICULTURAL OFFICER,UDAYA NAGAR (P.O.),
CHEMBUKKAV, THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN - 680005
THE TAHSILDAR,
THRISSUR TALUK OFFICE, CHEMBUKKAVU (P.O.),THRISSUR
DISTRICT, PIN - 680020
THE VILLAGE OFFICER,
AYYANTHOLE VILLAGE OFFICE,NGO QUARTERS ROAD, AYYANTHOLE
(P.O.),THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN - 680003
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV PREETHA K K SR GP
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
31.01.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
JUDGMENT
The petitioner is the owner in possession of property
having an extent of 51 cents of land comprised in
Re.Sy.Nos.382 and 283
of Ayyanthole Village in
Thrissur
District. The challenge in this writ petition is mainly against
Ext.P6 order passed by the 1st respondent by which the
application submitted by the petitioner in Form-5 to remove
the said property from the Data Bank was rejected. The
factual circumstances which ultimately led to the filing of
this writ petition are as follows:2.
According to the petitioner, the property was
reclaimed
much
prior
to
the
enactment
of
Kerala
Conservation of Paddy and Wetland Act, 2008(hereinafter
referred to as the Paddy Land Act). Earlier, the petitioner
submitted an application before the Revenue Divisional
Officer Thrissur, under Clause 6 of the Kerala Land
Utilisation Order, 1967, to permit the petitioner to utilize
the said property for non-agricultural purpose. The said
application
was
allowed
as
per
Ext.P3
order
dated
15.11.1995. On the strength of the same, the petitioner
reclaimed the land immediately after the issuance of
Ext.P3. Later, as the said property was erroneously included
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
in the Data Bank prepared under the Kerala Conservation of
Paddy and Wetland Act, 2008, the petitioner submitted an
application in Form 5, before the 3rd respondent as
contemplated under Rule 4(d) of the Kerala Conservation of
Paddy
and
Wetland
Rules, 2008. However, the
said
application was rejected as per Ext.P6 and this writ petition
is submitted in such circumstances.
3.
A statement has been submitted by the 1 st
respondent, in response to the averments contained in the
writ petition. As per the averments contained therein,
Ext.P6 order was passed by the 1 st respondent, acting upon
the report submitted by the Agricultural Officer stating that,
the property was converted before 2008, and the land is a
low lying land and fruit bearing trees are absent. It was also
submitted that, even though the KLU order was issued by
the Revenue Divisional Officer, further proceedings have
not been resorted to by the Tahsildar (LR, Thrissur). Thus,
the stand taken by the 1st respondent in Ext.P6 was sought
to be justified.
4. I have heard the Sri. Safeer Bava A.S, the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Smt
Preetha K.K., the learned Government Pleader for the State.
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
5. The specific challenge raised in this writ
petition
is
against
Ext.P6
order
passed
by
the
1 st
respondent. The main contention raised by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is that, in view of the fact that the
property of the petitioner was permitted to be converted as
per the order passed by the competent authority, namely
the 1st respondent herein, by invoking the statutory powers
vested upon him by virtue of clause 6 of the KLU Order, the
property could not have been included in the Data Bank.
The learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance upon
the Ext.P14 judgment rendered by this Court in WPC
No.15168/2020 wherein various decisions including those
rendered
in
LLMC,
Kizhakkambalam
Grama
Panchayath and others v. Mariumma and another
[2015
(2)
KLT
(DB)],
Geo
Peter
v.
Revenue
Divisional Officer [2019 (3) KLT 838], Renji K.Paul v.
Revenue Divisional Officer [2019 (2) KLT 262], Salim
C.K. v. State of Kerala and others [2019 (3) KLT 604
(DB)] were relied on.
6.
After carefully going through the materials placed
on record and hearing the learned counsels for the both
sides, I find merits in the submissions put forward by the
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
learned counsel for the petitioner. It is evident from the
records that, the property was permitted to be reclaimed as
per Ext.P3 much prior to the enactment of the Kerala
Conservation of Paddy and Wetland Act, 2008. It is also the
case of the petitioner that, on the strength of Ext.P3 order,
the petitioner had already reclaimed the said property and
as of now, the said property is not fit for paddy cultivation.
7. Examining the contents of Ext.P6, it can be seen that
the application submitted by the petitioner in Form 6 was
rejected only upon the report of the Agricultural officer
stating that the property was not reclaimed prior to 2008.
8. The crucial aspect to be noticed is that, in Ext.P6, the
fact
that
the
petitioner
was
granted
permission,
as
evidenced by Ext.P3 in clause 6 of KLU, was not at all
referred to. Thus, consequences and the implications of an
order under clause 6 of the KLU Order, were never
subjected to consideration while passing Ext.P6. As far as
the application in Form 5 is concerned, the same was
introduced as per the amendment brought for the Kerala in
the year 2018. The applicability of the provisions which
came into force as per the said amendment, in respect of
the orders passed under Clause 6 of the KLU prior to the
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
enactment
of
the
amendment
Act
was
specifically
considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tahsildar Vs.
Renjith George reported in 2025 KHC ONLINE 7012
wherein after considering the provisions, it was specifically
observed
by
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
that,
new
conditions in the Amendment, cannot made applicable to
the applications filed under KLU Order prior to the
amendment.
9. In this case, admittedly, Ext.P3 order has been
passed under Clause 6 KLU Order, by which the permission
for reclaiming the land was already granted. It is also the
case of the petitioner that, the property stood reclaimed
immediately after the same. The photographs produced
along with the writ petition also indicate the same.
In
Ext.P14 judgment rendered by this Court, a similar issue
was
considered
and
in
paragraph
14,
the
following
observations were made:‘14. In this case, it appears that the statutory
permission under Rule 6(2) of the KLU Order has been
obtained by the petitioner's predecessor as per Ext.P-4
order dated 16.10.1995, which is much prior to 12.08.2008.
A case of a party who diligently prosecutes his rights and
gets the statutory permission under Rule 6(2) of the KLU
Order, even before the coming into force of the Kerala
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 (State
Act 28 of 2008) would stand on a much better pedestal
than cases wherein the party has filed the requisite
application under Rule 6(2) of the KLU Order after
12.08.2008, but before 30.12.2017 (date of coming into
force of the amended provisions of State Act 28 of 2008)
which has introduced Section 27A thereof, and orders of
permission are passed either after the cut off date of
30.12.2017. Even in cases where the party has filed the
requisite Rule 6(2) application after 12.08.2008 but before
30.12.2017, this Court has held that the party is entitled to
get the said application considered strictly in terms of Rule
6(2) of the KLU Order and that in such a case the party
cannot be compelled to pay the amounts as conceived as
per the amended provisions of the Kerala Conservation of
Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, which included Section
27A thereof and the amended Rules including Rule 12(17)
thereof. Therefore, a case in this nature would stand on a
much better pedestal inasmuch as statutory permission
obtained much prior to coming into force of the State Act
28 of 2008. Therefore, in the instant case the stand of the
3rd respondent that the petitioner should necessarily pay
the higher amounts as conceived as per the amended
provisions of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and
Wetland Act, 2008 and the Rules framed thereunder is
illegal and ultravires’
10. Thus, it is clear that, since the property stood
reclaimed on the strength of Ext.P3 order passed under
KLU, under no circumstances, the 1st respondent could have
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
rejected the application submitted by the petitioner in
Form 5, without considering the said order. Since
the
property is already permitted to be reclaimed as per
statutory order issued by a competent authority, the same
could not have been ignored. Therefore, the inclusion of the
property of the petitioner in the Data Bank itself was not
legally sustainable.
11. However, in Revenue Divisional Officer, Ekm v.
M/s. Poothotta Resorts Pvt. Ltd. reported in 2023 (1)
KHC 34, this Court after referring to Rule 4(d) of the 2008
Rules held that, even in respect of such cases, an
application in Form 5 has to be submitted by the person
concerned and the Revenue Divisional Officer shall pass
appropriate orders on the said application. The said
observations were made by a Division Bench of this Court,
taking note of the fact that in Rule 4(d), of the Kerala
Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Rules, it is
provided that, any person aggrieved by the contents of the
Data Bank may submit objections regarding that, before the
Revenue Divisional Officer in a prescribed form, namely
Form-5. Therefore, even for removing an erroneous entry,
an application in Form-5 is required. However, it does not
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
mean that while passing orders on said application, the fact
that the property was already directed to be reclaimed as
per statutory order passed under clause 6 of KLU cannot be
ignored. The said order and its consequences are to be
given due weightage while considering the same, as that
was an order passed under a statutory provision which was
governing the field at the relevant time. Therefore, Ext.P6
order passed by the 1st respondent without considering the
said aspect is only to be interfered with.
12. Another aspect to be noticed is that once the
property of the petitioner is removed from the Data Bank,
the next question that will arise is with regard to the
change to be effected in the revenue records as to the
description of the nature of the property. It is evident that,
even if the property is removed from the Data Bank, the
same is likely to be retained as paddy land in the revenue
records. In the light of categorical observations made by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Renjith George (supra), for
the classification of the property in the land records, the
petitioner cannot be subjected to any additional conditions
introduced as per Sec.27A of the Ker`ala conservation of
Paddy Land and Wetland Act as per the Amendment Act,
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
2018, which came into force with effect from 30.12.2017.
This is in view of the fact that Ext.P3 order was passed
much prior to the introduction of the Amendment Act and
the additional conditions introduced as per the provisions
therein.
13. Therefore, the consequence of the aforesaid legal
propositions is that, once the property of the petitioner is
removed from the Data Bank, the property has to be reassessed in the revenue records, by invoking the provisions
of the Kerala Land Tax Act, upon an application being
submitted by the petitioner in this regard. It is the right of
the petitioner to avail the said remedies, and it is thus
declared in favour of the petitioner.
Therefore, this writ petition is disposed of quashing
Ext.P6 order, by directing the 1st respondent to reconsider
the Form-5 application submitted by the petitioner in the
light of the observations made by this Court in this
judgment and also in the light of Ext.P14 and the decisions
rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Renjith George
(supra). It is further directed that, in case the property of
the petitioner is removed from the Data Bank, it shall be
open to the petitioner to submit necessary applications
2025:KER:11311
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
under the provisions of Kerala Land Tax Act to get the
property re-assessed in the revenue records by making
necessary endorsement in this regard. It is further directed
that the 1st respondent shall consider the application
submitted by the petitioner in Form-5, and the orders shall
be passed within a period of three months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this judgment, taking note of the
observations made in this judgment and other decisions
referred to above.
Sd/-
SM
ZIYAD RAHMAN A.A.
JUDGE
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 14337/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit -P1
TRUE COPY OF THE REGISTERED DEED DATED 25-31995 BEARING NUMBERS 2228/1995 OF SRO
AYYANTHOLE.
Exhibit-P2
RUE COPY OF THE REGISTERED DEED DATED 25-31995 BEARING NUMBERS 2229/1995 OF SRO
AYYANTHOLE.
Exhibit -P3
TRUE COPY OF THE SAID ORDER DATED 15-111995 .
Exhibit -P4
TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPHS (3 NOS.)
Exhibit -P5
TRUE COPY OF COMMUNICATION DATED 13-1-2020
ISSUED BY THE AGRICULTURAL OFFICER, KRISHI
BHAVAN, AYYANTHOLE TO THE PETITIONER ALONG
WITH THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE DATABANK .
Exhibit -P6
TRUE COPY OF THE REJECTION ORDER DATED 24-12024 OF THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER,
THRISSUR
Exhibit-P7
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 29-71998 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
Exhibit -P8
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 30-92002 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
Exhibit -P9
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 1412-2005 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S
PROPERTY.
Exhibit-P10
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 28-62007 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
Exhibit -P11
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 26-62009 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
Exhibit -P12
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 11-92014 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
WP(C)No.14337 of 2024
2025:KER:11311
Exhibit -P13
TRUE COPY OF THE LAND TAC RECEIPT DATED 25-72015 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY.
Exhibit -P14
COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 07-08-2020 IN WP
(C) NO.15168/2020 OF THIS HON'BLE COURT.
RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS:NIL
TRUE COPY
P.A.TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review