Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.41 of 2024
1. Nripendra Chakraborty,
S/O Pran Kumar Chakraborty, R/o Bhattapukur, Agartala, Tripura (W)
2. Ratan Debnath,
S/o Lt. Gouranga Debnath, R/o: Vill South Badharghat, Ramthakur Para,
P.O. Charipara, P.S. Amtali, A.D. Nagar, Agartala, Tripura (W)
3. Sripada Acharjee,
S/o Lt. Chitta Ranjan Acharjee, R/o: Vill South Badharghat, P.O. & P.S.
Amtali, Agartala, West Tripura
4. Swapan Kr. Dutta,
S/o Lt. Sukhesh Dutta, R/o Sripalli Badharghat, P.O. ONGC, Agartala,
Tripura West
5. Sushil Debnath,
S/o Kshirod Debnath, R/o: Vill & P.O. West Bhubanban, Agartala, West
Tripura
6. Jayanta Choudhury,
S/o Lt. Nimai Choudhury, R/o: Vill: North Indranagar, Near 79 Tilla, Sarat
Palli, P.O. Indranagar, Agartala, West Tripura
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Health Department, Govt. of Tripura,
New Capital Complex, New Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN 799001.
2. The Director of Health Services,
Govt. of Tripura, P.N. Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
3. The Secretary,
Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Capital Complex, New
Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799001.
...... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Senior Advocate.
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing &
delivery of Judgment
:
13th May, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting :
NO
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the
appellant-petitioners. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. for the
respondents.
[2]
The delay of 100 days in filing the appeal is condoned being not
opposed by the other side and the matter is heard on merit.
[3]
The judgment dated 08.12.2023 passed by the learned Writ Court
in WP(C) No.254 of 2022 is under challenge in this appeal whereby learned
Single Judge rejected the prayer for regularization of the appellant-petitioners.
[4]
The
appellant-petitioners
were
initially
engaged
as
Slip
workers/Casual workers on different occasions during the year 1991 to 1995
under the respondents and were receiving their pay as daily wages. Thereafter,
the Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura declared all the
petitioners as Casual workers notionally w.e.f. 01.01.2010 vide memorandum
dated 30.03.2010 (Annexure 22 of the writ petition). The petitioners submitted
representations to the Director of Health Services for regularization of their
service in Group C post on completion of 10 years thereafter. As stated by the
appellants, all the representations were exactly similar and identical in nature
and therefore, one of such representation as a sample was submitted before the
learned Writ Court under Annexure 31. In support of claim for regularization of
service, the appellants also relied on memorandum dated 01.09.2008 (Annexure
23 of the writ petition) and memorandum dated 21.01.2009 (Annexure 24 of the
writ petition), both issued by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura.
But getting no response in respect of their representations, ultimately they filed
the writ petition with the following prayers:
[5]
(i)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to regularize the service of the
Petitioners in Group-C posts on completion of 10 years
service as Casual Worker/Slip Worker, w.e.f., the date on
which the Petitioners completed 10 years as Casual
Worker/Slip Worker.
(ii)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be issued
modifying the Memorandum, dated, 30.03.2010, issued by the
Director of Health Service, Govt. of Tripura, to the extent,
that, Petitioners Nos.1,2,3,4, 5 & 6 were serving as Casual
Worker w.e.f. first day when they joined service under the
Respondents.
(iii)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing
the
Respondents
to
pay
monthly
wages/remuneration to the Petitioners at par with the
minimum of the pay scale of Group-D post.
(iv)
Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or order/orders and or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
quashing and cancelling the Memo, dated 31.07.2018, issued
by the Under Secretary, Govt. of Tripura, Finance
Department.
(v)
Make the rules absolute.
(vi)
Call for records.
(vii)
Pass any further Order/Orders as this Hon’ble High Court
considered fit and proper.
Admittedly, abovesaid memorandums based on which the
petitioners lodged their claim for regularization were repealed by the State
Government vide memorandum dated 31.07.2018 (Annexure 25 of the writ
petition). While rejecting the claim for regularization, learned Writ Court, inter
alia, observed as follows:
“7.
After perusal of the documents annexed with the writ
petition, I find that the petitioners have failed to justify that they had
been appointed against any regular sanctioned vacant posts. Even
the petitioners have not produced any document to show that they
were appointed by the competent authority of the respondents. They
were appointed simply by an officer of the department. Moreso, the
petitioners had been appointed illegally without following the
established procedure of law. Furthermore, the petitioners ought to
have approached the court within the realm of the scheme and
during the existence of the scheme before the date when those were
repealed. The delayed approach and lackadaisical attitude of the
petitioners would not entail them to get the benefit of repealed
schemes. In the opinion of this Court, this petition is absolutely
barred by delay and laches. Moreso, the nature of appointment of
the petitioners is not only irregular but illegal also. Further,
regularization is not a matter of right but a right to be considered by
the employer/Government and equality clause enshrined in Indian
Constitution must be followed in sensu stricto. Another important
aspect to be noticed that the petitioners have failed to place any
material that at present there are sanctioned vacant posts exist in the
Health department, Government of Tripura for their absorption or
regularization.
8.
Above all, equality clause as enshrined under Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India in the matter of public
employment cannot be frustrated or flouted for an indefinite period.
As per direction of the Apex Court in State of Karnataka vs. Uma
Devi (3) and Ors., reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1, the State
Government had formulated guidelines for regularization of
Casual/Contingent/Daily Rated workers in the year 2008 with
revised guidelines, and, those were continued for long 10(ten) years;
however, those were repealed by a policy decision of the
Government in the year 2018.
9.
The concept of equality as envisaged under Article 14 of the
Constitution is a positive concept which cannot be enforced in a
negative manner. When any authority is shown to have committed
any illegality or irregularity in favour of any individual or group of
individuals, others cannot claim the same illegality or irregularity
on the ground of denial thereof to them. Similarly, judgment passed
on wrong premise in favour of one individual does not entitle other
to claim similar benefits.
10.
I have also considered the directions given by the
Constitutional Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Uma
Devi(3)(supra) wherein at para 53 it was held thus:“53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases
where irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as
explained in State of Mysore vs. S.V. Narayanappa, reported
in (1967) 1 SCR 128, R.N. Nanjundappa vs. T. Thimmiah,
reported in (1972) 1 SCC 409, B.N. Nagarajan vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 507, and referred to in
paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly
sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the
employees have continued to work for ten years or more but
without the intervention of orders of courts or of tribunals.
The question of regularization of the services of such
employees may have to be considered on merits in the light of
the principles settled by this Court in the cases above referred
to and in the light of this judgment. In that context, the Union
of India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities
should take steps to regularize as a one time measure, the
services of such irregularly appointed, who have worked for
ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under
cover of orders of courts or of tribunals and should further
ensure that regular recruitments are undertaken to fill those
vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases
where temporary employees or daily wagers are being now
employed. The process must be set in motion within six
months from this date. We also clarify that regularization, if
any already made, but not subjudice, need not be reopened
based on this judgment, but there should be no further bypassing of the constitutional requirement and regularizing or
making permanent, those not duly appointed as per the
constitutional scheme.”
11.
A Division Bench of this Court in State of Tripura vs.
Suprava Debnath, reported in 2023 SCC Online Tri 833, did not
find any illegality or arbitrariness in the policy decision of the
government repealing the policy of regularization formulated in the
year 2008.
12.
Another noticeable feature is that even the dates of
engagements of the petitioners were considered w.e.f. 01.01.2010,
they have not completed 10(ten) years of service as Casual Workers
before 2018 when all the guidelines for regularization had been
repealed by the said policy decision of the Government.
13.
This Court in WP(C) No.5 of 2023 titled as Sri Satya
Ranjan Dey and Anr. Vs. The State of Tripura and 4 Ors. decided
on 06.09.2023 had passed a detailed order referring many
judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court and held that the petitioners of
that writ petition were not entitled to get their services regularized
and therefore, dismissed the writ petition.
14.
Thereafter, a Division Bench of this Court (presided over by
Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh, Chief Justice and myself) in Suprava
Debnath (supra) had an occasion to deal with the similar issue on
regularization wherein after observing all factual and legal aspects,
by a detailed order had dismissed the writ petition.
15.
Accordingly, I do not find any merit in the present writ
petition and the same stands dismissed.”
[6]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel contends that even if
the claim of regularization of the appellants was rejected by the learned Writ
Court, the appellants are entitled to equal pay for equal work in view of the
decision rendered by the Apex Court in State of Punjab and others vs. Jagjit
Singh and others [(2017) 1 SCC 148]. Learned senior counsel further argues
that vide memorandum dated 11.05.2016 (Annexure 26 of the writ petition)
issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Health and Family
Welfare Department, with the concurrence of the Finance Department it was
ordered that Casual workers who were having the qualification of Madhyamik
pass out and above were to be treated as Casual worker (Gr-C) and were
entitled to existing wage rate of DRW (Gr-C) and the Casual workers who were
below that educational qualification were to be treated as Casual worker (Gr-D)
having entitled to existing wage rate of DRW (Gr-D). Learned senior counsel
continues his submission that there are vacant posts lying in the Department of
respondents and the appellants are also discharging similar duties and
responsibilities of Group-C employee due to acute shortage of staffs and
therefore, they are entitled to get the benefit of equal pay for equal work and
monthly wages/remuneration which is not less than the minimum of pay scale
of Group-C post.
[7]
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. however, contends that the
scheme of regularization itself was withdrawn in the year 2018 and as such, the
appellants were not entitled to regularization of their services and therefore,
learned Single Judge was completely justified in rejecting their prayers.
Learned Addl. G.A. further argues that all the appellants were engaged without
concurrence from the Finance Department as a stopgap measure in absence of
regular employees, for smooth running of day to day work of the hospitals and
even after so, they were declared as a Casual worker w.e.f. 01.01.2010.
According to learned Addl. G.A., the appellants are, therefore, not entitled to
get any relief as prayed for by them.
[8]
We have considered rival contentions of the parties and also
perused the record.
[9]
As it appears, the regularization scheme was already withdrawn by
the Government vide memorandum dated 31.07.2018 (Annexure 25 of the writ
petition) i.e. even prior to completion of 10 years of service of appellants as
Casual workers and as such, they cannot now claim for regularization of their
services. We are, therefore, in agreement with the views taken by the learned
Single Judge in the impugned judgment. So far as the claim for equal pay for
equal work is concerned, from the sample representation of one of the appellant
(Annexure 31 of the writ petition), it appears that no such claim was raised by
the appellants before the respondents on any occasion and for the first time it
was claimed before the learned Writ Court. Learned Writ Court also in the
impugned judgment did not give any decision on their said claim for such equal
pay with reference to prayer No.(iii) of the writ petition.
[10]
In view of above, we deem it proper, for ends of justice, to give an
opportunity to the appellants to make representation to the respondents in
respect of their claim of equal pay for equal work furnishing all the related
materials in support of their such claim within a period not later than 3(three)
weeks and the concerned respondents will dispose of such representations by
reasoned order within 6(six) weeks thereafter. Needless to say, the appellants
will have the liberty to the approach appropriate forum in case they are not
satisfied with the decision of the respondents in this regard. With these
observations, this writ appeal is disposed of without any interference with the
impugned judgment passed by the learned Writ Court.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Rudradeep
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
Date: 2024.05.24 18:11:29 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review