Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:2
Serial No. 01&02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.248 of 2018
Date of Hearing: 26.11.2025
Date of Decision: 09.01.2026
Shri. Nozrul Islam
S/o Nurul Islam,
Aged about 36 yrs, R/o Kashapari
P.O. Halliday Ganj, West Garo Hills
Meghalaya, PIN 794104
….. Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya, represented by
Chief Secretary, Shillong.
2. Deputy Commissioner cum Chairman SSA
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
3. Additional Deputy Commissioner cum
District Mission Coordinator SSA
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
4. Joint District Mission Coordinator,
Dadenggre SSA West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
5. The School Managing Committee of Lalmati,
SSA, U.P School represented by its
President Lalmati, West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
6. The Headmaster cum Secretary of the School
Managing Committee of Lalmati, SSA, U.P School
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
7. The Lalmati, SSA, U.P. School represented by its
Headmaster, Lalmati
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
….. Respondents
2026:MLHC:2
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr.Adv with
Ms. D. Lyngdoh, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA with
Ms. S. Shyam, GA (R:1-4)
Mr. R. Debnath, Adv (R:5-7)
WP(C) No.473 of 2019
Shri. Nozrul Islam
S/o Nurul Islam,
Aged about 36 yrs, R/o Kashapari
P.O. Halliday Ganj, West Garo Hills
Meghalaya, PIN 794104
….. Petitioner
-VERSUS1. State of Meghalaya, represented by
Chief Secretary, Shillong.
2. Deputy Commissioner cum Chairman SSA
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
3. Additional Deputy Commissioner cum
District Mission Coordinator SSA
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
4. Joint District Mission Coordinator,
Dadenggre SSA West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
5. The School Managing Committee of Lalmati,
SSA, U.P School represented by its
President Lalmati, West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
6. The Headmaster cum Secretary of the School
Managing Committee of Lalmati, SSA, U.P School
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
7. Shri. Syam Sundar Ray, Headmaster of Lalmati
SSA, U.P. School Lalmati,
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
….. Respondents
2026:MLHC:2
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr.Adv with
Ms. D. Lyngdoh, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA with
Ms. S. Shyam, GA (R:1-4)
Mr. R. Debnath, Adv (R:5-7)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Judgement and Order (Oral)
1.
This set of two writ petitions involving interconnected issues is taken
up together for disposal.
2.
In WP(C) No.248 of 2018, the petitioner has prayed for quashing and
setting aside of the Resolution No.1,2,3 dated 02.03.2017, Minute dated
09.06.2017, Resolution No.1 dated 23.06.2017, Minute dated 29.06.2017
and 27.07.2017 of the Managing Committee of Lalmati SSA U.P School
and also prayed for release of his salary w.e.f. November 2017.
3.
In WP(C) No. 473 of 2019, the petitioner’s challenge is against the
action of the respondents in removing him from the post of the Assistant
Teacher, Science and Mathematics, of Lalmati SSA U.P School and the
appointment of the respondent No.7 in his place. A prayer has been made
to interfere with the impugned orders dated 27.06.2017, 11.10.2017 and
16.01.2018 issued by the Jt. District Mission Coordinator, Dadenggre and
also the Managing Committee Resolution dated 05.12.2017.
4.
Heard Mr. H.L Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
D. Lyngdoh, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee,
learned GA appearing for the respondent Nos. 1 – 4 and Mr. R Debnath,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos. 5 – 7. The learned
counsels have also submitted their respective written notes of argument.
2026:MLHC:2
5.
The fact of the case, as can be revealed from the averments made in
the writ petitions, is that the petitioner was appointed as the Assistant
Teacher of Science and Mathematics in Lalmati SSA U.P School vide
appointment letter dated 02.05.2014 pursuant to a Resolution dated
25.04.2014 of the Managing Committee of the School and accordingly, he
joined the post by filing a joining report on 05.05.2014. The said
appointment was provisionally approved by the Jt. District Mission
Coordinator by order dated 22.06.2016. However, the petitioner had to
approach this Court by filing WP(C) No.301 of 2016 for a direction to
release his pending salary w.e.f. 05.05.2014 i.e. the date of his joining the
service. The said writ petition was withdrawn by order dated 10.11.2016 on
the basis of a deed of agreement dated 28.10.2016 executed between the
petitioner and the respondent No.7 and, thereafter, the pending salary of the
petitioner was paid w.e.f. July 2015 to October 2017. Despite release of the
pending salary on the basis of the said agreement, the respondents again
stopped payment of salary to the petitioner w.e.f. November 2017 onwards.
The petitioner had submitted representation to the District Mission
Coordinator, Tura, requesting him to look into the matter, however, no
action was taken. The petitioner, thereafter, submitted an application on
07.11.2017 under the Right to Information Act, 2005, seeking certain
information which were provided to him by letter dated 28.03.2018. It is
only after that, the petitioner came to know that the approval of his
appointment was cancelled by the impugned letter dated 16.01.2018 which
was issued pursuant to the impugned orders dated 27.06.2017 and
11.10.2017 and also the impugned Resolution dated 05.12.2017 of the
School Managing Committee. Further, the respondent No.7 was appointed
in the place of the petitioner as the Assistant Teacher of Science and
Mathematics. It is stated in the writ petition that the entire action was taken
behind the back of the petitioner without issuing any show-cause notice at
2026:MLHC:2
the instance of the respondent No.7 in order to accommodate him in the
place of the petitioner as the post of the headteacher/ headmaster held by
the respondent No.7 became a non-sanctioned post after Sarva Shiksha
Abhiyan (SSA for brevity) scheme was implemented.
6.
The respondents contested the writ petitions by filling their
respective affidavit-in-opposition. Separate affidavits were filed by the
respondent Nos.1-4, the respondent No.5 and the respondent No.7. The
reasons cited for removal of the petitioner from service are that the
petitioner had no requisite qualification for appointment in the post of
Assistant Teacher of Science and Mathematics as he failed in Mathematics
in his HSSLC(Sc) Examination and that his appointment was not made by
the Managing Committee of the School. The purported resolution of the
Managing Committee dated 25.04.2014, basing on which the petitioner has
made his claim for appointment, is not found anywhere in the school
record. Further, the appointment of the petitioner was made without any
advertisement and the petitioner did not join the school at any point of time
and has also obtained the provisional approval of the appointment by
misleading the concerned authority. It is to be noted that by order dated
26.06.2024, this Court had directed for filing of a detailed affidavit on
behalf of the State respondent by an officer holding the rank of Secretary,
Education Department or the State Project Director, Meghalaya, as the
existing affidavits filed on behalf of the State were confusing and were
filed by officers who were not even authorised to accord approval to the
appointment of the petitioner. Accordingly, an elaborate affidavit was filed
on 17.10.2024 by the State. The petitioner did not file any rejoinder to the
said affidavit dated 17.10.2024 of the State.
7.
The learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner was appointed by letter dated 02.05.2014 pursuant to a resolution
dated 25.04.2014 of the Managing Committee of the Lalmati SSA U.P
2026:MLHC:2
School. The appointment of the petitioner was accorded provisional
approval by the respondent No.4 on 22.06.2016 and, hence, the action of
the respondents in removing the petitioner without any show cause notice
and without affording any opportunity cannot stand in the eye of law. He
submits that the petitioner was removed from the post of Science and
Mathematics Teacher with a malafide intention to accommodate the
respondent No.7 in his place as the post of head teacher/headmaster held by
the respondent No.7 was not a sanctioned post under the SSA scheme. The
learned Senior counsel further argues that as per the National Council for
Teacher Education (NCTE in short) norms, neither the petitioner nor the
respondent No.7 has requisite qualification for appointment to the post of
Assistant Teacher of Science and Mathematics and, thus, the nonfulfillment of requisite qualification could not have been a valid ground for
removal of the petitioner. He submits that the fact that the respondent No.7
was initially accommodated as a Language Teacher just after the
introduction of the SSA scheme and subsequently as a Science and
Mathematics Teacher in place of the petitioner by allowing the respondent
No.7 to acquire requisite qualification at a later stage, demonstrates the ill
intention of the respondents to save the appointment of the respondent No.7
in blatant violation of established norms of law and principle of fair play.
According to the learned Senior counsel, the stand of the respondent No.7
that his appointment dated 15.01.2002 was saved by the notification dated
18.06.2012 of the Ministry of Human Resources Development is not
tenable in view of the fact that the respondent No.7 was never appointed in
accordance with the NCTE Regulation of 2001. He, therefore, submits that
entire action of the respondents against the petitioner is violative of
principle of natural justice and is liable to be interfered by this Court and
prays for issuance of necessary directions for reinstatement of the petitioner
and payment of salary with effect from November 2017 onwards. In
2026:MLHC:2
support of his argument, learned Senior counsel has placed reliance on a
decision of the Apex Court in Basudeo Tiwary v. Sido Kanhu University
and others, (1998) 8 SCC 194.
8.
The learned GA appearing for the State respondent Nos. 1-4 submits
that the petitioner was never appointed by the Managing Committee of the
Lalmati SSA U.P School pursuant to conducting a selection process by
constituting a selection committee or interview board. No advertisement
was issued in the year 2014 for appointment of any teacher in the said
school. He submits that the appointment of the petitioner was done solely
by the then President without the knowledge of the Secretary and Head
Teacher-cum-Ex-Officio Member Convenor of the managing committee of
the school and the same is void ab-initio. In addition, he submits that the
petitioner did not have the requisite qualification as per the NCTE norms
for holding the post of Science and Mathematics teacher as he failed in
Mathematics in HSSLC examination. He submits that the supposed
appointment of the petitioner was kept in dark for more than two years and
the provisional approval was obtained by misleading the respondent No.4,
who was also not the authorised officer to accord approval; such
provisional approval has no validity and cannot be accepted. He submits
that the so-called joining report dated 05.05.2014 was never submitted to
the school and the petitioner never attended or taught in the school as a
regular teacher. The name of the petitioner does not figure anywhere in the
Attendance Register of the school w.e.f. June 2014 to September 2016 and,
thus, the claim of the petitioner is totally false. It is further submitted by the
learned GA that the name of the petitioner is also not found in the Unified
District Information System for Education (UDISE in short) database right
from the year of its implementation i.e. 2009-10 to 2022-23 as a teacher of
the school which confirms the fact that the petitioner was never appointed
as a teacher in the school. Regarding the status of the respondent No.7, the
2026:MLHC:2
learned GA submits that the respondent No.7 is a founder teacher of the
school and is serving as the Head Teacher of the school right from its
inception in the year 2002. The appointment of the respondent No.7 under
the SSA scheme is not a new or fresh appointment and he continued to
function as the Head Teacher in the school by holding a sanctioned post.
The allocation of subject to a teacher, he submits, is the prerogative of the
managing committee of the school and the implementing agency or the
State normally does not meddle in the matter. He submits that the
respondent No.7 has the requisite qualification for holding the post of
Science and Mathematics Teacher which he acquired in due course on
being permitted by the concerned authority. He further submits that the
agreement dated 16.10.2016 annexed with WP(C) No. 473 of 2019 has no
enforceability in law and the state being not a party to it has no knowledge
of existence of any such agreement. The learned GA, therefore, submits
that there is no merit in the case of the petitioner and prays for dismissal of
the writ petitions. The decisions of the Apex Court in Mohd. Sartaj & Anr
v. State of UP & Ors, (2002) SCC 315 and State of Bihar & Ors v.
Devendra Sharma, (2020) 15 SCC 466 has been relied on by the learned
GA in support of his argument.
9.
The learned Counsel for the respondent Nos. 5-7 adopts the
submission made on behalf of the State respondents and in addition,
submits that the purported resolution dated 25.04.2014 of the managing
committee of the school basing on which the petitioner claimed his
appointment is not found anywhere in the official record of the school. The
learned Counsel further submits that the appointment of the petitioner was
issued by the then president of the managing committee in his personal
capacity in connivance with the petitioner in order to extend undue favour
to the petitioner. He submits that the petitioner did not join the school at
any point of time and kept the purported appointment letter in his
2026:MLHC:2
possession only for the purpose of claiming salary. He submits that after
the managing committee came know about the illegal claim of the
petitioner, a complaint dated 03.04.2017 was filed before the concerned
authority of the state and accordingly the provisional approval of the
appointment of the petitioner was cancelled by order dated 16.01.2018
upon realization of the fact that there was no valid appointment in favour of
the petitioner. He submits that the petitioner has no locus standi to question
the appointment of the respondent No.7 as he does not have the requisite
qualification to claim appointment to the post of teacher under the SSA
scheme. He contends that the NCTE norms will not bind the respondent
No.7 as he was appointed as a founding teacher since the time of inception
of the school in the year 2002 and the State or the implementing authority
of the SSA scheme has never raised any objection to the continuation of
service of the respondent No.7 under the SSA scheme. By placing reliance
on the decision of the Apex Court in State of Orissa and another v.
Mamata Mohanty, (2011) 3 SCC 436, he submits that a person appointed in
violation of due process of law is not entitled to any relief including salary.
He, therefore, prays for dismissal of the writ petitions.
10.
The submissions made by the rival parties and perusal of the
materials on record reveals that the petitioner claimed his appointment on
the basis of an appointment letter dated 02.05.2014 issued pursuant to a
purported resolution dated 25.04.2014 of the managing committee of the
Lalmati SSA U.P School. However, there is nothing on record to show that
the said appointment was made after issuance of any advertisement and by
holding a regular selection process as per the established norms and
practice. Furthermore, the contention of the respondents that the copy of
the purported resolution dated 25.04.2014 is not available in the official
record of the school has not been rebutted by the petitioner. In this context,
it would be appropriate to refer to the enquiry report dated 30.04.2018 of
2026:MLHC:2
the Block Mission Coordinator, SSA, Selsela, West Garo Hills, wherein it
was held the claim of the petitioner was not found to be genuine. The
relevant part of the report is extracted below: “That Madam, the claim of Shri. Nozrul Islam as an Asstt.
Teacher Science is not found to be genuine as in the original
resolution of SMC nowhere it is found any resolution as regards his
appointment though the appointment of Shri. Nozrul Islam has been
made by the then President in the outside without the knowledge
and consent of the Head Master cum Secretary. Moreover, the
signature of Shri. Nozrul Islam is not found in the teacher
attendance register from 5th May, 2014 to 31st Oct.2016 and also
vide SMC resolution No.1 dtd. 5th Dec. 2017 the Jt. District Mission
Coordinator, Dadenggre vide letter No. Jt/DMC-D/SSA/Appttr/cancel/2018/1010-13 dated Dadenggre the 16/01/2018, the
approval of Shri. Nozrul Islam is cancelled as in the letter of Jt.
DMC has quoted as ‘it is found in the records that the appointment
of Shri. Nozrul Islam is not done with at the conformity of the
rules’.”
The petitioner has not made any challenge to the finding recorded in
the above enquiry report dated 30.04.2018. Therefore, it is difficult for this
Court to hold that the petitioner was offered any valid appointment by the
managing committee of the school.
11.
It appears from the affidavit dated 17.10.2024 filed by the Project
Director, State Education Mission Authority of Meghalaya that the then
President of the School Managing Committee was all in all in issuing the
appointment letter dated 02.05.2014 and in accepting the supposed joining
report dated 02.05.2014 of the petitioner and everything was kept a secret
and done behind the back of the Head Teacher cum Ex-officio Member
Convenor of the School as well as the Education Authority of the state.
There is further assertion that the order of provisional approval dated
22.06.2016 issued by the then I/C Jt. DMC, Dadenggre was in violation of
the norms and procedures laid down by the Government issued vide letter
2026:MLHC:2
No.MEGH/SSA-SEMAM/AO/44/2012/52 dated 10.06.2013 as the Jt.
DMC was not the proper authority for according such approval. The fact
that the approval of the petitioner’s appointment was sought after a long
gap of 2 years in the year 2016 in itself creates suspicion about the legality
of the petitioner’s appointment.
12.
The contention of the respondents that the petitioner did not have
requisite qualification for appointment to the post of Assistant Teacher of
Science and Mathematics as he failed in mathematics in his HSSLC
examination has not been disputed by the petitioner. The claim of the
petitioner for appointment before this Court is entirely based on the
assertion that the respondent No.7 did not have requisite qualification to be
appointed in the post of Assistant Teacher of Science and Mathematics.
Even if such an assertion is accepted, that would not make the petitioner
qualified or eligible to be appointed in the said post. Unless the petitioner
is able to demonstrate that he fulfills all the essential qualification required
for appointment to the post of Science and Mathematics Teacher, his claim
for appointment in the said post cannot be accepted.
13.
Further, the extract of the School Teachers Attendance Register of
the Lalmati U.P SSA School annexed with the affidavit-in-opposition filed
by the State respondent Nos. 1-4 in WP(C) No. 248 of 2018 and the UDISE
database of the teachers of the school for the year 2009-10 to 2022-23
annexed with the affidavit dated 17.10.2024 of the State Project Director do
not reflect the name of the petitioner as a sanctioned teacher of the school.
In addition, the representation dated 20.02.2016 with regard to nonpayment salary submitted by all the then teachers of the school appended in
the WP(C) No.248 of 2018 does not bear the name and signature of the
petitioner. The above facts unerringly project that the petitioner was never
functioning as a sanctioned teacher in the school.
14.
In so far as the question of continuation of the respondent No.7 in the
2026:MLHC:2
post of Headmaster cum Science Teacher is concerned, there is no dispute
to the fact that he was appointed as the founding teacher of the school in
the year 2002. After the SSA scheme was introduced in the year 2010, the
respondent No.7 continued to function as the Headmaster and when the
post of Science and Mathematics teacher fell vacant, he was accommodated
in the said post while discharging the duty of the Headmaster after being
allowed to acquire requisite qualification by the no objection certificate
dated 18.09.2014 of the Sub-Divisional School Education Officer, West
Garo Hills, Dadenggre. The accommodation of the respondent No.7 was
not a fresh or a new appointment. It is clear from the averments made by
the State-respondents that the allocation of subject to a teacher is a
prerogative of the managing committee of the school and the State
authority does not normally interfere in such matter. The State-respondents
further asserted that the respondent No.7 has in due course acquired the
qualification to be eligible for the post of Science and Mathematics teacher.
15.
The proposition laid down in the case of Basudeo Tiwari (supra)
with regard to observance of principle of nature of justice cannot have
random application without ascertaining the facts and situation of a case. In
the present case the petitioner has miserably failed to establish that any
valid appointment order was issued in his favour by a person holding
lawful authority to issue such appointment. On the contrary, the resolution
of the managing committee dated 25.04.2014 basing on which the
petitioner has based his claim for appointment, is not found in the records
of the school. That apart, it is undisputed that the petitioner does not hold
the requisite qualification for appointment to the post of Science and
Mathematics teacher. In such a situation, the plea of the petitioner that no
opportunity was provided to him before the passing of the impugned orders
is of no consequence.
2026:MLHC:2
16.
The authorities relied upon on behalf of the respondents, though
relevant to some extent, are not discussed in details in view of the
observations made hereinabove.
17.
For what has been discussed, the petitioner has failed to make out
any case for interference by this Court. Resultantly, both the writ petitions
stand dismissed.
18.
However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there will be no
order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
09.01.2026
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2026.01.09 15:52:27 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review