Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 24 of 2022
Date of order: 08.06.2022
North Eastern Electric Power
vs.
Poresh Kumar Nath
Corporation Ltd. & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Marwein, Adv.
For the Respondent
:
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharshiing, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The appeal is directed against an order of May 12, 2022 by which
the first respondent’s writ petition challenging his order of transfer has
been allowed and the order of transfer dated November 26, 2021 has been
set aside.
2.
At the outset it must be observed that for a successful challenge
to an order of transfer, an extraordinary case has to be made out and
unless the high tests are met, the employer’s authority to transfer an
employee cannot be interfered with. Even if the transfer is in breach of
the applicable guidelines, once it appears to the Court that the employer
applied its mind and took a conscious decision for administrative
exigencies, the Court would be slow to intervene unless a case of manifest
arbitrariness or patent unfairness is clearly established.
3.
Three grounds are evident from the judgment and order
impugned, in justification of what impelled the writ court to interfere.
The writ court perceived that there was no administrative reason for the
employer to have transferred the first respondent herein from his
Guwahati posting to Arunachal Pradesh. Further, the writ court took
notice of the fact that the writ petitioner had indulged in trade union
activities despite being an officer and this earned him the wrath of his
seniors. Finally, the writ court found that there was no urgent need to
justify the transfer order of November 26, 2021 to move the writ
petitioner out of an assignment on which he had been sent to Mawsynram
only earlier in November, 2021.
4.
It appears that several needless issues were raised by the appellant
employer before the writ court. In course of such irrelevant matters being
canvassed hopelessly, the substance of the writ petition was lost as the
endeavour on the part of the appellant herein was more to ensure that the
Court did not entertain the writ petition rather than maintain that it was
necessary for better administration to transfer the writ petitioner to the
new project site in Arunachal Pradesh. There is no dispute that the
appellant is an authority answering to that description in Article 12 of the
Constitution. Notwithstanding such position, it was sought to be
contended on behalf of the appellant herein before the writ court that in a
matter pertaining to the service conditions of the employees of a statutory
authority, the scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution was not available. The point had to be urged to be
completely thrown out, particularly since there is no dispute that the
appellant herein, in its constitution and its functioning, would be
recognised as a State or other authority within the meaning of the relevant
expression in Article 12 of the Constitution.
5.
In the case of private bodies which discharge public functions,
ordinarily, the extent of judicial review would be limited to the area of
public duty discharged by such private body. There are other tests,
including the test pertaining to all pervasive control of the State or the
financial control of any government over the relevant body. Even in such
cases, when the status of the employer may not be that of an authority but
the employer is otherwise engaged in discharge of public duties, the
service conditions and disputes pertaining to the employees of such body
may not be carried to a writ court. However, in the present case, the very
nature of the constitution of the appellant herein was such that it was
amenable to every aspect of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution. On such count, the opinion of the writ court cannot be
faulted.
6.
The other argument which was put forward on behalf of the
appellant before the writ court was that no mandamus ought to be issued
pertaining to a contract of service. Again, such aspect is adroitly dealt
with in the impugned judgment. Suffice it to say that when the challenge
in the writ petition was to the perceived arbitrary and capricious conduct
of the State or an authority, the writ court had sufficient jurisdiction to
entertain the grievance and adjudicate thereupon.
7.
However, the fact that the writ court had the authority to entertain
the matter did not imply that the writ court would have to intervene
therein. It is now well established that when it comes to transferring an
employee, unless an extreme case of prejudice or caprice is made out, the
writ court would not interfere with the discretion of the employer in such
regard. The principal basis of interference, generally, is when the service
conditions are breached. Even in such a situation, there is a caveat which
is followed: that the employer has due authority to take extraordinary
measures in extreme situations if they are necessary for better
administration. Thus, even a breach of any service condition may not, by
itself, render an order of transfer invalid, if there are sufficient grounds to
otherwise justify the same.
8.
The two technical grounds taken on behalf of the writ petitioner
in the present case were that contrary to clause 6.2 of the service
conditions, the writ petitioner was sought to be transferred before he
completed the four-year tenure in his place of posting; and, that the order
of transfer was not issued by the competent authority as recognised in
clause 9 of the relevant service conditions but by a General Manager in
the Human Resources Department.
9.
Neither ground is of any merit. For a first, clause 6.2 of the service
conditions has to be read in conjunction with clause 8.1 thereof that
leaves the management of the employer free to transfer or retain any
employee at any place irrespective of the tenure at such location in order
to meet the organisational requirements and in the interest of the working
of the corporation. At any rate, there is a presumption that when an
employer seeks to transfer an employee, whether or not in breach of the
service conditions, some thought would have gone into the decisionmaking process and, ordinarily, it would be for better administration.
10.
There is no doubt that such presumption is rebuttable; but the
rebuttal has to be upon meeting the high test of establishing that it was
done with the deliberate motive of prejudicing the concerned employee
or capriciously or on completely extraneous considerations.
11.
Here is an employee who is engaged as a draftsman and is
expected to prepare designs for power projects. He was assigned from the
Guwahati posting for a 10-day period to survey and prepare a report
pertaining to a proposed project at Mawsynram in Meghalaya. The
assignment was to end on November 28, 2021. The order of transfer was
issued on November 26, 2021. Apart from the fact that it was for the
employer to decide whether it was expedient to transfer an employee even
in the middle of an assignment, there is no material to establish that the
action was taken against the writ petitioner out of vendetta or as a result
of the writ petitioner indulging in trade union activities. It must be noticed
that a notification was issued earlier in 2021 prohibiting officers or
categories of employees to which the writ petitioner belong from
indulging in trade union activities. It may also be noticed that a few days
before the order of transfer, a show-cause notice was issued to the writ
petitioner on the ground that he continued to indulge in trade union
activities despite the notification issued by the employer in April of 2021.
The writ petitioner was also accused of insubordination in the relevant
show-cause notice.
12.
The writ petitioner was a signatory to or otherwise instrumental
in a challenge being instituted by way of WP(C) No. 367 of 2021 in this
Court pertaining to the notification of April, 2021 by which certain
classes of employees were prohibited from indulging in trade union
activities. The writ petitioner contended before the Single Bench that
upon such petition being filed on or about November 18, 2021, an
immediate decision was taken to transfer the writ petitioner out to
Arunachal Pradesh, inter alia, to ensure that the writ petitioner was not
involved in the conduct of the challenge to the relevant notification.
13.
By the impugned judgment and order of May 12, 2022, the writ
court rejected the contentions of the appellant herein pertaining to the
lack of authority under Article 226 of the Constitution to look into the
grievance. The writ court also, quite appropriately, dealt with the
argument as to whether a mandamus could be issued in respect of a
contract of service. However, when it came to the merits of the grievance
in the writ petition, the writ court surmised, on the basis of the proximity
of the dates, that there were extraneous considerations which went into
the decision-making process culminating in the writ petitioner being
transferred. In the absence of cogent material to demonstrate that the
decision was arbitrary or capricious, merely because the order of transfer
came within a few days of the writ petition challenging the notification
of April, 2021 being filed, it would not follow that it was the filing of
such petition that prompted the decision; particularly, when the employer
insisted that it was necessary for better administration.
14.
As to whether a decision to transfer an employee is for better
administration or not, it is the employer which has the final say and the
writ court cannot look into the reasons for the employer perceiving it to
be necessary for better administration.
15.
Since the technical grounds urged by the writ petitioner were
unworthy as clause 6.2 of the relevant service conditions was subject to
clause 8.1 thereof and as clause 9 of such service conditions required the
transfer of an employee to be with the approval of certain persons
whereas the challenge herein was to the General Manager having issued
the order of transfer, the other extraneous considerations sought to be
cited on behalf of the writ petitioner ought to have been disregarded by
the writ court. There is no material to show that the transfer was not
approved by the appropriate personnel. Indeed, upon a formal order being
passed, there is a presumption that the conditions precedent to the making
of the order have been complied with. The mere issuance of the order of
transfer by the General Manager would not imply that it was not approved
by the appropriate officers.
16.
There is an element of discipline which has to be maintained in
service. As much as every employee, particularly an employee engaged
by a public body or a statutory authority, has to be dealt with and treated
fairly, when the employer perceives that the transfer of an employee
would better serve the employer, unless cogent grounds demonstrating
malice or caprice are brought, the writ court should be slow in stepping
in. Indeed, the further extraordinary feature in this matter was of the writ
court having issued an interim order. Even if a petition is entertained
against an order of transfer, an interim order is rarely issued unless very
high tests are met; since if the order of transfer is annulled at the final
hearing, the clock can be set back.
17.
Transfer is a routine matter in service, particularly in a large
organisation as the appellant herein which has activities spread all over
the North-East. There is no doubt that the transfer of an employee causes
distress to the family of the employee as the entire family is virtually
uprooted from a place. But that is a vagary of the service, if the service
conditions contemplate transfers. When an order of transfer is challenged,
the first test is whether it is illegal, in the sense that it is demonstrably
contrary to the service conditions. If the order is in consonance with the
service conditions, as in the present case, that ought to be the end of the
matter. In the event the order of transfer is in breach of the service
conditions, it is only then that the surrounding circumstances need to be
seen. It is also possible that an order of transfer is legal but highly
irregular or it may be discerned from a pattern of events that it is a part
of a scheme to harass the particular employee. The enquiry by the writ
court in the present case ought to have stopped at the initial stage since
there was nothing illegal about the impugned transfer. As to the alleged
irregularity, no case of egregious prejudice or mala fides as a result of
vendetta or otherwise was made out.
18.
The grounds that were carried by the respondent herein before the
writ court were not worthy enough for the writ court to interfere with the
decision pertaining to the better administration of the appellant herein.
With respect, what weighed with the writ court was the proximity of the
dates of the writ petitioner being assigned to Mawsynram, of the
challenge to the notification of April, 2021 and the order of transfer of
November 26, 2021.
19.
Since the high tests required to be met by the writ petitioner for
the Court to intervene in the matter were absent in this case and the
reasons in support of the interdiction are not found to be legally tenable,
the judgment and order impugned dated May 12, 2022 are set aside. As a
consequence, the writ petition, WP(C) No. 412 of 2021, is dismissed.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
20.
The writ petitioner should immediately proceed to join his new
place of posting to be entitled to receive his salary with effect from July,
2022.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
08.06.2022
“Sylvana PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review