Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :The Hon’ble Acting Chief Justice Sujoy Paul
And
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Sen
WPCT 95 of 2018
With
CAN 1 of 2020 (Old No.CAN 1575 of 2020)
Noorul Hoda
-VsThe Union of India and others
For the petitioner
: Mr. Pritam Choudhury
For the respondents/U.O.I.
: Mr. Anirban Mitra
Heard on :
13.01.2026
Judgment on :
13.01.2026
SUJOY PAUL, A.C.J. : –
1.
This petitioner filed under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India
challenges the order of Central Administrative Tribunal, Kolkata Bench
(Tribunal) dated 05.09.2018 passed in O.A. 350/00836/2017 whereby
the original application filed by the petitioner was dismissed.
2.
For getting the Grade Pay of Rs.10000/- in Pay Band IV, the petitioner
preferred a representation dated 19.09.2016 before the department.
The said attempt could not fetch any result and therefore, he filed O.A.
127 of 2017 before the Tribunal, which was disposed of by the Tribunal
by directing the department to pass a speaking order within stipulated
time. In turn, the department passed the speaking order dated 29th
May, 2017 which became subject matter of challenge in O.A. 836 of
2017.
3.
In a nutshell, the contention of learned counsel for the petitioner based
on written notes is that he joined Civil Construction Wing of All India
Radio as Assistant Engineer (Electrical) on 11.07.1988 as a Direct
Recruit Engineer on the recommendation of UPSC. The petitioner was
then promoted on ad hoc basis as Executive Engineer (Electrical) with
effect from 23.12.1996 and on regular basis from 13.04.1998. As per
petitioner‟s contention, he was further promoted as Superintending
Engineer (Electrical) since 30.08.2010 on ad hoc basis. He retired on
attaining the age of superannuation on 28th February, 2020.
4.
The petitioner‟s contention was that he has not specifically prayed for
any promotion before the Tribunal or before the department. Instead,
he prayed that he should get next Grade Pay of Rs.10000/- in place of
Rs.8700/- (GP) in the same Pay Band in view of his stagnation beyond
the eligibility period. In support of his contention, learned counsel for
the petitioner placed reliance on Constitution Bench judgment of
Supreme Court in the case of Lalit Mohan Deb and others vs. Union
of India and others reported in (1973) 3 SCC 862.
5.
It is submitted that once the petitioner has completed eligibility as per
Office Memorandum dated 18th January, 2011, and there exists a
promotional post, petitioner is entitled to get the Pay Band of the
promotional post of Senior Administrative Grade (SAG), the Tribunal
erred in not extending the said benefit to the petitioner. In the present
writ petition, the petitioner has quoted examples where junior
employees to the petitioner were given same benefits based on similar
facts.
6.
Mr. Mitra, learned counsel for the department supported the order of
the Tribunal and urged that relevant aspects were gone into in the
„speaking order‟ and department rightly rejected the representation. In
absence of availability of promotional post, Grade Pay demanded by
petitioner cannot be granted merely because he has completed/served
for a period which is equal to or above the eligibility period.
7.
No other point is pressed by learned counsel for the parties.
8.
We have heard the parties at length and perused the record.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on Office
Memorandum (OM) dated 18th January, 2011. Relevant portion of the
OM reads thus:
“
Dated 18th January, 2011
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:- Qualifying service for promotion to SAG/HAG Grades in
Organised Group „A‟ Engineering Services- regarding
***
This Department vide OM of even No. dated 15.12.2009
had issued guidelines for amendment of Service Rules for
incorporating the eligibility requirements for promotion to SAG and
HAG level in Organized Group A Services.
2.
The matter has been examined in respect of the Organized
Engineering Services where the functional SAG is at Grade Pay of
Rs. 8700/- and the eligibility requirement for SAG level is 3 years
in the JAG grade. Accordingly for promotion to SAG (PB 4 Grade
Pay Rs. 10000/-) level in Organized Engineering Services, the
eligibility requirement shall be
“Officers in the grade of Superintending Engineer and
equivalent (PB 4 Grade Pay of Rs.8700/-) with 3 years
regular service in the grade or officers in the grade of
Superintending Engineer / equivalent with 17 years
regular service in Group A posts in the service out of
which at least 1 year of regular service should be in the
PB-4 Grade Pay of Rs.8700/-.””
10. Learned Tribunal also considered this OM and other judgments and
came to hold as under:
“In N.G. Prabhu v. Chief Justice (Kerela), 1973 (2) SLR
251, promotion has been distinguished from upgradation in the
sense that main purpose of upgradation of a post is to confer
financial benefits and promotion is an appointment to a different
post carrying a higher scale of pay in the service.
Relying on the above mentioned ratio, it is axiomatic that
promotion being appointment to a different post, the post to which
an incumbent is to be promoted has to exist in the first place,
meaning thereby, that promotions are dependent on the
availability of vacancies in the promotional post The speaking
order does not debar the applicant to be placed in the zone of
consideration for promotion but only states that such promotions
would be actuated on availability of vacancies.
In his pleadings, the applicant has stated as follows:“This application is preferred for challenging impugned
Speaking Order No. V-11012/7/2017-BA(E) date 29.5.2017
passed in compliance of direction of Hon'ble CAT, Kolkata in
O.A. No. 350/00127 of 2017 of the applicant, declining right of
consideration to the promotion to SAG level i.e. Grade Pay of Rs.
10000/- even after fulfilment of all criteria by the applicant."
(emphasis supplied)
The applicant has claimed the benefits in terms of the Office
Memorandum dated 18.1.2011 which obviously refers to
promotion to SAG/HAG grades. It has been admitted by the
applicant that his basic prayer is for consideration for promotion
to the post of SAG Grade and not upgradation to the SAG grade
and logically, to merit promotion to the SAG level, a vacancy has
to exist.
During his oral arguments, the applicant has produced the pay
slip of the Chief Engineer, CCW, CDO, AIR for the month of May,
2018 proving thereby that the post of Chief Engineer, CCW, CDO,
AIR is occupied confirming the contentions of the speaking order
that no vacancy exists.
Accordingly, the applicant has to wait his turn according to
seniority and service rules to be promoted to the post of Chief
Engineer and thereafter to the SAG Grade Pay of Rs. 10000/-.”
11.
A careful reading of OM dated 18th January, 2011, makes it clear that
it talks about “promotion” and not “financial upgradation”. A particular
Grade Pay (GP) is attached to a particular post. In the instant case, the
GP of Rs.10000/- is attached to SAG level post of Chief Engineer. The
petitioner has not disputed that till his retirement, no post of Chief
Engineer was lying vacant. Thus pivotal question is whether an officer
who had rendered services equal to or above the eligibility clause can
claim the pay-scale/Pay Band attached to promotional post.
In our
opinion, the simple answer is “no”. We say so because a particular Pay
Band is attached to a promotional post. If promotional post is not lying
vacant merely because officer has rendered certain years of service
which makes him eligible for consideration for promotion, he cannot be
treated to be promoted or getting a right to get Pay Band and Grade Pay
attached to the promotional post.
12. The petitioner has only a right of consideration for promotion and not a
right of promotion.
The right of consideration of promotion depends
upon certain factors such as fulfilling the eligibility conditions,
availability of clear and vacant post, non-pendency of disciplinary
proceedings/criminal case, etc. In the instant case, admittedly no
promotional post of Chief Engineer was available. Thus, the Tribunal
has rightly held that in absence of the post, no right accrues in favour
of the petitioner to get Grade Pay of Rs.10000/- which is attached to
the promotional post.
13. So far judgment of Supreme Court in Lalit Mohan Deb (supra) is
concerned, suffice it to say that the said judgment nowhere holds that
an employee is entitled to get pay scale of promotional post without
getting promoted on the said post.
14. The „financial upgradation‟ in service law has a different facet. If an
employee is stagnant and not getting promotion for a stipulated years of
service, as per the ACP/MACP scheme etc., he may get the benefit of
financial upgradation and not promotion.
His service condition
remains the same and he gets a upgraded pay-scale. This was not the
case of the petitioner before the Tribunal that he was eligible but
deprived of the benefit of ACP/MACP scheme.
15. So far the examples of junior who got the benefit is concerned, learned
counsel for the petitioner fairly informed that there is no pleading, proof
and foundation before the Tribunal in this regard. In judicial review
under Article 226/227 of the Constitution, we are not inclined to
examine these new facts on which Tribunal has no occasion to apply its
mind and base its judgment. The Tribunal, in our opinion, has taken a
plausible view which does not warrant any interference.
16. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed. With dismissal of the writ
petition, the application being CAN 1 of 2020 (Old No.CAN 1575 of
2020) is also dismissed.
17. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be given
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Sujoy Paul, A.C.J.)
I agree.
(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)
s.biswas
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review